Skip to main content
Loading video...

Between Two Castles: Secrets and Soirees - Discussion

Transcript 19:12

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we are doing a no run through review for the new expansion to between two castles secrets and swags if you want to know how between two castles of mad king ludwig play you can definitely go check out the run through for that um but yeah this is an expansion sent to me by by stonemeyer um from a game that i value very very highly i absolutely love the the base game it took to me the best parts of between two cities and castle magic king ludwig and combined them and made uh a excellent combination of both while still also in my opinion allowing you to own all three but um if you don't want to know in all three i think this is the way to go to capture kind of both of those now uh yeah we've already done a discussion with the base game so secrets and soirees includes basically solo modes so two two ways to play this uh play this game solo uh i have a run through and a discussion for that so go check those out but it adds two new rooms uh secret rooms and uh activity rooms so what uh secret rooms uh pretty much all they do is they are duplicates of they have arrows on them that's all they have and they duplicate the room that they are pointed at in every way like they copy uh the the portrait or they copy yeah the the i don't know

decoration decoration they copied the scoring and they copy the room type uh so it all counts towards the bonus of three or five um in the activity rooms uh kind of imp uh take what the expansion to cities have not the expansion but what cities had where it's like hey this wants to be next to this but not next to this right um otherwise it's gonna be worth less points that's pretty much all the activity rooms do so what do you guys think of those two rooms i like um the activities room just because there's just so much room for activities oh yeah no i like them i think it's it's fun i like that the uh secret room is basically just like a and yeah because i can really help you yeah yeah and then the activities rooms are just fun yeah the activities rooms i think give you a little bit more spacial awareness uh when trying to decide how you want to actually build the castle uh which is something i liked in the between two cities um was kind of like oh man okay what we really want to get maximized points so we don't want to put this around these because it's either it only gets points for the orthogonal whereas it gets negative points if it's surrounded by anything of that type and it's it's like it's either one point per so it could be a total of four or it's just going to be one point um brett what do you think i agree um fits in just beautifully with uh the bass and adds more to think about adds more to strategize about yeah um without being overly complicated without breaking anything

and again thematically fits perfectly with both of the source materials exactly very impressive how they combine both of these into a single game right especially this expansion yeah they uh they did a fantastic job because you once you get the base or once you get the expansion uh they actually think god came with a sorting uh a tray that fits into the base game where it's all nice and snug as if it were like game trays or it's where it all just fits perfectly really glad that they brought that in because it would have been extremely annoying if you had the base game with those with the nice dividing trays and then this one just came with like bags or something i'd be like what the hell happened but nope they came with their own tray what's still extremely weird though is they didn't make the trays wide enough to hold all the new tiles so you have to weirdly kind of like organize like it's not super um user friendly because like if you want to get the new like they come with ballrooms which is what the activity rooms bring in these don't have like their own section like you have to kind of divide them and put uh you know of the regular tiles on top of them so that's just kind of weird and then and that's more of just a production standpoint and then also the uh what are these called utility uh scoring cards bonus cards uh the new ones are slightly bigger really yeah so it's that's i i hate that i absolutely hate that they're not the same size which doesn't matter if you sleeve them

but it's just annoying otherwise it i i just hate it but it's not perfect it's crap this is [ __ ] just throw the cards but yeah i mean that's pretty much all this expansion brings the the secrets and then the activities and then also there's the ballrooms which the ballrooms are pretty cool because ultimately yeah the between two castles has the semi-cooperative nature where it's like we obviously want to work together everyone in the best possible way but because if i you only ever focus on one castle then it's like oh hey 100 points three well my final score is three but the ballrooms add uh it's another type another special room type but it actually you get points based off what the other what your neighboring castles have uh which is very nice it allows you to kind of get a little bit of points off of your opponents so yeah i mean that's that's pretty much it like there's not uh really a whole lot to talk about except is this an expansion do you think should people run out and get if you like between two castles um and you've played it a few times and you're kind of like i wonder if there's anything more yeah there's more yeah i i wouldn't say unless you really love complex strategy semi-cooperative nature of the original and you really just want more of it right off the bat i'd say you

can wait on the expansion but you'll probably want to get it eventually if you play this a lot right yeah i i agree like i mean between two castles got a 10 out of 10 for me so this expansion just keeps it at that it doesn't like lower it it doesn't make the game it just gives you more of a great thing in my opinion um cat what do you think i i totally agree um it's just a just a good thing that got better basically yeah like i i really enjoy it um i don't think you should be like you know pounding down doors and like beating people up right you're not going to run to the sweet stonemeyer booth at gen con to grab this expansion yeah um but i mean like i said it also does come with a solo variant which is the initial game i mean it had a two-player variant but nothing for solo but yeah so if you want to know how that plays once again definitely go check out that run-through and discussion um but yeah i it's it's fantastic i think that i i obviously i want more like i'm kind of at this point i would love if they only supported this and expansions for it did replace castles and between two cities so then you would only just need this um because between the two uh there's this is obviously way more closer to between two cities than castles of mad king ludwig because castles has the auctioning and the price replacement uh so if anything this completely

replaces between two cities except that between two cities expansion adds goals that people are trying to compete for uh like public goals which i think that they could add to this they could honestly yeah i think just keep supporting it with different room types because the two that they added to this i think are extremely unique um and i mean not in any way like overly complex it's not like oh now that we have this tile in like oh god that changes the way the whole game is going to be played right no because you're still nothing nothing has changed fundamentally neither are they broken in that they're so valuable right the first player to get some oh this castle is fantastic beautiful yeah i gotta worry about the other one right now i gotta worry about this [ __ ] hole that that's i i it's my side project yeah exactly they like no no room is just like oh we gotta have this um now that we have the out the window tile like that copies this it's just like sometimes i mean you i will say that when you get the expansion really shuffle them together because secret rooms i mean don't do anything for you if you have nothing to copy true um usually i when secret rooms are valuable is whenever you kind of already have your castle somewhat built maybe like halfway uh through the first round then it's like cause like if it's like oh yeah i guess i'll copy this

outdoors like all right we're getting no points for that because you never know what the tiles are going to be like yeah and my initial worry with having more of these tiles especially one like i said that is kind of useless uh is that it didn't change you don't have any more rounds you don't draw any more tiles like the game is played exactly the same now you just have more in in the in the pile um but of course they gave you in the expansion it wasn't just those two new rooms like you got more of the regular rooms as well but but yeah the other thing that might be annoying to some people is that they obviously didn't reprint the sleeping rooms to take into consideration the activity room right like so that's not printed on any of the sleeping rooms yeah it but there is a section in the rule book where it just says hey sleeping rooms now i have to have six out of these seven yeah so instead of the only six it's just now you activity rooms count yeah so so yeah that's something to keep in mind um so with that being said uh let's talk about something that they promoted in their uh rulebook which is the app which i did not know was a thing the mad king stewards is a fan made app available on ios that is very helpful for end game scoring what do you guys think of the app first of all five dollars yep it's a five dollar app i i'd say it was helpful i'd say it did not replace scoring by hand no as it was supposed to

yeah yeah yeah i mean obviously i just let you do it because you know i mean it is i i would i would that would they uh so really what the app is is yeah it's a glorified scoring mechanism you it kind of scans and keeps and keeps track of all the tiles and then you select oh do you have any of these royal attendants and do you have any of these cards stuff that it can't scan easily right uh and i can't score one room type because that room depends on the other two other yeah yeah that's yeah so i mean essentially what you have to do right now at this point i mean who knows the the designer um of the app might fix it but as of right now you uh it does not take into consideration the secret rooms it can it takes into consideration the activity rooms uh so it does include the like the expansion but for some reason the secrets uh weren't being recognized um which i mean i guess makes sense but i even think so i mean i'm not an app designer but i have a programmer and i'm like you can scan for that logo or that color yeah and you can see the direction air was pointing true and then you know what that is so you can duplicate that right we got to be fairly easy way to do it it just was an oversight or we won't use an app right right which i mean there's no instructions on the app it just says hey point at the throne room and then kind of go from there uh and which i will say i i like i'd rather it have me manually input the royal

attendance and the cards than trying to scan it because that would just be annoying it's quicker to do that and even though when we were using it it didn't count the secret rooms it was still way quicker than having this waste of [ __ ] paper like these are such a waste to sit here and for one thing be like okay how many food rooms you got cat yes yeah zero okay this whole line is wasted because you don't have food rooms and then adding it up and then being like all right 62. okay that's it for that sheet of paper yeah um all we had to do was figure out where it was wrong and add those numbers that was it yeah because i mean this one it said it was like 60 or something and then it was just like oh it didn't count and you could see it on the app which is nice oh hey did it did it score that because we looked at the um what was that the dumb waiter and it said zero and it's like oh okay well like so we'll just that's not right okay and then so we just added it up because we and i think it was it was missing 12 points yeah which was i mean this is a significant amount uh because i made this castle 72. yeah but it took us less than a minute to rescore yes versus the versus we probably would still be scoring yeah like exactly and you're not wasting wasting paper you're not wasting time yeah it's it was really quick just to be like okay and it keeps track of all of them like in in the order so the app is extremely nice uh is it worth five dollars i don't know i play a lot maybe which i i mean

lately we've been playing this game a lot yeah right uh just as a time saver yeah it i mean it is a nice app it's nicely designed it's beautiful graphics yeah i mean it's and yeah with with the way that these score pads work and especially if you're playing solo um yeah it's you waste even more paper like whenever last time we played i took one sheet and i just divided each section because no one's gonna have 15 food rooms and if they do then they're not getting the rest of these so you waste the entire sheet i would say just for the five dollars but also thinking of the time it took us to figure out our scoring for all three of ours we could have just scored one manually yeah so i think it's worth it um you know if your collection's not super big or if you just really like this game and you play it you know frequently it was a big help right yeah i i agree not an official stonemeyer games product so i mean obviously it is in the rulebook which is kind of neat that stone meyer is like hey they gave a shout out to it and didn't probably didn't pay the guy to but who cares i mean why would they pay him he's charging five dollars for a [ __ ] nap not even full-fledged games or like through the ages is even i don't even think that's five bucks yeah um although they're starting to full-fledged right games are creeping up so so yeah i mean then you just kind of go out like like that i took off the uh the the token to see if it accounted for

that oh that's a thought um if it actually reads the type in the arrow it did the token was throwing it off oh so the requirement of the rules is not a required app interesting right yep so but that's fine yeah because uh it is yep yep it is literally right there and it shows on like 68 so we must have added incorrect somewhere interesting how now we now we trust the app i know right but it's it's less likely to make math mistakes than we are that that's true so that's okay so hey these tokens that you're supposed to put to remind you when you if you use the app take them off then take them off because uh because we there we go there we go then you just hit the circle and then there's that and then none of that no there we go i see it just uh i'll be using that one too yeah that's why so yeah it's still 72 but still yeah the tokens that you use for the app or for the expansion to remind you of what the secret rooms are mimicking if you're going to use the app take them off and then it takes you literally i mean i just scanned it twice in like two seconds just so yeah now it's worth more no yes now i will say it is worth the five dollars at least for me if you are playing this game a lot if you break it out every once in a while i wouldn't say it's worth it right or if you really like doing math by the

way yeah if you're really into meticulously counting every single tile then it could be for you but with that being said um on a scale of one to ten what would you give secrets and soirees brett i'm on the spot yep yep it better be a high number four that's not high out of three i have a weird ranking system one is garbage two is average three is great phenomenal and four is rotten again yeah four is bad five is average six is great as an expansion i'm gonna say ten yeah i mean it should it is exactly what it should be and nothing more and nothing less yeah yeah i i absolutely agree i would also agree yeah cool so that is our thoughts on the between two castles of matt king ludwig secrets and soirees expansion keep making more i think this could go i mean i'd probably say another expansion and then that would be that'd be a good a good maybe one every few years or so right star wars movies yeah yeah and just make them bad uh yeah it starts like the expansions start going downhill uh when stonemeyer gets bought out by another mega by asthma day that's when it starts to turn to [ __ ] um asthma day in this case being the corporate greed of disney um also asthma day is highly anti-submit that's not true start like writing slandering i heard listen i'm not saying that it's true i'm

just saying i'm just saying that it might be and you can't disprove me uh anyway that's our thoughts on the secrets and soirees let us know what you think of the uh the expansion or the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved