Skip to main content
Loading video...

Torchlit Review - Can You Time That Perfect Loot Grab?

Transcript 15:57

Hey, I'm Alex Rackle from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Torchlet designed by David Spolinsky and from Allplay. Torchlet is a fascinating trick-taking/dungeoncrawler, more more the former than the latter. The dungeon crawler is more in the theme, but it does manage to carry out that theme as you play through the game. Before I dive into this, I should note this channel is sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. And in case you caught that, yes, this is from AllPlay, which means bias definitely exists. I will do my best to give you my thoughts, my pros, my cons, and to be fair to how I feel about the game. But obviously, if you don't feel this could be as useful to you, check out any other content creators who have done content on this. There are a bunch out there. With that said, the general idea of Torch Lit is it's going to be a trick- taking game with predictive bidding, meaning you're going to try to predict how many tricks you think you're going to win, play through the round, and then score it out and see who actually won the game. Doing this across three rounds in total. The hook of the game is the fact that you are kind of moving through the dungeon over here.

And the way that plays out, it's a little hard to explain. You move through the dungeon by winning tricks. That's one way. There are other ways to move through the dungeon. And you're trying to both get the points for matching your bid while also trying to figure out where the most loot will be in order to get the loot. It's a it's again, it's a little tricky to explain. Let's go ahead and take a look at my hand and start the game off. I have two trump suits over here. Two trumps, which is going to be helpful to an extent. But right now based on this is a this is I don't really have any middle cards. I don't have any threes or fours. So I could I do have some high cards enough that I might be able to push this. So you know what? I am going to take my five and I'm going to guess I'm going to put this face down as my torch card and I'm guessing that I'm going to win five tricks across the course of this round. I'm playing through 11 cards per player as a five round game. Five seems ambitious, but the other option was going lower and I didn't feel confident about that. But there are ways to account and adapt for what happens from there. Let's pretend I have the starting torch over here, I'm going to play through a single round of this game in order to show you how it all kind of comes together because I find that at least from my first experiences playing this. I find that playing it or at least seeing how it's played really teaches you what's going on. Here are the player cards, by the way. I just have them laid out, but any individual player would have a single player card. I'll take the rogue because the rogue is cool. There are no player abilities. I wish there were player abilities. Not. I wish there were player abilities and you could choose whether to use them and the game said please don't use them until your third game or something like that.

Anyways, I have my rogue over here and now we're going to take a look and see what we can do. Let's go ahead and start off strong with a seven. I'm trying to win five tricks. Let's start off strong with a seven. And now I'm just going to go through players hands and show you how it's going to play out. Players must follow if they can. Which means right now this player is going to go ahead and play a I guess let's play our lower card. Although five versus four is not going to make a strong difference. Although I have a bunch of fives in my hand and I actually have a bunch of fours in my hand. So I think I'm actually going to get rid of the five. And you'll see why that that that happens soon. So they play that card over here. This player has a three. So I guess they're going to be following suit as well. They'll play a three. Next player has what do they have over here? They have a two. So they're going to be following suit. And the last player, do they also have a green? Cuz if they do, well, they do have a green. They're going to be playing a one. So we're going to play through a few tricks so you can see this how this plays out. But right now that's going to be a standard uh run over here. And right now, the first person who won is the person who has the highest number, which means that's me, the rogue. I'm going to advance through the dungeon. There we go. I'm the winner of the trick. I advance through the dungeon. The other way you can advance through the dungeon is if you had the same number as the person who won. So, if somebody wins with a seven and you also played a seven, even if it's off suit, you would win. You would advance through the dungeon as well. From there, the player who had the lowest suit in the round, which is going to be this player, they become the new torchbearer. They're going to lead the next suit. And additionally, they choose any one suit from these to put down into the dungeon on its spot. So right now, depending, and this is where I didn't play for all the players, so I don't actually know what they want. Let's pretend that they played low. So they're going to take this three and they're going to put it

down over here as loot effectively that they're going to attempt to be to be gathered when the game uh is over at the end of the the full round. The rest of the cards are going to go away. We took one card and spec spec strictly speaking, you take one card of each suit. In this case, there was only one suit. Then it goes to them. Let's pretend that they're trying to win three tricks. In fact, let's pretend that they bid three because that's why they wanted to put this over here. They want to ideally end up here. So, they want to populate that with as much loot as possible. Although, again, there's ifs and buts and reasons why you might do things. So, this player, they're not necessarily trying to win. They have enough control to hold things out. So, they'll start off. They want to maintain control for the next round. So, they're going to play a zero over here, hoping they can maintain control and determine what else goes. So, we're going to go around and around. We're going to have the other players bid over here. This player, again, you have to bid in the suit. This player has a two or a three.

That seems like it's not likely to win. So, let's place a two over here. Uh, they're probably winning right now, but they're not likely to be winning by the time it gets to the end over here. Uh, this player, they have a six, but there's probably a seven out there, so it's not necessarily the best time to play your six. They'll they're relying on the fact that somebody else is probably going higher. They'll play a four over here. Uh, this player over here, they have the seven, but they actually don't care about winning this right now for whatever reason. They don't care. So, they're just going to go ahead and place. Well, actually, they have to place this. I'm trying to teach the game and I'm focusing on the fact that they have to play that because they have the the suit. And then back to this player, they actually don't have any in that suit. But right now, do they have a seven? They don't. So again, we're going to be seeing things slightly different. Let's go ahead and get rid of our middle but lower cards. We're going to get rid of this one. And you know, they're out. So again, this player is now the person who played the lower suit. They're going to maintain the torchbearer. At this point, there are no threes that got played, which is interesting. They are going to have to place this out because you place one card of each suit. And then from the others, they can choose one of the 74 two or zero. They'll take the four because I mean, you know, let's take the two because no, the two's already populated. Two should be over here. I'm sorry. Let's place the four.

That's why we're kind of distributing the loot. We'll see how things go. The rest go out. Let's go and play one last round because I'm really trying to show you how that that matching element works. So again, uh oh, and the winner the winner was um who was it? It was this player over here. We're going to pretend there was that color because I don't actually know. Once again, we're going to have them go ahead and pick uh that same suit. Not necessarily because it's strategically sound, but because I want you to see how this actually plays out when you can't follow the lead suit. So over here, this player, they can follow. They're going to place a three. The next player over here, can they follow? They can. They'll follow with a six over here. It's the next highest one they have. The seven hasn't come out. The other player didn't play it last time, so who know? The other player did play it last time, so he knows the highest one. This player can break suit. And this is where they'll go ahead and play a six, which is off suit. And this player will also play a six, which is also off suit. And here's what happens now. Because of this, the highest color in this suit is a six of this suit, which means these this player is going to advance. So, let's pretend this player is purple, for example, the next player also is going to advance because they match suit, which is going to be the red again. And then myself again, I'm going to move again because I again match the highest one played. So, in general, if you win the trick or if you have a number that is matching the highest number that won the trick, then you advance in the dungeon. Then from there, these are guaranteed to go to the six pile because they are the only ones in their suit. And from here, the player gets to choose. They'll once again go with the three because they're trying to set that one up. That's basically the way a trick plays out. You follow if you can. There's also rules around Trump, but outside of that, you're basically going to be winning if you're going to be advancing if you win or if you matched. And the whole point of this is at the end of them, when you get to the

final round, you have a interesting twist on the final round. Remember those cards you played face down? The final trick of the game, you either play your last card, whatever it is, or if you think it's better for you, you can swap your last card with your card on the table. This becomes your new torch and you play the card that was set aside at the beginning as your torch, which means when you're setting your cards from the beginning, you can kind of know that you have this kind of get out of jail free card when you get to the final trick where you can swap it with a card in your hand. So, you can either go with the plan as it worked out or pivot if the plan didn't. And you can also go in different spectrums. You could have a three in your in your as your torch and then swap with a four if that was the last card or you could possibly have a three all the way to a six depending on how far and you can constantly adapt to watch how things go. Now, the reason you're doing all this is ultimately you care where you end up in this dungeon because wherever you end up players, let's go ahead and pretend that right now this is a situation right now.

Players will be splitting the loot. The way that works is in each zone you're going to get one point for every standard monster, but you split them with people who are there. So, for example, in this case, let's pretend this is over here. This player would get one point. These players would each get one. And this player would get, there's no one here right now. This player would get two points because you split the loot based off of however many adventurers are in that spot. But you also get two points for every trump card that made its way there. So this, for example, over here is going to be four points. They each get two. And additionally, your final card if you manage to end up where your final card was. Remember that player was trying to potentially get to the three over here. If he did reveal a three, he would get three points because he managed to predict where he was going to end up at the end of it. And again, ending up is not just winning, it's also playing the matching cards. Alternatively, if you reveal, let's say, a four and the four was not where you ended up, you end up with a three, then that card instead becomes a face down card and like the the Trump suit are worth two points as well. So, if you make your bid, then you get three points. If you don't make your bid, you're giving two points to the dungeon for the other players to split.

That's basically the way you play through the game. you are playing a uh mustfollow trick-taking game in which you are ultimately trying to figure out not just how to match your bid, which is one part of it, but also paying attention to where the loot in the dungeon is ending up and pivoting your plans as needed to ensure that you end up where the most loot is and that others do not. It's one of those games where you are trying to ensure that other players, oh, you look at that giant pile of loot by number four. I'm gonna help you win so you get bumped from four to five and things will play out in a chaotic manner, but with enough control to feel like you have agency over your actions. That is basically how you play through a game of torchlet, which means it's time for my review of what I like, don't like, conceal not liking, all of that. First of all, the production. And production, I mean, is basically a bunch of cards and a few little meuples over here. But the foiling on the cards is beautiful. The art is beautiful. I believe this is the same artist as um Veil's Fate and all that from from Ivy Studios, but the art, the production, the foil, the tiles, the the meeples are chunky enough. All that's great for a small box game.

Outside of that, it really gives that sense of dungeon crawling as much as a trick-taking game can, which means you're not actually like rolling dice and fighting baddies and all that, but you do have the loot piling up in the dungeon and you are trying to figure out where to go. Like you have this advancement aspect. Like there's an interesting push as you go through it where it's not just about the initial trick that you place down, the initial card you place down. You a have the ability to pivot, which I really like because first of all, it gives you a get out of jail free card as things aren't working towards you. But also, the very nature of the game is that you kind of need that in here. Otherwise, it's just not fair. If you bid six and I bid three and happens to be all the treasures ending up there, it's a little harder there. But the fact that you could adapt to what's happening means when you place your initial torch down, you are thinking through this is where I think I'm going to be based on the cards I have and how I'm going to try to control the engine. But also, I can pivot and adapt if the treasure starts ending up in other areas of the board. And you also have agency over that. So, I like that in general. I like the matching mechanic, the fact that you don't just move up when you win a trick, which would be limiting. You move up when you match, which means you can have a lot of people moving up even when they don't win. There's a lot more advancement, a lot more progress than you would typically see. Normally, if you play through like 11 card hand, one card is down, 10 cards, five players, that's two tricks average per person, but because of the matching, you can have a lot more there. There's a lot more progress than you might otherwise think for this kind of game. And the lowest card player having agency as well means you really have multiple things you're trying to do. You're either trying to win the trick, you're trying to match the winning bid, or you're trying to be the lowest player so you have control over where the the loot gets divided as well as starting the next trick. And that

really gives you a lot of things to strive for in this game, which gives you a lot of like planning, a lot of things you can try to think through how to make this work in your favor because multiple things are rewarding you or progressing you compared with just having a single winner per hand. So, the game gives you a lot of strategy and a lot of tools and a lot of things that will play out that can make you feel rewarded as you play through it. As far as what I don't like in the game, the biggest thing, and really the only thing is that this game, as much as it's chalk full of strategy, it is chalk full of chaos as well. This is the kind of thing where that yes, you can plan around where you think you're going to end up. Yes, you do have tools and agency, but so do all the other players, which means you are playing this game of, okay, great. I think I can do this based on my hand, but there's so much that happens throughout the course of the game that can adapt and pivot around that. There's cards you're forced to play. There's other small side rules we didn't get into as well, but there's cards you're forced to play. There's the fact that other players have agency over taking control of the of the trick and forcing you to win things when you're not. The final trick of the game as well. As much as you have tools and disposal to be able to swap things out, so can the other players. And I have found that it does very often happen in this game that you can almost have not necessarily kingmaking in the the traditional sense, but someone swapping their card out can completely change what goes on because you know throughout the course of the game you're like, well, you don't have any any red left because we played it. I know you don't have red, but you could have read the reds of trump. You could have read as your final cards after the side. That can change everything. So all the things you spent the whole game learning can be upended when you get to that final trick. So you can have nearly a perfect round where you have felt in complete control and then get to the end and it's like, oh, so that's the card you set aside. Now granted, you do have to be

counting towards it as you play, but I do find there's a lot of strategy and also a lot of things that will um hit you with the chaos of what this game is. As far as I can see others not liking, this is a heavier game to an extent. Even the player raids, like the player aids kind of give you everything you need to know, but there's still a lot of information to process, especially the first time you're going through this. This is not a easy or accessible trick taking game. There are much more complicated ones out there. Make no mistake, but this is definitely in that slightly higher tier as far as understanding what it is you're trying to do as you play through it. It is I do find your first game is one this is one of those games where I say your first game is a write-off game, your first game is a learning experience or at least your first round. honestly play a first round and then reset now that everyone understands and play through a full game after that because it very much is it's thinky and again I talked about this already in the things I don't like you will get caught unawares by a lot of things that make your make an otherwise perfectly planned engine just not work out so if you're looking for something more accessible there are other more accessible trick takers out there this is a deeper one that is rewarding with chaos which brings me to final thoughts overall on this game it is a very thinky and rewarding trick taking game with chaos that's my biggest issue with the game is that as much as I enjoy the process I'm going through the strategy is as present as the again I don't know if you want to call it chaos tools whatever you want to call it even just luck as you go through it you know you could be planning your way towards a perfect game and it just doesn't necessarily happen so I enjoy this overall but I do walk into every game thinking I will do my best and either it works out or it doesn't and and that's every game every game I play either works out or it doesn't but I think

sometimes you have you feel like you had more of a sense of how much it could work out or not you had more agency over that. And this is one where I will do my best to win and sometimes I won't and I write it off as, okay, it's that kind of game. Overall though, I'm going to give it a four out of five. I've really been enjoying this dungeon crawl of a trick taking game, both because it manages to feel different in a crowded space and also because it's good while being different. As far as other game recommendations, if you are looking for something that's a drop more accessible, but also very much on the thinky and creative side, check out Cat in the Box. One, Cat in a Box, Cat in the Box, Cat in the Box from AEG. No, it's not true. from Bezier Games. Count the box from Bezier Games. One of my favorite trick- taking games. And if you're looking for another trick taking game that manages to give you a unique theme similar to the way this one does, check out Origin Story from Stonemire, giving you a very different trick taking game as you build up your powers as you go through the experience. And then I mentioned that Allplay is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find games both from AllPlay themselves as well as a variety of partner publishers, all with $4 flat rate shipping in the US for any number of things you want to get. And check out Runes. Runes is more of a handshedding game as opposed to a trick taking game, but I did find it very much a similar notes for me in the sense that I felt a lot of strategy and control over what I was doing and also the chaos at the same time. It's shedding as opposed to trick taking, but both of these games have kind of got very similar vibes enjoying what the game lets me do and relinquishing uh my ability to win to whatever the card gods decide. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco. Hope you found this review helpful and as always I hope you have a good

Progress saved