Ra: Traders Review: Epochalypse Now
Transcript
Hey there everybody. I'm Mike Delisio.
And I'm Chris Ye.
And today we're going to be looking at the first expansion for a very old game. I think I feel comfortable saying a very old game.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And at a at the time of this filming, Chris, it's an expansion for my number one game of all time.
It's uh and Raw is I top 10, 11 or something like that for me, too. Game I like tremendously.
Right. So, this one I think uh you know it it was I I really tried to come in with an open mind as much as I can, but it's hard because I have a lot of history with this game and I thought to myself, I'll be honest, the first time I heard about this, does Raw really need an expansion? Why expand a game from 1999 correct now?
Right. Well, let me at least show you how the game plays and then you'll have a little more context in mind when we come back and give you our thoughts. Okay, here you see everything that's included in the traders expansion for RAW. You've got five docs boards, which are going to be uh one for each player, and you've got 20 of these trader tiles. Now, these are the new tiles that come in the game. All of these are going to be added into the large bag of tiles that are going to be used for the auction. You also have some extra 10 value scoring tokens. And finally, you've got this uh goods crates storage bag here. And inside you've got the goods crates that are in values of one and three. The brown tokens here are the one point and the gold are worth three. And you can make change with these as needed throughout the game. You also have this one double-sided sheet of rules. And so you can tell it's not a terribly uh complicated addition to the game. So to set up, basically every player here's a regular player board from RAW. You would just take one of these dock boards and put it right there at the top. It fits seamlessly in with the um the player board that already existed for RAW. You would then place all of these tiles, like I said, within the main uh set of tiles, and you would play as normal. How these new tiles work is that when you
win them in an auction, or if you use a god tile to take them, you're simply going to put them off to the right side of your dock board here on top. And you can have any number of these. These are going to be worth one point at the end of each epoch because these go away. Okay, they're on the right side of the board, so they're not persistent throughout the game. They're going to get removed every epoch. But the the way you're going to get the most points using trader tiles are when other players claim trader tiles and you already have some. So if say for example that another player, not this player, this player has three uh trader tiles on their board. Another player wins an auction or takes a trader tile with a god tile. Now, when another player uh takes one of these, every other player who has trader tiles is going to get one small goods crate for each tile in their own collection. So, if this player take other player taken one, this player actually is going to get three goods crates. They can go ahead and take a gold one in that example, one for each. If another player had won two during the same auction, then that would double up.
Each one of these would give you three. And so you'd end up with six. And so at the end of the epoch, these are each worth one. And one for each of the goods crates. So this would be six, 7, 8, 9 in that particular epoch. And then, like I said, at the end of the epoch, these go away. These go back to the supply. And you continue to do that. That is basically it. It's a way to um get points when other people claim tiles as long as you have one or more trader tiles along your own board. All right. Well, that about covers it. Let's head back up and we'll let you know what we think.
All right, Chris. So, um let's address the elephant in the room and put you on the spot. Did Raw need an expansion?
No. I I mean, I like the game tremendously, obviously, and the game has stood the test of time. Uh, all the like. One of my favorite Rinesia games. Uh, love the recent reprint done by 25th Century. The Love Tender Care that went into the graphic design by Eno2, all that stuff, right? Kind of felt like we got a good definitive edition of this game.
Mhm.
And then a year after they released, they said, "We're going to make an expansion."
Yeah. Yeah. My answer is the same. No. Raw did not need an expansion. Uh, I felt like it was obviously a game that I have my number one game at all time. I rate it a 10. There's no such thing as perfection, but I think this one skirts along the outer edge of perfection. And I feel like, as you mentioned, this new addition from 25th Century, who has also done this expansion, right? um really elevated to the point where not only is it a beautiful looking game, but it's even more functional than it ever was before with the inclusion of how the playerboard works. I think ENO2, as you mentioned, had a lot to do with that. And so, I've had great joy over the last year or so introducing this to people that had maybe heard of it but had not played it before. And uh that that's really what made it rise in my estimation. I had always loved it, but now being able to expose it to so many other people that are getting similar feelings out of it, that took it up there. So, it's a daunting task to do an expansion to a game like that. Well, number one, they went back to the source, right? Uh there have been times before where games that are pretty well known have had an expansion and a different designer took it on or maybe developed it, but I don't get that impression here. From what I know, this was a Reiner Kitia design from the get-go. There's an arcade fingerprint through and through.
It does. And so, while we've both said that uh RAW doesn't need an expansion, I guess the question now becomes, okay, we've established that if you agree with our hypothesis, but does an expansion diminish the game at that point or does it add a twist that keeps it maybe on an even keel and maybe just provides a slightly different experience and
and that's what this one does. I think that's the the route taken instead of saying, "Oh, here's a whole, you know, fifth era and a fifth phase and all these, you know, new mechan." No, it's it's it's actually I think going to be fairly underwhelming for a lot of people to say, "Oh, it's just one new type of tile, right?
Here's 20 new tiles and some little crates."
I think it sounds more underwhelming than it is
in a way. Adding something new, adding a new form of set collection that has this kind of timing element to it. it very distinct actually from the from the other things that go on in the basic game.
But I also don't think it over complicates it.
That's Yeah. Go ahead. Sorry.
No. Yeah. So yeah curious what your thoughts are.
That's the key to me is that it added Yes. It added a new tile, right? And it added something that it did not necessarily always have before, which was you actually getting some excitement and enjoyment about somebody else winning a lot outside of it being a negative thing. Because there's always the positive of you're taking that disaster tile. Yes, a shot in Freder, right? But this is not quite that. This is I've built up a few trader tiles here. Now, when anybody else wins a trader tile in an auction, it benefits me.
Yeah. And so that's a slight twist that wasn't there before, but complexity-wise, it's seamless. You know, just the last time I played this, I taught it to a new player and it was with the expansion, and I felt like it didn't complicate the teach at all because it it doesn't vary from what the other scoring tiles do so much that it was like it felt out of the phase of of what already happens in RAW.
Yeah, I I agree with it. especially the way that it's it kind of just attaches to the new player board, right? That's in this edition we talked about.
Uh the tiles line up on the correct side. All these little things that were like, okay, that well that's done correct, that's done correct.
So the tiles wipe at the end of the round.
It's a few rules, but they're very clear. Uh and it kind of lines up graphically, production-wise with everything.
And it the first time I played with it,
I thought that was fun. There's a few points given here and there. I don't know if it was actually that impactful,
right?
And then another time I played and it was hugely impactful. And so I think that's the thing about this expansion. I think some people are going to like one of the things they'll notice is, "Oh, is that it?"
And they'll play with it and you might have two or three games where it's not really that impactful actually. Then you might have a game where it's
pretty darn impactful,
but doesn't necessarily feel like it was um how do I say this? swingy, right? Like, oh, it's just a luck fest. It's not that, right? If someone builds up well,
uh, gets a couple of ships and then lets other people win a few strategic auctions where they benefit from the ships activated,
that's that's on them. That's a it's an interesting Nether um, it's another interesting little like um, axis of decision making
that I think fits in to what the game already does.
Yeah. And it can lead to situations where you it it can really impact whether you're going to actually bid for a uh an offer because, you know, u there could be times where you're like, well, this is a pretty good offer for me, but I'm just not willing to take three trader tiles based on what other players around the table may have. And so, they're not directly negative to you. As a matter of fact, you know, they're going to give you one point each tile when you win that initial bid. Um, but you can potentially be really benefiting other players more. So, it does add a little bit of a twist in evaluating the the market at any given time. There's 20 of these tiles.
Yeah.
That that you add into the general tile bag. And that number to me at first thought like, okay, well, that's not a whole lot of those. But you're right in that depending upon I've had games similar to you're saying where the just the timing that they came out or maybe if they were like heavier in the third epoch and you only only had a couple in the first two, they're not going to be terribly impactful like you know likely. But if they come out early and you see a steady distribution, it really can change it. So yeah, not swingy, but it can some games you'll you'll feel the impact of it more than others.
Yeah. So at the end of the day, it kind of becomes this weird thing where
are we going to recommend it or not?
Yeah.
So we said sometimes it's like barely impactful, other times it is pretty, you know, pretty significantly impactful.
Um and and maybe you could argue in the same way that sometimes the god tiles in a game of raw sometimes they're used
with utmost trickery and and such excitement. Other times none come out until near the end of a round and someone goes, "Oh, it's just two points." Right. So, I think it kind of fits in with with what's in there. Not everything feels exciting every single game.
Yeah.
But it's just one more thing that fits in pretty nicely, pretty seamlessly.
Yeah. Okay. So, it's a good question. I guess I'll take the mantle first and and and talk about whether I'm recommending it or not. So, um, the bottom line is that I still feel like RAW does not need an expansion and I will never push to include the expansion if people would want to play just base game RAW. Okay. I I I think that RAW pretty much as it is is a is a really good package, but I also will likely never argue against the addition of it.
Yeah. And I think to me that is pretty high praise because again in my favorite game of all time if somebody at the table or if several people at the table are like I really want to play with this new expansion to me it doesn't diminish my enjoyment of the game whatsoever. It doesn't it's not needed but it certainly isn't detracting. And so for that I'm going to go an 8.5. I think it's excellent. I think it's excellent and unnecessary is that I mean that's really how I feel. It's ex excellent but not essential. If you've played RAW a lot and you want a little tweak every once in a while, this is done really well. It fits in seamlessly really with the game. And so what it is I think is excellent. It's going to be up to you whether you decide you need a little bit more in your games of RAW or not. I agree with you pretty much on all fronts. I'm giving this an 8.5 as well because I thoroughly enjoy it. I think this is a great expansion. I think it's excellent. I think it's fantastic that
if you have this in your copy and you have those ship tiles, the trader tiles mixed in.
Yeah,
you don't need to go through and sort them out. You can teach this game to new players with them in there. It's just one little difference. Part of the joy of RAW for me is that it's a game that people within their first play, within a, you know, maybe two or three auctions, they go,
I see what this game is serving up,
and I'm going to start spamming this when I have low tiles or I'm going to let things build up when I have high tiles, when I have this mix. You people catch on to it really quick.
People catch on to how the traders work really quick. Mhm.
So for, you know, my personal copy, it's one of those things where
I'll have it mixed in and I, you know, I don't feel the need to remove it for certain groups, put it back in for others.
And I really like playing with it because it is a another unique little set collection thing. That timing of it can be so delicious. Other times, someone buys a few ships early in a round and early in an epoch and then no more come out and everyone goes point and laugh at Chris. Haha. Right. And that's kind of what RAW is about to do.
Yeah, it is.
So, yeah, I think it's great.
If you're getting new into the game, you don't need it, you know, maybe maybe play several games without it, throw it in, or if you buy them both, whatever. You're in for a great experience either way. I think it's excellent.
Yeah. And we didn't really touch on uh the uh components, but there's not a lot of components in it, but what's there is really great. So, that I think helps as well. Uh it looks seamlessly aesthetically and mechanically. All right, there you go. That's going to do it for Raw Traders. I'm Mike Delisio.
And I'm Chris Ye.
And um have fun sailing down the Nile. Maybe trade once or twice. Why not? It can't hurt.
Could have hurt a little,
I guess. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.