Batman: Everybody Lies - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for everybody lies newest game by portal games in their detective uh investigation system uh so to be fair for this discussion we had only done the prologue but i think that that is okay considering that we have played detective we have played vienna connection um so this is that but batman themed and with that being said i mean it has it has a few tweaks to it to where it's not literally just detective with batman right um but if you are familiar with those games and if you like those games um i could probably definitely say you would most likely like this um largely the same except for the uh comic book that's literally the biggest the biggest thing um the biggest difference is the the scene deck uh which i think are literally there just for like thematic flair oh yeah they do nothing but but turn a couple of lines into comic frames yeah which i mean i think is neat i think it's a nice addition because uh one it it ties in kind of the overarching theme together a little bit more and uh gives you a visualization it might actually help them a little bit instead they don't have to describe as much uh like and all the other ones they do describe quite a bit of what you're doing who you're talking to mannerisms because you need that stuff for the
forensics and like to help deduce cases but here you can just be like oh hey and it's me and it's neat yeah uh i think i think it's cool but uh yeah what are you guys thoughts on everybody lies cool like the ver this version of detective specifically or this case uh this this version okay uh yeah i like it i think it's cool um i am pretty passive when it comes to dc um i know it was real cool to pick a side back in the day yeah now it's obviously marvel's better they have conceded defeat um i've always been a marvel girl but um always everyone loves batman yeah which is probably why this is a batman theme first of all the detective second of all it's probably cheaper than any marvel property um that very true considering that yeah they have to pay disney now but um this is clearly yeah the more obvious theme if they were gonna go this route uh because batman is supposed to be first and foremost a detective yes and he has literally never been that in any um in any of the movies he is that in all the games in the arkham asylum arkham city um there i think they were like four or five total um you do detective work and uh i mean that's why i think the the new batman like with robert pattinson was so good because it wasn't like christian bales over the top beat the [ __ ] of everyone not killed in batman get his
back broken right it wasn't it wasn't like that it was oh hey he's been only doing this two years and he relies heavily on the police and because he's still a vigilante and all that and you definitely feel that here i was very misconstrued i thought you played as batman yeah but it makes sense that you don't because then it's like well i'm batman and who the hell are you guys why do i need you i i like the fact that it is other people and you ha you can go to batman yeah he's got he's like the sherlock probably of everything so uh what do you think um and an excellent joining of the layering of the theme and the storyline on top of the system um you know having locations to go to and having mitigations and if you go back there better get everything you want done here yeah if you go back there it's going to cost you more right but a simple mitigation technique for that yeah i think that's interesting i think that they utilize the tokens a lot more because in the other ones you kind of have a pool and you really just spent them all it was very hard to get them back yeah but in this one you were always getting investigation clues to spend them to go visit locations i think that's a nice little touch at least in vienna weren't there different types of tokens there were and that's that limited yes i limited to like how much information you got from going to a location um in each iteration of detective they've always kind of increased the token usage um the first detective modern crime uh still use tokens you can spend this to
flip this card and get more information or or spend it to get something else but uh i feel like they've utilized it in more interesting ways than the other two uh this one in vienna um i mean for me personally i don't give a [ __ ] about batman like i don't like dc um like especially in in media i've just never been into i think like like i'm not one of those that like hates on all the characters but i think superman's relatively boring like as a character because it's like yeah i mean he's cool in that he can do literally everything but he's boring because he can literally do everything right oh he died no he didn't they just hope him back to life and then now he's back um i think batman is i don't really like batman himself i think his villains are the best thing about batman which is what i'm excited for in the in the leading up cases like i've never and i hope they i mean they're probably going to use joker they're probably going to use riddler like all the named ones but i really hope they use some obscure ones like i've never heard of the doll maker that sounds like a really [ __ ] up sounds like a real person right i mean it probably is a real person there's there's most likely i guarantee you we've listened to a last podcast thing of someone who has the dominance of you know sit like you know sewed people together i mean we kat and i are listening to a woman called katherine knight who skinned her husband a lot but not alive she killed him but then skinned him and hung his his intact skin as a curtain
and uh so so she'd always be reminded of him better than usual she was caught like the next day oh like she's still that's just poor no she just she really just wanted to kill him um and uh the police officers who who found him one like has severe ptsd and quit being a police officer because apparently it was so well kept like and well done that you could tell it was him and like that's how disgusting so the doll maker i was like oh man yeah this feels like a real case i'm hoping that they don't go super in it where it's just like unrealistic to fall pandering yeah yeah like i'd be nice it'd be nice if like what the joker's doing or what the riddler's doing is is still relevant to the cases that you can solve they might be ancillary but not a core yeah part of it well this this itself was a pretty mundane uh normal type of mafia case so that bodes well so far yeah yeah so and i think i think it mentions where was it and that's going to be more satisfying for an investigation type yeah then hey here's this really nuts person where are they going to strike next and stop them yeah exactly yeah i mean and once again it mentioned falcone i wouldn't have known who that was if i didn't watch the new movie i don't know if they i can't remember when this was announced and when that movie i mean obviously this was announced before that movie came out so uh and and they they did another one you
haven't played those picat and i did called detective season one and it had like three different stories and one of those was very similar to knives out oh okay um and they even saying like they're just they i have a book about their like behind the scenes and they did say knives out they all went to go watch it and got a lot of inspiration um from that so uh overall like the theme doesn't draw me in um but the gameplay is still incredibly engaging like and they do a good enough job with the theme that like it's not a turn off for me but it might be for other people that would probably be the only reason i would say you might not like this but it's not so deep into the lore yeah that it really matters yeah i think it's more of a draw of a new set of fans to enter this system and then they go hey here's a cold war storyline yeah that might be interesting yeah that's true this reminds me um and thankfully it's more tastefully done and it's not just pasting it over a game um but it reminds me of every version of clue that's ever been released that is sure um that they were just finally like let's do a batman one yeah um i was gonna say it'd be really great if they did a laura greene's one but i was like that would be hilarious that'd be so dumb so funny and so far they don't have a cthulhu one they do not even though most no stories technically there there is one it's not by them it's called mythos tales okay and there is it's surely it's
more like sherlock holmes and it's already excellent um it's it's good like um the company is no longer a business uh because it was so excellent i have it but yeah it's sherlock holmes but cthulhu um yeah they easily could do it and i'm glad that they haven't like i love cthulhu and lovecraft stories and all that and lovecraft himself he's my favorite now yeah i know his stories and all that but yes this is a breath of fresh air though because this is a theme that isn't normally done like you really don't see a lot of batman there's the massive batman game but it was so poorly executed that ever i always see it being sold because people and no one buys it because it has probably the most atrocious rulebook that it's like it's a couple hours to even learn the game before you even play the two hours of game it's like it's an ad-lib it's even an even a mad lib was it mad i think it was coming like when you fill in the blank like you need like um but but yeah so the theme i i mean i guess you could say the same thing about the cold war people could be like i don't [ __ ] about that so they don't get the vienna connection right um so you choose your favorite theme yeah and i guess the names of characters that they're bringing in are just as abstract as some whatever mob boss they have in another story yeah so if they mention falco in here you just know that that's an established lore character and if you're into the theme you're like oh cool um but otherwise you can just
treat it as like okay falcone is no different than williams and whatever other story true um in terms of uh in terms of its like access into the like it's uh the the internet part at least in the prologue it wasn't really exciting yeah i mean i think the only thing it's doing is tracking what you've accomplished yeah in some major ways just so that it has a double check on on the outcome right or the questions to ask or something like that yeah because i know in the detective ones they've had videos they do the the fingerprints and all that and the puzzles yeah the puzzles oh yeah with vana connection it was yeah you had like kind of the puzzles that was pretty cool when they worked yeah um but it seemed like it was just a milestone kind of tracker yeah it really just oh hey you get a file okay but in the file you could like click on arrows to like move it and you could like zoom in but that was like okay what's up maybe if you're playing it on a not a computer maybe if you're doing it on your phone but they could open it up in the other cases there's four in the game uh guilt uh guild nostalgia and remorse so based off these pictures if i had to guess it's showing a sewer that makes me think of killer croc nostalgia showing batman as like he's
like angry um i'm not really reading these but um and another guy in a hazmat suit hazmat suit could be moltar who from space ghost oh i'm like i have no idea see it could be the joker's laughing gas or it could be um scarecrow's fear um i i can't really that would be nice like i would actually like to see someone's that weren't getting um so much attention i think more i'm just more tired of joker [ __ ] like it's he's just always brought in that it's like just stop remaking the joker jared leto he already did the best job like you can't beat him heath ledger's the worst joker no uh i'm here to jared leto yes definitely just the wrong take on a person just that crazy i know right um you guys have any negatives anything you i mean i guess any negatives we would have would be negative we have about the other ones yeah i was going to say it was like not for this theme specifically i i like that it's not like we said that earlier um i did it's not heavy-handed but it's not too thin yeah where it's just like okay this is obviously just detective like they're using key characters yeah mentioning people that were like oh that was that
was harley quinn right it doesn't feel pasted on correct right yeah um it's a good line to walk yeah what do you guys think of the uh the personal the personal gold deck i don't know i didn't have one yeah you played the main character your personal goal was the case oh fine i thought it was fun yeah um you know i mean i honestly wasn't really expecting to look into mine too much so i wasn't stressed out about it and we were able to use yeah well it's why i kept thinking about things that fit them right um i thought in the prologue i guess it makes sense but i thought we were gonna get like more um cards but like there's there's a ton here so probably you do as cause because like you can get these tokens and you can spend these tokens to get more information or to even get a personal goal yeah um card but uh what they do and what i really like is they give you because these are like the side quests and they give you a way to track those side quests so you actually know that you're going to be asked questions about them later on because if you remember with like the sherlock holmes games whenever it's like additional questions and you're like there was like i didn't even know that that was a thing or or we thought that was the main that was the main story or the main question and then it's like who yeah like who's the leader of the higgins game and you're like who what gang yeah you're like so lost that the the personal goals are like hey you
can you're gonna get questions on these so keep you know keep them in mind and i really like that i think it's very nice and also makes you feel more like a character which they might have been going for yeah because in all the other ones you're just people hey we're just investigators yeah we're just investigators here it's like i'm actually playing harvey bullock cat's playing catwoman yeah so yeah that is um that is kind of fun right um and it probably actually feels a little bit better in in this one because you actually well i don't know who the hell harvey bullock is but um or vicki vale or any of them i only knew catwoman but uh but this is pretty neat that you can kind of get a little bit more into it without drastically changing and making a role-playing game true um yeah other than that yeah i mean the map's a little flimsy yeah i mean the map's there they're all flimsy i don't once again i think this is just pre-order [ __ ] i don't know if these actually are gonna come in handy or it's stuff to make you keep playing and find out if they do maybe maybe like i mean like yeah i guess you probably could um look through these and see they probably do come up in other investigations is just like its own story because as i'm quickly looking through them they seem to be in like a storyline um
but maybe not i don't know typically when you get newspaper clippings they're kind of supposed to be relevant to the story or previous stories uh but yeah i mean final verdict is really if you like the detective system you're probably gonna like this unless you really hate batman yeah unless the theme does absolutely nothing for you and yeah like you have an aversion to batman then you then at that point you're just hating it just to hate it but even if you don't care about the theme it's still the same system yeah still the same kind of fun yeah same game just you can be like i don't really like the theme but okay you gotta really hate batman and i think to make to let that bother you right right right yeah so um yeah i don't really have much else to say like it's different enough so if you're kind of like but i love these games yeah like i don't even really care for batman i don't like hate him but i'm just like and whatever but i'm like oh a new detective series game hell yeah like more cases to never finish so just add them to the list of never-ending cases so uh yeah i mean i'll give it um i'll give it an eight out of ten it's not quite the nine cause i don't like the theme as much but um i was gonna say i was like i'm gonna give it a nine because i do not mind the theme i don't either i'm still gonna give it an eight but that's mostly in comparison to uh other systems that are more in-depth and more rich in their in their content i'm thinking particularly the sherlock holmes yeah um where it's
you're really kind of a choose your own adventure story but it's much more literary yeah but still eight excellent yeah yeah it's uh and because i mean the theme is batman for me it's harder to get into like versus the cold war history or just any other relevant i don't know i'm more drawn to the the other themes that have been in it and still even though this is batman it's still fantastical in some way yeah uh even though the prologue was was very good like it didn't feel fantastical but it's still like ah it's batman like it's so it's still batman gotcha like i don't know maybe that's my own thing i don't know like i guess i can see what you're saying because it's also just situations that wouldn't happen in real life uh like the city is not overrun with serial killer well i mean 70s la it was was very much so that's true are you saying that police don't get red you're telling me that skid row is not a nice place to live yeah so uh yeah i mean everybody lies eight out of ten um i'm excited to see what they do with the other the other cases but apparently it's supposed to be an overarching story um that we will see how that shapes up uh you guys get anything else yeah no great cool all right well that's our thoughts on everybody lies uh let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and ever wonderful with every time of day done this for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go
ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you