Skip to main content
Loading video...

Battle Merchants Video Review

Transcript 28:49

hey everybody it's me it's Undead Viking uh coming to you with another uh video review uh today it is a Kickstarter uh game review time if you will uh this is a game that I've had for a while and I played a few times now and um uh I'm not a huge economic uh game lover uh there's a lot of games out there that are kind of based in a lot of Economics engines and and what have you um and of course like I'm I'm pretty sure like a lot of people uh when you refer to economic games they think of either some of the more in-depth 18xx uh train games um because it's all about stocks and money and what have you and power grid of course you know comes up a lot in conversations and there's some other ones out there that um you know I played I mean space Merchants uh if you remember that one came out I believe last year maybe the year before which was you know an economics game U at heart and that was a game that I actually enjoyed it was one of the you know rare uh economics games that I actually had fun playing and today's game that I'm going to be showing you here very shortly is another economics game that I actually had a great deal of fun playing uh the game uh in question and this is a prototype is Battle Merchants um the premise behind battle Merchants is there is this uh fantasy land that fantasy land there is this uh like it's it's it's a fantasy themed game um where there are these four uh

super not Supernatural but four fantasy races uh dwarves hom goblins Orcs And elves and they are constantly fighting each other and each person uh plays a battle Merchant and you are basically a a person that forges and creates weapons and uh you are trying to make money off of the wars you don't really care who wins or loses um you know you don't really like well you do kind of and I'll you'll see that when I show you how the game is played because you want whoever's got your weapon to win but um uh you you don't really have a dog in the fight if you will you you aren't an orc you aren't a dwarf you know so on so forth uh you are just somebody looking to make money off of the wars so uh you create weapons and you sell them uh to the different races and then at a certain point the game um like kind of stops and you have uh you resolve all the conflicts that are going ongoing at that point the the different uh Wars that are happening and then uh based off of that you you figure out you know whose weapons are best and so on and so forth and and then you get a little bit of extra money depending on if your weapons survive the battles and and then you just go on to the next round and like a lot of Economics games it's all based on money and who can make the most money and whoever has the most money at the end of the game wins the game so so that's that's basically the theme um it

is a game that handles two to four people I've only played it with four and three um the two-player has a two- player like a dummy player and I i' monkeyed with it just solo to see how that works it works pretty well but um what I'm going to show you is I'm going to show you kind of like how a four player game works I'm just going to kind of show you a round of it I'm not going to go really in depth into the rules um but after that uh I'll tell you exactly what I think and since it's a Kickstarter game I'll tell you where obviously there's be a link uh below the video uh that you can follow and you'll be able to see where you can go if this game interests you and you can back it and you can see if it's uh gets published then you can get a copy and so on so forth and I'm sure um since it's uh minion games um I'm sure that there'll be tons of super cool add-ons and what have you is like all kickstarters have that you can uh of course pimp your game out and and uh get all those little exclusives and what have you but um the designer uh because I don't I I is uh Gil Hova I I don't know who Gil Hova is this is the only game I think I've ever seen by Gil but Gil he made a pretty cool game so uh kudos to you but enough jibber jabber uh let's show you how to play Battle Merchants okay everybody uh this is the battle Merchants game board uh the different it's set up for a four player game presently um over here you just see some of the weapons that you'll be building and you be placing on the board and here's some cards that'll be showing off and what have you um you do use money I don't have like I didn't this is

a prototype which I always say for most Kickstarter games so uh make sure that everything you see here uh it could very well end up looking um somewhat or much like uh the end result of the game but um there's even some things here that like uh don't coincide uh with the actual uh game you'll notice that there's spots here on the board for hammers uh yet um the parts I have don't have hammers instead uh I I have pole arms you know so um there's things like that that uh do little discrepancies but um the actual gameplay is unaffected all uh by it as as well um for money I'm just using my uh uh cool miniature poker chips and um you do get all these little player boards and like this is uh my dude here uh Max's Metal Works and um it's nice that has like the actions listed over here that you can do tells you what the endgame scoring is uh how much weapon prices are when you sell and so forth um you can see here with reward tiles um as you play the game you will take reward tiles which will make things uh worth more when you sell to certain races and so you can see Max already makes more money when he sells to hobgoblins here and you can see Max right now has the ability to make maces and swords um but as the game progresses he will learn how to make others so uh you know pretty straightforward

