Dragonkeepers Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I am taking a look at Dragon Keepers which is a two to four player card game designed by Michael menel this one takes around 20 minutes to play on average now before I get started on my review of dragon Keepers I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. c. who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order Okay so the setup for Dragon Keepers is going to look like this where you have these two decks of cards which formulate a book when put together now below those two stacks you're going to have two cards on display where the players are going to be able to draft their cards from now you can also see on the book you have a bunch of different information on there so this is essentially trying to show you which cards you are trying to play in front of yourself in order to score some points so in this example I want to play one one white dragon and as more cards replenish you can see how these um change either number or the dragon type now you also have a stack of these black dragons which are wild and you can get these through completing um these objectives and depending on the player count you're going to distribute some of these starting cards out as well just to counteract the first player Advantage now you also have a bunch of the different scoring components now the scoring is mostly consisted of these amulet pieces and when you put three of
them together like so you are going to collect one of these Little Gems which will go in the middle and they have a kind of random denominations of points on them um the red ones are slightly better so you're going to get a little Advantage if you get their first um just to you know give you a little boost if you are the first to complete those amulets you have these gems which give you some extra power when it comes to drawing the card you want as well as potentially synergizing with these bonus tokens if you choose to play with them so these are like an advanced module which kind of give you some gamebreaking abilities and we'll touch on these in a bit but for the first game it recommends that you do not use these uh you have these golden eggs which is another scoring mechanism where each time you collect an egg you're going to get four points but if you have the majority of eggs at the end of the game you're going to flip one of them over to get a massive 16 points and you also have these little bonus scoring tokens here where if you are the first to collect a type of or each type of dragon you're 16 points then 10 points and then six points depending on how fast you are so naturally the player with the most points is going to win the game and the end of the game will be triggered once a certain number of these amulets are made and that will change depending on the player count so let's talk about how the game play actually works so the first thing you can do on your turn is you can draw up to three cards from the display here now you can never top deck from here but you can always take either of of these and as soon as you take one of these so let's just say I took this
white dragon here and added it to my hand it's going to instantly get replaced by that relevant deck and you can see that each time that a card is replaced then the backs of these cards are going to change so you know in this example now I want to play two green dragons but maybe I'll take this green dragon add it to my hand as a second card and now I want to play two blue dragons and you can see how this works so after you have done or taken up up to three cards and there are valid reasons why you might not want to take all three because you might like the state of play on the books here but you have one chance to change the book types here by playing one of the cards in your hand you do have this kind of multi-use card system where you can play them as the dragon types or you can change the actual book state so let's just say I wanted to play um two um let's say I want to play two white dragons so i' play this blue dragon here from my hand which you can see on very very handily it says which type of dragon is on the back so i' flip it over like so put it on the stack and now I'm trying to play two white dragons and this is going to be my reward for doing that so I'm going to do that I'm going to play these two white dragons from my hand in front of me in my little scoring Tableau and I'm going to get the relevant rewards here now this particular reward says I will take the lowest level amulet piece so I'll take that amulet put in front of me which is going to get me another point at the end of the game and is also going to reward
me with a black dragon where if you remember this is going to count as a wild um for playing different types of dragons but I could also play it on the reverse side just like any other card which will give me a nice powerful ability but bearing in mind I'm going to have to play a massive six cards which will actually get me the highest level amulet which is a massive 20 points as well as the lowest level amulet and once you have um optionally played your bunch of cards matching the books all the other players in player order can play that as well so you do have to be quite careful about what what you're leaving here and maybe keeping a track on what the other people are collecting because ideally you do not want them piggybacking off your turns because they're going to also score the reward for doing so now that is essentially how the gameplay works you just drawing cards you have one chance to manipulate the book the book State and then you are going to play the um the cards from your hand if you can do so and all the other players will have a chance to do it as well and then it'll pass on to the next player however there is one additional twist to the game when it comes to the cards that you've already scored because of course there are only four different types of dragon but as soon as you have um kind of committed to playing a dragon type they remain locked in place in a particular order so you can see here I've already committed to scoring the white dragons and the blue dragons so say now I wanted to play these Red Dragons and I put it like like this I can no longer play the white dragons anymore because they are no longer on
the extremities I can only ever play Red Dragons and blue dragons from now on so you can see how you might want to pace yourself and not lock yourself out of scoring but as I mentioned earlier as soon as you play one of each of the four types of dragons you are going to be the or you're going to grab the highest remaining um scoring token here left which is quite a significant amount of points um if you do so so let's just ourselves again of the different scoring options so this is always take the lowest level amulet this one here lets you take one of the gems so the gems actually allow you to draw a fourth card from the um display to give you even more options to you know draw more cards but they'll also if you choose to use it let you use one of the special abilities which are very powerful just to show you a couple of them this one here will allow you to play um one of the Dragon cards that are in between the um the two remaining cards you've already played so you can see that it would let you break that placement rule that you wouldn't normally be able to do this one here lets you complete an objective by playing one card less than you need to I think this one lets you break the dragon type rule um and so on or this even here lets you take the next level up in terms of the the lowest level amulet to get some extra points um we've already talked about the golden eggs you know if you get a golden egg you get Four Points each the most of those you get 16 points and so on so and very simple stuff here yeah that take the highest level amulet um again more gems there more gems um and so on and
the black dragons which are nicely wild cards and that is essentially how the game works again you keep on doing that in turn order until a certain number of amulets are made and then at the end you're going to calculate all your points from your amulets flipping your gems over as well in between and scoring all the points from your golden eggs um from your um Dragon completion set set collection bonuses um and then player with the most points will be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on Dragon Keepers so first off I want to kind of um say how great this game is from a mechanical standpoint as simple as it gets no rules ambiguities just drafting cards one chance to change the card or change the book type and then committing to playing those cards if you can do so but I love how when it's not your turn you're always involved kind of eagerly eagerly looking at that book State thinking you know I'm going to play now because you you know if you can score when it's not your turn that's just fantastic because you're going to be adding towards your points through these amulets but this game has a great use of this kind of um Paradox between the rush strategy and being patient because there are definitely advantages to doing both because of course there are a very limited amount of amulets that get built before the end game is triggered but going too fast too soon you're going to get lumbered with these level one amulets which of course aren't great compared to some of the higher ones but kind of conflicting with that if you are rushing and getting all the ones then you're probably going to get
first dibs on these red gems which have more points um so there is that real incentive to either you know sometimes rush and catch people off guard because if you're too patient and you drag your heels you're not going to score anything but you're also kind of rewarded at the same time by collecting these huge sets which is going to take a bit more time and then getting those huge rewards because when you get to these level five Stacks um if I can find one there um you're going to get a really good reward by taking the highest value amulet which of course is going to massively counteract that that you know Rush strategy because you get a massive 20 points there there are other wrinkles to the gameplay here through that Timing System because you know when you are the active player you are the first person to cash in your cards and everybody follows you and because there are varying amounts of these different amulets you might have say the last level one here you might cash your cards take the level one and now you've just unlocked the ability to take level fours for the next players so again it's not always advantageous to actually score on your turn even though you have more you know manipulation tactics when or available to you at the same time that multi-use card system shine through strongly here um because you know sometimes you might want to be collecting these sets um but at the same time you might want to use some of those sets for the opposite power you know you maybe you have um you know you really need to play a big set there you want to play your five to change that book type but at the same time you are aiming towards collecting the particular type of dragon so you do have to um kind of pair off what you're keeping in your
hand as well as what you're playing to change the book State another thing to consider here is this kind of drafting system you might think at first well why wouldn't I always draft I know three cards and just really fill up my hand and that is because sometimes when you're drafting these cards you might get the perfect layout of cards there you know maybe I do have those five white dragons and I think you know do I do I really want to draft this cards and risk changing that or should I just stick with the one card that I've drafted you know maybe not have you know benefit hugely because my hand isn't going to get filled up as quickly but it's just the perfect layout here and I do not need to sacrifice a card for my hand to change it later so I do like that kind of um that conflict of filling up filling up your hand or remaining satisfied with how the board St actually is and another part of this game that I think is absolutely amazing is that commitment of playing the different suits in a fixed order in front of you you know locking out a cutter that you can no longer score it anymore now those cards might still be useful for you because you can use it to you know change the book state but this actually adds a whole new dimension to the game because you can actually keep an eye on what the other players are locked out of and you know you might be able to change the book state to think you know I can I can change it so I can just play one blue blue dragon where I know that all my opponents have locked out their blue dragons and can no longer piggy back off my turns because they can't play them and that does add a whole new dimension to the game as I said because you can
really exploit that and look other players out of scoring but at the same time you do have that again that conflict of wanting to rush somewhat to get to those big amount of points so it really is that kind of chicken mechanism of you know when is the time to stop me scoring a certain one and limit my options pairing that off with how many points I'm scoring in right now or how many points I'll score through that bonus token I'm really happy with the level of player interaction here and as I said there are a number of things you need to consider through the order in which you're taking those amulet tokens the competition for the golden eggs might be a viable strategy and you know a strong level of conflict between you and the other players that again that level of um utilizing the um the order in which you play these cards is important and locking other players out scoring particular types of dragons and using that to your benefit as well as that passive interaction in terms of having your fingers crossed so that the book State remains in your favor when it's not your turn so everything you do here has a thread of player interaction that keeps players engaged and speaking of Engagement this game moves at a very brisk Pace it's very engaging because you know again you're involved when it's not your turn the game only takes around 20 minutes to play so I think that depth to um to time ratio is Fant fantastic with this one and the production for this game is also right on the money for me know the cards look absolutely fantastic amazing illustrations by Michael Menzel um on the cars you can
see the dragons are super cute and they really do um pop and not only is the artwor great the actual symbology is great as well because know you have it on both the left hand and right hand um side of the card so depending on how you hold them it's all very clearly visible all the information you need uh to see the cards are slightly bigger than average which is quite nice um you know they're not L finished but there's no big issue there for me um all the extra components are absolutely fine and it all comes together nicely in a very affordable package you know I think I only paid about £18 for this game which um for me is is quite a rarity nowadays so I've got no issues at all with the production in fact I think it's pretty damn good okay so let's share some final thoughts on Michael Menzel's at Dragon Keepers and this game is so good I mean this is exactly the kind of game that I want in my collection just when you think you've seen it all with card games one like this comes along and just blows at you away I'm so impressed with everything this game has to offer love the scoring options and this one is like one of those games that when you first see it at face value you might question where the game is but I think halfway through your first game that penny is going to drop and you are going to start kind of um musing over the mistakes uh that you've made just as I've done done because you know you approach this game thinking you know I'll just keep on collecting the same bunch of cards and spam them when there's a high number that is probably not going to work for you because the amulet are going to quickly get gobbled up and you're going to leave yourself out of pocket and leaving yourself in a bit of a corner
already not giving yourself time to catch up with the other players so again I really do love that conflict between being fast but also saving yourself for the high scoring opportunities um just a wonderful Breezy game that time to depth ratio is off the charts here and what a breath of fresh air this game is and I I completely love it now I recently said in a review of a game called Forest Shuffle that that game is almost undoubtedly going to be um the best card game of the year and I might have spoken too soon because I think I might like this one even more which is saying something because Forest Shuffle is a fantastic game so I already have been spoiled for choice this year on great card games not just good card games but great card games and this one I think feels like an instant classic to me and I am head over Hills in love with dragon keeper so if you like the same kind of school of design that I do I have no doubt and no no hesitation at all in recommending Dragon keepers