Skip to main content
Loading video...

Aqua Review: There's Always A Bigger Fish

Transcript 9:29

hi everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we are bord of and Welcome to our review of Aqua biodiversity in the oceans which is a tile laying game for one to four players so this is if youve played tile Ling game before like Cascadia or Calico very similar you have the market in the middle you're taking a tile but in this one you're going to create a biodiverse coral reef and attract small animals and large animals while trying to fulfill scoring conditions before we get into the review and how play please note we are provided this copy as a review copy by the publisher asaday

nordx playing Aqua is quite simple it's a family weight game whoever starts a game as first player will have the sea snail marker and they will fill F the market with as many tiles as there are players plus one then they will add the sea snail to the market and make their choice now you can pick one of the tiles in the middle or the sea snail if you pick the SE snail you will then go last out of everyone but first next turn otherwise you'll take a tile and you'll add it to your little starting coral reef to make a habitat and what you're trying to do is to create reefs and habitats so a habitat is when by matching the colors you create a hexagonal shape and then you must instantly take a matching animal from here and place it on top if you get a number of matching or not matching so if you get a number of these small animals next to each other in certain shapes you can take a large animal and put them on top the small animals large animals are worth points but another way you can get points is by making reefs and this is when you have four of one color all adjacent to each other then anything next to that Reef will score its Point values if it's a small animal the big animals are taken off before you do that scoring finally you'll have these

randomized tiles every game and you'll have six of them in play corresponding to the six small animal types and they give you different ways to score and they relate to the animal so for example the seahorse here if you have the most seahorses you will get seven points all other players will get or second most will get three points uh this one for the total for every turtle you have score one point for every small animal adjacent to it things like that and there's quite a variety of these tiles and then at the end of the game which will last kind of 17 turns rounds you will score everything up up and the player with the most points wins an important consideration before we start is that we have only played this game with two players and we believe there's some elements that don't work quite as well making it a not ideal player count the issue for us is that when we have groups of friends over this just isn't a game that we'd want to get out because you are just sat quietly working on your own puzzle so it's a bit of a catch 22 for us at least so please consider this review through that lens one example of this is you have the sea snail which I mentioned you could choose to take on your turn and then you go last or you get the last pick in that round where you go first in the next round this is quite an interesting tactical decision to make but it's something that would really shine with more players because at two players you're either first or you're last and you have a choice of three tiles or two tiles which isn't

that big a difference whereas if you're playing with four your choice would be between five tiles and two tiles so taking that can be quite an interesting decision to make and really liven the game up a bit but at two just doesn't quite work a secondary issue with this is that it makes the round structure quite poorly paced at two because the game moves so rapidly in many other games of this type the marketplace has a consistent number of tiles so when a player takes a tile it gets refilled instantly and then the game ends when they run out of tiles here it's more more fiddly because the first player needs to put the sea now back into the marketplace only for the second player to have to remember to take it then refill the marketplace at the end of the round and then just immediately put the se s back into the marketplace another element that didn't quite click with us was the central Marketplace because you have one more tile than there are a number of players but it's not refilled as players take tiles so if you're playing a low play count game you don't have a lot of options if you playing a high playay C game and you're going kind of later in turn order not a lot of options and it comes across as quite frustrating at times when the the pool is so limited and with other games of this type A lot of them will keep the marketplace static you know a player takes tile and one goes back in or give players ways to

wipe the tiles or the marketplace a few times a game to give them flexibility and I think that would have helped this be a better game if there was some of these elements in there and the problem is that this Limited Marketplace it it combines with the fact that you have three most of the time different colors on these tiles and that means you basically have three different considerations and you're also very limited in the shapes you can make because you're trying to make hexagons for most of the time and then you're trying to make specific shapes of hexagons to get large animals and meet very kind of different and conflicting criteria so it generally just comes across at least to us as a bit more frustrating than fun because of these limitations and limitations in the marketplace I know some will say but wait that's the game however it's just really tricky to put into words it just doesn't come across as a satisfying experience more frustrating I think the summary is that that it's not first inclass it's not best in class but it's not worst inclass either which with so much competition in the space is tough however there are many great things about Aqua the variety being one of them in each game you'll have six scoring tiles and these will shape your considerations for how you play that specific game you can randomize these or play in the scenarios that the game

suggests they do create quite a different experience each game and are about 20 scoring tiles to choose from it's pretty fun to lay out your scoring tiles and consider how you're going to adapt to the challenge of the current situation or think of Novel ways to combo things together to rack up big points there is also a solid quarter Aqua to complement the variety there are many interesting decisions on how to proceed and you'll be pulled in a different direction with each tile you lay should you create a habitat or go for reefs should you focus on getting points from small and large animals or go for full steam ahead on the scoring tiles we actually think it's even maybe a little bit more complex than other games of a similar nature just because of all the different considerations that you're presented with aqua also manages to make some of these decisions competitive which is a rarity in this type of game the points on the large animals decrease as each one of a certain species is claimed so players are in a race to create certain shapes of biodiverse animals and claim the large animals with the most points some of the scoring tiles also further this competitiveness by awarding points to the player that has the most of a specific type of small animal lastly this is a beautiful game if you go for reefs you'll be creating some wonderful patterns and end up with something quite pleasing plus as you'll be laying tiles on top of tiles you'll end up with a really striking 3D landscape which will catch the attention of anyone walking past also the tiles are wonderfully

chunky so it has a really nice tactility so final thoughts Aqua is a beautiful thailan game with great variability if you get this game it's something we think you can play for a long long time without getting bored so the biggest issue we kind of have with aqua is that it's in a very crowded space and they are just playing better games in our opinion like Calico Cascadia yeah so it's kind of a tough recommendation when you could have that and I think there are design elements that I much prefer in those games which we talked about previously so yeah it it's kind of hard to recommend although I'll say tally does like it a bit more than me I'm bit ambivalent on it but that is our review of Aqua we hope it was helpful please ask us any questions down below we'd appreciate it if you could subscribe if it was helpful because it helps us grow the channel and we will see you next time thanks for watching bye

Progress saved