Skip to main content
Loading video...

All True Believers - TRUST NO ONE!

Transcript 13:31

All true believers. That is the game that we're talking about today. Ryan and I have it set up here on the table. Uh, this is not exactly a two-player game, but it can play all the way up to 10 players.

Yeah, it's a social deduction game. And like a lot of these social deduction games, there's some benefit to having more players, but what you will have is a number of true believers, which in our game, David is going to be a true believer, and you have some number of defectors. Of course, like, you know, in this style of game, that number is going to change based on player count.

And it's secret.

And it's secret. So, what you're essentially setting up is a little bit of a twist on the formula. We're actually the one team is the cultists, the true believers, and the other team is the defectors trying to kind of like subvert the cult from inside. So, you don't have secret cultists in this game. You have secret like anti-cultists.

are the true believers.

Actually. So. Uh, yeah, a little bit on the theme. They say that this is a game, a social deduction game of deceit, uh, and tax evasion.

Yeah, you're you're you're a cult. You you're a cult. I mean, there's you are. That's that's the way it works.

You're hiding behind some tax rules so that you can operate as a cult. Uh, but like Ryan said, we are the true believers. There are some twists in this game though, and we'll kind of give you a brief description of how the game plays. We're not going to give you a full how to play, but we will give you that. But, there are some unique differences. And one of the big differences is right from the start, you're all going to start with a disciple card. This is a pretty big part of the game, and there's a bunch of different disciple cards. You each get with sort of like not a level one, but one that only costs one at the beginning. But, a lot of the other ones cost more. Uh, but you get those, and the first phase is to go around the table and use them. Yeah. Uh, so, these change things up. Uh, and I won't get into like the specific ones yet because you'll need to know a little bit more about the game and some of the other components before we do. Uh, but it is an interesting thing because some of them can very, very much they're costly, but they can have huge impact on the game where it's like, "Forget all the deduction going on this round. The round is over. These guys win." Well, and a lot of these cards are used to further your side's agenda. So, we we set up the idea that you've got two sides working together, but these are all dealt out in secret.

And the defectors know who they are the defectors are. There's that moment at the table, everyone closes their eyes, you look, you make eye contact, whatever. The defector's job is to tank the game. You want to make sure the game fails. And a big way that you're doing that is by using these cards in a smart way at the right time. But ideally, you're doing so in such a way that it isn't like fully obvious that you're tanking the game. That's tricky. It is tricky. There There's a balance you have to walk where you want to do enough to to make you lose the game without making it very clear because there is a part of the game where you're going to be kind of relying on other players to help you out. And you know, you want to make sure that you're engaged, that people will trust you. So, like you said, some of these are really, really powerful. And some of them can very much break the game, but they might also expose you as being a defector if you use them the wrong way. Yeah. So, after that phase, you're going to go into the mission phase. This is the meat and potatoes of this game. You see, we have this sort of pyramid of cards out here. These are the missions, and we're going to start on the bottom row and go row by row up until the end of the game.

On the mission, there's going to be one player at the table who is the eye. They're going to have this really cool tablet, if you will, that's used to pass to their hand. The hand is sort of like, you know, the hand of the king. It's the hand of the eye.

round. For that particular round, the eye is going to rely on the hand to give them virtues that they're looking for. Now, the trick there is you don't know what virtues you're looking for until you've chosen the eye. So, this is where or the hand. This is where all that conversation starts at the table where you're like, "Can I trust you?" And at the beginning of the game, you don't have much information to go on, of course. So, you really just kind of go, "I guess I'll pick that person." But, that is where the real game begins because if they picked a defector or the true believer, that's when you have to start to behave and start operating in a way that you think might lay the groundwork for winning the game.

Yeah, and a round kind of if you can consider it a a round is to flip over one of these cards. And each one of these cards is going to require one of two virtues. For example, to blackmail former members of the cult, we either need a prosperity or justice card. And those virtues are cards in your hand. Every one of these cards is a particular virtue. Now, these cards are multi-use. David mentioned that there's a cost to these disciples. The cost is discarding these cards. But, you want to make sure you keep some because when it's your turn to be the eye and you're picking someone to be the hand, if you want to hand me the plate, I'll I'll Hand me the plate. I'll show you. You're going to take two cards from your hand, place them face down in secret, and ideally, if David and I are both on the good side, I've put either a prosperity or justice card down.

Or maybe I didn't. He did put a justice card in here. But, he also put a dominion card in here. Now, am I a defector or am I a true believer? A true believer is going to go, "Oh, justice. He did it. Justice. We got it. That's it. It works. We completed that mission successfully." So, you're going to put it with the blue side up. But, if I'm a defector, maybe, or if he didn't give me the thing because he's a defector, I'm going to say, "Well, he didn't give me anything." Uh so, I'm going to put this upside down. He gave me dominion. And you put it sort of with the red corner up, signifying that it was a failed mission by the true believers. Now, this is effectively a round of the game. And of course, this is going to involve a lot of conversation and accusations around the table as well.

fails.

No, I didn't. I gave you a justice card and you didn't pick it, you know? And then the other players at the table are trying to decide who to believe. And that's why at the very beginning of the game, like David said, you don't have a lot of information, but now everyone at the table knows that one of the two of us failed. Either I failed to give David a success card or I did give David one and he didn't choose it or maybe I spent too many of my cards playing disciples and I didn't even have a win. And we might both be good, but I was forced to pass him two fails just because I didn't have another option. And it's up to you to convince other players at the table of the truth or what you want them to believe the truth is.

Exactly. And a couple unique things are going to happen as you play the game. So just so you know how it goes, we're going to continue on all of the missions in the first row. And once the row is done, there's a few different sort of win conditions. Uh it can't end in a tie, but if it's not a unanimous, like if if they win everything, the true believers get two tokens on that row. That's two tokens towards all the tokens you want to have by the end of the game. And basically majority wins in that case. If they didn't get all of them, they got some of them, they'd get one. And likewise, if the defectors got more, they'd get a token. Or if they lost all, which would be tough.

It would be It would be tough to to make sure that you lose all four in the first round.

If you did that, I'm guessing someone's going to know who at least a couple of the defectors are at the table.

be the strategy you're going for.

It could be. It could be. But you're going to get tokens, then you're going to go to the second row. But before you go to the second row, after the end of each row, you're going to have a crisis of faith. This is yet another time at the table where everyone's going to close their eyes, the defectors will open their eyes, and then they're going to This is interesting because they can't really communicate with one another, But one of the defectors has to like very quietly pick up one of those cards and these cards do a bunch of different things. They can be helpful, they can be not so helpful, but they're going to place that in front of a player at the table. And then you everyone opens their eyes when everyone is back in the seated position and this one here says doubt. You cannot share another shame another player this round. We haven't talked about shame. But everyone has a shame card. It's about the same size as a virtue card. But these cards can be played at some points during the game to effectively make a player not be able to be the hand of the eye. Yeah.

Because if you start to suspect someone and you're like, oh, we don't want them to be the hand and we think the person who's the eye is a defector this round. So, hey true believers, let's place shame cards on that player. If they have three, they cannot be the hand. Yeah. Now a lot of this stuff is being used to kind of try to deduce who the defectors are. Obviously you're deducing a little bit based on whether the missions are successful or not, who's playing the shame tokens and when they're being played and who they're being played on and who's siding with who when it comes to shaming other players. These crisis of faith cards like David said, some are gooder and some are bad. If a bad one ends up on you, people might think, oh, he wouldn't give himself a bad card so maybe he's a good guy. Or a good one might end up on somebody and they say, huh. That's interesting. That was really helpful.

Right. And then being able to play these these disciple cards, some of these even let you just like flat out peek at other people's roles and then of course it's up to the rest of the table to believe you. So, all of these things are kind of being used in conjunction with trying to suss out who are the bad guys. Now, you cannot really stop a defector from getting the the plate, being the eye and handing it to

just goes around the table. But you can all kind of kind of collaborate and work together and say, we all think David's a bad guy. And if you give the plate to David, you're probably also a bad guy. And then

Well yeah, if you give

if you give them the play with the hand. So, basically, the eye is going to move clockwise around the table, but that eye is choosing a hand. Now, a couple rules. Whoever was just the hand in the last round cannot be the hand this round. That's why they have this token. So, if I have this in front of me, I'm not getting picked, which is nice, I think, from a defector standpoint, so that the true believers, if they have some trust amongst themselves, they can't just go, "Hey, let's just you and I play the rest of the game together." Right. Um but, yeah, it is a really interesting thing that again injects an opportunity for people to start throwing accusations around. Now, I did want to point out again, we already talked about these disciples. At the beginning of each row, you're going to have the opportunity to go around the table to acquire more of those disciples, but you're spending the virtues out of your hand. Now, when you spend them this way, you're not spending specific types of virtues, you're just spending them as virtue cards to meet these numbers to take these cards. The rub there is, if you don't have a lot of virtue cards in your hand ain't nobody picking you as the hand.

Correct. You could be in a situation where you have not If someone says, "Hey, pick me as the hand," and they have one card that's not a that's a kind of suspicious. So, the mechanics of this game, not only sort of these social accusations, but the mechanics of this game can certainly be manipulated to where you're like, "Hey, look. Like, I've done a really good job. I have a ton of cards here. Pick me. No matter what we get, I'll likely have what we need." Yeah, but then you're the you're the defector the whole time, and you're not going to put the good cards down. Correct. Yeah, and that's a big part like, with any social deduction game, it's very difficult for us to sit here and tell you how the strategy works. But, you'll get into that feeling of like, you know, a lot of these games, do I if I'm the bad guy, do I maybe want to help some of the early missions succeed so that I'm trustworthy? But, if you help too many missions succeed, it lowers your chance of being able to win at the end. So, that there's a balance, especially for I'll say, a lot of these games a little bit more difficult for the defectors because you have to balance a little more. The The true believers are really just trying to make sure that they don't accidentally give the plate to a defector. Like you're trying to make sure that you're passing every one of these missions, whereas the defectors are trying a little harder to make sure that they're, you know, being trusted when really they're tanking the game.

Yeah, you really have to be careful. That typical strategy that a defector or, you know, in these types of game would use where hey, I'm going to play along for a while.

Yeah. Um and I often screw that up and just keep playing along.

along for too long.

long and then like, oh, I we I'm sorry. I screwed up.

Yeah, David was the MVP for the true believers.

I would say in this game in particular, you got to be very careful about doing that because as you play the game, you run out of opportunities to turn and pivot back to like defecting and again, without necessarily being identified.

Well, yeah. And if you see here, this the setup of cards, this pyramid is how many rounds there are in the game. There's 10 rounds and if the game goes the right way, there only are going to be 10 turns. Now, if you get in a situation where there's a tie, say that the true believers won two and the defectors won two, you will deal out another one and then do another mission to break that tie. So, It can go longer.

It can go longer, but it's not maybe going to, especially when you get to the top. You have to realize like there, you know, it gets scarcer. Like these two cards here, if you're still trying to like earn trust and you accidentally pass one of those missions, Yeah.

Yeah, that, you know, you might have just sunk it for your own team.

more and more difficult and then the very top there's only one card. It's worth two tokens no matter what. So, you can kind of sling back and sort of take the lead, but it is tricky for the defectors. But that is all true believers. If you have any questions about it, please make them in the comments below. We'll get down there and answer whatever we can. Until next time, make Make everyone has fun at the table, and we'll see you then.

Progress saved