Which The Thing Board Game Should You Get?
Transcript
hi everybody hello I'm Ryan I'm Bethy and we are Ryan Bethany board game reviews and today we're gonna be doing something a little bit different we are going to be doing a compare contrast that's right there was a movie called The Thing and that has spurred on some interesting Creations uh and we wanted to talk about that a little bit um first off we have a mov a book a game called the thing and then we have another game called the thing what's going on here what are these the same game these are not the same game are this they they look a little they're called the same thing they are called the same thing but we are going to say that this one is Outpost 31 CU it's called um the thing infection at Outpost 31 so I'll be referring to this as Outpost 31 all right so this one is called the thing the board game I'll just be calling it the thing when talking about board games all right let's talk about these two different games see what the differences are if any and which one do you think might be right for you yes so this one was published in 2017 all right mine was published in 2022 BR spanking new brand spanking new mine was designed by joov Van watering and yours was designed by uh Andrea Krispy and JPI Cicero okay and then mine um Outpost 31 was um published by Mondo with the up Mondo was published by uh uh pen dragon games along with Flat River games Distributing Ryan normally holds
our boxes so I'm just like all willy-nilly with my box I just just hold it goes like this and I'm like I have to talk with my box okay mine mine kind of slowly drips down over the course and then I I realize it back up again back up mine does mine drifts down and back up yours is going to be like dancing it's going to be dancing my game dances okay so um mine is inspired by the thing the 199 19 82 movie but that is inspired by a short story that was written in 1938 um called who goes there and that was written by John W Campbell Jr and actually it's a Nolla by the way I read it it's really good it's super short if you can get your hands on it I highly recommend reading it it's a lot of dialogue all right so my game the thing also based off of that same movie which based off of the same Nolla um however there was a rem of the movie or not remake but a prequel of the movie that was made in 2011 and there is an expansion that goes along with this game called let's see if I can do this right so many boxes going on the thing the board game Norwegian Outpost so that is based off of the this expansion is based off of the 2011 prequel movie my game does not have any expansions however it does have it does have two re-implementations so there's a Harry Potter themed one called Harry hutter unmask the Death Eaters and then there's another one called the um based off of
the office and it's called um the office paper paranoia mechanically they are the same game it's not like they took this and explored it no they're they're the same game um and my game plays 4 to eight players all right so my game on the box says one to eight players one day players seems a little sus um in truth what end ends up happening is there it plays 4 to8 players similar to Post 31 however uh there is a variant you can play that plays one to three players the expansion the Norwegian Outpost this does ex is exclusively for eight players so uh yeah it's kind of in that higher player count world without the the variant okay so now I feel like we got all that like basic stuff out of the way so what is the thing remember I'm dancing I'm the one dancing with my game I'm the one slowly falling asleep um so this is a social deduction game there is a hidden traiter in it you're the alien um and you're trying to in the middle of the game okay so you're hidden a Trader you don't know what's happening you're trying to fix things but somebody's like no you can't fix things and in the middle of the game you do a blood test it ends up more people can become the alien and so then you have these shared objectives and you can help or not help you can try to just make it till the end um the thing the alien the thing is either trying to sabotage the
missions or they could be doing that and also trying to escape at the end of the game all right so the way the the thing the board game works is very similar uh you have one person who's a hidden trador and they're kind of trying to hide it through that the game and either Escape or or sabotage however uh in this game there is a little bit a different of uh they're trying to blend in a little bit more the alien starts very very disadvantaged right so very underpowered if you out yourself early you you just can't win so you need to kind of slow play it a little bit um try not to get caught essentially so that way in the later half of the game when things kind of more information's been revealed as things are more ramping you know which direction that the team is going your opponents are going you kind of work through that um there's just a lot of extra small details in this there's things like weather die things like that so you have a lot more to contend with in this game uh that make this a lot more of an involved experience yes this is a lot more streamlined than that okay so in the in condition of this game um the alien wins the alien wins if it raises the contagion to the maximum um if it destroys The Outpost um if it escapes a little bit like a Canadian like The Outpost The Outpost or it escapes and the humans win the humans win if they all Escape without any aliens aboard and you do need to have a certain amount of humans based on a player count with you in order to win so you can't just be
like I'm going to take myself and I know I'm a human so we win you can't do that at the end of the game all right so in the thing uh humans win the same way they all Escape U with no aliens and there's multiple Vehicles ways that you can do that uh the aliens win if they can either assimilate the last human or one or more humans dies so any one human dies immediately the aliens win or you can escape with the humans as an alien have you've been revealed even whatever but you still managed to stow away or you can escape as a human with the humans they just never caught on to you you're just pretending still be a human as you escape you win that way as well all right so in uh Norwegian Outpost there is a couple extra wind conditions um there's kind of like a dog track I don't know if you know enough about the movie to know what that's about but basically short story too yeah the uh the dog track uh is a thing and if the dog track goes on too long the dog escapes H you know spoiler alert a little bit uh you aliens can wi that way also uh the humans can win individually in this one which they can just kind of like go off on their own and and and escape and then just leave the party behind so that's something that can happen in the expansion okay so overall like what are our thoughts on the two what do we recommend well I almost feel sorry for Ryan's game I feel so sorry for you the reason being I love this game so much it's on my top 100 so make sure to subscribe to see our videos to see where
on our top 100 this game ends up but that's how much I enjoy this game I feel like the hidden the you know hidden Trader and the social deduction part of this game plays with the a perfect amount of time I feel like it's an hour a little over an hour game and when you're investing that in like a um a social social what was the word I just said I just yes hidden Trader type of game you don't want it to go on for so long but you also want to feel like you had some ability to control something I just like really really really like this game all right so this one the thing is there's a lot more going there's a lot involved there a much longer experience um it's more tense too there's a lot more tension a lot more anxiety and stress and for some people in a good way um for someone like Beth who likes our social G to be a little bit snappier so not like in that tension for too long and you're just kind of like dragging that on this is going to be too much this is going to go long for you however I do recommend this pretty strongly if you are a fan of the movie and or the movies or the short story you want to put yourself in that world and merch yourself as much as possible this is a fantastic job of recreating those experiences those emotions very very viscerally as you're kind of just anxious the whole time you're just like on the edge of your seat the whole time for for a long time too so uh if you are a fan of the movies or you like those long longer more involved experiences as you know you're very very tense moving around trying to hide trying to sus things out as if you're one of the humans um I would
recommend the thing the board game for that scenario and for that group of people all right everybody thank you so much for watching don't forget to subscribe so you can see all our videos as they come out and find out where the thing lands on my top 100 list until then you can find us in all of these places you guys the comments below be sure to let us know which one of these games would be more preferable to you and your play group we'd love to hear from that too all right every thanks for watching and we'll see you next time bye you guys thanks so much for watching uh this game was provided to us by a publisher for in exchange for a fair and honest review and if you want to see more stuff check out over here to see something we think you might like and over here we think that YouTube has picked out a great video for you're going to love thanks guys see you next time bye