Wargame Archaeology: Play by Mail
Transcript
we're live yes we are live hey everybody out there uh this is beyond solitire I'm Liz I'm here with Fred from hudin and this is a show with our special guest Dr Henry lwood about play by mail we're resurrecting war game archaeology nice thanks for having me again uh wait but that you're contractually obliged to have me on the show so I'm I'm but I I will still thank you for that and yes super happy to meet you Henry yeah same here I'm I'm even more thankful since I'm not contractually obliged to be here so it's really nice to have been invited uh yes Fred and I signed a Packa with the devil and signed it in blood so now we are now now we have to do uh like we have a contractually we're supposed to make 12 streams together a year um and potentially more uh but I think it's yeah it's fine we're a bit late this year though so yeah yeah we got to got to pick it up yeah um but Henry for those for people who don't know who you are and what you do uh can you give like the brief overview of your work uh yes of course um unfortunately I have a very long title I'll give that first I'm the heral c hobok curer um at Stanford University I'm responsible for the history of Science and Technology Collections and the film and media collections I also run a thing called the Silicon Valley archives at Stanford um and we collect games we've collected um electronic digital games
since the late 1990s and in the last uh year so we've uh ramped up our effort to collect board games as well kind of in the reverse order we did uh digital Games first and then physical game second yes that's wild oh and as we were talking about before the stream so um Henry has actually also uh sweet talked me into donating the Beyond solitire podcast this archive so I'm in the middle of transferring like files and videos over to be stored so that I can annoy all of you even if I died tomorrow so which we hope happen I want to say please no yeah of course but but my my my ability to annoy people will Outlast my lifetime I hope at some point I can make a pitch to Fred uh maybe the show to uh do the same with hom audin yeah I would be I would be I would be happy to uh to share uh anything that you want I think archiving those kind of things is great and I think it resonates really well with the series we are able to do that series War Game archaeology because a lot of stuff that we're looking into has been archived so yeah I think that's uh I would be more than happy to uh collaborate in that effort great yeah and Henry have you watched any of our previous episodes of war game archaeology I've watched episodes of both of your individual podcasts but not of war game archaeology no shameful Henry shame yeah it is how dare you how dare you come on the show and I will do Penance afterwards uh
but but I you know In fairness I have watched many of your individ watched or listened to many of your individual shows before so I'm not entirely a sinner there must be I'm in limbo let's say okay that's fine very well uh but work game Archaeology is a project that friend and I do together um where we we've been reading issues at the general we've actually been talking about playing Africa Cor by mail so this is very relevant for us um and you know we've basically been kind of we played we streamed D-Day we're basically looking at like the early history of our Hobby and talking about it from our perspective as people who are new comparatively to the 60s so interesting um what what uh possessed you to start uh to go back to the 60s just interest to start with the beginnings of the hobby I think that was the idea yeah um so it started from uh just finding out that all of the uh issues of the general had been archived in PDF and Liz and I were talking about this and we had people in our community that were really into also sharing old articles uh from um from older magazines and this whole idea that oh when you look back you realize that a lot of discussions as were having today were already happening at the time and I think through discussions uh liisa and I thought it would be really interesting to look back uh from the beginning and try to maybe chronologically uh try to go through everything that we could find the games
the magazines but also the people uh we had a a long form uh interview with marero who started War gaming really early on and just also having uh the experiences from the people that went through that that whole era just trying to to get a sense and and and figure out where the goby where the Hobie came from to better understand where it is now so that the that was the whole idea and I would say for now we're really having a lot of fun uh I'm just struggling to find a copy of Africa core in in France but that's that's that's the that's the way it is but we managed to do it yeah uh yeah if it was in the US I wouldn't have any issues there is a lot of copies available in the US for very cheap in Europe it's a bit more tricky um but yeah I guess we we'll figure it out we did play dday that was fun and we're planning on playing other games but uh but yeah I hope that we're going to be able to play more but it's really the idea of consuming everything that we can and trying to do it chronologically um and we came up to this discussion about wait a minute how did people play uh in like not sitting at the same table in the past not having Internet how do you handle RNG and everything and Liz came up with like she actually knew you and she was like oh we need to have him on the stream that's gonna be awesome and yeah I'm really excited I know nothing and that's what I said to Liz before the stream it's like haven't prepared anything I don't know I'm just curious that I'm just going to ask it T of question but I'm yeah I'm just uh I'm just here for Pure fun I would say and and curiosity Yeah question I'll just say real quick my
first two games since you're in that era uh besides sports games I played a lot of sports games when I was a kid uh you know and they were fairly sophisticated um things like uh stratomatic games you know statistics based games and so forth the first two War related games that I played were in high school I had an AP the only AP class I took was an AP History of social studies class I don't remember some some a TA or instructor from UCLA came to my high school and uh we played diplomacy uh that's about half the class was diplomacy uh that was a so that was the first and the first game that I owned that I bought myself uh was Panzer Blitz which in my household was called pza Blitz um and the reason that for that was I grew up in a a German American a German my parents spoke German you know we so we had historical background and I thought oh you know somehow I found out about this game uh got it I was probably late High School to Early College more likely late High School got it at home had nobody in the neighborhood remotely I could get anybody to come over and play a baseball game a football game basketball game no problem board game zero interest so I decided okay I'm gonna study this thing and figure it out and I failed uh I could not figure which
gives you an idea of it's really important for me uh in a lot of things that I do to realize that there's such a big difference between the historical uh actors playing a game in the 1960s and somebody in 2024 going back to to play a game like that because when you go back and let's say you had never played you as part of your project well you played Africa core you never played Africa Corp it probably took you 15 minutes to figure it out it's it's a relatively simple game um and not a big problem in 19 early 70s late whenever it was um it that P Blitz was a really complicated game compared to everything else that I'd been exposed to and I I simply could not figure F out how to play it today go back to it it's really easy and you know I complain about all the simplifications in it uh that really don't make it much of a simulation right uh so uh but that was you know me me 40 some odd years later uh compared to when I first played it oh that's really interesting and yeah so one of the reasons that we want to do on the show is because not only does your archive contain some playby mail archive but some of them are yours is that correct yeah the thing behind me is not mine but uh you know I've got I pulled up a few things that I brought with I don't know going to work with the backgrounds no it doesn't work that well
you kind of see hold it up close it up close to the oh yeah if you have the background should I get let me let me get turn off we can see your professor office it's good it can't be as as my office right let's see I'm not to years okay virtual background none w yeah um so this is like a this is a later version something that Elon Hill published I'm going to say this was in the 80s when this was all mature and people had figured it out you know the case for plain by mail okay you want to learn how to play by mail this is another thing 1980s versus 2024 you can see this is triple column single space right it's eight pages it's eight pages going over how to you know and there's a there's a Code of Conduct area by the way the rules for area that was the uh uh system for keeping track of player scores based on their wins and losses and all that sort of thing uh so a lot went into developing these systems it and again it was even though it might seem relatively simple looking back on it it was really quite complicated and people were would you say Okay I want to do this I'm going to read this eight page single you know I don't know how many words it is but you know very complicated document and I had lots of stuff like that so there were different period so that means that in the beginning people were playing by mail in
a more informal way trying to figure out as they went and then starting in the 80s like you had companies coming up with actual solutions to to play by mail so that actually earlier do you want me to give a quick rundown of the history yeah actually it would be cous to have minutes maybe yeah this context the early uh play by mail systems were developed in the mid 60s uh I am focused the work that I've written about it a little bit and you know my interest of more focused on uh war games that are dice based um the Avalon Hill games in particular the kinds of games that exactly the games that you're playing I want to just mention that at the same time almost exactly the same time though the people in this other Community claim priority systems were developed for diplomacy uh the first PBM system uh far as I know for diplomacy was developed in ' 63 and the systems that I'm talking about are 64 so they're very for all intented purposes this was going on at the same time you can argue about a few months here or there so there was the diplomacy side of things and then there was the let's call it the Aon Hill Board Game set of things what's the main difference between those two systems dice uh diplomacy diplomacy's PBM system was through a moderate through a I forget what they call it some kind of moderator someone that that an ire govern uh wait let me check did I write
down somewhere a game Mas they call it a game master I guess game master okay that that uh and they had some Zen that there's one I remember called clock uh I don't know why it's called that but uh that was formed around the 6364 time period and basically the moves would be sent into this uh game master who would then adjudicate things and tell everybody what happened and it was more like a almost like a diary kind of system going back and forth but there was no you didn't have that uh a problem with rolling dice board games you're playing from that era um based on you know the hexagonal grid map placement of units and dice had a couple of problems one was in the original games I mean you can look at your your Africa core map pretty sure there's no indication of what the hex's are identified as you know there's no systemes right yeah so first thing you have to do is figure out how you gonna tell somebody where a unit is um so you have to that part one and part part two is of course you have a combat results table to uh resolve combat you have to roll a DI to do that how are you going to do that and you know the corollary to how are you going to roll the dice is do I trust that other person because you could you could have a system Avon Hill talked about this when they were
introducing their own system they said you know there is such a thing as we call it the honor System you could just let the other person uh roll dice and you know the community a little bit bits and pieces of uh opinions about the system I've heard is basically players say you can't trust War Gamers to do that no way um so they had to come up with something else so to deal with those two problems uh the first thing they dealt with by suggesting kind of a row and column system you could A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 you know something like that where you could could identify them okay and you could uh you figure out a way usually the units did have some sort of uh unit identification on them so I could say unit X is a B3 or you know whatever it is and then uh AV Avalon Hill around 64 introduced printed uh sheets a form that would enable you uh they call it I forget what they call it now something like the order of battle form or something like that where you could indicate where each unit was placed according to this grid great and then you could list the combats these are my units my opponent's units odds are 3 to one and then there's a space there for combat result but how do you do that Avalon Hill intro introduced that in a kit they distributed I think in ' 64 uh that covered a Africa core and D-Day and some of the other games that were around at that
time um and with it they said we're gonna have a contest to deal with rolling dice um we do however there's some conditions to this contest and one of which they was they introduced another concept that's really important here they said it's going to be based um on what see I'm trying to remember what it's called on the ctd which uh is something transaction date I believe it's what that is is when you looked in the newspaper every day and you saw the stock transactions um they would tell you how many shares had traded in various stocks so IBM was around then so you look up the IBM and it would say 400,000 shares traded okay Avalon Hill originally suggested um you know as this contest was announced I never really saw that they they actually changed the system based on the what people submitted for this for this contest they just saw said hey you know send us your ideas about this so 400,000 shares ends in zero right so you have a you have a one to 10 system you know basically the zero being 10 guess what they did first they came up with a different combat results table that they distributed uh so instead of six options you have 10 options uh if you take an example where there's six options one to two is one result two to three is three
sorry 3 to four is another result five to six is another result each has a onethird probability their's was 1 to four is the first results 5 to 7 is the second result 8 to 10 is the third result so it's 40 303 and as it turned out usually that first number was advantageous to the attacker so people responded basically saying whoa the game's a little different now it's the game has shifted to the attacker this won't work and things were in flux for a short period of time eventually Avalon Hill I don't know if this was based on input theyve got I hav I haven't nailed that down but abon Hill then announced and and this was in their kits that what you going to do is you're going to divide that number 400,000 in this case by six now you're going to get a result from one to six right from the remainder actually zero to five but you know uh you you can you know you can you can you can figure it out uh so you're gonna get you're G to get that result you divide that remainder becomes your shifted becomes your D roll you apply that and you apply that to the system so you would send these sheets out I mean I don't know if I oh yeah here's uh let's see I've got one here that's
blank maybe not do you would you would um I wonder if I'm looking in your slides see if there's one in here Henry is it this thing uh let's see let me see let me that um this is the ahic system I'll get to that in a second of course it's this kind of a sheet uh you can see that there's um I'm looking backwards here so you have your battles listed and then you have um you know everything on there and you write that on there and then you would write the stock is on here you tell what the stock is and the date and the remainder and then you you would do your combat results based on that we show the second thing that you I'll skip fast forward then I can end the history real quick oh yeah yeah here put it back up um so that was popular but then a few years later I think 66 um yeah that that will be good the something was founded called ahx ah I KS the Avon Hill InterContinental Kiel Society they develop they develop their own this this uh I'm not 100% sure of this about 95% sure of it's still a is still around today they have a newsletter coming to they have uh but I believe the system
still is used somebody could correct me if I'm wrong about that uh what you would do in this case is you would contact them they would generate these tables that you see uh the bottom half of that sheet there that's pre-generated it goes to both players they don't see the sheet that the other person has um the Matchmaker ahex had a person in the in the role of Matchmaker basically uh would you know you'd write to them and say I'd like to play Africa Corp with somebody in this case it's Russian campaign which I played an awful lot this way uh see I want a game of TRC the Russian campaign is there somebody you know they match you with somebody else wants to play it we each get a sheet you'd start writing to each other you know there's there's your letter and yeah and you start playing when you do the mo same idea you list your comments locations uh now as you can see of course there's numbers on the map the the hex's are the hexagons on the maps are identified so it's much easier to list your units then you would refer to some place on the grid um tell the player use that uh cell the value in that cell for the die roll they would then cross that one out you can't use it again and they would see like you can see those ones twos three you know di roll numbers you would use that and resolve the combat using that so that those were the two uh of most commonly used systems the
the Avalon Hill system using just the stock stock roll T the the transaction tables divide by six or these uh sheets that ahx provide ahex also had its own ranking system newsletter all of these things um I'll make one last point and then I will be quiet um don't be quiet yeah well I want what people other people have to say the other thing is this is really interesting from the point of view of the technology and the mechanics and the process and all of that where it's really really interesting historically is how this figured in developing the community this of Niche culture for war games during this period in the 1960s we all know that this was a key period uh for the development of these games for at Evon Hill followed very closely by SPI and James dunan you know that this was all going on but like the example I gave of myself before many of the people who play were interested in playing these games and investing the time to figure out how to play these Looney games you know that were very different from other things things they were playing they more than likely did not have anybody next door or friends from school or whatever the case might be nearby that they could play with so uh the general the magazine that you I think you mentioned earlier from Avalon Hill uh began
