Piepmatz Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at peep mats which is a small box card game published by lookout games and designed by matt riddle and ben pitchback this one accommodates two to four players and takes around 30 minutes to play on average so peak match is going to look like this when it's set up where you have a deck of these bird cards with three in a communal drafting row ready for players to take in the future you also have this column of seed cards which look like this which are going to be potential points that you get throughout the game so each one of these seeds is going to be a victory point and you've also got this perch area on the board which is where you're going to play cards in order to collect these seed cards so depending on the play account you're going to have a number of perches in a two or three player game you're going to have two perches but in a four player game you're going to have an additional third perch like that we're going to stack another bird here you can also see we're going to start with two birds at the perch here which are apparently eating these seeds and each plate is also going to have a bunch of or four cards in their hand and i suppose the best way to explain this game is to explain how the scoring works because not only are you going to get points through these seed cards you're also going to get five points for every pair of male and female birds of the same type that you have so you can see here this play would have a yellow hammer female and a yellow hammer male and again if you get a pair of those then you're going to get five points you could do that as many times as you like additionally if you have the majority of
a particular suit of curves or a bird type then you're going to get these eggs on there as well which are going to be half the points of the value here rounded up so you're seeing this five you're going to get an additional three points and now again that is going to count for every single suit of cards you know for these ball finches for the sparrows for the green finches and so on so on a player's turn all you're going to do is you're going to take one of your four cards let's say i take this um this sparrow here and you're going to place it on one of these perches at least to the side of one of these perches so let's say i do this like so and then what you're going to do is you're going to go to compare the complete value of everything that's not on a perch on this side to the bird that's on the perch here and calculate the difference so you can see here this bird has a six this one has a five therefore there is a difference of one that would mean that you would take the first card in the column here so if i was two over i'll take this card if i was three over i'll take this card and four over i'll take this card if i was five or more over i would be top decking from the deck here and getting a bit of a lucky dip so again let's say i played the six here that means i'll take this c card like so and put it into my scoring pile for end game points and then i'm also going to take this bird here into my scoring area with that idea of again collecting the majorities of that type and collecting male and female pairs and then you're going to remove this move the strongest bird that's not at that perch to the perch like so
now if the value is not higher than the bird of the perch so let's just say i play this level one sparrow you can see i've got a total value of four here and the bird of the perch is six so i'm still under that value then what i'm going to do is i'm going to take one of my remaining cards in my hand and simply play it directly into my scoring area there is also the potential for this to create somewhat of a domino effect so let's say i played this three green finch here creating a total value of seven therefore trumping the six here that again that would make me take this card add it to my scoring pile that was one over so therefore i'll take the first card in the row for victory points um and then again the strongest card here is going to go up to the perch but if there's a tie then it's going to be the one closest to the perch so that would go up like this you can see that this value here still is above the one of the perch so that process would repeat itself so again we're still one over because we've got total value four now to the value of one up to the value of three being again one over then i'll take this c card again add it to my scoring pile again take this one into my scoring pile and then remove the strongest one to the perch now sometimes when you refresh this row of seeds from round around you're going to draw these crow cards or these squirrel cards and when you do that you're going to place them adjacent to the lowest card in that column of seed card so you see the squirrel went straight down to the bottom and the crow went down to the second from bottom now these are cards that you're gonna have to take if you end up capturing these seeds here so
let's just say um this player played their ball finch here creating a value of four to the three therefore they're going to be one over they're going to take this c card and they're also going to take the squirrel that goes with it which is going to be a bad thing and of course they'll take this one as normal let's talk about what these cards actually do when you end up taking them so once you've finished doing the whole sequence of taking the c cards as normal then you're going to resolve all these negative effects from these crow and squirrel cards so the crows are going to scare away a bird from your score pile and basically remove it from the game but it has to be from your strongest suit of cards or the most numerous um suit of card that you have so if i had say um five green finches i'd have to maybe lose a green finch and the squirrels are going to force you to shuffle all your previously owned seed cards and discard two of them at random of course which is going to hit you quite hard in terms of the end game scoring and once you've gone through the process of placing your cards taking any c cards or potential negative effects you're going to draw back up to four cards either top blacking from the deck there or taking from the communal draft row and that's essentially how you play peat mats you're going to keep going until you run out of these c cards or squirrel and crow cards then you're going to calculate all your seeds all your pairs of birds and all your numerous bird types and count the eggs on those and um yeah that's it ready so let's go into my review on peep mats
okay so one of the main reasons why i wanted to try peat mats was because i'm quite familiar with some other games designed by this design team of matt riddle and ben pinchback um they designed some recent card games that i've enjoyed thoroughly such as stella and sub sub-astral i rated both of those extremely highly and actually that made me want to dive deeper into their previous designs and hence why i'm here playing peep mats now something i would say about these designers is that they try things out the box you see mechanisms from them that you haven't seen before and peak mats is another example of that i've never seen this kind of perch system before where again you're playing cards with the idea of going over by a pretty particular amount so that you can get the exact cards that you want obviously not just to get the most seeds but also to avoid these horrible crow and squirrel cards but the management of your hand is quite interesting because of course you want to play those exact cards but you're going to potentially give them away to other players by playing them because they could end up at the perch on the following player's turn and they could end up taking them so you need to be careful about not always just to go higher in order to get the c cars themselves which are going to be a strong amount of points but also sometimes you want to keep below that limit because you want to play a card directly from your hand so i do like the way that again riddle and pinch back use that hand system of your are you going to use them to almost put into the ether and potentially give up to other players or are you going to keep them close to your chest and play them straight into your scoring pile but at the risk of other things so yeah i do
like the way that works this is actually quite intuitive once you get your head around it and the effect or the potential to do that domino effect can be quite satisfying when you play a right card you can end up taking a couple of strong seed cards if you map things out carefully i do enjoy the three different scoring criteria of the game you know the idea of collecting these pairs of male and female birds this is very obviously intuitive and logical and i also like the way that you can just collect the seeds and of course try to get these standard area majorities um and the weighing up the fact of you know if there's a very specific card you want you collect a new pair because you know five points is a nice nice swing of points you might even be prepared to take maybe a crow card because you have maybe a surplus card of your most numerous suit that you can afford to get rid of now that kind of leads into one of my most negative things about the game and that is these crow and squirrel cards so i will say that i do like it when games offer a risk of doing things and when you have consequences to doing certain things which could hurt you but i will say that i find that the the crow card isn't so bad i'll be honest but this squirrel card i think is pretty annoying and not in a good way because you can end up just again shuffling your whole stack of cards here and losing all your threes just by no fault of your own whereas if it happens to somebody else they might just end up losing all their ones so that felt a little bit jarring for me considering how meticulous the rest of the game is this felt like it wasn't quite a good fit and again it just made me feel like it was annoying rather than
any fun the game does take around 30 minutes to play which is about right you know it certainly doesn't outstate it's welcome and it's a quite a quick you know little punchy game that's um quite quick to set up and get played and packed away again and also the rules explanation isn't terribly difficult i think if you're familiar with a few card games you're going to wrap your head around the rules quite quickly despite being some differences and some unique mechanisms that you might not have seen before you've got some decent passive player interaction here you've got that standard turn angst of wanting to collect very particular types of birds you know there might be a you get a yellow hammer here sat out the perch that you really want to complete your set and hope that it doesn't disappear before it gets back to your turn and the same applies to drafting types of cards from the card row there and of course the um the having the majorities in each of the bird types is going to be a strong kind of um kind of tension throughout the game to make sure you get all those extra points from the eggs on the cards themselves and of course making sure you have the right card at the right time to grab the most kind of profitable seats from the column in the middle the production for this game is fantastic yes it is just a card game but the cards themselves are a decent quality but i suppose the main talking point is the illustrations themselves the cards look fantastic they have these beautifully illustrated colorful almost science book looking birds um that just pop on the table and they look fantastic also the kind of iconography and things on the cards look good you know the numbers are very clear um you've got the eggs that are clear there for the endgame scoring and um you can clearly differentiate the male and female ties due to the um you know the
gender symbols here so yeah very happy with the way the game looks it completely um goes above and beyond in terms of its visual appeal the game does also scale pretty well and to be honest i would almost always lean towards playing this at two or three players rather than the four because i think the ball could just change or the state of play could change a bit too much with that fourth player and you can't really pull off what you really intended to and because it's going to be too long before you take your turn again now that being said there is an additional perch you have got an additional option to go to but again i think i prefer that more controlled approach of a two or three player game okay so let's get in some final thoughts on peak mats so i will come out straight away and say that i do not think this game is as strong as those other two games i mentioned earlier stella and sebastian i think those two games are sublime i think this one is good i think it's better than your average card game and it's got some quite interesting things going on that i haven't seen before and i always appreciate um innovative designs and just trying new things so the way this perch system works is very interesting and there's always something you can do on your turn because there are different ways that the cars work you know if you even if you can't trump one of these and to end up taking a taking um some of these seed cards you can at least place something to your scoring tableau and work towards those pairs or towards this majority so you've always got something you can do now that being said i do not like the way that these um negative cards work at all uh to be honest i think they do take away from the game quite a lot and i would have liked to have seen something a bit more a bit a bit different a bit
more clever in the way they worked now i do understand this is a 30 minute game it's a simple card game so i do give it some kind of leeway because of that but particularly this squirrel card um some people are going to get hit way harder than others just purely by the luck of the shuffle they can end up keep losing their three eggs or their three seeds and when some people just might keep losing their one seeds and that's gonna quite strongly impact on who wins the game and that also applies to when you end up top blacking here by taking a five over the um bird limit some people are going to draw three seeds some people are going to draw a squirrel or a crow again which can hurt them quite significantly again i know you can make contingencies for that and you have to accept the risk when you do that but it was enough to detract from the game for me and to stop me enjoying it as much as i could have if that wasn't a factor in the game i think if you can look past that then there's a lot to enjoy here it's different it feels fresh and i think a lot of people could enjoy it so again one that i think is competing with so many other games in my collection that i don't think this one is quite strong enough to stick around however again i do completely appreciate some of the novel mechanisms here that i haven't seen before um but yeah ultimately it's not gonna be a keeper around it didn't quite hit the peaks of those other games but that is my final thoughts on peep mats