Ranking the Booker 2026 Shortlist
Transcript
Hey readers, this is Liz and I have read the Booker Prize short list and I'm ready to offer my opinions. So, there are six books in the list. Um, there was one I really didn't like, there was one I really did like, and then everything else is kind of in the middle. But I'm going to give a rough listing of what I thought about them from worst to best. And then, you know, when they announced the prize in November, we'll see how I did. Uh, but you just really never know with the Booker. I don't think that my favorite book on the list has ever won the Booker except for maybe uh when Hillary Mantel was in the running with Wolf Hall and Bring Up the Bodies. Okay, so um let's just start at the bottom, shall we? So my least favorite book on the list and this one it made me sad that it was my least favorite book because I love the author um was Elizabeth Stout's The Things We Never Say. So I loved Olive Kitridge. I thought that book was amazing and so I was hoping that having another book from her that's set in a new world would be really great. Uh, and the book isn't horrible. Like it's um it's an entertaining read. It's about a teacher who is depressed and he really finds out that his life isn't what he thinks it is. And you know there's a lot to that.
So I mean I wouldn't say the book is like terrible. I'm surprised that it's on the Booker short list. And I think my biggest beef with the book isn't that it's political because literature is political, but that there's just a whole lot of going on and on and on about the election and how the world is falling apart. And like I know that the election was bad and that the world is falling apart, but the way that was handled in the novel just kind of felt like hearing your aunt complain about it at Thanksgiving and not like literature that was taking it to a new place that helped me actually process it or think about it in in ways that helped. And so, you know, there were large chunks of the book that were very emotional that I was super interested in. And then there was just these long kind of detailed discussions of the election when you know the the main character is a teacher and that stuff infiltrates his classroom. I would have been way more interested in seeing more of that kind of scene and a lot less of just things are bad. So I really felt that the book hit some wrong notes. I felt like it handled a painful subject in ways that felt kind of hamfisted instead of interesting. And um therefore is my least favorite on the list.
Then things get a little murkier because I genuinely liked all the writing books, but I think my probably my number five is going to be The End of Everything by M. John Harrison. So, I'd never heard of M. John Harrison before, but apparently he's a very established author. I would certainly read more from him. But The End of Everything is kind of like a sci-fi novel about a weird future where these aliens have come and they've really like broken time and society has broken down and there are these things called artifacts that are clearly not dead. Uh coming up from the sea and you know we have two people who encounter one of them and go on a journey let's say. I don't want to like talk too much about what's in the book because I do think that you have to just go in and read it. Um, there were moments of intense emotion in the book. Uh, there were things that I thought were really powerful. I thought the writing was really good, but Harrison is really determined to kind of make your entry into the world as confusing as the world that he's created. And I think that it hurt my ability to latch on um as much as I wanted to to parts of the story. Um it was like he was just so determined to have the world be obscure and to really make you feel like kind of time loss and puzzlement that it took away from other aspects of the book that were really working for me. So it's not bad. I think it's really interesting, especially if you like that kind of book. but it didn't quite hit
for me. Uh I would try other books from him though. Then you know I think my number four is a book that I really liked but I am not sure that it's as good as the book that he already won a booker for and that would be John of John by Douglas Stewart. And I want to point out I really really like this book. I very much enjoyed reading it. Uh I thought that it was super well written. I thought that there were really great layers to the story. I thought the characterization was great. It's about a young gay man who returns home to the aisle of sky to kind of live with his impoverished family who still goes to church and he has a very religious dad who doesn't accept him for who he is and they go through it. Um, there were aspects of the plot that I thought were just a little bit precious. And it was interesting because, you know, I thought I really like Suggie Bane. Like Suggie Bane was a very raw book in a lot of ways. And it, you know, this is maybe my prejudice. It felt more literary. John of John felt more like a movie that was ultimately pretty uplifting.
Um, I don't want to give too much away. You know, there's there's moments of great emotional goodness and badness in the book, so don't get me wrong, but the book just it felt it felt more like a story that was just kind of going for my heartstrings as opposed to a story that was really showing me something in the way that I would have expected after having read Shiggy Bane. Um, so Jumpon was good, but it was good like I would recommend it to somebody who's a summer read. Um, and not necessarily good booker. I think like I want weirder books on the Booker Prize list. So that leads to I picked some weirder books for my top three. Uh so I think my number three is going to be Black Bag by Luke Kennard. I really liked the book and I did not expect to. It is a weirdass book. It is about a dude who decides to take a job. Like he's an actor who takes like shitty acting jobs and he works for a professor as black bag and he just wears a black leather bag that he can barely see out of and nothing else eventually and he just sits in class and like attends lectures and the students respond to him, but he becomes like obsessed with wearing the black bag around and it becomes something more and more and more. And just the writing was great. the characterization of the main character who's just such a weirdo really made me laugh. Um, it was I I very I very rarely just thoroughly enjoy someone's inner voice this much uh in a book and I thought that the main
character was hilarious. I really enjoyed him and uh you know his descriptions of doing crappy dinner theaters and interacting with other actors and like the truths he told about you know the more embarrassing parts of himself um I just found it all very charming. Uh, I think where the book fell a little bit shorter for me is that there are long stretches of the book where we're interacting with um the main character's friend who's a streamer and all the stuff about like streaming and monetizing things and, you know, discussions of masculinity and like how men exist in the world today. I didn't like that part as much. I kind of feel like it there's there were just things about it that didn't quite hit for me, even though I think that's a very timely thing to talk about. And it took me out of just the weirdness of this guy being black bag. So there were parts later in the book where it got like too weird, but not because of him. Like I was kind of down for him to just do whatever is black bag because of other people's reactions to black bag. It got a little too crazy for me and I just, you know, it it wasn't like a full five star hit it out of the park, but I really really liked it and I do highly recommend that you read it.
Uh, and then we have in second place for me, uh, May We Feed the King by Rebecca Perry. And so because I'm a trained historian, like this was almost certainly going to be cabinet for me. I was super excited by the premise, but it's about a woman whose career is arranging scenes in like old castles and old buildings and stuff that that are reminiscent of the time. So she might like make a king's chamber look like the king was there and like there's royal clothing and maybe like some halfeaten turkey legs or something somewhere. There's a book and some candles and like her job is to create the time and she's clearly really into it. Um, and then she becomes really obsessed with this particular job and you get insight into her thoughts and like she's really damaged. Something really rough has clearly happened in her life and she's healing. She's not really in a great place and she becomes really attached to this king who also wasn't in a really great place when he became king. He clearly hates his job. Um, and there are very limited records of him and what [clears throat] he did and how he dealt with his life. But nevertheless, you get like these accounts of how he felt. But the the book raises these really interesting questions about what do we reveal like about ourselves when we choose to study things. You know, what can we know uh from limited material when we're talking about history and who people were, how they felt, and like what they did? um you know, what does it mean to do something that's historically accurate versus like what the people want to see? It was all just a really interesting book that was written beautifully. So, Perry, this is
apparently her first novel, but she's a poet. Um, and you could tell the writing is gorgeous, but I just was really along for the ride. I was fascinated throughout the entire book. You know, the main character was weird. Both of them were weird. Um, and I really enjoyed it, honestly. Um, I could definitely see falling a little bit too far into a job like that. So, um, it it was just a really interesting read that I relished and it was short, so you don't get easy answers from the book. Um, but it it was exactly the right length to keep me along for the ride. And then my number one on the list, um, was Maron James's The Disappears. So, this book was amazing. I think it was maybe the hardest read in the list because it was a tough read in terms of just violence that happens in the book and it made me upset. Um, but it was also the best read in the sense of just the writing is great. The book really has a sense of place. It really draws you in and it was like every time I picked it up to read more, I was like transported back into the story like going into a portal. And when that happens, you know, a book is great. So, The Disappears is about a group of gay men who get together to put on a play and they kind of start bonding while they're rehearsing the play. uh but they never get to put it on because these they're attacked by members of their community. This is set in like the late 80s in Jamaica where you know violence against gay men is cheered on even by the police. And so you know these men are hated and they're looking to kind of scratch out some kind of life in a place
where they're rejected by their families, met with sort of violence. they could die for their orientation and you know then the after the crime they live with the aftermath of it. So they sustain various injuries. People have various responses. One person kind of withdraws another seeks revenge. And so the book just feels really real. It's very visceral. Um and I both enjoyed it and was really saddened by a lot of what happened in it. It's a very unflinching book. So, if you want to read something that feels a little bit warmer, don't read this one. But, uh, if you want to really get attached to characters who go through it, then I think The Disappears is far the best of the lot. Um, Marlon James is a great author and The Disappears may be his best yet. So, um, yeah, that's the one that I think is the best in show of the Booker short list.
However, all the books were interesting. I regret reading none of them. Uh, and if any of them sound interesting to you. You really can't go wrong picking them up. So, those are my thoughts on the Booker short list. We'll see who wins, uh, I'll come back and comment after the results go in. Uh, if you've read the books on this list or any of them, if you've read any of the books on this list or all of them, uh, I would be very curious about your opinions as well. Let me know in the comments. And thanks so much for watching. Happy reading, everyone.