to work towards developing a community for these games and at the back of the magazine they also told people they had these kind of little ads that you placed if you wanted uh to play one way to do do that was like say oh you know here I am I'm in Los Angeles their player you know nearby in Los Angeles and then youve seen a lot yeah and we've seen a lot of those in in the in Avon Hills General and we talked about it like it was a big part of the magazine like all ads yeah yeah and and so this this this took that to another level it made it possible for the for the people who were not nearby uh to still play a game via postal mail and I would guess at a certain period in time probably pretty early uh the these kinds of games were or this method of getting players together through postal mail probably was more common than people actually answering ads and meeting each other um that's my guess uh I there's very difficult to document a claim like that just my sense from the time and so some of the documentation I've seen um but this is all part of that process of constructing uh uh there's a guy named Rex Martin who used to work for Avalon Hill who wrote a dissertation about the about the history in this period particular at Avalon Hill he called it a subculture uh I think the word Community is more like what we would say today
about this maybe a niche culture of some sort I don't think I don't think it really works to call it a subculture quite as well but definitely community how do you do that when people are scattered around and you don't have the internet you don't have email you don't have all of these things uh This Is How They did it that is so interesting I guess one my question so like maybe this is just me not knowing how to live in a society before technology now but if I want a form then you know I can just get it in my email and print it out at home um if I want to send a form I've written on I can use no ability or I can just scan it in my phone or take a picture and just send it somebody El's email like how did people I mean was it easy to go photocopy these forms like how did you even learn that these things existed how did you replicate them enough to actually play well Evelyn Hill sold kits so you could buy forms and they were like um you know like you know like the legal te uh um sheets of paper you know you rip tear them off one they were bound together glued together maybe at one end you get maybe get 50 or 25 in a pack or something like that you could do it that way or of course maybe maybe you could if you had a photocopy machine at work um not saying I ever did anything like that but if you if you had if you had one maybe you could you could do that as well I I can't recall this ever happening but I I I'm going to put a guarantee down that some people made their own forms
just drew them and put them in um but Avalon Hill it's in 64 they released a kit um they didn't it was kind of strange because as far as I can tell they didn't announce this kit until this thing I mentioned about this sort of contest and how this thing works that was uh I think May 64 was the first issue of the general um so it's right around the same time I don't know when the general first announced the play playb Man I mean I do know in my notes somewhere but I don't know off the top of my head uh so but the kit was already in boxes or you know it was already available to buy um before they actually announced it uh so they were they were sort of on top of it um to Pro to provide this to people to encourage it and I'm I'm sure the explanation for that is it since it came out almost exactly when the general started that this was part of a um uh Tom Shaw who was running the company at that time was very good at this kind of thing he had taken over from Roberts not that long before that um uh and he had a plan for developing this community that these things were part of it so that was how most people did it is they got these packets from Avalon Hill or in the case of ahx like that thing you see there they they mailed that to me I didn't print it out on my own computer when I was playing a lot of PBM was more was later uh after
college you know I kind of like many people I didn't have time to play during my college Years and in fact I went to grad school so you can imagine it was quite a break but then as I was coming back into it um by that time I had a personal computer at home and that sort of thing and with there was already in my archive I can see this I have printouts of email along side the paper the move still had to go by paper because of this crazy system uh designed to trust your opponent but you you were still corresponding you know you would say like wait a second if you notice that one unit had been moved illegally you know one let say one hex too far than they could because of terrain or something like that you might at that time you might shoot an email to the other person say where do you want me to put the unit and then you'd have the email to document that you could you could just move forward do you want me to change the combat you could do things like that uh so it's kind of getting to be hybrid third phase of this is of course games that are developed for the express purpose of playing by male or on electronic systems like Prodigy you know like Jim dunigan designed some games like that in the 80s and then finally I guess yeah what is prodigy prodigy was a early internet not arpanet based not you know the whole university military complex based network but it was a thing developed by Sears and a coule which is a big
department store company at the time in the US and some other some other compan for home um kind of like it was my family's first home internet on our computer yeah yeah I actually was like a later adopter into household my parents got the internet my little brother got really into it and then I learned how to use it to instant message my friends and like read fan fiction yeah FR do you know about mini you know mini that's that's what Alex same idea yeah it's actually the because when you said skars and it was like a network is not like like oret or not distributed then I would say it looks like lumel yeah okay makes sense yeah comp serves another example of that kind of thing there were games on there the more recent thing and I'm just now starting a project on the history of this is vassel and those systems where you you're using the board game but the system itself encompasses all of the mechanics and everything like that you kind of leave the board game behind even though it's based on the board game um that was developed in the 90s so uh and now it's you without a doubt that's the way most people play board games remotely is through something like vassel or tabletop simulator you know other things like that I'm I'm curious then how how long would the game like like let's say the Russian campaign uh purely VIA mail no email anything just using the system and everything how how
long would it take like could last over a year yeah yeah yeah could it last if you were really fast you know think about the different phases some games had and like that you know you're not getting a move done in less than a couple of weeks right uh you know you're playing a big long game a campaign game yeah it could be a year more a lot of them fizzled um you know people just gave up at some point but yeah um you know I had a ranking of I had games that were completed one person won and the other person won so so um uh games were completed but yeah you'd have to figure with a big game you were going to play at least a year and that's interesting yeah that's interesting and that's that's super long where did you put the game in that like like oh let me let me upload another background here and I will show you do you see that behind me oh okay that's a system that I see in clubs and stuff like this okay yeah yeah and then what happen it was the the kandur that mag the magazine that ah hick published had an article where somebody said oh was that I oh I had sent you that already I just want everybody see yeah um they had an article where they basically said uh if you're playing a lot of games here's so here's how you can build this so I built it uh I can't remember now it's six or eight games you would have a big plywood board that you put the map
on and you would slip it into that you know TI it in or out depending on which game you were playing you put it on another table do your move send it off in the mail put it back and then in that on that shelf and then maybe move on to another game that you got to move from and did you have the impression that some designers or some companies started change their design to make it more play by mail friendly or it didn't really have an impact because as you say some games have like a lot of back and forth uh between especially in the modern in the modern day whereas in the past you had a lot of very static IO youo which also makes a lot more sense when you're playing over male you feel like it had actually an impact on the design itself um I can't point to a specific example of that but historically you're pointing to what became a big problem for playing bip postal mail uh the more the more chopped up the turn was the more interactive the turn was the more it went away from myo Yugo the more difficult the system became in terms of just time that it took yeah um one conversely and the thing if I had been a game designer maybe the thing I would have played with on this again I can't think of an example of anybody doing it but it would be that the pace of the game the way you approach the game was quite different think about it you know like if you're playing face to face you're playing Africa Corp for example you have a minute or two to think about what you're G to do and then the rest you figure exactly how it's going to be worked out postal met game you're gonna
spend you might spend hours thinking about the turn seriously that was where it was so the games if you did did them as a sort of like an after action report of the game it would have been very good play you know very wellth thought out play and detail you had that a different pace and Rhythm to the game and the the amount of thoughts you could give to each turn uh that would have been something G that I imagine a game a developer might might have a game designer might have thought about but I can't think of an example of anyone doing that you think I wondered about when you were talking about it is you know if you are still learning the rules to a game it must be so hard to learn it in isolation and with play by mail um especially with a partner to whom you keep submitting wrong moves and you have to like out by mail like how many games just kind of died on the vine because of that and then like how many games did people who are playing by mail often keep going at one time um I was pretty hardcore for a while I I would say I I did have that that table full with maybe a half dozen or so games at a time that were going and yes games uh did fail there was a nothing about play male is you have the turn the the here where my move here's where my units move here's the combats let's resolve the combat that's back and
forth but we're corresponding my mail right that means I can stick a letter in uh you know you have some examples out the images you I can stick a letter I can talk about sometimes that would be um you know I haven't been feeling well I'm sorry this was a slow move uh just had ankle surgery or something I've been laid up those kinds of things but also You' get trash talk you would get I remember one very distinctly uh it was in this uh archive that we acquired at Stanford when I fed Luci is an archive it was a whole bunch of letters from the 60s uh from an MIT Club around play by mail and um there's one letter in there where the guy says um Everybody M makes mistakes and you are no exception uh you're he the mistakes in your in your move so so you would you know you would get stuff like that um you know that uh sorry this move doesn't work and it would get it could get Frosty you know a little bit if somebody was repeatedly making or dis even with all the time that you have to study um you would still disagree about the rules sometimes uh um not can't Avalon Hill had some people that they are usually players who are considered experts on games that could sometimes adjudicate those things I don't remember exactly how that worked but ahex also has had people who I do remember they had uh speciic specific people who decided when there was a
disagreement in a game you would say here's how I interpret this rule the other point say here's how I interpret this Rule and uh you know we it's different help we can't we're we're um uh impass here what do we do and they would you know have to decide for you all of this is in there this is all the stuff that happens in real time at a convention safe as a tournament but it's it's happening still has to happen but it just dra out it's much slower it's much more uh I don't want to say it's less intense because it's still actually if you spend hours thinking about a move it gets pretty intense you lose sleep over it you know that kind of thing but um it's still a much more drawn out process but basically everything that happens when you play a game still is going to happen interesting yeah I think about these relationships forming too CU so I have people that I play obsession with that I've never met in real life but because we do a move then maybe like make a comment about somebody's fancy event or trashy guest or whatever um you know I feel like these people are my friends you know like and you know Fred I can talk to your face like but we've become friends exclusively Because the Internet exists yeah and so in in the letters do you see indicators that people are becoming friends as opposed to just game opponents like did you make friends this way or just kind of friendly Baner um absolutely um and it's different levels you know there are
people you're casual with um you know and you say a few you know might say a few things too there's some people you played multiple games with you have the same interest you talk about things more extensively with them and there are people you say hey I uh I'm going to a wedding this weekend my turn turn's going to be a little delayed we're going to do you know any good restaurant you happen to know what's in Providence you know any good restaurants there you know you would you would talk about those things and you would talk about it more it is different because post again we're talking about postal mail here so I don't see the face I have no idea usually how old the person is or anything like that so everything comes everything that's revealed is revealed there on the paper uh it's not uh like um oh even U you you know it's not it's not there no other clues that you get really other than maybe where some lives so it it just it's all basically all of the above different kinds of relationship shs would would form I also played by mail with people I had played with in person or you would play by mail and meet at a convention you know you might me meet at origins or something like that um so there's those options for developing uh relationships then U let me make one other sort of historical Point again to this thing like uh uh I once titled an article uh it is what it is not what it was meaning you can't go
back again and the thing is when I talk about those things of of having a remote friend you know that you're getting to know in a certain way we did not yet have the experiences that we have with the internet Virtual Worlds uh rating in a World of Warcraft together and you know all those all those sorts of things that we now are used to and we're used to and pretty comfortable with the idea of virtual friends virtual acquaintances people forming relationships that way all of that uh this wasn't um this th those ways of familiarizing yourself with this kind of relationship were not there yet uh it was postal mail and that was it so uh it it probably wasn't as the relationships probably weren't as deep or easy to create as we as we would think today so you never made friends uh with people that you played uh by mail or yeah at the time I would say no I I would say probably no lasting friendships beyond beyond uh that time I did however make lasting friendships with people that I met through ads in the back of the general people I'm still in contact with including probably a couple of names I'm not going to say them but a couple of names you probably recognize because they're g wellknown game designers now um to know cannot just
drop name drop name offline offline um the yeah but so that part of it yes but then of course you were meeting face to face and in San Francisco Bay area which is where I lived then as an you know have been here almost all my adult life really um there was a pretty active community in the Bay Area and so you know you might have to drive from Sano County where I am to the East Bay you know that kind of thing you might drive 30 or 40 miles to meet somebody but you would do that and you'd get to know them and yeah they're definitely people I've stayed in touch with the um and a the Third Leg of the stool is the whole convention scene which is you know like another another way of meeting people and playing games uh that you could in a way that you couldn't do at home yeah that makes a lot of sense so in terms of um I guess collections so you know you this is something that's you're talking about your personal experiences but you've also you know collected these items uh these artifacts of play by mail for for archival storage and also for scholarly work what kinds of collections have you acquired and how do you get them well we uh every collection is different you know and how they happen Happ to know about them some uh some are quite random others are me reaching out to people
others are you know me meeting people like you Liz and saying by the way you know um we have a home for your podcast series if you'd like and we'll we'll archive it um with regard to play by mail I will say documentation is pretty scarce um these are like many many other things uh these are this is considered pretty ephemeral by people who play play the games I would guess maybe this maybe this episode will help I would guess most people who played these games probably still do have uh records of some are all the games that they played I kept I never threw anything out for for in terms of play by mail sheets those kinds of things so I have a personal archive um but they haven't thought that they would be of interest to anybody else um they they haven't you know done that sort of thing you know it's kind of unlike like a different different Medium as maybe the after action reports to sort of Diaries of games that people have written up those are shared and circulate y having a cat moment oh okay I thought yeah this is K he's digging his claws in my leg I'll be right back um yeah uh so I think with the the documents we're talking about here and some of the things we've shown they're rare they're hard for me to get to and it would be
interest what people might have so that doesn't mean they're impossible to find uh one of the I'll give an example of one which I consider maybe the best thing that I've found so far in this vein uh and this was eBay uh somebody was selling a copy of Stalingrad uh it was a it was in the books was in the Box it was a it was an unusual it was one of the later versions of the game that was unusual I I'm I I'm not I'm a collector but I'm not a collector of you know in terms of um this is the box with the red stripe on the side very rare that means nothing to me uh but this was sort of in that category version of the solid gr gam but by the way the really nice thing about this is there's a whole bunch of these letters stuffed in the box that got my interest um so I I I bid on it got it up at the library and it's in our it's in our department of special collections now in our rare books and manuscripts Department uh so this is kind of manuscript collection what's in there uh it's from the mid-60s uh from something that was originally called the MIT war game Society I think it's not called or then became the MIT um simulation Society it still exists in a different form it's a lab kind of a Lab at MIT it's mostly focused on on on Euro games things like that um and these letter the letters were in
there the founding of the club the guy the guy sold it even pointed out in the eBay listing that one of the letters gave the date at which this was the first document this person had seen giving the actual date when the society was founded at MIT stuff like that and there were records of several uh playby male games that were played at that time now just mid-60s remember I told you before the system starts in the mid-60s so this is like at the very beginning of this kind of play and uh you know another thing I said earlier is you and I we can go back and play the games now but whatever we do is going to be very influenced by everything else we've encountered with games different standards of of uh production quality for board games different mechanisms uh all sorts of things this is the people who were these documents are from the are voiced by the people who actually were playing the games at that time they don't know about any of this stuff that came later so it's really when you read what they're saying how they're how they're interacting with with each other um it's it's it's a document of that period telling us how people received these games at this very very early period that's like archival gold for me I mean it's just such a fantastic Source uh to be able to get something like that do you have like example of things that you discovered
going through those males of how they reive those games that we might not expect like you have any uh like things to to illustrate uh how different it was yeah yeah um well there was uh this goes back to something Lista there was quite quite a bit of U incorrect moves um there was quite a bit of evidence that this really was sort of a new thing they were doing and they weren't quite uh sure all the time how how it worked the other thing that surprised me so this is the MIT simulation Society right they were these are uh it's like highbrow gaming right that's the way you think about boy there was a lot of trash talking in there um there was you know so it wasn't n um you know it was uh that was a little surprising oh and another thing I should mention is there were several people in there in the military uh which is not surprising but it's a document that when we could say like a lot of people who were involved in this growing you know young community at that time were in the military you can also see that when you look at the general and they talk about you know their various corresponden and things like that that's the kind of stuff that I I see in there uh I guess that the the really if I another that you've asked the question if I go back to it i' probably would be more analytical about
like what kinds of mistakes they were making what were the heart the the the real stumbling blocks with the use of the system that kind of thing oh now I'm interest in that question too dang it Henry um we haven't scanned that but it's Avail anybody who wants to can use it and you can you know you can request reproductions photocopies basically of things uh so it's available for research that's another thing I should point out I'm at Stanford everybody think private university I can't use it that's too bad no it's open to the public the our uh our special collection department is one of the Departments that anybody in the world can use you do have to show up physically but you can also contact UM them by email and request things and they'll they'll do the best they can there's limits to how much you know they can sit down and scan for you but um um and it's really you do want to go you know if you're ever in the Bay Area that would be something I'm the person you would contact just just you know write to me a few weeks before you're showing up and I'll uh I'm talking both to two of you and also to whoever is listening um I'll I'll walk you through the drill about how you request things and where to go and all of that oh man and now and now I need to schedule a trip um so just before we like kind of run too low on time I want to go through the images that you compiled just because yeah I I know that you put them together for a reason right so I wanna I want to check them out this is a cool little cover I take it this is
you um uh that's my depiction of me uh with the help of my good friend co-pilot um the uh yeah so uh my mother's side I'm I'm Austrian so that's the flag uh I don't know what the thing is in his in my mouth I guess it is there and yet I'm not quite that gray yet but uh yeah that's that's what Copa came up with all right oh okay we have a program I mentioned earlier that we started about a year ago to get really serious about tabletop games we have longstanding program around digital games video games and such Virtual Worlds um the my personal take is that the really compelling innovation in game design in the last few years has been much more on the board game side than on the video game side uh that's something for maybe people to discuss but that's my opinion and so I thought we you know we really need to start paying attention to this and we've developed we've now I won't go into the details but we've now started collecting contemp games and all of that it's not that easy to set this all up but we've managed to do that and with that we have an events program called tabletop Tuesdays uh we have this has been going now we just starting our third year actually we started this a little before the collecting program
typically we'll find a game that we can play in an hour or so or at least get to a turn perhaps and pair that with a a related short lecture or somebody talking about the theme that the game is about something that's related to the game you know something like that so it's a pairing of something uh that's sort of a preface to the game and then digging into a game that that the the two curators of this event series have started it's it's not me in this CA I was really happy that I have two colleagues in the library who who are organizing tabletop Tuesdays I'll say to people like yourself uh yourselves and other in the in game design if you're ever planning a trip to the Bay Area and you know well in advance such that we could could uh slot you in for one of these uh please it's pretty it's too far away well but you never know it could be two years from now you know that you have some occasion for being here uh we can also do things by the way now that you've said that uh the room that this happens in is has very good connectivity and um video conferencing in it so we could actually have somebody participate remotely it wouldn't be as much fun as being in the space and talking to people but it's an option maybe I'll extend SD hison like my trip next year yeah that's a good idea there you go now I'm
thinking about it also brand who runs the war game stuff at Origins occasionally comes to the Bay Area as well so you might you might uh might get us piling in let me know look like in your case we we would probably uh like we I said we always have something as a preface in your case we probably want to say something on your podcast series as well uh as whatever game I mean you you'll have a game to show we're doing um we're looking into doing some launch events um uh we're uh I hope it's okay that I say this I don't think we've announced this yet but in the winter we want to do one with uh for mly house uh cool with Cole and you know uh uh he he'll be coming to Stanford and we'll do something like that so that's another option is if if it's kind of like book talks right except it's with board GES I like it I like it it's an awesome initiative uh and I I I can see like on on this screenshot that you're featuring uh Team Hutchings games which are fascinating games you're talking about C world so it looks like you you there is really an effort to go and engage with is um like I would say seriously with with the community like looking at at a very very interesting designers that are re Forward Thinking so it's really cool yeah the uh so I'm a board gamer but my Silicon Valley archives which is not a game project it's about the history of Silicon Valley right but I have a team
of four people uh and we have the board gamer me the war gamer we have a ccg player and we have a u RPG play player so we have everything pretty yeah we can and everyone is quite in their domains is pretty well plugged in so we we sort of know that's the basis really for my my claim that the interesting um Innovation is happening in board games various kinds various formats you know card games included and going back to play by email uh Henry you made me think about something uh did you notice some similarities in other categories of games when it comes to play by email did you notice like play by email play by mail RPGs play by mail other stuff and any connections between communities around this or well of course it's later because like the the big big impact of role playing games you know leading up to and through Dungeons and Dragons is happening a little later those people uh appear in the general uh um Gary GX and Dave arners you'll find them in the general uh GX I believe was even the one of their you know they have these kind of like reporters for different regions of the country that talked about I think I think he was one for for his region for a while so uh yes
it's definitely later um I was not a role RPG player myself I was I'm strictly War Games you know then when we went to the conventions they were like those guys were off of yeah they have play on the other end of the of the of the convention floor um so I don't know from personal experience I have not seen a lot about them um but there's no reason why there couldn't be one the problem that I see as I mentioned diplomacy I think of as being slightly in a different category because Sho the issue with um most RPGs that I've played I had kids so I did end up playing them in various ways um is the way how you would deal with the placement of the units would be would be tricky in the pre you know pre- tabletop simulator pre send you a photo you all those kinds of things how would you uh how would you gather that information I'll say based on my experience there were systems I don't know them I haven't seen them but I can guarantee that there were players who tried to figure it out uh it's just a common line through the research I've done on any kind of game is the game is it's like an architect builds a building and then people go in and they do what they're going to do with the building right the architect loses control to if that building is opened up it's the same with games players take that g game as their own and they start doing things with it and
I'm sure with role playing games something like the like what I described probably happen it's just it would have been different and it would have been later yeah okay that's interesting all right so here it looks like we've got an exhibit oh I know this game yes you do yes I know so I've never seen a a physical copy of it I've only seen pictures and I was really interested in it that's the game about the German Finnish uh war in uh is it 198 1919 uh something something like this yes uh correct on the general en stuff it it U it's kind of interesting it's a German finish it's finished Civil War yeah the finished Civil War but you have German invasion in the end there were Germans swedes involved yeah um it is that um and this is the Finn game Museum the Cur Cur Nicholas and island is there in the middle in that one photograph showing me the game um what fascinated me about this game first of all it was exhibited in two this is a big Museum complex in Tuma in Finland and uh it's a former Factory building and they have about six or seven different museums in there this is the Finn game Museum but downstairs is's a Finnish History Museum as well that when I visited there this would have been uh spring of 23 um when I visited there they were having an exhibit on the finnished Civil War so i s this game was being exhibited in two places in two different museums at the same time um and they also as you
can see there they' also created a effect simil it's totally fascinating because when I first saw this game unlike other games I've seen that period I thought oh that looks kind of modern in a way point-to-point movement that this system for dealing with unit losses and things like that uh and no it was contemporary it was done at the time of the Civil War which then raises the other interesting question of why is somebody during a civil war over a hundred years ago even making a game about that war not that it's strange to do it I'm not saying that I'm saying I want to know why they did it who they were making it for how it was consumed and all of that reminds me a little bit of that game that there's I think one copy up in the world suff jetto that game about the suffet movement it's contemporary right okay what was who would they they making it for what was the purpose of what were they trying to communicate through that game it raises a whole bunch of questions they have gathered some documentation you kind of see in the one image in the lower left there's some uh interviews uh that they've related to the game and some other documentation they've put there but I was absolutely fascinated by and Nicholas was nice enough to kind of walk me through uh how the game is played have you so I was wondering have you played it because for me that was the big question so I've seen images of it because at some point I was really interested in uh that like the finished Civil War and I discovered that this game existed and I was also
surprised that at the time someone made a game seriously engaging with the history of the but I couldn't find anything around okay how does it play what kind of ideas are there because when I look at it from outside as you say it looks very contemporary like it looks like it looks like kind of games that we could see today uh and I was wondering does it play the same or is it just a an illusion that it looks like a game we could play today but it's actually different no it plays it plays like a game it it has a very very 2024 feel to it um when you play it so Nicholas has that that kit there I bet you know and we we can just this later I can give you contact information I he might be to reproduce the kit you know yeah just just uh ping me later and remind me uh as you can see there's a sheet of paper in the middle as I recall it though there are some rules to it uh there's something about you you sort of Orient Orient the counters to keep track of losses and things like that um uh I found it I I did not play the game entirely I did sort of just a walk through with him of one or two turns and I just thought it was amazing I would say if there's you know there's people out there uh uh you know maybe one of you perhaps this is a game that I think someone should look at as a as a foundation maybe for a reworking of it uh in some way that respects you know it's its historical
authenticity it just seems be a good project I think that's a really good point and I really like this idea of doing game Restoration in a way uh like taking old designs maybe that are even earlier than the Avalon Hill era or even that that or even at that era and saying okay could I keep the same effort of the game the kind of the same ideas and some of the things that were actually quite unusual and disappeared afterwards but we interesting mechanics and just refresh it and and make it a newer design um uh I think there is always some really cool ideas uh to to to do but yeah I would love to play this see if there is something to it because I think that would be so so interesting um and this is the start of the war game archaeology planned field trip to Finland yeah just even having the kids being able to do a kid at home and and and playing around with it to see what it plays like and there are some games like this that are actually quite unusual I don't know if you know the so the designer from risk was a was a French designer and he actually designed I think before risk a game called Roman carage uh and it is actually a point topoint map you play with cards you move units on the board and you're like wait a minute I've never heard about this game this is the the guy who made risk and it's super interesting and you're it looks like some games actually kind of disappeared and we forgot that there were really innovative ideas even before War Games became a thing and maybe there
is something to look back and and and really cover those games you know from an academic perspective and I say that it doesn't have to be that academics would do this it could be an event by anyone the thing that jumps out of me is somebody needs to do uh a conference or a collection of essays on War Games before World War II yeah since we kind of with diplomacy and Charles Roberts and stuff we tend to think I and I fall into this trap myself the first commercial us you know first commercial war game the world started with tactics everything yeah in in the 50s you know post World War II and to just say okay we're just looking at games before there there were of course many of these uh chase games and things like that that historical themes but then you come across something like this and you think oh my God uh there are a lot of ideas here that um don't fit into what we think of as the the the you know like the 19th early 20th century kind of game um I don't know of a lot of work that's been done on that and it it would be great to to dig deeper yeah I don't know of a lot of it and it's now I keep thinking about other games like I think about Stratego for example which originally was l once again a French game that was released early 20th century also had a massive impact on war games like it's basically the precursor of block games like you move units and
you don't know what they are until you're in contact with them and I think this is actually quite interesting and it and we kind of forget those things and you were talking about the fact that this was made around the era of the the finished Civil War and I think if if I remember correctly I think that during the French Revolution uh you had a lot of newspapers that were printed around and actually you had some of these newspapers that included games in it that talked about the politics of the time where you could actually cut off the cards and you could have a sort of card game that you could have at home and stuff like this and it feels like we have the sense that what we do is quite modern playing history through uh mass-produced games but actually maybe it's not that modern it existed in some forms before and we just kind of forgot about it um but yeah sorry for yeah no that's it's a call for a a more extensive history of board games I love it yeah for sure no this has given me so many ideas already all right what do we got here okay so another find uh was a thing called was this um publication when SPI was starting uh dunan you know bought uh strategy and tactics started SPI brought together this core of people that sort of um took where Avalon Hill kind of stalled and developed um different kinds of games but also uh this group Roger mcgallen and
dunan and people like that they developed a lot of terminology that we use today such as the idea of the game developer which you know has a little different meaning with board games than it does with other kinds of games and they had this publication called game design uh it's pretty rare uh it's um part of dunigan's weird you know interesting mix of projects when he was starting all of this you know he was designing games but he also had these sort of the first project I know of where he was invite inviting players to choose from from Little descriptions of game designs that they had in mind I think that's uh what might be what the page on the lower left is relating to where they had just a whole bunch of like short descriptions let's do a game about this or a game about that or G another sort of game uh and then they also had a kind of like play testing versions of games that they sent out to a lot of people that's in fact you know they would number them like number a number 19 and so forth and one of those is what became ponor Blitz which was for me the big moment around 1970 for game design this idea that you could go from these monographic games that were just about one topic and the spoke design to deal with you know the African campaign or Stalingrad or D-Day or something like that a battle or campaign to a system a scenario based system where you had components that could be reused for a number of different games games um that would
later have a huge influence as as it developed through other games a huge influence on the development of computer games as well um and so he was experimenting in all kinds of things and P publishing all kinds of things to build out a much larger Community than the than Avalon Hill had around not just um playing games but designing games uh the the basic problem for SBI was dunigan who had a kind of a LoveHate relationship with Avalon hill by by this time was thinking there's got to be a way to do more than one game a year so he made this commitment uh to putting a game in every every issue of the magazine and now you're talking about doing 10 12 you know however many games uh whoops my ear just fell out many games you need to uh do the magazine and other games that you want to do so he started developing all these techniques for getting input from people developing a bunch of games simultaneously and then of course with the p puner Blitz also offered the opportunity for one system to just develop a whole bunch of other different games as well so there's just a lot of things going on and this is just something where you know uh again I got lucky I was able to get a copy of this for Stanford libraries and um add it for the collection that's really cool also is
this to a misss Sneed it sure is hell yeah oh and thank you so I meant to caveat this at the beginning I'll do it now um I was talking about communities right and and subtext of what I was saying is gosh look at all these things that people did to include more people in this community and uh S as like a theme as wow how inclusive the war game Community was in the 1960s uh that's totally wrong Yeah Yeah from what we've read uh yeah I would say it's something wrong yeah yeah and you know I mean you know like uh Aaron trl's book privilege of play something or car CK's book um coin operated Americans which is like how arcades became a space for male adolescence when it didn't really start out that way um they the there was a lot of exclusion as well as inclusion not everybody was included um and yeah when you see women being involved in this it uh instantly you want you have questions you want you want to know you know was she playing these games or was her maybe it was her 12-year-old son who was interested or something and she someone doing this for it could have been different things things to explain that but you're immediately interested in it and want to know more about this because we know it was not a very inclusive community in the way we would think about that today there's a lot
that needs to be written about that um and I I had meant to cave out that at the beginning and I'm doing it in my fantasy version of this Mrs Sneed loves to play war games so you know I know people ask me this all the time uh in the in the earlier period uh today lots of people your self- included design games lots of women um and I only know of say pre 1990 there I only know of one board war game in this tradition was game about Civil War about the Battle of Gettysburg by a designer named Helena Rubenstein of all names um who did it as a master's thesis for I don't remember which college where she was but that uh there wasn't a lot roleplaying games uh I think Aon in his book goes into this you know he goes into it in much more detail there was a there was more going on uh I'll say here we I edit a book series for MIT press called game histories and uh we have working with an author on a manuscript about women and the early development of role playing games there was a community that story has not been told but there was a community um I I can't point to one for war games really um I hope I'm you know somebody will come along and correct
that interesting all right putting a stamp on games what is this is this what we can access ourselves yeah so the original the original um um article that I wrote about play by mail was I have to look here I'm trying to remember the a journey journey planet was that the name of it yeah Journey PL it's kind of an online Zen that was published they had a special issue about postal mail and games in general and things like that and so I gather this thing together like many things on the internet this online Journal is very difficult to find nowadays uh so we have a facility uh through the Stanford libraries where I can self- deposit items into our digital repository and I took the penultimate version I didn't take the published version I took the the last draft of it so there wouldn't be a definite copyright problem and I created a collection it's online anybody oh I'm sorry I did I took this photo in away you can't see a URL but if you just go to the that search works you see that search works. stanford.edu that's our catalog if you type in putting a stamp on games you will get this collection which includes my article it's in there somewhere yes near the bottom it says Journey planet and then documents some of the photos that you've seen but also scans of of some of the Publications around PBM some corespondence the the
combat resolution forms that's all in there so if you want to do a quick you know not comprehensive but just get an orientation with including primary sources it's all there and anybody in the world can go there and download it and and use this stuff uh that's also um if somebody who's listening or one of the podcast hosts perhaps at a collection uh of digital materials related to board games and there aren't any you know major copyright issues that would cause a problem uh we could do this it doesn't have to be me it doesn't have to be my collection but you could do it through me and I I would be happy to create a collection around you know a smaller collection of stuff um like this one that's awesome yeah all right I know what I'm doing later tonight um yeah yeah that's my that's my job is I I have conversations with people and they walk away with a hundred hours of stuff to look through and then I go back to having my coffee oh this is the this is the thing I told you about this game uh and you see uh you know this one this photo I took mainly to to show the game but you can you can see some of the correspondence that's uh in the box there you can see this is not a uh um mint in shrink wrap copy of the game the
counters are punched all that you can see some stains here and there I think even on the map there's a couple of coffee stains that's sort of thing Me It's Been Loved yeah exactly it gives ptin now yeah that's a yeah yeah yeah it's been used this is an artifact not a yeah this is cool yes have you played uh in your project have you played St gr yet no we hav't played St gr not yet yeah looks like we better what was the the time of the release for stting god um I'm pretty sure it was out or just about released around the time the PBM form started so it would have been mid-60s let me check because that could be one of the if we Zoom it's probably in the lower right corner there I'm guessing well again you see and by the way you see the hex's are not identified there's that yeah they're not numbered so this is pre Texas oh yeah it's it's 1963 so it was just before begin so it was released right when uh just the year before when the general started or around that time so yeah so there there were seven games I want to say that were accounted for in this PBM kit that came out in 6465 and I think Stalingrad was one of them so yeah nice also like you know Roberts had this notion in the marketing is also part of the story about building this community that these were adult games which every Everybody Snickers when they hear that that he used that term that way because he has different connotation today but his idea was you he he had
worked a little bit in Communications and so he had this kind of you know uh flowery language he sometimes had in some of the advertising but you know you're seeing this always there usually like you see on the side of the Box four adults 12 years and up well okay I don't know that's a broad definition of adults hey that 12-year-old was like damn right I'm an adult well yeah it's a good marketing tactic I would say that it's the important thing was to get that adult in there you know there's a different kind of game that's the that's the that's the little uh veneer that they wanted to have on all their games was these are in this different category for adults you know even if you're 13 amazing yeah so now we're opening it up to see what in this box some examples of it I've spread out a few things these are none of this is from these are all even though the sheets might look the same these are all from this box right so um there's the correspondence uh there's example like I mentioned earlier before that there's some Military Officers you'll see there's a captain you know Whitaker and the MIT SGS is that MIT strategic simulation game Society I think that must have been the full name uh typed letters handwritten things the newspapers now you know why there's newspapers there right there's and you can see those are stock tables right there you would an interesting thing about that a little side this is like getting into the minuche of this
culture so people got paper newspapers back then you remember you've seen those when you were young yeah actually my dad worked for newspaper and so of my mom before she she wrote for um other companies but I my one of my childhood memories is walking over the basement where they were printing newspaper and smelling newsprint oh lucky you wow yeah so you had the subscription but the thing was uh usually you'd read them and throw toss them out recycle them today uh you read them toss them out you didn't keep a stack of newspapers at home so you get the the move it might have been uh after the guy mailed it you know the other player mailed it to you but oops that was yesterday's newspaper I don't have it anymore so a little thing about this culture is it many walks or drives to the library were involved in this people going to the library and getting this the the count or maybe making a photoc copy or whatever whatever you did to get that information from the newspaper that you no longer had um with those stock numbers but was still over at the library um and that's you know um often times too people would clip out the reason for this is they would often say like okay here's the numbers I got and to prove that you weren't just making up the numbers if you did have the newspaper you would cut it out and
send it back with the move so they could see how you did the math oh that's cool yeah those are on the left you see them uh in the Avalon Hill form I think that's what that is you would actually see the counter depicted and then just right below it the location so there was visually it was really easy to work with and that's not something people would have been able to do on their own and it you know it again shows it's one of these uh examples this happens in history of Technology there's a lot of examples of this with Technologies of this feedback loop between companies producers and the consumers you know that they're going that they some things are produced by the company in this case abon Hill because they learn more about how people are using this kind of game or what they want from it or what's going to work or not going to work and they make it easier they create these affordances then with in something like this form so that players can more easily um play by mail other things were developed entirely by players like the sheet I showed you earlier from ahx that was entirely a player develop things and those things are in constant conversation with each other wow oh what do we got here oh speaking of which that's ahex yeah I was say oh okay so that's the yeah yeah and you see
um I think let's see there's a listing there's a listing of players there you know just give you an idea uh I was hoping to find some people there that were prominent um maybe somebody else will recognize a name there but um you know this is you would get these uh this oh uh membership oh this is actually the Avalon Hill play by male organizations yet another variant I guess um there's a lot of email that went back and forth about these things usually for something like ahx or another thing you would uh sign up and then you get like a welcome packet something like that and you would uh they tell you what you do what you get your membership how you do the how you use the playby mail system here's some other players you know you're not alone uh all of that was part of it and and through this you're feeling like you're part of the community I can see what I think is the stall gr yeah might be Russian I can't quite tell enough about the map from that little SLI but it it does look like the Stelling R map on the on the yeah yeah yeah so maybe this is even back from maybe this is even something that came from the MIT group nice all right and then Fred is running out time because it's late for
him so let's do like a quick tour so we saw this one yeah saw that one yeah that's for sure and that's Russian campaign which of course is later amazing great game by the way and this is a close up yeah and this is this is like the assemblage of different things uh this is all ahck um I'm been assigned a game that's I'm I'm 1101 you know that's my number I'm playing Russian campaign with another player that's kind of covered by the stock market stuff though it's Brian I guess if I see on AIS these allies you can kind of see numbers have been crossed out because we use them on the combat resolution key which was known as an irk that's how that was pronounced it stands I wrote it down because I couldn't remember uh what that stands for it's individual combat resolution key that's what I see very all that kind of stuff yeah exactly there's a there's a kind of language you know language in a way when you start having things like that it starts you know it's like watching Star Trek and then describing something that that the machine some technology on the spaceship and Stu yeah that must be a really cool technology so you have like a really complex name and people assume that you know there's a lot behind it yeah and there's stuff uh stuff here this the guy's writing to me as we begin the game and you see they you commonly introduced yourself you did talk about yourself so how much you played and then finally of course once again there's you
know the stock market sheet it's hard I have you know I think maybe by this point people have gotten the idea but I just have to keep emphasizing uh this weird connection with the newspaper and the development of these systems yeah um so Byron one of our viewers asked if there were ever problems with the stock quote being different the same day because of print time or did you have to agree to use the exact same newspaper you had to agree to use the closing uh the closing number so if your newspaper um if you're newspaper did something weird then uh you know you had to make sure that it was that number and that's one reason why you sent sometimes sent the newspaper with the move back uh that's one of my son's cats uh I just thought you know hey we're on the internet we have to have one of those yes always cats of all yes this it's amazing I have several this is that game about the I called 2040 or something like that about sort of Civil War in the US yeah um playing that and he just wanted to be part of it he's got to be part of everything it's good I like it all right so um we've we've been going for almost a full 90 minutes so we're gonna we're gonna do the wind up Henry thank you so much this was amazing I absolutely loved this oh you're
welcome and I'm gonna go part of my pendant is I'm gonna go back after this and look for some of your episodes we have a geek list we'll send it to you we're g boame geek like um um thread where we just update with our different I appreciate it you know this is I'm I obviously I'm interested fascinated connected to to all of this and I'm I'm really I really want to see what you guys did with these early games yeah and I'm actually really curious about yeah keeping this discussion going with you maybe uh offline maybe for you to inform some of the things that we could do in the series uh I think it's uh it's it's really a really awesome really thankful that you could make the time and and and show us all of this that's that's really cool oh yeah totally my pleasure and if there's something useful I can contribute uh just let me know I'm happy to do it great amazing all right those of you out here out there if you have old playby mail records that you would like to send them over to Henry posterity thank you yes absolutely my neck in I was talking to a friend who was playing the 80s in France and they had their own systems uh if you have any interest in this I can I can check with them to see if they by any chance have some archives to see how different it was between maybe the uh what was happening in the in the French Community was it like align with what was happening was I will ask and and I will let you know thank you yes we very interested in
that very interested in you know the sometimes we talk like everything what's happening in the US or Britain maybe but that's not the case we want to know about what was happening everywhere cool that's great that was awesome another awesome episode fantastic all right y we'll be back soon with some more war game archaeology now that Fred and I have both moved and successfully settled yes and Henry thanks again so much I can't wait for whatever we're GNA do next because I know there's got to be something yeah yes thank you thank you very much everyone