Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kilauea - First Play Review

Transcript 15:20

Hi there. I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and this is my first play review for Killila. Now, what you're going to see is a snippet from an exclusive live stream that was filmed with the Patreon supporters of the channel. And in it, I talk about how the game plays and my thoughts after playing it that first time. If you'd like to join in on one of these live streams in the future, then you can learn more about that by going to gettingames.com/sport. Now, if you have thoughts about this game, maybe you've played it as well, then please leave those as a comment down below. Also, if you enjoy this video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons down there as well. Okay, let's talk about the game. This is a new game. It just came out, I believe, at Essen Spiel uh 2025, maybe a little bit uh before that. And this is a fascinating game. Uh you have well, let's talk about how it plays. Um so, you have a board in the middle of the table. It has a volcano in the middle of it. And there are tokens everywhere, and there are these forest spots all the way around the outside. Now, in addition to this, in the photo, it's kind of hidden here, but there is a canoe right there.

And on your turn, you must move the canoe at least one spot around a rondelle essentially. So, it's a competitive game. And after you move your canoe, you're going to do one of three different things. The first thing that you could do is you can visit the forest and take one or two of these tiki tokens that are available. You kind of follow a path from the canoe and just grab the token and then you put the token onto your canoe. You only have spots forward of these. And after you do that, you may perform a wreath action. So these tokens right here are slotted in and they're random every time you play the game. So you have different action options available. There's a lot more than five. So yeah, you could do this action which can do a variety of mess things up. I don't really need to belabor the point, but they let you do various interesting things. And then your turn is over. The next thing that you can do, uh, let's say you move the the canoe. Let's say the canoe moves around to here. Yeah, why not? Let's just pretend. The next thing that you could do is you can take one of the tikis on your canoe and put it into the volcano section where your canoe is. So again, we're pretending the canoe is right here. And let's pretend it's this player's turn. They can take this blue tiki and they put over here and stack it on top of the other blues. or they take this red and stack it on top of the other reds, which is, you know, kind of hard to see over there. And then they take up to three of these holy stones and they put them onto their board over here. The last option that you have available to you is you can spend some number of holy stones, two or three, I

can't remember exactly, and you put them into the volcano. And then you take a tiki from your canoe and you put it onto your own board. This board is lined up to exactly match the board out here in the middle of the table. And you just stack these up as well. And that is essentially the arc of the game. You are moving around to get tikkis to put them on your boat. And then you put tikkis into the volcano to get the holy stones. So you can then spend the holy stones back into the volcano to put the tikis onto your board. Now you're going to keep going until I can't remember. Uh one or two of these forests is empty. I think it's one. And then you're going to do an intermediate scoring. And then you keep playing until I think three of the forests are empty. Something like that. And then you do a final scoring. Intermediate and final scoring are the same. Then whoever has the most points wins. And this is where the game gets really interesting. I mean, the other stuff is pretty interesting as well. But the way the scoring works is each player is going to score every single one of the sections that they have in front of them. They're going to score every single tiki essentially based off of the values of the tikis in the middle of the volcano.

If we look over here for example, the way it works is the stack that is highest is going to be uh give that color one point for every one in the stack. So in this example, there are three reds. Three is the highest. So that's three points. So that means everyone who has a red tiki in this specific part portion of their player area. So like right over here, we'll get three points for every one of those tokens. But then this is where it gets wacky. Every single other color is going to be three points per tiki. So there's three reds stacked here. That's three points per red. There are two orange stacked here. That is six points for orange because it's not tied with or the highest one here. There's one yellow. So that's three points for every yellow. And this is me over here. As you can see, I had an orange and a yellow. So I got six points for that orange and uh three points for the yellow. And that's why I obviously tried to build these here and tried to manipulate the essentially volcano market to match that up. And that is the arc of the game.

Again, you do an intermediate scoring and then you do a final scoring and then whoever has the most points wins. Maybe there's a little bit of final scoring. I can't exactly remember. And I guess it is worth mentioning there are also volcano bonuses. If you do a volcano action and there's a volcano bonus action here, then you can activate it. And actually, we could talk about these bonuses a little bit more now because this is where a lot of the control comes into the game. For example, if you see this uh reef action over here, if you end with your canoe here or there, you can activate this and that says you can take an available tiki from any forest and put it down onto any volcano section. Obviously, that's going to change things up over here. If somebody puts an orange on here, instead of the orange being worth six each, they are now worth three uh three total. three, you know, one plus one plus one because it's tied. Um, we can look over here, and this one gives you the opportunity to spend three holy stones as a special action to take a tiki and immediately put it onto your player board. This one over here lets you actually move a tiki in the volcano to a different volcano position, which is going to change the values of everything in a really big way as well. And that's Kila. So, playing this game is really strange. You know, I I read the rule book. hits super quick. And then we uh I taught the game and we started playing and all of us were just like, "What do I even do? The volcano is uh it's mostly empty at the start. There's a couple tokens, but almost nothing out there. Um I think you maybe have a token or two on your boat. Really not much." And for the

first, I don't know, at least 15 to 20 minutes, everybody was just like, "I'll do this. Like, I guess I'll take this color. I don't know. And then I guess I'll put this color into the volcano so I could get holy stones. I guess I guess I'll spend holy stones to put this color over here. I suppose like we just felt completely mystified as to why we were doing things because everything starts out so sparse. But as these sort of uh not random but not well thoughtout actions kept happening the the game state started to coalesce into having these incentives essentially um where like oh okay you know some more of these reds are put down over here and there's two oranges okay well now I think I want to orchestrate things to maybe find an orange in a forest and put onto my boat and then get the orange down into this area while also trying to defend that you know make sure get reds keep getting stacked up here so that the orange is going to get three points each. But of course, if you stack a bunch of reds, then red is going to continue to be worth points. It's one point each.

That's a lot less than three. But if there's a whole bunch of them, then it starts to be worth a decent number of points as well. And once we got to maybe the halfway point, I can't remember exactly where the intermediate scoring happened, like over the course of the game. I feel like it was maybe like between half and 2/3, and then we had another, you know, half-ish 2/3 and then we actually did the final scoring. Um once it became obvious that there was going to be that intermediate scoring relatively soon, a lot of things that we had to do became very not obvious like this is what I want to do, not necessarily how I do it. And you know, the ability to manipulate all of this means you have to look around a lot. It's not hard to parse the game state. You can look across the table and very easily see what colors people have and where they are, but who are you necessarily trying to target? You're also trying to work together. It's like, "Oh, well, you know, me and you, we both have this color in that specific section. We should work together and make that volcano better." You have those shared incentives baked into this game as well. But it was it was just so strange. I will say that there is an endame scoring thing that I forgot. If you have at least one token in every one of these sections at the end of the game, you will get what seemed like at first to be not that many points. If I focus in uh 15, 13, no, I think it's 15 points if you get one in each of those.

And remember at the start of the game, we were like, I wonder how much 15 points even matters. Like the way these multipliers are going to go, we're probably going to have way more than 15. When we got to the very end of the game, 15 suddenly seemed like a pretty significant number of points. I think the winning scores, actually, I could check this real quick. Yeah, the winning score was 64. Uh then we had 54, 52, and 48. So somewhat consolidated around there, but the people in first and second place both got those 15 points. And so I think overly targeting specific values out here maybe was a mistake. By the time I realized the game was ending soon and 15 suddenly felt like a decent number of points, I did not have time to get a token on all of these because of course you need the canoe to be in the right section to be able to place into that section. Like if I want to put a token here, the canoe needs to be in this matching section of the board. And maybe the canoe's over here. You can spend the holy stones to move the canoe further, but frequently it's just like you just can't make that happen. So, you have to take the opportunities that are available to you when uh they come up.

So, at the end of the game, we all kind of discussed it. Nobody disliked it. Uh one or two people were just kind of like, I don't know what just happened. That was a game for sure. Uh I don't know if I want to play that again. Was the vibe that I got from a couple of them. And then two of us, me included, felt a bit more positive on it. Um, a bit more like, okay, I could see myself playing that game again. I mean, honestly, my biggest issue with the game was the early stages where it just seemed like planning was not impossible, but pointless. It seemed like planning was pointless because you just have no idea where any of the stuff is going to be even remotely when you get to that first um the intermediate scoring. Obviously, as you start to commit to some things, um, which again felt pointless, might be an over uh, statement, but, you know, it's like, okay, well, put a yellow over here. Now, I really want to make that happen.

Getting those incentives was definitely a good thing. Um, as we were kind of building things up there, it just it's a bit mystifying at the beginning. And I have a hard time seeing it not always being that way, at least for the first quarter of the game. like it almost felt like extended setup or like just kind of let's put some stuff down and then we're going to start to see how these incentives all match up. It was a thinky game for sure. It was maybe a little bit longer than I expected. I played this a few weeks ago but I think I was expecting like you know 60-minute game and I think it probably went about 90 minutes which is certainly not crazy by any means but there's a lot to think about. There's a decent amount of counting even though the counting is relatively easy. Um and and things can swing so quickly like you know this example over here again if a red is removed then the red ties with orange and now orange is worth two points each instead of six points each which is you know devastating for people who have orange there. I'm one of those people and so I'm I'm certainly hoping that that doesn't happen. You have an incentive to try and share incentives.

Uh if you're the only person with an orange in that area then people are probably going to target it and make it go bad. But if two of you care about Orange being good, then maybe you could kind of work together and make that happen. Of course, competing in various other ways. See, good luck says, "I've heard a bit of buzz about this one recently. Seems like it's a bit of a secret train game, which sounds great to me, but I found that that's not always enough for me to uh love a game." Yeah, I mean, there's no route building or any of that kind of stuff going on, but as far as the um the shared incentives that are happening, it's definitely there. So, I don't know if I'd go so far as to say it's a secret train game. Um, like other maybe stockier games, if that makes sense. Um, but uh you are interacting like crazy in this game and you are definitely positively interacting quite often as well. So, you have to keep that in mind. So, I could see I'm not going to say people who say that are just flat out wrong. It definitely has those kind of vibes and that's a big reason why I wanted to try this game. It's beautiful. It's got great board presence and I knew it had these, you know, wacky shard incentives and super streamlined rules. Like there's I essentially taught you the entire game. Sure, there are these bonus um tiles that you have to teach at first. The iconography is good. It's small though. Like I'm going to zoom in over here. You can see the playerboard.

It teaches you essentially the entire game, but holy cow, these icons are so small. I feel like this board right here could have maybe been a bit bigger so that all these really helpful icons would be a little bit easier to read. Uh Delorean says, "Yeah, I'm also not a big fan of directionless starts." Yeah, at the beginning of the game, if I remember correctly, everybody takes like one or two tikis from an island and puts them into the volcano and then they start with one or two on their ship. But even so, like part of me feels like you should start with some tokens like literally on your board. So, right at the very start of the game, you have some skin in the game. Like, okay, well, I I have a yellow here. I got randomly uh placed a yellow here. Now, I really want yellow to score well into that specific section. Something like that might be a little bit nice to kind of kickstart the uh the crunchier decisions part of the game. Kitty says, "Do they include a magnifying glass for those icons?" I know. Fortunately, the actual tokens are big and chunky and they stack really well. Um there is a limit of six I think on the stacking before they you know fall over but um the production in this game was really good I guess maybe minus the incredibly tiny icons. I I would certainly play this one again. I feel like it's hard to really parse it the very first time you play and you have to go into it knowing that it is going to be all over the place. you know, unlike uh maybe a more traditional stock market game where it's like, oh, stock goes up a little bit, stock goes down a little bit, the way these can

swing so swiftly, like the flexibility you have with some of these uh actions like, you know, take this token and move it all the way over here can swing things enormously. You have a lot of control with that. So, obviously, you're thinking about that with the uh canoe. Also, you might be thinking about the canoe placement as far as what you don't want your opponents to do. like, okay, I don't want them to mess with this one section of the volcano. So, I'm going to move the canoe in such a way that they don't have enough holy stones to get the canoe over there, but of course, they don't get there and the next person could get there and maybe that next person will mess with it as well. Kitty says, "A little concerned about the start, but definitely think it's going to be just a pull levers and see what happens." Yeah, that's the thing. You just pull levers at the beginning and and and you'll get there. Also, I don't want to overstate it. You know, this is a first play impression. Um, this is how it seemed to us. Maybe we were missing a little bit there at the very beginning.

Maybe there was more that we could parse and more that we could see. Or maybe you just, you know, lean into a little bit of whatever and see where it goes. You know, just go a little bit broad with your options. Lots of different colors at the beginning and um and then see how things actually go. But it I remember like the first time somebody put a token onto their board. It's like, okay, all right, now they're committed to that. You can't remove or move these tokens on your board. At least none of the actions that we had let you move those. I don't know if other ones do. And it's like, okay, well, that person is committed to this. So now you know the game is a foot something like

Progress saved