Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dune Imperium UPRISING Review- Improving a Masterpiece?

Transcript 29:05

doesn't this all look so familiar and it should because Dune Imperium Uprising the brand new release from dirolf is so closely intertwined and related to the original 2020 release of Dune Imperium I almost see it as if it was the ship of thesis of board games just how much can you replace how many new components how many new characters how many modified cards can you add on before a game becomes something brand new and this isn't meant to be an insult to Uprising in fact Uprising is so closely related it's even backwards compatible to the original game and its expansions even though it is an independent sequel to Dune Imperium the majority of content from both expansions and the previous core game can be incorporated into Uprising but before I go into the complex relationship between Uprising and its prequel as well as the two expansions immortality and Rise of X I really want to focus in and talk about Uprising success and why I think it's the stronger of the independent releases ultimately the puzzle that Uprising presents is tenser more brutal requires more interactivity and also is the more rewarding and replayable game Uprising takes everything the original did well and refines it into a wonderful cacophony of decision decision making

which represents a brilliant game like any tight and stressful game the tension Rises throughout each and every round and your knives that you receive are blunt and shapeless until you are able to refine your strategy you create a deck or you build an army or you have access to resources that increases your strength as the stakes go ever higher the race to 10 points is so tense and each point matters as you bump up on the influences you can see other people sweating as they hold the alliance token close to their chest entry cards are powerful and always are so much fun when someone finally reveals for a huge reverse resources are so tight you always feel hungry and it's fun and it's brilliant because your creativity goes through by Saving cards or buying cards or what resource you prioritize or which faction you want to go to the game provides meaningful decisions and you always end the game wanting to make changes to your strategy and wanting to improve and refine your own decision makings and everything I said is perfectly applicable for Dune Imperium as well but Uprising goes one step further Beyond it's such a finely balanced game with interesting board spaces and fascinating card mechanics that really just tickles your brain in the right places you feel like you're making making meaningful decisions every

turn and that's because you are the game rewards creativity it rewards plans and it rewards plans within plans everything that was a little off or maybe felt a little unbalanced or didn't make the most sense has been completely addressed in this game and I know it's a different puzzle but puzzles can be improved upon and I think Dune Imperium Uprising really does improve on that core puzzle the sole of the games are the same they share the same love but uprisen is meaner it's smarter it creates complex board States and swings and meaningful interactions between players that really creates a fun and engaging game throughout in a way that Dune Imperium the original just doesn't reach and ultimately there's a couple key mechanics that Uprising implements which really elevates an outstanding game like Dune Imperium into one of the best games I've ever played Dune Imperium Uprising really has three new mechanics that really accentuate and increases that decision making space that a player has first of which are those spies these cylinder looking buddies each player is given three spies and you place them on a web of spy outposts that interconnect different spaces together and this mechanic is truly quite brilliant because whenever you gain the ability to place a spy it acts as a second layer of

worker placement when someone places down a spy it allows the ability for them to infiltrate it at a later time and essentially sneak another agent on top or the ability to gather intelligence by drawing a new card when they reach that space and this is really an excellent mechanic because it gives foresight to the other players while also providing an advantage to the player who puts down the Spy and let me give you a quick example in my own group's meta the two most in demand spy places are the lrad for the early game and the space and Guild for the mid and late game the lanc rad because when someone purchases that swordmaster the first time for that eight Solari cost having a spy ready to go gives them ease of access to purchase it second for that six salari while maintaining turn advantage on the other hand the the spacing Guild has one of the most powerful combat spaces with the highliner space and being able to access that late game gives the massive ability to sway a combat into their favor even if the space is blocked by another player these spies really create multiple levels of thought because once the Spy is down other players have some idea of what the player is thinking but it also gives that advantage to that player by giving them that future access to either card draw or to be able to infiltrate and use the space along with that because there's only three spies

you have to be intelligent on your placement you want to block other people's spies but you also want them to be meaningfully useful to yourself some characters or cards even have abilities of pulling up spies for certain benefits inry cards for example might give you a huge boost in fighting Power if you recall two spies for example all of this is layered together brilliantly because the puzzle of worker placement is is now layered in a way that's creative thematic and really creates varied board states that tell a neat story between you and your other players players for example know that I like putting my spy on the Benny Jer spot because the moment someone gets those four intrigues they know I'm coming after them even if they block the secret space it's fun it's thematic and it works very well lastly when it comes to these spies desperation breeds creative play and a lot of these cards the new ones they have limited faction access and you'll really feel a lot more restricted on which factions you're able to go through but cleverly enough the spies actually act as a medium to get to these factions lots of cards have a spy access symbol which will enable you to reach those spaces a little bit more conveniently as long as you plan ahead ultimately the spies create those juicy board States those interesting puzzles and creates an opportunity to plan for the future while slightly revealing your intentions it's clever and smart and pushes what can be

mechanically done now the second major mechanical upgrade is the CH module and in the manual the Chom module is pitched almost as a mini expansion but truthfully I would recommend everyone to begin with it there's no reason not to and it does solve one of the greatest problems people had with the original Dune Imperium The Cho module is about variance you'll notice that the currency to get get your engine really moving Solari is quite restrictive at the start and the Cho module gives out Solari but in a way that requires you to accept a contract one of these little cardboard tokens on this token it's super easy it says the space you need to go to um maybe there's a requirement that needs to be met you need to harvest so much spice in one turn and in return you would get some kind of reward mostly it's Solari the money to get that engine going the reason why this is an important addition is that D Imperium the core game um and even rise of X and immortality have been somewhat solved in the early game there's almost a set path of what the optimal play is um and that's really to rush Solari in whatever way possible to get your sword master as quickly as possible for that turn Advantage now because the CH module exists you're not going to be able to go to the same spaces every single game you're going to need to modify your strategy while I still think it's very strong to get Solario as quickly as possible the method that you need to do so is now different and varied for each game depending on what contracts you

receive some of these contracts are quite deceptively difficult as well for example harvest in for spice in a turn it's quite rare and it's quite hard and almost restrictive to do on the other hand easier spaces easier contracts um are often quickly snagged by competing players so you want to be on top of those to get those contract spaces at its core The Cho module and the contract system really try to increase that variance what might not be an optimal play in one game could quickly become the most cost effective move in another game putting you in new situations which ultimately tickles your dopamine receptors and keeps you engaged game after game final mechanical addition is regarding the combat system um two major additions have been implemented to increase player involvement throughout all the combat the first of which are objectives um you have the Cris knife the desert Mouse the or thopter and these are the ones that have little symbols that you're trying to collect into pairs at the start of the game each player is given a symbol for a four-player game for example there's two desert mouses and two Chris knives and the reason why these objectives exist is that each individual conflict should have some deeper level for example two players with the desert Mouse objective will be more likely to engage each other in that conflict on the other hand and players with other objective cards might want to stop other players from collecting that pair as each pair is

worth a point that's the more subtle mechanic I would say but it is Meaningful because each individual conflict does have a prolonged impact on the rest of the game because each pair of symbols does result in a victory point in a game with such tight scores each Half Point each match and symol gives the potential to overtake other players in a clever and more engaging way the big selling point though the one that everyone talks about are these sand worms um and thankfully there's both the wooden tokens and a more deluxe plastic token that can be painted um both function exactly the same but the idea is throughout the game you can gather the maker hooks to actually activate and use the sandw warms sandw warms are more powerful than regular troops with three strength but the key reward is that whatever conflict rewards you receive are doubled no matter if you win or come in second or third place with in the conflict this gives massive potential for swings but also encourages other players to make sure that if there is a sandw warm in the combat that you aren't receiving two three four even more victory points by playing that sand war that said the sandworms are a bit of work to actually gain and collect you need to gain friendship with the freman as well as go to sich tabur to gain the hooks to eventually summon sandworms by going to one of the two spaces or playing cards overall all combat is a larger focus in Uprising relative to Dune there's a greater emphasis on the rewards not only of yourself but of

other players each objective card pair really does impact the general flow because you can tell when people are starting to collect these objective cards through each victory that they're slowly gaining momentum and having more possible Pathways to reach in the 10 points along with that the sand worms themselves are a massive potential for swings and as soon as you see someone building up to it you need to be prepared to deal with the actual consequences otherwise they'll steamroll through each round and make their way to the very end of course there is the aspect of actually blowing up the shield wall that's almost kind of like a game of hot potato of who's going to do it as each player with sand orms will eventually want to blow up the shield wall but it does either take a resource such as an Intrigue or a player's turn to actually commit to do it overall the stack handoff approach to each round of conflicts does increase the general tension of each game and since each round is capped off by a conflict it makes sense to really emphasize and focus on them as the peaks of the game there's great memories when it comes to secrets and intrigues at the very end that completely reframe the upcoming rounds when a sand warm is in play and those rewards are given out it results in a meaningful change of what the board state is conflicts are always tense and fun and really are a culmination of all the decisions that have been made in the round as well as rounds prior for this reason I think the direction of the game

of actually increasing the emphasis on conflicts is intelligent it makes sense it makes sense to put extra emphasis on the key moments the moments that people will leave and remember when they pull off a great combat when they receive a ton of rewards it does create meaningful experiences to all the players involved now of course there's all the new stuff there's the objective cards the sandworms the CH module the spies but when we look at the core of the game when we look at the actual meat and bones one of the key modifications that they've done is through the Imperium deck it should be mentioned that the starting deck is exactly the same as the original Dude Imperium but the actual Imperium deck the one you will purchase through each round this one is completely rebalanced and remodified this some subtle changes for example the spice must flow card it's now a spacing Gill card which then has chemistry with other cards where you need to discard a space and Gill card which all have been perfectly fine-tuned in a way that creates a more engaging and interesting deck that can be built cards on average have a higher payoff but also a larger cost as well as the reduction of faction access is now mitigated by the new spy mechanic some cards may be overtuned a bit but I think in general this is a much much stronger deck than the one that was previously made for ding Imperium just

another example is that the standard card that can be always purchased in previous game was the Iraqis leaon it is now the prepare the way one of the Ben Jr cards and to show the level of thought and kind of the refresh that has been put in place this card actually interacts with the Bor cuz you need to have your friendship with the Ben JZ to activate the ability of this card overall the deck feels more balanced it feels Tighter and it feels like each purchase matters more now there even seems to be more card draw throughout the game as well as the ability to recycle and trash cards quicker and I think deck building as a whole is a much more viable strategy than the original Dune Imperium and it's in a way that's more natural than rise of X with immortality um and I hate to say it but immortality while it did increase the deck building it created other problems Dune Imperium Uprising though doesn't have those problems and I'll definitely talk about it more but truly it's about the experimentation cards that kind of skew the boards more to Yellow spaces along with the completely revamped Imperium deck there's also the aspect of the leader cards total of nine brand new ones but all of the originals from the first game and most of the other ones from Rise ofix if you do some fiddling around are perfectly compatible with Uprising that said the nine brand new original ones are all quite creative and

interesting and I do think some of the easierto playay characters actually excellent introductions to the game more so than the original game for example gurnie HCK encourages that constant conflict but it does reward after six strength and that reward is about the deck building aspect of the game game so it creates a very interesting Dynamic where a new player will understand that they should be involved in each conflict and the reward for that is to build a better deck gurny HCK is just one example for example muad the new Paul character really emphasizes creating a strong sandworm machine where you get to top deck an Intrigue intrigues are super fun and sandworms are fun so M enables for a very enjoyable play style even for a new player on the other hand more complex characters still exist but there are some fan favorites that I will be adding on for example the baron everyone loves the baron there's lots of room for influence Focus leaders such as Daddy Leo or the very welld deserved hated tessia as well as the more combat oriented ones like the Beast or even potentially Prince rber if you decide to use rise of X all of these leaders seem to bring something new to table whenever we do the play test for them and I think that they do integrate well enough that they can be ported over the only leader that feels a little bit out of place would be Helena and the reason for that

is the Spy mechanic is so much fun purposely disengaging that with that through her passive does feel like a little bit of a Miss um that said of course she can focus on placing spies on the faction areas for example but it doesn't feel as satisfying as just using another leader and fully engaging with the SP mechanics that said I'm sure in the next couple months once there's a better understanding of the core mechanics and the relationship between this game and the other two expansions there will be some kind of understanding of which leaders best acclimate within this system versus their previous games but now we come to one of the most important questions of the night what is the best version of Dune Imperial is it Uprising by itself is it with one of the expansions or both both expansions is it with the entire deck list of the original game all the expansions into one giga complex game with hundreds of cards dozens of different characters and many different mechanisms all put together and I want to start off with each expansion individually um and we're going to start with rise ofix now rise of X can be pretty much ported over to Dune Imperium Uprising with little complication but I do think there are some areas that you shouldn't bring over infiltration the card mechanic does not bode well with rise of X I think any card with infiltration removes the spies

and spies being such a strong aspect of Uprising to negate that through infiltration which was pretty weak of a mechanic we shouldn't be diluting a good mechanic with a bad mechanic another consideration is that I actually will overtake a couple spaces of Uprising and this does toss the B bance a little bit off I think that the new rebalance shipping area that encourages the use of contracts is better than the ship and track and I think Paul den and the creators at direwolf would agree with that because players who use rise ofix actually have a special 10 card contract deck that's handed out to players ahead of time for them to get a head start on their contracts even with that though the ship and track is notoriously difficult to balance I feel it's impossible to say as I'm just a sample of one but I don't think the ship and track is as well thought out as the revamped Uprising ship area that's said dreadnots are a welcome addition as a third unit in conflicts and TecTiles while they don't have any that interact with sandworms or spies or contracts I think they're still a good idea overall overall I would say that it's actually quite a different game when you play with rise of X I don't know if I like it better yet but I do think think it's worth a deeper dive and seeing the best way we could balance the Imperium deck to reflect rise of x's unique quirks on the other hand I think immortality is a mistake immortality as a whole really

emphasizes that deck Bill and aspect by encouraging people to get essentially free cards by experimentation by using those tacu tanks and getting new cards through that mechanism ignoring the Imperium row and like I mentioned earlier I think deck building in Uprising has been buffed and is a viable method to play the biggest complaint I have is those experimentation cards by adding on those research icons by taking away the units from research station it does dramatically change the way that the game is played there's always that necessary need to get those research icons off on your turn and it kind of skews the balance of your star in hand in a way that feels messy and almost undesirable well I don't have any problems with the TXU tanks and the cards that are provided I think by implementing them it doesn't add something substantial enough to counteract those critiques I have for the research icons when it comes to the actual family atomics that's a whole another issue as well I think family atomics were good for the original game because it allowed for us to remove those insanely overpowered cards like the tacu master or web Powers but I don't feel like it's entirely necessary for this game because having a stale and Puro isn't inherently bad it just means it's a different kind of game that said I think the family atomics you can definitely make an argument for them more so than you can with those research

cards and the research icons so what does this all mean what is this relationship all about and I think the question is what's the best version of Dune Imperium Uprising or what's the best version of Dune Imperium as a whole and I I think when it comes to these expansions it's clear that they were made to address issues within the original game but uprisen doesn't share those same issues and that's why these expansions do feel a little bit off and they're not meant to be implemented one to one no matter what you're going to have to remove some of the content some of the intrigues you're not going to use the conflicts from the original game you want to have a tailored version of this game and I think when it comes to the best possible version it does start with uprisen uprisen is the better game than the original and I would argue it's actually the better game than immortality rise ofix and the original version but I can't say for sure what the exact perfect recipe is for the best version of Uprising I know Paul Den is going to release his deck list his Frankenstein mix but I don't want it right now so if I could say anything in this video it's don't release that mix yet let the community play through it I want to play through it I want to see what can be better Incorporated where are my mistakes when I'm actually designed and thinking about the best version of Dune I hope that the community will be able to experiment and through thousands and thousands of samples we're able to come

to an agreement that rise of X and immortality these are the cards we should use this is the deck list this is the actual way we should implement the game to make it work in the most fun and engaging and balanced way possible the best version of Uprising right now I think is Uprising by itself but once you start adding things on I think you can make a better version through these expansions eventually through I and immortality there will be a way to make a better version but we're just not there yet we need more people to play we need more input and with that input and follow-up discussion I think an ultimate version will eventually come out of all the arguments so after all of that all of these points and thoughts and upgrades and modifications where does everything fall into place starting with the original Dune Imperium just the base game I think it's about a 9 out of 10 it works great it's a smooth silky experience that's tight and tense but I do think it gets a little stale and and kind of has some funky issues um with immortality and Rise of X put together many of those issues are solved there are some other ones like those experimentation icons I mentioned but overall it's about a 9.5 it's a improved game it's more varied there's more leaders there's more going on each game with Uprising though it's closer to about a 9.7 there's a lot of depth there's a lot

of nuance and it's overall a more interesting and engaging game even from Rise ofix and immortality it avoids many of the pitfalls that the original game has and also has the potential to be even something better better I think once you add on I and immortality to Uprising though the game qualities do seem to decrease I would put it closer to about a 9.3 and the reason for this is I and immortality Were Meant to solve issues within the base game Uprising doesn't share those issues of course like any game Uprising does have issues but I don't think the overlap between the original and Uprising issues are very similar from this perspective though I think that eventually we will be able to implement X potentially even immortality and create a deck list a band list a draft order something that works to make the game as equal as balanced as deep as possible I disagree with those who just put everything all together and make one giant Imperial row with all the mechanics available to them but I do think that might be a good starting point because once we start from there we can start to remove things like I mentioned those infiltration cards s potentially some leaders that just toss the balance into disarray and eventually a new mix a new ultimate version will come out which will likely be better than 9.7 might be a 9.8 9.9 10 out of 10 who knows but it's just not there right

now in the next year or so there might be an entirely different expansion which is exclusive for uprisen and that might push the game to the next level there's a lot of room for this fr and I think that Uprising brought it to a new Direction a fresh Direction and a direction that ultimately improves on the base improves on immortality and Rise of X and has that potential to be something even greater from this perspective I highly recommend it I think it's the best version of the game you can get right now and if you haven't delved into either game start with uprisen and then go back if you really want to I know my group we're pretty much exclusively playing Uprising now although we are experimenting with those expansions and seeing what works best the only thing left I wanted to talk about is the single player the two-player and the brand new six player experience that said I think that they're worthy of their own video and I don't want to muddle the main message of this one after a couple more playthroughs especially of that six player version I hope to come back and re-evaluate that as well overall though I think it's fun it's thematic it does feel a little less balanced in the four player version but that's expected it's more of a thematic more of a team based experience more than a competitive format that the four player version presents that said keep it in mind I am coming back to it I haven't played enough and especially not with rise of X and immortality to give it a proper examination and walk myself

through all of the Nuance of that six player mode especially considering there's multiple factions and multiple roles I think it's important to play through all of that before I can give a truthful opinion anyways that's it for me I would love to hear your thoughts on Dune Imperium and dune Uprising and thank you so much

Progress saved