Skip to main content
Loading video...

Disney Robin Hood: Sheriff of Nottingham Game Review

Transcript 12:27

let's talk about Robin Hood a Sheriff of Nottingham game that's all about bluffing and bribery kind of brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we're going to talk about Disney Robin Hood a Sheriff of Nottingham game that is as I said earlier all about bluffing and bribery in order to make your way to Victory this is a game that's based on that Disney movie that I remember from when I was a kid I mean this fox I this fox was the coolest Fox for many years until The Fantastic Mr Fox came along and then maybe this box is now the second coolest fox in town but Robin Hood Sheriff at Nottingham game is a game for between three and five players you can play with kids age 10 and up and games only take about 45 minutes let's take a deeper look at Disney Robin Hood Sheriff of Nottingham game this is a Disney themed version of an older game Sheriff of Nottingham that's also all about bluffing and bribery and they've kind of simplified some things and and maybe added a few things here to bring that Disney theme to life this is by Simon and Spin Master games and one of the things that jumped out at me right away when I opened the box was the lack of plastic this game came I ordered it from Amazon It came it was not wrapped in plastic it was taped together on the bottom so there was tape attached to the bottom of the box and the insert is made

of paper as well this is a light game in terms of its complexity and it's all about trying to be the player who who earns the most points by collecting Goods that you're going to bring into the village but also by helping villagers so one of the things that you can do in the the Robin Hood version here of the Sheriff of Nottingham game is you can trade some of your goods to help the villagers in the town if you manage to get three chunks of cheese three wheels of cheese into the village you can turn those in and get these villagers now the villagers are going to be worth points but you also get bonus points if you're the player who helped the most villagers of each type there are thick cardboard cards here to just remind you of what you're trading for each of these and to keep the tokens organized so these will go at the top of the board when you're playing each player is going to take a role as one of the characters from the Disney Robin Hood movie so of course you've got Friar Tuck and Little John and Maid Marion and the second coolest Fox of all time perhaps Robin Hood himself one of the players though is going to be the Sheriff of Nottingham and this is the guy who's going to try to catch Robin Hood and his merry men before they managed to get to the village with stolen goods or any kind of contraband players in in this game are going to start of course with their player board they're going to start the game with a hand of cards a bag and some coins and

what each player except for the sheriff is going to do is choose some cards from their hand to put into their bag they close that up and they hand that bag to the sheriff they're trying to get to the village with as many Goods as possible now players can lie about what's in their bag and they may have to do that if they want to get stolen goods like this Crown into the village so you might say I've got a bag with four carrots inside one of those carrots might be a crown instead and then the sheriff is going to have to decide if he wants to search that bag or not all the players will decide what cards they want to put in their bag and then the player who's playing as the sheriff is going to decide which bag do they want to open do they want to search those bags or do they just want to let the players pass and and decide that they're telling the truth now most of the time you're going to be lying in this game and saying well I have four carrots but one of those carrots is actually a crown or Rings or some stolen good or maybe you're trying to sneak some other things across in order to help more villagers so the the sheriff is going to say well I think I'm going to open Robin Hood's bag or made Marion's bag and then the players get to start arguing and there's some bribery and hopefully some compromise happening here and and what what happened when we played the game is we tried to take the role of the characters and you know we might say oh I'm just a I'm just a fox I why would I lie to you about bringing carrots to the Village uh so so we tried to act things out and role play a little bit when we played the game but a lot of

this is about bribery maybe the sheriff is going to say well Robin Hood I don't trust you I don't believe you I don't think those are four carrots in that bag I'm going to open up this bag and search through it and then Robin could but Robin Hood can decide to bribe the sheriff with coins with kurts that he's collected previously with treasure he can return stolen treasure to the sheriff as well so so then there's a negotiation and a discussion that's going to happen and Robin Hood is going to have to decide well what's in this bag and if if the sheriff opens it what's it worth to me to prevent the sheriff from opening it now if the sheriff opens a bag and the player was telling the truth the sheriff pays a penalty but of course if the player was lying the player is going to pay a penalty instead if the sheriff doesn't open the bag you just get to go through with all of the goods that you've collected so you're really trying to decide you know is the what's worth more to me do I need to are the cards that I put in this bag going to be worth so many points that I can afford to spend 10 coins 15 coins in order to get these things through or do I want to just pay that penalty instead do I want to maybe make a promise and tell the sheriff that well when I'm the sheriff I won't search your bag next time if you leave my bag alone so there there are lots of of options in terms of what you can do but again someone's going to pay a penalty the sheriff gets the penalty if they open a bag of a person who was telling the truth and and the players pay a penalty if the sheriff opens the bag and

they were lying so you've got to remember what's in that bag and decide what's it worth to you in order to prevent the share from opening it each player is going to get a certain number of rounds as the sheriff and play continues until they've had that number of rounds and then the game is over you count up how many points you've earned from the cards you've collected and the treasure you've you've collected along the way you award the bonus points for players who have helped the most villagers but what skills are you working on when you play Robin Hood the Sheriff of Nottingham game well I mean there's some math here of course you're counting up the number of points you're going to earn you're evaluating the penalties that you're going to take if you lie and the sheriff opens the bag then you're deciding what's what are those points Worth to me do how much can I bribe and and still earn a net number of points even though I'm giving another player some points by bribing them or some some other opportunities to to earn some reward by bribing so so there there is a lot of math in terms of calculation here maybe probability two if you think about well what is the likelihood that this player actually had five carats that they put in the bag but certainly you're you're deciding on how many points are in that bag and how how much is it going to be worth to me to prevent the sheriff from opening that bag but I think the main thing here this is not a math calculation game for sure but it is a there's a social component we

are talking about well bluffing of course and being able to recognize when another player is bluffing but there's a lot of negotiation and compromise that's happening here and you kind of stare into one another's eyes and try to decide you know maybe I'll give you a few extra coins or maybe I'll give you an extra card so that you can help a villager on the next turn so that is the the main element here it's been a long time since I played a game where there was so much discussion around the table and negotiation around the table in order to come to some kind of a compromise and what what a skill for younger kids to practice for sure now the final thing that I'll mention in terms of skills when you're playing this Robin Hood game is that at a large Play Count you're going to have these cards that you're going to have some cards in your bag the bag gets closed and hand it to the sheriff and the sheriff gets to decide what to do but if you're one of the later Players whose bag gets open you have to remember what you put in that bag so that you can decide when sometimes you know you might forget after long discussions with three other players or four other players and wonder well I don't even know if I'm lying or telling the truth right now did I put carrots or cheese in that bag so there is a memory component here keeping track of what you put in the bag at large play counts with long discussions you know your mileage may vary but we had to think about it for a second sometimes I had to look back at my cards that I had left to decide oh wait what did I put in there but memory isn't the main component we really are talking

here about social skills negotiation and compromise for sure final thoughts about Robin Hood Sheriff of Nottingham game well this is a simple silly bluffing negotiation game it's been a long time since I played a game like that so it's simple and fun to have those discussions and arguments around the table to be able to pull the wool over the sheriff's eyes maybe it and it's got the addition of the Disney characters from that movie now it's been many years since I watched that movie with my kids I remember it from when I was a kid but it's been a long time since I watched it with my kids and it was fun to kind of remember you know how cool those foxes were in that movie I like the fact that the the plastic in the Box was limited but there are some downsides here one is that this box was did it wasn't wrapped in plastic it arrived and I looked at it like oh wait a second did I get a used game from Amazon the box was a little bit dinged up there was no plastic wrap around the outside and then I had to very carefully remove the tape so that I wouldn't damage the Box further uh by opening things up the other downside I would say is that the perforation here for the cardboard tokens uh they didn't do a very good job of Perforating the tokens in this game Simon is usually great in terms of their components and and uh the the quality of their materials but although I would say that the cardboard

cards here were high quality the player boards were very good the cards themselves are a little thin and some of the coins would you had to be really careful not to kind of take the paper off the outside of them when you were punching out these coins from the cardboard that being said if you are looking for a game to play you know a bluffing a negotiation game to play with the younger kids I think that this one has the Disney characters uh and and it's it's just got a lot of great table talk we had a lot of fun playing this game I wish the cards were a little thicker sure I wish that the coins were a little bit more easy to to punch out of the boards of course but overall we had a lot of fun playing Robin Hood Sheriff of Nottingham game if you have any questions about Robin Hood or anything else about brains on games you can of course leave them in the comment section below the video I you know I've been doing this for three years and I only realized today that I post these videos on Mondays and of course there's the what did you play Mondays hashtag that that you always see online so hey leave a comment with the games that you played over the weekend if you have any questions you can also email me at Brian brains on games dot CA brainzone games dot CA is the website that's where future episodes will go the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on

over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time thank you

Progress saved