Skip to main content
Loading video...

Condottiere Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:50

hi everyone today I'm talking about Kier which is a 2 to six player board game designed by Dominique aart and published by zedman games this one takes around 20 to 45 minutes to play according to the Box uh before I get into my review of Kier I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor k.c. which is actually the retailer where I picked up Kier so if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get 5% off your first order but let's get into the review so Kier is an area control and hand management style game that's going to take place on a board that looks like this now the objective of the game is to control five regions which which can be anywhere like so so let's say I was the yellow player and I had these um five regions then I would win the game and but additionally if I have three adjacent regions like so as in the borders are touching each other that also going to be an instant Victory condition so the way these regions are contested is the use of these cards and at the start of the game each player is going to get given a hand of 10 cards out a random from that deck and you're going to keep those close to your chest and not show anybody but just for example sake I put some face up here to show you what these cards consist of so essentially there's going to be two types of cards the first of which is going to be these mercenary cards which are basically your your troops your battle line which is your power to try and influence that region and these are going to range from 1 all the way up to 10 I believe there's 10 one cards in the

deck and eight of every other type and additionally on top of those um standard mercenary cards there are a bunch of these special cards scattered throughout the deck and these do vary in their rareness some of them are a lot more common than others so the way the game is going to flow is that the player with this battle marker is going to select which region they want to be contested so let's just say they um they chose fenzi with no Rhyme or Reason there and that means that this round foren is going to be the region that is contested and what's going to happen is that in player order you are going to either play a card from your hand or you are going to pass so those are your only two options so let's just say that the first player wanted to bid with this three card here just to start off and show some strength so again once this player has played the card it's going to go to the player to the left and they are either going to pass and drop out of the fight um potentially still winning if they had played any cards beforehand or they're going to play a card El and when they play that card it doesn't necessarily have to be a stronger card than the one that's already been played they just need to put something down to show that they are still in the fight but let's take a look at what some of these special cards do and show why and when you might want to play them so the first special card we have here is the bishop this is a quite a powerful card that actually eliminates all the strongest cards in the battle at that time so let's just say that I'd already played a one and two of my opponents had already played their 10 if I played my Bishop next time that all the 10

currently in the battle are going to get wiped off and no longer participate so it's a very strong one to play at the right time and you want to be doing it when you know that all your opponents have put a lot of strong cards on the table and additionally after playing a bishop card you actually get to move this little pie stove somewhere on the board to show that this um region that where you place it cannot be contested until somebody else plays a bishop so this is a really good tool to use that say um you're not in a strong position to win the fight but you really need that region if you play this one then it's going to protect it from being claimed by somebody else the next card here is this scarecrow card which I have to say is one of my favorites and this can be used in a number of ways um but essentially all this does is that when you play it you get to pull back a mercenary card back into your hand you've already played uh this battle so let's just say that you played some high cards um and all of a sudden that battle starts turning against you and you weren't in such a strong position to win it as you thought you would have been that if you play the scarecrow card you can take your strongest card back ready to fight another day additionally this card can be used um as quite a strong way to Bluff your opponents into thinking you want certain regions so let's just say um you know I I wanted to fool my opponents into thinking I wanted this region when in reality I didn't want it at all um I could maybe play a high card um kind of lure my opponents into playing their High cards as well because they might think you really want it and then all of a sudden you spend your scarecrow card bring it back into your hand and have nothing in the in the fight at all and hopefully force your

opponents to waste their cards the next card we have here is this turncoat card and this is a very powerful one because when you play this card the battle ends immediately so this is a really strong one to play maybe after you played your highest cards it gets back around to you and then all of a sudden you can play this one and end the fight immediately without having to donate too many cards to that fight it's also a really strong card to use towards the end of the game when you need that final region however it does have its vulnerabilities because if you are playing those strong cards of course you are going to be vulnerable to cards like the bishop the drummer card here actually doubles the value of all the mercenary cards that you've played in that fight so this is like another good one to lure people into thinking they can win a fight against you you know maybe you've played some you know middling cards they played some higher cards down they drop out the fight and thinking they're still confident in winning the battle then all of a sudden you play the drama card down and all your values are doubled the Spy card here is a bit more common than some of the other ones we've discussed however it does still have its uses so despite only being a strength one um if you are the player who's played the most spy cards in that battle by the end of the battle then you are going to take control of the battle marker and get to choose where the next fight takes place which of course can be used to massive um benefit as things start to fill up the heroin here rather simply gives you a plus 10 benefit to your battle strength and however because she is not

a mercenary she is not going to be affected by cards such as the drummer or the season cards which we'll touch on now so the first of these season cards is the winter season cards and when you play one of these cards you simply put it on the main board to show what season it is and the winter card basically means that every single mercenary is going to be worth strength one so again if people have started playing their really strong cards down down if you start playing a winter card down everything is going to be completely nerfed back down to a strength one meaning that even if you have just low cards in your hand you still have a chance of winning and and when the uh winter is the current season it really does become a bit more of a a war of attrition you know how many cards are you going to contribute to this fight and how far are you willing to take it now some other cards still do affect the winter card like for example if you have the drummer and the winter out at the same time then all these strength one cards will be taken to strength two and much like the winter card here the spring card goes directly onto the board even replacing the winter card or the winter card would replace the spring card if this was on the board already um and the spring card basically adds a plus three strength modifier to the strongest card in the battle at the moment so again if the strongest card amongst all the players is a strength nine then all the strength NES are going to be suddenly worth a strength 12 so the players are either going to keep playing cards or passing until everybody has passed and then whoever's got the strongest battle line in that

battle is going to place their Victory cube in the contested region and normally the winner of the fight will take the battle marker to determine where the next battle is going to get fought however as I mentioned whoever played the most spy cards if any in the previous round Will trump that so again taking spy cards is very powerful for that reason now something I haven't mentioned which is a pivotal part of this game is the way the hand management works because unlike a lot of card games whenever you play a card or at the end of the round you do not draw back up to your hand limit so these cards that you have that you're dished out at the start of the game um have to last you potentially multiple fights meaning that you really do have to pace yourself and you can't really go gung-ho into all these battles however there are some little tricks you can consider because if you ever play all your mercenary cards and only have special cards left in your hand you can voluntarily um discard all of the special cards meaning you'll have no cards left now you might want to do that because if there is only ever one player left with cards in their hand then they are forced to discard what they have and that could mean they have a bunch of really powerful cards remaining so it really is an interesting game of wanting to play your cards you know with a with a relatively easy Pace to L you but not wait too long so that you're caught off guard and are forced to discard um a bunch of great cards and

once everybody does have no cards either through playing them or being forced to discard their cards that is when you draw back up to your um either 10 cards plus one card for each region you already control and as I said you're going to keep playing that way until somebody has five regions anywhere on the board or three adjacent regions so let's just say that the yellow player ended up claiming that region there they would instantly win the game because they have three connecting regions there okay so let's share some thoughts on condotti a so I want to start with how easy and simple this game is to digest because all you do on your turn is to either pass or to play a card but despite that very simple formula the consequences and the ripple effect of your actions is absolutely huge because as we've discussed these cards interact with each other in a really cool way everything has its strengths and weaknesses and everything has its part to play and that is really Amplified by the fact that these cards have to last you through multiple battles meaning that everyone is a very valued resource you know is now the right time to play it how am I going to Pace myself when is the time to commit these cards should I do it now while um you know while I have the strong hand of cards um I don't want to be caught off guard because I don't want to be forced to discard them however again I don't want to be left out of pocket while there's still a bunch of other people with full cards of hands at their disposal so yeah there's a lot of weight to your actions here despite the very simple formula I also

love the degree of mind games that come into play uh with this one you really do have to get into the head of your opponents and try to think why they are doing what they're doing you know if especially when it ties back to a developing board here you have to read the board State thinking why who is this region important for who is this a must-win for and why are they playing the cards they're doing because if they keep on playing low cards you might have to think you know what why are they playing these low cards if they really need to win this fight maybe all of a sudden they are going to turn it into winter and completely ruin all your strong cards and turn them back to a strength one and maybe they are going to double the value of all their troops meaning that you might want to end it early by playing your turnco or something before it gets to that stage so it really is this kind of game of chicken chicken of you know not only when to play the right cards but how much you are willing to dedicate to things and something I want to mention of a personal note is that generally I do struggle with remembering what all kind of different roll cards and things do with games like this however this one did resonate with me instantly because everything makes sense I don't even have to kind of look at the symbology or anything because I can just completely remember what each card does because everything has its place and there's not like Philly rules or anything to um you know to take you out the imers of the game you can look at a glance at what these cards do and understand how powerful they are and when is the best time to play them the time this game takes does vary quite a bit depending on

the player count this does cater to two to six players and and to completely transparent I wouldn't even consider playing this at two players it's just not something I'm looking to do but if you do I think you both start with a balanced deck of cards and have to play like that um at three players the game actually does still work really well um and you can actually get it done in about 25 minutes which is quite remarkable considering the depth that you have to kind of rack your brains over but where this game really does come alive is at that four or five player count um it is really fantastic at that but you are looking at probably slightly longer than the Box stage and we played a five player game of this the other day and we were looking probably around 75 to 90 minutes um but that being said um we it did go right to the wire you know we all had places all over the place and you know it probably was the longest version of the game it was going to be but despite that I think everybody was on the edge of the seat and completely immersed and engaged from start to finish which is quite a big Accolade um because it's not it's not that often where I'm not looking at my watch thinking you know this is taking longer than it needs to this is taking longer than the box says in this one I did not even care because I was that engrossed I also feel like the replayability for this game is very strong because this is one of those rare exceptions where if you play this game with the same gaming group again and again you are going to start to develop a bit of a meta game and those little kind of strategies and tactics that you

might use to Hoodwink your opponents might not be able to work down the line meaning you might have to think outside the box and play things in ways that might not seem so productive to start with so yeah I really do like the way that you can get develop the game and start to think of new ways to um conquer these regions and to win I think the production for this game is pretty much perfect uh the board is pretty small but it's very nice that this game especially if this is like meatiness um it fits in this tiny little box on your shelf so you're getting like a full game experience here without taking much of your shelf um the artwork of the cards is spectacular this is exactly my taste when it comes to artwork love these kind of medieval um drawings absolutely brilliant to look at the card stock is also Lin and finished so it looks um you know very nice to play with nice to shuffle um just good quality all around not over produced not under produced and again because it fits in such a small box absolutely the cherry on the icing okay so let's get into some final thoughts on Kier and if you can't tell um I think this game is absolutely fantastic I am enamored with it at the moment I'm just completely um inspired in terms of getting this one back to the table because I think it is such a brilliantly well executed um game especially if you are looking at that four five or six player count and you want to you know cater to these higher player accounts without having to lean on lighter games or party games this is going to be a fantastic option for you to sink your teeth into but still engaging in these mind games and trying

to lure people out to playing their best cards bluffing um just pacing yourself the attrition part of the game is absolutely brilliantly executed and I just think it is such a well done um area majority game it's definitely going to be one of those games that lasts a long time if not forever in my collection because of it purity because of the layers of interaction that this game offers I'm so so impressed it plays quickly it plays smoothly um and despite all the different roles they are easy to understand and I've not had a single problem in anybody remembering what each thing does and you know what there's even like a good reference on the back of the book here so if they do have that little bit of a problem to remember what all the roles do they can just have a quick glare at that but yeah overall just so so impressed and I cannot wait to get this back to the table and play it with some people I've not had the opportunity to share it with yet um if you like a majority games and even if you like something like the king is dead um where you do have that mixed with this hand management system this is a fantastic option because while I appreciate games like the king is dead it felt a little bit stuffy and a little bit too transparent for me whereas this one just has that little bit of spiciness that little bit of um you know I suppose you can call it luck in relation to the way the cars are distributed but it just works you know I don't even care if the cars work against me because it's just that much much uh that much fun and that immersive and the stakes feel really high despite the breeziness of the uh of the rules so yeah so so impressed and um yeah going straight to my collection and just want to play it more and more and more

especially um at those higher player accounts because it is that good that is Kier

Progress saved