Chinatown Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
Hey everybody, today I'm talking about Chinatown, which is a board game that dates back to 1999. This one is an economic negotiation style game that accommodates three to five players and takes around an hour to play. So, the idea of this game is to acquire the most money by the end of six rounds or six years thematically uh depicted on this track here. And as you can see from the board here, we've got all these different regions um with these different units numbered from 1 to 85. Now, normally the board would start completely fresh with nothing on there whatsoever, but I've advanced the game somewhat just to give you better examples about how the game actually plays. So, the way you're going to accumulate money is by building shops. And as you can see on the board here, there's all these different types of shops such as laundry shops, you've got antique shops, restaurants, you've got tropical fish shops. So, all these different things that can be um built. And the idea is you're trying to build the biggest stores um at least connected and controlled by yourself in order to get more money because the smaller the unit, the smaller or the smaller amount of cash you're going to get at the end of the round. So, for example here, this tropical fish shop, um this number shows what it needs to be to be at full capacity or full size. Um and this one's controlled by the yellow player. So, this one is a full four shop, which is going to be quite a nice little earner.
But from um an example here, this factory shop, um needs a six to be at full capacity or full potential. Um and I'm only controlling one of them at the moment, which is going to be a lot um smaller amount of money that's going to gain. Um but of course, as the game goes on, you can expand that. So, let's talk about how the game actually plays out. So, the first thing that you're going to do in a round is you're going to draw a number of cards from the stack here uh depending on the player count. So, in preparation, I've I've already done it here. And these are going to show the units you can potentially um claim for your own at least for the uh time being. So, um you're going to have a number of cards, and out of those cards, you're going to keep um uh a number of them. So, in in this example, in a three-player game, you're going to draw four cards uh sorry, six cards, and you're going to keep four of them. So, let's just say I claim these top four here.
And then I'd place my disc on the board um corresponding to those spots. So, you know, for example here, that 13 card, I've already put my disc on there. But everyone one will be doing this at the same time. And the reason you're doing this is not only to um potentially claim spots for yourself in order to um build your own businesses into, you have to bear in mind what other people might want as well because those spots could be worth quite a bit to those players. So, for example here, uh this red player has these two seafood shops here. Um but he needs room to expand into that to get that third one down. But this spot here and this spot spot here might be worth a bit of money to that player. So, once that's done, you are going to draw a number of tiles from the uh bag here blindly um depending on the amount of cards that you've kept. So, in this example, I'd draw four tiles, and I would place them in front of me. And these are going to be the uh shops that I can potentially um place onto the board into my own units. So, in a in this example, I've got two takeout stores, I've got a jewelry store, and in fact, I've got a third takeout store, which can be really good because um if I had three adjacent pieces of property, I want to a bit of a winner there.
So, once every player has placed their units onto the board and drawn their tiles from the bag, then a complete open forum in terms of trading is going to start. And this is where any player can trade anything with other players um as as you know, as much as they want to. So, for example, you could trade units for other units. You could end up trading units for money. You can trade tiles. You could do any combination of that lot at all. So, it really is open reign on what you want to do here. So, for example, this yellow player might really want this spot here because he wants some room to expand his factory into. And he might be willing to trade money for that. He might be willing to trade some of his tiles for that. He might want to um give the uh the white player a spot that he wants um in exchange. So, for example, he might want to swap this yellow token with this white token here so that everybody um benefits mutually.
So, this is completely up to the uh players' content. They can do whatever they want and um strike a deal that they think's good for them. Now, after that's complete and everybody's satisfied with what they've done, then it is going to be time to place your tiles onto the board. Um and you can basically um all once these tiles are placed onto the board, then they are not going to be able to move anymore. So, once the tiles themselves are placed, they they are stuck there, but it doesn't mean the owner is necessarily going to be the same. So, you know, even though um you know, this this player here um has has already claimed this building, it doesn't mean that I couldn't trade that for a yellow token um you know, in in a in a deal that I've struck previously. So, that is something to bear in mind. The only thing that you can't move is things that are already stuck onto the board.
And after everybody's placed their tiles that they want to, then you are going to basically start the scoring round where you're going to score money uh depending on the different size of shops that you own. So, if using this little chart here, which I'm not sure the camera will pick up very well, um it's going to show you how much money you get per store that you own. So, for example, if you've got an incomplete store of a size one, you'd get 10,000. If it's a incomplete store at size two, you get 20,000. Three, 40,000. Four, 60,000. And five, 80,000. But on top of that, if you complete the stores, then you're going to get an additional bonus um starting from three up going from 50 to 80 to 110 to 140,000. So, you know, not only are you incentivized to get the bigger stores, you also want to complete them for an additional bonus. And as soon as that's done, you're going to take all your money from your bank and you're going to advance the round one track one space on the track and go again. And by the time the sixth one is uh the sixth round is finished, you're going to tally up your total amount of money, and the winner is going to be determined. So, that's going to be the rule set, pretty simple in terms of the rules overhead. But let's talk about how I feel about the gameplay itself.
The first thing that really struck me with this game is how simple the rules themselves are. Simply drawing cards from the stack here, choosing which ones you want to keep, and placing your discs on the board, drawing a few tiles out, and then basically, the negotiation is going to start. So, that negotiation is really where the game sings. It's what the game is all about. And I love the way that the game puts that magnifying glass over that part of the game and doesn't bog it down with all the other sections. It really is about that crux, the crucible of the game. It really is about negotiating, striking deals that you think are going to benefit you more than the other players. Now, I generally like negotiation as a as a general mechanism. You know, there's a lot of my favorite games use negotiation as a as an aspect of them. And this one, I just love the way that it's the sole focus of it. And um the things that you can do in terms of negotiation is fascinating because it pretty much is open game. You can do whatever you want apart from move where the stores are. But even though the stores are placed there, it doesn't mean that you can't just start claiming them as your own if you're willing to pay for it. So, I really do love that hustle and bustle. I love the um you know, people thinking they've always got one over on each other. And that really does shine through probably more than any other negotiation game I've ever played, to be honest. I just love the freedom and um enjoyment you get from just striking those deals. Absolutely phenomenal. And um after you've done that, of course, you're going to start um tallying up your worth of all your different businesses. And that itself is great because that mathematical puzzle of what things are going to be worth you, you know, whether you are going to maybe take a speculative punt on you know, um you know, am I going to pay
quite a lot of bit of money for this land in hope in or in hope that I'm going to um draw the shop tiles to grow into that as well, or am I going to sit on a bit of land and hope it's going to be worth a bit to someone else later and potentially charge them a fortune. But also bearing in mind that as the as the rounds go by, that land's going to potential potentially diminish in value because of course, you're only going to get the money at the end of each round. So, the uh the returns are going to diminish as you go throughout. So, there is a real mathematical aspect to this game that you do have to rack your brain over, but the the enjoyment and the likeness of it doesn't get bogged down by the math or the the mathiness. And I think that is absolutely great. So, in terms of the decisions, it really is up to you what you want to do. And I think um Chinatown does a great job of facilitating that negotiation aspect of the game. Just really well implemented, and I'm very very impressed.
And kind of following on from the mechanisms and the decisions, the balance is uh naturally or is naturally kind of um formulated because, you know, it really is up to you what you think things are worth. You know, if you get completely ripped off by a deal that you've made, then you know, that's your fault. And um but you know, you can't blame the game itself for doing that. So, it's not one of those games that you feel completely shafted if things don't go your own way. You know, you really have got yourself to blame. Yes, there are sometimes where players are just going to draw a bunch of um of these units right next to each other and can easily just expand into them and smash their big buildings down straight away. But that just means that other players can just start driving up or you know, start making uh harder and harsher deals with that player to try and catch up with them. The production of the game is fantastic.
Uh this isn't an overly expensive game, and you know, all the finishes on those products are really nice. A nice glossy feel to the board. The tiles are good quality. These little discs are really good. Uh the card stock is good. You know, the money looks looks decent. These are all nicely clearly um you know, depicted. So, yeah, no issues whatsoever in terms of the production. I think it looks wonderful, and it's just uh strikes a nice balance of being um you know, really good quality, but not being overdone. As scalability, you are going to need at least three players to play this game. Um but of course, you'd probably presume that with a with a negotiation style game, it's not going to be good to negotiate with one other player. Um but even at that lower player count, at that three player, it does work extremely well because it is scaled in terms of you know, you're going to get more buildings, and um you're probably going to be um more likely to get these full-size units as well. So, yeah, overall, I was absolutely blown away with Chinatown. Uh I'm really surprised I haven't got this one played sooner and I'm really glad I have now.
This one is you know, I always think it's a bit of a a giveaway when a game has been around for over 20 years and is still being sold and still in production and still in print. And this is I think Chinatown is a testament to this timeless design where the rules themselves are so low and easy to understand but the gameplay itself is so strong and the game is all between the players. This is exactly what I want from a negotiation game but certainly probably the strongest example of pure negotiation I've ever seen. Just absolutely phenomenal. So interactive, really low rules overhead. You're probably going to have to have the right gaming group to get the most out of it but even if they don't and you got that kind of shyer um kind of player, you know, I think they're going to be more invested in this one because they are going to going to be able to tangibly make those deals rather than just, you know, play along and role play kind of thing that a lot of other kind of negotiation style games do. This one, you know, you can really mathematically map out what you are willing to spend with things and get involved that way. So I'm so so impressed with this one. It's it's brilliant. I absolutely love this one and it's certainly been around for a long time for a good reason. So yeah, certainly stay in my collection. I'm actually going to give this one my highest acclaim in terms of the elite shield because I think it is phenomenal.
So that is Chinatown. Definitely check this one out if you like your interactive you like your economic games and you like to negotiate your good deals with other players. This one is just a prime prime example. So I hope you've enjoyed this video. If you have, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too. For everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.