and like over here is a spot for defeated weapons when you your weapons are successful in battle uh you'll take trophies uh other other people weapons that lose and here are the weapons youve forged over here that you can then sell um I won't really refer back to this much as we're playing the game um but just wanted to show that to you so each person will have something like that so uh as the game progresses um you will slowly but surely uh kind of develop your uh weapon forging Empire uh and you will make basically spur combats to occur between uh the four races The Dwarves the hobgoblins the Orcs And The Elves and um the way it is set up is like the dwarves and the Orcs will never fight the hobgoblins and the elves will never fight it's just um these little spots here these are where the combats are occurring uh to begin the game you have to uh make sure that you turn over the cards that are available to start with um this is just these are just paper obviously these will be much better um these are uh the three you start with three and as these are taken you immediately replace them at the beginning of the next person's turn uh you like a standard card here is um this one says scavenger uh you gain a dollar every time one of your weapons was defeated in battle so even if you aren't uh don't have a really good weapon and it gets destroyed uh you still get a buck for doing that it's important to note that like this card like traveling salesman card you notice at the bottom it says uh add $2 you

don't pay $2 to get the card you just get the $2 uh when you take the card so um sometimes taking your card will earn you a little bit money too and I just wanted to show you this one real quick um the localized need um it says take the village reward tile well unfortunately um there is no Village uh because uh in a like uh previous version of the board um there was a a village location where battles occurred instead now it's the grassland so in this case you would be taking this grassland style and um much like other reward icons uh when you take that uh you're earning an extra dollar whenever you sell uh to one of these battles that's located here so I'm just going to kind of uh go through what you can do in each turn and I should also I apologize um you do set out uh five of these cards to start with one two three four five and these are the different um uh weapon forges that you can do and the different uh crafts if you will and so each one of these uh will be available um on and as they're used um they uh you replace them with the next person's turn cuz you can take these as an action now some of these um we'll we'll say free on them so if you take like this which would increase it's it's a battle axe craft there's one little star up here meaning that you'd

increase your battle axe skill or battle axe crafting skill by one uh will never cost anything to do that but if say you have this one which is uh pole arm * 2 you take whatever level of pole arm you're currently at or whatever thing you have and then you times that by two and you have to pay that amount of money to take this if you happen to start have zero meaning like with Max he has no uh pole arm skill if he took this time 2 * Z you get it for nothing and I should show you this one as well um this one is for crafting maces and there's a gold coin over here and the gold coin means that whenever you craft a mace now it costs one coin less to make them so and it's a times one so you whatever skill level you take that times that and then it gives you an extra level of skill in the the weapon and then uh it would once again cost less so you know something nice to have as far as uh you know ongoing as the game continues you can make those weapons for cheaper um when you craft weapons you can craft weapons of varying skills and normally skill is just number I made a level three sword and that only really comes into effect when you actually have a battle meaning that like a level three sword against a level one axe the level three sword wins sometimes once you get to level five in your crafting ability you can start making waral weapons and waral

weapons have notice the five they cost a heck of a lot more to make they sell for a heck of a lot more and a vpal weapon will always defeat a normal weapon if two vpal weapons um happen to uh meet if you will you would still uh measure the two different skills against each other it also should be know it that uh if you manage to get to be the first person the first battle Merchant that gets to a level six uh in making a weapon you can unlock one of these skills and you just get to take it and once per season you can both Forge and sell a weapon uh as a single action normally you forge weapons then next another action later you sell them and then when you use them you just flip it over for That season there's four seasons in the game that are denoted by here uh you know spring uh summer W autumn and winter now I some of these cards like have permanent on them and when you have uh permanent those you can only have a certain number of permanent cards in Spring you can have two in summer you have three in Autumn you have three and winter you can have four so you got to make sure you pick one that's uh good obviously that's actually going to continue to help you because you don't can't have a ton of those cards anyway on your turn uh you can take several actions you can just take a card which pretty self- sanatory you can take one of the upgrading craft so like if on my turn I said well you

know I like this um I like the idea that I can spend less uh to to make my maces it's a times one card and if you remember um max already has one level of Mace there so if I add this I times one times level and that would be one coin so I would take one of my monies and I would put it in the bank but then I would have the ability to make a level two mace and would cost one less so and then everybody else takes a turn and so on and so forth and I'm not going to go through everybody's turn I'm just going to kind of show you what each person can do so um comes back to to Max and now he wants to uh say Forge a weapon uh so he can look and you can see well where where Ma is needed I see the dwarves need a mace here and uh the Orcs need a mace there now it's important to note that um you can only sell to the top level first until these battle tokens get taken off and once they're taken off then that unlocks the next level so you can't just sell down to here you got to start at the top and work your way down so max decided he's going to forge a weapon and so he's going to forge a mace cuz it costs him less and you can see it's a normal that the two base Forge for a mace is five but because he's got that one that lowers it down he

