Mercurial: Alchemia Review - Collect, Brew & Win
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco and today I'm going to be reviewing Mercurial Alchemia from Hyper Elixir. This is a prototype all rules and components with exchange and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. And I'm going to start by saying this is not going to be a full how to play. My my reviews never are full how to plays, but they usually do cover like 95% of what you need to do. Today I'm going to cover like 20% of what you need to do. I will say there's a fantastic uh how to play and playthrough over on Before You Play. Highly recommend checking that out if you want to get a full sense of the game. Uh, for me, I'm going to try to give you a general sense of what the game is, so at least you get that short overview pitch. And then from there, diving into my general thoughts on the experience. And the reason I'm not doing a full everything is the game. The core game structure is actually very intuitive and very simple, but there are a lot of small details that take a little bit more time to wrap your head around. So, I'm going to go over the generalities, but not try to get into all the ins and outs. With that said, what is Mercurial Alchemia? Well, it's a deck building, worker placement, potion brewing game. That's the core idea. Deck building, worker placement, potion brewing. You're going to be taking a worker. Worker placement might be a bit of a stretch. You only have the one worker, but it is nonetheless to an extent a worker placement game. But let's start with what you're trying to do and then work our way into the mechanics. What you're trying to do is you're trying to brew potions. You're going to have your own little potion board. I'm going to bring this up over here. This takes up a lot of table space. Looks beautiful on the table. But over here, we have our potion brewing board. Throughout the course of the game, you're going to have the opportunity to infuse ingredients into your potions. So, for example, let's
pretend I've bought this card from the card market and right now I'm trying to infuse it. I'm not getting into how you get to infusing it, but let's say pretend that we're infusing this potion. You're going to look at the things on the side. You're going to put it over here. This is your potion spot. You're going to look at the various elements and materials. You're going to move that element that way towards that icon. And we're going to move these ones over here again towards their respective icons on this potion brewing board. As you move these markers to the left or to the right, well, the left or the right. As you move them one side or the other, eventually you're going to butt up against various higher numbers because you're going to do is you're going to look at them and say, "Oh, if I were to brew this potion right now, I would get three shells over here. That's the currency of the game. Two points, four shells, one point, one shell, and one point." So, you're going to get all those benefits. Let's go ahead and add in another shell on this side because I want to show you something else about how this works. And now we get another shell over there. In addition to that, you're going to look at which side is stronger. In this case, we have three elements on this side and only one on this side, which means we're going to get a three shell bonus. 1 2 3 for leaning into a particular side. There we go. We got a bunch of shells, which helps us to continue to play our engine.
And we got some points over there, which points are going to help us well win the game. That's what you're trying to do. You're trying to infuse cards into your potion in order to brew those potions and then get shells to continue your engine and points to win the game. the entire game comes down to trying to successfully brew the best potions. Now, how you do that is where we're going to work our way back into the mechanics of the game. That's where it goes into a deck building worker placement game, which you're going to start with a standard deck. That standard deck is going to have a bunch of fun cards, but it's also going to have some negative cards. These cards over here, you can be adding them through your game throughout them as you play. But in general, these cards when played have a mandatory effect that they will increase your blight. Plus, they're worth a negative point. Increasing your blight means moving your marker over here. And whenever you brew, you're going to get the effects on this marker as well. So you are trying I should realize so you don't see it over here. You're going to be moving your marker over here as you go up this track. And whenever you brew, you get the effect to the right of that marker as well, which means you are constantly trying to manage your blight as you play. There's bad cards. This is a deck building game. What would it be without a few bad cards that you have to that you have to purge or weed from your deck? So now you have understand the basic concept. Let's go back to the structure of the game. The structure of the game is nicely laid out on your individual playerboard, walking you through what you do each round. The first thing you're going to do is place your worker out. Now, technically, the first thing you do is you play cards.
