Naruto Shippuden Battle Review - Attack, Take Control & Dominate!
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex, back with Board Game Co, and today I'm going to be reviewing Naruto Shippuden Battle from Don't Panic Games, and this is a game Naruto Shippuden Battle is a two to four player skirmish game in which players are going to attempt to win through defeating enemy units and taking control points. Before we dive further into this, this is a prototype. All of those components are subject to change. I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below, and this channel is sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. Speaking of sponsors though, while this review is not sponsored, they did sponsor a gameplay on the channel, so take any potential bias or conflict into account. With that said, in Naruto Shippuden Battle, you're going to be playing through a skirmish game. The main mode is going to be a head versus head skirmish game in which you'll take control of teams of three characters. You'll have your teams, you can use the pre-constructed recommended pairings, or you can combine your own before diving into drafting your characters onto the board, setting up the various control points in order to try to figure out how you can take down the enemy units. I will not be going fully into every single rule. You could check out the gameplay if you want to get a sense of how everything goes together. Most of the rules will can be covered pretty quickly, and then all of the edge cases are what takes the rest of it. We'll actually come back to that point. But in general, in the game, you're going to have a hand of four cards. Your goal is to get your domination marker over here to hit your team's prestige marker. So, as you do things that are good, you're going to move this marker towards you, or alternatively move your prestige marker towards that. And when these two cross, you're going to win the game, hopefully sooner rather than later, because your opponent is trying to do the same. The way you're going to get the domination marker to move towards you is primarily through taking control points. So, in the game, when you take a control point, when you move your character to a control point, you're
going to take a marker, put it onto that control point, and that's going to get the domination marker to move one towards you. That's going to help you win because again, it's closer to your prestige marker. The other thing you can do is you can kill enemy units. When you kill an enemy unit, you're going to look at their prestige value, which is going to be like one or two, and you're going to move your token that many more towards the domination marker. So, if I took down a Naruto over here, that's a two prestige character, so I'm going to move this two forward making those two closer. So, taking control of control points, killing enemy units, and then in between rounds, you're also going to get additional domination marker movement for being the player who controls the most objectives on the board. So, you're going to look at all the various objectives on the board. Whoever controls the most is going to result in this moving one closer to that player. And then whoever controls the central control point is going to result in that moving one closer to that player as well. All of these things combined to get your marker closer to your prestige marker so that you can win the game.
Also, at the end of each round, you're going to move both of the prestige markers one closer to the center, meaning that even as this bounces back and forth as players do different things, slowly but surely these markers are approaching the center so that eventually uh crossing it is more likely and game end can be triggered with a victory for that player. That's what you're trying to do. How do you do all this? With cards. You're going to have a hand of cards representing the actions that your characters can take, either any character, alternatively sometimes a specific character if it has the character portrait, and you're going to play these cards down into your combo track. When you play the cards, you're going to get a chakra if it has a chakra marker, or sometimes gaining a chakra if it has a cost in it, and then doing the effect with again either any unit, alternatively the unit pictured on the card. Those effects are primarily going to come down to movement and attacking. Ultimately, this is a skirmish game, moving and attacking always be the main things you do, but also control of things is important as well. So, for example, with this card over here, this is a two movement as well as two range attack card. So, right now if I'm playing as the blue team, for example, I can take this character over here and I can do a range attack against Naruto because I have the range marker. It's a two damage range attack. I'll go ahead and shoot Naruto and he's going to go one, two, moving backwards on the board because whenever you deal damage, it kind of pushes them backwards in the game, kind of having that that mass effect, you know, you whether it's a melee attack, whether it's a range attack, they go flying back in the arena, and if they hit walls or characters or things, they'll take extra damage on top of the basic damage you dealt. You'll go to the health track over here and we'll move that marker down by two. In this case, it didn't actually, you know, move them into push them anything, so he's just going to take that two damage. Then you can go ahead and take the movement. Whenever you have multiple effects, you can do
them in any order unless there's a specific order to them. Depends on the card, some have a sequence, others are just do this and that. In this case, do a range attack and do a movement in the order of your choosing. So, now that I have that, I'm going to try to go ahead and I'll move this character. Unfortunately, I'm not close enough to any subjections, that would have been great. I'll go ahead and go one, two, which will take me out of the uh direct line of sight of Nerdo and position me closer to the spot on the board. So, you have basic movement, you have a range attack, you're seeing some of those effects already. Other things you can do is you have Let me see, let me grab some more cards so I can show you some actions. You have melee attack. Melee attack is going to uh let's have over here. This is going to be a double movement card. So, if we put this down over here, that's going to allow you to move twice. So, I can go ahead and take this control point, putting my marker on it, pushing the objective marker back one towards the other character or whatnot, and then also move on to here, gaining two chakras, putting them onto my character board. Those chakra tokens are incredibly important because once you get your third chakra, your character is going to power up, flipping to its opposing side. For example, with this card here, I would have gotten a chakra from playing it as well, plus the two that I landed on, means I can flip him to his opposing side and now he's upgraded, unlocking a unlocking an extra ability, and having a stronger ability as well. That's going to be the way those cards work. You also have things like melee attack. Melee attack is exactly like range attack, but you have to be adjacent to the character. It often hits a little harder, but again, adjacency is required. And then there's going to be running. Running is going to allow you to run across the arena. For example, this card over here, you can go as far as you want in a straight line with one of your characters. So, maybe I go ahead and I don't know, what's a good example here? I don't kind of don't want to go anywhere. Let's all just go directly there. So, I'll move that character there, putting it once again a control point out and moving that marker one more towards me. So, that's going to
be a running action. Move as far as you want in a straight line. And again, you can attack before or after that movement. So, in this case, I would have attacked first because I was over here. I would have attacked that guy, hitting him to the wall, and doing that extra impact damage. That's going to be the basic idea. You have movement, you have running, you have range attack, you have melee attack, and then you have a lot of effects as well as a lot of reactions. Your cards are also going to have reactions on them. Things you can do as a response, boosting your defense, keeping in mind all these attacks I played, the enemy could have also played those cards. So, you can go ahead, you can play a card like this, which will allow defense. You can play a card like this, which will allow you to react as part of an ally. You can play a card like this, which lets you react after your opponent played a card or combo. There's a bunch of reaction effects, but you have to have space in your combo track in order to play them. If your combo track is full, you can't play a card as a reaction. That plus you're limited to one reaction a turn, but the cards in your hand are going to give you a lot of flexibility over the things you can do, whether you're taking attacks, whether you're taking reactions, or whether you're setting yourself up for combos.
Speaking of combos, once you have a bunch of cards in your line over here, you can use the combo of a character in order to discard some of the cards to do the character ability. For example, if Dede over here had a chakra, she can play a chakra plus discarding a yellow and a green card, and that would allow you to trigger the combo on the character. So, again, you have combos, you have action cards, the cards you can play as actions, you have reactions, and then you can also just pass. Passing is how the round ends. Once a player has passed, they can no longer take additional actions. They can still play cards as reactions if there's space in the combo line, but that's kind of all they can do until the opposing player passes, at which point you'll go ahead and resolve end of round phases, which is where you'll get those extra points for having control of the central point or having control of the most objectives, all while trying to then set yourself up for the next round, where you're going to once again move those markers, those prestige markers one closer to the center of this track, as well as drawing up a new hand of a new hand of cards in order to go into the next round of combat better prepared to take down your opponent. When a character dies, the only thing that really happens is you're going to move your prestige marker of your opposing team is going to go closer to or well, one or two, depending on the character, but then they'll respawn at the end of the round, or there's ways to respawn earlier as well, but by giving up domination points, it's risky. You may not want to do it. But, that's basically the idea of Noda Shirogane Battle.
There's a ton more complexity to get into, the character abilities, all the keywords, all the ways other things come together. But, for the most part, the core mechanics of the game is everything that I already told you. It's a skirmish game in which you're trying to kill opposing units and take control points, and everything comes down to how you combine it to do that stuff better than your opponent. That's going to bring us to the review of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking. Starting off with what I like, the tension of the rounds getting shorter. This little mechanic here where they keeps uh slowly uh getting closer, that adds a nice degree of making sure the game doesn't stay too long, especially if players are evenly matched. It is slowly creeping together. Eventually, one person can break through and get the few points necessary as the rounds go on. This is a game you can win you can knock out in two, three rounds, or it could be four or five rounds, but it will slowly decrease, and it will get to a point where someone will sneak that win in. And it's also all being relatively accessible on the rules.
We'll come back to that as well, but relatively accessible on the rules, relatively accessible on the game time, uh giving you that I I think it has the perfect combination of character depth in the sense that the characters do bring their own abilities to the table, they bring their own cards to the table, but it doesn't do so in a way that's so overwhelming that there's a strong advantage to a player who knows the game better than the opponents. Granted, I'm saying that with the core box over here, prototype and all that, but these six characters I have don't provide so much interaction. I mean, you can set up a game, learn the characters on both sides, and it doesn't take too much to learn. I don't know if that will be equally true with either other characters or once you have a much larger roster, but at least with these characters so far, it felt like it didn't take more than a game or two to be able to get a good sense of who you're playing as and what you have to do to be mindful of their abilities, uh whether they're going to steal shock or something you plant terrain on the on the battlefield. They bring their own complexity to the table, but it's not overwhelmingly complex. It's just It's just enough to make the characters nuanced without so much as to be overwhelming. There's a good balance of killing each other versus control points. That's a key mechanic in the game, the idea that do I want to uh shove you against the wall and continue to slam fists into your stomach as crippling you as a character, or alternatively, are you taking control points on the board, and I need to respond to that because ultimately you're going to swing the battle in your favor if you take too many control points and get that extra control point boost at the end of the round. There's a lot of tension around what you're trying to do and how you try to do it in this game, and the character movement between the running across the board, the uh easy movement. The game gives you again just enough tools to be able to do everything while being while being forced to choose what is the most advantageous thing. Is it important to set up that combo, to get more chakras, upgrade your character, or just take that one last control point? The miniatures in general are fantastic,
although again, I will have some uh caveats on that later. I'll come back to uh some aspects over there. But in general, I do like the miniature sculpts, and I'm saying this is somebody who's not necessarily a fan of Naruto. I don't know enough about it. I just I know this exists, so I'm just not a fan of the anime or any of that. So I just I just don't know. I just don't know. But the miniature sculpts are very solid. They're nice and chunky, uh large characters. And in general, the combat tracker is is a huge element in which you have to tactically plan. The game is going to give you the ability to mulligan at the beginning of the game, as well as when you draw up each round. And that means you really can try to sequence your characters in order to get the right cards for the combo, while getting rid of cards that don't seem as strategically advantageous for you in the current moment. And so there's a really good mix of everything going on as you tackle the skirmish game. As far as things I don't like in the game, I a few things I kind of hinted about already. I'll start with one is the characters. As much as I like the miniatures in this game, I've struggled to tell the miniatures apart and which character belongs to which miniature. Uh I just think they're a little bit too similar, and I don't know the world enough. So like, you know, you just have similar-looking sculpts that don't really stand out. Again, this this character girl over here, this is great.
I can see who she is at a glance. But like, these two or even these, to be honest, this entire team, I was constantly trying to figure out who's who because they're all just wearing large coats and they look similar. And again, like it's something that I don't think it's super hard to tell apart, uh but especially between looking at the character the character portraits when you're sliding their health track, the character cards, and the character miniatures, it's certainly not something that I uh easily was able to tell difference. I also touched upon the rules aspect. I do think this is a game which you can learn 90% of the game in 20% of the time. Let's just make it up over here. Let's say it takes 10 minutes to teach 90% of the rules. The problem is it takes the remaining, you know, 20 to 25 minutes to teach that last 10%. A lot of the small rules aspect come down to the details. I think for the most part, the game is pretty straightforward, but there's possibly a bit too too in all the edge stuff. And I don't just mean the keywords. Keywords are keywords. You can look up a keyword as it comes up. That's totally fine. But there's a lot of just things you have to know about in the game. To that end as well, that I think the reactions are a bit too much in the game. Like the reactions in terms of like, you know, having cards that are always have a reaction on them. I appreciate the battle flexibility provides and the decisions base it provides, but I think it does so almost at at the cost of being too accessible between just how much you can try to get done in the game. Every single card has a reaction and it can be both information overload as well as decisions base overload, especially if you're not It's one of those weird balances. Like the more you know the game, the more it provides that little extra element of strategic differential. On the other hand, when you're first diving into it, it just feels like there's a million things you could do and you're constantly choosing not to engage in the thought process behind those things. This is also true for boosting. There's a constant in the game where you can discard all your
shockwave to go ahead and boost your attack or defense. It's the same aspect. I think there's almost a little bit too many small small sets of decisions. I wish the game kind of took some of those away. Even small things like maybe you can only boost an attack once per round and boost a defense once per round and you special spot for that. So, there was more decision space, but when you use it as opposed to always using it. Small things like that perhaps. I just think the decision space was a drawn too large in the game. As far as what I can see I do not liking, first of all, the drawing cards into your combos. As much as you have the opportunity to mulligan, mulliganing does not guarantee you that you're going to get the right cards to pop off your combos. And that can be incredibly key. If you're in round two or three of the game and somebody can trigger combo and you can't, that might be the difference. With the round track shrinking, that might be the difference between them managing to get out of that victory while you just feel stuck because you didn't draw the right cards to trigger one of your character's combos. That can certainly be a thing. I'll also say, speaking of which, that track swing aspect, I like how this track swings over here because it forces the game to not draw too long, but it also does mean that in later rounds, as you have these condensed if if no one actually shifts these too much in a one direction or another, this is a tiny little swing over here. It doesn't require a lot of work to boost this to one side or the other.
And that could start to feel, as you get to later rounds of the game, it can feel like your opponent just got the victory in before you can stop them as opposed to truly earning the victory. I should note that there is a variant where you simply do not reduce the tracks as you go. So, if you find yourself not liking that, you can engage in that variant instead. As far as final thoughts on the new edition of Battle, there's a lot to like about this one and I was surprised. Skirmish games are always an interesting one. Skirmish games are weird for me. I'll say they they are always weird because I do find that I enjoy skirmish games, but I find that I don't really pull them off the shelf that frequently. They're the kind of game that I can have a lot of fun with them, but to a large extent, skirmish games can come down to close the distance and hit each other. And so, it requires almost this weird balance as well as the fact that there's that character aspect and things that are either too light and not interesting enough or they're too deep and they reward players who know the systems too much. And so, it's weird that I've actually While I've enjoyed many skirmish games over the years, I've enjoyed Godtear and Super Fantasy Brawl.
There's many skirmish games that I've had a lot of fun with. I will say most of the time they don't end up sticking around. They just aren't the ones I pull off and and table. So, I find myself in a weird place with this one because rating-wise, I'm going to come in at a four out of five. I really enjoyed this. I had a lot of fun playing this one and I didn't expect to because I'm not a fan of the IP and I expect to have that character disconnect where I just don't care. I'd almost rather generic characters. But, I thought this system was really well done. I thought they gave you a lot of decision space, not a lot of rules overhead with that caveat around all the edge cases. That's honestly my biggest complaint, I think. Uh but overall, I felt that the game gave you a lot of tactical decisions, a lot It felt rewarding. It felt like there were strategic elements you were you were in charge of while giving you a lot of abilities to kind of lean into while not being so overwhelming in those abilities that it just became overwhelming to figure out what's going on on the battlefield. I had a lot of fun with it. I'm looking forward to the other content that's there. Although, I will say just full of clarity and all this gamers and all that, I have no idea how long this will last my collection.
Skirmish games historically have not. That said, I have been enjoying it so far and I'm looking forward to diving further into the final game. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Arena the Contest. It's a game that kind of span the world of Tanares and I talk a lot about the cooperative aspect of the game where I really have had the most fun, but the skirmish game in Tanares is top tier. Like I've played the skirmish game both as like a head-to-head one versus one controlling all the characters, as well as controlling multiple characters like a two versus two game play with all the battlefield. It is an excellent skirmish game when you lean into it. Tons of characters, tons of abilities, tons of feeling super powerful. If you like the world of Tanares, Tanares Adventures Arena of the Contest gives you that skirmish game uh very well done. But also check out Tekken. It's not out yet, but Tekken from Going Board was another skirmish game that I had a lot of fun with. It's another one that really surprised me with just how much they game let you do with an assistant that was not so overwhelming, but also strategically satisfying at the same time. I mentioned that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games from from both All Play as well as their partner publishers. And if you're in the US, it's $4 flat rate shipping.
Check out War for Chicken Island. It's an interesting uh kind of tongue-in-cheek skirmish game with a lot of character and charm. You can check that one out as well as any number of other games. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. I hope you enjoyed this video, and as always, I hope you have a good one.