can forge it for four so we're going to take four of these coins turn them into the bank and then I'm going to take uh this mace and know it says one on it but don't worry about that it doesn't matter you just take that mace and then you just put it in front of you uh and you have that mace that you can then sell on your ex turn so it goes around and around and let's just say you know somebody in their first turn um they had uh built a a pole arm and they had placed it there in that location let's just say and you you place a cube on them like so when they do that and uh technically since green did that uh they would have taken uh a race token off there but I will explain that on Max's turn when he goes so now it's Max's turn and he is going to sell his mace and he notices now he can finish off a combat so he's going to go there and he's going to place that he's going to sell it to the Orcs well the first thing he does is he makes his money well if you can see the base cell is six for all weapons so I will take six coins back out of the bank so I get that back and I can place that in my my my stronghold if you will and then I'm going to take a cube and I'm going to put that on there and now the what's going to happen is that

battle is complete so we're going to take that that token and we're going to place it on that spot in the spring now once there are three battles raging that's going to Signal the end of the season and so um just several more turns go people are taking these cards and what have you and I'm not going to like I said go through everything but um let's say you know battle axe got built there and a long swur got built there let's just Place those like that that finished off that battle and you know um let's just go ahead and let's put a long sword there but nobody ever you know fought that one um maybe Max uh went and he had a long sword and he built that there and um nobody else fought against him but over here uh a battle ax was built uh by yellow uh not a battle ax I'm sorry a battle was built over here and a pole arm was built uh by Green like there so that signaled the end of the season there are three B battle is going and it's the end of the season so what happens is is that everything is done and uh each each person um actually when when one person like if Max is the person to Signal the end of the season

every other person gets another turn because you can't just end it like that so already gets like uh and then after that has been done you now uh have to resolve the battles and what happens is you compare the different skill levels of each uh like crafting ability of each weapon and whichever one uh is better uh they they win if they tie um both the weapons are destroyed but for your troubles because um during the battle you were there and and helping them sharpen and maintain the weapon each person would gets a dollar for doing so now in some situations you might actually even own both weapons on either side you know you're playing both sides against each other but in this sit let's say these two had the same level of weapon and so these two weapons were destroyed we just take them off but both uh red and yellow would uh get a dollar for their trouble for for for having that battle and then when we got over here um the green pole arm uh wasn't as powerful as as the battle axe so the battle ax stays but the pole arm is destroyed now but yellow would get this token as a prize and they placed that next to their their board there was no fight here nothing happened and Max let's say increased his Maes high enough and to defeat the pole arm and so we defeat that pole arm and Max gets to take this as a prize at the end of the

season and so now we take a look at the board and anybody who has a weapon that's still out there regardless of they they a battle or not gets two coins because gets $2 um basically the you have a contct with them to maintain the weapon and upkeep and sharpen everything like that so yellow would get two uh green would get two but Max since he's got the two weapons sitting out there would earn himself four more coins and he placed that in his bank and then um we take the cards that if there are still cards here we take them get rid of them take these uh crafting cards take them get rid of them fresh new cards all all around and then you start the next season now the interesting thing is that even though this one doesn't have a token there you can still sell to these locations you could sell a pole arm here you could sell a pull arm there things like that and you can continue to build the big thing is is that you got to try to make sure that you sell to each race at least once a season so you can maintain that extra bonus of getting that extra dollar each time that you're selling off the coins after you've done all four seasons uh youbody collects all the money and you unsold weapons you get to sell them for its endell value you can see uh basic weapons are worth three and warp 11's over 13 and then whoever has the most uh defeated armies like meaning the most uh little tokens

that they've collected uh earns a bonus of 15 and second earns a bonus of seven um some Kingdom cards uh will give you a bonus at the end uh like this traveling salesman card and then you just total up all the money and whatever who's got the most coinage will win the game and that's how you play Battle Merchants so um but as always let me tell you exactly what I think of the game and uh I'll do that right now you know uh um candies come and go uh but but uh the the classic red hots good stuff left over from a movie I went to uh which good stuff but anyway here I am talking with my mouthful I should be telling you what I think of Battle Merchants okay so you should have an idea of how to play and um it's pretty straightforward um it has a lot of things um little uh intricacies and what have you that I really enjoy um a lot of times um economic games are really dull and uh uh kind of um for lack of a better term they're just really dry and I know a lot of people say oh you Euros are just dry and you know honestly you could you could take this theme it

wouldn't have to be a fantasy world it it could be present day you know you you could have made a um you know current you know uh weapon of death Merchant whatever type of situation and you could have made like a or or a light-hearted James Bond spy type thing you you could have gotone a lot of different ways and and and just regardless it's just you got to come up with an item that you'd create where two people would fight and the items would determine uh which one survives and so you could have got everything but I do like um the fantasy theme and I I I do like uh the idea uh that I am just playing uh this person uh that's just uh making money off of the blood of of these these wars I mean and the thing is is and I guess maybe there's a a little twinge if if you made it real there would be a twinge of a moral dilemma if you will you know it's just like here I am I'm profiting on the death of these people or what have you but since this is you know fantasy elves and Orcs And what have you we don't really have to worry about it because they're not real uh so um regardless I I I I do dig the theme and I dig the the way they went with the art kind of cartoony and and it's very interesting but don't let don't let that kind of um that uh the look of it uh fool you into thinking that it's it's a very uh simple

game because it isn't um there's a lot of really cool things about it that I enjoy um I like the fact that um you know you have to be buying and selling weapons uh at bulk for one cuz I mean the difference between making it and selling it isn't enough for you to really start making money that way but the most important thing to do is you need to start collecting uh the the bonuses that either decrease the amount that it costs for you to make the item or increasing the amount of money it's worth to you to be selling the item so you got to make sure that you're you know diversifying in the different uh markets you know and and make sure that you you try as much as you can to sell to each race at least once every round uh so you can you can make sure that um you're you're constantly escalating that ladder because you never really want to get stuck uh in a situation where you can't either one make the weapon that you need to uh for the the spot on the board but you and also you never want to be stuck trying to sell something to a race that really isn't worth it you know worth your trouble trouble uh you you want to make sure that you you kind of are always uh diversifying if you will I I guess in a way you could try to um specify or I mean like or try to make a very uh like I'm just going to sell the Orcs that's all I'm going to sell to and and I and I I guess you could try that but I mean it just seems to me like whenever I've

tried to do that when I played the game uh you know there's so few opportunities on that spot that you're you're just kind of hamstr yourself um I like the little extra cards that they have they add in there and the fact that um you have to be really choosy about which ones you pick cuz they're Perman a lot of them are permanent uh so right away at the very beginning you think oh this card's great and you take it you put it in front of you but now you've used up that spot for the rest of the game so you got to make sure that you you know pick the right you know card you know that that's going to actually keep paying you off for the rest of the game because that's a very very valuable spot I mean a lot of games out there it's it's like one of those things where it's like oh and then you can replace a card with there with another card you just can't do that in this game so I mean uh it requires a lot of forethought and planning I also really like the fact that uh the players in a lot of ways have the ability to kind of speed or slow up the game because of the fact that they're the ones that are causing the conflict I mean if you sell a mace to an elf and they sitting around waiting for the hob goblins uh to get a sword uh to fight well if nobody sells that that fight never happens and so if you are in a situation where you know you have a pretty good economic engine going and you're you're making money uh but other people are just you know they're they're you know they're they're trying to get going you know like how a train is beginning it's like they're just spinning their wheels and

they're trying to get going you're in a situation where you might make a sword and sell the sword uh to that H and like and maybe make next to no money uh by doing so but you're doing it to Speed the game along so the other people's engines can't catch up to the one that you have and and also you as another player you're you're the one that has to be constantly on the lookout for situations like that and trying to prevent other people from doing that by taking uh uh certain uh um uh like the the we the weapon uh contracts I not contracts I can't think of the word right now um the the different weapon plans that you have so you can create other weapons so like taking certain weapons so other people don't have it so you can kind of try to hedge the market in a lot of ways in in certain situations like that so you can see there's a lot of different things that I I I I really like about the game it it it because a lot of the cards are random um you know the game is different each time you play and uh you can kind of go in with a mindset saying okay this is going to be what I'm going to try to do but if the right uh cards don't come over over or the right tokens don't come over then perhaps you just don't have that option you have to kind of think in the fly and recreate your strategy all in all like I said it's a very challenge game it's a lot of fun and uh I've had a great uh deal of uh enjoyment when when I've played it with my friends and for a group of people that don't play a lot of economic games this one's seen a lot the table a lot so I guess that's probably like the the

best uh the best suggestion I can give you is that normally we wouldn't play a game like this but this is a game that we've actually ened enjy it a great deal uh just because of the fact of the way it feels and it's very um it's it's it's deep but it isn't uh overly complex and uh it actually um there's a couple people I've played with that they've never really played this type of game but I just introduced the game to them and they had a lot of fun as well I wouldn't say it's a Gateway game by any means but um it definitely if you're looking for an economic engine type game it isn't as complex as some of the other ones that you'll see out there uh and uh on the Shelf if you will so there you go uh that's battle Merchants U Minion games um if you follow the link that I will post you will be able to head over to that Kickstarter and see if it's something else that you would uh like to back and uh get a copy of once it gets published so I invite you to do so and like I said there's probably going to be a bunch of really cool little added bonus Kickstarter stuff so uh you can always make sure you get all that cool bling to add to your game if you uh if you back the game so so well thank you as always for taking the time to watch this video I really appreciate it uh if you have any questions or concerns or ideas you can post them as always down there and I will try to answer those to the best of my ability um well until next time uh this was Undead Viking you have an awesome day bye-bye

Progress saved