Skip to main content
Loading video...

I've Made $8938.51 on Board Game YouTube (Here's What's Next)

Transcript 30:19

Well folks, today's video is going to be a bit different. It's a meta video. It's a board game YouTube video about board game YouTube videos. It's about time I talk about money, sponsorships, patrons, and the whole thing from a perspective of a board game content creator. So, why do I want to talk about this? Is this the end of the channel? Am I going to put everything behind a payw wall and memberships with a multi-tiered Patreon? No. I have no interest in any of that stuff. There will be no payw wall or Patreon if you're worried about that. But I do have a favor to ask of you, a way to help support me and how things will evolve a tiny little bit for this channel. I also really wanted to talk about this because I feel like I have a somewhat unique angle of this whole YouTube and board game thing that I felt that you might want to know as a viewer. These are the details I wish I knew before I got started on YouTube and how this whole thing works with regards to board game channels. But just as importantly, I wanted to reflect on the idea of money as a content creator and this whole side of an industry that you don't get full transparency about too often. My own monetization.

Before I dive too deep into the weeds, let me be entirely clear on my current monetization and explain how this channel earns revenue. Big Pasti is run by one guy, me. I do not have anyone else who helps or that I pay. I don't have an editor or anyone who helps film B-roll or anything. Any mistakes are entirely on me. The only exception to this is that years ago, I paid an artist on Fiverr to help make some thumbnails, which I didn't feel really fit the vibe of the channel. So, I stopped and went back to making my own thumbnails. I have never taken a single copy of a board game from any publisher or designer. Every game I talk about is bought with my own money when the game is actually released. The only exception to this is I have a few real life friends who gifted me games.

So technically I didn't buy those games myself. You know, whenever someone's cleaning out the Kellix, I'm the one who usually gets the goods. And I also talk about games that I played with friends that they bought. Like for example, I talk about Battlestar Galactica, but I actually don't own Battlestar Galactica. A friend does. We play it, so I talk about it. I mention this because I occasionally get a comment saying, "Great video, but you should disclose any conflicts from receiving all these games." But the thought never really came to me because I've never actually engaged with this potential conflict of interest. Put simply, I get and play games the same way normal non-content creators get and play games. Also, I have never taken a single sponsorship. While I've actually had a few sponsors reach out and even made it to the contract signing stage, I've ultimately declined to do any sponsorships. The majority are sponsors from tangentally related products. Like you might see a VPN or a gotacha game or DICE or storage for games, that kind of stuff. And likewise, I have never ever received a single dollar directly from any viewer.

I do not have a Patreon or Kofi or YouTube memberships activated. I've even declined the potential options of having members directly send me money through YouTube, which is absolutely the easiest way for a creator to set up an extra stream of income just with a few clicks. So, what's the grand exception to all of this? Ad revenue. I am most certainly monetized on YouTube in case you didn't know, but the criteria for full monetization is 4,000 hours of long- form content being watched by viewers and having 1,000 subscribers, which I hit in September 2024 when I made my giga hit video about complexity and depth. As of December 28th, 2025, I've made 8,938.51 Canadian since. Spoilers, I live in Canada, which is a very hefty chunk of change. Some months are absolutely higher than others, and dependent on viewer retention, different videos tend to bring in substantially different amounts. Very roughly, I make about $7.15 Canadian for every,000 views. But it does deeply depend on viewer retention and watch time.

A short video with 100,000 views won't earn the same amount with a longer video with the same view count. So, when I factor in all of the cost, the camera I bought, the microphone, Da Vinci Resolve, Photoshop, sound effects, music license, the games themselves, and taxes, this channel is just about to break even. I'm not there quite yet, but I'm predicting profitability in the next couple months. So, you might be thinking, how do I live? The great secret is I have a normal job. I always saw big pasti more as a fun little side experiment, a medium for exploring concepts I wanted to talk about and get deeper inside. It really was for increasing my own expertise and my own enjoyment. And there is a bigger purpose behind all this that I'll talk about near the end. But right now, let me walk you through some of YouTube insights that you might be curious about.

Games from publishers. So, first thing first, and the topic that interests me the most is the relationship between content creators and publishers. There's this very interesting feedback loop between the publisher and content creators. Publishers know that success for their game, especially in niche corners of the internet, does depend significantly on some sort of verility of their game. The cost benefit is tremendous for publishers. Sending a complimentary game copy to a content creator is a fairly minimal cost for a publisher who's producing like 1,500 copies of a game. And if that content creator can even get a few hundred organic views, that is a very good deal for a publisher. I see the real magic coming in two forms. Publishers don't just send games to one or two content creators, but will generally send out to a curated list of many content creators that have an active audience. Publishers literally have lists of content creators that have been vetted and will consistently receive games without many strings attached. With enough content creators covering the same game that they all received for free, there becomes a saturation of your algorithm.

The impact of this is that there will be a point where everyone is seeing the same game even if everyone is seeing different content creators. Like I might be subscribed to the channel Board Game Party and you might be subscribed to Night at the Board Game Museum and both channels were given Blue Factory Express. Then we both see the same game even if it's from different channels. This algorithmic magic is simply a form of impression saturation. It's the effect you feel when you open up YouTube and you will see videos on the latest games from different content creators. And even if you don't click on that video link, the fact that you had an impression, a thumbnail shown to you is good enough to justify the cost of sending the game to the content creator. For example, I average about 3 to 8% impression clickthrough on my own videos. So, what that means is if I get 10,000 views on a video, the thumbnail and the title has likely been shown to about a 100,000 or even 200,000 people, 200,000 people seeing that thumbnail for the cost of sending a board game box over is a stellar deal for the publisher. In a way, the value of the thumbnail shown a game box is far more than just the engagement with the video itself. It's an ad that doesn't necessarily even feel like an ad. Like, let's take a look at my own thumbnail for Thunder's Edge. Even if you don't click on it, it can still read as an ad to you. Now, imagine 50 or 60 or 70 creators all talking about Thund's Edge over the same month. Thousands and thousands of people will be made aware

of the game, and the cost is fairly minimal to achieve. The second form of magic is true virality. This is when a big content creator showcases your game. It doesn't necessarily need to be an analytical analysis. It could be a playthrough or an unboxing or a tier list. It doesn't really matter the form of the content. All that matters is that tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people are directly engaged with the game. This form of magic is the most potent and we as consumers can feel it because that's when crowdfunding campaigns start to skyrocket or stores start running out of stock for a game or even if it shoots up the beauty hotness. This is the loftiest dream of publishers. And the cost to send a few dozen copies of a game is a very small investment for what is potentially a massive return. Having 100,000 people watch a raven review about your game for 30 minutes is an absolute dream scenario for many publishers. And if the cost is literally just sent in a box that's going to be mailed over, that's a ridiculous return on investment. Plus, it's relatively safe. Even if no YouTuber they send a game to creates true virality, the impressions are often good enough to justify the expense. Now, on the flip side, content creators get to avoid one of the greatest expenses of the production pipeline. If you recall my own metrics, ad revenue from content creation alone is not profitable enough for most people. And while I'm still a tiny YouTuber, there are many, many out there who receive even less ad revenue

than I do. So, what that means is people who want to create videos and can't justify the expense of spending upwards of $100 on the latest hotness, they're more than happy to receive board games directly from the publishers with few if any commitments to cover the game. Many of the publishers who have reached out to me literally just want me to receive a copy of their game. No strings attached, no deal to sign. They just want to send it over in hopes that it ends up on a viral video or even just as a, "Hey dude, check out this game. We think you might like it. By the way, we love your videos." Of course, some other publishers, they do want you to sign some kind of contract or some kind of deal, but it's not really that stringent on what you have to say or do to cover that game. And this whole symbiosis means that content creators are able to consistently push out new content without having to spend much actual money on the actual product they receive. It allows them to stay current without worrying too much about the return on investment on each and every video they produce. So, it creates this positive feedback loop. Publishers want to send copies for engagement. Content creators don't make much money, so they happily receive game copies. And then lastly, and arguably most importantly, viewers are happy to watch content about the newest products.

So, do I have a problem with this? No, not really. I think it's actually a fine way to approach content creation. Almost every single board game YouTuber that you watch has likely received some game copies from a publisher. It's a symbiotic relationship that is really a part of the nature of the industry. Creating board game content on YouTube simply doesn't feed a household for 99.9% of creators. So, at the very least, they can try to sustain their channel by receiving game copies. The reality is that board game channels that get maybe one or 2,000 views per video are only making a few hundred a month from ad revenue. That revenue is simply not enough to cover the potentially dozen or so games that they actually cover per month. So, I think it's mutually beneficial for the publishers and the content creator in most cases. And if you as a consumer want to hear about the newest games, it's the most effective way to get a steady drip of information from people you like to listen to. So, you might be asking, why doesn't Big Posi receive promotional copies if he's fine with the concept? And that's a great question. Let's take a look at the real email template I send to publishers when they ask me if I would like a copy of their game.

Hi, name here. Thank you kindly for the email and information. I sincerely appreciate your message and offer for collaboration with publisher for game. It's honestly an honor to have you and your company reach out to me. I took a look at game and it seems like a insert comment here. I must apologize though. I will politely decline your offer to send me a copy for collaboration. My filming schedule is extremely tight and I have many other ideas I have already resigned myself for. It would not be fair for you to send me a game copy and I never get around to actually covering it properly. I am also not confident that receiving promotional copies for a game will produce unbiased content for viewers even if disclosed. I have not yet received a promotional/review copy of a game and I think that is healthy for my channel and for my opinions to remain truly unbiased. Again, I sincerely appreciate your email and offer, but I will politely be declining. I wish you and your team much success. Should there be any questions, please always feel free to reach out. Best regards, Big Plasti. So yeah, in essence, I have enough ideas for videos that I'm already backlogged and I would feel bad if someone sent me a game and I don't ever get around to talking about it. And I think to remain as unbiased as possible, I should buy my own games. All of that said, I know many, many board game content creators who do receive the games for free with few strings attached, and I think that's fine. The good content creators who aren't afraid

to critique and really dig into a game are still valuable resources of information and can provide mostly bias-free analysis. I think the one Achilles heel of all of this is when every single game starts becoming the best game ever. But I find those kind of channels tend to fade away in the background just because they're not really making much interest in content to begin with. For me personally, it's a combination of all the reasons in my email that I don't accept games. If I was completely out of ideas or if I had all the time in the world or if I didn't have access to regular work, there's a good chance I probably would also accept games from publishers as well. Nowadays, I just put this little disclaimer when people try to find my email and it deters like 99% of all the people reaching out to me. So, it seems to work. It lets me check my email less and I don't always have to disappoint publishers with a refusal to check their game out. Now, another side of the coin is sponsorships. This is where a company, often tangentally related to the topic you cover, will reach out for a direct collaboration. I started receiving offers from sponsors when I reached about 5,000ish subscribers. And at that point, I was rather surprised. I wasn't averaging that many views or that many impressions. So, I thought it was an interesting area for future growth. Now, let me explain how it works. From my experience, a sponsor, let's say it's for a mobile game called Gotacha Board Game Waifu, will typically reach out and ask you for your demographic details. This would mean they want to know the age, country, and gender of

your viewers. This demographic analysis is an important first step because a sponsor needs to make sure that Gotacha Board Game Waifu will reach a suitable audience. I actually turned on my brand connect option to take a deeper look and you can see the exact media kit that YouTube created for me. There's a ton of details about age, gender, location, interest, and all kinds of data about my own videos like average watch time and percent of the video actually watched. Hence why most sponsors want their spot in the first few moments of a video before people click out. And I know I don't like the personal data collection either. It's kind of insane right now, but I can say with confidence the majority of YouTubers who actually have sponsors have shared their demographic information with sponsors as a part of that media kit. And I'm sharing it right now to the public so you can all know how that glue is made. Now, very importantly, I don't know the details of users individually. It's all an aggregate of people who watch my content. It's all anonymous on the individual level. So, while I might know I had 100 viewers from New Zealand and that hardcore gamers watch me, there's no way for me to find out who those individuals are. Okay? So, once you send those demographics over and you're approved, there's this negotiation phase. This will often be about how much money per certain amount of views within a certain amount of time. For example, a realistic negotiation for a small YouTuber such as myself would be something like $20 per 1,000 views up to

35,000 views within the first month. And if you hit that view count, a content creator could earn like $700, while on average 35,000 views from YouTube ad revenue is closer to maybe $200. Sponsors essentially can triple or quadruple your income on a video, even for a very small YouTube channel. Now, I'll be honest. I was very tempted to take some of these sponsorships. One of them in particular made me extremely excited. It was one of those sponsorships that every big YouTuber has done before. And when I was talking about it to close friends, a lot of them argue that it actually helps legitimize my channel. And what I mean by that is if a viewer saw that specific sponsorship, people would be like, "Oh man, big pasta. You just made it into the big league. Let's go." And I was actually on the final stages of signing off and making the sponsorship deal when I really sat down with the product and really took a critical look and decided that it was kind of trash and I declined it. I just felt dirty knowing that I might have told someone to get something that I personally myself didn't enjoy. So, it kind of made me sour on the whole sponsorship thing.

It made me think that sponsorships just weren't for me either. I couldn't endorse something that made me feel icky. But I did go back thinking that if a sponsor I actually enjoy like I don't know Costco reached out to me. Yeah, I would probably do that. I think sponsors are totally fine if the content creator truly believes in the product. I don't see anything wrong with advertising something you believe in. And especially given how low ad revenue is for board game YouTube, I don't really blame anyone for taking them. That said, it wasn't really for me. I was never approached by a company I truly believed in and used myself. And like I mentioned, nowadays I put this explicit mention on my YouTube channel profile that pretty much tells everyone I don't accept game copies and I don't take sponsorships. But Costco, if you're listening, I'll talk all day long about how much I love Kirkland Signature.

Anyways, I hope that sheds some lights on how that sponsorship deal works. The other kind of sponsorships. So, I'm not a large YouTuber, but I still find it worth discussing. Sponsorships from gotacha games, VPNs, facial creams, these have all been fairly normalized from a consumer standpoint. Even if we as viewers don't like the product, we kind of understand that content creators need to eat and that if a content creator talks about gotcha board game waifu, it is a wink and a nudge from them saying, "Please let me pay my rent this month." The other side of this and what I would say is the more trickier side is when a publisher gives you a game and then pays you to cover it. Reviews, previews, Kickstarter hype machine videos. There's this wide range of potential content, but it's all paid directly from the publisher to a content creator to explicitly highlight a game. Do I find this a conflict of interest? Maybe. Yes. No. Honestly, I don't know. So, let's sit with it for a moment. If a big channel way bigger than me gets paid $2,000 to cover a game and if they're completely upfront about it being a paid promotion, is that unethical? It would be basically a commercial at that point. So, I suppose that's fine, but there is an added element of parasocial sway. Like, if my favorite YouTube reviewer was like, "This game is magical. It's an absolutely a contender for the best game of the year." Even if they disclose it was a paid preview, I would probably

still trust that subliminal parasocial connection I have with the content creator, I would take a deeper dive into the game and heavily consider buying it. So, is that okay? I think it depends. I'm both a viewer and a creator. And I don't think I would be mad necessarily if my favorite YouTuber said that this game was fantastic and then I go buy it and I'm like, "This sucks." I think it would probably reduce the value of that creator's opinion to me. But then I think about it from the creator's perspective. And honestly, I do feel uncomfortable. Like there's this kind of pressure. Maybe not an explicit say nice things about Glue Factory Express or else kind of pressure, but more of an unconscious kind of I want them to work with me again or this company, they're really nice to me kind of pressure. I guess the question is, do creators who take these kind of deals actually say mean things about these games? Is there an example of a big serious board game YouTuber who got a paid promotion who just kind of says, "This game kind of sucks." when they received payment to cover a game. I honestly don't know if that situation has come. A part of the reason is that I don't think there's that many explicit videos where the creator says, "This is a paid review or preview for Glueactory Express." And look, I'm not saying the positivity is malicious. I don't think taking money automatically makes you a sellout. I truly believe most people are doing the best they can with what they

have. But I think the wrong stance is that some people say it's always categorically wrong for creators to get paid for coverage. Consider this. Many of the best howtoplay tutorials are paid by publishers. And those channels do excellent work with amazingly clear teaching. and their generally neutral presentation about the game. I that seems fine, right? That doesn't seem to bother anyone. But what if at the end of that 30 minute tutorial they add, "I hope you enjoy because we really love this game." Now it's an endorsement, a personal perspective attached to paid content. Is that still okay? It's not as clear-cut, is it? But for myself, deep down in my heart of hearts, I don't know if I can truly remain unbiased if someone is paying me $2,000. And this isn't me being on some moral high ground. It's just being self-aware. So, I avoid it. That's my line. But I'm not going to sit here and say everyone who crosses that line is wrong. Maybe they're stronger than me.

Maybe they take deals where they know they have full creative control. I don't know. But I think it's important to think about anyways. I think for me when I watch a review or see a preview also want to know can that creator be critical. Not every game is 10 out of 10 so much fun can't wait for it to come out kind of game. So does that critique exist? Now what I just spoke about this is my own experience. I'm not a large YouTuber by any means. So my perspective is fairly limited and I'm sure if you talk to other larger YouTubers they probably have more sway in the way that they can present games. direct contribution from viewers. I hope so far you can see how being a small content creator is not that profitable. But this leads me to what I would say is the most successful way to survive off YouTube. Direct contribution from viewers. This spans a whole range of methods, but most popular are Patreons, YouTube memberships, and donation sites like Kofi. This method is most likely to result in some form of long-term stability for a content creator. Even if your view counts are fairly tepid, you can still survive as long as you have a core fan base that is willing to support you. And this method is popular. Board game channels of all sizes will often use some sort of direct viewer contribution to survive. I would say it's a very feelgood model for supporting your favorite creator.

Usually, there's some added perk, some additional content that comes along with membership. But it's also nice helping someone who you feel some sort of positive connection towards. When I talk to my own family and friends, the number one suggestion I get is to start a Patreon or encourage YouTube memberships. And I'll be entirely honest, I sat down and pondered this idea for hours and hours. I've dreamed up a script on how I would introduce a form of monetization to my channel in a positive way, justifying how independent game analysis is something that needs to exist for a healthy marketplace. And I don't disagree with my premises of justification. My problem is that I grew up in a time where I would watch my favorite YouTube videos, my favorite content, and there was never any pressure to pay. There just wasn't that pay wall. And I feel like this is an ideal of something that I would want to uphold. I really don't like the idea of putting my content behind a payw wall.

My videos are really meant to be explorative and enjoyed and discussed and brutally torn apart without any financial barriers. Even bonus content, I don't see it that way. If the bonus content is good and people want to watch it, I would want to be able to access it for free like I did growing up. Okay, but what about donations for donation's sake? just asking for funds because you like me and want to support. But that was never the point of Big Pasti. I still see this YouTube process as a hobby. It might come to that stage where I eventually need funds to survive, but I'm not at that point. And I have no interest in advertising doom or gloom for sympathy donations. I think to myself that I want people to enjoy my videos without any strings attached. And I get it. like times right now. They're not great. And I don't want to use any of my parasocial credibility to guilt people into directly financially supporting me. And I don't mean this as a criticism, but there does exist some level of parasocial bonds between you and I, even if we don't want to admit it. I know that I'm way more likely to financially support a YouTuber that I've been watching for years and years, than I am to donate to someone entirely random who might need the money more. Do I think it's unethical to ask money from your viewers? No, not at all. It's an amazing idea to live and survive off board game content. And for the talented few who actually make it work, I applaud

them. But for me, it just doesn't feel right when I can be fully employed. And I just felt icky with the idea of locking content behind a payw wall. So, after all that talk about money and independence and not taking sponsorships, here's my next steps. Recently, I've downsized my 9 to5 work obligations to finish a bigger project. Ever since June of 2023, I've been working with every spare moment I could muster on my own board game. Yes, the rumors are true. Yes, it's happening. I am neck deep into developing a game. Sunlet's Eulogy will be up for crowdfunding summer 2026. This game is really the culmination of everything I've learned from my YouTube analysis, from all the games I've played, from all the hours and hours of research, and from reading all of the debates in my YouTube comments. It's a game I'm incredibly proud of, and it's the kind of game I would want to play over and over again. It's a game that's really focused on two of my favorite things: religion and grief. I don't want to give away too much yet, but it's centered around a schism between disciples after the death of their prophet. Each player is trying to sway the faith towards their sect, but the true goal is to actually have the religion succeed in the long term. The key mechanical feelings I want to focus on is the feeling of mourning.

Not only for the death of your prophet, but also for the loss of faith. What it feels like to be a non-believer among believers. and ultimately the more you feel when it's the loss of kinship and trust. I've incorporated a ton of things I've learned about from this channel, from social deduction to asymmetry to meanness in games. I dove deep and kept digging to make this. It's a game that wants to create a puzzle of alliances built out of paper thin agreements and conflicts that are often forgiven but rarely forgotten. It's a game that's admittedly weird, but it's a game that's pure in design. I have no interest in mechanical bloat or feature creep. And even though it's a game about mourning, I'm aiming to ensure that this game isn't one of those massive coffin boxes that just sit idly on your calax.

So folks, it's the morning of January 1st, 2026, and it's time for the favor. I spent just about 28 minutes explaining why I don't ask for money, and now I'm going to ask for some help. Over the next few months, I'll be gearing up for the launch of Sunless Eulogies crowdfunding campaign. But right now, the best way to stay in the loop is to subscribe and hit the notification bell. I want to talk about this game in upcoming videos and to start that pre-launch hype machine. I expect the preview launch page to drop in about 2 months with gameplay overviews to follow and the actual crowdfunding beginning in summer 2026. So, I'm not asking for any money yet. All I'm asking is if you'd like to support me and this channel, and most importantly, if Sunlight Elo sounds even the slightest bit interesting, please subscribe and turn on notifications so you don't miss any updates. Now, I want to keep in track with my previous financial transparency. Sunlets Eulogy is my game.

Supporting it, following it on Gamefound, backing it in the future. All of this will directly help me both financially and to increase awareness of the game. With regards to the expenditures related to Sunless Eulogy, every single dollar in its creation to date came directly out of my own pocket. It took roughly about $10,000 as of today, and the vast majority of that expenditure is towards art and graphic design. I completely expect to fund another $5,000 to 10,000 in the coming months as we gear up for launching the campaign. What this means is that if the campaign is a failure, I expect to be out between 15,000 and 20,000, which is actually perfectly okay. That was the expectation going into this project, and I have no issue if it gets 20% funded, cancelled, and I move on to the next exciting adventure in my life. But I do think it would be really cool to get it funded. I wouldn't just push something out into the world just because. And I am legitimately excited to show this game off, to have you play it, to see people talk about it, how it made these crazy stories happen at their tables.

I'm hyped because I believe it's a good game, and it's my brainchild that I want to see experienced at your game nights. Anyways, I sincerely appreciate you for listening, your comments, and your support for me. That's it. As always, thank you for watching and bye.

Progress saved