Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 153: Holly Black on Enemies and Lovers

Transcript 53:38

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and is as usual they're up to some amazing things their next game hydrologic cycle is currently on Kickstarter and you should absolutely go and check it out clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con the next course Jason Fury's crowdfunding with confidence starts on May 6th and we'll teach you all about board games and crowdfunding go check it out and I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com beond soliter thanks to listeners like you have been able to keep upgrading my equipment subscribing to streamyard and more uh but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from beond solitire and this week on the podt I have a very special guest this is young adult author and now board game designer Holly black she is a very big deal I'm super excited to have her on how you doing today Holly I'm doing really well thanks for having me I am super excited to have you on and very excited to find out that not only are you a literary nerd but you're a nerd like us um but for for people who don't know who you are which I'm going to assume those of you who are not young adult readers in the audience might not um why don't you introduce yourself and talk a little bit about your wider work so I have been a fantasy novelist for about two decades now I've published over 40 books some of them um for young kids a lot of them for young adults a

few of them for adults um and uh probably my best known work uh is the folk of the air series which the game I'm going to talk about is based on um and the spider Chronicles uh and there was a TV show out on Roku as a Friday for spider wait seriously yeah really I was out of I gotta I gotta get on this excellent so you've been a writer for a long time did you ever expect to design a board game and how did that come about for you you know I I probably should have thought about it but I I did not um so I have been a gamer for pretty much my whole life um you know I was deep into Dungeons and Dragons in my youth um I still play today but like there was a time when it was you know a a huge focus of all of my time in college I had a big map of Water Deep up on on the wall um I had the old red box like the first early set before it was Advanced it was just dungeons of dragons now it's I guess dungeons dragons um and you know from there just played a lot of games I uh right out of college edited a Gaming magazine called d8 magazine which was a tiny like startup where I would go around it was it was during the the rise of card games sort

of the end of liveaction roleplay playing being like the dominant thing that was happening at like Gen Con and moving into games like obviously magic but also inom and like a bunch of different um let the five ranks like that kind of stuff so that was during the period where I was much more involved in like the actual business of games and then I kind of went away and um like wrote books and in that weird way that you do forgot how much I had been involved you know in this in this industry and um at some point uh I was asked about oh well would you ever you know would you ever do something with a game let someone license a game and I had been on tour uh so I had this conversation like at the beginning of tour and I thought oh you know I have some friends who've designed games like I could go and and ask them and then as the tour went I was like or I could just try like I could just try real quick and then I was like okay or I could download a ton of books about gaming Theory and then I could come home and be like family I have made a game let's try it and uh and sort of that was part of like the Journey of the

beginning of me making this game because that first idea of what a game was was entirely wrong like my first sort of attempt at Game Theory you know it's interesting I really missed what made a game because I thought the game was the mechanic and it turns out the game is the the wild you know the wild sort of separate business like that's actually the stuff that makes the game work and fun so you mentioned that you looked a lot of game theory how long did it take you to go from thinking about this to like doing the Prototype and what did your first prototype kind of look like so for those of you who out this game is called enemies and lovers and it is a tight little two to four player card game I probably should that thank you um so I was interested in trying to find a way that I could link characters together um I thought that that would was something that like one of the challenges right is not just you know making a fun game but like making a fun game that felt like the books and they're romantic they're sort of lush and decadent and they're mean there's a lot of backstabbing there's a lot of murder and poisonings and um and they're fairies so they're also Trixie and untrustworthy and um things of that

nature so I was like what how can I represent that somehow in a game um and I had this idea and this is the idea I started with where I thought okay maybe this is like worth something and it has lasted the whole uh the whole way which is to have a hand whereas your you know your cards that you are playing with and then your court which is your cards that you are sort of placing down and will eventually win from but the idea of it being a court that you assembled and therefore you had to link like a prince in this case with a conspirator and you had to learn you know link them by some means that was not necessarily you know uh great like for instance you know knowing their true name which is a very folkloric piece of business but you know nobody wants the other person to know their true name and therefore be able to control them so that was sort started with and I thought I got something I did not have anything

so how many iterations did you go through to get to this um this version of the game that's going to go on Kickstarter so I came home and I got I got um like basically Magik card backings and I started putting little slips of paper into them with the rules and that's what I like we just played over I have no idea how many iterations because I don't even know how to like how to gauge it right because I brought it home and I played it and I immediately realized it was terrible and then I came up with some more variations and more um things you could do and then I took it to my family and I have a a 10-year-old son and my husband who's been a long time gamer and we just played it over and over and you know came up with different things we wanted to do and different things that turned out to be confusing and then we started playing it with friends and then we play started playing it with strangers and just Tred to refine it it's a lot like editing a book you can't be precious about it you got to throw things out you know so we're gonna Circle back to that but one thing is so maybe that's an assumption on my part but I do not think of authors as people who kind of Workshop their work widely to a lot of strangers before publishing it but with games that kind of play testing is really common practice right so how did it feel for you to expose vulnerable work to large groups and uh how did you

figure out how to process that feedback because I feel like that's different from taking editorial feedback where somebody scribbles on your on your manuscript I mean it it definitely is right because I I am a work Shopper I have you know a group of people who Workshop My Books sometimes I'll Workshop it with a group and then I'll Workshop it with several individuals but it is true that they are all known to me um but I have certainly gone into situations where I didn't know the people I was going to workshop with um you know sometimes you'll go to like a larger Workshop or you'll go to you know just into a situation where you're with new people um and so I tried to approach it like that you know um I teach workshops too and a lot of times those are students who don't know each other before this moment right and you know we always talk about like you have to look at the feedback you're getting and say to yourself does this resonate with the story I want to tell right is this speaking to the story I want to tell and most likely they are identifying correctly that there's something wrong but most likely their solution is not the right solution and so I sort of looked at it that way like if people are saying there's a problem there's a problem you're not going to get away from from that you know um but it doesn't mean that the thing they want is necessarily what you should give them you just need

to find a way to fix the problem it's hilarious that you say that because I've literally heard another game designer say something like that within the last like couple weeks so it seems the processes are maybe more more links than you would think um so the other thing is that you know when you're taking play test advice I think you know changing wording or changing order of events or something is maybe a bit different from deciding mechanically what to do especially if you've never designed a game before so what were some of like the biggest changes me mechanically to the game that kind of came from play testing with Outsiders um so I had a couple of different sort of one thing I realized is that I had a friend who is a super you know has many many many games has played games over many years and he a lot of great advice for me but he also super wanted the game to be more complicated and so at some point like I sort of introduced some things that in the play test I really needed to shave off because they were making it over complicated but the biggest thing I took away from the play test was um I needed to mark on the cards several things that I had never considered For No Good Reason marking before um there's a particular card called a trickster uh that can B basically stop a lot of attacks and the logic of what attacks it can stop are is pretty straightforward but they got nervous and

confused and they wanted it marked on the card easily done but I understand how that could be super stressful if I hadn't done it and in the same way there's a bunch of cards that like there's cards that are like draw two there's cards that are like steel one and saying how many like do you draw and do this can you mark that on the card I can but I didn't you know so I think actually like putting a bunch of things on the cards that I had not considered putting there was the biggest play test note oh that's really really interesting all right so then I did want to walk back so you mentioned that like editing for a game is a lot like editing for a book how did I guess the drafting process for this game like feel for you in comparison with you know writing a daily word count or you know doing outlining for a book I mean I've been writing for a long time I have a lot of deadlines and um this felt like playing and all I wanted to do was sneak away and do it so it's really hard to compare it I would be like you know I would I would I do um a lot of times like uh pomodoros where I'll like set time and then I'll write continuously for that time and then I'll have a little time to break take breaks and I was taking my breaks like looking up different things about games like trying to figure out how to write rules because it's a very different kind of writing that kind of

technical writing and just you know so for me this was such it was so fun to be bad at something and having to figure out how to get good at it do you think that you will continue to design games that you one like have you caught the fever I don't know I mean I it feels like I was so lucky to think of something that felt like my books that I don't know if I would like I don't know if I would luck into it I would love to again um you know I keep thinking like I would love to help um like my kid make a again or like do something where that felt really different than what I did do I don't know what I'm gonna like I still feel so deep in this I'm like will I do it again I remember when I wrote my first book and I had sold it and my and I was super like I was waiting for it to come out and I was doing and my editor was like you need to write another book and I was like another one I just wrote this one it took me so long 40 books later right so that kind of leads me to another set of questions so you know you you created a game that's deeply intertwined with the folk of the Year Trilogy and like even just looking over the rules because I've also read the books it was very easy to link up the different mechanisms and what they represented and what the characters

meant to each other um so I guess the first question is how did you make the game feel like the books without over complicating it and then in pursuit of that um were there things that you wanted to get in there that were left out um so you could kind of link up a bunch of different people in different ways um I had a time when if you linked people sort of um for instance they're the protagonist there's a love interest there's you know a way that they are sort of linked and I thought it would be cool to figure out a way to make that give you some kind of bonus or give you a special power and I tried a version of it that did that and that was too complicated and just I think not worth like it was one of those rules that you know you could just sense that people's house rule would be leaving that out because because the thing you know like you just you just it feels like extra yeah and so I just cut it uh um so when you're trying to like make games match up with a a literary property um did that did that prevent you from I mean we talk about like you

know extraneous mechanisms and maybe trying to go too close to the plots like sort of like when you're making a historical game it can't just redo history it has to have enough flexibility to still be a game right um but what was the core feeling that you wanted your players to have um the thing that you would cut everything else out in service of that I want them to have that feeling of throwing down a card and really screwing somebody like like that like that to me is like that core game pleasure oh see I'm a solo and Cooperative gamer so like I do enjoy screwing somebody over a little bit a little bit but we family we just

I will say this for for my son he you know as a tend he's a he's very good at not winning he because he truly understand like he truly like like has played enough to appreciate like the game that's fantastic also I will say that having a very nasty game full of betrayals is extremely true to the books so there there's I think that was the thing I really really I want it to be fun as a game separate from the books yes uh are you worried that instead of going from enemies to lovers this will go this will take people from lovers to enemies that is why it is called enemies and lovers rather than enemies lovers um so when you uh you know I've seen some illustrations from um the game and I looked up the studios Frost Studios yeah yeah and they seem to kind of do a lot of literary themed art on Twitter how did you pick them and how did that collaboration work for the game so I was looking at different one thing that I felt like there's so much character art here that working with an artist who actually knew the books would be the only possible way that they would be able to sort of engage with this amount of different characters and things and um and also like for them to

I think then get not just the characters descriptions but the aesthetic and so I saw I saw their work and I just super loved it um I also felt like I had pulled a piece and put it like into an early you know draft of the game and it looked so beautiful like it looked exactly right it it was um like easy to read from a distance and easy to read small um and just like super elegant and fun I mean you know one of the things that I love the most is she did um or like uh there's one for a card called writing Toad and it is a beautiful large toad with a um with a sadle on it it's so good makes me so happy to look at that's really really fun so this kind of leads to a follow-on question which is you know you've this is clearly going to be a game that extremely appeals to people who liked the the folk of the air series and who are very interested in the world of alame yes hoping that they will be like beautiful art I'm in you know what that works a shocking amount of time but um how do you hope that your game will pull in people who aren't necessarily familiar with the series so like if you've got a family and one member of the family has read your books and the others have not um how what kind of responses are you getting from

testers who maybe didn't know the books uh but are willing to play the game um I think that the fact that it's fast um quick to learn I think uh you know it's lightweight but there's some strategy no little parts no tallying um I believe this will draw people in I try to make the kinds of stuff I like I don't want to be counting and I will immediately lose everything and so I wanted it to be self-contained it's not collectible you know it is it is what it is and hopefully it will be you know fun to uh try to get the crown assemble your court you need Prince a conspirator a coercion card to link them and you need the one Crown in the deck crown of belf Fame which you can uh must you know steal poison and uh you know otherwise attack to protect or to get yes by hook or by cick Yeah by hook or by cick you need to get it in your court so so you mentioned you'll enjoy kind of light quick easy setup low overhead games so what are some games in that vein that you've been playing that have been keeping you hooked I mean it

definitely our family play a lot of exploding kittens and as a result we also uh played some throw throw burrito which is which has taught the concept of dueling very important I don't know if you played it fantastic pretty great I've never we do love love letters uh I played some coup some Guillotine um my son loves Dixit which is a very different kind of game but super super loves it um cat crimes that's really fun oh that's I like that I love I love the idea of like a good family game night um so when when it comes that it sounds like that is kind of the core audience for you when you're playing games like you want to play with your family um who are you imagining as the core audience for enemies and lovers who is who is the ideal person you picture playing this game I mean I know that for me as a like you know longtime like roleplaying gamer one of the positions I often found myself in is with a bunch of people who were not and who I had to extremely quickly get in and so I guess for me when I think about playing and I think about somebody who you know is is a reader of my books and has taken a chance on this weird game that they've saw on

