Glorious Guilds of Buttonville: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Brian and I are doing a discussion over the glorious Guilds of Button Wood. This is definitely a game that I frequent on my channel. It's this is right up our alley. Games that we talk about. Uh No, this is a game that Brad [ __ ] brought over on on one of our game days.
2026 game.
It's a 2026 game and you know, we got to play as many of those as possible to have a well-rounded final year uh you know, list that we do. And I think I while we were originally playing this, I was I asked you I'm like, where the [ __ ] do you find these games? Cuz never in a million years would I ever come across this. Come across it, let alone buy it, let alone play it.
I do a lot of retail buying though. Like
That's true.
You know, you do more crowdfunding.
Yeah.
I do more of this and then I also with podcasts and
That's yeah.
You know, I play have that other group and then talked about it, you know.
Yeah. It's amazing that I get as many games played as I do with how little I actually pay attention to.
Right.
Um I mean, I watch a lot of YouTube. That's where I get And by a lot, I don't even really watch a lot of board game YouTube anymore. Uh all that being said, uh you're probably going to hear Brad compare this to a another game the entire review that I haven't played, but this this has this a similar Something with my eye. Uh a similar vibe to the only game I can compare it to, which would be like Elysium.
Yeah.
Which has just take different different sets of of guilds or gods or whatever it might be. Smash them all up into a deck and then you are playing sets. It's a set collection game at its core and it's not bad. I didn't hate it.
Yeah.
Um I don't think I would ever be super keen on playing it again. Uh which doesn't which doesn't [clears throat] mean it's bad. It's just that I think this is for a level of gamers this kind of super pretentious, but that is at a a threshold of of just where I'm not at.
Right.
Uh it's very straightforward and go with the motions. This is a very good like a really good gateway game to the style of games. You're not going to be overwhelmed by the amount of combinations. Uh you have a ton of combinations of whatever kind of set you want to try and go for and there's a decent variety, but I just like a little more meat to it.
Mhm.
Uh so Brian, what do you think of the glorious uh guilds of of Button Bill?
All right. Well, here's going to be my first comparison, right? So, if you have ever played Thunderworks Games game uh uh Citizens of the Spark, this that's the closest game to this. Like um and if I hadn't played that game prior to this, I would like this even better than I do right now because I like I mean this is an interesting style with your set collecting and your sets and all that stuff.
Mhm.
Citizens of the Spark though, I played it first and it is a much better, more game-ery,
[snorts]
more replayable version of this game. You know, this is like this is like, you know, grade school and Citizens of the Spark is like high school. You know, like like this is not saying anything bad about this cuz this is very good intro,
[clears throat]
you know, gateway game like you're saying, but Citizens of the Spark is not super complex by any means. I'm not meaning it's like a high-level deal, but it's just got a lot more interaction.
Yeah.
Um because, you know, you're making your sets like this, but when you play a card or you you play you can add to the sets you have instead of only having one of each.
Yeah.
And stuff. And then you have an action phase where you can do the action. You set the card up here, you take an action. You're going to lose that card out of your set
Mhm.
when you do it, but then everybody else around the table has the option to spend one of their cards if they if they have one to do that exact same action.
Right.
It's just a better game.
This one This one's still solid. I mean, with the replayability and the very It has its place. Right. I think I was I was just looking at Citizens of the Spark artwork. And while it is very good artwork, I I vibe with this one a lot.
Yeah, see I like Citizens artwork better.
Um but I also like Ghibli and like that that type of more anime cartoony style, which this gives off that vibe. But yeah, the set collection is is fine. I think it would have been cooler cuz there were there were sets that just had a threshold to meet. If this is three or higher, do this. But it was still only do this one thing.
Right. But you also want to get
You want to get more just for the points, but I I think I would have liked it more if if X is three or higher, you get to like the steal card for the hypnotist. If X is three or higher, steal a card from an existing set uh set of the player. So, no matter how many you have, I'm only stealing one card.
Right.
So, you're only playing more just for the more points, whereas I would much rather prefer oh, if I get seven, I get to steal more cards.
Right.
Um Citizens of the Spark is also three is also three. Like if you have three versions of it, that's where it caps the card ability.
Oh, gotcha.
But you're going to be spending those cards. You can keep adding to them and stuff. And it also has a set collection amount
Right.
as well.
Yeah.
So, I mean it it has that threshold, too. So, that's why I guess I didn't mind it as much because I knew I was trying to
Yeah, cuz I mean it's not bad. Like you want to do it because if you get seven of a set, you get 17 points, which is not nothing.
Now, you don't want more than seven because there's that little little where you get
gets you nothing.
at the same time, I mean, I kind of like the fact that okay, there are there are some cards, this is a a neat aspect of the game, that you kind of really don't want a bunch of them. Alacarte, the count, for example, you actually Yeah, you can have more of him and it's just going to reveal more cards, but
It might help your opponent.
Uh it might help your opponent or I mean it it should help you cuz then you reveal more and ideally you would get more cards for a set. But every time we've played him, it's been I'm going to play one card cuz there's three or four cards out there, so I'm just going to grab this set already. So, there are some cards that do benefit from not having that many out. And then I also like the fact that you're not once you play a set, it's not okay, that's over. I can take an Alacarte one and then play it to do the whole thing of oh, let's reveal one card, take one set, and then I just nix that one. I was using it just for the ability. Um and there's a decent amount of variety of cards. There are some that are actions that you get to do every single turn. There's some that are end of game scoring.
I think this game obviously these all these kinds of games will always benefit from more.
It's for sure. The one thing this does kind of different is I'll just pull this. So, [snorts] every game you play you have you have uh three to four you have to pull from this.
Oh, from yellow?
for a two-player game you have to get do three of these or four if it's three or four, yes.
Okay.
And then it's one from each other color.
Oh, got you. Okay.
not So, that kind of cuts down a little bit on the variety, yeah.
Where this that doesn't belong in that other other game, you randomly just I mean, you just can pick any of them and stuff.
Yeah, that is a little bit cuz I didn't know that, yeah. Uh because there [clears throat] are there are some that have to do with just a bunch of buttons. Hey, spend spend three buttons, take another turn, you know, again X buttons, and uh if you do this, gain a bunch of buttons, and if you're kind of limited on you have to have three yellows or four yellows and then one blue and one purple, one pink, one red. It's And it's like, "Oh, I wish I had a little bit more variety."
Right. The yellow ones on the left that they're Those are called citizens. Then the purple are tradespeople. Greens were magicians. The blues [snorts] were artists. The pinks were automatons. And then uh nobles. So, he was a noble. So, it's the box color is what
Got it.
Those are the the the
Yeah, I mean, the theme is literally non-existent.
No, and and same with citizens.
Yeah, it's just you have to give it something.
sets. You're doing
Yeah. It's cute, I think. Funny enough, these kinds of games, I it for this one, it kind of felt that the interaction was maybe it was just cuz we just played this at two, but it almost feels a little forced. I almost feel like this game needs to be more of the combo nature, not I'm going to steal half your buttons. I'm going to steal your sets. It's like, "Okay, [ __ ] you." Yeah. That's annoying. Uh so, our first game that we played uh of this, I enjoyed a lot more than the one we just played.
Cuz you won it.
Uh
no, because uh well, yeah, everyone everyone enjoys games that they win.
the first one. I won the second one.
Um no, because all the interaction was literally again just capped on on on if you had three or more. Uh you just get to do one thing. So, all the better cards were the ones that oh, reveal X amount of cards and add them to your sets. We gain X money, pay X money to do more buttons. Uh or to do more buttons to do more turns.
Right.
All [snorts] the ones that were interactions of oh, each other player puts a card from their hand, you take two cards. I didn't feel were actually that good. Or the one that steals half the buttons. Well,
We didn't need to run out of head buttons this game.
Yeah, so it becomes a a dead a dead set.
just getting a set for points. So, that's the only reason
Exactly. And I find games like that trivial. It's oh, I'm playing five sets just for 10 points. Okay, that's a waste of my time to play games like that. Let's just not do that and just say if we just got an arbitrary amount of points. Uh instead of cuz that's I mean, like you said earlier this game kind of has a feeling of going through the motions.
[snorts]
So, uh And and both games had that element of even with the interaction cards, none of us did any of the cards that really did an interaction. If you did, it was so inconsequential it shouldn't have even been in the game.
Right.
Cuz what does me stealing one card from you do? Nothing.
I guess if if I've been hogging some and I needed another you needed another one. I mean, because you had cards that let you add stuff to your sets out of your hand cuz there was some that were in there that let you take cards from your hand and put them in your sets. I mean, if you just needed to get to that seven.
Yeah, but all that does if you had like if I was able to take your fortune teller, you had seven there and let's say I needed that one, it's a four-point swing and that means I would have to spend two turns playing one set to steal one card to then on my next turn play the hat card that lets me put it into a set. That feels a whole lot of effort for four points.
Right. And I think this one is it's meant to be a family game. A family Oh, yeah. It's an 8+. Is all it is. Like so they probably because of that aren't making it too mean.
Cuz yeah, I'm going to steal half of your buttons.
Right.
like I'm going to steal one of your cards. It's not like you're wrecking their side.
Cuz then you'd have kids, you know,
Yeah. Kids throwing things at each other.
That's And then that's why you don't have kids. Cuz then it's like Ooh. Ooh. You're going to get it when I drink.
So, I mean, yeah, for sure. And that's why these This is one reason why I typically don't cover games like this on my channel cuz people are going to be in the comments be like, "Um well, this is great for me and my 7-year-old." Oh, yeah. I mean, I don't have kids. So, I'm just talking about what I liked and disliked about the game. So, yeah. But apparently Citizens of the Spark is the greatest game ever made. Brad wins. Stop talking about it every time. I'm like, "I'm going to play Navoli the Miner." Well, in Citizens of the Spark
mean, it is. And literally this is like a such dumbed-down version of that game. Like
And then I'm going to play Citizens of the Spark be like, "Dude, they're the same game."
Well, no. They're not the same game.
What are you What are you talking about? They're like they're the
Because the symbols actually mean stuff on that. They I don't understand the symbols on what they were using, I guess, unless there's something they're planning on adding to it down the road or something. But
This would be such a weird game to pop expansions for.
some That's what I'm saying. It's like I you know, Citizens or I have Citizens at a nine. Yeah. You know, so Yeah, you all gave it a nine.
the land at like a 10.
I didn't do that. I didn't do that. I gave it a 10. We never did do a talk on that one, did we?
Yeah, we did.
Like at the like at the very, very end.
Mhm? Yeah.
Cuz I don't remember what I gave it then.
I don't remember either. I I do these reviews and then forget about them immediately. Uh so, yeah. It's It's a cute game. I think this is a solid one for This is a solid gateway one cuz I do not think it's going to be complicated at all.
No. Not at all.
Even with cuz we read through all the different decks that we hadn't touched and there wasn't a single one that was like, "Wow, that one's really Oh, that'd be cool if it was in here."
Right.
Uh it had enough to be to be like, "Oh, you know, let's try this set." But then again, you're kind of restricted on the color combos. Which is disappointing. But yeah, it is a game. I like the art.
Yeah. Um and I also like this first player marker cuz it's interesting.
that as a component to a game to how I how to cut.
Yeah.
It's like take X cards and put you know, like play with every cards.
count them all out or put them in evenish evenish halves. But this one is number players, you just whoop.
Yeah. And then that's that's that's kind of a cute little game.
kept Cuz I kept looking for it. I was like, is that a standee? Cuz it has that real It has this little But I think that's meant for just the slide over and I was I kept I was like, did they not give me this [ __ ] standee?
It's Yeah, it's pretty cool. So, Brad, what are you going to give this on a scale of one to 10?
I will give this a six.
A six?
Um because it does have its place and it's not bad. It's just I know there's a game very similar that's much better. Like I said, I gave it a nine citizens. So, so uh I I mean, this that this doesn't even come close to citizens as far as what it does. It's just a different
Nothing comes close to citizens.
This is just It's number one game.
No.
Next top 100.
the style of game it is because But yeah, uh But yeah,
Citizens is not in your top 50.
It's trash.
Um I don't know where it is.
I don't even know if it was on your top 100 last year.
played it a whole lot until this this year. So.
Uh yeah, I mean I'm a little bit lower. I'd probably put this at a five. I think this one is perfectly fine. Uh I think it's average for I guess. I mean there's not I mean there are these style games where you just have a bunch of different decks. Uh I mean I mentioned Elysium Citizens, obviously. And what was the other one that I just kept kind of thinking, mainly cuz of that order? Um What was that space-based one? The fantasy space-based.
Space-based?
The fantasy space-based, where it just had a bunch of different sets of
Oh, uh Valeria?
Yeah, Valeria. That I was also getting that kind of vibe of just a bunch of different cards that you can shuffle into a deck. And uh that that increases the variety. Uh still totally different games, but that was kind of the vibe I was getting. I think I think a lot of people I mean I don't know. This is such a weird title and niche game. I would never have expected this was the kind of game that was coming out of this box.
Right. And even says the tagline at the bottom.
A simple game of glorious combinations.
There really wasn't a ton of combinations.
No, not really.
I mean, you know,
No, I mean after just playing again, totally different spectrum, but Dark Pact and Recall, those have glorious combinations. This one is you're you don't really have combinations cuz you only get to play one set a turn.
Right.
Um
I was looking to see if these guys had done any any other games because um
Cuz again, there were some moments of oh, take a card and add it to your an existing set. It'd be neat if if you did that, you also popped out ability. That would be a combo.
Right. Um But yeah, so Glorious Guilds button builder is a promo pack.
I saw that.
Um Let's see. Oh. His His name isn't even on there.
Christian Kudahl and Eric Anderson Sunden.
Christian Kudahl did Mind Bug.
No way.
Yeah, he's he's the Mind Bug guy.
See, that game has
Agent Avenue, Mind Bug. He has all the Mind Bugs under his deal. And then the other guy, Eric Anderson, he did all the silly games, like Whirling Witchcraft, Hungry Monkey.
Okay.
Yeah, so
He might be the main designer of this.
I don't know, but yeah, Christian Christian Kudahl was the Mind Bug dude, so
Well, stick to Mind Bug. I need to look at designers more cuz I have everything for Mind Bug and I really like Mind Bug a lot.
Yeah.
Um Again, this is just Ravensburger. This is a This is a kid/family game.
I know. I When I saw Ravensburger, I'm like, don't they make games for babies?
and some like they do like, you know,
What's that other really that German one? Haba. Haba Yeah, they're kind of like the the Haba version as well.
Yeah.
Uh again, it's it's perfectly fine. It's not bad. I wasn't miserable the entire time playing it.
And it's fast, so
And it is pretty fast. Uh how long does it say on the box?
It doesn't.
Uh so So, I guess we don't know what they were trying to tell us.
Wow. So, they didn't want to You know what? I'd rather not be there than it's than it lie to me.
Yeah. It probably doesn't even say on the bottom, but yeah.
I mean, it's it took us what? 20 minutes to play?
I mean, I wouldn't expect it to be
30 minutes. 30 minutes, yeah. And that's like with setup and teardown, too. It's It's very, very simple. And I mean, I'm assuming it's also a cheap game.
Uh I think I only paid like 30, I think, for it. It wasn't bad.
Yeah. So, kind of like what you were saying, it it has its place and uh our its place is just not for
Right.
Not for us.
Yep.
Anyway.
You got anything else?
Nope.
Cool. Well, that's our thoughts on Glorious Skills of Button Ville. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.