A Look at Spire's End: Hildegard
Transcript
thank you hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay today in the dungeon today we are going to be taking a quick look at spiers in Hildegard this is the Standalone follow-up to the original spire's end which I have taken a look at on the channel before uh this game was provided to the dungeon dive as a review copy so uh thank you uh favrogames uh this game was designed by Gregory Favreau with illustrations by Diego Frias and Audrey rovin I did purchase the small expansion that is kind of like a booster pack that adds a few cards to your set but I have not mixed those in overall I think spiers and Hildegard is a pretty good game I've had a few frustrations with learning the game and we'll talk a little bit about those later but if you are looking for another game to add to your collection of game book style games presented as card games then you will probably want to look into spire's end I know it will be delivering or is delivering now from Kickstarter and I am hoping that this one does go to retail so that other people have the opportunity to play this game because with just a few caveats I think I can recommend this I've been having a lot of fun so in the game you are going to get four
decks of cards that are separated into chapters so this is one of those games where a lot of the fun is in the discovery is then flipping over the cards and seeing what comes next so I'm not going to be showing a ton of stuff for the game because I don't want to accidentally spoil anything major I will show on screen some pictures of some of the cards and I will do a quick flip through of the deck 1 cards here for chapter one just so you can get a sense of some of the variety but you will get a large deck of cards for chapter one or chapters 2 3 and 4. so there are four chapters in this game one of the things that I was most attracted to about this game is the art and graphic design I also really did like the art and graphic design for spiers and the original but as you can see it is a very different uh the original spirez and used used these very large cards everything was black and red and gray it was very brutal it had a very Stark look to it whereas spiders in Hildegard has a much softer look to it but make no mistake the softer look may you may think that the game has a softer Edge to it that it's not as maybe kind of brutal or as violent or as as dark as the original because the original went to some pretty dark places and it was pretty violent and uh this game is uh keeps in that
tradition I was a little surprised because just by these softer tones and the colors used I thought this would be a little softer on that side but it is not and that's one issue I'm going to talk about a little later but I absolutely love the color of this game I love the dice the dice are Big And Chunky and they have really great soft colors the normal dice that you will be using in your combat checks are really nice we'll talk a little bit about the combat checks that's something I enjoy the plastic cubes are are nice if a little bit confusing we'll talk a little bit about that as well but overall I think this is a very well designed package in terms of visual presentation now I'm just going to very quickly fan through the cards from chapter one just so you can get a little look of them or look at them I should say I think there was a pretty strong Kingdom Death monster influence on the graphic design of the cards some of these cards look straight out of Kingdom Death monster especially something like that and that's not a bad thing if this is a very kind of classy looking game and I think it looks really good on the table I also like that it takes up a small space you know it doesn't take up a ton of space I know you can get one of those neoprene mats but it just the neoprene mat is much bigger than it needs to be if you just want to play a small game you don't need that mat and you can just play in a little space like this
so on my adventure through chapter one these are the cards that I didn't get to so a small stack of cards that I didn't get to and about I probably only saw about maybe a half of the cards in this particular deck so there is definitely some replayability there are definitely choices that you will make that will lock you out of accessing certain cards in each chapter so you can go through and make different choices and have different outcomes I saw two different endings in chapter one but the last ending I saw said that that was ending three so somewhere there was another choice that I could have made that would have given me another ending the endings do end your game but what I do is just like playing a game book I just kind of like went back to the uh decision point and continued playing with that other decision or without making better dice rolls or something like that just so I wouldn't have to start over I don't like starting over in these kinds of games I want one game to be kind of like that game's choices throughout with a fail forward and then the next time I play I'll make different choices I didn't want to reset up the deck and play the game again from the beginning so that's kind of up to you how you want to do it but you can kind of cheat just like you would in an old game book you know keeping your finger in the in the page so if you die you can go back but
just know that there are there are moments where the game will just end and sometimes those endings do come just because you didn't roll the dice Pro um you didn't get lucky with your die rolls and I know that that can be a little bit of a frustration to some people I think the story is well paced and that's one thing that I do like about this game there's a lot of energy to the narrative and it is pushing your character Hildegard through the opening scenario it feels like the it feels like there's an urgency to her Quest and I did really enjoy that there were Parts where I wanted to play faster because the narrative Drive was at a certain Pace that it just wanted me I wanted to keep going to see what was going to happen next in this kind of game that's kind of like the best recommendation I can give I do really like the dice system when you are trying to figure out combat so I'm going to show you a couple cards now these are I'm not showing you in any order so they're going to be out of context so I really don't think this is a spoiler but I'm going to show you how the combat works just because I think it is very interesting it uses a system that is kind of like Elder Sign or Yahtzee and so uh during the game there's a part where you want to shoot because you are armed with a slingshot I should show you some of the items I've gotten I have received in my quest I found a will I found a fishing rod a
slingshot an enchanted bota bag a silver cap mushroom and a mysterious package Hildegard is a marksman she is a great shot with her slingshot in order to kind of simulate that you're going to be rolling Dice and you're going to be combining different symbols to uh to make bullseyes and a bullseye will be a complete circle with a bullseye dot in the center so if you were to roll these two dice and you got this particular combo that would be considered a bullseye or if you got this combo it is a bullseye sometimes uh this combo will be a bullseye sometimes you will have uh something like that and then so that creates a circle and then you will roll a third dot so that creates a bullseye so you're looking for certain dice combinations and then what you're going to do is each test will tell you what you need to get how many bullseyes you need it will give you a super kind of a challenge where if you get this number here then you get a bonus and then each test will give you an accuracy value that's how many dice you get to roll per shot and that is it tells you how many shots you get they call sets so you get to roll four sets of three dice in order to get four bullseyes with uh on this plot on this pot and down here it tells you which symbols you can use to construct your Bull's eyes so on this particular test I can
use the half black I can use the white circle and the white dot and so then you play a little game of Yahtzee so I have three uh accuracy and I have four attempts so you're gonna roll your dice you're going to look at what you rolled and then you can lock one so I did roll a circle so I'm going to lock that Circle and now I can continue to roll in this first set I can continue to roll these two dice as long as you lock one you can continue to roll okay so I didn't get anything on that one so I do have to lock one and now I can roll I'm looking for a DOT okay so I did not get a bullseye on that set however at the end of each set you roll a what do they call this a a um a wild die and depending on the weapon that you are using but depending on the slingshot or other things you might get to roll a black dye this is kind of like the worst the this die gives you two chances to get a bullseye but it might give you a chance to lose one die or you might just get some blanks which don't do anything these other wild dice they might add something like a re-roll or maybe you can change a uh facing to any other facing and so these are used when you get other weapons so at the end of each set you roll your wild die and you see what you get okay so nothing so that set was a complete waste so I didn't get anything so then you would go on to your second set and your second set here let's roll that okay so I can't use those I can't use any of these but I do
have to lock one and then you can keep rolling okay I'm going to lock that dot and now I need to get a circle nothing okay so then you can roll your wild die and you would have to lose one of those so you could choose one to take away from that set combination as you can see I'm having very difficult time of passing this test sometimes you roll well sometimes you don't now uh there is a thing called Marksmanship and that is a currency that you can spend to help mitigate some of the luck during your dice checks and this is very handy so always make sure to have this card out we're going to talk a little bit about a frustration with this card towards the end of the video when we get to some of my frustrations with the game so that are that is a representation of a simple combat test a simple Marksmanship test where you are trying to shoot things there are also uh moments in the game where you will be fighting creatures you will be fighting animals and fighting other people and then it's kind of like a battle where you are trying to roll certain symbols to get bullseyes on the enemy and the enemy will be rolling their Dice and they will be trying to fill up this meter with their symbols and you can spend certain symbols that you have rolled in order to add blocking Cubes To Where the enemy has to roll two uh two of those symbols to get a single hit and so there is some contested roles and I think that is uh done really well
as well so the combat the dice mechanism the pushing your luck the Yahtzee style the the Elder Sign Style game here the dice game is a lot of fun I do really enjoy it and I think it does a good job of simulating um shooting a slingshot in a very weird way there is also a fishing mini game and I'll show up I'll throw up a picture of the phishing setup on screen and the fishing minigame is a lot of fun I like the way that that the cards get laid out there are times in this game where you will have to lay cards out in a certain order and so a lot of times with these kinds of Game books slash card games people ask like well you know shouldn't this just be a game book and I think this game does a good job of of separating itself from a game book by asking you to do certain things with the cards and you will lay out cards in a certain order and have to interact with them in a way that you just couldn't interact with them in a book form so that is another good thing um the last a really positive thing I do have to say is just the writing of the story I think is pretty good it's it's fun it's well written they do a lot with a little bit of text and I think that is another uh plus to the game as far as learning the game I have had some frustrations there are some things that just could be a lot clearer in some of
the decisions you make on the cards and in how the game teaches you to play one of the first cards you draw in the game tells you to take three gold and two feets of markmanship but that's kind of before you even really know what those things are and in reading the book it doesn't have a component a detailed component list at the beginning of the rule book it tells you what you get in the box but it doesn't tell you what to use the various items for until all the way back here on page nine I believe it tells you what to use for uh to keep track of your gold and your Marksmanship it's just it's a little frustrating in how the book is laid out you might think that this is a learn to play as you play the game style uh card game but it's really not you really do need to read the entire rule book before you start just because of the way things are ordered in the rulebook I don't think they're ordered in a very logical way there are some inconsistencies I think in some of the language about how you are supposed to manipulate the cards in the deck and I was a little confused there were just there were a handful of times while I played through chapter one and I started to second guess myself if
I was playing the game correctly and I think just with just some tightening up of of the rules of how they are written how they are presented I think that could be solved one really good example is the game tells you to work with like one chapter at a time so only have chapter one out when you're playing chapter one okay that's fine however the card that has what you can spend your Marksmanship on and the status effects this card is at the bottom of deck four I've actually seen some people who are who have taken pictures of their game while they are playing it and they don't have this card out if you don't have that card out you're kind of having to constantly check in the book to see the status effects and it's just it's odd that they don't say hey also pull out this card when you start the game and they're they're just enough things like that that just make the learning experience a little frustrating I also want to mention something that this is probably the first game I've ever played where I have questioned the age recommendation and this says 12 and up the original spiers and was pretty dark and it got pretty violent in some places but the original spire's end says 16 and up and I think that is appropriate I also think that this is a 16 and up game and that's part of the reason why I've mentioned how the art looks a little
softer it might portray or convey a softer tone to the story but I don't think that's the case I for me I I think this game should be 16 and up I just want to let people know because this is a two-player game I could imagine some parents buying this to play with their sons or daughters and um it is pretty violent there is some violent depictions if it's not the the the softer artwork does not mean that this is a softer story so just know that going in there is also one card that I was really taken aback by and that is this card here um this is a test where you are shooting at a crow a live crow that is strapped to a Target you do learn something about the crows later but I'm not sure it's all crews in the game that maybe softens this a little bit but I felt like this was just a little bit too close to animal cruelty for something that I would like to see in my games I'm not being overly sensitive I'm not saying don't play this game all I am saying is just know that there is some things like this in the game don't think that because it has a softer look to it that it has a softer Edge I would have liked to have known some more information before seeing this particular card that's all I'm that's all I'm going to say but yeah overall I think this is a pretty good Adventure game I'm having a lot of fun with it I am really looking forward to going into
chapter two there are some some threads that I'm interested in seeing how they uh you know how they end up and really enjoy this dice system it is a lot of fun very creative and a just a neat way to kind of simulate a uh you know using a slingshot and looking for bullseyes I don't think I've ever seen anything quite like this dice system in in a game and that is really cool I'm excited because I've seen some things in chapter one that are making me really excited to see what the game is going to offer in chapters two three and four and in a narrative German game that is a really good thing sorry guys well I hope you enjoyed this video I hope you enjoyed taking a quick look at spiers and Hildegard we will talk to you later bye-bye