Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tower of Babel - First Play Review

Transcript 12:23

Hey there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and this is my first play review for Tower of Babel. In this video, I'll be giving you an overview of what the game is like to play and I'll talk about my impressions of it after my first and second play in this case. Now, what you're going to see here was a segment that was recorded for the Patreon supporters of the channel and you can learn more about how you can join in on that by going to gettinggames.com/support. Now, if you have thoughts about the game, maybe you've played it in the past, then please leave that as a comment down below. Also, if you enjoy the video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons. Okay, let's talk about the game. This game was designed by Reiner Knizia. It came out back in 2005 and it's fascinating. I played this one twice and I really enjoyed it and let's talk a little bit about how it plays. So, out here you can see a photo of what the game looks like on the table. It's a bit drab.

Uh you've got the eight different wonders, I guess one of them being the Tower of Babel, you know, instead of seven wonders. And for each one of these, uh you complete the building if you complete three different building projects. Like you can see these three tokens that were randomly placed there at the start of the game. For this building, these three for that building over there. Now, to explain more of how this game works, I think I'm actually going to jump over here and show you this online implementation. I think it'll be a little bit easier to understand the mechanics of it looking at this, uh even though the buildings look different and the resources are different. Yeah, I'm sure you can follow. So, everybody has a hand of cards and when it's your turn, you choose one of these building uh project tokens that again were put out randomly at the start of the game. So, down here this randomly got a four brick, a five brick and a five tools. In this case, it's my turn and I chose this five stone over here for this building and after making that selection, I wait.

Everybody else is going to simultaneously decide how many cards they want to reveal. So again, we all have these hands of cards and everybody around the table can reveal any cards they want, although only stone is going to matter. So, I wait and then everybody reveals and as you can see in this case, uh Dex over here revealed three stone and Srinivas revealed two stone and a trading uh card, which I'll talk about in just a second. So now what happens uh that everything is revealed, I'm going to potentially complete this construction project. I need exactly five stone to complete this project and I can use the stone that's been provided to me by my opponents and I can also make up for that with the stone that I have in my hand. I can also just use the stone that I have in my hand to complete this. Let's say for example, I take up Dex. Uh so I say, "Dex, I'm going to use your three stone and I'm going to use two of my own stone." What happens is these are discarded and then you take cubes from your supply and you put them onto that building equals to the number of resources discarded. So, Dex is going to get rid of three stone and put three cubes down over here. Uh Dex is purple and I would get rid of two stone to make it up to five and I would put two cubes over here. Um after that, everybody else who was not chosen, in this case Srinivas, they return all their cards back into their hand and they get one point for every single matching card.

So, in this case, um two stone were revealed plus a trading card. The two stone match, Srinivas gets two points magically for offering cards that were not actually chosen. This is where the game gets really funky. This game is really strange in that way, especially when it's not your turn and you're trying to figure out how many cards you want to reveal. Of course, you're giving up information and if you reveal cards, you want to make sure that you're okay with the current player getting rid of them and turning them into cubes. And why do you want cubes? Well, as soon as the third construction token is removed from one of these buildings, we do a simple area majority scoring. So, in this case, if that happened, uh purple would get three more, so purple would have seven cubes. I would get two more, so I would be at four cubes and Srinivas would be at three cubes. So, in this case, we look down to this chart and we look to the current position of this token. Uh the person with the most cubes is gets 10 points, second most gets five and everybody else always gets three points.

So, in this case, Dex gets the 10 and I get the five and Srinivas gets the three. Then we move this token over one space, so the next time a building is completed, the scoring is going to be even higher. So, there is a push and pull in this game of uh do you go really hard in the early game to put cubes down to win these competitions? Well, maybe that's not a good idea because you're going to be winning the lower value competitions. But if you wait until later, it it's going to be harder to compete for those because there's more time for everybody else to jump in, but of course, the value of them can double as you can see getting now to the very, very end, which you may or may not do. So, we've now talked about two ways that you can get victory points in this game. The first is by the majority on the completed buildings. The second is if you uh your cards are not picked. The third way that you get points happens at the end of the game and that has to do with these uh construction tokens themselves. So, in this case, I uh spent two stone, I take this token and I put it into my hidden area. You can see I have two brick and two stone already, so this would be my third stone. And at the end of the game, I look down here and three stone is going to be worth 10 points to me. So, me getting this third stone is worth five points and if I'm able to get a fourth stone, as you can see there's a couple down here, that's worth 10 points and winning score in this game seems to be in like the like 90s, 100, you know, 80s, that kind of thing. So, 10 points is significant.

Five points is certainly significant. And this is where the trading card comes into play. So, if we rewind time a little bit and say instead, I'm going to pick Srinivas. Uh Srinivas is has these two cards and that means I will use three of my cards and I will put three cubes down for my three cards. Srinivas over here is going to take this token. But because of that, I would get to put my own cubes down. That's why in this mod it shows a blue cube. So, that means I would put three cubes down for mine plus two of my blue cubes for these and Srinivas foregoes putting their own cubes down in order to get this stone token. And obviously, these tokens can be worth a ton of victory points and this is another big part of the game. When do you reveal these trading cards?

Uh when do you care about your cubes going down versus not because of course, your cards are going to be spent in this way. This is Srinivas saying he's okay with spending two cards to get this stone uh resource. And of course, I really want the stone because that's worth five points to me right now and if it gets me closer to my fourth stone, which will be worth 10 extra points, which would also, you know, obviously be awesome. So, that's pretty much the game. You keep playing until all of one type of these construction tokens are gone. So, like once all the stone are gone from here, game is over. So, you might not make it all the way to the end. The game could end with, you know, the competition being here or something and then you score up and you see who has the most points. That was pretty much the rules of the game. Not really a high-level overview there, but its its intricacies are fascinating and I felt like I needed to kind of go into them to explain the the feeling of this game.

So, so far I've only played this twice and I played them both at three players. The game does technically play up to five. I've heard five is not great, but four is is good, so I would happily play this one at four and the decision space that you find yourself in this game is fascinating. Like it almost feels like push your luck to a certain extent because frequently when it's your turn, like in this instance, I picked this five stone. We look to my hand, I have four stone cards. So, that means I can't build this by myself. I forgot to mention, I suppose, if I had five stone cards in my hand, I could just build this entirely by myself, put my own cubes down and then say no to everybody else, but of course, they get one point for every single one of these tokens I say no to. So, if I say no to Dex, Dex gets three points and if I say no to Srinivas as well, he gets two points and sure, I've just made some points, but as you can see, you know, five points for getting that third token and you just got three points for revealing some cards and then nobody picked them.

That's pretty good. Later on in this game, uh Dex who ended up winning by like six points, it was close, uh had a five point turn. They revealed five cards and the active player who was not me

uh didn't pick them. So, he got five points for free. And this is just a fascinating head space to be in as a player. As the current player and and not as the current player. Like if you're the current player, you have to figure out which one do you want to pick. How many cards do your opponents have because you don't want to set themselves up for that mega turn. Like let's say you really need that fourth stone token. It's going to get you 10 victory points and you have enough stone in your hand and you go for it and then somebody reveals like a trading card and five stone. Well, I don't want them to take this token. Like I I started this construction project specifically so I could get that and if it has the trading card, then they're going to take that token and sure, I would get five cubes down for their five cards, but now I'm going to blow out the majority. I don't need that many cubes, but am I really going to say no and give them five points for free so that I could take this token? That's the head space as the current player, which is just and then if it's not your turn and you're that person sitting there thinking, am I really going to reveal this like five of these resources? What if they take them? Because at the end of every single turn, you get one card automatically. So, one card per turn and then on your turn, instead of picking one of these, you could just do a draw and pass turn where you draw an extra card and then everybody draws a card.

So, instead of picking one of these construction projects, you one more card on all of your opponents. So, if you throw these five cards out there and your opponent decides I can't give you five free points, I'm just going to use them and throw a bunch of cubes down like blowing out the area majority, maybe you've given up too much like resources, like literal uh opportunity to get points because every card could be a point if it's brought back to your hand or it could be points if it's turned into cubes or of course, it could be points if it's turned to other people's cubes and you get those resource tokens. It is bewildering in a fascinating and really fun way. Um there's been lots of like casual swearing and groans in this game. It's a very groan inducing game as you're just like, "What do I do?" Um and then you know, the bids reveal and then the active player is like, "No!"

There were three times in this game where I did something like this where I picked a construction project I could not complete on my turn, and then my opponents revealed and they did not reveal enough stuff to complete it, which means I just passed on my turn essentially. I did not build the construction project, so it just stayed out there. My turn ended and everybody drew a card. It would have been way better if I just drawn an extra card and then everybody draws a card instead of essentially passing on my turn. And this is where a little bit of the push your luck comes into play because, you know, you can't always start a construction project for something that you can complete. Well, I guess you can. Technically, you could just draw, draw, draw, and then only start construction projects that you can complete, but you are opening up the opportunity for your opponents to get huge amounts of points by just revealing their own cards. Um and then you are not picking them because, dang it, you need those cubes down. You You want to win that early majority. So, you are weighing all three of these scoring conditions with every decision that you make, and you make these decisions on every single turn.

It's fascinating. And if we go back here, this is what the game looks like when you actually play it on the table, which I have not done so far. It looks usable. Um obviously not quite as easy to understand when you're looking at that screen right there, but you know, you have the tokens here. You have these little houses down instead of cubes. And um you know, you have a hand of cards. I think it's probably perfectly playable in person even though it might look a little bit drab. And I have to be honest, I really like this game. After my first play, I was captivated. Um like plagued almost for like 2 days, all I could do was think about this game and how strange it was. Uh I finally got to play it a second time after like a 3-week gap or so. I played it just a couple nights ago, and it was just a fascinating, amazing experience again. I I'm surprised I haven't heard about this game until somewhat recently. I mean, there's just a treasure trove of wonderful older games out there, especially designed by Reiner Knizia, who just has so many wonderful ideas for designs that just keep surprising me, and this one is definitely been a surprise. So, this is a game that I'm certainly hoping to get a copy of it at some point in the future. It's not like crazy hard to get a copy of it. I mean, it's super out of print, but it seems like you have to spend an arm and a leg for it. I'm going to be keeping my eye out for it because I think for a the experience itself, this is not just like, "Oh, it's another auction game."

or "Oh, it's a set collection game." It's its own thing. Like I don't think I've really played a game that's put me in this headspace before, and I would like to explore it more.

Progress saved