Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Queen's Dilemma: My Favorite Mechanism

Transcript 6:37

Hey, I'm Jimmy from Stonemaier Games, and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in The Queen's Dilemma, a new legacy game, a sequel to one of my favorite all-time legacy games, The King's Dilemma. I'm going to show you an image that is not a spoiler for the game at all. This is just the setup that you do it before you even start the campaign. This is the game on my table. Uh we had the full six players. The game recommends that you play with five or six players. We had the full six. And I want to say as right off the bat um so I guess I I'll I'll say this first. The King's Dilemma is a game about uh voting. You're voting on different decisions that lead a kingdom, and based on how you vote, there's a tug-of-war element that determines who like does better in each individual game. And also, oftentimes you're adding cards to the deck that you're pulling these decisions from. So you're changing the shape of the kingdom, the types of decisions that you can even make later in the campaign. The Queen's And that is my favorite thing about the King's Dilemma, how simplified and streamlined that was, and how impactful our decisions were on the shape of the kingdom.

The Queen's Dilemma retains that, but it adds this map, and I think it's delightful. I think the map is a fantastic addition to the game, because it gives you something beautiful to look at and kind of plot over as you advise the queen and try to run the kingdom while the queen is away. Opposed to in The King's Dilemma, all you had in the middle of the board was a rather bare-bones tug-of-war track. And so the tug-of-war track is much more subdued now, and the focus is on this map. And each player, at least in the six-player game, has influence and kind of control over two of these regions. I I care to about two of these regions more than other players. I get income from that region. I care about what's happening there. Like we had some pretty key decisions happen in one of my regions in the first game.

And I cared about those those decisions because that was my region. So I love how much focus is on the map. There are also buildings that can go on the map, so you can improve your income or kind of change literally change the shape of the kingdom by putting stickers on the map in your area based on things that happen. So, I really like the central focus on the map. I think that's a really clever addition. I also like similarly, I like that the tug of war track is a little bit more subdued. It's only three tracks now. I think there were maybe six in the original King's Dilemma. And let's see if I can zoom in enough to actually see it. Yeah, so one is tradition versus progress, one is uh something versus diplomacy, force versus diplomacy, and then order versus liberty. Um and when you use this track like it it based on how a vote goes, you would shift some of these tokens to the left or right. And also to kind of keep track of how the different votes went, you put little tokens on top of So, if like a vote goes in a way that moves order moves force to the left or moves it towards force, then you would not only move shift that token, but also put a special token on force. The game kind of remembers how many votes went one way versus the other because that tug of war track could just go back and forth over the course of the game. So, I like that element. I like that the game remembers that over the course of each individual session and that there are fewer tracks on the tug of war track. I think that's important to keep in mind in games. It's good for me to remember this as well in in a game that I'm working on that has some tracks like this.

The last thing that I Well, I want to mention two things that I'm a little bit on the fence about. One thing I appreciate, but I am on the fence about a little bit, in that during the voting, when you whenever you're voting in the Queen's Dilemma, uh you can either vote or you can kind of raise your vote or stay if you've already voted, or you can pass. You can only pass if you haven't voted at all. So, it it just had the option to pass. And when when pass, there are a couple of different options that you can choose from. You can claim the moderator token. You can claim your share of uh the force that's currently or not the force, but the the power that's currently in the kingdom the the the main area of the kingdom, not the whole kingdom, but part of the kingdom. Or you can use a special action a special bonus action on some cards that will be on the table.

Those are a little hard to read from across the table. And adding those extra layers to passing uh can add a little time, a little bit of complexity. Overall, I think I like it. The part that I'm still a little bit on the fence about, I know I'm I'm sharing an opinion here, is that one of my favorite things about the the King's Dilemma is that the games were even at five players at most really around 45 minutes. So, it meant that every time we got we got together to play, we were playing three games of this over 3 hours or even less, usually around 3 hours. And so, it meant that we were able to get through the campaign in about I think it was five sessions for us, which is a reasonable amount to ask adults to get together to to commit to and finish for a campaign game.

In The Queen's Dilemma, our first session took 3 hours, and it was a learning session, but it was just one game out of 17. There is no way. It is impossible that we can get together 17 times to play this game. So, I am really hoping that that was just a learning game and that subsequent sessions will be I I know they won't be 45 minutes. The game just there's enough added to the game including these past actions that uh that make the game longer, but I'm really hoping subsequent games will be closer to an hour. I hope we can get through them in an hour, and that way maybe we can get through at at least get through two in a session. Maybe sometimes we can get through three in a session. Uh so, I'm on the fence about that part so far, and I I I am hoping that that evolves over the course of the campaign. I hope we can just jump right into the next game. And part of it, too, is that there's a lot to do after you end the game. Um not a lot of cleanup per se, but like there's a checklist of a long checklist of things that you need to do at the end of the game. And a fairly long checklist of things that you need to do the beginning of the game as well. Anyway, I will hold judgment. I am very excited to play this game cuz really it it is The King's Dilemma was one of my favorite legacy games of all time. So, I'm excited to see how this unfolds. And hopefully around five or six remaining sessions.

We will see about that. I'd love to hear your thoughts, your non-spoiler thoughts about the structures uh implemented into the core of The Queen's Dilemma. Or if you have any thoughts about what I mentioned here, any other games that kind of do these type of do similar things as what I just discussed, um I'm happy to discuss them in the comments below. Thanks.

Progress saved