Isle of Trains (All Aboard) - Board Game Review - Ah Nemesis, We Meet Again!
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences so on today's episode we're taking a look at a pretty small card game the Isle of trains all aboard and uh yeah you know me in train games get on yeah it's a little worrying for some people to give me any gain that involves the word trains on it and understandably so but you know there are some on my shelf which are train games and lighter train games I can get behind just not the really heavy stuff like Imperial steam age of steam and 18xx all those can burn in hell for as far as I'm concerned wow that was pretty brutal even by my staff they're still fine with particularly if the the fact that it's a Train theme doesn't really matter too much now this is based off an old board game called Isle of train so I say oh I think it's 2014 odds now I never played that game didn't even know it existed so frankly this review isn't going to have no basis from that this is its own separate thing it's a portable card game version with a little twist I think the passengers ads is new from the original one but I'm just gonna rate this based on it and it alone so Isle of trains is essentially a full card game and it's a kind of compared to other games it's a bit like San Juan and race to the Galaxy in which the deck of cards kind of consists of everything in the game it's your currency it's also your trains it's also
you know the cargo that you can do and San Juan had a similar thing you know the card deck was the buildings you could pay it was the coins in order to purchase the buildings it was also the tobacco and the Indigo that you put under the buildings and I I like games that can simulate all these different things with just simply a deck of cards I think kind of just sort of works for me so the general premise here is that you have a map layout on the board which just consists of a few location cards and everybody starts with their own level one engine it gives you a capacity for how big your train can be but it also has a cost a victory point value and a little special ability but it is your basic starting engine and then what happens from this point is that the rest of the game is dictated basically by a bunch of cards a bunch of cards from a deck which essentially are all these different types of trains that you can do so you can do tankers you can do let's say a coach Caboose you can upgrade your engine you can have a what's the ones that deliver coal I'm trying to find some examples here Hoppers and such boxcars but then you can also get buildings such as Northern station a coal Factory a bank you know these are all things that you can build and these are all things that you can add to your train while also upgrading it but during a round you essentially have two actions that you can do from a very simplified list of actions basically to take cards build stuff from your hand load stuff from your hand onto your train or other people's trains more on that in a minute or to deliver to various locations for bonuses points made you know and all sorts like that but you basically take two of those
actions and then next player two actions next player two actions next player super fast but it's all these cards so for example if I want to build from my hand you know a particular car I need to say right well I want to build this level one tanker here cost two right well I need to bend two cards there you go don't get too attached to your hand now because a lot of it you're going to be chucking away for money but what you can also do is load your cargo on your train so for example all of these cards have got a particular cargo icon on them for a coal Iron Coal oil and boxes I guess just Goods in a sense and the idea is is that if you have the matching type you can basically load it onto a cart as long as it's got enough capacity for it now if you load it onto your own train you can deliver it to a place and fulfill contracts but points and place it for bonuses but you can also put them on someone else's trade if somebody else happens to have a particular train let's say someone's got a level three engine there and happens to also have something that I can put oil into then if I put it into their train I get to trigger the bonus on the top of the car which could give me more cards it could give me more cool stuff the downside is you're giving your opponent something to work with so you gotta balance that out you know do I really need this bonus and if so who am I more willing to give something to preferably whoever is losing but again who's that person and do they have something that can even fit what you want to do but you also have passengers and I think this is a new aspect for All Aboard this is a deluxe version of the game you normally just get tokens but other than that there's not a huge amount of difference between the deluxe version and the retail version but in
this one you get cool screen printed meeples which I think are pretty cool actually I mean the tokens are fine but these are pretty nice and they do feel good in the hand and they do look the part but what you can do is that you can deliver them to these various locations and there are tickets tiles where those ticket tiles gone here we go where you shuffle a bunch of them up you dish them out randomly at the start of the game and basically each city is color coded so you might have to deliver this orange one to here and it this one in particular gets you more passengers and more cards but they're basically more ways to get points and cool stuff so that was a slightly long-winded explanation certainly the game is not the quickest to explain I know it's a simple case of oh you've just got the two actions here but this isn't probably what I would call the Gateway level game it's definitely light but a new gamer might struggle with a few Concepts here particularly as with these actions there are a couple of little edge cases you need to be aware of that being said the rules are pretty straightforward I had no trouble learning from the rule book when I first played this and you do get a nice linen finish rule book with a rules reference on the back of it as well as you know how endgame scoring works and such but they may look like a longish rule book but bearing in mind that chunk is basically the solo mode more on that in a minute the main rules they're not a huge amount of them and there's a decent amount of value between text on page and pictorial examples honestly I learned the game fairly easily from this it's a good little condensed rulebook but then these reference cards this is near perfect but what I want to see on reference cards okay firstly tells you all the actions
that you can do and pretty much all you need to know about each action with one or two little edge cases that it doesn't mention but you know you can't fit everything on there like I said near perfect but then on the back remind you of the end game scoring and gives you the card Anatomy yes it's on the back of the rulebook as well but I never see this on reference cards you never see something that explains what the symbology is on the cards and here it's critical that you know what is what so the fact that it tells you on the back of your reference card is brilliant Kudos this is this took some thought okay this took thought and I praise you for it very good little reference cards but the artwork is always very nice it's very nice and colorful I mean it's not like you know we're not necessarily talking like this new trailer Michael Menzel here but I think the artwork here pops off the cards it's very colorful it definitely looks nice on the table when you've got the map and everybody's trains laid out it turns heads people sort of look at it and go oh this is very pretty I'm intrigued particularly if you've got the deluxe version with these knee pulls as I say I'm more interested in the retail version from a review standpoint but honestly the tokens look pretty good as well they're cardboard they've got little artwork on them and they they are decent enough quality so you know it's just whether you want to spend what an extra fiver or something I don't think there's a huge price difference between retail and Deluxe Shut Up And Take My Money and this game feels very Snappy I mean you have two actions in a turn that's it just two and you pick out of four you might have a slightly elongated deliver action where you go to a location you can deliver all four of the potential things that you could deliver but that is extremely rare in fact I'm not even
certain that's physically possible to do it probably is but you'd have to work to it and even then it's not that long so you're talking quick and snappy whether you're taking cards building cards loading cards or delivering cards and passengers it's all Snappy so even when you play this at the max count of four players doesn't take that long for the cards the sorry for the turn to get back round to you now is it better with less players that's a little trickier to um explain really because there's an up and a downside here yes if you play with less players you don't take as long and the game is shorter I've played this with two players and it works really really well but then I've also enjoyed my time with four players because when you have more players yes you add a little bit of extra time to the game but it really isn't that much I mean this game should not take you more than 75 minutes I'd say to play it's a 75 minute game tops really as much as the Box seems to claim 60 minutes I'd say yeah even with a slow player four players including the teacher probably talking 90 minutes max but you can get this done quickly particularly with less players but when you add more players you have more trains so here's my train here's another person's train here's somebody else's train all these different things that you can load up for their special bonuses so suddenly when you're thinking right well I need a cool bonus I need to load some Cargo in that you've got all the free other players to look at it's like oh okay this looks pretty juicy and that's maybe what causes a slight bit of AP with players the fact that they can look at all these different trains but most of the time people are pretty quick to realize whether they should or not but that means the game has a decent sense of interaction again it doesn't
have to be I play this card and I punch you in the face haha my you know it sucks to be you that's not what I mean by player interaction when I talk about this a lot I mean I should care about other players being in the game I reviewed stuff like Planet unknown and some other games lately where the player has been in the game like revive for example where I couldn't care less what the other players were doing they're like oh there's some tiny little aspect that means I care slightly about another player whoopee do this isn't a tiny aspect this is a fundamental part of the game I want to see whether you're going to deliver passengers to certain places I need to check that you're not likely to Nick a contract before I do but on top of that the fact that you're giving cards to other people and people are giving them to you influences what they do on their turn it can influence what you do in your turn suddenly I've got an oil in my thing that I didn't want I'm sorry that I didn't have before and it's like oh what can I do with this now if I had this it makes you rethink your turn slightly that's good player interaction yeah nobody wants to play with me now you can play this Solo solo has a challenge mode where you pretty much play the game entirely the same way as multiplayer except that you get the benefits from the trains when you put them on your own trains that's obviously it's just you that's a really cool addition because frankly if you didn't get that in Solo mode it would be a pretty lackluster mode but the fact that you get to trigger all these cool abilities is Paramount basically but you also have a bunch of scenarios in the book where it changes the setup slightly and gives you rather than having you beat your own score it gives you a condition so I have to fill at least
five ticket tiles with their corresponding passengers okay so it's not a case of I need 60 points or anything I mean you could do a beat your own score but I couldn't care less but the idea that it's like right when I play this scenario I need to really go heavy on passengers so as I'm building my train and going to various locations and that I'm thinking more about getting a lot of coaches you know I don't need oil and coal and you know tankers like that I need a bunch of coaches I need high capacity passengers can I build a train long enough to do that do I have to get some particular with their special abilities maybe a building that gives me points for in-game scoring which is what they typically are there's a lot of different ways that the scenarios make you change your play style and it makes the solo mode here particularly really really solid now it can get a little bit busy on some of the cards with the iconography I mean yes you do have a reference card to tell you the anatomy but you have some iconography that repeats in certain places which throws people off but I mean you've got like the victory point value the cost what cargo it is what ability it has what capacity it has what you know way to add to your train there's quite a lot sort of staring at you on some of these cards and so that can get a little bit busy at times also you are going to need the rulebook reference um nearby not because of the rules that but because of the buildings and the cabooses they've all got different abilities and the iconography is not 100 intuitive on them now all of them are explained in the book great and I don't really expect you to have a reference card in a game package that is small to explain all of them but you are going to
need this book nearby to explain what all the engines and that do which granted they put everything in here so you will not have an FAQ moment with any card in this game it's all perfectly well explained in here but you are going to eat this nearby so bear that in mind the olive trains is just a really solid package at the end of the day it's small compact but it has a good amount of depth it has easy to learn rules it uses the teach rules with maybe a couple of edge cases that get in the way like you know I'll make certain that when you do bonus actions you can't load on other people's trains it's not on the reference card some people can miss that out but they're small little niggles like that it's a relatively quick setup it's not a long game to play I willingly play this at every player count in the Box one two three or four yes I think solo and free player are the sweet spots but two and four is still solid and there's a lot of games lately where I don't have that opinion where player scaling is always a massive issue here it's not this game just does a lot of things right short you know with up to four players a good solo mode I'll probably play the solo more than I will multiplayer but that's just because of how quick and snappy it is but I like this whole San Juan deck is everything mechanic it's just a concept I really like like I think it's quite clever I have good decisions to make and I have cool little bits of interaction with other players about giving them stuff to use it's a solid game I'm giving this a 9 out of 10. it deserves a sale of Distinction and it deserves any accolades that it's had already it's just really solid I urge you to give this one a try if you're into small box
card games because I think you'll enjoy it don't worry about the fact that it's about trains if that puts you off because you are talking to the person here who is the poster child of being put off by train games and even I'm telling you to go grab this for a 9 out of 10. so if that doesn't speak volumes I don't know what will French so that's it for me on this episode of the broken people if you like what you see then please remember thumb it up on YouTube and also thumb it up on Board Game Geek when the review goes live on there don't forget to check out more content on the show including all the other UK games Expo reviews I've done Moon rich and the good Planet unknown uh mind bug you know not even just the Expo stuff but all the other backlog of games I've had to do plenty of content on this show so far and plenty more to to come and of course get your comments down below you know do you have experience with the main board game this was based on what are your thoughts on this you know do you know of any other games that use this whole your deck is everything in the game mechanic because I certainly want to know more of them I know of San Juan this one and race for the Galaxy are free that immediately come to mind any others you can think of let us all know I'd love to read about them but until next time remember regardless of whether the game is themed about trains or not it's still only a game and it can still be a solid one take care and bye for now