Hansa Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
Hey, everybody. Today, I'm talking about Hanse, which is a two-to-four player board game. Takes about 30 minutes to play, um even though the block the box states it takes 1 hour to play. Um from the look of the box, you probably think this game looks ancient, and it does look ancient. I mean, it's a very bland-looking game. However, it actually came out in 2004, so it's a lot more modern than it looks. And um the the look of the game and the way the game plays, I don't think it's quite um you know, it's quite fitting either, because it's actually quite a a simple um fun little game that's um isn't quite as stuffy and dry as it looks. So, the idea of the game is that we are different merchants um in the Hanseatic Sea trying to um collect different kind of resources or merchant goods and trade them in at our own merchant houses for victory points at the end of the game.
Um however, there is quite a few twists in the game that um are very simple, but quite um you know, quite well designed and quite well implemented. Um so, first off, everybody is going to have an investment or an interest in this main ship on the board, which is your the player piece, but it's not only your player piece, it's every other every other player's um you know, piece as well, because you've got this um basically a trade route of um different sea paths you can go down which go from city to city. Um there's going to be some resources allocated to every city um represented by these different barrels of different colors. Um and the idea is you're trying to collect these different barrels of of matching colors and trade them in at least two at a time for these victory points. The game has quite a structured breakdown in what you can do on your turn. Um you know, at the start of every round, you're going to be rewarded three coins, um and you can need coins to pretty much to do almost everything in this game.
Um so, first off, it's going to cost you a coin for move to move um from one trade route to another. Um so, you got to bear that in mind. When you get to a city, you can take one action before having to move on to take another action. Um and those actions are pretty simple. One of them is to um pay a coin in order to take one of the resources to that city, but that's not always the case because if you um if you have a or the most trade houses on that city, then you're not going to have to pay anything. Uh if there's a kind of a a draw or a tie for who's got the most um trade houses on that city, then you pay it to the bank. Or if another player's got the uh most trade houses on that city, you actually have to pay the coin to them. So, that's a decision to bear in mind there. Uh the second action ties into that, whereas you trade in those um resources or the the the barrels you've collected in order to build more merchant um buildings in that city, so you can kind of increase your stack of buildings, which also gives you the majority, which means when people go there to buy goods, you'll get the coin instead.
Um, and the other thing is to trade in your um trade in your resources for points. So, um to do that, you need to have a uh your own different merchant house there, otherwise you can't do it. Um, and if you if you trade in your goods, then you as I said, you have to trade in at least two at a time, um and you can trade in multiple different colors. And when you trade them in, you're going to get victory points equal to the uh the number of tokens, but also the number of barrels on those tokens because they come into nominations of um one, two, or three barrels, and obviously three barrels being a lot more lucrative. Um, but there's another trick to it as well because when you trade in those um resources for those victory points, or selling the goods, I think it's called, you um well, every other player with a matching token of that color has to um discard one. So, um you know, there's a little bit of um player interaction there, a little bit of nastiness, but it does work quite well. And at the end of the round, you can only ever carry up to three coins um through to the next round, and also three um merchant goods.
So, you can't you can't just stock load load of money or stock pile a load of money or stock pile a load of um resources, either. You've got to be quite savvy about what you do on your turns and how much you're carrying from turn to turn. But that being said, um obviously if you are dominating on a lot of those different cities by having the most um trade houses, and people keep buying resources, um it doesn't mean that you're not going to have a lot of money on your turn because maybe it's at the end of your turn you have to discard down to three coins and not at the beginning. So, you can go into the round quite comfortably with seven or eight coins sometimes, um which is um really powerful, and you can get a lot done. Um it's quite interesting about how the how the map is laid out because um it's not like you can keep going from city to city back and forth um because you can only go certain paths on the on the kind of the merchant route. So, one city might go to another, and then that city can go to another three cities, and then that one can go to another two cities, but you can never kind of go back on yourself. So, there's this real kind of interesting puzzle about what you're going to do on your turn, and you can really map it out quite cleverly. For example, you could say um I've I've got the most merchant merchant um houses here, so I can take this resource for free, which lets me travel to here. I'll trade in that resource as to build a new merchant house there.
Um I'll go to the next city, pick up a good, go to the next city, trade in another two goods where I've got my what my merchant house. And also when you do sell your goods, you have to take off one of your merchant houses, so that stack's going to be constantly fluctuating. Um so it's just a a really nice tactical little game that's simple but thought-provoking. Um you know, bearing in mind what other players can do on their turn because you want to make players um you know, pay for what they want to do. Um not only by collecting those goods by paying you, but also leaving the ship in a maybe not so um advantageous place so that they have to at least travel a little bit by and spend their coins before they can do anything. Which um is pretty much where the the tactics and the strategy of the game game really lies. Um the I I I I do love the way that game works mechanically, I'll be honest. Just that very structured um almost throwback streamlined stripped back mechanisms uh just work really well.
Um and all the different approaches and tactics you can take are quite interesting and um quite rewarding as well when it does pay off cuz you can as I said sometimes if you have a little bit little bit of money you can get a lot done um on your turn. And these turns are quick as well because you know, you are literally just traveling down a ship getting rid of a coin, picking up a resource, get rid of a coin. And um you know, before you know it your turn's over and um you know, so there's not a lot of downtime, there's not a lot of kind of scope to lose interest. The board state is always changing because um you know, the trade houses are going up and down as people are building more or selling goods. Um the resources are constantly getting eaten up. And something I should have mentioned as well is at the start of the turn you get an option to replenish all the resources on the different cities. Um obviously as the game develops they're going to get taken. Um but you can pay spend one coin which completely um you know, makes the board flush with resources again which can be a double-edged sword because it's going to benefit you because you you get a lot more kind of the pick of the litter of the resources you want. But players coming after you are also going to get a very good deal out of that as well. So you've got to bear that in mind um when you you know, when you are going to replenish the market because um you can you can really help your opponents at times.
Um time investment-wise, as I said the box says it takes an hour to play, it doesn't. Um I got the game played I got like a three-player game played in half an hour. Um it felt very snappy. Um it's not actually that or the game ends when there is a certain number of replenishments because there's stacks of tiles um all the resources. And when you replenish them they're going to get constantly eaten up and when it gets to that last pile of resources the game um you know, the the end of the game is triggered. Um and it doesn't take long at all. So uptime, time investment, excellent. Uh replay-ability wise, um I don't think this is a game you're going to constantly get to the table. However, it does feel very unique. So, in that respect, it's not like there's another game out there that does what Hansa does better than Hansa does. Um it's very different in the way it feels. Um again, very stripped back. So, it there's no bloat to the game whatsoever.
Um and it just feels fun, fast, and um it just just different than anything else. Um aesthetically, the game looks miserable. It is so ugly. It is bland. It is drab. I mean, I like dry-looking games, but this one is almost a bit too dry for me. It is very boring-looking. The art is very primitive. All brown and just yeah, not attractive. So, I think a lot of players are going to be put off um by the initial look of the game. Um but as I said, the actual mechanics and fun you get out of the game is not reflective on the art at all. Um but yeah, it's a strange direction to go in in terms of what the game looks like, but I kind of understand where they're going for, but um it just it just I think it's going to be more of a hindrance um in terms of not gaining people's interest than it is in actually getting the interest of players who like these kind of dry games.
The theme is um very dry as well. Um you know, just being different merchants, picking up goods, and selling goods. Like a lot of these Euro games. So, um nothing uh nothing new whatsoever, and it's pretty much tried and tested. Um progression of the game is is a bit strange because you're pretty much doing the same thing throughout all of the game. However, you're always keeping an eye on where you've got your merchant houses. Um because it is a bit of a balancing act, you know, you want to collect these resources in order to trade them in, but you also need these resources to build your own merchant houses, which is very important. And also, at the end of the game, you get two points for each city you're in with your merchant houses. And also, if you've got a monopoly on those cities by being the only person there, then you get four points, which can be quite swingy, and it give you a lot of points. So, um you know, you've got to monitor the end of the game um because you want to have uh quite a good coverage on the board.
Um scalability-wise, um I think I the sweet spot for this game is about three players. I think it works well at two, but three players is really where it sings for me. At four players, again, absolutely fine. I think I the the kind of hierarchy of player counts I'd rather choose would be three players, then four players, and then two players. And comparison-wise as well, I mean, I suppose a lot of pick-up-and-deliver games have similarities to Hanse, but the terms or the way it's stripped back and the the almost mechanical um mechanisms are quite unique. But yeah, overall, um this is a game that really could come out of the, you know, come out of the nothing for me. Um but I really enjoyed it. It's really good. It's really different. Um again, not brain-dead decisions. You're always thinking about what you're leaving your opponent, um how to get the most out of your turns, how to um you know, use your money um in the most effective way, um you know, picking up resources when you've got the most trade houses so you get it for free. Um and you can really get a lot done and travel the board a lot on your turns if you do do things um in the right order at the right time. Um very tactical, but really engaging. The dynamic board state is interesting. Um as things are constantly, you know, changing in terms of all the different things you've got to manage. But yeah, a really solid game and um one that I would recommend if you like your pick-up-and-deliver games. If you like stripped-back simple um games and are not deterred by the aesthetic of the game because it again, it looks so so
bland and that is going to deter a lot of people. But um yeah, it's fun and um I would I would recommend it. So, this one gets a good verdict from me. Um I'd happily play this again and I will play it again. And I'm actually looking forward to introducing it to new players because I think um I think it's so easy to digest but has it quite a lot to sink your teeth into. So yeah, a good one for me that is Hamza. Um go check this one out if this one does appeal to you. Um I hope you've enjoyed this review. If you have, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. For everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.