This is structured to be at the end of the round, though. You play the cards at the end of the round, preparation for the next round. But, you're going to start the game by having a bunch of played cards. The way that's going to look is you're going to draw your your hand. You have a hand of four cards. For example, these four cards over here. You're going to play them and you're going to deal with the effects on the left left bottom corner. So, for example, here we have that blight. We're going to move our blight marker up one because we have that blight card. That's a mandatory effect. Then we have two draw effects. So we can draw more cards helping us play more cards. Then we can play these over here. These two cards will help us roll our dice and that will give us various elements. I got I got void which is not going to help me. We get these various elements you can utilize for a variety of effects. And this one over here basically activates my familiar. You're going to have a character that you get at the beginning of the game as well as a familiar and that let me activate my familiar's effect. There's a little icon. This card always refers to whatever your familiar is in its current state. I say current state because you can upgrade it. When you're done playing cards, you're going to go to the worker placement phase, which is where you basically take your worker, you take your person, let's grab our person over here, and you're going to place it out onto one of the five zones. The five zones are the four zones on the board over here. And then the last zone is this tower, which indicates you're going to be taking a brewing your potion turn. So, we're going to take our worker, we're going to put into one of the zones over here, and that's going to allow us to take effects, both a day effect as well as a night effect as we move into the day and night phases. So, as we move over here, we're going to take a day effect, doing whatever that effect is going to be. That's usually going to be a combination of drawing cards over here. Let's refill the market. You're going to have the opportunity to buy cards from the
market. You're going to have the opportunities to get more of the various resources of the game. These guys over here are incredibly powerful, incredibly helpful for a variety of effects. You have the ability to upgrade your income marker. So, you have all these various effects. You get more dice. You can gather more dice because dice are going to be incredibly helpful. Having only two is a good start. It's not going to be where you want to end the game. And so you take a day action over here. This is where I'm not getting into the weeds of things, but there's a lot of sharing going on in this game. When you go to the same spot as others, you're going to share benefits. But when you go to different spots as others, you have the opportunity to pay to take their action. So there's going to be little costs over here where you can pay to take the action someone else did. That's going to go into how much you get done on a turn. Then you go to the night phase where you're going to take the night action. Those often involve either moving your blight marker back or paying for an additional effect, getting more cards, infusing more cards, get purging cards from your deck, bumping up on the track.
You have a bunch of effects you can take on the night action. And you can spend dice over here in order to double those actions. So day actions have a place you can spend to take someone else's day action. And night actions have a tuning where you can spend to double your own night action. That's going to be the structure of a turn. You're going to go through the night phase, do all of that. Now, if you if you did brew, you're going to skip all of the day and the night stuff, and instead, you're just going to brew your potion. So, you're going to go ahead and brew the potion and you're going to go through the sequence of taking the cards that you play that round. At first, it's going to be a maximum of five. As you upgrade the game, you can do your entire hand, whatever you have, which usually isn't five, but if you have those draw effects, you can get higher than that. There's like one time I had like 13 cards on the table. It's pretty insane. I did not take a brew turn. It would have been great if I did. longer story anyways, but basically you're going to brew your potion, adding the cards to your potion, infusing those cards and also having an opportunity to infuse the various dice if they are on a side that's going to be helpful for you. And then you're going to go ahead and move up on this track where you're going to get various benefits as you move up until you eventually get to 25 and endame. That's the core structure of this game. It is a worker placement game where you're building a deck, using those decks to infuse your potions, brewing those potions in order to gain points with a whole lot of other things that I did not get into. And when I say a whole lot of other things, I mean a whole lot of other things. There's going to be these cards over here, which are awesome. I love these cards. These let you draw a card and get a shell. So, they just replace themselves while getting you income. And then you can cash them in later to go ahead and copy the infuse effects of another card.
There's going to be these goals over here. These goals, you can be drawing these goals as you move up the income track. And those goals give you other ways to score points. There's whole ways to play the game. There's asymmetric player boards. There's variable locations. All these locations over here, they're all double-sided, so you have even more variety to the various locations, both the day and the night side that are in play. There's a lot of other things going on this game past the core general structure that I've told you. But with that, you hopefully know enough that I can dive into my thoughts, my opinions, and uh give you a general sense of where I am with this one. There's a lot to like here. There's things I'm not as much of a fan of. There's a lot to like here. This it feels okay. The game is very satisfying. Before we get into the satisfying part, let's start with the the art, the production. The the art looks great both on the box, on the table. The card art looks amazing. I love all the various ingredients. Those look absolutely beautiful. Uh the components look incredible. Again, this is a prototype, but the components as they are look absolutely incredible. Like, if you told me this is a final game, I would absolutely believe it. It's I would hunch believe this is a final game. It just looks incredibly premium in every capacity of it. The game play The gameplay is very rewarding with Cavish.
