Beyond Solitaire Podcast 106: Kate Cook on Women in Classical Video Games
Transcript
thank you time for a quick ad break Beyond Solitaire is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and they are launching their Kickstarter campaign for 500 year old vampire at the end of March designer Jason Cox has adapted Tim hutching's solo RPG design to create a Cooperative experience that can either be played among friends or as a creative exercise in classrooms in fact it is written to satisfy National English and art standards this one is going to be good so I recommend you check it out I also want to put in a quick plug for myself I absolutely love working on Beyond Solitaire and I wish I had more time to put into it you can help me make that possible by giving to my patreon at patreon.com Beyond Solitaire My ultimate goal is to get to a point where I no longer have to teach summer school so I can budget my time for game work and summer conventions instead but no matter what thanks for listening and let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and today on the pot of a very special guest this is Dr Kate Cook she is associate lecturer in Classics at the University of St Andrews how you doing today Kate I'm great thanks hey it's wonderful to have you on and and I've asked you on because you do two things that I find very interesting you study Classics and you play a lot of video games so uh why don't you tell us kind of your academic background and how you've gotten to where you are a games researcher uh yeah sure so um I've always played video games I should say um and one of the kind of things that almost cued me into the fact that probably I should study Classics rather than say history at University was that
I spent a lot of my time when I was supposed to be revising for my history exams playing um the old city builders Zeus master of Olympus um and I mean doing other things as well you know doing Latin revision and so on but I was I was kind of repeatedly coming back to this to the ancient world to the sort of myths and to games exploiting them um and that sort of made me realize quite how interested I was in the ancient world um and so then I went and kind of did study and my first kind of background in Classics my first research interest is actually Greek drama um and it's only over the last couple of years that I've Diversified a little bit and uh picked up this kind of games interest which has always been running alongside as a kind of personal capacity it's something I've I've done for fun um but which then became part of my research as well in the last few years oh that's awesome so um when you were doing Greek drama who was your favorite author like what were you interested in before you made this metamorphosis I'm always interested in these things um probably all three of them so I'm I worked specifically on Greek tragedy um and I'm interested in kind of tracing patterns um across the genre through the genre um so my PhD project and what will be my first book uh with Bloomsbury which uh should hopefully be out I would have thought next year um is on kind of praise and blame in Greek tragedy as a whole so looking at what characters say about each other rather than what they do necessarily um but another kind of very strong
research interest um has always been gender so I'm particularly interested in in what sort of female characters say about male characters um in the praise and blame sphere um and look at also looking more broadly at women in Greek tragedy um and that sort of gender strand is actually of course an interest that has come across with me into the games research as well so so looking at women and looking at gender is kind of a strong interest for me across all three trades awesome and you know we were just talking before this at the time that I was finishing my PhD you know video game studies was not a thing the way that it is now um what tipped you off to the idea that maybe your study of classical women could apply to video game reception studies as well um I mean I think kind of the field of of classical reception studies has as we were just saying um has been kind of growing in the last few years and has started to Encompass a really wide range of things as well so there's always been interest in you know things like um almost what some people call High culture I hate that as a label but things like you know theater and Opera and so on and how they engage with the classics um but more recently there's been a lot more kind of serious engagement by Scholars with things like film and TV as well um and you know games is a kind of mass media industry alongside those I mean the games industry in the US in the last couple of years has been bigger than this the Hollywood industry um in terms of both numbers of people in get engaged in the games and uh the kind of turnover
of the finances of the industry uh so so if we're thinking kind of you know multimedia Industries and and what they're doing with the classics then games is absolutely a big one up there um and it's also started you know it's not just me looking at it either it's also started to become a bigger topic across Classics so there have been a couple of other books out in the last couple of years that have started looking at this area and to some extent in other fields too so the historians are actually slightly ahead of us in this regard I would say there's kind of historical game studies is a it's still not a massive field but it's a bigger field than than what you might call classical game studies and there are certain kind of areas of History like medieval history or modern history are particularly interested in the moment at looking at how their kind of historical periods are presented in games um and that's as I say that's another kind of growing area of scholarship so it has started to become a thing not just for classicists but outside in history as well um and as I saw that you know I wanted to be part of it really that's awesome and so you mentioned that your dissertation is going to turn into your first book but only kind of because you have an edited volume that's out and it's one of the things that caught my interest and made me want to talk to you so you've got women in classical video games that you co-edited with Jane Drake hot is that correct yes it is and um so tell us about tell us about y'all's book uh what was the process of pulling it together what kinds of essays mated in and you know for for interested readers you know what
might they find inside foreign yeah so so um actually this book was in some ways a response to the fact that this field has suddenly started appearing in Classics because as I mentioned we had these books um the first of which was another edited volume um on Antiquity in in video games um and both Jane and I were interested in this we'd both sort of been separately looking at um games a little bit by ourselves and one of the things that struck us about this volume um was that it didn't seem to be engaging with the issue of gender very much it had one chapter out of about 15 or um on women and we both felt that that wasn't really enough so um it was it was important to us that um the question of gender and the kind of question of women should become a topic that was being raised at the very start of this new field right we're looking at Classics in video games and we didn't want it to be like looking at kind of Classics more broadly where we do men for 1 500 years and then someone says oh well you know maybe let's study women now we wanted women to be in the agenda to be in there from the beginning um so it was really important to us to get this book out to get this book to be part of the conversation right from the start so that people were not sidelining these issues of gender um particularly because in games questions of representation and questions of gender and kind of the end in the games industry is is a really big deal as well um so we decided to put out a call for papers and actually this happened kind of during the pandemic so we didn't have
a conference so anything like that we went straight into putting the book together and we were really lucky we had a huge amount of Interest we got something like 50 or 60 abstracts Which is far more than we could put into a volume um and some of them were not on Classics so Jane actually took some of the ones that were on sort of History more broadly um away and made those into a separate volume and we kind of gathered the classical ones together and selected the ones we want um and for us it was really important there were a couple of things that were really important firstly we want to to make sure that we're getting kind of decent diversity of voices so early career Scholars and and kind of people who maybe haven't written on this material before I mean not many people have written on this material before um but it was important to us to get kind of some of those voices that we weren't necessarily hearing elsewhere into the volume um and it was also really important to us to have a decent amount of variety as well because there are kind of some games and some topics that come up quite a lot in the field so there tends to be quite a lot of discussion of strategy games for example because these make a lot of use of historical content they're kind of very popular um sometimes the kind of action RPGs so Assassin's Creed get a lot of discussion but it was important to us to try and look uh more broadly and actually what you asked me about transitioning when I said I like to look at kind of all the tradians it's probably coming in here again actually because we wanted to look at all types of games in the same kind of way we wanted to think about games as broadly as possible um so we've looked at a really wide
range of genres we were really lucky that we had the kind of contributors willing to do that so indie games are in there as well as the strategy games I looked at a mobile game we have got some action RPG we've got a modern platformer we've got one chapter on uh Japanese games for early Japanese games and the interaction with the character of Athena by Dunstan Lowe um so so really trying to get a kind of very broad range of of different representations of women's different kind of settings different genres of game to see whether we could find kind of patterns or Trends if you cast The Net more broadly than than some of the sort of more typical games that people often discuss so that was kind of a big a big driving selection process for us so I had a couple of questions about how books and articles like this come together and one is what does your research process look like how do you select what games to play and then how do you decide what you need to kind of pair with that in terms of engaging with the historical record like it's just a totally different process than you know what did this ancient author think about X thing where you just look at them in their context well I mean it is and it isn't um so I think in some ways you know a lot of what I'm doing certainly I mean I can only speak to my own research process really uh you know other authors may take different approaches but when I'm researching a game a lot of what I'm doing is very similar to when I'm researching a tragedy except it takes a lot longer because it doesn't normally
take 90 hours to read a tragedy whereas it may well take me 90 hours to play through a game um and that's something I didn't actually really appreciate before I started doing this research quite how time consuming it could be um but so what I will normally do is if it's a game that I'm sort of playing for research um I think it's quite important personally to play them not everyone does some people look at kind of videos and so on um but for me it's important to have control of the process and be able to kind of Guide to the right sort of scenes or the right conversations which obviously you can't do if you're just watching someone else play it um so I will play through and I will take normally hundreds of screenshots it's really kind of a key aspect so I will play through every scene sometimes I will have to to play through scenes multiple times so the mobile game that I played for my chapter in this volume I played at least I think nine times in full in order to get kind of all of the different options in all of the different scenes and find out what all of the kind of permutations of dialogue could be take a lot of screenshots to have a record of that so then when I kind of get to writing the the chapter or the article I've got that at hand and I could go back through and check the dialogue and kind of check all the as it were the evidence base um and and just sort of go from there and that's you know as I say that's a lot like reading through a primary text really I mean it's more interactive there's more of the kind of play aspect but in terms of of getting all of the information and then kind of pulling out the key examples that are relevant for my argument the process is quite similar just bigger
that makes sense and then you know how do you how do you cast your net for games that will be relevant to research like this so something like Assassin's Creed Odyssey or origin seems you know pretty obvious because it's a big Blockbuster game but you know uh mobile games came up in your volume and you know things other than just total war came up in your volume so how you know some visual novels I noticed as well so how are you hunting for these do they just kind of fall in your lap do you go on Steam and just type mythology and see what happens uh a mix I've always just kind of wondered about this yeah so so it's probably a mix um so the the mobile game which is um a kind of chapter based almost like a kind of visual novel that I wrote on for this book um appeared weirdly in Facebook ads for me at the very start of the pandemic so originally I was going to write my chapter in this volume on something else um but this game started and it started spamming a lot of people on Facebook during the pandemic and I sort of picked it up and noticed that it had this Roman story and so I thought oh well I'll just you know I'll see what it is I have no idea what this game is I've kind of follow it and see what happens um and there was a lot of really interesting things going on in it so I thought well actually this could be you know something we should be paying more attention to and and I I'm lucky that it's just showed up for me through random ads but a lot of people are missing it so this is a good chance for me to highlight it
um sometimes it is about literally casting the net as wide as possible so I've written um elsewhere recently on the blog for pies demon which is a database that collects ancient world video games they run a Blog and I've recently written for them on kind of mobile games more broadly they interact with the ancient world and a lot of collecting examples for that was literally just searching you know Rome or Greece or ancient or absolutely mythology or whatever and just going through pages and pages of search results and downloading anything that looked relevant and giving it a go that's obviously for what I'm trying to you know gather samples across a broader range um or I'm writing at the moment a chapter on Persephone in modern video games and that's been a similar kind of some of the big examples again you know the things like the fact that she features in an Assassin's Creed DLC you've you know it's a major Blockbuster game so it's very easy to find that out um finding rarer examples has very much been a case of just sort of searching Persephone and all of these these tools to find other examples and sometimes that gives you stuff that's useful and sometimes it gives you stuff which has the name Persephone for no apparent reason it doesn't have anything to do with Persephone which is interesting in a different way um and I'm also lucky that that places like Twitter are a really good resource for this one of the one of the advantages I think of historical game studies and classical game studies being so new is that a lot of other people involved are quite young and they're all on Twitter and they do things like share
games with each other so when interesting mobile games come up now there's normally people around who will point to me to them and say hey have you seen this you know you should include this in your in the next thing you're looking at and so on and that's been really good so the community of other people working on this although we're quite small um I think is really good about sharing Resources with each other which is very helpful that's awesome yeah you know Twitter has its drawbacks but I would say that in board game world too like Twitter's just such a it's amazing the connections you managed to make with people almost in spite of the platform sometimes yes so the other the other question I had and I think we could probably go pretty far with this discussion is what kinds of historical expectations can we place on video games especially those that are not necessarily holding themselves to any particular or any consistent set of standards and then how does that actually impact your reception work yeah I mean this is a an interesting question really because I think obviously video games games of any kind are not setting out to be as it were almost historical documents or you know historical textbooks or or anything like that um they're designed for entertainment and they're also designed with a kind of clear commercial process involved which is they are designed to sell um and that is going to have a huge impact on the kind of content they how are producing um and I think it would be I'm not very
interested in doing the kind of work that is just sort of looking at these games and saying well you know here's a historical and accuracy and here's a historical inaccuracy I mean of course we will find plenty of those but we should expect to find plenty of those because that isn't what games are aiming at um and historical game studies one of the things that has kind of become a big topic over the last uh 10 years or so is the difference between accuracy and authenticity and um interestingly while game players often don't really distinguish between the two game developers have recently started talking quite clearly about authenticity as opposed to accuracy by which they mean they're actually not even interested in talking about kind of specific facts but they are interested in portraying a sort of sense of the period and they label that as authenticity so if it feels to a player like a kind of Classical Greece then it's authentic even though it may simultaneously not be very accurate um if you see what I mean does that distinction Yeah so basically it's like Vibes versus details a little bit yeah absolutely and and interestingly as I say developers think of this as kind of a fairly clear distinction in their minds but players often don't players will talk about accuracy as meaning both really um so authenticity has become this kind of big thing and and that's something you can look at you could talk about you know what makes something seem authentic um authentically Classical Greece for
example what do we mean when we talk about that what kind of things are developers aiming at um and why um and the choices that are made around that I think are perfectly interesting and perfectly useful for doing reception work um but also because of I think particularly because of my work in on gender um sometimes I'm not even particularly interested in authenticity I'm I'm interested in in kind of What kinds of narratives are games telling about the ancient world or about women in the ancient world and and for me that's not really about you know is it is it accurate is it kind of historically accurate but what ideas is about women in the ancient world are these games suggesting we have we as kind of modern developers and modern players and how are they kind of reproducing old narratives or how are they trying to strike away and make new narratives and all of that kind of thing which I think often personally I think is often much more fruitful as a way of looking at these things because I think um even though games have started to move more into the educational sphere with things like the discovery tours on the Assassin's Creed games they're clearly not aiming at being you know historically accurate educational resources and to try and hold them to those kind of Standards is is I mean it's unfair as well as being kind of pointless really at the same time I mean I'm asking these questions because I kind of see and in your answers I see things sort of coming together in a way that makes it all connect so you know yes we can't hold video games to actual historical standards but sometimes we
say we do and also even you know in this language about authenticity right the question is authentic to whom authentic in what way because it doesn't sound like authenticity actually means this feels like actually being in ancient Rome authenticity means like feeling I'm on a tour of the ancient world and this feels sufficiently classical enough to satisfy me and then those things all kind of explode like in the intro to your book you mentioned having the Amazons as you know a faction in a game about Troy they're warrior women and something about that even though it's perfectly authentic to the sources broke the feeling of authenticity for some of the players of that game and so you know all these things are in play and these kind of weirdly flexible ways so I mean I would actually like you to talk more about that about the Amazon issue and then what what does that say about authenticity and about historicity and about claims to authenticity you know in one it's just such a clean example yeah absolutely I mean you're kind of framing it as authenticity to to whom is exactly right because um but there's no kind of blank objective standard against which these games are being held when they when they have these kind of ideas of authenticity and often it what we're really talking about is players perceptions of the Ancient World um as being the kind of standard which they then set so the Amazons is a really interesting example because this was from Troy
um and actually kind of comes on the back of um what is sometimes called the female General controversy of um Total War Rome uh Total War Rome two um where they had increased numbers of female generals um the generals already existed they just amped up the kind of Spawn rates of these um the chances that you'd end up playing with one and there was a huge outcry of of objections that this was not historically accurate that it was um attempts at being politically correct and this kind of thing and creative assembly the company said um we don't care effectively about this backlash we're going to carry on keeping the female Generals in there and so then when they brought out the Troy game they kind of carried on this pattern of um keeping women to some extent in there they were downloadable content but they were downloadable content that you got uh free if you pre-ordered the game so for many players they were kind of slightly many um interested in advanced players they were effectively like base game content um and it was two Amazon factions with two different leaders hippolyta and Panthers layer and they have kind of different play Styles which kind of nice and interesting um they come in sort of on the Trojan side except sort of not really because they are also quite independent they can you know you can play them slightly differently um and they're not that fully tied to the Trojans um and they they add some exciting variety and and creative assembly produce a beautiful concept art for them
as well which some of which you can see on the cover of our book because we liked it so much that we like these Amazon so much um but for some players this was still really objectionable and people in particular claimed that they were again not historically accurate um and that there was no truth behind the myth um truth behind the myth was a slogan that creative assembly had used had attached to this Troy game because they had suggested that they were sort of representing it as a kind of truth behind the myth game this is the kind of historical conflict behind the myths of The Iliad for example although it's very clear that the game is drawing on the Epic poems as one of its sort of main sources because you have the figure of uh apparently Homer is the person who gives you the tutorial so this is clearly these games are based on the Epic poems they're not based on on you know archaeological record or historical documents only partly because there are no historical documents for any Trojan War and yet nonetheless players found that this wasn't in their view accurate because they were all women armies and this was felt to be to be untruthful that there was no truth behind this myth this was just kind of mythical um and again some of them as as is kind of a repeated refrain with some of these complaints um quite a few of them attached this to the idea of being um kind of politically correct and being about marketing um this this kind of claim of it's not historically accurate to have women is
often Associated by the people who make these complaints as being a marketing Ploy something to kind of sell the game rather than than carrying on their usual approach to representation um so I found this kind of particularly interesting because I mean in this game you can if you play as Aeneas you can have him talk consult with or talk to dead heroes in the Underworld which is fairly obviously kind of mythological content there's not much sort of truth behind that um and yet you don't find players complaining about this as being as being untruthful or inaccurate but you do find players complaining about the Amazons as being inaccurate and so that's absolutely as you say it feeds into this kind of authentic to whom well to this group of players it is not authentic to have women involved even in a mythological context let alone a historical context um and we see the same thing I should say you know my interest is particularly in in gender but we see the same thing in connection with race in other particularly in games in other historical contexts actually um so one of the things that the medievalists have kind of been bringing out a lot in their analysis recently is is um medieval games where player perceptions that even developer Perceptions in the case of some games um lead to kind of all white casts and this is felt to be kind of historically accurate or historically authentic to a certain type of player who believes that it is only historically accurate if everything in in medieval Europe is
completely white despite the fact that this is clearly not historically the case that's their perception and that's the kind of standard of authenticity they set um so I think you know even when we're not talking about accuracy in terms of detail there are some problematic ideas about about historical periods about the medieval period and about the ancient world that are um creating discourse around some of these ideas of authenticity absolutely so I noticed some pretty familiar strains throughout the essays in your book you know women as hypersexualized or you know women as not really having distinctly women's experiences in these games um you know comments about violence in women that were depressing but not necessarily shocking uh was there anything in the studies that have emerged so far of women in classical video games that surprised you and that um you found exciting foreign I'm afraid I'm going to do a surprised meaning negatively first but then I'll come on to something I've had slightly more exciting all right um I in some ways I was surprised and you know Jane and I mentioned this very briefly at the end of our introduction we were surprised and disappointed that despite the huge variety of types of games we tried to include and the kind of very different approaches that our contributors took um we weren't finding a greater range of positive stories um and and you know this is looking at games um from relatively early right the way up to you know now or you know 2021 and
so on and we're still not getting any more um positive stories coming out there's there's some attempts in places particularly in the more independent games but not as many as we'd hoped we'd really hope to be able to say you know look at all this positive progress and we couldn't and that was surprising to us in some ways that things hadn't moved further forward than they could have done um but surprised in a more positive sense or something that excited me was that you can see um at least in some places more engagement with questions of gender than you used to be and particularly I think this comes in the kind of the less mainstream almost the sort of less moving away from the AAA games so these are games produced by major or medium-sized Studios um into the places where games are being produced in smaller Studios or for different audiences um so some of the more independent games like Hades or apatheon were doing more interesting things with their narratives of gender they weren't necessarily always doing everything I would like to see but they were engaging with them they were trying to create new narratives um trying to kind of discuss some of these issues in more interesting ways um and the area that kind of um we've talked about a little bit already but that particularly surprised and interested me was mobile games um because the type of mobile game that I looked at has as its target audience um young women uh particularly kind of older teens but really they're sort of aiming at young women um and that's despite the fact that women actually make up more than 50 of
Gamers it's quite rare which is always a kind of surprising number of people but it's true it's quite rare for major game studios for sort of consoles or PCS to explicitly say they're aiming at female players they may say we're aiming at kind of neutral audiences but the typical gamer is still often assumed to be the kind of young male gamer and a lot of things like marketing and so on make it very clear that that's the target audience for them whoever their real audience is the target is the young man but that is explicitly not true for these kind of um story driven mobile games who are very upfront about the fact that that that isn't their target audience um and that means that when you kind of engage with their content when you have a look at what they're producing they're often producing really different stories um so the game I looked at choices in their kind of story of the late Republican Roman period um has got a female main character which is relatively rare who is surrounded by women as well there are other men involved in the story particularly there are men interestingly there are men as love interests so there's some kind of sexualized men appearing um including sometimes appearing you know quite naked um for basically a female gays um which is you know quite unusual really in in this context um but there's a lot of you know semi-critical engagement as well with what women's realities of this time period therefore would have been so you have the opportunity to talk to a character who has experienced um forced child marriage um and kind of her her
experience in this and her difficulty balancing the needs or the wants of um her husband and her father and her kind of growing Independence is a key story that intersects with your main character across the game um there are you know even just sort of throwaway comments um one uh female character comments on the fact that if there is going to be civil war um that's going to be additional dangers in the city for the women which is not going to apply to the men in the same way and therefore they need to think about it differently um this kind of thing you know it comes up because they're they are trying to think about and engage with women's lives and experiences in a much more explicit way than you might see in the major kind of Assassin's Creed style games um so I thought that was kind of really interesting and and really positive and also suggests a really good reason why we need to be paying attention not just to those big AAA games because we're going to miss these other interesting narratives that are going on in the kind of smaller or in the in the mobile type realms yeah I think one of the weirdest things especially as a scholar in a field like yours it's growing right is that you have a lot of choice about what you choose to Spotlight and then that means that you actually have a surprising amount of power over where the narrative goes and who gets attention and whose stories make it you know into the fancy Journal as opposed to just somebody's internet forum and you know do you is it a responsibility that you feel or is
that unrelated to you know just looking for the kind of classical elements in work um yeah I think Point actually um and it kind of cuts both ways because on the one hand I mean yes we have some element of control over what we discuss on the other hand if we had released this book and no one had talked about anything to do with Assassin's Creed that definitely would have been some people out there saying well this game has over 10 million players why have you not paid any attention to it so it very much is a kind of you know these these sort of Big Ticket items require some attention otherwise people are are surprised and concerned that you seem to have missed something key and important um but I think personally we also absolutely have a responsibility to try and highlight these these other um areas of evidence and I think again mobile games is a really interesting one um and it's why I've sort of carried on pursuing it a little bit um since this volume came out because uh mobile games because they are kind of more casual in many ways than the sort of Big Ticket um AAA games and um because of things like micro transactions which is absolutely I should say a really Insidious business model I'm not saying mobile games are are brilliant or kind of fantastic and everyone should be playing them there are clearly problems with them however they don't attract very much attention because of these things these problems have kind of overwhelmed everything else so they don't get very much journalistic
attention they don't get as much attention in scholarship but they also have kind of millions of players playing them um and if we kind of follow along with the journalists and we don't pay attention to these because they're sort of getting less attention as it is then I think we are risking missing what is effectively a large body of evidence that's that's right there so I do think we have some responsibilities to think about you know that can we push Beyond just the big ticket items and can we make sure we're looking at the other types of games as well um so that we're not missing anything that that could be out there yeah it also makes me kind of think about a kind of an inadvertent High culture low culture distinction within like our quote low culture you know I I really think that we should take games very seriously um I think we should take play seriously but you know we like to um kind of not treat games as high culture in our society you're absolutely right like from your comments earlier but I also think that the AAA game is like the high culture of video games and mobile games are I actually think look down upon more and you know I also wonder about the interconnections between things like well a lot of mobile games do have these kind of romance themes or they're like visual novels a lot of them are specifically directed women um or they're cute and you know I do wonder you know if some of the same things are playing out just in our own modern gaming culture that we're also trying to spot when we're talking about the classical world
yeah I think absolutely and I think you know particularly the the kind of um the stereotyping of mobile games as casual and absolutely as played by women means that they're often kind of not taken as seriously and therefore um kind of dismissed um in this kind of writing and in other areas I think yeah you're kind of um the sort of stratification of games as in just kind of some which are worth paying attention to and some which aren't absolutely happens you're dead right and that does affect the kind of scholarship that is happening um and hopefully won't after this but you know it's I think something for us all to be be aware of as this field grows um and as we start looking at these types of material to what extent do you see your work as activism and then to what extent do you see it as observation I feel like when you're trying to make a really good academic article you don't necessarily expect anything to change you just want to make a really good point about it but also because you're dealing with very current things that you can impact theoretically in some way you know do you feel a sense of responsibility towards that or is that not really the point of your work foreign I don't think it's required necessarily so I'm not I don't think it's the case that everyone who wants to come and write academic work on these games should be doing activism but I think certainly from my point of view I would really like to to see this as the beginning of a conversation between kind of us as academics and the people making and playing these games I think um given
the numbers involved I mean I mentioned this earlier but you know an Assassin's Creed game has 10 million plus players um even the mobile games I've mentioned have you know one or two million players each um small games or smaller games sell hundreds of thousands um there are these huge audiences here and there are these people you know making games for them and I think if we can say now you know straight away hey we're here we see you doing this thing um this is great but perhaps there are ways you could be doing it better you know I see this story with about this female character that's a good start but I think there are some sexist elements you know have you thought about this or could we talk about this or even just would you like some ideas of women from the ancient world who you could conclude in this game who are not Cleopatra for example um I think you know if we can start having those conversations and we can make it clear that we are here and ready to take this work seriously as well because I think um some of the things we've been you know you mentioned that people don't always take game seriously and that's absolutely the case I think but those of us writing on these games are taking them seriously as an art form and I think many of us would be really Keen to get involved and kind of speak to developers and say look we are not dismissing this material we think it's great can we work together to do things better and I think certainly that's my perspective of it I would really like to see books like ours and kind of ongoing work especially on gender become part of an ongoing conversation that improves the kind of outputs that we see the kind of games and the kind of narratives they're telling that would be my ideal
absolutely so for me personally um as I said I think everyone necessarily has to but I would like like this to be a kind of a form of activism I would like to see us changing the conversation through work like this because there are so many people involved that it seems to me to be too important not to really nice and then just one kind of I guess this is a nerdy question and then we'll go into I just want some game wrecks from you but so I've been thinking as we talk about this concept of authenticity and what feels authentic to US versus what is authentic and how do we know do you stop my students about curse tablets this week like the ancient world is a really strange place um if you really think you know I mean yes everybody has some human commonalities right like fart jokes remain funny over thousands of years or like people care about their children and people love their dogs like you know there's we have a lot in common with ancient people just by being people but also their culture and way of life like if you put us in ancient Rome now as experts even I don't know that we would do very well so would it be even possible to create a video game that feels authentic and to somebody who's a historical expert is without it just turning people off I don't know um and I think part of that is about it's again it's about what is the point of games I mean if you were trying to create a game of current day life that was really authentic I think it would be a really boring game because we spend a
lot of time day to day you know doing things which are not entertaining right we spend you know if we're lucky eight hours sleeping for example and if your game was going to be really authentic are you going to make the player sit there for eight hours doing nothing well the character sleeps probably not or you know if they have to walk down the block to to buy a supply you don't want them to get there and then find that this shop is out unless there's an exciting plot Point behind this shot being out of whatever it is they're trying to buy so I think you know these kind of gameplay requirements mean that even the best kind of created world based on the ancient world couldn't be completely authentic because it that isn't going to be fun um I think there are also aspects as well of kind of the strangeness of the World which maybe we don't understand well enough to reproduce completely Faithfully as well I mean there are certainly things that we can you know based on the evidence we can put in some curse tablets and so on but whether we necessarily truly understand what people in the ancient world will try to do with these things um such that we can then accurately represent that in a game maybe not I don't know um so I think you know I think Perfection is is unlikely just partly because of the medium and partly just because of our own level of evidence and level of connection with with people in the ancient world that you know it's it's bound to being complete yes it's the the great tragedy of our work uh there is still a lot left for us to
look at and enjoy and it sounds like there are a lot of really interesting games out there so if you're gonna recommend somebody says okay this conversation's intrigued me I want to go play a game about the ancient world what's our a game or games that you would recommend that offer an interesting experience if not a fully authentic one um so I think I've mentioned it briefly before but I think uh Hades is is a very popular among kind of classical Gamers has been very popular but for good reason um Hades takes the kind of very obscure myth of zagrius the son of Persephone um and Hades himself um and turns it into a roguelite which is a game where uh you have to kind of effectively have to repeatedly die but you attempt to level um don't get very far get sent back to the beginning but get further on the next time and each kind of iteration gets you a little bit further and one of the really interesting things about what Hades does with the kind of mythological setting um is that it uses these little repeat iterations to uncover a little bit more of the myth or a slightly different detail each time so you have conversations with characters um and the more times you do this the more the story unfolds in a different way um and so that's doing something really interesting I think with the kind of myths that it's set on that it doesn't give you all of the information straight away and it allows you to kind of explore these stories and get different perspectives on these stories the more you play as well as being a really enjoyable game um so I would definitely but Hades very high up there um there are a whole bunch of very
interesting looking city builders coming out um in the Builders of series uh there was already Builders of Egypt but I've just seen they've just announced Builders of Greece as well as coming out this year um they I cannot vouch for the whole games yet because they're not out yet but from what I've seen for those who really enjoyed the kind of old style city builders these look like a really good new and interesting kind of version brought up to date um that will be well worth playing um and I think also I mean we have mentioned Assassin's Creed a few times and that's that's always a kind of standard option although personally I'm not sure I'd recommend it um I in particularly given actually the industry context behind that game makes me very loath to suggest anyone should give them money at the moment um so I'm gonna say for my kind of third option if you'd like a bit of uh tactical RPG it's not quite an action RPG but it's it's kind of got some tactical play and really interesting story um Expeditions Rome is something I played for work last year and enjoyed a lot more than I thought I would um it puts you male or female so it has a female protagonist option which is great um in the position of kind of a young uh new person again towards the end of the Republic um joining a legion and kind of attempting to uncover the the dangerous situation behind your father's death so kind of preserve your family at the same time as advancing through the legions um and kind of going on various quests
as part of the growing Roman Empire but the story is um interesting I I have colleagues who've complained a lot about the accuracy of this game as we've already said I'm not very interested in accuracy what I do think is is interesting is the kind of stories it builds out of this Roman world and the various characters so I would recommend that one as well I enjoyed it um I played it much more than I needed to for work even which is quite a good kind of sign with these games definitely a good sign um so if people have further questions for you they want to follow your work where can you be found online um probably the easiest places on Twitter as long as that stays alive it maybe give it six months so this this announcement will become completely irrelevant but for the moment you could still find me on Twitter um if you just look for Kate Cook or my handle is at cat X which is k-a-t-e-x-e fantastic okay thank you so much for coming on this podcast and talking to us about your work and your research is just really interesting and I will definitely be taking some of those game recommendations thank you very much for having me Liz all right are we out there uh hopefully by now you know that I can be found anywhere online is beyond Solitaire so please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming
thank you foreign