Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dawnshade - Why it isn't for me

Transcript 19:32

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive daniel here all right today we are going to take a little look at the dawn shade game um don don shade prophecy of the the watchers prophecy uh that's the full name here so i'm not going to call this a review because i haven't played the game enough times or much at all to tell you the truth to call it a review i have however played enough times to know that the game just is not for me and i kind of wanted to talk a little bit about why that is there are some things that i do like about this game for one i think the production values are just outstanding i mean everything looks really nice i like the components i like the cardboard is thick it has pretty good art the character boards are kind of uh they're oddly shaped for sure but they are nice the uh cards are nice and even the little uh are not the little but the big kind of uh story book has some good art in it and the writing is decent it's um you know it's it's i've read much worse writing in a board game in a kind of a narrative board game so it's up there with like some of the some of the better board game writing and some of the mechanisms are interesting what is most interesting in

a positive way actually it's kind of a positive and a negative it's the double-edged sword of this game it's just how many different things the designers creamed into one game and that leads me to kind of like the main issues i have it's just the two main parts for me just they don't gel together in a satisfactory way and those two main parts are like the adventuring and then how you determine the outcome of all of your challenges most of the challenges in this game are actually little dexterity mini games and it just doesn't really fit in an adventure game at least as far as i'm concerned i would have liked like a couple little dexterity things is a good idea i have praised warhammer quest silver tower multiple times for having little kind of weird mini games but it's never the focus and don shade a lot of the game the focus is actually on dexterity games and i didn't get that sense during the kickstarter campaign i thought that there was just going to be maybe a couple little dexterity games that would kind of augment or offset or add a little spice to the game but that's really not the case you're doing a lot of dexterity stuff in this game

so let's talk about when the main thing i do like and that is this board here this is the adventure board this is the board that you're going to be moving this token on which represents your kinship which represents the party of adventurers you're going to pick a starting hex and that's going to be where your starting village is and your starting village is going to have a number of different outposts that you can visit such as guilds and shops and places where you can buy and level up and uh do your your adventure prep and then in each game you are going to be building a stack of quest tiles and these tiles will have certain things like other outposts that you can visit to do certain things they might have these journey tiles which those just represent your places where your party is out uh journey journeying going on a journey across the land so that's just going to kind of take up time and then you can have more journey tiles and then you will have some event tiles which one of the event houses out on the board already so this one here rep corresponds to event number 15 and you might have a watchers temple which is a place that you can go to kind of get the benefits of the prophecy of the watchers that the different gods that are reigning over the land and then you can also have battles which these are where you're going to be fighting and finally you're going to have your final threat and what this does is this comes out at a certain point when you

are venturing on the map basically each time you move to a new hex you count how many spaces you have moved and you're going to set a threat level at the beginning of the game and for each space that you move through you're going to add one to that threat and when you reach that certain threshold then that triggers the uh the end game for that uh scenario and another thing i do like is the campaigns are short like the whole campaign is really only three games and you play this game this map game for three games you have an epic you have a threat you you have an epic challenge at the end boss fight usually and then that's going to be the whole campaign so the campaigns are manageable i like how you build your quest um your tile quest deck from the available tiles and i like how the events correspond to all the different events in this book so you will have 20 different um non kind of they're not i don't want to say non-combat because there are some combat things but 20 different narrative events and each one of them has a handful usually three different ways that you can approach the event three different choices and then there are a number of different battle events these red events and that depends on the level of your party of your characters you will face off against different uh battle scenarios and then the epic threat the

major threat also depends on the level of your party and so there are a number of different epic threats or major threats that you will have to overcome to win each uh scenario in the campaign so it does a really good job of keeping things in balance of maintaining a presenting a short campaign that is actually finishable and a really cool sense of adventure while you are moving around the map trying to connect the tiles and pathways there's a little bit of tile placement because you want to make sure that you can get to places where you need to go without moving too many spaces generating more threat because you want to try to stay adventuring quite a long time in order to power up your characters and you can also move around and you can collect these different uh bonuses that the the watchers have placed out for you and these are going to give you bonuses usually for a combat they will allow you to do certain things the main problem that i do have with the game and the thing that is is really keeping me from from even wanting to play it at all anymore is each most of the time when you are faced with a challenge what you are going to be doing is some kind of mini game that is a dexterity game so there are a number of different so if you turn to the rule book here we can see that the different challenges are going to be um there are let's see here so there are

stat challenges um stat challenges represent the kinship testing their skills based on collective stats so you will take you will take your battle board here you will look at your like defense value on one of your characters you will take a number of defense dice that are correspond to that then you will roll on this battle chart here and you will roll and it's kind of like shuffleboard you have a minus one a plus zero a plus one a plus two and a minus one and you're trying to roll these dice and you're trying to look for these red pips there and you wanna get those rolled in places where they're gonna add a certain total to those pips and you have to reach a certain threshold to overcome the challenge so each player is going to roll their dice and then you want to try to get it into that plus two so that's a little bit of a dexterity challenge there and then you also have um things where you have to you might discover some treasure you might discover a treasure chest and to get the treasure inside to unlock the treasure you might have to do a little lock picking mini game and for that you're going to set up these red health tokens in a certain order depending on how hard the challenge is and then you have to take one of your characters tokens and you have to roll your um your token through to the end in between these two white dots without knocking over

any of these stacks of red tokens to show that you have picked the lock so there i would have successfully picked the lock on that particular challenge and you might have to set these up in different ways and the more red things you set up kind of corresponds to a harder lock that you have to pick so that's another way that you will have to uh overcome a challenge and then there is a couple like poker not poker but gambling style mini games where you're going to be flipping over these cards here these little like initiative hit cards and you're going to be looking for certain symbols and you can bet money and you can um as long as certain symbols line up you might get more money there's a dice mini game where you're going to be taking a couple dice and you're going to be trying to roll you're going to be bedding and then you're going to be rolling and you're looking for certain combinations of those dice and then you have what is basically a game of a bay blade and so if you're playing with two players each of you is going to take one of your cog bots and you're going to spin those and the last one standing is the winner and they're going to get some money or some additional xp you have challenges where you are going to be um taking a stack of red chips like this and you're going to be putting your uh cog bot there and you're gonna be flipping those trying to uh land close to certain spots they're doing damage to certain enemies

um there are sliding challenges where you're going to be sliding these tokens on certain uh trying to get close to certain spots so like all of the skill challenges all of the skill checks in this game correspond to some kind of little mini game that has to do with tossing dice or tossing chips or rolling chips or spinning chips and the the main reason why that doesn't work for me is that as a game where the game was really kind of touted as having this kind of complex character progression where you could mold you could build your character in a variety of different ways they could be a spell sword or a melee build or a straight mage build or something like that but all of the ways that you overcome the challenges except for combat in this game are done through dexterity mini games which have absolutely like no bearing on how you've built your character it has to do with you as the player and how good you are at flicking and rolling and sliding things so the main way that your characters in the game are overcoming challenges has nothing to do really with how they have built themselves out how they have progressed how they have leveled up and that's a huge disconnect this is

for an rpg i don't want me i don't want to be as the player i don't want to be the one who um is having to overcome the challenge i want my characters to overcome the challenge because of the way i leveled them up and speaking of leveling up one of the main things you're going to be doing throughout the game is you're going to be trying to keep your trying to keep a balance between all of these different um gods and their powers so you have like nature and what is this uh sun fire mountain air and water and you have these chips here and at certain points of the game usually during combat you can roll avaki dice and the vaki dice will allow you to take these chips here and these chips correspond to different gods and different prophecies or different watchers i should say and as you take certain ones and spin certain ones you're going to be moving these little cubes up and down trying to maintain a balanced um just a balanced outlook on life as far as like the different gods go and if you ever get out of balance that can be bad and if you get out of balance you might have this cataclysm that'll come out it'll kind of uh it'll kind of haunt you for the rest of the campaign but while this is kind of interesting and you are going to be wanting to get different elements in order to spin

those elemental chips to do your characters super abilities i found that while i was playing the chances to get these chips just they just weren't happening enough to make these different skills um a viable solution a viable option when i thought that they would have been more necessary and i found myself kind of ignoring this board here this balance board except for the three dials where you're going to keep be keeping track of your experience your threat and your level those are those are used all the time but i found that i just didn't really need to pay attention to this in order to have more fun it seemed like this kind of cool concept that just wasn't utilized enough and again these really only come out in combat when you need to use one of your skill cards but most of the time most of the challenges were these little dexterity challenges where this didn't really seem to add anything to those dexterity challenges and so there's just there's just this kind of just big disconnect between those two parts of the game i think this should have been advertised more as a dexterity game

something like uh what's that one game i completely forgot um castle panic right castle panic is a dexterity game there was another one too where you had to do like silly things where you had to like stand on one foot and flip a chip that was kind of a a an adventure game but those games are advertised as being dexterity first themed dexterity games this would have been a much better game as a if it was advertised as a themed dexterity game if they really leaned into that thematic dexterity style game then it would have been something really unique it could have simplified the adventure part simplified the rpg part even probably gotten rid of it all together because it really doesn't amount to much and had a narrative thematic dexterity game be the focus and that would have been something unique and kind of cool and i think people would have if people had would have expected that then they would have known what it is more going into it there are ways that you can overcome your stat challenges your challenges without the dexterity minigames but they really amount to nothing more than rolling two dice and looking for certain symbols and then once again the way you've built your characters doesn't really have any impact on that part so there still is that disconnect

and also playing dexterity games as a solo player is really kind of boring i mean you want when you're playing these dexterity games and you're rolling you're rolling good and you're like bouncing you know bouncing dice off and doing cool things you want that uh that camaraderie around the table to like give a cheer or or a boo or something and so i think this game would probably also be much more fun if you were playing with a group and so for me also since i do most of my gaming solo these days that's another way where it's just not hitting the mark and that's too bad i was really hoping to like i was really hoping this would be one of those kind of uh those under the radar games that i could really champion but i just don't think it's for me i think this game could be for some people however i think some of the nature of this like of this balance board and keeping track of this could be a little more complex for people who might really be into the dexterity part and so there may be this weird place this weird middle ground where the game doesn't appeal to enough to a crowd looking for a lighter game nor does it really appear appeal to a crowd looking for a heavier game it's kind of in this weird nebulous middle zone where i'm not quite sure who the

audience is one thing i do know is that i am just not part of that audience and that's a real shame i really wanted to like don shade but again this isn't really a review i just wanted to talk about some of the reasons why i i'm i'm very quick i'm just going to add this to the cell pile it's not a game for me i don't think it is necessarily a bad game i just think this game is going to have a really hard time finding its audience and that audience is going to be a very niche audience and that's okay this game might really connect with a very small group of people and for them i think they're going to have a fun time but for me it's just not the game for me so i am going to pass it on and sell it so all right guys well i hope you enjoyed taking this really kind of quick just brief overview look of dawn shade the watchers prophecy and we will talk to you later bye-bye

you

Progress saved