Kickstarter and now they have it and it has a lot of shiny foil and they're with some friends who don't know the books and who maybe have some time maybe they're at College you know maybe they're you know out in the world and you know at at a bar or whatever and they're like you want to play quick you want to play quick game like you want to play a game and like let's really get into this and let's um have fun and be mean to each other fantastic it's a that's the the right way to maintain all gamer friendships uh so I do have a question so I'm I'm looking at the kickstarter preview page um and you know you're the you're the project Creator and it sounds like so little brown and Company's your publisher right so I guess my question is did you have to consult with them at all to do this game or is this all you and you made all of like are are you the publisher of this game as well I am indeed the publisher of this game so um when you sell a book and you know for anybody out there who's considering you know traditional publishing when you sell a book one of the things you're doing with your contract is you're NE negotiating what rights you reserve and so you know you can reserve game rights you can reserve film rights you can reserve um comic adaptation rights you can reserve audio rights uh you can reserve translation rights and all of these things are things that you know you really need to actually think about if you're not reserving what are you getting in return for them so

there's my weird weird if you're selling a book pitch you know be careful of your sub rights and so I have my gaming rights and um it turns out that right now my book is not under option which turn which is great because actually a film option might well have put me in a position where I wouldn't have these rights but we under option yeah that's actually the the big one it's not your publisher it's it's film adaptation they often take the game rights too and really I bet they would take and I assume they would take paper game rights when they took really what they would be wanting to reserve as video game rights right because that's you know such a huge industry equally the size of a film um but I think they probably would have taken the paper game rights too but because I'm out of option I'm in a position where I can make my own game and I can and I can do this thing and we can print it ourselves my husband's designing it he did the line art um for the back of the card and so he's been doing like all the layout stuff um wow and we've just been doing it together that's awesome and my agency is sort of helping me out um as you can see because they they talk to you I know uh yeah because they are fascinated I think

with um with like how does this work okay Holly you're really GNA do this thing all right we we'll help you a little and we'll watch what's you know what you're doing that's absolutely fantastic so the other thing then is that you know I'm I'm assuming that you have not contacted a printing press about the print of your own books or done your own layout have you done those things in the past yes uh so oh awesome yes I've talked to a printer like I'm I'm the person who's in contact with the printer yeah no we're really doing so for novels too you've done that oh no never okay that's yeah that's the thing oh this is my first time oh man so how did you how did you figure out who to ask uh so I went online it turns out there's a lot of resources for for starting game designers and I read a lot of I read like all the stuff you know everybody else probably reads and I reached out to a bunch of different printers I also there was a Kickstarter um literary Tarot deck that I was a part of um and I reached out to the um publisher of that and they were incredibly gracious and gave me a lot of advice and talk to me about the printer they used and uh there's a lot of learning as you go and I think that is absolutely part of

what I love about doing this even though it is scary because yes all of this stuff is not stuff I usually deal with at all that is really cool um do you feel that it has impacted I guess your creative process to be behind all parts of the creative process yeah I mean it feels it feels like doing something super new it feel it is a reminder um I think of you know that that you can do something really different that um you know that there was a time when when what I am doing now felt really um scary and uncertain and I mean publishing is always scary and uncertain but the actual process now I I know very you know I know well I know the industry well and so to learn something just from the jump when I don't know any part of it is right is exhilarating and scary but exhilarating so um so one of the things that people have talked about a lot in recent years in gaming um is the possibility for games to tell stories and to contain narrative so you come from the sort of narrative creation side of gaming primarily sounds like because of your past with with sens and dragons and role playing um but there are also I think a lot of I guess I think I guess we're having more increasingly critically serious conversations about board games and how we talk about them and what they do what they make people

do what they express as someone who is now both an author and a game designer what sort of narrative and storytelling possibilities do games have um that maybe are very different from what novels are able to do well I mean I think there's a I mean there's a couple things one is there's a participatory aspect where like one thing that you're doing in a novel is your um you're having the experience of being in some sense a character and experiencing their decisions but you are separate from their decisions and in fact sometimes it's incredibly pleas able to go along with a character who is making terrible decisions right but there is something different about making those terrible decisions yourself and I think that um actually weighing your own decisions figuring out what kind of player you are figuring out what kind of way you want to move through a game right is a very different experience um I think uh the idea that you can do things again and again differently is a way that you're experiencing a game that you're obviously not going to experience most books right the idea that something can have a different end each time you know is is is is interesting when it comes to

narrative and um and not always true like a lot of games sort of funnel you towards one end right but there is the possibility of games with many different ends and many different ways of of of experiencing them I had a friend who um he he made um and I think he kickstarted these they were cards and they were story and you could reshuffle them and each time you reshuffled them and pulled a bunch you got a different story and the way he wrote them they each time you did it it made a story and it was so interesting to hear I went to a reading where he just did it and it was just incredible to hear and I think that games have that that quality right each time it's a different story oh that's that's a really cool way to put that so that also leads to sort of you know when now that as you're designing this game you're still kind of doing things in the universe of elfhame like I know the stolen error is about Oak grownup yeah um but you know you've also got this established series with established relationships between the characters is it strange to watch your readers not only read your story and interpret it or be like oh I hate you how could you've done that to my favorite character you know all the things that we do to authors um but also kind of co-create with you with established characters through playing

your game is that how you feel it's happening like do you feel like you've opened up your narrative for other people to kind of mess with a different way um or do you kind of separate what's going on with the game off from from that so um I should have said my my friend who did the interchangeable cards was jedia Barry um but with this I because of the way I had to structure it around the crown of alame H it really is a limited set of time within the books so and it is a time that has passed and so people are participating in a way but the books themselves almost are a version right this is how it worked out um and so it it it does not move forward in time because this is really about like who becomes the king and we know who becomes the king but not necessarily the only way it could have gone right uh the other thing I think is really interesting about seeing a ya book adapted for games specifically is that the I think the last time I saw statistics what 60% of ya readers maybe more are are women that makes that checks out there's also actually a high percentage of adults who are ya Raiders yes I was going to get there um so I'm just interested in this question both when it comes to books and to games so you know when I look at my own statistics I feel like I'm kind of an elder Millennial um

and I feel like one thing that's also very interesting is you know I read a lot of ya still in addition to other things I read like the full spectrum U of of book but I still really enjoy ya um do you feel that your card game is most likely to be played by young people or kind of people already in that slightly older board game Community that's a great question and I'm not sure um certainly so um my friend Cassandra CLA just did a Kickstarter for books um but one of the things that she found was that a lot of her readers were coming to Kickstarter had never Kickstarter before and so they were like what is this crowdfunding you speak of you know um because it just wasn't part of of you know the ecosystem in which they moved right and I don't know what will prove true for me you know I know there's a lot of games on Kickstarter I have backed a lot of games on Kickstarter um but I don't know who of my readers will come along for this and so I think it probably will be some degree of a cross-section you know hopefully some young people you know hopefully anyone who would like it but um but I yeah I really honestly don't know because I think part of the

question is who is familiar enough with Kickstarter you know um and you know who plays games that's a really good part of that I want to talk about maybe the gender distribution as well so as as we were kind of like laughing about before um we went on air you know there are more and more women and people of color and just you know the The Gaming Community gets more and more diverse by the year sometimes I feel like by the month it's a great thing um but you know a lot of I like I look at my own YouTube audience and I know this isn't true for the comments I get but it'll be like oh yeah like all your viewers are men mhm um and then you know when you think about kickstarting a game um are you I mean I I I know you play test with a lot of people did you see any um I guess interest among young women in playing your game in particular uh and then also do you think that your game will have strong crossover appeal for like the full audience of people who like board and card games so the way I wound up um play testing this I was play testing it with um board gamers because I I was reaching out to I have um a friend who runs like a local game night and so I was recruiting from sort of a you know a pool of people that I could find that I knew played games um and then I played sort of individually with smaller groups or people who maybe weren't as familiar with games but I think in my

experience gaming has always been more diverse than its representation you know as a a like I'm so I'm a Gen X you know um generationally genx person generationally um and you know as as a woman going to jaff conon at that time you know there weren't necessarily you know a ton of of women there but there were always you know women in these spaces and you know um and I think that they're not necessarily always though going to conventions um and they're not always going to the same kinds of conventions like I think as a as I go to sort of your science fiction uh literary conventions which have a very different demographic than like ComicCon which is incredibly diverse right and is grown more so over time and so I think it's always hard to know who is actually playing the games versus who is making the narrative about who is playing the games I like that that's a good answer uh yeah I think about that myself um I'm actually sort of quietly hoping that this game will get people who get it for the books to contemplate

getting more games as well um so kind of speaking to that you know there are books that get made into games so you know there's a red Rising Game a few years ago um you know things like World of the Rings in Game of Thrones like you know High fantasy stuff easily translates did any of your fellow authors Express surpris that you were doing a um a folk of the air based card game and also do you think that there will be more projects like this uh coming up the pipe I mean I really hope so yes I I think a lot of people were surprised that I was making a game um I think in part because you know we all are we're all working we're all sort of like okay what's your next project what's your next thing and to do something that is sort of different and sideways I think they're like wait what are you doing over there what's happening um you know and you know you also have that moment of being like okay I need to convince you of the legitimacy of this game so you know like we're going to sit down and play and when it's actually fun there's that moment of not just of like surprise and relief like with each person because you know they're like okay you're doing this is this a good idea or a bad idea and great idea it's been it's been

it's been great to actually like then be like like hey guys will you play with me will you you know give it a try will you give me some feedback and um and people have given again great feedback over the over time but yes uh much some some real surprise uh and do I think people will do it all right here's my pitch if you are a novelist and you're listening to this and you make your own game think about it you're automatically reserving part of your gaming rights

come on I hear that so you know you use the word legitimacy earlier like the legitimacy I guess of like making a game and and making sure it's not some sort of crackpot idea but I also find it very interesting to talk about the legitimacy of games like in relation to other media I think that and this is also I think that sometimes ya is unfairly seen as less legitimate than other types of of literature so I mean may just be that you're kind of used to it yeah luckily I came up in fantasy so I was ready for it yeah I was I was you know I was like oh really another genre people don't people frown on let's just frown at everything and never have any fun um but uh do you consider games to be um a type of media that is I mean do you see it as as expressive as or as worthy of critical attention as um the things that we read read absolutely I mean I think um we are so I I read a book once called doll bones which was about um kids who were playing dolls and the moment when you no longer are able to play dolls and I realized that I had carried a lot of shame because I was a kid who really loved playing when my friends wanted to stop I really felt like childish and it took me a long time to sort of

process that feeling and realize that storytelling with your friends is not childish storytelling with your friends is a human experience that we have had throughout time and is incredibly rewarding what it isn't though is it doesn't produce a lasting product it is ephemeral right and it it is not curated it is not edited it is you know impulsive and sudden and you know created in a way that is not able to happen again in exactly the same way and I think that makes it hard to talk about academically right because you can't point to it because what it is it is a moment in time and it is gone but that is also what is so precious about it because it really is something that is is about Community it's very interesting to hear it put this way I I definitely agree about sort of like the co-creation and the ephemeral nature of of um a specific instance of play uh but as a historical gamer I'm also like very fascinated in games as like historical statements like what kinds of setups are you creating what do that how how do we interpret you know through a game like a historical period or like forces that push people politically right that is really interesting because it is something that I think a book cannot do

because a book um a book is taken as it is and so if a book has a for instance if if a book has a political bent that you don't agree with you're going to notice and very likely I mean it can sort of take you it can take you in a way where like um let me take something non-political like the the which in the wardrobe right which has Christianity sort of baked in and which you might not see and therefore has a kind of of thing under the thing yeah but by and large it's easier to see that stuff I think in literature rather than it's true in a game if you know for instance if you have a game about um you know how great of a serial killer can you be you are you are taking on a position right in that case not a not a particularly subtle one and I don't think anyone would come away from that being like ah an advocacy for murder but it's true that like if you if the winning conditions of a game are um not ones you necessarily agree with you might not notice I actually just want to come out and support of women's wrongs because I haveen played it yet one of my most like hot on my list of Play It's called deadly dowagers and it's about murdering your husbands plural to become increasingly wealthy while not getting too much notoriety for their disappearances I actually think my

friend has I believe my friend has that and he wants to run it but he has like we've never had a chance to do it I'm so excited about that game at least I know it was I know it was old I know he had a game that was old ladies and we were going to murder some people that sounds great honestly um but yeah you know kind of on on theme for what we sort of talked about on and off throughout the interview you know when you are reading a book you're presented with a narrative where the events are set and you can kind of read you know everybody's going to have a different take on something that you write like I'm sure you're used to lots of different takes on things you write um because a lot of people have read your books uh but you can kind of do your best to get at authorial intention and like try to figure out what the writer meant with games that is a little bit muddier because you it's it's a the because the players are active participants it it changes how it feels even if the designers set you up to do specific things because once you're in it too you're like complicit as opposed to just sort of consuming sure I mean to to win my game you need to poison people you need to attack people like that is part of it's true that like you know you need to betray people like that is part of the sort of baked in structure of the game is that if you are you you can't play nice you know um I don't think there's a way to you know to to move through it that

doesn't involve doing some harm and that that is it that is a choice but it's and it's true that it's an obvious one and I think what you're talking about are ones where it's much less obvious right where you find yourself doing things and you don't necessarily know that's where you are going to start indeed I like it when a game kind of brings something out of me you know that I maybe didn't expect I think I'm a nice person and then I play games I'm like oh I I had that in there too um but choose kindness see it's not as valuable if you don't have to choose uh and then sort of one more question about I guess your game and then your your books in general so um you know the cruel Prince is set in Fairy and it's a very interesting I would say very nice blend of um you know accepted fairy lore and then your version of things how fairy do you think that your game feels and kind of having those like conventions of the land of fairy as part of the backdrop did any of that make it into your game and how so I had a lot of conversations actually um with my husband when he was trying to when he was doing sort of the border design stuff uh about what it meant to be INF fairy and I think the thing I landed on is this is very high court fery and you know when we so it is less like the numinous sort of small creature

strangeness of fairy um yeah and uh as a result I think it is less folkloric in that specific way um because it is Royal Crest Crest Crown stuff I think it has some high fantasy business that does not necessarily feel fa like but I think there's um a lot of Whimsy in it and um a lot of like strangeness in that sense like you can steal someone's whole court and switch it with yours um and you can uh let's say you can grab from the discard you can do a bunch of of you can make everyone show their hand you can do like these kind of big Whimsical moves that feel fa to me very nice um and then just the the sort of obvious question when is this hitting Kickstarter May 1 May 1 so we are recording this just about a week out but those of you who are listening this is running the day before so um I will have the kind of launch page in the show notes so you can go check it out um but just a couple softy questions before we let you go so I normally ask people um what uh what game is currently giving you a lot of Joy but because you're an author I also want a book recommendation oh my gosh

um let's see what game so um I think we so gutin is probably the thing that we had not played as a family before and I wasn't sure how much I would love it I had a friend who like super super loved it and uh we're deep in now it's uh there's a lot of there's uh we have played it like through a couple of times and we're starting to like there's a lot of little rules and I admit the first time we played it through we were like okay this is just cut off people's heads this is great and then I was like oh there's a lot of actual some more stuff to do here um I'm trying to think what else I feel like I just got a game that is that everyone has been playing for a long time I think it's the sushi game that everyone's been playing forever Sushi go which we never played and yeah that's a very cute game very cute um and then I so the game that I am really excited about trying that was on Kickstarter that is a big game and very different is old king's crown oh yes Pablo is wonderful I'm very excited I mean I super excited about it so beautiful looking yes yes and mechanically I I know it's had some changes since the last time I played it but it is looking good yeah it looks so good and very different and that's one that I do not think we will you know I I don't know if my son is ready for but

like I'm really excited to actually like play it with friends fantastic and as is true of uh you know the of enemies and lovers on a small scale this one's mean it's excellent exced I'm so excited and then a book wreck I know you've got lots of books you could recommend what is bringing you um I'm trying to think what I read recently uh let me see oh gosh um okay so my friend Libra Duo's book came out recently called the it's called The Familiar and it's really Lush and um really beautiful it's historical fantasy and uh it is I can't recommend it highly enough so beautiful so good fantastic fantastic and then just for people who want to follow your work online uh where do you most like to be found um you can find me on Instagram where I think I'm Holly black but it might be black Holly I'm sort of one of those two and I'm on uh and my website is black holly.com perfect Holly thank you so much for taking the time to come on here and talk to us about your game and about your work in general and just the the lot of it well thank you so much for having me I really appreciate it all right out there uh if you're looking for me online I can be found anywhere as Beyond Solitaire so please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved