Skip to main content
Loading video...

Alone, Together: Vijayanagara w/ Saverio Spagnolie

Transcript 1:00:09

hey everybody I don't know who's here but it is Showtime I'm Liz Davidson of Beyond soliter and I'm here with Saros magnoli and we are going to play some we've had problems pronouncing this before so give me the the help that you that you gave before because it was really good the key to remember is that it's actually two words Vaya and nagara and vaya means Victory and nagara means City so it's city of Victory which you may have seen in the title of a recent Solomon rushy effort but it's VI anagura that helps so much it helps so much knowing that this two words actually was like really good for me all right so vagina Naro is here and we are gonna do an Alone Together stream if you are out there and you have questions by all means ask uh but we're just G to talk about this game it's like half interview half gameplay we're gonna play through a couple turns and we'll stop at about an hour that's the current plan so um I guess my first question is s what interested you in this particular topic you and all three of your uh your code assign um the the backstory of the game was that it was part of this consim game Jam which was organized by Fred sural and Joe duur and Shan O'Keefe and it was the first one it was in the middle of covid and we got together and the rules for the contest were to recycle a coin game so reuse the parts of a previous entry in the coin series and uh I had at that point had Gandhi out on the table sometime recently before that um by Bruce

Mansfield and thought that's been such an interesting experience I wonder what else we could do with that and then it was just a Mad Dash to go back into history and see what might fit and just the bones for this game just emerged I don't know they wanted to be found for this purpose so you could just see the the kind of the sweeping narrative and the factions you could kind of make out what might be the the primary movers and and what was driving this Century of dynamics that just kind of all you could I don't know you just kind of see the bones of it quickly and then that was the beginning of it and then um and then three years later we understood things well enough and had had sanded things down to to publish was the history of India something that was already an interest for you so you do where to look I've um India specifically I didn't know that much about I know a lot more about other uh parts of Southeast Asia uh South Asia I have a number of students and post who are from India so that's been a little bit I mean my into India so far has been through physics um and so but but historically it was for me and I think for a lot of players who come to this game kind of a new uh part of of our shared human history that that we just don't learn about in this country and so that Drew me in and I figured it would Drew draw other people in and and um and and then you know as with anything else in life you start learning a small thing about either a topic or a subject and then that makes learning the next thing

about it kind of more interesting and possible and then you start building out from there and then all of a sudden you have a wealth of of understanding of not just this period but related periods and distances uh nearby so that was kind of the the development part where it came from um and since then of course there have been a lot of other uh aspects of the journey which were totally unexpected but we we at some point early on uh brought historical consultant on board parac capadia at Williams College um she and some other people at the University of Wisconsin where I work um were able to basically open up lots of doors into other uh researchers who who have been very prominent working on this this period of history and we've been in touch a lot actually there there's one book in particular India and the Persian at age written by dick Eaton he's at University of Arizona he's been working on this area for decades many many decades and he's coming to Madison in maybe a week for there's annual uh annual conference for South Asia which always happens in Madison fortunately enough for me and so he's going to come and we're going to play this and he's uh he he's very very interested for obvious reasons I mean if you spent decades working on a historical subject and then out of nowhere you get contacted by someone who's produced something of this type I think that'd be pretty entertaining so yeah for sure so was it immediately obvious there let's do like kind of teach and explain I think that makes sense was it immediately obvious there needed to be like three players in this game did you think about having more or fewer and then also like how did

you decide what they wanted let's segue that into like the actual goals for the game yeah um I think I I don't think it obviously had to be three players there are some other factions that could have been elevated to playable I mean the most obvious one are the invading uh Mongol armies which play a role in this game they're just a non-playable faction there their roles are taken um by both the vagara Empire and the bomini kingdom two of the faction get to control what the Mongols do from time to time we could have fleshed that out into a fully playable faction although I felt like it was kind of um a little bit tangential to the Dynamics in the subcontinent uh they didn't penetrate further south in Delhi for instance during this particular Century they'll come back later as the malls um but uh I I think the I I think I just really like three player games and I think there's something kind of magical about just the right mix and balance the self-balance in the I mean games like Maria I think are just wonderful and so um I think uh for me anyway and I can't speak to the other uh designers um that was an immediate draw for me and so I think I probably was uh that was behind my desire to find three playable factions but it was very natural in the end so um you know the Bengali sultanate would have been an option but it is it's not as prominent as the ones that we have here for this particular story anyway and then what to uh what do they want to achieve what who are they what are they

trying to do yeah I mean of course you see the big events you know you learn about the big events early on and then um you can try to characterize and classify them through things like dynasties and emergence and births of new empires um so you to have these big hits um and I think that just standard thing and that's going to draw your attention to you know what led to to this event occurring you know what brought this about why did this group of people feel the need to uh you know cast off their relationship to some other greater power in a very maybe potentially violent or certainly a very sudden uh event and then you start reading a little bit more and you see that okay so if if it's the uh if if it's the viagara viagara empire in the South the the yellow faction down here um it had maybe a lot to do with the Fairly oppressive taxation being levied on them by a distant power the Delhi sultanate up in the north Delhi sultanate wasn't stationing troops in the South they would just come knock on the door from time to time expectation was you know you're gonna send some gold you're gonna send some horses you send some elephants and you'll send it every year and that will just be the arrangement and as soon as that starts getting too uh stiff then there's just a natural desire for Independence to keep local wealth for yourself to build have control over your you know autonomy so it's this in some sense as simple as that um the bomin kingdom is a little bit different actually the bomes are a

breakaway faction from the Delhi sultanate this they're composed of minor rulers who also had um some stiff requirements in terms of their interactions with the Sultan in Delhi the all powerful Sultan um but nevertheless had their own large network of uh they had a large Trade Network they were very um uh healthy economically they were powerful but um but it still took something uh which pushed on them a little too much for them to feel the need to break away in this particular case it was that the new Sultan in Delhi the second Sultan in this game or that and the second Dynasty does as it it becomes very Game of Thrones really this this narrative this century and as you would expect at some point ass Sultan is going to become paranoid and they are going to start seeing threats left and right and then they might do something hyper aggressive like uh there was an assassination of 89 Amir or rulers in the South uh in one shot for fear that they might be trying to usurp power and this led to an immediate response and the birth of the bomin Kingdom so just playing with those ideas playing with what were the kind of forces moving in the background I guess the last thing I'll say in answer this question is what's driving the deli sult inate is it pure greed I don't think so I mean there is if if you know you'd have the actual the ruling class in in Delhi they're certainly aware and they

have been aware for you know centuries that there are great wealthy Kingdoms in the South and it's certainly very appealing to plunder and if you're trying to maintain power and control you need to go and get those resources in order to share them locally to keep power but it's not even just quite as simple as that kind of maybe dark and unpleasant underbelly you also have this constant and unexpected raiding coming in from the Northwest from Mongol armies and that leads to the sultanate needing to maintain a standing army in the mountain uh the Mongol invasion regions as we call them like punab and the mountain passes this is very expensive so they start to to have their own uh the first kind of standing army in this period And so as is always the case nothing's clear nothing's clean everything's a mess and uh but you start to see some of those guiding forces for why these factions might be trying to do what they're doing excellent and then how do those motivations translate into actual game terms so how does each faction score points and uh how does that relate to the history that we just talked about like in in short form so this this game it's a it's an asymmetric game based on the different abilities and interests of these three factions but it's immediately asymmetric just based on where the points start off the deli sultanate starts off with 18 points the bomin kingdom and the Veta nagara Empire start off with zero points and the points are calculated differently

but at the end of the game Whoever has the most points wins so um the sultan its victory points are based on if you look at each province has a Prosperity value either two or one and it's based on how valuable those regions were the regions like Gujarat and Maharashtra and cartica on the west coast and Bengal on the East Coast are more valuable because either they had Maritime connectivity to Central Asia uh or otherwise uh trade routes primarily for things like horses which do not grow nicely in India for whatever reason so they need to be imported um every Province uh is either in a tributary relationship with the sultanate so that's tributary Province meaning that the the sum total of the rulers minor rulers there are continually sent back uh payment to the sultan or not so once that marker gets flung off this becomes an independent Province and that independent Province can be controlled by whichever faction is there in this case the bomin kingdom and they would plant their own flag of Independence as a consequence of controlling it having a majority of pieces so the Delhi sultanat points are simply the total prosperity of all of their tributary provinces they really want to maintain they want to keep the the the money flowing so they want to make sure that the M the the rulers in all of these regions are in an understanding about the frequency of payment and they begin the game with all

of these tributary markers down on the entire subcontinent how are they going to keep them there well they're it's essentially defensive they are going to try to uh keep the other factions from ceasing payment and that would be something that they do all at once together the the bomin kingdom can throw off a tributary Market when they plant these flags to become independent they gain that uh Prosperity so that's part of their victory points and when they do that the sultanate loses victory points and that comes into the points actually enter into some of the actions in the game so for instance the Delhi sultanate has basic commands and special decrees for those who play coin games this will look like operations and special activities and they work very much the same way but the commands are conscripting more troops marching them around the country governing placing very dangerous Governors who potentially may have some loyalty issues uh or attacking and their special decrees are to collect tribute that's just gaining those resources and it depends on their current points so they are really incentivized not just for the points in the game but so that they can do what they need to do economically which is more historically I think narratively interesting um it depends on on their current points large campaigns which were which were done during the century and demanding obedience which is how they send a governor down to a region and plant that tributary flag back down to make sure that the rulers there are in understanding of the

arrangement um the bomin kingdom is gaining points by becoming independent claiming their own Prosperity with these regions and building forts which are defensive in nature protecting them um also allowing for attacks on neighboring regions to where the fort is and the vinara Empire is similar in the sense that they are also trying to cast off tributary markers to gain the prosperity values in those independent provinces building Temple towns which are beneficial for rallying more uh local rajas or rulers to their to their flag and has economic benefits and then finally there's a bit of a tug-of warar between the southern factions the bomini kingdom and the viagara Empire there is what's called The decan Influence track and this is in some sense uh a foundational myths tug of war there are a lot of minor rulers in the South who aren't really sure as the Deli Salt in its curtain peels back on the subcontinent it's not entirely clear if they should be aligning themselves with one or or both in some cases of These two factions and so uh these factions gain points based on their influence which can be affected by economic means it can be affected by uh military means and through some events and once again it's not just about points but with better influence the bomes have a better Trade Network this allows them to gain Cavalry more rapidly or to conspire with the governors of Delhi more effectively

and the viagara Empire which was enormous I mean going back to us not learning about this stuff uh in the US in schools anyway usually um the vigin nagara Empire the the the capital city was like 500,000 people in the 14th century this is the secondar city in the World Behind Beijing at this time it's huge sprawling um and so you know when when European uh nations are are looking for uh Pathways to to Indian riches I mean to a large extent they're looking for the vigin nagara Empire um I'm I've now gone far a field from your question but um no that was good okay maybe I'll just leave it at that because I'm not sure to what extent the people listening to this will have already played this to know things like building forts trading and conspiring with those governors who if they're too far away from Delhi may actually be bomes waiting to emerge and the finally the viar Empire which is able to tax as their special decree to build Temple towns and to compel a little bit of extra elbow Greece some new alliances and if you're sufficiently influential those new allies can do a little bit of dirty work for you on the side and also gain some Cavalry which is hard to come by for the vinagar Empire it's the bomes who were milit arily uh dominant in this particular era between the two of them excellent Molotov cockatil wants us to know that a recap is always welcome all right so I I know this is a three-player game but who plays with

three people when you could play by yourself so tell us a little bit about the solo mode and how it works and then I was thinking we could just slow walk through a couple turns to show people game Flow fantastic so um the first thing I want to say is that the solo mode I mean we built a three-player game which you know obviously takes a ton of time in terms of all the details balancing what have you at the end um and and that was going to be it but then it was Jason Carr who said you know what I I strongly think you should do is put a solo mode together and at the time that was a little bit devastating because of just how exhausted you know we were but looking back it was I'm really grateful that there was that push because it what I think what it ended up being was basically a new design in some sense as you will fully appreciate it's just a different animal yeah on the other hand um I really like the way it came out uh and what I'm what I like the most about it is that I think what was most important to us in its development was that this game has a real narrative right as any game wants to have but but for this Century I I just really liked the story and I wanted to at least retain a lot of the important dramatic beats of this Century without having to shoehorn it you know I don't want to Railroad the history in here it's still a Sandbox of of sorts you can still explore you know ahistorical narratives but I still wanted the the fundamental narrative to to be to really shine through and that means in this game that

the Bots play by all of the rules of the regular game and that includes resource usage which is not always been the case for this type of game even if they're playing by the rules there's some things that are done with resources which you might have to do a larger game but in this one especially with the way that the sultanate responds to a dwindling economy which drives a lot of the history I felt like that had to be part of it so the Bots really do play by the full rules of the game and they're driven by a system which I think originated I mean I I actually don't know the full history on this of course the early coin game started with uh solo player AIDs that had uh spreadsheets not spreadsheets um flowcharts flowcharts thank you for just you know you'd walk through how does this faction Gonna Act and one of the nice things about these coin games is that it's all open information so you really can just explore like that um but there was a very nice advance I think on these ideas which came with I want to say Gandhi being the first with Bruce Mansfield's work and uh between Bruce and Jason they built what was a really really uh nice I think they would say ergonomic structure which kind of encodes a lot of that flowchart into um these player AIDS and these space selection tables for instance so each faction has uh four of these action cards and they are at the beginning of the game just shuffled up independently unlike some other coin games but they're shuffled up let's do that independently and you know what why don't we learn this as we go a little bit yeah why

don't we pick a faction and sit there do you have any preference um do you I was gonna say what faction should we be we've got a bman Empire fan a bman kingdom fan in the uh in the audience so maybe we could be the for we're going to sit as the bomin kingdom I like the bomes and so uh we don't need the bomin player a that's going to be us we don't need these cards but for everyone else let's go ahead and Shuffle up their action cards another thing that we thought would be important to offer um is some difficulty settings and so before we get going let's just look at the bottom right uh I don't know if it's clear enough to see but of each other faction's player Aid we said that there's different setup instructions do we want a normal challenge do we want a hard challenge or are we using this as a single bot against two players that should take the hard level or do we want to go full expert and I was playing full expert a couple days ago just to refresh my memory on this and it is it is very difficult um so I think maybe uh I think we'll just stick with the normal setup if that's all right let's just do yes let's do and let's take just a couple questions really quick um so oh Matthews answered one of them so u m you want to know how much design or development time did adding solo mode add to the total and did Matt answer that one yeah he's coming to say gonna guess like four or five months yeah that's right excellent excellent and then um Mike wants to know

if y'all have had any experience with the game Maharaja from Avalon home Mike I have never played it I have to say I'm sorry yes answer is no but there's was more time for more games right we'll get them all in before we die all we'll do all of them at some point um okay so we're going to leave the normal setup you know like hard or expert would place a couple of extra temples out there or shift a little bit of influence but we're just going to start it and the way the game without I'm not gonna teach the game I guess so we'll just some knowledge of the game the walkthr let's do it all right so let's just start with the first card and the first event card is the kakaa Empire one of these very wealthy kingdoms based in warangal in the South extinguished by The sultanate Who tired awaiting tribute uh so we see on the top of the card that the deli sultanate is the first to act so we'll just go up to the player Aid card and just a look at the anatomy of this card on the top left is just that's where you would start on any card to see what's the CATE gonna do the next the dotted grid is how is it going to select spaces if it's going to place troops we just kind of work down from Top toot bottom as we'll see on the bottom left is what does that faction do in the three important succession cards that split up the game on the top right it tells you how do they use Cavalry how do they gonna how are they going to use events how are they going to move and what are the peace priorities so that's the anatomy now what do they do we start by we've already shuffled this deck but

when it's the sultus term we look at the top left it says do they have less than three resources and at least six tributary Prosperity they have more than three resources they start off the game with 12 so that is irrelevant and we skip it next is is the command and decree available and it is and then the instruction there is just draw for command and decree the Su inate is very uh taxed with its uh economy action economy so it is more often than not going to take that command and decree which command and decree do they do we are going to look at their action card we'll draw off the top and take the next card down and we just read from the top here we go are their resources greater than 12 and do they have more than nine troops in one space which would mean are they getting ready to maybe do a big campaign they don't have more than 12 resources so instead of moving down the left with the arrow we move to the right which is flip the card 3d6 is less than the number of available troops so that is something we have to roll to find out let's take three d6s and Liz I'm sorry I Pro I feel like I should be letting you kind of no no I don't mind you doing the controls it's all good I'm terrible just let me know in what sense you'd like to jump in oh I will so that's 11 we have 10 troops and so here again the answer is no so we move down along the right and the next check is are there at least three

available Governors and there are we have four available governors in the sultanate available box so all right finally we get a hit and we move down with a green area arrow and we are instructed to govern now in order to use the solo Bots you kind of need to know the rules of the game uh and um that's at least certainly very helpful uh because they play by the rules of the game so if if you're given an instruction here that looks like you could cheat Uh something's not right you should be playing by the rules of the game so the Govern uh priorities we see the first priority would be to remove any obedient units that's part of selecting where are we going going to govern and I also want to point out on the top right of this card it says Max resources meaning the sultanate is always going to spend as many resources as it can to do this action in as many places as possible all right so it's gonna blow all the money it's gonna spend as much money as it can it's going to govern and right now it's got one Governor down and four to be placed it's going to end up costing us five resources but where do we place them so when when we look on the space selection table at govern which is the third column scrolling down we see that the first dot is where if we are independent in a space we need to get a governor there so that we can demand obedience but the game is just started so we don't have any independent provinces which means we just skip right past that dot and we go to the next

priority which is that it's going to be a province as opposed to Punjab or the mountain passes in the Northwest so we're just going to look at provinces and after that we have fewest opposing pieces but at least one okay so we want to mess with our opponents but not get into a fight we can't win exactly we don't want to be too delicate here so fewest opposing pieces but at least one has us looking at Gujarat gondwana and tamilakam but the next dot down after that had to Prosperity which means that the first uh Province we would look at is Gujarat all right so maximum money minimum opposition there you go and I and just remember on the card it also gave us an additional priority which was to remove any obedient units if you know the game you know that a governor can remove up to two obedient units and it would do that first then to place casbas if possible so the second priority is to place a casba the governor who's already in malwa will then go first so he'll place a casba with govern that costs one resource then to get the rest which is in provinces using Place Governors I jumped ahead of myself and I was looking at Place Governor so we decided that the next one would go in a province uh with the fewest opposing pieces but uh uh priority um sorry Prosperity two so that's the next one in Gujarat the next would go well there are no

other provinces that have the fewest opposing pieces which in this case is one and are to Prosperity so after that we just slide down to province with the most troops so that they're more protected so it looks like we're going to do anything that has one one y more resources and then for our last Governor there are no more uh provinces with only one which is the fewest um opposing pieces ah but then we go to the next few supposing pieces which in this case is two two so are we gonna wait would we choose which one we choose oh good okay I didn't even notice there we have Andra and we have madesh which both have two opposing pieces so to break that tie now we go down and see province with the most troops okay Governor is not a factor here it's the troop count the it's just the troops and so thank you for catching me because it's actually madesh that gives the governor the best protection here and that one final uh 12 down to seven there it is so that was the command and and then we look down to see what's the decree the first priority would be to demand obedience this is where if there's an independent Province they would plant that um tributary marker back down and now they've got Governors out there so the bot did a good planning as far as ordering is concerned and then collect tribute so to collect tribute they're going to add half of their tributary

points so add nine 9 plus 7 is 16 and they gain two no they spent all that money they got it all back they are beginning in the beginning of the game the sultanate is enjoying a lot of resources and if the southern factions let the sultanate enjoy those resources for too long in the game they will regret it uh oh and that's it for the sultanate okay that was a big turn though all right so just for people who are not sure how to play this game um let's I want to look back at the sequence of play just to kind of talk about how the rest of the the rest of what the rest of every what everybody else do uh comes into play so um in a coin game basically if you go at all you end up ineligible but this is a regular conflict game and so there's different options so basically by taking command and decree that means nobody else is going to take commanded decree this turn but somebody can do event or command and then the third person if they want to can do a limited command and remain eligible for that next card so all of us are going to get to do something um just these these two spots aren't necessarily going to lock everybody up and the other thing is that everybody could just do a limited command um and stay eligible they don't have to do one of these even if there there is the option both of the things you just said were in service to reducing uh downtime for players uh and just part of General streamlining and so every faction can play on every card if they're eligible if they've taken a big turn like the sultanate just did they

will be ineligible for the next card as you said but any number of factions can just take a limited command meaning a command in only one uh Province and then stay eligible for the next card in addition two-thirds of the events in the game have a stay eligible feature which allows you to take the event and slide back to eligible so there's just a lot more kind of dynamic and some gambling on do we want to stay Limited in the hopes of being first eligible on the next turn so there's a little bit more of a a rapid fire in that sense what led y'all to I guess have so many events that allowed you to stay eligible that was that was in service of reducing downtime I feel like it really depends on the the coin this is not a criticism of the coin games that do this it's a different model there's different intent but for what we were trying to achieve with this particular uh game uh I I we we just like the idea of people being engaged with every card ideally or every other card worst case scenario but the the the moments in a longer game where you might sit out for a card or a card and a half because you're last eligible or ineligible you can end up sitting out for 20 minutes or something like that and so this game is meant to be like an hour and a half or less um and so that kind of downtime just doesn't really work so that was the aim with the stay eligible of course that means that the the the strength of the stay eligible events are lesser there are some events that you don't stay eligible but those are huge events and so you might be it might be worth spending it in that way excellent all right so um it's not

our turn yet because the what are they going to do let's look at the top of their card perform the first available available action first up they cannot Rebel is that true it's true that they cannot Rebel because the beginning of the game is in the KY Dynasty Fierce oppressive rule births opposition but protects a growing Deli sultanate aluin Ki will not be allowing any rebellions with his firm grip on the subcontinent during the first of the game so vagara is not going to Rebel the event is available now is it effective what does it mean for an event to be effective it's what you think it is it's on the right side of this card events are effective if in this case they add vagara pieces or the sun is the dec and influence for vagara or cavalry or gives them money or adds Mongol Invaders which is a problem for the sultanate any of those things are effective and so if we look at this event it would be effective it gives the vagara Empire the unsh shaded part the top we give them an influence and then they can compel so it's definitely effective so are they going to take it they cannot Rebel the event is available and effective okay they may or may not be willing to go for it They're Gonna Roll so it's either one D3 always take the events that makes it a little hard to know what they're gonna do they're not gonna take the event so we continue less than four resources no they start off the game with seven so

they're fine they don't need to tax immediately do they have at least one resource and commanded decree is available no move down is the event effective yes and has stay eligible still no this card does not have stay eligible otherwise it would say it right underneath the title so this is where I'm saying if I can get a quick event and it's still eligible and I can't tax or do other big things I may as well go ahead and do that lastly if they have at least one resource let's just do a limited so vinagar is going to do something that a human player I think would probably want to do in this situation which is to just do a quick small effort and to remain eligible for the next card got it they're not biting this time so they're going to do just a little something something to stay in the game you got it so what are they gonna do we're gonna draw for that limited command so let's just take the top card off oh no some touchous over here are there at least seven rajes in one Province at the beginning of the game certainly no that would be unusual to see in a um a game but it can happen and if that happens then the bot is going to want to flow outward from cartica probably so because that's not true we flip to the other side um are there at least two available rajes okay I apologize this top box is for selecting a decree we're not doing a decree they're doing a limited command so the rulle state that we skip that and just move to finding the command are there 2d6 is 2d6 less than or equal to the number of available rajas so we need

to roll two dice to find out let's take these two dice three so three is definitely less than or equal to the number of available rajas available rajas currently eight so the instruction then is moving down to Rebel no indeed so the the southern factions are going to want to rebel as soon as they can the Bots except for the fact that as we were just saying the rules of the game state that during the KY Dynasty there shall be no rebellions and so on venag gara's Rebel command you can see there's a inold only available during the tlock dynasty which is the next Dynasty so what do they do since they can't do that rally using Place rajas so they're going to Rally which places rajas from available where are they going to do it we look at the space selection table Place Raja the top dot is to prosperity first of all where can they rally based on the rules of the game they have to have a vinara piece in that Province already all right It's gotta be cartica Cara all right now how many do they get in cartica the rules are uh one Raja but plus one of cartica it's a bonus so they get two another touch mouse failure there and

that cost them one resource and that's it and that is something that's worth remembering which is that they do not take a full decree and command they're just doing a limited command they're done that's it all right now it's our turn it's all right would you be willing to take the Helm of the bomin here I'm here I can't think straight okay so um for so can you enlarge the event Card War more time for everybody is available so here's the thing the event's available but we don't want that event that doesn't do anything for us so we're gonna have to obviously take just a limited command I think that's our our very clear best option so let's look at a menu and and let's see what we've got so we can rally so that means we can pull some more pieces out I mean that's never a bad idea in my opinion um we can migrate but I'm not really sure where we'd want to go just yet uh Rebel is not yet an option or we can attack so I'm thinking probably a rally is our best first choice and okay we can place up to one a mirror and then here let SK my sorry I pull that back up no no it's okay I'm I've got my little menu right here at home um uh so we can also do a plus one if we do it in uh Maharashtra you got it so I think that we should definitely do that and it's another plus one if we're in control but we're not just because we're a tributary right correct so even though we have the most pieces which is kind of a coiny way of establishing control we

still do not yet have control this place what they have is a majority they're whether they are face down or face up is whether they are obedient in the eyes of the sultan right or rebelling obvious to the sultan as an opposition Force when they are obedient the sultan may still suspect that something's not quite right but they can't attack them outright they're still paying the taxes it just it's not it's doesn't feel good they can send a governor down to govern them into small committee work rapidly however so e but that's right right now beginning of the game they are all on the surface obedient all right let's get let's get some some people on this map I think that's our best choice I guess we have to spend money it should all be free for us and that's it so the factions here becoming eligible for the next card oh yeah and These two factions are eligible as we move forward to the vaka temple which is the cover that Graces the the temple that Graces the cover of the game beautiful excellent all right so that ends the first turn and let's pull did you just pull that event card I I pulled the I pulled this next event card oh it's another crappy event card for us blah blah blah we don't do anything cool yet but that's okay because that just means our turn is coming maybe they'll

take the event and we'll be able to do something big maybe let's find out um the sultanate is not eligible so we have an opening potentially here this is a time to move against the sultan maybe yes that's right so you'll learn something historical if you play this game and the two Southern factions just start beating each other up immediately while the sultan is in total control I think they'll learn pretty quickly that that may have been a way for history to bend against them we're gonna we're going to keep sweet with our other neighbors the South for right now I think um okay so do you want to lead us through this or do you want me to uh um here let me pull it up okay so we are looking for ah uh we're looking to see they are eligible and we're going to see basically I'm looking up at that top left corner right what's the first thing that we can do so we cannot Rebel Che the event is available and effective check so that means that we need to roll and see if we're going to take the event they roll a one okay so that means they are going to take that event they're taking the event they're doing it all right so they get one influence yes one influence which brings these two potential allies into a slightly you know they might be more interested in this Empire now vagar is on the board they got some stuff it's getting scary sorry there we go okay and then they may build then in each province with a temple they could replace a unit with a Raja so basically that means that

they're replacing somebody else's piece with one of theirs in that case uh but um so let's see if they can build first they want to get temples out because that is going to get them some points so I guess we need to look at this chart and figure out where could they build I guess first the rules of the game are that they'd have to have uh units or Raja where they're going to build so it's got to be one of these three spaces but which one brings us to as you say the space election table exactly okay so um let me have a look here okay so Place Temple is what we're looking for we're looking for a place with two Prosperity before anything else so that's going to take us right back home to cartica no surprise there they're beefing up uh the home turf I mean it's not a bad plan it's not bad it's certainly a sensible play indeed and then that's all they could do right but if they had built in a place with one of those troop cubes they could have also then converted it to a Raja correct that's right now who what would they do though if we look on the right on um Peace priorities if they're going to replace um there is a list of which pieces they would replace first so for instance they would Target a governor before they would Target a troop so there's a kind of an ordering of danger that they have in mind ah very interesting oh I have a question just if we get to the point of random at the bottom what does random mean and how do you decide that is it's just like you just pick up a die and you're like okay well one to two this place one to three to four is that place

and five to six is that place or is there a more involved way to determine that in mathematical texts there are there are sentences like uh the proof is left for the reader so uh so we basically leave that to the player um almost in almost every case it's as simple as there are two choices or there are three choices and so it's pretty natural to come up with a solution there taking a die and either rolling it and then it's either even or odd or 1 through 3 4 through six or if it's three spaces 1 2 3 4 5 six but we have left we have left this to uh the player to decide got it fair enough all right so that's the end of their turn correct that's it all right then the sultanate cannot go correct and that means that we could go for a big old commanded decree which I don't think is a bad idea at all let I think it'd be fun to take a big turn um and then actually we got enough time to play just one more this this like a you just can't stop once we started no I'm kidding we'll stop it at hour okay so what's the most exciting decree for us to do right now because trade means we get money and hores which is never a problem money and hores is good building is good um the vinara Empire just did that because that's not a bad plan it gets us points um or conspire we can Form B with ag grieved leits just as flavor text I

absolutely absolutely love that we do have places that have Governors that we could get rid of which would be fun potentially For an upcoming not only is it fun but it may be the only way that the sultanate doesn't decimate you quickly because what a governor can do if they govern again is they can remove two obedient units sending them into lower level admin ministrative duties yes and build a casb this is a really dangerous situation right now those governors are in your face yes so I think we need to rock the kaspa and possibly get rid of some of those governors okay so um what is a good command to pair with that do we need to move anybody around should we rally are we good the way we are it's a uh worth maybe saying that unlike certain coin games or at least in this particular one you can take the command and the decree in either order but you can't go back and forth like in in certain volumes so you could do conspire and then Rebel that's sometimes fun that's a very thematic one we can't do it just right now but you could migrate into a region that has a governor and then conspire with that Governor that would be a way to stretch out a little bit although we don't seem to need that right now no we don't need that right now because we can do one or two provinces with one of our pieces we could just go ahead and and knock out to these Governors that's right it's also maybe worth noting that if you're going to trade you want to have a nice big Trade Network they get

money depending on the number of provinces with a bomin pieace so migration early and spreading the wings is is not a bad uh thought especially because if they stay obedient then they're a little harder to uh to the thing we could do is we get influenced by moving into an area that has uh venara Empire peace correct good thinking I mean we don't have to fight you don't you just build some nice step Wells and some aqueducts and impress the locals and there you go we just want to peacefully hang it's fine nothing nothing could happen um so maybe what we could do is we can pay one to move some M into do you want to say Andre because Kaka does not seem like a good idea that like a terrible idea it'd be an interesting strategy to just try to distract the faction by sending someone into their Hometown but I think Andre is probably a more sensible place let's let's go with Andre and then how many Amir should we move do you think uh it's up to three and with a full command we can choose a number of different spaces to migrate into so it doesn't have to just be one but for now let's take Andra and you're thinking two yeah let's move two two is a good number okay it kind of evens us up with everybody else there so we're not like outstandingly distracting as you say it costs one to do the command but then on the bottom of migrate we see shift influence in only one of the locations if any Amir moves into a province with viagara piece they may spend one more to do a zero sum

influence shift and it sounds like I think should absolutely do that and with that extra impressive payment influence goes up and down these two rajas who were thinking maybe vagaro was kind of back on their own no not so interested and the bomes are on the board there we go a point I like it um and then uh I do think we need to uh conspire let's let's like talk about our feelings with these Governors and then make them our governors in truth they if you were influential if if your influence was just a little higher you could even reach out to neighboring provinces and even that could work out for you see and you could even communicate with some rajas of vinagar and convince them that actually the bomes are or where it's at but right now it's just two where you already have a piece yeah what are you thinking all right so we just we talk ERS okay um let's do garat because it's got two prosperity and I like that that Governor is actually looking very nice in turquoise now all right it's just a better color on you man you look great um and then what uh what are we thinking here um what's okay so here's the question um so our other options are madesh and gondwana yep which is smarter in terms of our current piece count in situation because gandana seems nice because there would be no pieces belong to the sultan at there

left so that seems tempting to me but is there any reason to mess around in madesh instead madesh is very Central as is given by the name um which means that if they excise you they'll cleave you in half they'll plant a casba that could be pretty uncomfortable but it's but if they do that then maybe you're free to run off to Bengal and start some other part of your network unclear see Bengal is worth some money over there is maybe we go with gondwana I think gondwana it is I enjoy running off to the side and being annoying to people who then have to work to come get me so it is very annoying yeah though it takes some effort for the sultanate to get out there very historical I must say okay that's it so that's your that's your big turn and Matthew wants me to know that I've made the riskier play that there was a more conservative play why would I do that come on man all right so now we're in a place where neither of us is eligible uh why don't we see what that looks like and then we can chat take any final questions and and we'll call it just a we could talk about like sort of how the game will progress as we move through the decks for the sake of exposition why don't we imagine that that third card was one of the many Mongol invasion cards interpers throughout the deck I mean oh yes um so the rules we'll remember of the game are that whoever is being asked for assistance in this case the vagara

Empire they are going to be asked uh which two Mongol commands should be chosen and it could be the same command twice to figure out which one there is a card here which we just walked down are there two commands remaining there are would advancing troops get at least three more Mongols than Troop and Punjab they haven't even started to roll yet so that's that's false um and this is a typo this seems to be corrected uh in the first one should have said Deli because if they can go to Deli they'll attack in Deli you can see it on the bottom left that they would advance and then attack and Telly uh so can they do it in Punjab also no so we just flip and then we're just looking for spaces where the Mongols really outnumber the sultanate and should attack there but they have no Mongols anywhere yet so really the only thing they can ever do at the beginning of the game is to amass and that just moves three Mongol into the mountain passes let's go but now for their second command we start over are there two commands remaining no so we flip and now it's not entirely clear what's going to happen so you can't plan ahead perfectly um are there any spaces with four or more Mongols no no and then we would roll a 1d6 and we would check if that number less than the number of Mongols in Delhi right now there's no Mongols in Delhi so that's not going to work right there are no there are no Mongols in Punjab so that's not going to work but we do get to this last check 1d6 less

than the Mongols in the mountain passes and so they might amass more or they might attack right away and they are gonna attack right away let's go get them how do they attack we've got four I'm missing where is that other die here it is so we've got four dice for for the attacker two dice for the defender in this case the deli sultanate and does this does this work the same way as other combat so like basically if you can do this you can do any other combat if you can do this you can do any other combat that's right it's all I mean there's little tweaks very small tweaks if you were to attack a bomin with a fort you would only use three if you're attacking Deli if the Mongols attack Deli the saltate in Delhi you'd only use three but otherwise this is the same as anything else okay see y'all are going to know how this works when you play on your own the Mongols are going to try to get three or less because they have three Mongols in the mountain passes the sultanate's going to try to get two or less on each die because they have two troops or units in the mountain passes we don't carry this out just yet because we've yet to use caves the horses are a critically important resource during this Century so they are important in the game uh I should say a one well a six is not a hit however Cavalry can be used to change these things um the Mongols always have a cal Cavalry

Cavalry can be used in one of two ways either to charge what charge does is it reduces a die by one pip so it could take a six to a five if you had multiple Cavalry you could change the same die multiple times but that's how if the Mongols if there were five Mongols they could turn that six which is always a miss into a hit with that Cavalry in this case it doesn't matter because they've got three hits but uh and there's not much else I can do about that but before we uh look at the consequences note that the sultanate has four Cavalry tokens right now they're not hitting at all but cavalary tokens as I said can be used to charge to reduce the Pips so they could reduce it down to a hit we'll see what they do we cost you a lot it would be very expensive or they can do a defensive screen what a screen does is it cancels out a die from the opponent Al together a one cannot be screamed that's it for the minutia that's all the rules for combat So currently we have to figure out the sulan that has four Cavalry what do they do with this situation let's go look at their player Aid card on the top right cavalry charge only the sultan bot is an aggressive competitor they're going to save those horses for when they are going to try to you know do some some offensive work all right so they just gonna take it on the chin up here that's it so it looks like there's three hits for the Mongols which means they're going to remove all of the troops there uh the sultanate will do no damage to

the Mongols and then at the end of any attack on the bottom here uh on attack and plunder we see that for each Invader left in the space after the attack sultanate going to lose one resource so they're going to lose because it's a mountain passes three resources oh no had that happened in Punjab it's three resources and three troops from the provinces must be recalled available if it's in Delhi it's three Pro if it was three Mongols it'd be three resources and twice as many six troops must be recalled from a panicked Sultan in Delhi who needs them to come back to the north excellent and that's it for the Mongol card beautiful so uh hopefully this giving everybody a good idea of game Flow but the other thing is that so we played sort of the first first part of the First Act where you can't Rebel how many decks are there in the game and let's talk about the game timer and how it works because if you play coin this doesn't work the same way there are um how do want to say this there are essentially four acts we are in the middle of the First Act which is composed of just six event cards and two Mongol invasion cards and at the end of those eight cards total we'll get to the first oh that's not coming there we go first succession card which has a little flavor text and it's the Zenith of the deli sultanate this is when they're at their Peak but it's also when they start to see some succession crises and things

begin to whisper that there could be a problem coming in the coming decades um so that's the first act at that point the KY Al Alin KY and his successors are no more and it is the two Glock Dynasty and this eccentric ruler uh is leaves Delia more vulnerable the rebellions will start to happen there's a shifting gears right at this point in the game and it starts to get a little bit more fireworks in the South um so that's this then the second act is six more event cards and two Mongol invasion cards and then the third Act is again six event cards and two Mongol invasion cards and um at the end the fourth Act is a potentially truncated act because this is the the second succession card rise of the Rebel Sultans and then Lords of the decken and then the final stack is six event cards and two instead of Mongol invasion cards it's the timid Empire which will be rolling through to knock on the door of Delhi the first one just is a warning and the second one leads to a an invasion of Delhi by the Mongols they play out the battle until there are either no more Mongols or no more Deli sultant troops or uh units and then the sultanate gets an additional Plus or three points depending on how well they do there and that's the end of the game and so depending on when those two cards are shuffled into that last set it could be a short ending or it could be a longer

ending there could be some drama not knowing if we've seen one do I have chance to do one more big action should I save it and gamble with a limited command it gets uh tense at the end I like it so for everybody out there if you have a last minute question this is your last chance but hopefully this gave you a good idea of how the solo for this game works um and whether uh this game is for you I think it's awesome so I'm super happy um that uh that that you came on S this is great I'm really grateful for your time and your interest and yeah thanks a lot I look forward to seeing you around in your your upcoming projects indeed um but everybody this is vagina Nara this is a fantastic game it's in the regular conflict series from GMT um and and uh yeah Matthew I'm also glad that you were in the chat thank you for being an invaluable contributor can I can I can I say how just briefly how wonderful it was working with Matt during the pandemic that was the best part of the pandemic it was amazing uh working with the whole design team and working with Joe Dost who is magical uh creature so it's all been great Folks at GMT are fantastic we won't tell Fred how much we love Joe Dost on this channel uh and then just one more question as the kind of close out what made you want to explore this time in history we talked about it a bit at the start but uh I I didn't know anything about it that for me is extremely alluring I mean this is one of the reasons why I think these games are so wonderful is

that it's just a portal into a different time and space for me particularly it was covid and I I remember thinking many times like I would love to get out of my apartment but I would also not mind leaving this point of time in the the timeline so so just diving back into the 14th century and and I have post you know there are postdocs and graduate students that I'm around who are from India so I have a little bit of a general awareness of certain modern uh ongoing political situations and and I I I'm my plugin is usually Through Math and physics but uh this was just yet another neat thing that I could start adding to my understanding of uh our Global human history fantastic all right thank you again everybody out there thank you so much for coming it's been so wonderful to your have a lovely chat going while we play and everybody out there please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved