Flashpoint: South China Sea | Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson review on Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing Flashpoint South China Sea designed by Harold Buchanan and Polished by GMT games so here is Flashpoint South China Sea it's all set up for solo play I'm gonna give you quick overview of what the games about and then just a very quick description of what happens during the turns so Flashpoint South China Sea is a game that is meant to represent the United States and China's War for influence over this area of the world over the South China Sea and essentially what that's going to mean is that both sides are placing cubes in these different areas and you can place economic or diplomatic influence in various countries and when you feel like you have enough influence if you have the right card you can try to score one of these screen cards and they can be scored once per campaign so during each campaign there's one two three campaigns in the game that's essentially just rounds of playing cards you are going to try to score as much as possible and then all the cards are going to be scored one more time after campaign number three so make sure that you're in a good condition at that point there's a tension track up here that kind of represents how the actions that we're taking around the South China Sea impact the relationship between China and the United States and it makes some actions more expensive especially for China so mess around with the tension track is a key part of the game and then of course you've got your little reserve of Cubes I'm playing United States in
this setup so I have some in my Reserve but the AI player has nothing in reserve and is just ready to go down here is the victory Point track that represents whether we're winning or not and because it's a little bit easier to play China the United States starts with a couple of extra victory points is basically what it boils down to there's a more nuanced conversation we had about that I think but you're trying to pull influence in your direction as much as possible if you ever hit 15 points is an instant win over the other player so we're having a big tug of war across the South China Sea in order to see which world power is going to have the most say over what happens in this part of the world this is a card driven game it's got a lot in common with Twilight Struggle so during your turns you are going to be playing these different cards that have different attributes so I got a lot of American Events this time I guess that's good but we'll talk about that but each of these cards has a few different things to note about them you can play them for their Ops points in the Ops points vary in value from one to three there are suits on them that you can use to match things in the discard pile which we'll talk about briefly you can play them for their events or at least you can if the event is a United States event for me or a China event for the Chinese player they're also event cards that have a black bar and that means that either so I can play them and your other option is to play for scoring so whatever flag is in the bottom left of your card you can play that card and then score that scoring card so you have to be careful if you think you're going to gain Primacy in
Vietnam for example you don't want to waste that by then playing your Vietnamese scoring card to do it because then you can get more cubes there but you can't uh score oofs so in a Solo version of this game you are playing very normally as yourself and then there's a very simple little flow chart for what the solo Bots gonna do so the solo opponent doesn't actually draw any cards but they are going to go through a series of steps involving these two decks of cards the solo cards and then also just the regular event cards that everybody plays with so the first thing is solo player is always going to do is draw the top card of the event deck and then they're gonna see if they can score the area that comes up so in this case we have Brunei um can they score it no because we're actually in control over here right now by a little bit but still so they're not going to try to score Brigade so they're going to move on to the next step in their little flush art if they'd scored then they would end the turn immediately but they didn't then you're gonna turn the top card of the silhouette deck face up and you're gonna check for what's called mode match so that's not what's showing up here but mode match is basically once you've started to play events and you're putting your events in the discard pile don't forget some of my events I can play and then some of the events I can't because they're my opponent's events Meanwhile my opponent is going to draw some United States events that I can't play because they didn't come in my hand however if there's a mode match things might be different so if I have a Chinese economic event up here at the top of the discard pile that I played then the Chinese player can attempt to do a mode match with this symbol in
order to get access to his card that they never drew themselves so you just turn over the top card on the deck nothing too crazy is going on there so there's no mode match here not for them if the opponent only has one operations value then they're going to adjust tension which is up here at the top of the board the Chinese especially want tension to go down because it makes it cheaper for them to place cubes so watch out for that but these guys have two Ops points right now um so that's not going to come into play but what is going to happen this time is that there's going to be political Warfare uh because that's what's on at the top of this card so basically political Warfare is what happens when you place cubes in your political Warfare tracks then you draw another card off of the deck and if its opposite value is equal to or less than the cubes that you've put down then you're successful with political Warfare so that increases tension which has consequences on other aspects of gameplay but it also lets you dump somebody else's cubes out of a country and lock it so if we got to play political Warfare on the Philippines we could toss all Chinese cubes here and then lock them out for the duration of The Campaign which is pretty wild and then if that doesn't work then they're going to use their card to perform operations which basically means putting out cubes and competing with us for all this delicious space across the South China Sea of course on our turn we don't have to use the flow chart at all because we get to look at our cars and just decide okay which one of these do I want to play and do I want to play it to score do I want to play for the Ops points do I want to play for the event or do I have a mode match going on with the discard pile so for example I'm ahead in Brunei right now and what I might do with that is try
to score it because if you look at the very nice scoring card it says compare all cubes in Brunei decide what the positive differential scores it as VPS not exceeding one so I can only ever get one VP here and I'm also the only one with a cube in this part of the world so if I want to I can play this card for scoring I can flip this card over to indicate that it's been scored this campaign I moved my victory track one and as one of the bonuses in the card I can move on I can move one of my Reserve cards to available and then it will be time for the bot to go again and we're gonna keep going until I run out of cards and that's going to mean that the campaign is over then we'll reset and do it a couple more times to see who ultimately holds Sway in the South China Sea so I try to keep this explanation short but hopefully it gives you a good sense of what's going on in the game it is a nasty little tiger War where you are placing cubes forcing people to discard cubes messing around with tension in the region and trying to score cards at opportune moments in order to take out your opponent the only thing that we didn't talk about are these little island chains in the middle so basically for scoring these are usually counted as part of the country that they are attached to with a line but these are phonop and CR spots and they are in these little island chains in South China Sea one thing that's really interesting is that phone ups are always pretty cheap for the United States to place but they get removed at the end of the campaign it costs China a bit more especially the tension track is high to place CR cubes
here in the middle of the ocean however these remain from turn to turn as an example of as a way to represent China's continuing proximity to this area so the United States has other interests elsewhere in the world but China is always here so the investment in CR cubes can actually be very good for the Chinese player even if they're expensive sometimes and that is the essence of how this game works get your influence out there kick other influence out score these cards at the right moment take advantage of any mode matches if somebody plays an event that you wanted but it wasn't in your hand and see how well you can do across the course of three campaigns so that's an overview of the game let's go ahead and have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts I have very mixed feelings about this game and I'm gonna explain why on the one hand mechanically I think this game is absolutely gorgeous it flows so beautifully it's very smooth it's super easy to learn the solo bot is very easy to run I can see this being a really intense two-player experience as well and I just really have no complaints about the cleverness of the card play or the challenge of getting your cubes in there or the possibility of locking people out of various countries or even like the scorecard structure where you have to make decisions about when the time is correct to try to get a scorecard all those things are really cool and there's just so much thought that went into making a relatively simple system have a very pleasing thinkiness to it and I for that reason would really like to see some more Flashpoint games there was a lot to like
in this game system I also thought that the rule book was super clear it was very easy to understand what to do in this game I liked the boy order the components everything just looked really clean everything was very smooth everything was very nicely organized and you know really this is one of those games where I don't have anything to complain about except that I do and that's that's what's so challenging about this one so it's it's about ostensibly a super dramatic issue that's going on in our world right now like the prospect of the United States and China going to war is terrifying you know there are cars in that deck that represent current events that are really serious there's a Vladimir Putin card in there and we know how much Havoc that dude has caused in the past year on the global scale and yet nothing ever really seems to rock the boat that hard in the South China Sea everything is so Sleek everything is so smooth that it's almost like all the gritty dramatic emotional aspects of the game that could exist are smoothed away like it's all sanded down to an incredible smoothness that while it is impressive and it works beautifully and it's nice to look at also makes it less of a memorable and intense gameplay experience um it's kind of like I guess it's like a Hallmark movie where I watch Hallmark movies and I enjoy them but then I can't actually remember what the actors look like and then next year I won't remember whether I watched a specific Hallmark movie or not because they all kind of run together in my memory and I don't
have strong feelings about or memories of any particular one and I think that in a game that's about global politics and especially a very Live Wire Global issue that that is a problem so I would like to see another Flashpoint game but I would really like to see one you know this is called the first in a series which is why I keep bringing this up um but I you know I want to see these really beautiful and well thought out mechanics again I like them but I also want to see them applied in a way that has real fear and tension and just something more in that's going to kind of hook me and grip me and keep me in there and kind of like make it hurt good because I feel like that's what a good political or historical game ought to do so Flashpoint South fantasy is a good start to a series I think you know the the mechanisms are great the rule book is great the graphic design is clean you know on the surface of it everything is great it's just that it's too much surface and not enough depth that said I think there are people who really enjoy this two player I don't intend to keep this one of my solo collection just because it's not compelling enough to keep you pulling off the shelf again and again but I would definitely try another Flashpoint game and I certainly have a lot of respect for the designs it currently stands so that's where I'm at on the flash points uh thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment support me on patreon if you are feeling generous and most of all happy
foreign