Skip to main content
Loading video...

Perseverance: Castaway Chronicles - Episode 1 - Discussion

Transcript 54:42

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for perseverance castaway chronicles uh this discussion is going to be specifically for episode one we debated on whether or not we should do one big discussion for both of them but i think the games are going to be different enough it'll warrant two different discussions um so this uh we have played this game uh a few times now um and brett and i and and my wife we did like a quick trial um game prior to all of that and this is certainly a mind clash game like without a doubt um i i i hesitate to even say if it's heavier or lighter than all of them because i think all of them are just static heavy like there's not like veto lasagna it's like oh escape plan this is lighter one then you have in the no no they're just whoever is designing these like those five guys um just must be insane with with uh game design because you can just tell that this is a mine clash game uh which for me is a highly positive thing right i really really like this four variety reasons that we'll go over but i'm curious what what your guys's overall thoughts are um right what do you think of perseverance castaway chronicles episode one specifically i can tolerate it you can tolerate yes which i did not think listening to the rules i thought actually i tuned out i didn't

even get all the rules after after 20 minutes of the explanation that i watched i i have no idea what he's saying anymore right yeah you can almost hear because we we watched uh paul grogan so if you want to learn how to play i mean him or rodney smith excellent they're both both of those guys when i used to do how the plays and now if they have one i'm like i'm not even gonna bother like why why should i even try they're gonna do it better um but like uh you can almost hear him sigh after ever like before just i'm gonna talk about the assembly phase well and that's the thing like if you watch it it's like and this will affect the assembly effect which we're going to talk about later and then it goes the next thing and we're going to talk about the assembly phase which we'll talk about later right more about combat and because there's always live sections later as those sections yeah well because there's so many actions you take that have no immediate effect but you're it's like so far forward planning right like when placing dice in certain areas like the first eye of your color you place it's just like yeah obviously i want to do that action there but i'm also wanting to control it ten dice from now right um and i hope i can still control it so there's a lot of forward thinking in this game um but anyway brett keep going well that's you know you're right and that is exactly why it's not my kind of game now i do appreciate it and i do as i said it's tolerable which i really didn't think it would be yeah um after playing it one time i really wasn't interested at all in trying it again yeah but you know it is definitely easier it's definitely quicker yes i i understand

the actions better i still don't understand the layering effect that you have to in order to win um i did okay but honestly i don't know how or why i just happened to do kind of my strategy became let me take second placing everything instead of trying to gain the lead and fight for lead all the time at anything yeah well what was your final score 121 what was yours 120 oh you so you edged him out by one point yeah but but but he came roaring back that last round that's true right and i didn't i flattened because i'd like you know i started out resource heavy i spent all my resources and i never really got them back yeah we all went for a strategy that we had talked about doing differently last time we played um mainly to i feel like that was also to see if it was balanced oh hey i'm going to try this and see if it works if it's a valid strategy uh and that's one of the things that makes me praise this game is the strategy we had talked about seeing if it's a viable option is very much a viable option yeah which i i would not have seen why because prior to us playing it and i was just like i'll do walls i think i put i have two soldiers and that's only because one of you gave me one i think i had only two soldiers i didn't take a single patrol card only contributed with walls but with how many breaches that kept happening like and keep getting safeguard the the one that happened to be out there i was like oh i have all these dice okay i'm just gonna keep getting 16 points yeah so which i i didn't even

think about when we talked about that as a strategy of oh yeah you can just get a bunch of points for the dyno attack right which is where i thought about so like i messed up because i was kind of going the wall strategy and then fell behind and i went really heavy with the commander for the patrol but then just never went on patrol and that's where this game is there's lots of avenues to go and play the game you kind of focus on one maybe two avenues and that's your game yeah yeah um like you went walls pretty much exclusively yeah i had one left and that was your game you know walls and dice yeah dice plays dice and that was it that was your strategy for this game yeah and i kind of again went broad spectrum like i did last time and wasn't bad i mean our spread is actually less than it was last time we played yeah um and so and i think when end of second round i was 50-ish points behind you and now i am 30 30. yeah so it's not like you can't come back from it oh yeah um no not at all especially with the the votes and the voting process like if if we like to counteract like my strategy if you guys had um i think the only reason my strategy did so well is because we had constant dino attacks yes so if you guys had been putting out soldiers to defend those my two yeah i'd still be getting points my walls would still contribute because they go before so you can't completely shut out someone for doing that but i wouldn't have had such a drastic lead um

we also had fewer attacks because we would actually have fewer attacks yeah so it wouldn't i wouldn't have always been getting safeguarded and spent and being the only one being able to spend it right um so uh so yeah i mean what do you what are your overall thoughts like i do you like it do you i like this is this your first mind clash game have you played grenade or i have carry-on yeah no have you played what was their other one it was about emotions do you have you ever played a game about emotions that was heavy okay i don't think so celestia no i'll have to look it up i can't remember i've never played that other one but it was something i just didn't feel like sorry i mean i like it um it's an interesting uh design um there's lots of strategy that goes into it and again it is something cerebria if you don't enjoy planning ahead i i would think this game would be rough to play oh yeah um yeah because it's almost never about the turn that you're playing on like there's a little bit planning on what the turn is for now but realistically you are just prepping for the future yeah because well the the great thing for me about this game is also the fact that it still is instant rewards and almost everything gives you followers um or gives you something like it's like oh yeah i'm going to get some soldiers and i'll place them out well that gives you valor and safeguard and well that's going to be needed because it doesn't go away until you're in the dyno attack and you're guaranteed to get something over

there right um almost guaranteed i guess theoretically if you don't have like if there's a breach and you don't have any safeguard then it's like oh well everything that's available requires safeguards so i guess i can't get anything right but uh the dyno attack rewards don't change so it's always you can always plan for getting that um but i like that i like the fact that there's always an influx of followers there's always uh the fact that you do a main action with the dice and then the secondary which you're fighting for area control or influence control on these four different officers which also kind of dictates extra victory points right um which is going around your strategy no one did the chief steward because no one went settlements until literally the very end when they were safe to put out they were safe to put out and they were uh they were for area control um the control of this game is extremely unique uh what do you guys think of the the i guess area control of the four different sections and the two different the two tunes yeah on each section right because it's essentially yeah split in half and then four different areas do very specific things go ahead because i got the same answer it's it's it's too much for me to plan for so i just kind of did stuff and some of it worked out and some of it i had no clue so this section the top section to me while there's area control the reward for is significantly less than the air control down here

and so for me whether i take the area control or lose the area control in this section it doesn't bother me that much because the reward for it is be able to do the same action on that board twice yeah which let's put this way isn't bad that's where you can get a lot of points quickly but it's not the make or break like we're talking normally two to four points difference between doing one action and different action uh yeah yeah i mean if you had max um safeguard and valor you could theoretically get like i mean imagine if you were able to do the dino one and then the the dice one twice i was able to do the dino one twice if you don't have lots of raptors it doesn't matter right now if you killed lots of raptors from that tech yeah then it's worthless on the flip side i'll say if you lost lots of heavies it's cheaper to take the um soldier loss ones that's true um so realistically if you don't have a breach and i and i still wasn't top i would do the top one and the um soldier loss because if i lost lots of soldiers killing raptors i i don't need both which is which is a very weird way of thinking because yeah the theme is you are defending against dinosaurs against your settlement as you get onto the beach um but you can realistically plan for that that you can plan on sending your people out to die you can be like yeah i'm gonna pull out all my heavies put them all in and then take dice actions to only put raptors out

right so i can ensure that they die but i'm going to kill all of them and then boom get 10 16 points maybe oh 2 4 6 8 10 12. you can get 12 points if you literally have them all out right um but uh and then you get to do that twice right so even if you can't get all 12 out let's say you get just uh three of those out you're still making pretty a pretty good bank on that one right um over here i feel like it's a lot more um what's the i was going to say it flips around but that's not it's unstable like okay so here's a good example i had this locked up brett puts his extra guy there to basically seal it and that's it yeah and he could have taken it completely right that's true and i've spent quite a bit of effort to basically take control of it just to have it knocked out from under you and that's pretty common yeah like round one you did that you killed off everybody's and then i basically had the last round and did the same thing to you yeah and wiped out well that made me think i was like because i wasn't initially doing that because i forgot that placing your leader doesn't make dinosaurs come out right so my first well i was like oh this could be a [ __ ] move i thought i was gonna be able to wipe both your settlements out in one turn i'm like no i can only kill one of yours and i kill brett's um but this game is like

it's indirectly cutthroat yeah like i even though people are clearly taking areas for me they're vying for control over here potentially taking my dice and putting them like you took one of my dice and put it over there where i had it locked up right and it's like oh okay like for me i i just don't take that personally i don't think it's ever like one of those this isn't a mean game no i don't think well there's way too many possibilities right for you to be able to focus on screwing one person right and it's like oh okay yeah you took you took my die well you lost two followers in that okay no no i agree with that what i'm saying is down here it's really hard to plan the area control because hey if you have any breach um with a trampler you lose a hard to replace one of these buildings um it only costs one food that's an expensive way to do it it's a good i know it's interesting is let's say you do that let's say um whether you went up there and got the votes yeah so let's say i you like if you get another turn like i do something destroy that yeah that sucks for you um technically you have another settlement there's raptors left you actually do lose two more followers um but if your turn comes back around well now you just do this action pay a food and you get two others so you don't lose the rewards you don't lose for what you placed initially so now it's like i might actually be helping you because now you instead of two votes you now have four and so it's like well [ __ ] and once someone goes out of their way to place settlements to get votes it's very hard to

overtake that from them right i think in our last game brett swan like swapped the uh he beat you by like one vote to get the final 21 points right but yeah once you had like four and then you had i like you had some i was like i'm not winning 21 points here so i'm just gonna go for end game victory points and take resources uh but i like that i i really like that because it's it can be undermined um and it almost certainly is gonna be unless you really like lock it up like i feel like two presents in an area here on these cards yeah on on the officers i mean i we were neck and neck and i was thinking about fighting you for it and then you put out four more and well two more yeah and i went okay i don't have a chance so bother yeah but i mean even if you went somewhere and got two that you would have right i i couldn't have planned it but i decided to do other things exactly yeah that i thought were probably worth more and it turns out they probably and what i like is that the area control is something that like it can be overcome like i i had two here and i had two over there and i was like well two kind of feels like a pretty good people aren't going to try and compete with you yeah but as we saw all it took was brett he just dropped two settlements and said okay well there's a tie and since there's no settlements there that makes this other option kind of ass right um and then he placed the die there to take it and i'm like well i thought i had that locked up um and mo and really i did that not to

take the area control but because it was the by far the safest place to put them right and not lose them oh well yeah that's true um but that's just kind of one of those things that's like yeah it's constantly ever shifting and no one person can really have it locked down unless they put all their eggs in one basket and they put i put all my dice there but then i'm doing the same action over and over right yeah and unless that's my strategy then it's you want to spread out well all the good actions take resources so you have to go somewhere to get resources exactly exactly um and there's other ways for you to get other resources like i wanted to see because last game i went very heavy on patrol and i was like is that is that like is that the strat is that the meta to go for patrol because you get resources you get right followers you get cards you just get a bunch of stuff you can even potentially get votes um and as we saw no no i didn't touch it once um because i also had enough of my own dice to go somewhere and be like well because luckily this is you don't need a lot of resources right uh you just need a few and it's like okay yeah i got i got two metal oh perfect that's all i need right now to pop to two walls down uh i'm trying to think what do you guys think of the dice placement that's work replacement starting out with like the neutral dice and then changing them on your own

because that's probably for me my favorite aspect of the game bill changed the dice i think i think because it has so many layers of what you're doing it's not just something that oh yeah this is now my personal die and out of all of these now i have more options of mine but it's like well and forcing other people to lose forces other people to lose followers um because if they're rolled and your dice are the only ones for icons they need then you don't even have to stress you can be like i'm gonna use the neutral ones and take up the free ones so they have to potentially use my own dice um and then the other part for that is it counts as presence if someone uses your own dice it's like great thank you unless you use it in a way that's like oh i'll put it somewhere that which works against the stacking yourself up in one area exactly because then you don't have control over how they spread them right so it's not it's not super op but yeah people could just be like well i kind of i have more followers than everyone yeah i can afford to lose two just to move this dice you know out of the way it's like damn i was gonna use that diet right so so i like it um i thought it's fine it's not my favorite mechanic in the game um but i'll say like so i know i use story once to flip a die did anybody else ever use it no no i never had it no i just spending on other things that's the thing like one of the two things that we played we only one time did i ever see a need to flip a die right yeah yeah and only

when and it's probably your last turn before right right so i'm almost at the points like so why don't you just have cubes instead like for guys yeah for placement yeah because at the realistic we've played two full games now we're only one time to even slightly mayor there were a couple of times that i was hoping to play something and i just didn't have the right guy face for it yeah it's definitely it's but out of 20 placements i think it only came up twice yeah and then i think i commend the game for that because it's it's tight enough that you need a specific resource or a face but it's not so tight that you're hinging on the luck of the roll like this game would be a slog if you were rolling and nothing worked for anyone and everyone had though we have to all fight for the pub or we have to just take the whatever to gain story to mitigate it like because there's so many areas all the best actions require you to have story right um that you almost never have some but on the off chance you really want a specific face to go somewhere then uh then you have that option of turning something into something you need uh it could also be that we because you have to always take into consideration how many dinosaurs are coming out if you don't want to you don't want to be the one to cause a breach because that's losing followers that you're um like we're leaving the free spaces open right because the the ones that require are cheaper are cheaper in dinosaurs so yeah and that's

actually one of the reasons i didn't put my last die over here i was considering maybe using a wall or something like that but i didn't want to risk breaching another so i wanted to put it in a safe spot right yeah and i think all those very little nuances in the game showcase themselves this is one of the few games that i play that upon further playthroughs new things are becoming oh my god if oh i didn't even realize if you do this and that becomes available right and most games don't do that right most games show show themselves and they're like hey here are the multiple strategies but that's it you know yeah uh and this one i was just every single time we've played i'm like huh well that works yeah uh or that doesn't work i mean the first time we even played this together brett immediately started the breach and we're like okay brett uh i guess he'll just be here and then he came out ahead and followers yeah i got i netted one you netted one that's still one follower versus what we thought you were just gonna have zero points the rest of the cake because it was like all raptors and people and you flooded it and it was like huh right did not did not see that working out so uh so yeah like i like the fact that the dice mitigation is there um but there are you are rolling a lot of dice um and there are enough free spaces that might not uh it might not ever come up but i think i'd rather have that come up less than more just myself i never noticed before

but this is by far the most restricted zone yes yes it is um because three dice spots four down here and they have to be specific i mean you just get so much for those areas like the settle like you get you can like you can swing the game in so many ways by placing settlements down like the right and then i lost them well the reason well yeah then that's because people are actively trying to make them yeah to remove them but this game would have been radically different had you guys been going heavy in settlement because i wouldn't have won a single [ __ ] vote thing but we wouldn't we couldn't do settlements heavily because nobody was doing defense and we couldn't do both at the same time right because they have different areas yeah but the ones that have this as soon as i lost my first settlement i kind of went no i'm done with settlements i mean right these are piling up and and i don't see an end in sight so i'm not gonna lose them so my problem no you do but you do get a reward for placing one yeah and the reward it's not like you lose it again when they're destroyed so yeah you place two and it's like okay yeah they got destroyed but if you don't put them all in one area like because all the votes are the same or all the the settlement spots are the same which i like i'm glad they weren't random for each section that'd be annoying so you place i feel like your settlements your your if you place two settlements i feel like you would you would place more than dinosaurs would destroy them in my head because you wouldn't place them in a spot where clearly it's all tramplers you would avoid that and you would put them over here and then oh

someone's coming over here yeah that's probably gonna be destroyed i go back place two more and so you just constantly spread them around and um like and then as you're and the other cool thing is since you guys always had soldiers your secondary action you place your soldiers in a spot that's going to kill the trampler unless it's literally this i was only going for rewards i wasn't even trying to kill anything oh right i want to be number two in every battle so i get something you've been trying to say something what was it um sorry so i think that's fine to a certain extent but like so if you lose buildings to tramplers yeah you still got the reward but if you have buildings that don't get destroyed then the raptors come upon them i don't know that you net positive because you lose two followers and that's the challenge yeah you only ever lose a max of two followers like no matter how many raptors are there um i don't think each raptor attacks the same settlement no no but if you have multiple settlements there they'll attack each zone well that's why you don't put them all in one basket because once again you don't gain anything for controlling one area um right so you spread them out and um and you get i mean you do the same thing instead of walls um where was it yeah i mean this guy becomes a significantly better because if you can do dice and walls not only do settlements give you presents your own dice give you presents and if you just can how many settlements do we have are there 12 2 4 6 8

uh 10 yeah 12. so what would that be let's say max you had all your dice out so 5 15 points right is that 15 points for controlling that um on top of the fact that oh well now i own area control so i'm most likely going to get votes um and this is obviously best case scenario no one tries to prevent that but that's where this is a competitive game and not cooperative right if anyone's letting you constantly place settlements down because all of these are good like yeah the lower ones are bad or bad because um but they're they're lower so the chance of them getting destroyed or less but still that's one vote i mean even having one vote lead is i think pretty big right um placing influence cubes down like this one like i i had the most but all brett had to do is place a settlement there and then he ties it on top of a secondary action i don't know i don't know i think them getting destroyed because you don't lose anything except one presence there but yeah it's it's it's weird in the in the sense that you feel like you're building something but everything that you build gets destroyed wiped out it's on a regular basis except waltz yeah you almost have to change your mindset of like this isn't like a civilization game you're not you're not thematically yeah you're supposed to be building the community but the settlements are all temporary um

theoretically your soldiers it's the same mindset over here you're not sending your soldiers to keep them there to keep killing dinosaurs you're like well i want i want them to go there to die so i can get you know a bunch of extra points over here everything almost feels temporary the only thing that's not is your leader and your dice which is why and they stand out because they're so permanent yes you can't have it back except under certain circumstances yep uh if you can get a patrol that lets you pull them back or if you put them out here one that's an area that's a point of area control but boy you better make them count because they're there until all those dice are gone um they're more apt to come back to you if you can cause a breach right but that's also where i like it because you you're still competing this isn't one of those games where it's just you doing something and then you're doing something and you're doing something because if you put you're working we're all working together to fight each other pretty much like if i put my leader out over here then you guys could actively be like okay we're not placing dice because that locks your leader up yeah until so then i have to try and make a make a breach happen um to uh to get him back or wait for a patrol or an action or something to get him back uh settlement right there yeah that action brings them back and there's a fighting condition you're right yeah that was blocked in this game it was blocked the entire game yeah we had one non-breach

we did and that had the leader out in that fight so that one was yeah yeah those um yeah the ones getting your leader back it's kind of like it's very situational right like you if you put your leader up here then you're like which i like i like that that options there so it's like if i lock him up if i put him up here i don't know where he's at if i put him here and then you guys actually avoid then it's like oh [ __ ] okay i guess i better build a settlement and put him down so i can pull him back because [ __ ] you guys really the time to use that one is when you know there's not going to be a like in this case because reach but let's say it wasn't you know that token was moved to a different spot right then it's actually not that bad because then you place the dye to cause basically an attack you have some kind of defense you're going to get some points from it you put your leader down somewhere to get a bonus yeah you do the dyno attack and then you return your leader for two for two now next turn you have your leader again to do another big end situation having that leader i love this i love having like a special badass worker that's very restrictive um because there's only one area for him to go down in the community section right and it's like man okay i really want to do that and brett went there but it's also super good for attacking um it's extra you know basically extra action space that doesn't do dinosaurs um benefit no risk yeah even though like yeah whenever these are dangerous i like that too that they become dangerous but

it gives you better options for settlements but it's also it's not super hard to wipe an area no it takes longer for the dinosaurs to stack yeah so you have more time to be getting stuff ready um like realistically you'll probably have a breach in every area the first time it goes through maybe not one if you focus on it yeah the um the last game we played i think the protection area was it went un un um what do they call it breached it went well it went like unattacked for a while right dangerous like it was the last one to go and it lasted for a little bit but yeah uh you're almost like his last game nobody put walls out but me the one time right so i literally had two dice out and there were only two dice worth of dinosaurs out yeah so with walls defending it it was basically like who cares at this point yeah i think the only meta that i can think of is you should play replace your dice or place your own dyson that seems to be the general kind of consensus on a lot of points um like the chief mate you can choose areas i have have your dice there the obviously chief stewart requires dice and settlements um yeah areas over there one area over there require like gives you two points per per your own dice um followers career dice right when you place another one

yeah yeah so i think i think that would be the only thing but it's also a race because everyone has their own five dice and there's only eight neutrals in the entire game just like there's only everyone has seven um walls and uh there's only um 12 spots so so if that only allows one person to be able to pull put all their walls out right yeah um yeah are you guys gonna have any negatives uh nothing you would consider negative i mean it's not my negative like if it's your negative i mean my negative it is really complex and so many possibilities to juggle all at once if you like that sort of game it is a big positive i don't so so it's a big negative no it's it's i know it's again it's i will absolutely play it i will not play it with a particular focus or strategy in mind i will see what comes up and i will play each turn with very little thought to what comes next yeah and if i win or if i do well it is largely luck it is you know the last couple of the last couple of moves you can make in a round i go okay i can see this i can do this i happened to go last so i happen to be able to make the final stomp plan yeah um

and that again was just luck yeah you started that was luck i think i've started every game we've played this and uh right and yeah yeah i was like okay um well it's also the way the dice placement works is is very balanced because everyone's gonna get to go first once and then yeah everyone's going to get to go last before an assembly phase right and you can plan for all that like there's really like you can even plan for your own traps like placing traps in a certain area unless i mean there is a chance someone goes there and they try to read what you most likely put down um they're 50 50 shot but if they don't go there then you can be like ha ha i put two traps there it's a it's a trampler and a raptor i'm gonna go to that spot that puts both of those on there because that could potentially get me eight points um so zack do you have any negatives i don't think so i mean i got one but man i would agree with the complexity of this game i mean so again watching the like the how to play and i think my first comment literally is wow this is complex yeah um and so and that's coming from someone who enjoys complex games so this is one of those that if you are wow a fairly complex game overall yeah i'm like yes sir board game geek it's a 38

right what it is um it goes up to five no it's not that it is complex to learn it is complex to learn i think it's complex to play yes um i think if you don't have a 4.13 out of five yep yeah which is pretty high yeah i guess that's significantly high i rarely enjoy anything above about a two and a half but well i will say where i feel this game is tight enough in complex i don't feel starved ever which is my biggest probably complaint with what i call heavy thought complex euro games is when i feel starved that's why i say i just don't enjoy the scene right like resources of choice like do an imperium where it's like man i sure wish i could do anything to me it's more agricola is the classic example of literally feeling starving yeah and it's like you took the one spot that everyone needs and there's only one spot and you basically have doomed everyone not like entirely but now everybody has to figure out a absolutely different strategy yeah for the game yeah no i'm in the same boat like and i don't enjoy that yeah like complex games need to still have a balance and a rhyme or reason on why it's complex right like video games have a hard difficulty it's like well this is hard for the sake of being hard like there's no challenge to overcome it's just wow enemies kill you in one hit how creative uh and that's like in this one no it's

like okay yeah i ran out of resources oh there's four spots for me to go to get two metal which is just enough for me to then go to the protection spot spend that two metal into place uh it's not like go to the salvage spot roll the salvage die and hope it's like no i'm guaranteed to get something right like that kind of [ __ ] is so frustrating and it's not in this game no and so that i enjoy about but it is a heavy game um but there are many ways to play it how you want to go with it so it's heavy with options instead of being um narrow yeah it's not necessary it's pretty open yeah and there's a lot of work replacements a lot of displacement games that are good are just real specific and it's the contention for space that is the game yeah and this one there's lots and lots of options it's right what is my best one now and three turns from now yeah yeah and also the fact is um there's no meta like out of multiple plays of this it's not like well there it is like that's gonna guarantee anyone a win if they go down that path and then those games just get boring yeah it's like okay well and the only way you get any enjoyment is if you're the one who's played it before and so you just try something completely different playing with new people you know what [ __ ] it like early ons um have either you played that so that game is still a phenomenal bag building game but if you do not get the

um uh citizens the multiplier and go up on that track chances are you're losing right like that is the meta in that game and for me i don't like want to play orleon's a lot unless it's like oh you guys haven't played oh great that gives me the perfect opportunity to try to win without doing that yeah see if it's option and i mean theoretically yeah but you're also busting your ass way harder than anyone else when they're just like i'm gonna get this one and now i have a times seven multiplier it's like great let me put all my guild houses down and just hope i can get something like and this doesn't have that like it's i mean i think it's extremely well balanced and a very interesting production or design choice by the company and those designers to release this as an episodic kind of game with all full intention of making it a campaign there is a campaign um and that way if it tanks they don't have to make any more probably i mean definitely they've already announced seasons no no this is plenty in fact they could have released episodes one and two separately they could have yeah i actually think they probably shot themselves in the foot by not doing that it's an interesting thing because would you want to buy a whole separate game that ties in with the original one i think maybe i think it comes down to if you but if you get a chance to play episode one

chances are you're gonna like episode two right but if you and but if you let's say let's say they separated them like you only can buy episode one oh this is really great oh i can go out and get episode two or if you hate it then you're like oh i don't have to touch episode two right here to even try episode one you have to buy both of them that's true and this isn't a cheap game right so and then if you play ups with one love it but hate episode two for whatever reason then it's like [ __ ] i'm stuck with the this whole box and the thing is you're using half the components anyway for episode two so you just do it as an expansion you can have those parts back so you're cutting out half the plastic for the first one yeah you're putting the half plastic back for the second one up charge it by 10 for the second one anyway yeah and now you know because you can make it half the cost of the first you know one and two and you're there yeah and the people who are going to get it are going to still get it yeah i mean what they did well by combining them both is the fact that it is one box and they did a relatively good job on the on the game trays like everything does fit well organized into the box right but and then so if you have episode one and by episode two you don't have two separate boxes right which is always annoying with the questions this way they get people hooked on the idea of continuing right then they can release episodes one at a time right in the future well yeah i think it's genius i'm sorry it was it's strange i wouldn't call it genius i

still think if it works it's genius that's true and um i mean only time will tell if it works but yeah if they're planning on continuing a storyline because episodes one and two uh like you play one then you play the other and then you do the campaign uh which is i think it's supposed to incorporate both of those and then oh you get three and four i don't know how long they're going to continue with that i like it i like that because but i also really like their games yeah so it's also hoping that you can have people who do like these kinds of games and then be like oh great now let's try episode two yeah yeah which we're gonna play soon anyway and and and hopefully that it's different enough otherwise if it's really kind of the same overall field and it's like well why is this a second episode right because when you think episode you say drastically different oh you oh that's right you did one you spoiled lorelei yeah mechanically there are definitely similarities because you still use the dice right the dice are stuck yeah that's not the end of it uh and the concept of settlements and how they get placed but they're not the tracks like this right yeah i mean looking at the board the only thing i saw were the dice placement spots and that was it and then it's like this whole area or exploration with your soldiers don't die in it you don't think anymore but they're harder to get okay yeah it's different it's different uh i can't speak to the strategy but the mechanics are different enough that yeah they could have released it as a completely separate game right

um i think if we're talking about components or overall i mean the concern that was that was the negative though the components are uh are really good like uh the the tokens are thick um i but there are a few hiccups i wouldn't necessarily say they're bad but i can see they're annoying um one is the game tray for everyone um i'm amazed that they actually fits all your soldiers i thought it was totally gonna like have a lid lift uh but really the only one that's kind of annoying is actually just your cube spot yeah that thing is and i have tiny hands and even i'm like which i will say for most games that have cubes in a container it's almost always annoying it looks like they tried to fix that that they have a little hump in it yeah so that so that it separates yeah pushes some up in the middle yeah so that's which works until you get to that bottom plate right maybe that's well [ __ ] right and you don't want to take everything out because that's the only limiter episode one it's like hey you only get 15 cubes so everything else you can keep in there but then so then you're like hey let me just i mean it's possible like they're lit you don't have to dump them never once have i had to like weirdly cover it to try and dump it but you've also never taken all of them out i have not also taken all of them out um second would be i would just rather have a track these things are annoying because they

yeah they're spinning they're very they're very loose i have never been able to figure out a fix besides going outside with a hammer well smashing it down one one good decision along those lines is it's a very very small area to turn it right yeah but on the back it's completely open so anything touching it is is a chance now i didn't have any trouble using it and no i mean because you only do it and it's you just go uh like you're you're modifying it by relatively small numbers yeah and then you just kind of set it down um it's not so bad that like when you pick it up that it you know it turns which i have had those and i'm like well this is trash right but i don't know like i love the succinctness of the board full art on the board really enjoy that but you could have added a tracker like i i don't know this also becomes on the outside the only thing i can see is you do spend followers on semi regular like you lose two followers you gain two followers yeah it would be kind of like oh hey can you yeah yeah that's true maybe that maybe they had that and they're like it was constant annoying of people reaching over asking others someone make a better one of these just period yeah and then figure out how i just put in industry as a whole that's true yeah really the better option yeah really it's just it's loose dials yeah like i i just don't like that and i can substitute your own you could use a twenty sides and a ten set of dots right um it also kind of comes down to

where you're still but you're still checking people like you're still going oh hey don't forget to lose two followers for my dice or whatever and it's like oh yeah thank you or i already did and it's like okay and you hope that they remembered or they were telling the truth or whatever it might be and then it's like okay well i'm not gonna call him a liar i didn't see it but uh but then that kind of comes down to don't play with those people that would theoretically like cheat to not lose two followers or two three points it's like really it's that big of a deal other than that i the uh oh yeah the dual layered boards uh yes that was extremely annoying once again i have tiny hands you would think it'd be easier for me but the a side and it's like if you're gonna make them dual layered make them dual layers on both sides right uh not just one side and the dual layered side which is side b that gives everyone a special ability if you have and this is only in the deluxe version i guess so maybe it's easier if you have the metal coins yeah they do not come out easy in the beginners is they are beveled to basically fit in perfectly and then because that bevel in they're smooth fairly actually kind of nice yeah um they're incredibly hard to get out yeah because they're not large enough to kind of like stick out the cardboard just enough to really get a good finger and they go right up yeah like i'm literally i'm i i kid you not there we go and then

if you're really forcing it you're probably going to tear up the edges of the dual layer right i'm trying to eventually yeah so it's just once again like it's not like the the hardest thing in the world like those are those are they definitely had a finger edge to make that easier right all along each track yeah but i never but honestly you want to use it i'd rather just memorize people's special abilities and flip it to the a side because it's so much easier to be like oh i have six safeguard okay that cost me four and then just go down and then it's just way easier and since you're never touching this you're just dropping stuff on it it's not getting bumped which is oddly the exact opposite of this device right but but overall like i mean that's nitpicking for me at this point oh yeah like it's super high quality um yeah i mean i think this is they could have easily done the same resist recesses in the dice areas i've actually never seen a dual layer i mean i there are dual layered boards um clearly that those exist but in most games i've never really seen that as a method i don't think it's necessary probably not not particularly valuable i think one time in one of our games a settlement got excellent well what it does and what i what i never did is i got the the dice tray over here um which worked well for me when i was rolling and then whenever you guys wanted to roll it's just like all right let me roll and i'm like why why are you guys

rolling it across and i was like i have a second one why didn't i just give that to you but that's almost the only time that people are rolling then it might knock stuff around but yeah it's not a big deal it's just no and it would add a lot to cost yeah so i totally understand yeah so overall um if you like actually no this is actually a really good i did want to bring this up what do you guys think of the semi-cooperative nature of the game in terms of theme overall like this was cat cat just would not stop bringing it up and i'm like it's not it's not cooperative i know yeah it feels like it should be but it's not i never felt like this game was cooperative but the theme itself feels like it should be why are we we're all stranded on this island why would we want to work together see that struck me when i first started watching the rules and i'm like so is it cooperative because we're all stranded together and we're all working to build a society and protect ourselves it's probably one of the opposites no we're we're fighting to be the best leader yeah right that's what it really comes down to yeah um episode three or four is probably a cooperative game in there which honestly that's the other genius of doing the episodes have you done any cooperative no then no they that could go either way yeah i think about anachrony definitely not uh cerebral i don't believe is i doubt if that's what their mindset is but it's possible it'll be interesting uh i mean again this game could be cooperative it wouldn't be hard to

switch it too cooperative um honestly i don't know much different that you would do to make this like other than saying hey everyone is cooperative well we collaborate on placing settlements i know so you wouldn't have boats for that anymore right you just have to have more threats come out yeah but this game's already limited to where you place dice so now it's like okay seth i'm going to start placing soldiers here you start building walls over there instead of saying now seth wants to build walls over there because it benefits him the best as an individual player he's building it there because it benefits the best of the group yeah you almost you have to still restructure the game significantly to make it a threat i mean yeah you'd have to figure out a way to make it more threatening yeah but that is something that they have actually done extremely well with the episodes is that because they're so significantly different and it's not just an expansion episode two is a drastically different game episode three could be hey now it's cooperative episode four hey now it's a bag builder or dice builder or whatever right hey episode five is a deck builder or whatever they do um all keeping the same overarching campaign story yeah which is really cool right but yeah um i think the theme is really what hiccups the concept where it's like well it should be cooperative but it's not yeah but it doesn't have that same feel of you placing soldiers over here you're not protecting me you're not doing

anything to be like hey you know hey brett can you place a wall over here so you so my settlements don't die it's like no i'm gonna place them all over there so i can get safeguard and contribute all the time um but yeah there might be a common misconception like theme wise should be should be cooperative but it's not yeah it's not it's not head-to-head either yeah it's definitely we're each doing our own thing and occasionally we clash yeah i mean actually in terms of mechanics it's very competitive because right you're always attention not intentionally but like maybe intentionally screwing someone over but always to your benefit yeah which i like like you guys losing a settlement it's not just me distorting it for the sake of me destroying it it's oh that also makes you lose area control yeah right and me placing one of your guys i lose two points yeah but i take away from you the ability to stack that in somewhere stack it somewhere else to take a potentially take area control away from me yeah um yeah i just wanted to bring that up like because it's i'm sure that it's been thought of oh it bugged me at first but i got over it right but yeah i'm just like damn this should be cool and it's and it's complicated and option driven as the whole thing is i really wanted to be cooperative right yeah it's not that's fine yeah um okay well uh with that being said on a scale of one to ten what would you guys give perseverance castaway chronicles episode one

start with brett can go around the table um again just my personality it's hard for me to judge so i'm gonna have to give it a ten wow well i mean i i just can't think of any flaws other than it's not a style that i particularly enjoy so i gotta go with nine nine yeah zach i was gonna go with eight eight yep i was wondering whether you're gonna waive her on on eight or nine um yeah i'm gonna i'm gonna agree with um i actually [ __ ] ate this game no um no i'm gonna give it a nine as well like i i really can't think of any flaws either and the reason why it's not a 10 is because out of all their games this is my least favorite theme like tricarion is about stage magic um not like actual like magicians but you're a stage magician think the prestige the game right yeah uh and anachrony is about time travel so those just appeal to me more and the dinosaurs are at least in episode one are still a second thought i never have been like oh my god the tramplers are coming right well you do because you're like well i don't want my settlements destroyed uh but once they're gone who cares yeah and it's not like wickedly thematic of a game yeah yeah but other than that yeah there's there's just it's so clean such a balanced game for me yeah um and i think definitely on more plays it becomes the overall options start to either become clear in

the paths that you can take right um or uh like it just thinks click and i guess that would be more of a question for you is on third playthrough was it like ah okay i'm starting to see a little bit more definitely okay still not seeing it but it definitely it's like the the mud is is wavering if i were inclined to play this four or five more times yeah i think i would start actually liking it well hey we got episode two coming up so time to do away with all that and then join it and start yeah and then uh we'll see what the campaign's like potentially but that is our thoughts on perseverance castaway chronicles let us know what you think of episode one specifically in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful ever time of day just for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved