Dune: Imperium – Uprising Review (including 6-player game)
Transcript
hey everybody Welcome to drive-through view 786 today we're going to talk about Dune Imperium Uprising which is a standalone SL expansion for the original Dune Imperium now I recently talked about this on a podcast and in that I mentioned uh the plays that IID had up to that point and I had played I think at that point 1 2 three and four players I have at this point but I had not yet played the six player kind of variant mode the team mode where it's three players against three players and I have now just once but I have so that was kind of what I was waiting for to get at this review um because you know well we'll talk more about it in the review let's just say that and I I'll cover everything not just the six player game I will go over some of the you know minor changes and stuff that are you know different between this and the base game and some of the new additions like spies and the worms and all that stuff I'll go down and show you about that at the table and then I'll go a little little bit into the rules for uh the six player game the three versus three game and then I'll come back and give you my overall General thoughts but I was waiting to get that six player game in cuz to me that was the most kind of unique part of this expansion otherwise it would just kind of be like a regular expansion uh you know granted with a new board and stuff so too much to do let's go down to the table and we'll come back up and talk about it okay got some stuff laid out here on the table and first
thing we're going to look at just a couple of the changes that are kind of new with this expansion and this is kind of the expansion part of this box because you can actually play this Standalone you can see this is a brand new board you it replaces completely the board from the base game now I have it on the six player side there's not too much differences between the six player and then the one to four player side mostly it's the same but I thought I would just have it on this side now both sides have this little spy space here and so players can play spies out here onto the board and so different actions like if you go here to the ESP space you can see you go there it's a Benny deser space you draw a card and you can put a spy out you can put a spy out on any of these spots here and these spy spots are linked to multiple spots on the board so if you go up here out onto arus itself you can see there's multiple spots out here that connect to spies and what happens is let's just zoom in a tight bit there is let's say somebody else has gone to one of the connected spots here like the spice Refinery having a spy there allows me to place my agent there and then without being blocked and when that happens I'll pull the spy off so I've used up that spy there now the other thing you can do with the Spy is you can put that there and then if you want to pull that off of your own free will and then you just draw a card from your deck the other part is there will be other cards and things that will interact with spies that are out there so they may say like you know as an
example here's an intg card that kind of works both ways so you can either put a spy out on a blue spot which is one of those or remove a spy and if you do then you can in this case break the shield wall or and excuse me and get two spice and so there's some other cards and things like that that will interact with the spies in that case and the other major new thing is if we go down here to the battle area get these house cards out of the way and we can take a look here we can see kind of the same sort of battle area that we had before with four quadrants and you'll get troops out here and and so on now the next thing that you can do is you can summon here a worm to your section of the Battlefield game comes with wooden worms and plastic worms they're are not different mechanically uh but that's what you've got now to get a worm out though you have to have gotten these maker hooks you just have to do it once once you get the maker hooks then you can go and recruit worms to fight in the battle now if you see down here the worms are worth three points in the battle or three strength and you know swords are one troops are two worms or three worms will go away they'll go back into the desert after the battle has happened however if you win a battle or place in a battle you get some reward in a battle then you will get double the reward so let's take a look here at an example of a reward card there and so we can see here so if I had gotten first place then
I could do that twice so I could get basically two points I can claim the Imperial Basin twice which is meaningless and I could spend Four Spice to get another Victory Point twice so I could get four points out of that and you only need 10 points to win so that's almost half your points whereas if I got second instead of five spice I could get 10 spice as long as I had a worm so it really ramps up the fight and the conflict when those worms kind of come out now a couple other things to notice about these cards here you can see this little symbol here a lot of the early entry cards this is a level three like the ones and twos don't really have a lot of points as much as they used to in the base game but everybody will start with a symbol here so you've got a m and Chris knife ornithopter another thing there and um if you get a set here so let's say I had started the game with this orthop here and then collected this one here and you actually won that battle card when you win you keep the card and once you have a set of two of these you'll turn both cards face down this and that and then you get get a victory point so there's a little bit of kind of a delayed Victory point it it works kind of interestingly because it sort of sweetens things up a little bit and makes people maybe prevent you from getting a card that they normally wouldn't care about necessarily cuz sometimes you know the rewards will be more or less useful kind of depending on your situation it's a nice little kind of wrinkle there now the last thing I'll mention is these two contract spaces here on the board now this is kind of
like an optional mini expansion that comes with the game so it says you can play with or without those I would assume play with them there's no no harm in that there'll be spaces on the board and cards and stuff like that that'll allow you to go and collect a contract you just go and grab one of the two face up contracts for free and they will give you a few different things so these two are pretty straightforward so this means if I go to that ESP Pace I showed you earlier in addition to doing that I will get three bucks three Solari and then I turn that face down and so that will count as a completed contract once that's taken by somebody you know a new one will come out here and a lot of these are like giving you sort of incentives to go to a space to get something a little bit extra now you can see this sard car one there's two of these in the stack if you are playing the emperor shadam then you will start with those two contracts in front of you allows you to have kind of a big turn if you go to the sard car you can fulfill those contracts and there's some other cards here or contracts here let's just use a couple of examples like this one here if you harvest three or more spice you get an extra money if you purchase a uh spice must flow card you get to go up on the guild uh track and then get three bucks so those little incentivizes that you will always play with if you've got shadam I fourth in play uh but you don't always have to play with them I would recommend just playing with them now a couple things to notice about the team game so that's all the basic changes there so first thing
about the team game is you will see here we've you've got a little bit different of a scoring track so if you are an ally there will be two allies and one Commander the Allies start on the onepoint part of the track and the commanders will start on the Four Points so at the end of the game you are going to total up all the points for your team so you're going to have two allies on your team and using an appropriate color here have one Commander so we get all these up here let's say we've got like this so in this case the game will end as soon as one player and then would be six markers out here on the track as soon as one player Hits 10 just like normal but then you total up everybody's points so if this is one team we'd have 10 plus 14 so everybody would have 24 points so when you win battles if anybody's getting points it's good for your team because that effectively is points for your team and so you might if you're in the battle with somebody else cuz you're still s of effectively competing against each other in a way but you might say you know what I want a little bit more spice and it's fine fine if you get the points and I don't not a big deal and so it gets a little bit interesting that way and adds a different Dynamic now the commanders do not participate in the battles the commanders do not go up on the different faction tracks that we can see here and one thing that you can notice here is if we look up here this is normally like the Imperial track but this is called the Great houses track on this side of the board here because again this is the six player side
whereas if we go down here this is The Fringe worlds track not the fman track so in the case of the six player game the commander for the emperor which is always shadam IV will have their own little faction track here and only they are going up that track they'll have the one little Cube that goes up and then they have a couple of spaces that they can access here and so the interesting thing about this is the emperor's team their whole team cannot get maker Hooks and cannot summon the worms cuz that makes if you've seen the movies or read the books that makes perfect sense there's no way they would be able to do that and so you can still get a couple of victory points out of here there's a little Victory Point token thing there when you hit these spaces you will distribute uh from the bank one Solari to every player on your team and then also every player on your team could place a spy in that case the other thing here with mad on the other side same idea here go up the track distribute spice distribute water and then and the interesting thing about this is when one of mad's allies gets maker hooks they both get them okay and they have got their own little spots here so if the two teams I've been showing you yellow and red one of them gets maker hooks they both get it they can both summon worms for the rest of the game now the other thing to note about the worms is you also have this spot up here this is The Shield wall there is a spot here I showed you a card earlier that could do it there's also a spot on the board if we'll just zoom in this little symbol here means destroy
The Shield wall now when we were looking at here we go this card from before this was the battle for their Imperial Basin and you cannot send worms to any battles that are depicting places that are inside here basically Arin this is the main capital city of Iraq it's it's surrounded by a bunch of rocks and mountains and stuff the worms can't get in there there's no way for them to physically get in there until the shield wall gets destroyed then and only then can you summon worms uh in round where this uh battle card is depicted once the shield wall is destroyed it's destroyed for the rest of the game so if you're not you know really participating in the Worm Game then you don't want to destroy that Shield wall you want to prevent people from doing that so just so we are clear on that um there are restrictions on this space and some other spaces so you need two influence here and then you can get maker Hooks and get a recruit a soldier and then you can break the shield wall so the um the emperor's team in the six player game was not really ever going to want to go there but the places to recruit worms are down here and this is where you get spice and this is the same on the other side of the Border you're basically either getting worms or you're getting spice so that's that's what there's kind of interesting thematically about what's going on the emperor and the har conans and those guys are trying to just get spice out of the Desert and by by doing so they're blocking the freman from uh
you know getting their sort of attack ability and M's allies whereas the uh if mad and them go and get the worms they're preventing the emperor and the Imperium from getting spice which is cool now just two more things the emperor and muad have their own deck of starting cards you can see by the symbol here in the upper right You' got the the emperor symbol there and then you've got the more deep symbol there so these are the starting cards they can go and they can buy decks they play normal turns like I said they don't send troops to battle they don't you know recruit up these faction boards only on their own and then their workers are like this so instead of Agents they get these little tokens now they only start with two workers just like everybody else they have these two agents here you can see there's arrows like this and like this and then their sword master their third agent that they get has this one and so the way that the game works let's zoom out a little bit and so if I'm looking at the board like this and I'm sitting right below the bottom of the board on the planet the Mad player sits here so we take mad they sit here okay Emperor is out in space he's out in the galaxy somewhere the emperor player will always sit there then your two allies will sit across from you diagonally so princess Ulan she would sit here next to to Mand and then cuz she it gives you a list of who can be allied with who and then fade
ralo would sit over here so M will be surrounded by his enemies Al so will shadam I fourth so let me we have lady Jessica up here she's got a pretty cool ability where she uh takes the Water of Life spoilers and then she converts to Reverend mother Jessica so she would sit let's say over here on this side and let's find another one let's put gurnie into play here so we put him up there so the way that you take turns you determine start order same as the base game the two commanders will never be start player so let's say lady Jessica gets start player so she will go so that would be mad de's team the emperor will go Emperor's team back to M Deep's team gurnie then down here down here down here so you will alternate teams like so and so that makes sense why we have these arrows now so if I'm want here and I go to a spot it's just like any other agent but anything that the Mad player doesn't directly do like put troops out or go up faction tracks then this player will do that the one pointed there if I were to use this one instead in that case that's pointed there that would be gurnie and then when I recruit my swordmaster when I play this I can either I can choose either one so there's a very very interesting thing timing things there because maybe this player's gone maybe they put troops in they haven't put troops in yet so you're trying to figure out
who you want to help out and you're also sitting across from each other so you can't sit there on your side of the table and go back and forth and Whisper and all these kinds of things you've got to talk in the open and you have to kind of talk uh the rules say not to really like you know have hand signals or code and stuff like that but we found that we talked in generalities and you know you know it's it's interesting because if you think of the theme of it with spies in everybody's houses and stuff like that it's kind of interesting because they can hear you but you know you know they probably have a good idea what you're trying to do so it's an interesting table Dynamic for sure uh so that's that the only other thing to mention here with these sword Masters cuz you get your third agent is when you get your third agent whether you're the commander or you're a regular player and you have a normal agent you get that third one you can only use that third one once in the whole game once you get it and you spend that third one that one's gone forever you say well why well because the board's crowded first of all cuz you got six people putting stuff out the other reason is when you get a swordmaster you then get this permanently and so the instant that you recruit your third swordmaster let's say we you know the red player here we got some troops out here and you will mark this like so so you will always have plus two to your combat okay and then if you are the commander you put it here in the center and then when it becomes your revealed turn any swords
or anything like that that you reveal at that point you can choose which of your allies you're going to apply that to so you apply all your swords to that Ally so you're going to say oh I'm going to I'm going to try to beef you up so you can win and you can you know obviously have an open discussion about that but so the sword master gives you the plus two and don't sleep on the plus two cuz that that will be you know pretty useful um yeah so that's that's pretty much all the little changes and stuff uh I mean we could get into all the different powers and special abilities and the cards but who wants to do that okay so that's Dune Imperium Uprising I'm going to go through just my uh main pillars of review first off it's player count um I've played this all the player counts 1 2 3 4 six uh the game still plays great at all the player counts including six which I'll leave some of the six player discussion towards the end but I like it at all the player counts if you're thinking of getting the game for any player count I'd recommend it the solo game is really cool I didn't show you the new rival cards so each of the instead of like using the ring ability on the faction cards there's a special little card that gives you kind of a different ring ability it's a little bit more appropriate for solo and there's some other little wrinkles there so it works really well I think it's great solo this way and you know all the way through um now play time you know just playing the base game takes about the same time as you know the original like so an hour and a half 2 hours so I have not played Uprising with any of the expansions I'll talk more about that in
a second but I just wanted to play it just by itself see how it works by itself um now the six player game that took us uh almost 4 hours to do and we had everybody had at least played the original Dune Imperium at least once but it had been some time for a couple of the folks that they hadn't played it in probably at least a year or so and there were some other folks that had played in you know you know Uprising and the the base game a whole bunch so kind of a mix of folks and there was definitely like a learning curve not in terms of the mechanics or the complexity but just in kind of in terms of like how is this kind of supposed to work you know trying to sort of sus things out and try things on and get everything figured out so there was a little bit of a slow burn there at the beginning and I think if we were to sit down with you know a similar group of six people would go a little bit quicker I could see the six player game getting done in about 3 hours but it's a big epic experience I mean that's kind of what you expect uh out of that and that's kind of what the point of that game is there's even a six player variant and speaking of expansions there's rules for throwing in expansions with you know kind of the normal game there's different rules for throwing them in with the six player Team game and all that kind of stuff um so first I'll talk about um the expansions and kind of compare this as if it was just kind of an expansion to the base game and that kind of stuff and then I'll talk about the six player game so I to me the two the experiences of this game that I've had are just Uprising by itself I think it's it's
tied with the base game plus the uh rise of I expansion so I really really like that expansion that adds the uh dreadnots and that kind of thing now you could mix all that in you could have dreadnots and worms and all kinds of stuff um I think I would like to do that I think um that in some cases that's kind of a big ask for my group cuz not everybody is has the same level of enthusiasm some people like me they really really like it other people are kind of like e they don't it's okay or they don't like it at all um so that's kind of a tough ask but that would to me that would be kind of like I wonder if that's kind of the gold standard now there's been a lot of stuff online and and some suggestions from the designers about how to actually mix in you know build a card pool that's like perfect or something cuz you can take base game original Dune Imperium cards throw them in with this you know take certain cards out of X Out of immortality all that stuff it all works together so this is really not a new game or anything it's just another expansion it just happens to be also be Standalone and is also compatible with every other Dune Imperium you know release that they've had it's just a really big expansion and I was actually thinking about this I'm like this is the first time I've seen what I would call like a super expans that's a stupid name but I'm like this is a huge expansion because it it not only does it add new stuff that you could mix in with the old stuff it kind
of re jiggers the game it has a whole six-player format and you know and it kind of unlocks a lot of creativity I think in people to be able to build a custom deck you know a lot of times with these deck building games and deck building is a decent part of this game people like to custom cize their deck and I'm thinking of like Thunderstone and Ascension because people like to play that epic Thunderstone where throw like one of each card or they like to build up that perfect sort of setup or set up different scenarios especially with like Thunderstone Quest you kind of build thematic setups and Ascension because the way that kind of is like plug-and play with expansions you can say I'm going take this expansion this expansion maybe a couple cards from here and this and so you can really kind of play around and set up kind of an experience there which is really neat I like that the game sort of gotten to that point where hey there's a lot of cards here pick your favorites or whatever and throw them in there or you you know you don't have to do that but it gives you the option to do that and it gives you a a bunch of different ways to play it and I've seen more people want to play sort of like an epic experience where they play the Bas game which is kind of like the first movie if you want the first part of the book and then move into Uprising which is the kind of the climax of The the end of the first book and everything so that that's pretty cool that you can can do all that um but yeah so if if you said what was your favorite way to play this game I think rise of X with the base game is still there but I just don't know if
adding x with this game would just be too much stuff going on because I did like immortality but playing that like with X I mean it's just like I'm not sure what I'm getting like what I'm gaining to me to me it should be and I think I mean my mind could change here over time as I try things out but should be discreet it should be one of the two base games with maybe an expansion but this kind of has an expansion built in cuz there's all these other things going on because the base game by itself I still I mean I would still play just the base game it's still pretty pure in that way and one of the things I really like about the base game that I don't hate about this but I like that you can kind of win that game without doing a lot of combat sometimes because I mean if you think about it there's not like a lot of fighting and dune it's like I mean there is but it's also a lot of political maneuvering and stuff like the you know the the bureaucracies and the the Intrigue and the backstabbing and all those kind of things and the setting up the kind of like personto person Warfare the psychological warfare whatever um manipulation of economies and things like that which is a vastly important piece of everything you know resources and human capital and everything like that is super a part of conflict it's not always just like Bloodshed on a battlefield um so this more focuses more on that with Uprising and not so much with the base game
um which one do I like better I really care you know it's like I don't know what whatever I'm not like oh I have to have conflict and I have to have you know Blood on the field or I have to have not have blood on the field I mean it's just like what it is it's whatever right it it is whatever it's going to be and just know that you're going to kind of get that different experience and you can play with that different experience to me there's not like a better way that way I I don't think there it better doesn't come into the equation in that case okay enough with that so the thing that really kind of pushes elevates this box and I was hoping that it would and I was a little bit nervous how it would based on the rules and how things work out is that six player Team game which is see that one might be my favorite way to play the game now that's going to be a tough ask like I said getting six people you need exactly six people you need six people who want to play a team game which isn't you know necessarily easy to find because you don't see a lot of that but there's a cool Dynamic there that elevates the game to an interesting level of discussion and back and forth and teamwork and all that kind of stuff that you just don't get um with the base game and it really the one thing that is interesting I I do like the 1979 original Dune game from oh whoever made it Avalon Hill I guess I don't think that's right but gaale Force 9 has the license to that now I do like that game and I think that game has that
interesting sort of player to player political negotiation Dynamic among the players this game kind of simulates that in a way through the mechanics and in the card play and everything and I think it does an amazing job of it I don't think it's it's a black and white because we're negotiating head-to-head that makes it better a better negotiation scheming game than because you do with three mechanics I again I don't think there's a better there maybe there's a preference from folks I don't know but the group experience thing is missing from just regular Dune Imperium or Dune Imperium Uprising when you have the team game we have that group dynamic cuz in the original 79 version you have that shifting you could have alliances is and you could have a two or three player Alliance and that could change the next time you know a sandworm card came up those alliances could reshift so there was that those this has the alliances cuz it's just a fixed Alliance there's no like moving around which thematically you know from the 79 one doesn't make a ton of sense on the theme um you know cuz the fman are not like ay with the emperor ever there's no way and you know certain things like like that and especially when you had the expansions in and they had the what is it the Benny tax and the I and other they've added some more and it starts to be like that's not how those factions really work you know and you can say oh they could win through subterfuge or
face dancers or whatever but you know whatever um so but this has sorry for the digression this has that cool group experience that I really think people should give a look because now when I played it I played as M de I found that fascinating and I my buddy who played as the emperor he was like I love it I love it everybody else at the table also had a really good time I kind of wonder if there would be a little bit on my part like a fear of missing out if I were to play one of the allies and not be playing as as the commander but I don't know now that I I think that I've played it one time I'm I would be good playing that because then I've had that experience and so now I know how to kind of talk to the commander whoever it was cuz I kind of know what they can and can't do whereas if you're one of the allies and you've not been the commander you don't necessarily get a good sense until maybe you played it through a full playthrough of like you know how can they help me or what can I be doing to set myself up to be helped that kind of stuff we had a really good discussion in the game that we played with myself and one of the allies and they was like oh you know if I could have done this in this order and was it was feasible then you know we could have been much better in this particular situation um because I needed you know he in his case he needed water in a certain case and that kind of stuff so that's a pretty cool interesting Dynamic there with how how that works
and it's pretty interesting thematically as well because you know when you play the one to four player game then um anybody can go get the worm doesn't really matter in the team game the emperor's team doesn't can't get the worm so they don't have that doubler um for the combat so that's a huge disadvantage now in the game that we play damper actually won the game but they get a lot of other tricks that they can do to kind of make up for that kind of bring the vast resources of the Imperium into play so it is a very kind of asymmetric experience strategically and tactically mechanically you know pretty close but that's also a very very cool thing and if you watched the movie read the books I think you will really appreciate that team game and how that really kind of shakes out cuz it actually seemed very very unfair at the beginning we were like this is way lopsided for want de team because it's like go in there get some worms like blow up the shield wall right away so we can be in every combat and just start doubling up uh victories you know rewards and it doesn't matter let's get something and you're you get 10 spice or whatever and that's just going to make things awesome for you but it it definitely uh shifted towards the end game was very very close there and then the emperor pulled away in the last uh the last round there um so they do get a lot of stuff in their toolbox to help out and so that asymmetry is it's just another nice element to that six player game um yeah so I mean there's no
there's no Dune spoilers here I think I mentioned I might cut it out but um anyway I'm not going to spoil anything but if you watch my top 50 video uh last year this is my number one board game on the list I have a couple of games higher than aren't board games but this is my number one board game it's I think this makes it even more so you know it's just like all the six player thing and all the just different configurability and all that stuff just really cool and dune is like my favorite nerd thing so that kind of does a lot of the heavy lifting I think although I mean if this wasn't Dune I mean it wouldn't be it wouldn't exist nobody would make a game like this and have it be a different theme like sometimes people say Well it wouldn't be popular wooden Dune I was like well wouldn't exist cuz nobody would just make these mechanics like out of thin air anyway give me a break anyway so um but for me personally yeah it does do some heavy lifting I think I don't think you need to know Dune hey you need to know it you need to have an idea about it but that's it I mean you need to have an idea about trains right to play an 18xx game anyway um I think this game is great I would get this expansion you probably already got it I was a little slow in getting this out but I really wanted to try the six player experience before I reviewed it and it was getting so late I was like well I kind of want to see the second movie before I review it and I'm like yeah there's nothing really to say there but it does it does a good job we got this um I think
there's going to be a part three movie anyway I I recommend it thanks