Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Years of Gaming - TCbH Podcast

Transcript 1:15:19

Hello and welcome back to the Cardboard Herald podcast. My name is Eric, joined this week by my lovely co-host Jack, but more importantly, joined this week by Jack, the founder of the Cardboard Herald, this this YouTube channel you're watching on that has grown into what it is. Uh 10 years. 10 years. Uh yeah, Jack's been doing this for 10 years. Uh I have joined on more recently, but it's been 10 years of what this channel has become. Uh Jack's been doing it for for a decade now. Uh

Uh it's it's Sometimes it feels very much like I've been doing it for a decade, and then other times it's like, "Oh my god, it's been a decade. I can't believe it." Uh it's it's been a long time coming. I'm glad that I get to do a little bit of a celebration chat with you.

Yeah, I mean, I think that it's been something that you should be proud of in a sense. I mean, like I you and I I think both know that there's bigger, greater things that we want to do with this channel in general.

Yeah.

But I think that this is a really good mo- moment to look back at what uh what we've done so far. Um

Yeah, absolutely.

So, this is going to be kind of an interview, kind of a podcast for people tuning in. Uh and I think the first question I kind of have for you is, you know, you've discussed it before uh I think on this podcast uh in a couple other places, but for everyone who hasn't heard, um what made you want to start the thing that would eventually become the Cardboard Herald?

How sentimental do you want me to get?

Oh, cr- it up. Crank it up. Go big mode.

Um so, it is a story of life and death. And I know that seems hyperbolic for uh a board game blog, which it was initially, uh that had some podcasting components because I wanted to create an audio diary, and then eventually changed into an interview podcast. And then more written reviews, and then eventually into the YouTube channel. So, 10 years dates back to the first time The Cardboard Herald name was used. Um yeah, so what happened is I I've always been a pretty creative person. I have a lot of hobbies. Uh music, for the most part, has been my main passion in life. Um and uh in 2015, the year before we started, two life-changing events happened for me. Uh the first uh was that my son was born, which was super exciting, you know. And anyone who is a parent will tell you uh that there is kind of like a a profound transcendent change that just impacts your scope. It impacts how you think about yourself, how you think about the world. Um and I was no different than that. Um then uh also my uh oldest childhood friend, uh Peter, he uh passed away of cancer uh after a long

battle with lots of um lots of health issues for the prior couple of years. But those both happened in 2015, and Peter, he was a writer, uh and he was someone who always challenged me on music. He challenged me on uh our our personal taste in movies and books. Uh he was one of the weird kids with me who uh in fourth grade was trying to play the strangest video games we could rent. In you know, seventh grade we were looking at the weirdest comic books that we could find. In high school, he's the one who ended up trying to get me to listen to the weirdest indie music he could discover.

But his main passion was writing and mine was creating music. And we would send files to one another. He eventually moved out of Alaska. He moved to China. And we would send I would send music to him. He would send writing to me. Um and when he passed it felt like you know, a piece of me was going. Fortunately, he got to meet my son. That was really important to me before he died. So, how this relates to the Cardboard Herald is um my music. I I have all these like guitars and bases over here.

I love playing drums. My first instrument was the flute. I love playing pretty much anything loud, you know. Give me a harmonica, give me some woodwinds, some horns, anything. I'll make use out of it. But with an infant in the home and the sort of I guess uh infrastructure in Juno, walls are thin.

[clears throat and laughter]

It's not It's not easy to be able to uh practice and record and play a lot of music when you have an infant and you're trying to work around their schedule. I can play quietly, but you know, so I wasn't doing music as much. And after Peter died, I started thinking a lot more about what I wanted to do creatively. And I wanted to do some sort of writing in his honor. Um and I love reading and I love fiction, uh which is what he uh typically worked with. But, I I didn't really feel either confident or truly inspired in writing fiction.

Mhm.

So, I was like, well, what are the things that I most like reading that does feel within like a a wheelhouse? Uh and Peter and I used to talk all the time about um like some of our favorite uh film critics. Um so, Roger Ebert is uh obviously um a touchstone there. Uh but, uh there there's all kinds of film critics, you know, you can go back to some what is it uh Pauline Kael um and check out some of her uh old stuff, but I I started thinking about more colorful criticism, and I was also very into tabletop games since I was very young. Uh so, I was like, well, how about I just set this modest goal of writing Roger Ebert-like reviews for board games uh as an amateur writer who never went to school for writing or anything like that.

Obviously, uh that was a super high um uh bar to meet, but it allowed me to feel closer to Peter um and closer to kind of honoring some of the memory uh because he always encouraged me to try writing um instead of music or in addition to music. Uh and it gave me a creative outlet uh to work on while um my son is was sleeping uh while my family was busy, while I didn't have time to play with other musicians or or find an opportunity. So, I'm I just uh uh dove into it, uh launching with four reviews uh as a blog. I knew nothing about this. I I got a Squarespace uh because the podcast kept on recommending it. I was like, "I don't know anything about a website design, so sure, Squarespace."

And from there um it quickly pivoted to interviews being a secondary pillar of the Cardboard Herald because like I said, I was listening to podcasts. I listened to a lot of uh Mark Maron's WTF podcast. And I thought about like, man, there's so many interesting people out there uh that have worked on tabletop games. Uh in particular for me, I was interested in like the old guard. Uh I really sought out old um Magic the Gathering artists or the creators uh from like the original Magic sets. Um I sought out uh uh some of the people who had made foundational games in the past. Um but uh that all kind of started because um my friend Mike Hyman is a published board game designer here in Juneau, Alaska, and I was like, I don't know. I'm doing this like diary podcast thing.

What if I just had you on and we just [snorts] talked about board games? And that extremely quickly pivoted to uh talking with Patrick Leder of Leder Games. Uh he was very early on. He was doing a Kickstarter for Vast. That's how long ago this was, before Root, before Cole Wehrle even worked at Leder Games. Um way back in the day, and uh the moment I had one established, well-known uh kind of uh crowdfunding creator, then it just rolled from there. I had access. I I had legitimacy. I could ask anyone to do an interview, and I had the receipts to prove that this interview it would actually be a thing.

Yeah. It kind of rolled. That's That's the story of the early stages of the Cardboard Herald.

And was there a point where you saw like, "Okay, this is gaining traction?" When did you start getting into video reviews?

Mhm.

Which is I think most of our bread and butter at this point. I mean

Yeah. Yeah. At this point the YouTube channel is by far the the central hub for everything in the Cardboard Herald. Um I I think the first actual video review [snorts] I did was of either King Domino or Santorini. I I probably could have done the research, but it was something very small where I wanted to experiment with it because I saw that video for the most part just at that time, maybe in six or so years ago, had a lot more space and would gain a lot more traction. Um there are of course incredible blogs out there and written reviewers like Space-Biff does incredible work and is dedicated to written reviews and gets a ton of traction for those written reviews. Um but I if I was aspiring to be something deeper in written reviews, Space-Biff actually manages to do so. Um whereas video I could pivot to and actually feel like I was engaging in some of the more creative stuff that I had done with music editing. I didn't know anything about video editing, but I I kind of knew a decent amount about music editing and it allowed me to dive into the craft a lot more than just the the written portion.

Um so that was probably around six or so years ago and immediately as soon as I started doing it, I started falling in love with the

[snorts]

the format. Like I I just love video production in general.

Yeah, well, I mean, I think to me, just knowing you, I think it makes sense that you found your way to video production just because I you love you you love music, but you also you'd love movies. And it's not

the same thing as like right doing a big Hollywood production, but uh I definitely know the love of doing videos with your friends or doing videos for your friends and the letting yourself just be creative through video. There There's something that said.

Yeah, there there's something that is extremely satisfying about editing something together and having the sequence, the montage, the the edit itself um be some level of storytelling. Like I I get it, you know, like I'm still very much an an amateur in this, but as far as a hobbyist, as far as someone who, you know, does this predominantly because this is a creative outlet still even 10 years later. Um a good example is I was working on this review for the Defenders of the Wild Second Edition, and I ended up sending this to you, but for the audience, I wanted to convey something about reflection on the past because I'd covered the first edition of the game.

I now have the second edition, and I wanted to somehow inform the audience that this is a video within a video because I'm watching the first edition video and just thinking about how do you properly convey that without it being too contrived, without it being too slow, and having it flow in a naturalistic way. And I then I wanted to show the the pivoting because I'm at the desk that I'm at right now that is normally set up in a certain way for a video review. I wanted to show the pivoting from me in a focused on computer perspective into the video, and being conscientious about that. Whether or not I'm totally successful in the execution, whether or not I could do something better, it is something where I feel like it's firing on all the creative sparks that I most feel inspired by and get a lot of satisfaction from. So, like that sort of thing.

How to just sequence these images, the sound, the look, the script, all of that together in a way to come out moderately how you intended. It's the best.

It's I mean, it's a lot of fun. I do I've I think you also know my my backstory a little bit, but just making making videos is was just such a treat for so much of my life that I and I can just see the thing the reason that I liked doing it, I can see in you as well of it's fun it's fun to be creative in this way. I mean, I think for for both of us this is a fun outlet for getting to do that kind of creativity while also having it tied to our other hobbies. Uh

Speaking of, what was there any part when I had spoke to you because we're friends for the audience, you know, like we met through me trying to offload a bunch of games and Eric was just some dude who came over to my house based off of either like a Facebook or some other ad, and he was like, I'm here to buy this game. I'm like, great. Do you want to play a game sometime?

Yes. I had I had moments

moments before messaging Jack moved to Juno. So it was like first thing I did when I moved here was let me try to buy games from someone and then We'll we'll see where that goes. I was right. That was a great move. I've done it in DC as well. It's a good move.

Exactly. But you know like it wasn't until a little bit later maybe like 2 years later or so where I I had been thinking for a while about the cardboard Herald as like If this is going to sustain I just need someone to work with. I need some sort of help. I need someone to be [snorts] a co-conspirator a collaborator someone to bounce a bunch of ideas off of Eric's background is in uh

[sighs and gasps]

In I guess Hollywood. So you know like I I was like oh this is a perfect fit and so I I bore my soul and I was like Eric you know would you like to join this adventure and he's like Does it matter that I'm moving away from Juno to the other coast of the United States? I was like son of

but we made it work out. We made it work out and it's been

[snorts]

successful and great and I don't regret it at all. Um But when you were first coming on I know your background was in video production you went to school for this but you had kind of moved away from it. Was there a part of you that was like

[snorts]

I don't know that I want to get in on some rinky-dink YouTube channel covering board games. One I moved away from the whole film industry thing and two This is they're are small potatoes and then there's the teensiest potatoes, you know, like

board game YouTube reviews.

Yeah, exactly.

No, I mean, I I fell in love with video production growing up. I went to I was fortunate enough to have a uh school middle school for the arts and a high school for the arts that let me like really get into video production from a young age. Uh And I always have found like the most fun I've had doing video production has been making videos with my friends. Like sometimes they're like bigger budget [clears throat] things that we're doing, so like uh college thesis films where it's like we're there's like some money getting put into this. Like it's usually still not a lot, but it'll be like I I think the budgets I've had were like somewhere between 2,000 to 10,000 dollars for like a 10-minute short film.

Right. Which is

[snorts]

en- enough money that it's like, "Okay, we're like doing things." But truly the experience was we're all in this I'm helping out Wes's thesis film. I'm helping out Andrew's thesis film. And like feeling like I was helping one helping out my friends and two just like getting to be creative with them in a way that I just really it just clicked with me in a way. Um one of the reasons that I left LA cuz I worked in the film industry, mainly in commercials and music videos for a couple years. Uh one of the reasons I left LA was I just one didn't like Los Angeles. Not a not a city for me. Not not a thing that was up my alley. Um but I think another reason is I just worked on so many car commercials and like Target ads and a number of things where it felt like I wasn't getting back that same thing of I feel like I'm being creative here.

And obviously most of it's just because that they have they have their own team that they've worked on. They've they've worked for a while to make these ads.

Yeah.

And so it's like, you know, obviously me as the production assistant or the assistant director is not going to have much say in how they they make their ads. Yeah.

comes out.

But it was it was a combination of that. So, moving to Juno, seeing you making videos in that way, I was like always fascinated in a way that was one a little tempted by I also was actively watching board game YouTube reviews at that time. Like I before I even met you, I was I was watching Shut Up & Sit Down. I was watching Man vs. Meeple. I was watching the bigger YouTube channels that I was always like, "Man, that that's that is a cool way for them to use their video skills for this hobby."

Right.

And then meeting you and being like, "Oh, I can just do it. Like there's

just make it happen. Yeah.

And this was before you'd asked me to join the Cardboard Herald. It was more so like, "Oh, no one like told Jack, like, 'Hey, make a board game review YouTube channel.' You just did it and grew it and put time and passion into it. And it was like, "Oh, that's just a thing that you can do. You don't need to have like some You You did have a reason to, but you didn't need a reason to."

Yeah, I mean, the the the reason was entirely self-fulfillment. I mean, it's gratifying when you get free copies of games.

Yeah. But that I mean I I think you and I both don't do it for that

reason.

Yeah. Yeah. And it's cool to make uh, good relationships. It's cool to get like press passes to, um, the the conventions and, uh, you know, like ad revenue and, uh, the Patreon pays for, uh, going to PAX, you know? Like that that's awesome. I'm completely appreciative of all that. Uh, but I wouldn't be doing this if, uh, it weren't kind of that principled I think it's important for every soul to do something creative, uh, and this is my primary creative outlet.

Um, just take a little bit of a left turn here. You just mentioned about, you know, uh, building relationships within the space.

Yeah.

Uh, you've been obviously doing reviews for a bit.

Uh-huh.

And through that I I've, you know, been with you at PAX. I've been with you, uh, at a convention where there are a ton of publishers that you know, like you've

Yeah.

You've [snorts] you're able to walk past and be like, "Oh, hello. How are you doing?" Uh, in that sense, do you have a favorite relationship you've developed with a publisher throughout the years?

Um,

Or just another person within the board game space?

Yeah, so one is kind of a weird question [clears throat] because, you know, it could be like pick your best friends and call them out publicly and then, you know, have everyone with bated breath, you know? But I I've made a lot of relationships, uh, over the years and almost all of them have, uh, been extremely positive. Um, there are some that are particularly meaningful to me. Um, like the And for those in the audience, um, you know, like you naturally develop friendly relationships and I I try to call those out, uh, in videos where, uh, it I think a degree of transparency really needs to to happen. Um, but a a good example is, uh, um, Nick and Carla Kopp from the first time I went to PAX, the very first PAX Unplugged.

Uh I met with them. They were just starting Weird Draft Games. I uh had just recently started The Cardboard Herald. Uh and we barely knew what all of us were doing, but we ended up finding each other and recording a podcast way late into the night. Uh and it was one of my favorite things I'd ever done. And when I go to the Philly Convention Center and I go upstairs, I think of the tables that we pushed together and, you know, even the convention was brand new. Um and just that bonding experience. And since then, I've remained close with Nick and Carla. They came up and visited for our local Platypus Con. They stayed at my house.

Uh it it in the guest room, right over

Right there.

Uh yep. Um Uh and that was great. Uh but uh there are different degrees of relationships. But, I've grown particularly close with Rita of Post Curious. Uh and then um Brooke, who's over at Leder Games, is someone who uh worked at Fantasy Flight or I guess Asmodee North America before going to Leder Games. And I remember communicating with Brooke there. And then, all of a sudden, I'm communicating with Brooke at Leder. And that's remained like a an important um relationship that even if Brooke was no longer at Leder Games, I would still be texting Brooke and, you know, talking soccer, you know, talking junk food or other things with Brooke.

Um Any any city I go to, I feel like I can text Brooke to get a cafe recommendation. She is She is a cafe fiend. In a good way. In a good way.

knows knows what's up for sure. For sure. Um And I think one of the more important relationships and maybe this is just the way he holds himself and he he makes everyone feel this way. But Jamie Stegmaier came onto the cardboard Harold. Geez, I think it was like episode [snorts] 16 or something and that's including where I was interviewing essentially myself, you know, or like my best friend who's like, "Hey, do you like playing board games?" Yeah, I like playing board games. Do you like playing board games? I don't know. This is why I like playing board games. But Jamie was one of the first people I reached out to after I'd gained legitimacy and he was like, "Yeah, sounds great. I'd love to come on." And we talked about all kinds of stuff from the smell of the side of the minis smelling like vanilla cupcakes, which is very true. You should smell those. Talked about adoption because he's an adopted individual.

And I work the the thumbs up is coming out.

Yeah, it happened again.

He's an adopted individual and I in my professional career work in the field [snorts] of adoption. And we also talked about just the the practice of crowdfunding games. And throughout the years I have maintained access and interviews and ongoing relationships with Stonemaier. Even while being pretty critical critical of some of the recent releases. Um And very appraising of some of the other ones. God, I love Wingspan pocket. I think that game is amazing.

I I've gotten into the table a lot recently. It's It's so good for very quick plays, getting people You're You already did a review. You don't need to do a review a review here, but I don't think I've talked to you since it's come out, so I just wanted to echo that.

Yep. Yep. Uh but yeah, those are just some of the relationships that pop in mind, but um to to peek behind the curtain, Eric sent me these questions in advance, and uh one that isn't necessarily like an ongoing relationship, but was probably the most meaningful, like personally meaningful to me as an interview, um was I interviewed Anson Maddox, who's one of the original 16 uh Magic the Gathering creators, uh or artists, um and I was uh younger than my son, you know, like I've been playing Magic since uh it first came to Alaska, which I think Boscos got the first set with the dark.

Um and so that would be late '94, early '95. And I was playing with cards that had Hurloon Minotaurs, Elven Archers, Sengir Vampires. Um Anson Maddox's art looks so unlike fantasy art up until that point. Um and I read in like a Duelist or Inquest magazine or something that he was from Alaska. I was like, wait, what? This guy's from Alaska? The guy who makes the like weird Cenobite-looking Hellraiser-esque vampire art for

[snorts and clears throat]

Magic the Gathering?

Uh that blew my mind, um especially because at that time there weren't really celebrities or like people that you'd read about in national magazines who were from Alaska, especially that would be cool to a kid. Um and that always stuck with me. And so when I did the cardboard Harold, I made a list of like 10 people that would be the ultimate podcast interviews I would love to do, and Anson Maddox was on that list, and I sought him out. Um, he had kind of at the time, uh, scaled back from being in the magic world. I I think he had some, uh, personal and family stuff going on. Um, and he was, uh, just kind of living an artist's life in the middle of the desert. Uh, and, uh, it felt like he got some validation out of the interview.

Um, and it was very meaningful, uh, to connect with him, and whether or not that was one of the best interviews, it still was like incredibly important to me, and incredibly validating, and, uh, uh, over the years he's sent me like thank you cards, him and his now wife, uh, who was his girlfriend and manager at the time. Um, uh, and, you know, this I I have a couple prints, uh, of Anson's that are signed in the back. Um, it it meant a lot to me, and I I think it meant something to him, too.

Yeah, have you have you made have you done all of the interviews on your, like, ultimate list, your top 10 list?

[sighs]

Uh, god, I would have to go back to that list. I I've done most of them. Uh, there's a couple that, um, uh, are definitely, uh, missing from there. Um, and some of them I don't even know if I would I mean, yes, I would want to do those interviews, but I probably would be less misty-eyed about now. Uh, 10 years is a lot of time for people to say dumb crap on the internet. Um,

No.

uh, Sandy T. Petersen of Petersen Games, uh, has, uh, has said some real wild stuff, and, you know, uh, God bless everyone who's still waiting on some sort of Cthulhu Wars or some other Petersen Games, uh, things out there. Um but uh, yeah, you know, like I I wanted to interview Bruno Cathala cuz he was probably my favorite Reiner Knizia was a designer who meant the world to me and felt so foundational to bridge old school gaming and new school gaming. Um I didn't get a chance to interview Klaus Teuber who passed away before I had a chance to do that.

Um I uh Let's see. I I had a bunch of people on that list. Ant Maddox and Mark Tedin, I don't want to throw out Mark Tedin who was also from Sitka, Alaska. They were childhood friends and both magic artists. Um But Ant just had that real weird vibe that I always loved and sought after. Um And uh there are some old like RPG people that I never got around to talking to and in part because I was never I'm not really foundational uh in RPGs like in my own experience. I have grown up around RPGs but like I I wasn't the kid playing Dungeons and Dragons at 10 years old and I just liked to reading the Monsters Manual and you know, copying the critters out of there.

But there there are some people that I I still aspire to get to.

Yeah, I mean we'll be check back in our next 10-year 10-year podcast.

How about How about you, Eric? Are there, you know, like you've done a handful of interviews at this point. Um Are there any that before joining the Cardboard Herald like you wouldn't have even thought I I would be talking to this person. I don't know how starstruck you get if you've worked in

Yeah, I There's There's less Yeah, go ahead.

Uh yeah, I at this point I I had starstruck kind of beat out of me in LA. I met

Yeah.

uh good chunk of celebrities and just I was never really There was

cares about pop stars and movie producers when you [clears throat] could be talking to someone who made Ascension, you know?

I know. Well, I mean, yeah, I was going to say Justin Gary was really was really fun cuz he's Ascension is one of the games that got me into gaming and additionally past that it's uh a a big part of my relationship with my wife is playing Ascension with one another. Uh that was like one of the first games I could get her to play consistently uh as I got her into becoming a board gamer. Uh so Justin Gary was great. I mean, Cole Wehrle also I I know that you've you've talked to him. I met him in person before I actually interviewed him uh at PAX, my first PAX. I was like, "Oh, I'm meeting Oh, I'm just meeting Cole Wehrle right now." And Jack knows him really well, it seems.

Or at least well enough to be like, "Oh, hey." And he recognized who you were. Um cuz Cole again, Root is another game that made me see how much board games could be just in terms of past. As like I didn't even play it immediately after like I had been playing Catan and Carcassonne, but like getting through the gateway games and seeing like oh, Root is like this big complex thing that I could really dive into and seeing seeing that game made me appreciate board games a lot more for like what they could be and what modern board gaming was past like the games I played as a kid and and like the gateway games.

Right.

Um And so being able to talk to him, especially with his like move over to his new you know, his new studio. Uh I really enjoyed it. I thought that was one of my one of the interviews I was most looking forward to. Uh I I truly did like him and Justin Gary like back-to-back, so it was very much a I just had a month of oh, I have a really cool interview that I get to do this week. And oh, I have another really cool interview I get to do next week and like prepare for and then put together all of the editing after the fact. Um Yeah, I mean, also, I mean, you mentioned it or you mentioned her, but yeah, Brooke is Brooke at Leader Games is lovely. I went to Epcot with her uh when just happened to be in Orlando at the same time as her and got to uh just hang out with her for a full day.

Definitely one of the the closer friends I've made from the board game publishing side. Uh and it's I'm excited to be able to keep building those relationships cuz I feel like now I am one a bit more comfortable being like, oh yeah, I may I'm a board game reviewer, but also just being able to talk to publishers without feeling like I have to I feel like my first year at PAX, I felt slightly out of place of oh, I don't actually this is my first time coming to a board game convention of this size, so it's a little overwhelming in that sake. Uh and then just meeting everybody. Um but now I feel a lot more comfortable being able to just be like, oh yeah, like I've I've been to a few of these.

Some peo- Some publishers recognize me, others don't and that's I'm I'm totally happy to be in that space. Uh and it's great. Uh I I'm happy with the relationships that I've built, happy to keep building them. I think at this point we've both been doing this for for a bit enough to be comfortable with with where we [snorts] are. Um is there a moment that you've ever like stopped and looked back and and been in awe of what you've accomplished with the channel?

Uh I don't know awe.

I I'm That That's That's a little bit weird, you know, like I I'm proud of so many things on the cardboard herald and I'm trying to maintain perspective of um that it's good to be proud of anything that you do creatively. And again, you know, like it's it's grown, you know, like I I I don't know if I would still do it for 10 years if I had a YouTube channel that was only 500 subscribers or something, but maybe. And I don't think that there's anything uh that you shouldn't be proud of with that amount. Um awe, you know, like uh I don't know like I I may be like annoyingly humble of a person or maybe too self-deprecating to um uh to use a word like awe. But uh yeah, I'm definitely proud. Um there have been times where I have reflected on do I want to just stop feeling completely satisfied with everything that I've accomplished so far. Um and there that's come at several stages over the last 10 years and I think it's good to have that uh reflection. Um

[snorts]

and in each case I've always thought to myself, if I stop now, it wouldn't be because I felt frustrated or defeated, it would be that I have accomplished more than I ever really thought I would be accomplishing and completely satisfied with the the endeavor.

So looking back at you know where the channel has gone since where it started. There's a thing that is in like a lot of professional sports leagues of like a welcome a welcome to the league moment where it's either been either something that's like a rude awakening or something where it's like oh you really showed off. So it's either like a little bit of a negative or really big positive. Have you had a welcome to the league moment in terms of board game YouTube reviews?

I mean so [snorts] you know like there there have been moments where I've become aware of how much of a grind just YouTube in general. Like being a YouTuber and I'm not like a big social media person and I you know like I don't mind if others are um whatever works for you but for me I can feel the damage to my mental health you know like especially because I'm I'm someone who logs the amount of board games that I play. I'm you know meticulous about looking at inventorying my record collection you know like I I can really dive into things on granular levels to the point of obsession. Um and I think social media in general tries to play on those hooks to create reward systems but also prey on desperation.

And how this relates to YouTubing in general is that it's impossible to not look at numbers and start going, well, had I done this different, would I have gotten more views? Had I done this thumbnail different? Had I presented myself in a different way? Had I just had better had better content? And then you look at other videos and you go like, well, I think I'm making objectively better videos than this person, and yet they're getting so much more. So, what am I doing wrong? Maybe it's not objectively better. And then you start, you know, hyper-criticizing yourself. You start hyper-analyzing yourself. You look at all these metrics. Those can be incredibly powerful tools, especially if you are trying to grow something as a business.

And I've had to do a lot of self-reflection, especially maybe about three, four years ago, before you came onto the channel, about what I wanted the Cardboard Herald to be first and foremost, and how I wanted to proceed. There's also some seeing how the game is played. You know, like I know some objective things that could help monetarily and also visibly for the channel to grow. Um We do not do paid reviews. That's something that we just don't do. We don't do paid reviews. We don't do paid previews.

Um There's one video that was a paid preview that we did, where the publisher was so insistent because I was like, I'm I can just do this for free. Like I don't do paid. And they were like, I totally understand that, and we want you to maintain as much objective clarity as you want, but we also think that, you know, you should be rewarded for your time and we really insist that I I was like No.

[snorts]

Okay, fine. And you know, they were like, "What So, what's a fair fee?" And I was like, "Well, a fair fee was you know, $0. So, uh 50 bucks." And they were like, "Great. That's so much more affordable than everyone else." I was like, "Wait, how much are other people getting paid for this stuff?" Um and uh then I I didn't I didn't necessarily enjoy it. Like I I I liked the review and I liked the publisher and I I don't think anything salacious came out of it, but it was uh eye-opening moment to see, you know, um that there's big business uh to be made, especially if you were doing paid previews. I and uh I'm not trying to shame other channels for doing so, uh but I I don't know how to pivot um this into something that is paid by publishers to produce content and yet still have it be the creative independent core that I want it to be.

Yeah.

Um and uh over the last couple of years um seeing uh some other channels uh come under significant criticism uh for uh some of their uh leveraging some pretty nasty practices with publishers uh because often times publishers uh especially early on are creative people who just want to make games. Like they they they want to make games first and foremost and the business aspect is later. And then you, you know, dump a bunch of money into uh a content creator who says that they're going to promote your game and it's going to cost a, you know, like [snorts] $1,000 for them to cover it initially. And then um they say, "Well, now, you know, like we're not so sure and you got to uh pay us another $500 to cover the time invested of learning the game and doing this other stuff and it's like, man, this is crazy. Um, and I've also heard about, you know, like without naming names, some of the biggest channels out there that you know, like have roundups and stuff that charge immense amounts of money to be you named on like these roundups.

I don't know how I could look a friend in the face like, you know, uh

Yeah.

like Rita Orlov uh or or Nick and Carla Kopp, you know, to look at them in the face and be like, oh, yeah, you know, like even if I had a platform that had you know, uh exponentially more um uh viewership than we do to to look at them and say, well, for 5 minutes of my time, you know, it's going to cost you between three to $500. Uh it's like, what? Yeah. That feels crazy. That's also the business um

Yeah.

that's out there. And and that's not every channel. There are definitely channels that don't take any money for coverage and there there are channels um uh that uh even view taking review copies of games as uh some sort of compromise and want to be entirely independent and you know, the like we take review copies all the time. Um, so, you know, everyone has to draw their lines, uh but when I started to see how much uh that kind of like insider biz was that that was like uh I don't know what I have what it takes to be part of the big world of tabletop gaming production.

Um

Yeah.

Instead, I'm just going to keep on doing what I've been doing with my friends and I like what I'm doing, and you know, trust trust in the process. Uh and you know, if you build it, they will come. People will show up.

[snorts]

Yeah, and I mean, I think that a lot of what we do I I'm I mean I'm in the same boat, and part of that is I think that I was kind of introduced to board game YouTube, the back side of it, through you, but I I feel like I probably have ended up in the same boat as well of I don't I'm not going to take money to do like I just it's

Yeah, you know, like I guess when when you worked in LA you know, you were paid to do those commercials, and you know, you did good work, and I think that the work that we do has value. Um I think it just the nature of what we do under this channel is not the same nature as you doing a commercial for Target, and I also wouldn't want it to be. And so, in resistance of trying to stop it from becoming that, I'm trying to make sure that it and you are as well, make sure that it kind of maintains this thing. Don't get me wrong. I would love if we had

uh you know, like a thousand patrons. Uh you know, like I I wish I could pay Eric uh a living wage I wish I could pay myself a living wage out of the Cardboard Herald. But, we're also professionals outside of this. We have jobs and aspirations that also lay outside of

For now.

that lay outside of the Cardboard Herald. And so, you know, like I I [snorts] like my job outside of the Cardboard Herald. I was never outside of my wildest dreams trying to envision oh, this could be like an actual job that I can move my professional career into. Um And so, as a product, I I think I've been not nearly as ambitious when it comes to um growth, as well as some of the things that would raise exposure because the channels that do play that game are also the ones that are prompted by publishers more than anyone else because you you have that relationship.

Mhm.

Um But, uh Yeah, you know, like I think that was that was that was my big awakening uh moment. But, there there were also, you know, like I said, you know, the the moment where I talked with Jamie Stegmaier, who had just come out with Scythe, uh was like, "Holy crap, I'm a real person." Like the Yeah, I don't know if there's a Marc Maron of board games, but if there is, I'm relatively close to him right now.

I and I feel like we've always said that you're the Marc Maron of board games. We're always saying that.

Exactly. Yep. Yep. I have my cat ranch, except instead of cats, it's three dogs. It's terrible. [clears throat]

You do. I They That feels like a very apt uh metaphor for if you're the Marc Maron, the dog ranch is there.

Yeah, exactly. I literally have a dog touching my feet right now. He has one

Arrow would not let you do this podcast alone. He He knew you needed the emotional support of of of him.

Yes, absolutely.

um And I mean, we I we touched on it briefly there, but we're like

Arrow is right right down there. Hi.

Oh, hi, Arrow.

Hi, Arrow. Yep. There we go.

Hey, buddy. Hey, friend. Um

So, I mean, we talked about it. We're obviously not one of the biggest YouTube channels out there for board gaming. I don't think that either of us wants to be necessarily. Uh like, there are there would be some benefits that we would like, but I think the the level the level of work needed and the level of stress needed would be an investment that at this exact moment I think neither of us is wanting to be.

some people who make it look easy, you know, like there there are some people who out there who like they just always are calm, cool, collected, have great presence, and you know, have started after this channel, and have had meteoric success well beyond this channel. And that that's one of those things, you know, that it's hard to not be like killing yourself in comparison. I'm happy for other people's success, and I don't want to take that away, but you know, like at [snorts] least from the way that you or I could envision taking this and moving it up to like higher level tiers, through brute force, I think would take a significant amount of stress and blood, sweat, and tears.

And I think it's really tough for us to be not I don't want to make this like a woe woe is us, but it's tough to be in this space at the size that we are in terms of subscribers and views and not at least start off comparing ourselves to others, where it's like, you know, it's I feel like you and I both put time and energy into doing these reviews, and it's sometimes like you'll see a review pop pop up on your YouTube dashboard, and you're like, I you know, I think there are but it's they different YouTube channels have different levels and different reach.

of work speaks to itself, too, you know, that's that's the thing that I always come back to. You know, whether whether or not this is just like publishers saying something or another. We get contacted by a lot of publishers, and there's a lot of publishers who say extremely nice things, pointed things that clearly they have watched our videos. Um there are people who support us on uh Patreon who like exactly what we do. Um and I like exactly what we do. You know, like I don't watch a lot of uh other uh review channels because I I wish that they were closer to our format. There are some uh and there are some that we've definitely taken inspiration from, but um there there's hefty amounts of criticism, you know, people being like, "You hardly explained the game."

Uh and uh over time I've been keen to think, "Yeah, cuz I don't really care that much about explaining the game." Like that I'm not in this to make a how-to. I want to give enough context so that way I can give my impression, my criticism, my what makes this game interesting or fun or bad or you know, like those kinds of things. And that's not what a lot of people go to uh videos for, you know, like uh there are some people who are like, "Oh my god, why do you have music playing over these B-roll sections?" It's like

You don't want You don't want Freddy on the Fritz? You don't want Scarlet Fire? What are we What are we doing here?

What are you doing?

Uh this is royalty-free YouTube music cuz my jam.

You're not out you're trying to get absolutely turned on Scarlet Fire by whoever makes that song.

And Dialga or

Dialga?

Exactly. Uh you know, McCloud's like library of infinite uh usage. Um

Dude, when I found I found uh artist on YouTube Creator Studio that I'm like I got genuinely excited for new music that I was like, "Oh, this is going to be so good for this kind of video."

Right, exactly.

That speaks to me. I don't know that any

And there there is cool stuff out there. Hey, going back to the video production thing. Recently I did

[snorts]

a container review and I had a good concept for a beginning, but the beginning didn't I sent it to Eric and I was like you know, like I'm playing around with this and he's I think Eric politely was like there's something here.

No, it was good.

this up a little. Um And having someone to turn to who you know will will

[snorts]

say okay, I see the vision but you're not quite executing in the way that I think that you want to is really good to have the kind of feedback that you can go like, okay, how do I do this? And I changed from really ominous music to more manic music. I used in the Hall of the Mountain King which is you know famous classical piece that just is is mimetic at this point. You know, like [clears throat] even if you don't know the song you've heard the song and

It feels familiar in certain sense.

memories. And it's like the Jaws music or something. Even if you've never heard Jaws, you know what it's supposed to convey because of how it's been parodied or used or adapted or whatever. Um So, I ended up changing the music and also leaning into the mania of what I was trying to do. So, I ended up making these quick jump cuts throughout and compressing this opening which made it both more efficient but also more psychotic and then I started using like weird fades with Dutch angles and like

just how do I make this as crazy as can be? I have Milton Friedman like crossing across the screen and it ended up being one of my favorite intros to a video that I'd done in ages. Um and part of that was because like I I had something in my mind, but I didn't know quite how to convey it. And being able to springboard off of Eric um and use the royalty-free music that I had available

just changing the music alone allowed me to think oh, I see what this is supposed to be. Because our song it it intentionally starts at a slower tempo um and then it compresses. It becomes a much faster tempo and a much more swelling of music. And I was like, that's what it needs to be. That's perfect. I need to start [clears throat] a little bit slow and then the cuts need to be faster. And then you have just this whole kitchen sink of manic insanity that is coming out over it. And that reflects to me the experience of playing Container, which at first seems kind of stable and like, okay, yeah, I I kind of get this. But it's like layer of layer of layer of depth in that game and also weird obscure rules and craziness that do ultimately make sense, but in some Charlie from you know, Always Sunny in Philadelphia

Yeah.

conspiracy board sort of way. But yeah. Yeah.

And I feel like it also worked in terms of that was you explaining the game. That you explained how the game worked.

Yeah. So you got that out of the way and then you could get to your you could get to your thoughts. Um I just did a uh I just uploaded it last night. But I did a uh shorts review of Loners. And something spoke to me and I I when I first joined the Cardboard Herald did skits for like my first two or three videos cuz it just felt right. [snorts] And then

I think we're all nostalgic for the like early the the early shut up and sit down early no pun intended that kind of thing where it's like that was my introduction to board game reviews and I'm like, oh yeah, this is a thing that board game reviews should have a skit. But I I did a skit recently it was like, oh yeah, that's right like this is this is a thing that I can do. This just felt this felt right. So it's

Yeah.

I I love when it makes sense and when it's like a game that I feel like is not necessarily like worthy of a skit, but a a game where it's like it evokes enough emotion in me that a skit it feels less like a chore that I need to write out and plan or if it just comes naturally.

Yeah. I think when it is a tool um that's when it's the I think the best like uh I think for me for container uh having that intro was necessary to convey some of my thoughts in the game uh in a hyperbolic way, but also setting the tone um and I think the same thing is true of uh the introduction that I did for um Defenders of the Wild, which was less a skit. Um you know, like it wasn't intended to be humorous, but it definitely was uh it was not just sit down explain a game and discuss it.

I my point of view in the uh review itself was entirely about the reflection of a second edition uh and so I wanted to acknowledge that in the format in the in the um actual media itself that this is a second edition of a review as well. So I think using a skit can be or you know, some sort of maybe contrived, but uh some sort of framing device can really enhance the point that you're making.

And I I think this leads nicely into the last question I have written down, which is, you know, I think we've both learned some things from being in the space and working in the space. Uh if there's somebody who is like where you were when you were just starting out uh of starting [snorts] out either just board game reviews in general or the podcast or just entering YouTube within the board gaming space, is there anything you would want to tell them? Is there anything that you want to like just make sure that they they know is is on the way? Um so before I started

[snorts]

uh The Cardboard Herald, um I I had uh uh my friend Cheyenne, who's my other oldest friend, was also very close friends with Peter. Um she had uh been doing for a little while a podcast called Fictional Females, um which uh just was a weekly podcast where uh her and her co-host would talk about um uh women in fiction, uh different subject every week, and just talk about uh that character. Um which was great, and I I loved that, and I was inspired by that. Um and uh uh she and I talked, and uh you know, I I don't think Fictional Females grew to any enormous uh levels or anything, and has since uh uh stopped, but she told me early on uh just like in Field of Dreams, if you build it, they will come, you know, like [snorts] and uh I think that meant the a lot to me. Uh one, coming from a friend who's so dear and who I respect so much. You know, like Cheyenne and I have X-Men tattoos that we got together when we were really young and stupid and you know, didn't think of much about like, do we need to have X-Men tattoos?

It was like, yeah, we grew up reading comic books together. We're getting some X-Men tattoos.

What what X-Men tattoo do you have? I don't know I don't think that I know this one.

Yeah, I have a big pink cloud on my shoulder that has the bamf on it which for those in the know is the onomatopoeia that Nightcrawler makes whenever he disappears. Like Wolverine's snikt which would have been my other tattoo, but I I was not ready for having a wrist tattoo that said snikt. So, I decided to go with Nightcrawler. She got a Phoenix symbol tattoo. So, that was kind of like I was moving away from the town that we grew up in together and we were both feeling sentimental and it was like, we're getting X-Men tattoos.

X-Men tattoos, great.

Yeah. But, yeah, so I would reciprocate that advice. You know, like and to hone it a little bit think about the things that bring you joy and that you would want to see in the world and continue at that honing your craft and seeing if there's an audience for it and give yourself time and the room to breathe before you start making too many changes. You can change. You can compromise in some ways without it totally compromising your vision. The Cardboard Herald is very different than how it was when it initially started and in some ways I may have been a little too principled in what I viewed The Cardboard Herald was or wasn't and it probably took me longer to find ultimately what I thought was the best version of it, which is what it is right now.

Um but the point being is, you know, like before you scrap what is really meaningful to you, um hone into that and give time for an audience to find it because if you change it too much away from that, then I don't know that you're going to have the the fortitude and energy to keep up with it, you know, like I the most successful people in this space um are either the people who completely treat it as a job, which you know, more power to them, but not everyone loves their job. They do it for the money. Um or it's the people who have found a way to do what they love uh and maybe be rewarded for it uh along the way.

Yeah, I mean, I think my I the way that I've always approached and again, I've been doing it for for less time than you have at this point, but the way that I've always approached and and part of this is from my film background and also from my just exploring creative spaces is uh if you see other people that are successful and you try to copy them, you won't won't you won't get any traction because everybody who wants to watch that kind of content will just watch them. So, one, I think you have to be just you have to do what feels right and natural to you because one, I already said the one, but uh obviously, if you're interested in making that kind of content, there is a a reasonable chance that people like you will want to watch it.

Uh and it'll just it will burn you out less to do things that come naturally to you than if you try to make yourself fit into I think trying to copy other people.

Yeah. And, you know, take inspiration. Think about the things that you like in the world. Uh, you know, like what are the the videos you like? Uh, and lean into that. And don't be afraid of using your resources. You know, board games is an incredibly small space even now. Um, not [clears throat] as small as 10 years ago, uh, but still there's a lot of people who you can access. Like you could if you were starting a channel, you could use the contact link on our website and be like, "Hey, Jack and Eric, do you have some advice for X, Y, and Z?" And there's almost a 100% chance

I mean, we'll get back to

Um, and that's true even for people who are in significantly larger platforms than us.

Yeah.

Publishers, designers, producers, media contacts. Like the it is a relatively small space where you can still have that level of connectivity unlike other forms of business or hobbies.

Mhm.

Yeah, and I think that it's board games are just so, from from my experience at least, are are so collaborative of it feels very much like rising rising tides raise all boats, where it's, you know,

Yeah.

reaching out to people who you think would be above you in a way,

Yeah.

they're usually very receptive just being just being able to chat. Um, yeah. And it's it's fun. I I would say do it for the fun. I I I I think that the, uh, the reason that I joined The Cardboard Herald and the reason that I feel like I still do it is one, I still love board games, so I'm still I still have my passion for for playing games and having strong opinions about them,

Yeah.

which I think is is also very helpful to be a reviewer. Um,

Um, but also [clears throat] like I just I enjoy making videos. I enjoy doing my my silly little skits or or you know, putting together scripts for the reviews that I think is you know, you're not having If you're not having fun, maybe find a different outlet.

Totes.

Yeah.

Totes.

But

Yeah.

I think that's all I got for you. Um any any other like non-board game YouTube advice you want to give people like any recipes or any other just general advice?

Uh, have a miniature Australian Shepherd under your feet that you can kind of curl your toes around uh, cuz I have a nice wooden bar at the bottom of this desk uh, that I can rest my feet on and then

Just rest them on the Australian Shepherd.

The the toes are just doing that.

Um but uh, no uh, find yourself a friend who's a uh, kind of like a bizarro world uh, copy of yourself I guess. Uh Uh, I don't know how Eric and I managed to uh, proceed to uh, both be bald, bearded, beautiful men but uh, you know, we make it work. Um, maybe that's a symptom of uh, of too much homogenization in uh, the board game space uh, but

uh, I like having Eric around. Um and [snorts] as far as advice, you know, uh, go easy on yourself. Dream [snorts] big. Don't get uh, upset when uh, things don't make it there and just kind of uh, appreciate the moment. Like uh, if I spent too much time thinking about like where I could be or where I should be, I would miss the value of all the incredible things I've done up until this point or the opportunity in the moment to do the things that I'm doing. You know, like regardless of where I think the Cardboard Herald or I should be in life or whatever, valuing, you know, as I'm working on a Defenders of the Wild review or Container review or playing Fate of the Fellowship last night with a big group of uh friends, um just being like, you know, what whatever life choices I made led me to this point and this is a pretty cool point.

Mhm.

And I think that that's just good in general for people to kind of stoically keep perspective.

Yeah, great note to end on. Uh so, thanks so much for chatting with me, Jack. I know that we were

Thanks, Eric.

going to

Happy happy to have your uh your decade of YouTube interview.

years. 10 more years.

Uh but thanks so much for chatting with me and thank you to our audience for tuning in. Uh if you have any questions or comments for us, uh you can reach us either through our website, which is Cardboard Herald .com. The Cardboard Herald .com? I should know this.

It's It's cardboardherald.com.

Uh my website just or my computer just auto-fills it at this point, so I don't really think about it. I just type Cardboard Herald and it gets me where I need to go. Uh

You You can You can find us at all kinds of links in the in the uh show notes and uh you know, you like check out the website if you're listening to this as an audio podcast uh or just go to youtube.com/thecardboardherald.

Uh

And yeah.

Yeah, let us know.

I'm going to miss Eric.

Thanks for tuning in. Thanks for being an awesome community. Uh I've been Eric with the Cardboard Herald joined by Jack.

Later.

Progress saved