Until Proven Guilty: The Starry Sky Necklace | Playthrough
Transcript
hello hi everyone ra you just off screen do you think something's changed since last stream I might have zoomed it in actually let me Zoom let me Zoom back out a bit it was on 117 there we go I've been filming the top turn so I also need to do let me come out I need to make us a bit louder which is that one and make us a bit less red should be that one hi everyone hey James how's it going we are going to be playing today until proven guilty which seems very much to be Phoenix right the card game board game which I love Phoenix Right R played a bit of Phoenix Right you've played about two cases haven't your AG yeah if you enjoyed Phoenix right it's all right we must play more which is like if you buy advertising for a completely different thing but you can buy the Phoenix R Collection on Steam and you get like I think there's at least is there like five Phoenix Right games in it or something at least three there's a loads and each of those got loads of cases it's amazing it's funny it's logical sometimes but we are going to be playing
until proving guilty and see how we get on so you do need it say an app for this it's a a web a web app you need a website pop that in the middle for when we need it uh so I've got it open and basically that's what we've been told so far is it that like open the app don't open any envelopes or anything yet and probably just have a load of Story Time with r really so I guess we need story Sky necklace new game and this is just going to like get our results do we need we need to just flip the first card then and this this is where we go when we've got answers yeah you yeah so you reveal a try to reveal the first card reveal a card make it sure it's the same number was the trial card showed on the web app accusation card number one well we haven't read the story yet have we is there a little starting story or no not really I think this is the start of our trial and then we choose any evidence that we think will support our case and then the app will tell us what to do go on then re get us going I'm mind doing both people yeah congratulations Mr mustakas today's process was quite complicated but you managed to surprise everyone once again
thank you Peter but it was your idea to question the warehouse keeper who knows it might be time to assign you a case I have to admit that your help today was really valuable anything else in the agenda no we're done for the day we don't have any more hearings go home I'll settle the paperwork and as for my first case I'm ready Mr mustach I assure you read the next card and open envelope a and open envelope a should we do envelope a first Here Comes envelope a I think Peter looks like you when you've got your glasses on insulting is it so here is a load of characters and documents and things trial one there is such a mess in this bag prze today's case documents for some reason we also brought along the documents for a murder case yet to be dealt with the accused name is hi I am heroni sampath I'm looking for Mr mustakas good evening I was just thinking about your case strange though I remember that we were supposed to deal with it soon but flipping through the schedule I can't seem to find any trace of it could it be that something is hiding it from my sight oh man here it is the heroni sth murder trial it starts in 5 minutes no way Mr must gets back in time I read something about it I think councelor what's going on is there a problem no
ma'am no problem at all mustak has entrusted the case to me after a thorough explanation today I will take care of your case come let's enter the courtroom please have a seat here perfect now I just need to review some details of the case allow me a few moments to concentrate discard evidence 28 and 31 B so maybe we should have gone through the I don't think you can really see anything on them I don't know if we were ever supposed to have them it's Mr must' agenda and a Donuts receipt oh how much did the donuts cost 325 for a green donut so we've got an envelope one Nick mustaka character your boss a successful defense attorney on these is just like the envelope they came out of on the other side got Peter Howard you an assistant of the mustus law firm obsessed with detective stories who sampath archaeologist arrived in the USA on August 16th as a representative of the most important Museum in Sri Lanka charged with murder charges against murder of Gregory star found with her hands covered in star's blood she was locked in the house and promptly arrested upon the arrival of the police she was searched nothing was found on her of relevance to the case or notes the best detectives know that there is always a more recent Will somewhere the kind Butler always hides something never forget to check the wines for presence of poison if someone has an identical twin rest assured that there has been a switch at some point often the solution to the crime lies in our pockets and diamonds when examined often turn out to be worthless
copies so that's all of our stuff so far Jack yeah it's guess who but like like what they do in a courtroom it's courtroom guess who Rich's medalist for her birthday it's her birthday today it is my birthday which is 40 I'm not 40 20 34 34 so are we allowed to I I assume we're allowed to go through all of this stuff when when we found it I would imagine we can open the evidence and then have a little look at them and then they're all still there even when you've use them for another trial card unless you're told to get rid when you're told to take an open an envelope take open it and take out the contents read the newly drawn evidence cards and put them visible to
everyone pull the story through to the final trial card and count the number of jurors we got to go all the way through all of the cases it's one big case in it is it yeah it's oneing the whole thing uh no it's one thing oh it's one like whole case I thought it was multiple cases one thing oh okay thanks everyone so we just keep going through the envelope B this is envelope B yeah so we've got Gregory star the victim entrepreneur and contributor for the archaeological section at Art life last will in Testament Gregory star's considerable Fortune will be divided into three portions the first will go to charity and the rest will be evenly split between his grandchildren Robert and Ringo insurance documents Mr star has taken out an insurance policy for his Starry Sky necklace in the event of theft he will receive millions in reimbursement examination of Heron's car car rented on the 16th of August say what date it is today that's when she arrived in the USA it was parked in the driveway contained a suitcase a return flight ticket to Columbo Sri Lanka and a box are containing an ancient necklace adorned with sapphires an expert identified it as a Starry Sky neckace neace certificates of authenticity for the necklace it is authentic but its restoration was once again disrespectful Gregory should have learned something from last time last time
interesting the story Sky necklace commissioned in the second half of the 9th century by a king of the lambuk Dynasty made of gold painted with enamel and adorned with sapphires the history of the necklace isn't it beautiful the painting depicts the three daughters of the ancient ient King of the Lamb lambuk Dynasty who he loved above all else it is from here that my dream of completing the entire collection of their jewelry was born prosecutor Norman disdain one of the Old Guard he's a tough guy he's not going to make it easy for you he building up our Clues and characters and stuff this we we keep going through the caruse right until it tell until it asks us to do something do you think yeah these these are just the numbers on the cards aren't they so I thought it's at some point you might if if you like this and you think you'd like to get it for yourselves you might want to stop watching at some point because this I thought there were several things in this for some reason and that you would play through like Phoenix right that there's an overarching story but we do little bits but no this is this is the one thing now good job we didn't try it before now I know go on then ra back to you I declare the hearing open Council are you ready I of course I was just finishing reading some documents if the prosecutor is kind enough to grant me another 5 minutes obviously not members of the court I don't want to waste your time when the case is so clear the murder was committed by Mrs sampath I rely on this simple
incontrovertible fact no one else had any interest in killing poor Gregory star damn it I'll retrieve the remaining documents as soon as I have a moment right now I need to find something to counter argue so I don't think we're allowed to flip it are we when does it say
like I think I think it will tell us at some point like go go into the app and um and find things right
maybe it's like in one of the envelopes there'll be like accusation card number one like when we open envelop C or something cuz it's not told us to do anything yet has it okay I guess we keep going until it tells us not to he's just thinking he's just thinking to himself I've got to i' got to find something to counter
argue okay go ah the best mystery writers have taught us the murder of an elderly entrepreneur can only have the motive of inheritance Gregory star owned a considerable fortune and excuse me counselor but I must interrupt your prattling yes there was a will however the two individuals you mentioned have been living outside the United States for years attending prestigious European universities we are well aware that the person who committed the murder was actually a a guest at Mr Star's house that
evening besides the servants and Mrs sth Mrs es the port and Mr Randy McMillan were also at Mr stars for dinner that evening among all of them however only Mrs sapath had a motive her desire was to take Gregory stars star Sky necklace back to her Homeland at any cost but despite a generous offer she couldn't convince him to sell it so Mrs sth had to resort to murder to steal the necklace which was later found in her car it can't have happened like that I'll prove it prosecutor disdain you accuse Mrs sampath of killing Mr Gregory star to rub him of his Starry Sky necklace indeed that's the case but you've told us that the necklace was found in sampath's car how is that possible we know that after the murder Mrs sampath was locked in the house she couldn't have taken the ne to her car counselor I'm about to give you an important lesson about our profession listen to me carefully members of the court in a tribunal the only thing that really matters is evidence with have a signed document from the police confirming that the star Sky necklace was found in Mrs sampath's car if you believe that this does not imply your client's guilt it is up to you to provide an alternative explanation okay calm down we've established it it's not possible for Mrs S to to have left the house and taken the necklace to her car however the police report says that a necklace was there there has to be an explanation hey Mike hey Dereck how's it
going why is it going to tell us open another thing uh on the back of this envelope spoilers okay not just Story Time with ra birthday Story Time with ra so she's doing several characters for us the only explanation is this that there are three star Sky necklaces in fact as seen as in the painting each of the King's Daughters is wearing one we all know that the Ancient King had three identical necklaces made sth brought the first one from Mrs Port last year and the second one from McMillan a few days before the murder Mr disdain so you must know that the necklace was found in the car was McMillan's and sth was just taking it back home I am very well prepared contrary to what you seem to be sir but don't worry we will we will conclude the trial quickly but we're discarding evidence that we haven't used this feel very strange I don't think we're playing this right I think we have to choose the evidence and we type it in type it in there and then when it's red
look yeah that is card number one card oh okay sorry we're playing this completely wrong let's go back I did think it's weird that we haven't been asked a question yet I did say so what does it mean then when you see him do a red light so at the bottom of the card okay I didn't hear the red line but at the bottom of the card before you flip it over one player takes the trial deck and reads the current card making sure the same number as the trial card is shown in the app Don't reveal the back of the card as a group we choose an Evidence card that they think will best count to the current trial card so like oh how do you know that other people are going to have a problem with him or have got motive oh well the last will in Testament says he's got two grandchildren so they probably killed him so then you type in the app oh evidence for focus on highlighted sentence and that's what you're trying to prove okay so but what what were we trying to prove oh that something is hiding from my sight in number one something yeah probably he supposed to put his agenda in right let me give it a
go oh it's that the dut receipt is in the way oh oh probably one of these is it this was in the first charges against a ro sth
wherever we're supposed to deal with your case but I can't find anything any trace of it oh so are they the traces like the I supposed to ask
him put in here oh I think it's his notes are in the way so like on the on the thing at the beginning we can't see her we can't see her appointment cuz his notes are in way I think is what it's going to tell us get back to the to put this on so his notes would be 26 so if we get those out of the way mrus won't take this well flip jur one flip one J on their innocent side not even in the trial yet this is like your lives or somewh flip the trial card and read the back okay so then for two we were supposed to say that no one else had any interest in killing poor Gregory's door well hang on a minute the will has got two grandchildren yep there we go I mean GL you're here ra rewind all that time to when was like I think we need to choose an Evidence and that didn't say get rid of that three she had to resort to murder to steal the necklace which was found in her car and then we say that she was locked we say that she was locked inside she couldn't have gone to the car because she was locked inside yeah didn't say get rid of evidence until it says go
away I'm catching up now so for the one that we're on now it's saying if you believe we have a signed document that says the star Sky necklace was found in her core if you believe this does not imply her guilt we need an alternative explanation so trying to kep the evidence up on there well what about this thing that says that it's the third time you should have learned from last time oh yeah it's been restored last time I I don't know as if it's a fake or something it says certificate of authenticity for the third necklace don't know well all three of these are wearing the necklace oh like he's got an extra necklace say like 25 then the history of the necklace yeah exactly it was from this painting that excuse me counselor now I think about it are you sure you have read all the documents for this trial oh and that that's to him yeah and then with the only explanation is there are two there are there are three necklaces so if she stole one it's not the one over in
here so now open envelopes see so we know from the necklace the found in the car was mcmillon and sapath was just taking it back home so we get rid of we don't need the car anymore or that was that painting 25 yeah we don't need the car or the painting and then open envelope see so that was that's this stuff I've got here so we' have got Esther Port head of the archaological section at artlife and longtime collaborator with Gregory star former owner of the first star Sky necklace broken window this was the second time the window of the studio had been broken about a month ago Mr star spotted the Breakin but it was established that no one had entered the house Mr star reacted with some discomfort but in the end he merely replaced the glass sales register for August in this Ledger Gregory store noted the sales of the jewelry he kept at home he took care of everything himself from bargaining to shipping if we can get anything from that not yet not port or anything there's something crossed out for 300 bucks Randy McMillan gemologist and wine maker friend and collaborator of Gregory star former owner of the second star Sky necklace the life of Gregory star Gregory Star had been a steady contributor to the archaeological section at Art life he made his fortune through unscrupulous trading of ancient jewelry but in recent years his
reputation have been declining due to his increasingly excessive and extravagant Behavior the discovery of the third Starry Sky necklace brought him back into the Limelight once again detail of the crime scene that glass is on top of the choke outline broken after has it been broken after it oh it gets flipping of the juror thank you the butler wait a minute what advice have we been given about the butler the kind Butler always hides something Mr Alfred Trey Mr star's employee for more than 20 years death report for Gregory star his death occurred on August the 19th at 11:15 p.m. at as P the testimonies the autopsy conss confirms the time of death caused by a single close-range stab wound to the chest death was practically
instantaneous deposition of the butler after the dinner after dinner Mr star asked everyone to join him in his study because he wanted to show them how the glossy enamel used during the restoration work made the necklace glow in Starlight alone McMillan preceded Mrs port and Mrs sampath who closed the door behind them star seated his guests in the dark okay what a strange thing to do it wants to show it was glowing the idea of a dinner meeting of all the former owners of the star Sky necklaces came from Mrs sth herself reconstructing the entire collection was her Obsession she hoped that Mr McMillan and Mrs Port could persuade Gregory star to s his necklace Mr star however refused to give into her pressure which led to her despair with the Good Will of the defense Mrs sampath is the only person who is intent on resting star's necklace disdain won't give me a break until I find another threat to the necklace so well surely somebody would steal it he's taking out insurance
although I don't know what I mean Esther used to have one Randy used to have one they don't have one anymore I wouldn't I wouldn't necessarily say the but the butler but Mrs Port was there I don't know they were they were both there well maybe he knew there was a the threat is is that somebody might steal it so we could get insurance I don't know yeah what why would he suddenly take out insurance on it 17th just after it was authenticated I suppose you would it's worth millions it's
not oh what about it says a second time that the window had been smashed there've been a break in the window's been yeah the window's been smashed before do you think we say
that oh yep uh here we go excellent counselor disdain would like to only talk about me we need to try to widen the field to other possible culprits cuz the window's been smashed before someone else becomes innocent and then we read the back of the
card nearly everyone's thinking innoc we just win then we have to wait till the end yeah we got get to the end I think I bring this fact to your attention prosecutor Stars Butler informed is about a broken window out a month before the crime when Mrs sth had not yet arrived in the United States someone attempted to break into star's study where the next neckace was kept to steal it counselor it's obvious that others might be interested in the necklace however you cannot deny the strong interest bordering on Obsession that Mrs sampath had for it as I've already mentioned we must focus on the individuals present that evening to find the culprit your words don't entirely convince me prosecuted disdain why limit the assumptions to those present that evening maybe even Council stop wasting the time of this court Mrs sth was literally found with star's blood on her hands my client cannot be the only suspect perhaps someone intervened from outside the
room don't know is that when you say the crime scene has got the glass on there cuz when when was that glass broken if they're saying it happened at the dinner what about the what about the butler could have intervened from outside so everyone was in the room right s paath Port McMillan and star were all in the room no we're in the study yeah once he joined the study they closed the door behind them star seated his guests in the dark so where was The Butler okay so do you think that's a reasonable would you do 34 though because that's that document well perhaps someone intervened from outside the room say it's the butler because everyone else was inside the room weren't they yeah
no uh we're not there yet but I'm sure I've grasped the point to insist on to enter a room locked from the inside requires forcing the entrances or breaking them among the clues there must be one that shows traces of this violent action okay you're open window but it said someone intervened from outside the room maybe they lock because he locked the door from the inside he couldn't open it so then had to run around and break the window okay so we're just saying that cuz cuz there was glass this is the turning point of our case I feel it flip someone back to innocence so we lost one but we got one
back prosecutor disdain take a look look at the photo of the crime scene pay particular attention to the floor tiles notice how many shards of glass have fallen from the still closed window in the confusion someone must have hit the window no prosecutor if someone among those present had broken the window the impact would have caused the shs to fall mostly outside not inside the room the window was broken from the outside so we've discorded that picture and our boss oh weird and then we open envelope
D so we have the murder weapon the killer likely used the napkin to avoid getting blood on themselves or leaving fingerprints the crime scene there's a layout for you the deposition of Randy McMillan Gregory asked us to wait in the study with the lights off I believe he had just opened the safe when the window was broken and Gregory screamed that that's the murdered guy there were sounds of a struggle I didn't know what to do it was too dark to see clearly when Esther found the switch we saw harumi sampath leaning over Gregory who was dead deposition of heroni sampath I just closed the door when I heard a strange hissing sound like something quickly screeching and then glass breaking and a noise maybe of a struggle star yelled and I got scared but when I heard the thir of a body falling to the ground I felt compelled to move in the darkness crouched down I made my way way towards Gregory with some difficulty when they turned on the lights I was leaning over him my hand stained with his blood but I was just trying to help there's a crate of wine there's the
safe deposition of es the port shortly after we entered the room I heard in quick sequence the window shatter Gregory shouting and then some commotion I may mistaken but I believe he said Thief at that point Panic took over and I began searching for the light switch however I had never been in the room before and it took me some time to find it when the lights came on Mrs sth appeared to be crouched over Gregory's lifeless body didn't he get stabbed in the chest would he be able to shout out well maybe shouted at the window and then she doesn't mention the screeching something quickly screeching then glass shatter she just says the window shatter then he started shouting well he said the windows was broken then Gregory screamed then there was a struggle yeah so heroni is the only person mentioned mentioning this screeching whatever that is Stars desk there's some kind of elephant on there with like a wire coming off it a wired elephant okay where's this going
let's stick to the facts counselor as you said yourself the window was found still closed the glass is broken but certainly not in a way that would allow a person to pass through a small Gap would have been enough to throw a knife no the wound is not consistent with the throwing action Gregory star's killer was in the room with him waiting for the right moment to strike the simplest explanation is this taking advantage of the darkness in the room Mrs sth moved toward the dire direction from which star's voice came and plunged the knife into his body yeah the elephant in the room so we need an objection move to the direction from which Mr star's voice came he didn't say anything before there was a struggle and then he yelled yeah the glass broke before like he his sounds were struggling or something weren't they well them two said that he shouted then there was a commotion well where's the layout of the room so we have to prove that like we have to prove that she he says she moved in the direction from which star's voice came his voice and plunged the knife into his body but she said she was at the door she was last to enter she would have w walk straight into the desk or this chair or something yeah she
wouldn't have been able to walk to him so we present this yeah there's evidence you don't sound sure well it might be a deposition oh I don't know I just closed the door no I don't understand what you mean if there's anything that could prevent s paath from reaching star that thing was in the crime scene room if you want to be taken seriously you'll have to be more specific more specific finish right does this as all you haven't said the right thing yet okay so was his desk in the way yeah the say the desk she would have had to climb over the desk oh do not flip any je I just flipped one you claimed that the path was blocked by this desk perhaps you haven't carefully listened to the words of your own client counselor when the window glass was broken Mrs saath had just closed the door from the corner where she started the desk didn't cover block that much the path to Mr star I've got a flip two f one I would say that the desk is in the what is in the way then what is that it's like a computer or is it the Crea of wine oh it's the create of wine it's the create of wine we're not looking you can see you can't yeah you can't you can out of the things we've got in front of us you can see it's a crate of wine you're right counselor but we're back on the defensive you must attack as soon as you can my innocence depends on it flip one juror back to innocence we didn't look close enough you can see this has four bottles in it I thought it was a chair with a laptop on it I was like we haven't got a chair
with a laptop card right I must contradict you Mr prosecutor you must consider the situation Not only was it dark but Mrs sampath had never seen the room before if she having just entered the room had headed quickly towards Mr star's voice perhaps she might have managed to avoid the desk but surely she would have tripped over the crate of wine placed on the floor it is clear from the testimony that only a few seconds passed before the scream Mrs sth would not have been able to reach star so quickly once again counselor you overlook the facts well we did we didn't then CU yeah we found the fact eventually support you claim that it was not possible for S paath to react so quickly in the dark but the same applies to the others none of those present knew that star would turn off the light or that the window would be broken yet star was murdered so perhaps it was not so impossible to get close to him by luck or agility Mrs sth was able to get to him and hit him with this reconstruction I'm sure I have clarified everything that happened in the dark moments objection your honor there must be something missing from this reconstruction what is missing from the reconstruction
I suppose where the knife came from well I mean it's a kitchen knife I mean nobody's mentioned the elephant in the Reconstruction yet
single close range Stab Wound well where did the knife come from is it silly to say oh where's the knife from I mean why is the why is the safe open yeah oh cuz oh he would have taken the necklace out of the safe probably that quickly let just show them maybe it's not weird that the safe was open maybe it's the key to everything we do have the murder weapon yeah we have we have we have the murder weapon but like where they apparently used the napkin to stop any fingerprints did we say where did this come
from like agility wise she's running across the room and leaping over the um wine crate with a knife in her
hand I'd like to know where the knife and the napkin and everything came from but I suppose like they could just say she had that in her hand beforehand well they would have seen it I suppose yeah where would she where would she hide a great big knife no I'm desperate disain is putting me on the ropes there must be something that has not yet been explained I need to reread all the latest documents and look for a detail that is still missing from the Reconstruction flip someone to guilty we're stumbling and bumbling reach saying that he's just open the safe when the window was broken maybe we do need to click on the safe when Esther found the switch but he's saying that they he had time to open the
safe so the safe he's opened the safe in the door do you think her thing when she says screeching maybe Yes actually I qu I don't quite understand where you're going with this counselor but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt we get them back that's the thing that stuck out in my mind when we first read it that no one else said screeching ladies and gentlemen of the court I believe that this dain's reconstruction is missing a crucial detail namely the hiss heard by Mrs sampath before the window broke counselor you are cleaning to trivialities not at all prosecutor to reach the truth we must leave nothing unexplained capsel you are bluffing what does this hiss have to do with the murder face your defeat like a true professional and don't waste the Court's time with your delusions it's not necessarily that the H is directly related to the murder but it could explain a particular Behavior first we need to understand what produced The Noise it the safe you think it's the crazy elephant screeching I I wouldn't describe an elephant as screeching but maybe this does okay I want it to be this more than anything so what that 36 we're on card number nine right yeah yes such a messy desk is a sign of an equally disordered mind I think I
understand your point counselor flip you come back flip you that noise was produced by this wire attached to this paper weight imagine securing the paper weight outside the window and passing the wire over the top crossbar of the window making sure it could slide now picture giving it a little sudden tug the paper weight would detach from its housing and hit the window breaking it from the outside immediately afterwards it could be retrieved and put back in its place on the desk this was the hissing sound perceived by heroni sth the noise of the wire rubbing against the window frame exactly what I said how was he come up with that little plan of what to do with a paper weight on a desk through a window just by looking at that picture that is the kind of thing Phoenix right has to pull out a this is what I say happened exactly they tied a little rope to this yeah paper weight put it through the top of the window then pull on it that is exactly the kind of thing that happens in Phoenix right though he says something insane and it turns out that's exactly what happened counselor I can't believe the audacity of your claims they are assertions that leave a trace though we have a photo the outside of the window doesn't it look like there's a tape mark on the underside of the upstairs balcony oh it does there is CL damn fine let's assume that you
are right and that someone wanted us to believe that a person from the inside had broken the glass what reason would there be to Stage such a mechanism why would they break the glass so that turns away from the safe don't know to steal the necklace I would imagine
or to get the knife in I don't but wouldn't star have had to pull that well star hasn't pulled it has he the murderer pulled it okay the murderer has pulled it startled the guy Gregory star and then stabbed him
what are we being asked why why would they stage this mechanism a mechanism I don't know hi Jose how's it going you have made it we're in the middle of a
mystery he says he just opened the safe she says after we enter the room the window shouted Gregory shouting some commotion he said Thief
I don't know ra what should we present I don't know is it to get him to come away from the safe so they can steal the necklace I don't know I don't know was who stabbed him I'll say safe and it might give us a clue as to what the right thing is I'm so close I believe with the window broken from the outside someone was trying to simulate a theft there must be a strong motive to do something like that doent well I did think that but bro can you flip two jurors or reach we've lost two of them with that blunder well we'll get some back of course this truth overturns the entire trial and its foundations my head spins just thinking about it flip one back
the trick this trick served to make us Believe The Disappearance of the necklace was due to theft I feel that the motivation is one that too often drives human beings money specifically in detail the money Gregory would have gained through the insurance claim for the theft of his necklace believe me my voice trembles as I say it but I'm am certain that it's the case Gregory staged the fft of the necklace no one else could have orchestrated the trick that's what I was saying he's he stood over there in the dark pulling the wire himself backfired because someone has stabbed him counselor what you say has now entered absurd territory even assuming that what you asserted actually happened putting such a plan into action has high risks would the paper weight have held up until the appropriate moment would it have manag to pick up enough speed to break the glass how would Gregory have so much confidence in the success of the trick damn he's right Gregory star loved taking risks but he was certainly not a fool somehow he knew the trick would work because he has TR is testing
before the window has been broken before about a month ago you know I hadn't thought about it but you're really good aren't you I'm sorry maybe it's not nice to see him so surprised flip someone to innocent
certainly it was a risky plan Gregory star was a very meticulous person and he would hardly leave his fortunes to Mere chance in fact Gregory star has already attempted this trick in the past or perhaps you have forgotten about the broken window in his stud he found a month before the crime didn't it strike you was odd at his reaction to a broken window in the room where he kept all his jewels was so calm impressive counselor now we begin to get serious Phoenix would be slapping the piece of paper as he would be saying all of this stuff I don't understand this danain what are you reading before the trial I met with prosecutor Maxwell for an exchange of views I have her advice here what who is this prosecutor Maxwell she's one of the best let me see ah here it is in this situation she recommends asking this question where is star's necklace now we know it was last seen at star's mansion on August 15th during a party we also know that star did not leave his house in the following days the police searched the entire Mansion after the murder but they didn't find it if the necklace wasn't stolen how did star get rid of it the crate of wine
mhm it's the only thing that Springs to mind and there's two bottles missing out of that crater wine it does say check the wines for pres of poisons let me turn that back on then nope the creative wine was delivered from outside instead you would promise to tell me a way in which star could have gotten rid of the necklace in short this evidence says about the opposite of what you were trying to demonstrate two jurors UNG guilty okay what day was this for what day are we looking for he was murdered on the 15th no it's the 19th wasn't it he was murdered on the 19th he saying that he's he sold it to this woman y well because it says he had a party and they saw it on the 15th he leave his house between the 15th and the 19th he got rid of it somehow so how did he get rid of
it all these people that he's been meeting with since the 15th he took care of everything himself from bargaining to shipping he sent it to somebody that's bought it and then he's claiming that it's been stolen yeah poping this number the N the more we reconstruct the actions of the unpleasant person Star Wars the closer we get to the truth one person's back on our side didn't we flip two to bad time did you not flip any when we got it wrong the first time so just flip one it was two for being wrong and then one back for being right
even if star did not leave his Villa the shipments he prepared did it seems even those notes can't help you perfect you answered exactly as prosecutor Maxwell predicted you hit a dead end counselor at first the defense of Mrs sth was based on the fact that if she had committed the crime we would have found the necklace in her possession then you moved on to speculate about the intervention of an outside person now thanks to your own reconstruction both these objections fall my reconstruction on the other hand has not been affected the fact that Mrs sth may have killed Gregory star is still the most probable reconstruction what very Phoenix right I wonder if I'm thinking of edworth slapping the paper not Phoenix right maybe they both do it so we need to Discord 8 oh 81 12 1315 3455 35 what you got there so number eight Broken Window 12 crime scene 13 15 34 35 go on hi Steph how's it going open envelope e we are fairly far through the story might want to skip back if you don't want to be spoiled on it there is a murder invest there's a murder trial going on
so in the final envelope we have a newspaper article about a necklace sale yesterday Randy McMillan held a farewell party in honor of his necklace at home the daffodil mansion in fact the well-known gemologist had sold his Exemplar of the Starry Sky necklaces to heroni sampath the pric twice as much as the sale of the first piece many years ago the only obstacle to sampath's dream of gathering all three nees Remains the grumpy Gregory Star magazine article necklace exhibition so that was the 18th so the day before the murder on the 16th necklace exhibition private party for better or worse as long as they talk about me seems to be star's motto who yesterday in an arrogant display of Joy mocked the sales agreement between McMillan and sth by organizing a grand social evening where he showed off his own copy of the Starry Sky necklace very little resp respect was given to the important jewelry it was even carelessly DED with champagne during star's toast deposition of the butler before dinner before dinner McMillan and star stepped aside into the study for a short private conversation by chance I passed nearby and overheard them arguing fervently I believe they were talking about the necklace because star concluded the conversation by telling McMillan he would not change his mind emails between Esther port and Gregory star so this is from Port to Gregory Gregory I don't know how you managed to import the third necklace
without getting caught by Sri Lanka's Customs but your behavior is becoming a big image problem for art life this is back in March you're overreacting you're just jealous you sold your necklace last year before the set was complete at a much lower price now they are worth much
more what if they haven't got the third one in their just lying what was he dowsing champagne then that they've just got they've just got Randy McMillan's of who that Randy McMillan had one definitely yeah R sth bought it oh yeah let's see what is happening is this the logical power of prosecutor Maxwell sadly she's right everything I've said so far does not exonerate sampath for the murder it's not fair I have no one to help me I only have this list that I wrote myself and it's us wait maybe one of these tips could really help me so back to the tips there is always a more recent Will somewhere maybe that's the tip the kind Butler always hides something never forget to check the wines for the presence of poisons if someone has an identical twin rest assured there has been a switch at some point maybe it's that one the necklaces have been switched often the solution to the crime lies in our pockets diamonds when examined often turn out to be worthless copies maybe it's
that so it's either a more recent will but I don't know about that we have been given a will into estimate well we've been given everything that's on that list and we've got to choose which one is we think is going to help us everything on that thing we could do I'm thinking the identical twin might r to like a copy of the necklace so one four or six do four then if you think it's identical you think it's diamonds when examined often turn out to be worthless copies there's no diamonds in it though you think four
mhm an do you mean to say that I can't believe it I really can't believe it bit sus maybe McMillan was working with him what if the third necklace was never found counselor what are you rambling on about men's with the jury it can't be any other way it's like in detective novels if there's an identical twin rest assured there had been a switch at some point and in this case there are three identical twins the star Sky necklaces we all know how the ambitious restoration work initiated by star made the necklaces indistinguishable from each other anyone who saw one couldn't tell if it was the third or one of the previous ones but what are you saying counselor what reason would star pretended to discover the third necklace to regain what star valued most the spotlight but he wasn't the only one interested Star had an accomplice even if we consider the stage theft to give the impression that a had entered from outside and a complice would have been useful yeah but who perhaps there is someone else who would gain from the fake discovery of the third necklace
well with the insurance policy that You' get millions if it's stolen yeah but who we got have say a person well Randy Randy McMillan lives at the daffodil mansion and if you look at his Ledger oh it's been sold to the daffodil something's gone on with with the daffodil Villa so he's seen somebody from the daffodil Villa during the time when he the necklace was last seen and he was killed so we saying Randy mcmillon mhm oh make the browser come up hit but he was so kind to me he even helped me organize the dinner it's always tough when people disappoint you flip a jur
Randy McMillan Mrs sampath was forced to increase her offer to buy the necklace precisely because the artifact now belonged to a complete collection I can't believe this let me remind you that the third necklace was certified by es the port would she also be an accomplice Mrs Paul was probably not aware of this she was given a necklace to certify for Mr for McMillan and all she could do was note that it was authentic after that the necklace was sent to Mr star hidden among the bottles for display during the party on August 16th star sent it back on August 17th addressing it to Villa daffodil AKA The Mansion owned by McMillan the illusion of a third necklace is complete so you would have us believe that Gregory star was planning to execute two different scams first one to increase the value of McMillan's necklace his accomplice and then a second one to fake the theft of the non-existent third necklace exactly prosecutor disdain allow me to complete the argument it is true that Mr star planned two scams with Mr McMillan but he was the only one who stood to gain from the stimulated theft now I just have to prove that McMillan had no intention of taking this risk at
all what do we have that says M Millan didn't want to take the risk at all well the butler heard him say something oh yeah what what did he say oh yeah saying he would not change his mind they were arguing we've got it we've got it cancor go ahead with your closing arguments lip Aur to
innocence here we go before dinner McMillan and star argued and the latter said he wouldn't change his mind they weren't talking about the impossible sale of a non-existent necklace McMillan was objecting to the stage theft if something went wrong subsequent investigations could have uncovered the truth and exposed McMillan he decided to intervene after the clever trick broke the window McMillan already knew what would happen and how he could reach star when Star moved to put the paper weight back on the desk and remove the string McMillan was there waiting armed with a knif and struck him this is the only reconstruction that explains with certainty what happened in the darkness of that room this was not foreseen not even by prosecutor Maxwell I don't know what to say ladies and gentlemen of the Court what the defense Council has reconstructed is nothing but an extraordinary fantasy there's no evidence of this hypothetical scam organized by star and me this is not possible there must be something to prove Mr McMillan's guilt I have to prove that the necklace that was found in Mrs sampath's car is the same one that Mr the star had shown at the party the necklace in the car is the same one that he'd
shown I mean is it that the fact that the when they certified the third necklace it was its restoration was the same as the previous restoration yeah there's got to be something to it there that he dsed it with champagne in his toast and
stuff proof that the necklace in the car is the same one he showed at the party CU this this is authenticated on March 15th yeah oh yeah that's that's after the party isn't it it would have a load of champagne on it yeah maybe do6 then correct incredible you did it I'm saved I can't flip it you take a look at this magazine during the party which starx exhibited the necklace star handled the necklace with his bare hands and even spilled champagne on it if star's necklace as I claim is the same necklace that was later sold to Mrs sth then by analyzing the latter we will find evidence of these facts touching such a jewel with your bare hands corroding the gold with alcohol that's bloody star he never had any respect for jewelry he thought he was a genius but he was nothing but a propheter and a criminal I could hardly go through life with the thought that he might blackmail me from one day to the next ladies and gentlemen of the Court understand me I was forced to take him out do you understand I was forced Revelations broken him I can't believe it I did it it seemed impossible but I did it an ancient per wrote like a bee that has seen the blooming Lotus my bewildered heart found solace thank you
counselor I admit at first I was a little worried that mustus wasn't here but you did a great job ah right I'll have to explain what happened to Mr M stus well considering the results he can't score me too much in the end right you shed light on the case and successfully defended your client heroni sapath congratulations not guilty it's time to see how you did on the next card you'll find a table you compare your number of jurors to the table while we have got all of them in our favor so that means you beat disain in an exemplary way so in love with the sound of his own voice the poor prosecutor closes the process without being able to pronounce a single word so you got beat by a rookie Pro prosecutor disdain say Maxwell prosecutor Maxwell apparently we were wrong about the starcase and Mass's assistant was definitely surprising you made the mistake prosecutor I just gave you a pointers this defeat is your own doing anyway I can't wait to meet this assistant I haven't had a proper Challenge in a while to be continued in the next case in the next case there we go as far as we know play it again uh there is something on here there's the final exam on the main page so I assume
that's the next maybe you go up against Maxwell case you must have to as you go along the stuff page takes you just to the rules it is currently out of stock on the Publisher's website so there we go that's until proven guilty it's nice I enjoyed that it's just like a one-off thing you're probably never going to forget that are you and like the score scoring in all of these like exit games and everything is strange is it because we've always thought that like back to the first exit and unlocks that fair enough that you're given as a rating but it don't mean we never going to do it again so it doesn't really matter but yeah generally like we made up for the few failures along the way and there was a couple of nice little Phoenix Right style jumps in logic with the but you can see like there's a strange like there's a strange string coming off this weird elephant that's just out of place out of nowhere that's cool is it I can't remember how much it was it just said on the website didn't it I think it was about1 15 or something 169 90 off the Publishers website Euros was that about4 something like that yeah and like you don't all you're doing is opening you're not even tearing SEALS or anything these are all tucked in so like you can completely reset this and give it to someone else to play or sell it or something it's it's like any of the
that's what we used to do with the unlocks in it yeah back in the day after you fin when it was like fold or cut this thing never cut that's that kind of ended up spoiling some of the exits that we went we had to go to elaborate length to not destroy the get into the spirit we we couldn't bear to SN I'm not cutting beds up but yeah you get you get one case in it it'll be nice to like I always like it's more attractive to someone to just buy like an individual box for not a lot of money and give it a go but it would be nice if kind of Detective season one style you when they did the the the new detective box that had shorter cases but but it was like it was like3 or something like that and had several and it would be nice to have that jewelry box is quite nice yeah that's very cool but like they're going to have to keep making that with punch boxes every time for every box or are the future ones just going to be like a little pack of just the cards and the envelopes you know what I mean like a a smaller one you got to have their base yeah Bame it's strange is it cuz imagine it would add a ton of cost but it's got to be adding some to do this every time but I don't know there we go this this is their first like launch into it I don't think like would it be in upcoming releases it's not in upcoming releases yet uh games for all section I'm just looking on the website you can't see right now what about all
games you're sh me all games in in the bank system nothing yet in their News section or anything I haven't had a email and this is technically just like it in in Europe it came out of Essen in America it's saying quarter 4 so it might have only just made it there so like you would imagine with them being like small cases you'd imagine they're going to have to be more often than a year right it seems slow to be doing them in a year which just like I think it says on the box like 45 to 90 minutes then 75 to 90 minutes depends how good you are at yeah finding evidence it's probably like if it's anything like Fenix right it' be a little bit easier to get you started as well like saying you're just against that disdain that's the the way that Phoenix wght did it anyway you're against someone kind of completely inept in the first case and then you were against someone formidable later on but yeah I enjoyed that good I I'd give the next one to go but there we go that is until proven guilt it it's gone a little bit quicker we gave it potentially two hours just in case it went on a little bit longer than the time said but yeah took us about about
an hourish and that is it this is probably like something may change we're not sure of the circumstances of the next couple of weeks there's probably a lot of people AR with where we're going to be and who's going to be here and stuff but this might be the last stream of the Year they'll three one fairly early into next year with the anticipated games of next year there might be one before there could be like say there might be something around we did a new year one like I don't think last year but the year before we did like a choose adventure at some point didn't we and we did a I remember was doing the app of um the Warlock of fight up Mountain at one point and we did like a two-day stream where we just got lost do you remember that when we got like lost in a maze repeatedly in that book and it kind of spoiled it for us there might there might be something around New Year's but if not like happy Christmas everyone happy Holidays happy New Year all of those things there there's going to be pre-recorded ones there's several playthroughs in the pipeline they're going to be coming up on uh patreon and then later on the channel there going to be the top 10 games next next week on uh Christmas Eve as usual there's still stuff coming up but in terms of live there's not going to be any for a bit anyway I don't know how long a bit's going to be but there's plenty of pre-recorded stuff to keep you going there's freedom five there's the new cthul of death may die um fear of the unknown there's going to be some videos for that and there's going to be something for me Metal Gear Solid I'm
very excited about although it's it's tutorials to start off but you got to start somewhere right on Shadow Moses is it's Solid Snake there a little tease of him look at he's right there he's got a little cardboard box he's the only one painted though I haven't done meril or anyone yet so thanks everyone for being here thanks ra for doing a stream and doing all that narration on your birthday yeah you're going to have a birthday meal soon aren't you yeah going out for a birthday day mail so yes thank you everyone have a lovely Christmas holiday time and I'll see you in pre-recorded form in the meantime but it's not going to be long until we're live again is it time goes like that doesn't it thank you everyone and you can support the channel on patreon it's I'm able to do any of this stuff it's not a sponsored stream uh and uh or do a little cofi oh yeah there cof as well by ra whichever one you would prefer thank you everyone that can do that and keeping us going for this year and stuff and uh yeah have lovely times everybody and we'll see you soon bye bye bye e