Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 35:00

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for now or never which if you're not familiar this is the third in the asrium uh trilogy uh there were two before this above and below uh which god when did that come out 2012 at least yeah now we're never which i want to say was around 16 16 17 and then this one in 2022 uh i'm gonna go ahead and say i do enjoy this game but it's not sleeping gods sleeping gods has basically i know they're completely different games but i'm just like i'd rather play that but it's not a sleeping guides review you can go check out both of those but i will say and this is probably where we're gonna disagree maybe i do think this is a culmination of both above and below and near and far merged together i can see that it works together i mean i i very much enjoy this i have a i have a better time with this than i did with near and far because it takes what's what's really good about above and below and what's really good about near and far and combines them so this feels like a a more and it makes sense you know it's been 10 years since above and below and then it's been like six since near and far so he uh he definitely had a lot to work on probably heard the hot you know the pros and the cons of people as the games went on um but man do i get very much elements from near and far especially when you're doing the the chapter stuff

and and then the buildings with above and below so if you like both of those then i would say without a doubt you would like this um that's just my my presumption but it i will i will also say if you like one a lot and you don't like the other you might not enjoy this just because it does have similarities of both of those games um but overall impressions yeah i i do enjoy this this definitely has like an engine building element to it so if like if you can if you can kind of ramp and kind of get get a certain engine for a strategy that you want to go for this game rewards that uh but if if not then it might it might not be if you don't like engine buildings or things like that and this one just doesn't work then yeah you're playing a two-hour game trying to catch up so that's what my one of my points was going to be is it's it's it's hard to catch up in this game i mean like once you get things going it's just like just keeps steam rolling right you know about halfway through that game we played when you had two rows full of buildings and i had two buildings i mean i knew where it was going yeah because because there's just ramping and ramping and and stuff like that right because money goes a long way you even start with a bunch of money uh because you need it to be able to build the buildings uh there is one complaint that i do have and i think

the the run through makes it very apparent but the the order tokens and the tower of miners are huge like because you as a free action you can just complete it and all that all they need are goods so like and it's not that hard hey four or four you know hammers i mean i when you get all those people they're just like there you go that's 12 coins that's massive and it goes like 16 16. the hardest one was the very first one i got needing four crystals but that was 19 coins and while there's no adamant ways to get crystals i mean the crystal meteorite you can get one but that's one turn then you'd have to leave and come back if you want to try and get two in a turn uh just being like oh okay 19 coins boom now i'm going to do a build action which i mean i love the fact that you can just free action get a [ __ ] ton of money instead of having to be like i'm going to spend an action to get money your turn now i'm going to do this i do like the free-flowing nature of the any anytime actions is what he called them that's that's huge it allows you to do a lot of stuff before you even take your turn to maximize uh your limited options um but yeah i i don't know if like if you don't have a money engine or a goods engine uh it's it's gonna be rough because monsters don't give you points yeah i had an

engine and the game hasn't played i've always had the engine of trading in and getting more street and stuff it just i don't know i don't know if it was because i it was costing me more to build when i did build my builder was yeah she she specifically yeah she specifically namal is it i mean having one of her upgrades be buildings cost one fewer coin uh and then getting the building out that building costs one fewer coin i was essentially always ahead by two coins well and that brings up another point because i don't know what the other characters are because these are the ones we've been playing right you know like the buildings are super important oh yeah absolutely that money goes towards deal and it has all the shielding and stuff i think her whole thing is attacking yeah but that the monsters i mean really the only thing you got was more villagers for defeating the monsters yeah you get villagers that was really it for taking all the damage and have to pay six coins to or whatever to heal and stuff i mean it was like everything for her is attacking and the monsters aren't really yeah there and they get you stuff i'm not saying they're worthless yeah they're definitely a lot different because uh near and far was you had the stack if you remember the stack of bandits or monsters that oh okay i killed one now the next one's a little bit stronger but you get victory points or stuff this doesn't have that the monsters are really tough and they always hit uh pretty hard but yeah you either get a bunch of villagers which

i mean killing monsters isn't useless by any means right because you do get the villagers and then if i mean if you can buy which luckily the the really good ones to house them are super cheap uh to be able to get the one with two beds therefore that first thing lets you immediately place three so then that gives you the goods to therefore have the goods to then sell to then have money to buy more buildings yeah it's that's that is the crux of of all of now or never is that you are rebuilding the monument village now here is my biggest complaint and it was more balanced in the in our in the last game we played um but everyone has the same buildings that's not the complaint the complaint is that you shuffle these and how they're laid out is random which is cool it's your own puzzle i mean now or never definitely has a more puzzly aspect than the other two i would say but the fact is that because getting an engine early is so important how your tiles can come out can drastically change how easy your game can be because my very first building was the three cost you know two money generation right and it's like and then just that kind of ramped off into oh man i just could build all these because i now have a money engine and it's like oh where's yours oh directly in the middle you know which i mean i will say no i know they have ways to i'm not saying that you didn't do that i'm just saying if people were like well that sucks you can go and

fix that but you're a step behind at that point because now you have to run to the hermit side to swap it and it's like well someone is just like i'm gonna build and they're they're already one building ahead well another thing that was rough and i know it's just lucky the draw that goes with a lot of the stuff on this game is your character can ignore monsters yeah when you move and then when you get the mountain climbing stuff it's like you had no hindrance right i always i had i was taking two damn anytime i moved four spots and i have more time right so i mean i was taking damage like that's what would hinder me from moving over here so much to move that stuff because i had to go through double mountains right right and all that stuff yeah it's just like and there is stuff in the game that is definitely more mechanics than theme because it's like yeah the moving throughout the board is a puzzle in and of itself which i enjoy like i i as far as i can tell like near above and below it doesn't have like a board at all and near and far does have movement but it wasn't really that bad uh you just have to exert energy to move further but this one yeah you kind it's kind of grid based you move around trying to avoid monsters um and yeah i i i definitely see the despair the despair the disparity between why couldn't they just make this two movement points i know damage every time that's the thing it's like because mountains are rough apparently no but it's like because you know you can exert yourself yeah so force yourself to move

take the damage for exerting yourself not automatic damage from moving through like yeah like and it does you know yeah it does seem like there are paths around mountains and around monsters um that is definitely the uh i but it takes you it's not it's a it's the longer way um maybe uh because she i mean yes she's all about attacking her things are she has heightened movement uh what are your three because i mean she's super e4 okay so she's two three four um and has two mana you have an extra mana and uh i think the vampire knife has been huge because you then you could restore it probably what's what's best for her granted her sword seems to be all about killing things because once the monsters are dead they're dead there's two it's depending on the number of players but once they're gone then that just radically opens up um more people like maybe she's all about going on killing a [ __ ] ton of monsters because you hit really hard that she doesn't hit hard i just have to tank it um and then now you just clear up the the thing you have a swath of villagers because luckily it's not one of those where oh i can't house them so i i have to get rid of them no you can keep them all near you and then like you're like it's almost thematically representing like people following your like like uh was it moses leading the uh people out of egypt it's like i will get you a house just hold on a sec i need to kill all these monsters because then

once you have all those villagers because you're getting a [ __ ] ton of xp to constantly keep cycling then now you can move around a lot more because she has extra movement she already has her buff movement yeah there's just a lot of stuff like the the the fighting the monsters and i ran into that a lot of times like especially the bigger ones because there's the five hit point the five hit one six hit one's yeah seven he'll kill him in two times yeah you're done yeah and it's like so you have you know i i wasted an uh a couple of turns not being able to happen to not finish a fight just right and i mean i had big hits it was just like yeah i'm not sure how i feel about the d4 determining what you do like yeah it's it's very it's very weird because it's like i'm me so i know how i want to attack so the random like oh well i thought i was gonna double fist you but instead i slammed it's like okay that's very once again not thematic it is mechanical in that sense uh because i i really don't mind the searching and taking damage like oh no no no that that's fine that's fine but being like man i really hope i can use my my royal pike i didn't i rolled the three actually it was your royal pipe but it's like i guess i used my flame saber right well and that's not fair and i wish and i know this is a mechanical thing again

but like if you kill them on the last turn and it would kill you too like yeah you lose yes that's like you know i don't know yeah that yeah the fighting monsters is purely they are obstacles it's not meant to be thematic in any way but i will say that every this game doesn't well the standard game itself doesn't feel so i don't know there are a lot of avenues to be able to play the way you want to play but now or never and this is why sleeping gods have has ruined all these games for me now are never near and far and above and below have their theme and that's what you do and near and far you build trade routes and you you go out further and you would get you know you build camps here you build buildings that's gonna get you a bunch of points um and uh and like it's so there is kind of a track in how you're going to play this is kind of like what engine are you going to get to do so uh i think the variety is definitely the the quest like the quest could be huge yeah that was i was having trouble complaining mine in this game because they all required two books yeah like all of them they all required two books to do any of them and i'm just like i'm not getting books you know right i mean i know i could go and pay for books but when you only can move three times in a round i mean so really you can move 18 times in the game right and i know

there are there are a few monsters that do give you books but they're high health and uh and there's definite like um like card engines like you have the one that you can spend a mana to be able to heal six like that's huge the uh vampire knife five damage you restore one mana that's huge uh so it's like you can get pretty cool combos and i do like the mana system but uh it's all like a means to an end which is getting buildings because i think if i even like weapon wise you almost have to have something that does at least six damage consistently if you're going to survive because you can only get two two attacks on most of them a lot of them not i mean some of them are three attacks but it's like you have to have high enough weaponry you know so like yeah that was a five attack and gave me an extra mana but it's like five was not going to help me in any of my battles i had to get right you know higher than you have to have you have to get like ways to heal i mean or you you coat yourself because all of these every single blue thing gives you a um an armor so it's like which isn't that definitely isn't nothing like the fact if you max out on your blue stuff and that's three armor that's that's a lot because even the uh the heaviest one this level nine deals seven which just naturally it will just deal hit you for four

um and so you're at that point you're always going to have higher damage output but yeah that's that's that's a some of them are rough the uh what are they going to say i i mean really my only negative is the fact that these can definitely be set up in a way that someone can kind of start off a little bit better um and at the same time this is also roughly about i mean i don't know how long he says but it's roughly a two-hour game and it's definitely it cannot be fun to be like okay he's getting all those points over there ah [ __ ] i don't know i don't know what i can do to catch up you know and then you just kind of have to sit there because six seasons is it's a long time especially because you're able to do more as the game goes on um now let's talk about the story uh because it i will say i like i like the story system better in this than i do in the other two and well yeah above and below story system was completely completely just very bland there wasn't the outcomes that's true like these these you know when you make a decision it explains because then above and below it's like you choose a you complete a oh you just yeah this one this one near and far at

least went in and explained what happened when you succeeded right and in this one they do the system to where your own character has their own encounters and there's enough out on the board that uh like whenever you go to encounter them it's just like oh man it's gonna be my own personal thing versus in near and far he they kind of had that like your characters could have a known special thing but this is guaranteed going to be your character's story and at the same time you uh like you're always gonna get like a benefit and you don't really step in anyone's way if you take a slot from them you know like there's one right here in it or like near it's like okay i'll go to that one first it's like okay well i can clearly get to another one immediately as well so it doesn't you taking that one it's like oh man now i have to trek all the way over there to try and get a story event uh but it's well written there there definitely has near and far above and below um vibes but so if you like the stories in those two then this is good um brad what's your overall thoughts um are we doing either like rankings because we've played it using the stories and without the stories um definitely the play to play it is with the story because when you do the search tokens you just

flip them and do whatever it says on the back right no and it's not it's like oh man lucky me four coins right someone could be like i really wanted four points it breaks the monotony a little bit let me read a little bit because if there wasn't those parts where we were reading the stories it's just like i'm just gonna do this and yeah yeah i knew this i knew that you know it's like at least that brings a little more liveliness into it um this one i'm still i i like it better than near and far okay not as much as above and below this one sits right right in the middle right in the middle there's things i like about it's not a bad game you know it's it's not my favorite game you know it's just kind of like sits square right in the middle of those two yeah um there's there's there's some good parts to it um there's other parts that just kind of don't settle well with me yeah you kind of have it has the rpg aspect you you spend xp to get upgrades uh or you go spend xp to certain locations to get stuff that's that's a nice little touch makes you feel more unique other than some just generic person that's wandering the land it's just one of those and i know this is a lot of games do this so this isn't a knock on this it's just something i felt during this game was that there's there's more things you need to do than you have time to do does that make sense no absolutely you know like like there was stuff i needed to do you know but there was not enough time

to move places to get them like i said there's 18 you get to move 18 times in this game yeah that's it yeah unless you happen to get something unless you get take a hearer action it's like lucky me right i happen to get that you know so it's like you can't just there were some times where i was you know spinning a form movement to move two spaces to do stuff and that's yeah you know it's like you know there's there's just those kind of things i mean to be fair i very much enjoy those games where it's you know you have a lot to do you can't do it all so because for me and there has been games i can't think of one off top my head but where it's like you can do it all and then you're like why would i want to play this again you know so this one does have you at least me wanting to come back uh the one of the most annoying things is like i do like the fact you have to get villagers to run in the middle villagers they're not specialists who they can't do anything but you could you house them that's kind of neat uh to kind of get them there because that's that's your engine at the end of the day this is an engine building game uh but you have so much going on you have atmospheric story ryan lockett [ __ ] kills it with his his world and his art and his uh i mean his storytelling is campy it's fun it's not like serious sleeping gods is i mean to god the game is amazing but uh so i mean this is without a doubt like the culmination of

you know the two that came before it uh so it's like yeah you i do like that it's like man okay i only get three actions and you're right yeah there's times where it's like you're like okay i'm gonna move my four and then you use and you do something that you need really want to do and then you're like oh man i need to go right there it's one space away i guess i'll waste my three to do that and sometimes you have to it's it's action efficiency but then again there are a lot of random elements like the stupid people that i i think i was the only one that cycled every single time trying i was letting you because because i i was looking for certain things but i didn't have the experience to do it or right like i was going you i was you were you were spending all your experience on upgrades and i'm over here like trudging trying to get two just to wipe it to be like okay please give me a crystal person because i was looking for a crystal too um but once again kind of like other games that you know work replacement things that uh whenever you're fighting and you get to recruit someone but you get an xp you can be like oh and then spend it to then you know increase your odds of getting something but there is a massive pile here i would have i don't know why they didn't make a bag like in near and far as a bag for the specialists this easily should have had a drawstring bag yeah for those now um here's the other thing that might raise race some concern brad i mean brad's been playing games longer than i have

uh and of course we've played these kinds of games but i haven't seen a game where and this isn't trying to be bragging or anything but it might raise some concern for people the point spread was just so drastic and it's like and that's the thing is like i don't feel like i did anything different to have that that spread um it's just like it felt like this was one of those games that thing just happened things just happened to help me more so than they helped you not through any fault of your own the cards i happen to start with the the stories i happened to have gave me the things that i happen to need for like and it's like and it's like you're sitting there and you're like man could i get some coins in my story and i'm over here like oh man goods and coins i'm just gonna sell it all and i'm like okay well i don't feel like i'm playing better i'm not doing anything different it's like i'm over here like [ __ ] idiot he wasted his turns you know i'm not over doing that it's just like lucky me because it's like uh what because it was like oh i didn't even [ __ ] i even forgot to add these points like so that would have been yeah like 125 to [ __ ] 40 at 39 39 which it's like what the [ __ ] did i do to catch 125 uh i don't know i really just think that things just happen to

come my way that a lot of people if you're wanting an engine builder should be more about player if player strength i really think the long term and this isn't the only reason but i'm still going to lay down the fact that the the luck of the draw that you got the mountains and you had the ability to go through monsters because you didn't have to worry about that i was taking two damage every time i tried to move and then i actually caught up where i was having to spin to heal and do all that stuff right well the climbing gear was something i bought don't know i know but i'm just making it when you you it came up and you bought it you know and you were just able to whizz around you exerted yourself right for going from one side to the other side of the board yeah and that's the thing is like this it wasn't clear it just says may ignore mountains so it's like okay it's one shield is that a shield in combat or is that a shield only to ignore mountains is that one mountain or is that all mountains i go through so because it just says may ignore mountains and it's a shield icon i'm like okay and then i i mean because i think that's how it's supposed to be right and i i which makes thematic sense i'm climbing through the mountains but then yeah you're right that and each character can get those kind of engines it's just in this particular run through that happened to work i mean also put it this way because because i had that and you're kind of getting pinged every now and then just because mountains it's like because of just the way that you know my tiles came out and the goods i was able to get i always had money to radically heal myself be like okay i'm

gonna i'm like i'm exert myself seven times to bolt across the land which i do like that you can do like you're not but then it's like okay now i made it there okay i'm gonna get this you know eight point you know quest card uh oh it costs four health uh for me to use that okay anyway i'm gonna do that and then now i have so much money so i'm gonna heal myself which is cool like that's cool that that can happen but it's not cool when i didn't do anything to earn that so it's just you're sitting there while one person is raking it in the other one's like how long is this game yeah i still think it would have been better to leave the option on the player and make this like a a two movement space mm-hmm like like a lot of terrain games do you know yeah into the space it's two movement that way okay that stopped me or if i if i choose to go further then i take then it takes the damage you know yeah that would make it more gameplay so you it's not just like an automatic right oh you're [ __ ] i would move this spot it has the little squig line right damage yeah i know yeah there's a i will also say that i usually never bring this up but this is a very weird setup like it it's relatively long um to actually set up the game grant at least the game takes about as long to play and there's a double-sided board uh we haven't tried the underground method the underground board in standard mode rules um so that's there that that looks like it's like yeah it's underground so once

again above and below that he really must have because i didn't know anything about this i just knew he was making a third one and i'm like pre-order immediately um and i didn't even know it had like i i was like well maybe he doesn't have a story thing because i i do and but of course he does there's six total chapters i refuse to play this as a campaign because at least he learned and it's six chapters but absolutely not because if uh which i to be to be fair it's like um after the uh where is that let's end the game i'm looking for that's what i was going to ask because with such a point disparity like how does that change like what would there be to be like and then again players earn a player with a positive reputation earns oh [ __ ] i even forgot about my reproduction points oh yeah i didn't add my reputation either so i gave me one i don't know you got you got two i got 41. you got 41. so what was i at 125 because i thought it's 13 and then 10 there so it's one so i was at 125 plus 3 128 131 uh okay keep track of each player's victory points yep the player with the highest total reputation combined from all six gains an additional 25.

uh the player with the highest total victory points is the campaign winner yeah absolutely yeah so it's like so i would have been like if we do if we were doing a full campaign i just would have been completely [ __ ] then yeah because i would have been down by 90 points right off the bat from chapter one yeah not saying well i mean to be fair if i'm able to get 131 points that's not saying you can't in the very next one but i despise that as a campaign hey plen play near and far was the exact same way play 10 games and then out of your score because then it's no longer about the story that's what his games do so well at you want to go and you know explore you want to have encounters and stuff like that but then near and far turned into trade routes like it became cutthroat it's like oh but there's a quest time i'm gonna [ __ ] about that quest okay get the tents yes i'm gonna go get the tents i'm in this game so i can ramp up all these artifacts i need to buy and uh so i can have the most points because that's all that matters at the end this is that it's definitely shorter and because when whenever we did the discussion not not you and i but when i did the discussion for near and far i was like i don't like it we talked about it for a while that like oh i don't like near and far then i played it again as just a standalone kind of game with the story stuff and i was like oh no this is amazing it's the campaign it's the horrible monotony of the campaign so whenever i saw this sheet i was like hell no will i ever do that now once again combination of both if you

like niren far's campaign then perfect this will be amazing for you because then you just add up your scores and at least what's kind of neat is he has like four so you can have four games going that's that's smart that's a nice touch overall this game i like it but i can very very much see if i was like i was if i was in your situation i'd be [ __ ] miserable like because it's like what the [ __ ] like why am i struggling so hard and it's like i'm i'm a robot cat apparently i'm god and i hover through the land taking no damage uh and i'm rich i'm actually a coin machine so we just poop out and poop out money so yeah this one has has some disparity with randomness uh but if you're playing it casual and you're just kind of like oh okay you know let's just do the the story stuff let's just pick a chapter um because it definitely doesn't seem like they connect there is technically a chapter two and three and four and all that but it's not like you're really having an overarching narrative because you have your introduction and then depending on where you go you just have an encounter there's no i think it's just a way to change it so that the story individual stories are different like on b is going to be different you know for each person yeah it's just yeah because there's no conclusion it's not like oh well this is what happened to you now

next time in chapter two so uh luckily he also removed keywords and things like that which i enjoy in near and far that they're there but it's like okay let's write all that down and be a little odd and kind of tedious uh i got really i got really nothing else to talk about i'm good so on uh on a scale of one to ten um what are you going to give it all right so i can't remember what i did for near and far we didn't discuss that well i would give near and far probably a four oh wow okay okay and above and below was probably a seven okay for me give or take you know right around there yeah i'm gonna put this game to me is math yeah it's just a game to me now if i was on that side maybe it'd be different but uh i'm just going to give it a five right in the middle okay just i mean you know i like the story but you know the story is better than above and below but it's just it just didn't click with me yeah i know it will for other people i'm just this yeah yeah totally right you know the times we've played this it's just been like i just felt like i was one step behind constantly no you know yeah totally totally get that yeah because even though i mean ryan's a super awesome guy he's i mean he he does amazing job with his games uh i'm not gonna go in and be like well he's the best person ever he makes the best games no i do enjoy this game it it does click for me it's worth the engine building at least in my experience it's just happened to work

out uh because at first like whenever we very first played i was like what the hell do i even do like where do i even start and then i was like oh it's about villagers in the buildings how weird that's what it literally told us about so above and both now above and below above and below it's been a while since i played it above below would be about a seven near and far gets about an eight uh this one it's closer than near and far than it is above and below i think i'd probably put it at an eight as well and that might actually shift you know that i think about it i think above and below would be a six near and far would be a seven this would be an eight uh they just kind of they've gotten better for me over time um yeah that feels about right i'm gonna keep this as an eight and i'll drop the other ones down uh a point because they whenever we were sitting there doing everything i'm like this is this is both those games they're like without a doubt so uh that's it everyone that's our thoughts on now or never let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other

than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you

Progress saved