Garden Club Review - What To Play & What To Gather
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co, and today I'm going to be reviewing Garden Club from Chris Couch Games. Garden Club is a one to two player game in which players are going to be working together to build a communal garden while trying to figure out how to maximize their own scoring within that system. Before we dive into the game, this channel is sponsored by All Play, more about them at the end of the video. And also, this is a prototype, rules components are subject to change, and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. A crowdfunding campaign that has this game as well as Petal, another game that has similar similar aspects yet very very different. Also, I have a review coverage of that, too. You can check that out as well. In any case, in this game you're going to be playing out across three rounds. You're going to have seven actions in the first round. When you move to the next season, you're going to have six actions, then five actions, and that's going to uh wrap up the game. On your turn, you're going to be doing two things. You're going to be taking one of these tiles and placing it into the shared garden, and then one of them placing on your own personal board to score. I will note I'll be trying to show you how to play this without overthinking every single move because there's a lot of possibilities of overthinking things. So, let's say it's my turn first, and let's say I have these objectives right now. I'm trying to work towards Oh, that's all the same type. Okay, I guess that kind of answers that. Uh we're going to go ahead and take this, and we're going to place it out onto the grid. I will place it down over here cuz I think that's going to help me out. Um and then and then from there from placing out there, then I'm going to take this tile over here and put it I was hoping for that. I was hoping for that on the back. In general, you have some degree of accuracy because from the various types of vegetables on the front, if you don't see that type, that type is present on the back. So, it could have been a few options, but I'm hoping for this cuz I'm trying to build
that little grid system there. So, I'm going to take this and place it down to my personal display. That's going to be my two actions. So, one tile for me, one tile for the shared garden. Additionally, you can take up to three other actions. You can play a tool card. You're going to start with some basic tools. You can gather more as you move around the score track, and these gives you ways to manipulate the various tiles in the garden. We'll come back to them later. I can accomplish a project over here. There's two ways to accomplish projects. One is to cash it in for the side over here. This will be one for every matching set, and a set is not two like that. It would be touching sets that I have. Or alternatively, for the patterns that you have there, which as you can see right now on all these cards, I'm working my way towards patterns. Three points is not enough for me. I could try to do strawberries there, but these other ones I can start building out that system. If I place another lily over here, that or whatever if that flower that pink flower is, then I'll be able to score that one cuz I can rotate it and score six points. That's going to be my first turn. Goes to the other player's turn.
They start working towards Let's see what they're working towards. Uh they also have that, but they have that and that. Maybe they you know, they honestly they see this. They see that pattern happening there. So, they're going to gather this one right now, and they're going to place it out on the grid on the table. And then from there, what else do they want to do? Again, I'm just going to try not to overthink this. Uh they're going to grab one of these tiles. Neither of these will have that scoring for them. They'll just go ahead and grab a blueberry and place it down and see what happens. That's going to be their turn. Back to this player's turn. We are going to actually complete that grid because we don't we both don't realize this, but we are kind working towards the same goal, but in my case I have these, and I'm going to take this to double my chances of scoring for that. We'll explain how that works soon. Back to this player's turn. They don't love that I took this. That's not great. They see this as me up for that. So, they now just want to start working towards other things. They could try to separate out the tools, but I'm not going to You know what? Maybe we'll use a tool. Maybe we'll use a tool over here. We'll swap two adjacent tiles. We'll swap two tiles in the garden and do not rotate. So, maybe if I'm going for blueberry scoring anyways, I can go with the gloves. Uh rotate one tile. Nope. Swap two adjacent tiles in the garden. You may rotate. So, we'll go ahead and place uh this down over here like so. Uh and then we will swap this tile. I'm going to place that out as my my personal. I'm going to take this and put it into my grid, and then I'm going to play my garden fork to swap two adjacent tiles. Oh, which is adjacent? Oh, well, we're going to swap We're going to swap two tiles. I messed up. I'm overthinking this. I'm over I'm overthinking this. We are going to rotate this tile over here. Okay, we're going to mess up that that system over there. We're going to play our tool.
That's going to be our actions. Players are going to go back and forth trying to build the grid as well as putting tiles into their own display. The reason for that is at the end of the season, when the board is full, which is going to happen at the end of round one, you're going to fill the board. Rounds two and three, you start overlaying and building on top of other tiles. But first of all, at any point you can actually score for those sets. So, for example, if on my next turn over here, if I take the took this and place it down over here, which again works for me over there, I can then say, "Hey, look, I'm going to score six points." I'll go ahead and move up the score track taking six points, 1 2 3 4 5 6. I'll also get a new project card giving me new ways to score points as I go. As you cross these on the board, you're going to choose one of the benefits and then give the other benefit to your opponent. And you're trying to work your way towards scoring points in game for accomplishing various project cards, as well as scoring points at the end of each season. The way that's going to work is you're going to look at your personal board, and you're going to see who has the most of each of the six vegetables. Whoever has the most of those six vegetables is going to score for those sets on the board. So, for example, assuming I do end up with the most of uh these popcorns or squash or whatever they are, uh peppers peppers.
Assuming I have the most peppers in the at the end of the round, then I would look and say, "Look, that's one two three. I will score three points for having the most peppers." But then I'm also going to add a cube to my display, which will increase my scoring for next round. Next round, if I get the most peppers, I will score two points for each set. So, in the game you are getting more proficient or better at that vegetable when you score them. So, not only are you scoring the points now, which is obviously good, you're improving how many points you score the next time when you dive into it for the next season. So, that's going to be helpful. Keeping in mind, these will clear each round. So, you are going to lose all of those, and you have to rebuild, go to market again and gather those again while attempting to build a display to your liking. So, for each of the six vegetables, you're going to see who has the most cards. If no one does, no one scores for it. Uh but if you have the most, you will both score points as well as increasing this uh for next round. I haven't talked about trellises yet. Trellises are going to be one of the extra actions you can take. Again, you have three actions, accomplishing a project card, spending a tool card, or placing a trellis. Trellises lock tiles in place while also adding plus one to that scoring. So, in this case that pepper set is one more pepper set, but also no one can manipulate those tiles because they've locked it into place with the trellis. At the end of the round, you're going to get back an extra trellis, so you have two trellises in round two, and three trellises per player in round three. That is basically how you play through a game of Garden Club. You are trying to alternate Every turn you're taking two actions. You're taking one tile that's going into the garden, and one tile that's going to your board representing the vegetable you're collecting and getting better at.
You're vying for the uh ability to score those tiles. Then you're using various tool cards, which have a lot of benefits, including my favorite one is I believe it's the shovel, which lets you pull back cards uh pull back a tile from the garden placing it into your personal display. That can be very very helpful and satisfying. And then ultimately, you're trying to manipulate in the shared display to optimize how you're going to score both for the objectives, the projects, as well as at the end of each round. With that, let's go ahead and dive into my review of what I like, don't like, and can see what others are liking. Starting off with what I like. In general, the multiple aspects that you're trying to score for is challenging to think through. You are constantly adding tiles to the garden trying to figure out how to rotate or adjust them to optimize what you're currently going for while also undercutting what your opponent's going for, or even cutting in on their action. Because another thing you're doing is you're constantly taking tiles. So, if you see your opponent building up those uh peppers, you might want to get in on peppers, or you might want to ruin how peppers score, or you may actually want to focus on your own thing. Keep in mind, if you're playing this as a two-player game as opposed to solo, every time you take a point from your opponent, that is evening out the score. So, it's just as efficient to work on how to build yourself up as it is to help tear yourself tear your opponent down. Both of those are viable in this. As you enter the second and third round of the game, you are going to be starting to overlay tiles on top of others, which has an extra element of you have a full grid in place, and now it just starts getting more and more chaotic. Although those trellises can help anchor things.
Speaking of which, the trellises are a fun little aspect. The trellises and the tools both give you options to further manipulate the board in ways that either protect yourself from messing around, or give you tools to manipulate things while you're constantly trying to again both help yourself and undercutting your opponent. The real-time aspect of playing through the game and earning points for your objectives is a nice point of tension in the game cuz otherwise you might sit there and say, "I'll just hold on to these until late game when the whole board is full, and I can just cash in for as many peppers as possible." The downside of that is by playing cards early, you actually ramp up the track earning more of your more cards. And since you can only play one project per turn, although there is a thing if you're behind by 15 points, you can play two. There's a thing like that. But because you can only play one card per turn, you kind of want to pace yourself between waiting for the optimal scoring versus just ramping up and getting more cards, especially because once the decks run out, there are no more cards. You don't reshuffle anything else. So, if you're constantly cashing in your cards and the player's waiting for a big payday, you're going to end up winning because of that. So, that adds a nice degree of tension. Overall, across the three rounds of play, you are escalating how the board's going to present. You're escalating your own personal scoring. That aspect where you lean into how you score, it's interesting because in some games powering up your scoring is really make or break. In this game, because of the fact that if you power up in a certain scoring, it really just makes it that much more in my interest to minimize how many points you get. If you're getting three points for every pair of strawberries, I either really want to make sure I score strawberries that round, or really want to tank strawberries on the board. So, there's this push and pull of trying to get better and stronger in your tableau, but also making it more of a threat that
your opponent has to focus their energy on, which again, that also pushes their strategy. There's a lots of delicate balance between all the things you're going for. As far as things I don't like in the game, I have one complaint about it, but unfortunately, it is a bigger one for me, which is the game the amount of of tool cards that you have access to, and the amount of rotating that you can do, and the amount of swapping tiles, it's too much for me. It's too much in a way that it slows the game down. There's too many things you can do. I I love the trellises. Locking things in place, that's great. I love the placing tiles onto your board and placing tiles onto your personal board. All of that's great. But the amount of tools that are played throughout the game, it adds an element of AP, of analysis paralysis, and it slows down the game while also making it a bit too chaotic. Don't get me wrong, the chaos is nice because it does mean you can undercut your opponent, so there are pros to it, but overall, it felt like I was constantly looking at a handful of tools, and I had too many options on the table, and or my opponent had too many options, and that both gave uh too much chaos on the board, and also slows down the game. I think that to me, this felt like a game that I I'm after two rounds, I feel like I've gotten enough out of it. Playing full of through a full three rounds with what the tools are doing, just feels like it overstays its welcome. I either think it needs to be a shorter game alternatively, or either either needs to be a shorter game being two rounds, or it needs to have less tools to just make the chaos. I want this to be a faster-paced experience than the hour that it plays out in. As far as I can see others not liking, it is a lot of mean plays. I mentioned this earlier, but that fact that the the fact that every point I take from my opponent is a
point that functionally counts for me, meaning it's a direct anything I hurt you is evening out the score. It does mean that this is just as much as just as much of a focus on trying to tear down your opponent's score as there is in building up your own, especially when your opponent has a lot of scoring something. If I'm getting three points for every strawberry, again, that's a big thing. Because for me, it feels satisfying. Yes, I got to three points for strawberry. Now I'm going to I'm going to build strawberries all across the board. No, you're not. If you're getting three points for anything in this game, it is in your opponent's best interest to tank that as much as possible, which I don't mind the winning or losing aspect, but if you if you want something that built up and you're waiting for the the huge amounts of points you're going to cash in this round, that rarely happens in this game if you're playing with somebody who is trying to ensure that you don't get three points times eight different pairs, cuz that could be a lot of points. As far as final thoughts on Garden Club, overall, I like what the game is doing. My biggest issue is the combination of tool cards and game length just makes it so that there's a lot of fun things that are happening, but it does outstay its welcome. Every time I've played this, it has outstayed its welcome, and it's felt that by the time I got to the end, I wanted to be wanted it to be done a round ago, which isn't a great feeling in the game.
Because every time I start this, I'm like, "Yay, I'm building up the the the garden. I'm putting things out. I'm configuring it all." And then it just slows down as the game progresses and outstays its welcome, which is a weird feeling. So for me, I'm coming in at a three out of five, but it does come in that weird aspect where I do really enjoy a lot of things the game is doing. I just feel it is too long for the experience that I personally get out of it. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Petal. Petal is another game in the same series. I mentioned it's part of the same campaign, and I felt that one did a much better job at maintaining a lot of the puzzly aspects of this game, while also feeling like it it fit the play time more appropriately. And then also check out Shallow Sea. If you are looking for a brain burnery experience that is going to play out again. It's going to be multiple things, tile placement, you're you're trying to optimize everything, very thinky. That's another one that gives you a lot going on. It is a little bit on the longer side, but I think that one more appropriately matches the game length.
And I mentioned that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find games both from them as well as their partner publishers. And if you're in the US, you can get anything combined for $4 flat rate shipping. And check out Pollen. If you're looking for another tile laying game of a bit of a shared landscape system as you try to optimize how you score while trying to just place various bugs and critters out. Uh Pollen is an interesting one that has a unique scoring aspect to it. Uh also plays quick and very accessible. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hope you enjoyed this video, and as always, I hope you have a good one.