We'll get into the things I don't like later, but the gameplay is very rewarding. Now, it starts off slow, and it does, we'll get into that what I don't like, but it does start off slow, but once you ramp up over here, working your way towards the ideal potion is a lot. The deck building really matters as you go through these cards over here, as you try to figure out which cards you want to add to your deck and how it's going to play out because we didn't talk about it, but this potion over here, it can be used to buy extra actions, but it can also be flipped to reverse the direction of one of the materials that you're infusing. And this one can also be used to buy actions or it can be flipped to double an element that you're infusing. That means as you gather more and more of these, the cards you buy and how they feed into how your potion is going to work, as well as the actions you take, as well as how you handle your blight, it starts off a little slow, but as you ramp up, it starts to feel like you have a lot of control over the type of potion you're going to be brewing and working your way up those tracks as far as possible. Now, you do need to be careful. Brew too often. The problem with brewing is every time you brew, you advance your base blight marker, which is where your blight marker resets when you're done brewing. And that means later in the game, you're going to have it up here, which means you're going to be resetting directly into negative effects, making it harder and harder to manage your blight. So, you can't constantly keep brewing small potions, as much as it might be tempting to do so because of the ease of those quick early income and points. And money is going to be tight in the game at first. You're going to be able to work up your engine again, but at first, money is going to be tight. and trying to figure out the actions you take and how to spend those resources is going to be so key, which is why brewing rapidly early on feels compelling, but again, that blight mark is going to move up. So, you have to balance all of that. You have to balance
the cards you take. The actions you take, every action is so satisfying. I love weeding cards in games. One of my favorite things to do in any deck building game is to weed cards from that game. And they give you an action to do so. Pay pay shells, weed, and then go ahead and move up a blight. That's amazing. That's incredible. you can start building the perfect deck as soon as you possibly can, which is again incredible. It's exactly what I want out of a game experience, except there's so much other stuff you need to do. You want those cards, those cards, getting a good deck early on, every time you shuffle, you're going to be advancing your blight. That's one of the structures of the game. You get income, not in each round. You get income when you shuffle your deck, but you also get blight when you shuffle your deck. So, there's a lot to balance there as far as padding out your deck sooner rather than later, so you're not constantly reshuffling into a bunch of mediocre cards. So, you want to buy cards early on, but you also want to get these guys over here. These, again, getting a good supply of these early on is not just essential for brewing the best potions.
It's also essential because they're often a way to pay them by flipping them in order to take additional actions if you want to get more done in the game. Sometimes giving up getting a few cards to get another one of these so you can later trade that in on a repeated basis to get more cards. It opens up the doors for you on a serious level. And so there's so many decisions you're making as far as what it is you're trying to do and how that's going to work towards either the potion you're currently brewing or the actions you're taking. It is incredibly satisfying to start off. You start off with two dice and one of each of these. And it's incredibly satisfying to then later in the game have like five dice, three of these, three of these, and be working your way towards a lot of flexibility every single time you brew. Not to mention the improved card effects. So this is a game where it just gives you ways to upgrade. The entire game is structured around how can we make you feel like you can do more because everything you do will help you do more. It's a question of which lanes you're going to work your way towards. And so we have a game that gives you a compelling tableau to work on to build. It has a lot of actions to take. It has sharing actions which gives you a decision as well. Again, I didn't go into all the details of it's called the handshake. When you go to a location, you share actions, you get benefits, but there's a lot of different things that are all going to make you feel better as you go into it. And that's before we even get into like the asymmetric characters. this again the the the advanced modes, the asymmetric characters, I highly recommend not playing with them the first game because again while the core gameplay structure is very simple, the nuances of each individual thing is where there's just a lot of information. But as you dive into those things, the game really opens up even further, giving you more flexibility. Like even the size of the play, there's a lot going on in this
game and it's all incredibly rewarding to do. The things I don't like in the game, the biggest thing I'm going to have is it's a slow start. It is a very slow start and that to me I love the endg game of this but it's not a short game and the early game feels slow. It feels like it takes time to build your way up and the first game first game who cares. That's fine. That's not a big deal. Your first game is is is fine. But as you play it more going through that same starting loop at that slower pace every single time you play, it's not something that's quite as satisfying because you're no longer in that learning phase. You're in the I want to get to the cool stuff phase. And so this game, I think, really could benefit from a jumping into it kind of aspect. Something that accelerates the early game to get to the action you want as fast as possible. There is a lot of potential for simultaneous play, which is a good thing, but there's a lot of things that you have to do sequentially when you kind of small details that will slow things down and that can overall slow the experience. This is not a shorter game. It can certainly get faster as you get more familiar with it, but it's definitely not a shorter game.
There's also some small elements of the game that are, how do I put that? that are not not as fun or not as rewarding. And the two things I'm going to point I'm going to call out specifically are going to be sometimes the market doesn't have the cards you want. And in this game, there's no such thing as a good dead card. Dead cards work against you working your way back. These tracks over here, they have competing sides. So, if you infuse a card that doesn't help you, not only is it slowing down your game, it might actually hurt you. So, you have to be very, very careful about the cards you buy to add to your engine. Not that you have to infuse them to be clear, but you really want specific cards. It's not like, oh, every card is a good card. No, there are cards that will not help you in this game. And so, you really have to think carefully about what you buy. And if the market doesn't have what you want, that just is what it is. It's like some games have that rotating card market, and you can always make use of something. This is not one of those games. So, when the market has cards you want, awesome, amazing. When the market doesn't, that eliminates some of the core actions you can take on your turn.
Or even worse, sometimes you go to buy cards and other players buy cards first and then by the time it gets to your turn, you don't have the cards you want and you wasted your action. So, well, not fully wasted. Usually, usually there's a way you can actually proxy something else. Depends on the uh side of the board you're playing. But either way, it sometimes you just don't have good cards, and good cards are essential. So, that's not a good feelood moment. I will say the card market does clear at points. So, it's not like the card market is stagnant, but any individual turn can have those moments. And lastly, I'll say that when you get to the end of a track, on the one hand, it can be incredibly satisfying. On the other hand, sometimes you're building your way towards a deck and the way the cards come out, you get to the end and further materials or elements are wasted. And again, depending on the quantity you have wasted, that can also be like, okay, well, I maxed out the track, which is what I was aiming for, but now I have all this wastage, which is not as efficient, which I I mean, I want to max out the track because that's where you get the most points, but you you kind of want to balance it, but it can sometimes be a little less of a feel-good moment there. Overall, I really think Mercur Alamia gives you a lot of satisfying moments, and it gives you a lot of gameplay ways to adjust the gameplay to make it more nuanced and variable. a lot nuance to make it to make it more variable to give you more things to do, more challenges, uh more variability to the experience. You also have different uh you know, characters and and familiars and all of that stuff.
There's a lot of satisfying things going on here. My biggest complaint is that it does run a little long for what you're getting out of the experience, and I wish there was a way to ramp it up. Right now, it's easily a two-hour game, closer to two and a half, depending on your group, of course. uh if it can get to that hour and a half point, this is gives you a very this gives you a lot of things that are incredibly satisfying if it were a game that's an hour and a half, but I haven't gotten to that point yet. So, overall final thoughts wise, I'm going to be coming in at a four. Now, it's a four that I I almost want to go higher and I almost want to go lower. The reason I want to go low almost is because like there's the slowness to the start of the game and how much time you get out of the experience does make me almost want to drop it down a bit. But on the other hand, there's a lot of satisfying things going on here. There's so much fun to the experience. And again, the the asymmetric characters alone give you so much room to play with how those characters completely change up the game, as well as, of course, well, completely change the game, change up the way you're going to interact with the game, as well as the various modes.
I have not played with all the um all the advanced modes yet. And so, overall, I I'm coming in at a four for right now, a four out of five. It does feel I'm I'm calling it a review, but it does feel almost like still like I'm in that fleshing it out phase, still playing it out to see where it can go. Uh, I will say there's a lot here to like. There's some small things that slow down the experience, but overall it's a very solid, very satisfying game. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out uh Dune Imperium. It feels that there's definitely a core amount of DNA between the work of placement, between the deck building, uh, between the familiar and you have your card that activates a familiar. It feels like there's some DNA of Dune Imperium in this one. And if you want a potion brewing game that is much more on the lighter side, check out um, oh my gosh, Quacks of Cutber. Check out Quacks of Cleber if you want a totally different game about brewing potions in a way that will genuinely and completely blow up in your face. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Trac from Board Gameco. Hope you found this review helpful and as always I hope you have a good