Skip to main content
Loading video...

Are We Breaking The Rules? | The Arkham Horror "Podcast"

Transcript 58:04

Hello everybody and welcome to a video here at Playing Board Games. I'm joined by Daniel from Quick Learner and Daniel uh sent me this Reddit thread um that he thought could be an interesting thing to kind of dive into and talk about and this is actually something that I have a lot of opinions on. Um and I want to just say right off the bat that this is not an intention to dog pile on this thread or this poster. uh because overall uh I actually kind of agree with a lot of the sentiment that we have here. But I do find some stuff uh a little bit interesting to kind of to kind of like figure out and I think that this is also a good thing for us to kind of propose to the viewers here to even ask if you have seen stuff like this to kind of like talk about it and kind of go the dialogue with it. Um, so the gist of it is that this was a player who went to Arkham Con, which just happened uh last week at the time of recording, which wasn't a good time. Daniel, did you have a good time?

It was fun.

It was so funny if you're like, "No, it it was miserable."

And for that matter, if we're not dog piling on this post, I'm out. Um, no. Uh the conventions I think are are super interesting because you do get to uh actually see other people play. Then you know

I play with you of course a lot. I've got other friends online. I've got friends in person and sometimes we have a little bit of a our blinders on about how other people interact with the game. That said, we are content creators. So I suspect what we're doing is not so unusual that other people have completely different experiences. But I also understand that as content creators for the game, we probably I don't know what percentage of the player base actually is ever logged into YouTube.com, right?

Yeah.

Could be very small.

Yeah.

But cons are a place where at least the people who are even engaged in the community quite a bit who maybe don't watch or listen to our stuff, uh you get to see what they're thinking about cards and and all of that. I even enjoy talking with with Chad and and Beard who are at the con as well, but that they think different things about cards and you know that that's fair.

Yeah. Um

same opinion.

And if you're interested in another con, Arkham North tickets go sale, I believe, on November 16th. So, you should come play Arkham in Edmonton because it's going to be a great time. So, you should all do that. Arkham North.ca CA because it's in uh Canada, the great white north, but it shouldn't be cold or snowing when the con happens. Knock on wood. We have gotten snow in June before, but it shouldn't be. All right, so uh let's go into this kind of thing here. So, this was a player um who uh had a bad experience um while playing at Arkham uh at an Arkham convention. But they also say I think a big gist of this they've also seen this for Lord of the Rings which they have done a lot of their conventions with it. Uh and there's kind of that kind of thing where like I imagine what happens is they saw a lot of this stuff at uh the Lord of the Rings stuff and then when apparently it it happened at Arkham Con that it was kind of like is this happening everywhere? So, uh there's some stuff here that actually relates directly to uh the content creation, which also is something that I think will be interesting to talk about. Um but I want to just say uh we're kind of just going to jump over to this one. So, at first at Gen Con and a Lord of the Ring convention, I was surprised or would try to engage other players in discussions around this, which is the idea of um we can't really have discourse around the games when there's no standard of play.

I understand that everyone misses a trigger now and then, and I'm not trying to rules lawyer Wolverine Claws, the community. I just so I just don't seem to understand how people look at the game and engage with it so differently. So, this is like kind of like the topic of conversation here. So, an example of this is Lord of the Ring feels particularly rough and we see content creators about to be blown out by shadow encounter cards tap their boards in response and say, "We'll just say I healed in player phase." So, I think the discussion for this one is coming with the idea of uh cheating.

Yeah. Like that. That's kind of like to me what this like raised here because like to me this is um a very different sort of thing than uh like a generic mistrigger, right? Where it's like, oh, I wanted to trigger a bounty or a crack the case. Do you guys mind if I do that here? Right? That's to me is a lot smaller of a thing. albeit, I think in fairness to this poster's point, is also still kind of a bend of the rules, right? I don't think it's enough to nullify conversation or analysis or even evaluation, but I think in all fairness, that is kind of bending the rules of the timing windows that Arkham has to do something afterwards.

Um,

so, uh, Justin, you're currently moderating Major League Arkham and you have a standard of play here as well for these kinds of things like takebacks is kind of the the the question, right? Yeah. Like when can you say oops, I meant to do this or

even in the case here of like we'll just say I did something that I didn't actually do. So, what is what's the standard that you've come up with with with Major League Arkham?

Yeah. So for me, my standard for Major League Arkham that is if any new information has been gained, it is too late to do a takeback or do something that you might have missed. So this would be for example if a player was uh debating to um cancel a card um that someone drew during the mythos phase. If that person immediately drew a token to resolve that test and failed or passed, it was too late to do any sort of ward of protection shenanigans, right? Likewise, if someone realized they missed a move that they wanted to take for free and a test happened, a card was drawn, an enemy moved or anything like that, it would be too late to do that move. that at this point would be information was gained, the game state has changed. It's too late to do something like that.

But for example, for bounty, let's say you feed an enemy and then you take an action to move to the next location which was already revealed and you say, "Whoops, I forgot to play this."

Yeah, that those are to me that at least in the terms of Major League Arkham is a fine thing to do with that. But say for example, you drew a card

uh and you that that would be out of the realm of what is possible for uh a takeback so to speak or a missed trigger if you will.

Mhm.

And like this actually also like even happens in like uh Magic the Gathering where I believe there are some sort of like I actually don't know what the mistrigger rules are for Magic the Gathering, but that would have been a good thing to kind of like discuss here. Um

uh yeah, cuz I think that like to me takebacks are not what this is, right?

Um

I think that this is a different beast. But I also think that this is um uh I think when we're going to get into the meat of it, which is kind of like down down here as we get to this. And I do also want to jump up to this later in this video as well because I think this is kind of like the thesis of the whole thing and honestly something I kind of agree with in a way that I'll I'll explain explain later on. So as for Arkham Con itself this year it felt like the wild west. Simultaneous play makes it rough, but even setting that aside, you see I prepped my own bags with no failures ever drawn and people drawing through their decks multiple times with not a weakness in sight and quite a um few non-stop whipwobs or we'll say we did X Y Z instead. So, I think that these are three very different things and I think we should kind of like talk about them and how what you saw from your experience at Arkham Con for this kind of thing. I also like to add here, I don't think it's in this comment, but I read somewhere else, maybe on a different Discord, about someone having a similar complaint to this poster. And I don't know if it's the same person cuz you know, Discord usernames, but they said that um someone was playing a curse deck and lo and behold, their random basic weakness, one of the ones in standalone mode was dread curse.

You know, seems like they stacked the deck in their favor. That's sort of a a charge being levied that players are making things easier for themselves in that way. So when you're placed standalone mode, you play with extra weaknesses, right? And these should be random, but since you're prepping your decks ahead of time, you know, just leaving all the cards, is it possible people are, you know, leaving out some weaknesses that would have been really tough in that deck or in this case putting in ones that are extremely easy or even very beneficial for the deck.

I don't know the answer to that. I can't possibly know.

Yeah.

But also,

yeah, it's it's very likely. Yeah, it's very likely they could have uh just rolled to find the dread curse. It's also very likely they could have um

uh rolled it randomly because that could have happened and been like, "Oh, killer." You know, like that's great.

Um I think that this so like uh for some context,

I don't have a problem with like someone looking at my deck is supposed to be big money and they get paranoia and say forget about it, right? Like that's I understand in this sort of co-op game at a convention that it's not that big of a deal to as some people play as a house rule, right? They look at three weaknesses, veto one of them, right? And then to get the other one of the other two randomly that they could be doing some version of that here. I have no idea. And frankly, I don't think that means people are

seriously cheating.

No. So, I think that I I will say I think that I agree they're not seriously cheating, but I do think they go to the thought that this user had where it can kind of be hard to facilitate discussion regarding deck building and weakness. If people are doing the most commonly used weakness house rule, which is like roll three, remove one, draw one of the other two at random, right? Yes. And I think that is a fair point when it comes to the uh analysis of this game. And like it's like the conversation like this is something that Beard often talks about and it's a little bit different than this where he's like he gets someone who is like comes to give Chris some critique on their his custom campaign and he's like I crushed it. It was too easy. And Beard's like well what investigator did you play? It's like oh I played my custom Goku investigator.

And Beard's like, I can't I can't do anything with this information. I don't know who Goku like with his Goku investigator does. I don't know how powerful he is. And I think that like there is some sort of fair logic behind the idea that uh and this is something that I I firmly believe that if we're going to analyze the game, it needs to be without that logic in it, right? Yes. With like without the house rule. However, for convention environments, it kind of is the wild west. Like I think that that's like how it should be at a convention type environment because

uh it's not a world where it comes in and been like it's like there are some some things that we're going to talk about later on for this poster um about like some other things that kind of happened during the convention here. Um, but uh I think that like you have to just trust that everyone is there is trying to engage with the game

in good faith. But you also got to know that there are people who don't like losing, right? Who are going to [clears throat] band it in their favor so they don't lose. Like that's going to happen, right? I think that that's just like unavoidable and it's just like ultimately you are the arbiter of your own life. you're the only one who can decide that I want to play legitimately and then I think that it's like so like for example like let's I want to just go on this right like the as for Arkham itself this year felt like the wild west simultaneous play makes it rough but even setting the aside like the simultaneous play I have never seen that happen

I've never seen it

yeah that that's the one that like

I I I personally While I empathize and believe some of the sentiment that this poster is sharing, I I I believe that this is hyperbole. I think that this is like a little bit like um it happened like I I just can't imagine it happening multiple times in the weekend. No, I mean I can understand it sort of happening where you're So I've heard about it a little bit in Iron Man where like you have two clusters of investigators that are a different side of the map and it really doesn't matter and trying to hurry up. That's a little bit different than a regular scenario where people are maybe not always as familiar with the whole scenario and they're still reading things. Maybe someone's just like I'm just going to go while someone else is still finishing up their turn. That's pretty benign.

That's not simultaneous play. This is making it sound as though everyone has their own chaos bag and they're all off doing something in some other corner and there's no player interaction. This seems sounds like a different game to me. This player mentions playing Min and having nothing to do and I don't understand that either. Clearly other people should know what Min does and try to take advantage of this. I don't know. This is just this doesn't gel with my understanding of what was going on. That said, I didn't play with everyone in the con. I was playing with people either I knew them already or people I was playing with knew the person I didn't know. So, there was like some small degrees of separation. So, it wasn't that I mean, I wasn't likely to run into people who have a completely different understanding of the game than I do, but I I just don't think that people who would play this way would go to a con.

Like I think they understand how the game is played already and they don't just show up and start doing something that's clearly not in the rules in any way. You know, they would never see this in if they were to watch any content, they would never see this.

Yeah. So, this is also why I I kind of was into the idea of doing this for a video. Were you at Arkham Con and did you experience simultaneous play to this extent? It's kind of like a it's like a it's a this is like a a call to arms so to speak where like did you like I'm curious because I mean a big thing is I am holding a convention in the in the coming year right so it's like one of these things that I want to learn to like even approach this and how I as a as a a a convention organizer can try to uh potentially make it so people feel okay to say I do not want us to take turns simultaneously, right? Like I I think that that's what is the big de like the big thing where if like if that was happening at my table, I'd be like, "Yo, guys."

Yeah. I wouldn't accept that.

Yeah. I'd be like, "We can't play this way." Like even like to me like I I can understand like an Iron Man of like if there's like trying to play faster, but I think at that even for me, I'd be I'd have a hard time doing it. I I I don't think I could accept it. I'm just like I'm

No. And I wouldn't do it myself either. Like I know the group that did it, they've played together for four years and they kind of knew they weren't planning on doing it. I don't think it was just sort of a hurry up sort of situation. And I get it. Playing in person and Iron Man is is a little different when you're trying to do in limited amount of time. But that aside, I think that's like the exception. they're really talking about sitting down for the u the regular scenarios regular regular organized play and that's just wild to me. So as an example of like the wild west per se the I played with beard um one of his scenarios it was a great time I knew what I was doing playing with him. He told me I only brought custom investigators and I said fine right? He wasn't bringing Goku. like I knew that wasn't going to happen.

Um, and you know, you're playing a custom scenario already and and you trust of course in this case the designer to know what the limits are to playing um something busted or even underpowered, right? Uh so that was fine, but it was kind of a question that he asked everyone who was playing with us like, "Are you okay with this?"

Great. You're doing something that's outside the normal rules. You consent to it? Okay. If you're doing something outside the normal rules and you don't ask the other people at your table, then that's a problem to do that up front.

Yep.

Another example, um, and again, I think I just sort of expect these sorts of zany things to happen in a convention because it's fun. It's a co-op game. U, we played, uh, Blob.

The entire room, you know, does a epic multiplayer of Blob, but we do it for charity. And the way that it's done for charity is you can donate money to change the effects of what happens. So if someone donates like $25, they get to redraw a token.

If you're going to go and play at this event, you should be okay with this.

Yes. Yeah. Because again, that's like the rules of the event. Yeah.

Right. Exactly. Um, if you want to play like straight Arkham as it were, right, with no rules changes and you want it to be as difficult as possible and not have these other weird things happening, like you could affect the entire um, room. I think if you paid some amount of money, you got like a random reality acid, but the Elder Sign was the first token drawn. Um, these things are all good, right? Um, if you don't want that kind of help, go play in a different room. Like that's just not what's happening during that particular event. So, I think that idea of consent upfront, whether it's talking to the people or participating in an event,

is is important,

but I also don't really believe that that doesn't happen a lot. Maybe it doesn't happen sometimes, and that's what this person's experience happened to be. kind of weird that it happened all the time, but if you're not playing by the rules, you should tell people that you're house ruling something. I don't think the weakness thing is that big of a deal. I don't really care about that for a con. But these other sorts of things that are a bit different, then yeah, you got to talk about it.

Yeah. Like for example, like for the weakness rule, when I do my patron game days, I tell people they can feel free to roll a weakness that ruins their deck. Um because uh the goal of the patron game day is to have fun playing a deck, right? I'm not using this as assessment for the quality of cards, right? Or like the quality like the only information I gather in my head because I'm always collecting data on Arkham all the time. The only data I'm gathering during a patron game day is investigator selection

and then also like card choice. what cards people bring, but I'm not being like, oh, I I don't go like, oh, Hank performed badly here. Hank sucks, right? Like, I save that for campaign a campaign analysis because that's like where it belongs. But, for example, if I see everyone's bringing uh this investigator, like when Carson was first revealed, he was there for like every group for like four months, right? And I'm like, "Oh, Carson is very interesting." And Carson still sees a lot of play, right? I think like that's like to go back to again, this is the kind of thing that I really resonated with because I've never been to a con. I don't I'm very socially anxious, so I don't like talking with people at a con.

Well, you're going to think I know, but I'm working there. I'm working. So, it'll be different. I'll be able to be in

uh the PBG mode. Um, so it's like one of those things where um it's I don't think you can gather a you can't I don't think you can evaluate from a convention setting. I don't think that's the goal of a convention setting.

Yeah, [gasps]

I don't think you can do that in a con. That's not what cons are about. And I think that uh I think that this part of this is a little bit

uh disingenuous to believe. I mean, I guess like they could infer that if they're playing this like at a con, they're playing like this all the time. And I think that could be true for a lot of people, but I think those people also aren't um like trying to analyze in the way that, for example, people like you and I are.

Yeah. Like I said, there's a line, right, where do you recognize the game or do you not? And I also respect that you're not thinking too hard about the game when in a patron game day sort of situation for the reasons you outlined and I would say the same thing is true about the con. But if this guy's talking at all about is there anything we can say about the game? Should we even play the game? He says that a little bit later that you know are we even playing the game? I think that's a bit much, right? I think we still are. Even if there are some small changes, it's still the game. There are some changes that I think are are much worse. I don't know if it was in this content or this comment or somewhere else, but someone made the uh comment that they thought people were looking into the chaos bag and pulling a token out and that's cheating, right? Like there are certainly things that I would consider to be beyond the pale. And then there are other things that I think make such a small minuscule difference that I think it's very disingenuous to say that we're

why bother playing the game if you're not 100%

rules compliant.

Yeah. And even there was this one right over here. Uh I prepo in my own bag with no failures ever drawn. Uh I a little this is it could be a statistical like likelihood. I um I was playing in like uh Major League Arkham. Vault didn't draw a single Elder Sign or auto fail over two scenarios. Like he didn't draw a single one of those, right?

Um

yeah,

in my Iron Man, I didn't draw a single auto fail until scenario four, five, something like that. Oh, and boy did it hurt. It was a bad one, but it was in the bag. It was in the bag the whole time.

Yep. It's one of those things where um that could just happen, right? Like and and it's one of those things again it's like how the sim t timeless play makes it rough. You can even just be like hey you could even just say like can I see the the quant the quality that like the contents of your the chaos bag, right? Like if I was actually playing with people and everyone wanted to be their own bag, I'd be like I would just say, "All right, we're going to do a bag check to start to make sure we all got the right tokens because I don't really I don't want to I just want to make sure we're all on the same page." Right.

Well, that's what 100% what happened though. Like at the beginning of the scenario,

if there was multiple people playing with separate bags, and that did happen,

we dumped our bags out and were looking at the scenario setup and saying, "Okay, there's two skulls. There's a minus six in here." And and yeah, maybe someone did a little slight of hand and didn't throw the auto fail in, but come on. Like

you have you have to have faith in your fellow man, right? Like you have to just assume that people want to actually play the game, right?

Right.

Yeah. And even like drawing through their decks with multiple times with not a single weakness in sight. You can even just be like, uh, what was your what was your basic weakness? Again, you can just ask that question. I ask that like all the time in patron game day. I'm like, so what was your weakness? Okay. Yeah. Okay. I can help you with that if it shows up, right? And I also am going to just say something. Was this person really paying attention 100% of the time in a noisy room?

Maybe they got up and used the bathroom and missed something. I, you know, I I I without video proof of this happening and maybe we're going to see comments from 10 different people who said they all saw this happening and then okay, sure. but without really some hard evidence and not just like this one dude's anecdote, which is just a lot. There's a lot here. Um I don't believe it.

Yeah, it it is one of those things where it's hard to um like I can see it happening. I can I can I can see like someone uh like cuz like what's like what was the Arkham con turnout? like 160 people like it's probably like like

do you know

maybe not quite that many but 120 maybe

120 okay um still a lot like let's just say for example uh 10% of those people cheated that's 10 people right like that I think that that is a likelihood that that happened and not even meant to be uh derogatory or flaming right like let's just say someone was like I don't want to draw the auto fail today I'm not going to put it in my bag right like say let's just say someone did that right Um I think that it's that that could happen just on the thing and it's like maybe this person ran into one of those people, right? Like but I I think it's unlikely that it happened to the extent at least with the accusations here on the level that no one else has like seen it. So again, that's that's kind of partly why this video is here is like, did you notice anything or did you I mean, my guess is that most people just had a great time playing. And I think this person might have a stricter view of takebacks. That could be another thing as well. Like like I I think like the the logic behind like the the takebacks or the we'll say we did XYZ instead. I think that that is a fair thing to be critical of because I think that is something that happens quite a bit and I think that there could be a more unified I mean like maybe just like again that's why I'm personally trying to go now follow the Major League Arkham rules going forward because then at least I have a way that I can always look at it right and be like I learned

something new I missed my window I'll do it again in the future.

Yeah. Look, when I play in person with some people, you have to sort of judge how seriously you want to enforce every rule, right? I mean, online, of course, too, same thing. But when you're playing with people that you know that are your friends, especially, you might have settled into some kind of a a routine where someone's going to be really upset if you don't let them take something back, and you say, "Who cares? Let them do it." Right? A con situation is different. I think you're playing with people you don't know. It's It's not going to be that way. I don't think as much. You just learn to live with it. Um in Blob, you know, you pay your $25 and you re redraw the token. That actually happened to us and we drew redrrew the auto fail and said, "All right, we're not spending another $25." But it was very funny. [clears throat]

Uh um but you know how it is like you have to judge a little bit on your own. And I do this all the time where I have to say like, am I really going to tell them to take something back because they did they missed the trigger or they didn't have the timing right? Most of the time I don't because it's not worth it. Like it's not going to change anything really. Um, now when I'm recording things for the world to watch, I can be a little more strict on myself just because I want to, right? I know people are going to make comments or they might. And then I can say I missed something. Oops. Right. That's just the way it is. That is what the game is like. And that's where when I read this this uh post that was kind of pointing fingers at maybe Lord of the Rings uh content creators more than than anyone uh that's Arkham.

Uh, I just don't see a that we make so many mistakes, any content creator, and I watch enough of us, that we're demonstrating that this is how people can or should play.

Mhm. And even if we do make a few oopsies here, whether it's actual like rules mistakes because we didn't understand a card or we do something that's maybe quasi cheating like kind of what we were talking about before. Not like this real draw new card, new token kind of thing or just say we did this instead, but the the timing windows like you missed a the chance to play something or whatever. Something that's a little bit minor there. I don't think those things in the many hundreds of hours of Arkham that we've uploaded, thousands of hours probably for you, that it changes our evaluation of the game. Like, does that really change this idea of this card is good, that card is bad? If we truly have misinterpreted a card, like the text on the card is not how we're playing it, then sure, I think it's fair game to say don't trust their evaluation of that card. Mhm.

I don't think that's what's going on. I think that's that's so far from the reality of at least Arkham. I don't know about Lord of the Rings, but I've never seen anyone do something like we'll just say we did that. And then also have their card evaluation be based on their kind of flawed playing of the game.

Yeah, that's the thing too. Like I I I can't find like all the videos I make with gameplay, I try to interface with the rules in a consistent way that the rules demand because that is the way Arkham works, right? That's like that's Arkham. Um, and I mean I have moments like for example uh in my uh recent my forehanded through uh Brethren of Ash, I had Trish with the um otherworldly compass and I didn't reread the card and I was playing it incorrectly. So at the end I was like I I'm not counting this one. Like this is not a win. like this is I always put like an asterisk whenever I notice a rules error that really changes the structure of

the the the campaign or the scenario, right? Uh so like with that one, I forgot that because I didn't reread the card like an idiot. I assumed I knew how it worked. Um that uh it it's it was it's only revealed locations that reduces the shroud, right? It's not unrevealed locations. So I was getting value out of it that I shouldn't have. So I said this one doesn't count, right? And I think that that is uh an honest way of dealing with rule errors that we make, right? And kind of apply that to this. And I think that this uh like the thing is like uh from kitchen table course set to content creators apply rules differently, make terrible rule errors or just flat out break setup phase errors nonstop.

And I think that those do happen. Like I've made errors while playing, but

it's it's never the intention. And I also do not believe that it reduces the ability to evaluate or analyze or even discuss the game. To me, what makes it harder to discuss the game is when people are starting to add extra rules onto it or tweak the discussion where it's like, okay, but like like for example, I've been like this person I had a commenter chain where it was like this person this is a great investigator. They're really good. I take an extra move action each turn. Right. Right.

Where it's like that well that that can't that doesn't count for this discussion anymore. like that goes like I know there's ultimatums that do that but I think ultimatums are automatically removing the evaluation from where the base version of the game is. But I think ultimately only we as players are able to decide what the base version of it is. And it makes it a little bit hard to discuss the game online in some places because of that. But I don't think it happens enough to really sweat about it too much. No, I mean again, I've played with lots of different people and I've never sat down and then someone was playing what I felt was a different game,

right?

There these things are like along the edges really. Most of them there was a bingo that in Arkham Con they give out a bingo card for, you know, things that happened during the weekend and then you check off if that happened and one of the squares was someone saying, "I've been playing this card wrong the whole time."

Yeah. That's just that's just the nature of of the game that there's going to be small things like that. But I stress that it's small.

Yeah.

Terrible rules errors is such hyperbole. If you were going on or or me either of us saying something like we think that, you know, Olivier Bishop is this crazy overpowered ally and it turns out we've only been playing him and never spending four resources to play him.

Yeah. or not exhausting him to move. Yeah.

Or not exhausting him. Something like that, right? But we don't I mean a that's just we don't do that. There's video evidence of us playing these cards the way they're supposed to be played. Um but also we generally don't talk about evaluation of cards scenarios somewhat as well without playing them uh more than once. Right? So we're going to catch these sorts of things every now and then if we're making a mistake. Right? So, you didn't just say, "Wow, uh, Otherworld Compass is this banger of a card. I'm sleeping on it." And make a whole video about it. And then just someone says, "Dude, you're playing it wrong." Like that. It generally takes a bit more for us to have these kinds of comments. And you probably would have caught that whether it was someone else said something.

Yeah.

Right. In the comments and then you, you know, played it correctly and then had another thing to say about it later. But I don't think our our discussion about anything in this game is just so knee-jerk like that that we would be subjected to mistakes in a huge way.

Yep. Yeah. No, I mean

we all make mistakes like playing the scenarios for the first time, you're bound to miss something

and that's okay.

And one thing I've often said, I mean the Bible said it first, yet he who was without sin cast the first stone, right? Uh I I would bet money that this player is making mistakes that they don't realize they're making, right? Like everyone makes mistakes in Arkham. I have seen it firsthand, right? Like I'm watching some of the best Arkham players I know make mistakes in Major League Arkham, right? Like just like little misses or little things like that. And like they're all minor. Like it's a big difference between like again it's just like handwaving the enemy phase, but that's not a mistake. That's cheating, right? Like that's like

Luke Robinson.

Yeah. Well, he's cheating, but it's like that's like the big thing. I feel like there's such a big dividing line where this post is putting cheating and mistake in the same box. But like cheating is bad. Like if I was playing with someone who says, "Let's just have this enemy not attack this turn." I'd be like, "What are you talking about?" Like that's that's bad. Like that's that's against the rules. But that's like miles difference between uh I forgot to play a bounty. Uh but nothing else really changed. Are you guys cool if I play it? At the same time, I think that we should do that less. I think we should just sit in mist windows a little bit more. I think it'll make us better players.

Um fine.

But at the same time, it's a social game. We're going to be talking, right? We're going to be like joking around. we're going to be like, "Oh, I missed this because I was having too much fun laughing with my friend because I'm mean as a Dane is wearing a weird mask." Right? Like it's like one of those things where like that happens and we have to have a little bit of like forgiveness and like space to let those things happen. But

don't let them Yep. Yeah.

I want to say one more thing about this too that we should give each other as players grace for sure. But this idea that we're messing up like the setup of the game, sometimes the designers don't do these things super consistently anyway.

And to point to something like this as being so crucial for you played the game correctly or incorrectly is wild to me when I don't think the designers are consistent about like when do you draw opening hands versus set up all the scenario stuff. So, like if that's the thing that you care about, can I use a line of yours? Can I say go touch grass?

Like that one is not there. There's no I can't imagine anything that would change about my evaluation of cards or investigators if I happen to switch a couple steps in setup.

I can't think why that should matter so much. Yes, I know the information that it would give you if you're sitting there studying every card before you look at your opening hand. I get it. I'm just talking about the overall conception of the game. These big picture, you know, what do survivors do? What do rogues do? That's where this comment gets me so much as how can we talk about this game as a community in any way when people play differently? I my take on this is yes probably everyone plays a little bit differently but not so much that we can't possibly look at the same investigator and them as completely fundamentally different things.

Yep. Yeah. And I also do think that uh I just can't I agree with you 100% and I I don't want to add to it because I think it's just on the money but like I just I can't believe it was happening as much as this poster was saying, even in some of the comments, which we're not going to go in and read the comments because this is just like the the topic of this idea was what was covered here in this like this main the main body of the post, right?

But like I just can't see it happening as much as it is. So, uh like the simultaneous play,

I don't know. I just can't

Yeah.

How could I have played Carson if that was happening? like as a standard. Yeah.

Across every table. Like that just you don't do that. That doesn't make any sense.

Like maybe this person I mean again but even the thing like if I had to think of the percent I mean so if you ask me what is the percentage of Arkham players at 120 person con that uh did simultaneous play. My answer would be like I don't know one or two people who always play together and they're playing two-handed like they're playing two player together.

So it's like a fraction of a percent right? But I don't think it's likely that there was like 10% of people and this person got all of it. I just can't see it. But again, maybe I'm wrong. So again, if you have experienced that, if you were one of the people or you played simultaneously or you played simultaneously, let me know in the comments then maybe I can talk you out of it.

Yeah. Like please don't do this. And I I get that the everyone has sort of their own preference on like the weakness drawing is is a bit contentious. Like there was someone even on on your Discord, I think a few weeks ago, a week ago, who was kind of adamant about like selecting a weakness rather than it being a [clears throat] random one. And I'm like, that's not really the game, but okay. I'm not going to spend too much time.

Yeah. To me, I just I put that in the back of my head and I'm like, I cannot trust this person's analysis. It's like I think that's I'm I'm again, you're I'm the arbiter of my own fate. I decide it's like, yeah, that's like what I do when I see that kind of stuff. I'm like, "Okay, this this is I cannot bank on this person's evaluations being sound." Right.

No. Right. It's like, "You're not playing the game as I play it, so all right, but like I'm not going to engage with that." As soon as they are adamant about doing that, like, cool. All right. Bye. But clearly people do this and I I think it's it's okay if they want to do that, but they need to be upfront with other people they're talking to that they have some house rules and you should expect some house rules. I've just never heard simultaneous play be a house rule. That's wild.

Y

that's such a big change.

And and if this all truly happened to this person at Arkham Con and they had a rough time because of it, that's sucks. Yeah, that sucks.

Yeah.

But again, Yeah. I don't know. I don't know.

But I do agree like with kind of the initial part of this video when you said I get the I agree with this person with the if this is truly how people out in the community play like it is wild west out there and people do play well all kinds of different house rules and I again I know that people do have their own kind of styles I suppose. Um, then yeah, I agree. It's hard to talk about the game. I just don't see any people who are publicly talking about the game in the way that you or I or the Mythos Busters, anyone else who is recording their gameplay at all.

Mhm.

They're not doing this.

Yeah. I I haven't seen I haven't seen it. Like,

and if it is happening, please post a video.

Yeah. Like maybe when I was when I was learning, I probably made mistakes, right? Like there probably was stuff like this, but I can't recall ever just like doing anything. I I can't recall cheating.

Yeah.

Like

and I would admit it if I was at this point like I would say like, "Yeah, we cheated here." Like we never I never try to like I always try to shake the token bag. I never try to pull the same. Right.

I don't think I've ever rage cancelled an auto fail. I don't think I've ever done that. I know people do that. I don't like I don't like that either. Right. Take your lumps. I can't recall ever doing that. I think my biggest thing was I just stopped playing. I just was like, I'm done.

We we restarted our Carson Silus run, but we told people that, but it was we were upfront about it.

We didn't just post the gameplay that was the positive thing because and hide that we ever did anything bad.

And the only reason we didn't restart it because it sucked. Uh I restarted it because I wanted to do the chapter 2 cards like cuz you said I'm happy to go, but I want to play with these new cards.

And you were like, I'm fine to keep going with what we have. I'll leave it to you. And I said, I want to try. I want to play uh I want to play glassing and silus. Like I think it works so much better than what we had before. It was like it was a it was a reroll for not just bad but at the same time I think that r-rolling a campaign is totally within the rule structure of the game, right?

Oh, like we can count it as a loss. You know, if you want if you're keeping stats on which I'm not,

then we count that as a loss. It's just not everything gets published.

I mean, you also took a break. I think we came back and just started a new for that reason. That's fine.

And like I I've mulligan scenarios as well. Um but the only time we've ever done that I know Travis and Brenn and I've done it like three or four times in our life which is not lots if you think about all the scenarios we played.

But I think it's because like Binn or I or Travis died within like three turns and then the thought process was like we're making a video, right? Like let's do this again. But there was like there we also have a times where like we played the last king and Mark killed me as men on like turn five and I'm like I'm dead. You guys get to play without me. Right.

It's like one of those things where like sometimes we make decisions for um the the good of the video, but it's never like you don't die here, right? It's like if we're going to if we're going to make a decision to try again, it has to be from the start. We're not like trying to test again or skipping the enemy phase. Yeah.

Yeah. I I've retried scenarios where um there was some big fundamental rules.

Rules errors, too. Yeah. I also reset for rules errors.

Yeah. And I don't mean like we didn't move the hunter, you know, an enemy because I had hunter somewhere. I mean, like the setup was wrong or

I I don't know, like an enemy had a particular interaction that I missed for five rounds, you know?

That's I don't think that I mean, I think it's everyone's preference, but for me, I don't think it makes good content when you then realize halfway through that it should have been totally different, like really different.

Just start again.

Just start again. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. But like at a con, I'm never going to just be like, "We should start again." I mean, unless maybe everyone like someone died on turn two and I'm like, "You flew you flew here. Let's let's try this again." You know?

Yeah.

Yeah.

We thought about doing that with traces to nowhere because it went so badly at a certain point, but we recovered, but it wasn't again rules flubbing or anything like that. It was, you know, not having played the scenario before, but

yeah,

we got through.

Yeah. So, I mean, I'm sure I've like again going I've been recording Arkham for a long time. I'm sure you can find stuff that is um like little things where it's like I mean I probably I mean at one point I must have done something. I must have done some sort of like like hand wave where I'm like oh I I so one thing I even started doing was like I would always like click too much and I'd draw too many tokens. So, I then made a rule where I was like, I'm I'm only draw when I say I'm drawing a token that counts for the test. Like, I actually have to say it, right? Of course, that doesn't happen when you play in paper. That's like a digital only thing, right? But yeah, no, I mean, like again, I I I'm of the belief that I wish that the discussion of this game was a little bit like we had like I have to assume that everybody's on the same page, but it's not always the case for the rules, right? But at the same time, it's mostly I trust myself to do it. So that's kind of like where it comes in. And I I trust the people who I I trust to be doing it.

So like I engage with their opinions. Um it's why like for example, you Travis and Brin are the opinions that I I take the most stock in because I trust you guys to be playing the Arkham that I view to be Arkham, which is the rule book, right? and you've seen us play like you're not just taking

it on good faith, right? You are

there's evidence that it matches

again if I were if you suddenly watch me play two-handed or something and I'm doing something wild like simultaneous play. I don't know how you do that as one player, but you know what I mean? Like there would be like no turn order. I don't know. I don't understand it myself. But um if you if if we suddenly started playing that way or when we first started playing a few years back, you'd be like, "Yeah, no, that that's that's not that's we we can't engage on the game in the same level." And I would agree if I saw that out of you or anyone else.

Yeah. Yeah.

But I just don't see that. I just don't.

No. And yeah, we do a good job of keeping each other in check, too, for rules because again, you miss things. You miss things, but we're never like intentionally going out of our way to do things. Like I've never removed a auto fail from the bag uh to make it easier. I've never done it cuz that's not I mean we've made videos how much we love the auto fail. How important it is to the game, right?

Oh my Yeah, I love the autofail. And it loves me back. I think it seems that way when I have been playing recently. But yeah,

that's the game. That is what makes the game fun. So it's a shame some people are I just don't know. I I don't know what they're doing here. But

yeah, I'm taking them I'm taking this post in the good faith that it did happen. Even though like I have a hard time believing it was as much as it did. But if it did happen, that sucks. But if it did happen, I think it's also on us as players to be like, "Hey, can we not do that?"

Yes.

Yeah.

100%.

Yeah. That's I think like

the consent thing I was talking about before, just like

y

if you are sitting down at a table with people that you don't know, if you're doing something that you know is strange, then you need to tell people. And if you don't don't tell people, then you should be okay with people calling you out on it.

Yeah. And and likewise, if you are asking if it's okay, you have to be all right if someone says no, cuz

then you're not really asking. Like like you need to have a plan if someone says no to not do the thing that you're asking if they'll say yes, right?

Yeah.

I don't know what Beard was going to do because I think he only brought custom investigators. I I think the only thing you could do is just be like, "Uh, then can I borrow one of your decks?" That would be all the way. Yeah.

Yeah. But I'm not going to say no to Beard. His decks are really cool. Investigators are fun. So,

yeah. Yeah.

Like I'm I'm sure but I'm sure Beard would have had a plan in the back of his mind if someone did say no. Right. Like

Yeah.

Cuz I think that like Yeah. Maybe he would have wanted to chat and been like, "Okay, I'm going to go get take a take a deck out of the library." Right.

That's right. They did have decks in the library.

Yeah. So yeah, it's one of those things where I think [clears throat] that I I wish this person felt uh better to stand up in the moment than like but I understand it's hard but I think at the same time it's okay. And I think also that's where um if I was the event organizer uh and honestly the event organiz because I I know the Arkham con team are great. their organizers for that and they probably had the same opinion too where they could have come and been like hey yeah I'll I'll ask not to right like hey like you could come to me at the convention and I'd be like hey guys let's uh how about we take our turns like one at a time I'm I'd be happy to go to a table and say that yeah

yeah see let me ask you just I know this this video has been too long as it is but just on this sort of idea for your con if someone goes to a table and says I'm playing this infinite Wendy deck Would you allow that? Would the t would the table need to consent to that sort of thing?

Uh, that's a great question. So uh this is actually so like if you played commander with people in Magic the Gathering again as much as some people don't like Magic the Gathering infecting Arkham in terms of its lingo and all that and the philosophies there's a lot to learn from Magic the Gathering and EDH in commander is another thing we can do with that where at the table I think that you can be like hey this deck has an infinite are you guys okay with that? I would personally be okay with that. I'd probably only want to play with that deck once in a convention, but I'd be like, "Yeah, I'd like to see this infinite in action if you can make it work, right? As long as you're not like making me play the game while you're doing the infinite." That's what I would say as well, right? Like if you're just like sitting here drawing cards to find your combo, I don't really want to engage with that. But I think it's the same sort of thing where you say, "Hey, you should be upfront. This deck has an infinite. You might be watching me play for a little bit. Are you okay with that?" And again, if they say yes, it's fine. If they say no, you need to have a backup.

Yeah. Yeah, I agree.

Yeah.

I wouldn't want to not know that was coming. If I were playing with the table and suddenly this person just takes a turn that doesn't end, you know,

I'd be like, "Uh, yeah, all right. Have fun."

Yeah, that's the thing. That's what you do. If people have seen this in Magic um where it's like if the people don't say that they're in a commander game, a four-player commander game, if someone says if they hide the fact that they have an infinite wincon, sometimes they just say, "Okay, you win now. The three of us are going to keep playing, right?" It's like the same sort of philosophy. If you're going to surprise people with an infinite, don't be upset if they say, "Okay, just so you know, we're going to go down to three players now." Right? Like it's like one of those things where be open about it, right? That's why I'd also at the start be like, "So, what's everybody's deck doing?" I would just be like, "So, what's your guys' goal?" Right? And that's why like when I do patron game days, I have I give everybody their roles, right?

And while I can't do that at convention, I can't be like, "You're the flex, I'm the clover, you're the fighter." Right? It's the same sort of idea. It's like, "What's everybody doing?" Like, "What are your unique allies?" Right? That's another conversation you should have, right?

And in my experience, again, I've been playing with people that I generally know or people that those people have already vetted. I have to say that every time because I'm not always I mean, sometimes I play people I've never played with before, but this year was not that way. Um or sorry, people that I had no connection to. Um but yeah, I we all talked about it like who do you want to play? What decks do you have? How much XP are in your decks? And we kind of work it out pretty quickly like, "Oh yeah, this is a Norman deck that tries to use, you know, astronomical atlas." Okay, great. Sounds good. Do you have anything that fights? No, mostly getting clues. All right, then we go. Like, these aren't long conversations. This is less than three minutes. And then you decide on who you're going to play and you run with it. Sometimes someone asks, I don't know, I've got a choice between these two. What do you think makes more sense?

How about that one? All right, great.

Yep. It's usually not we we have the conversation. It's not a tough one.

Yeah. Yeah. But no, this um I mean yeah I think it's just also yeah a lot of people they don't feel confident to be able to say even if something is going on that they do not they feel is breaking the rules. They don't want to speak up about it. But I think it's totally fine because like in the situation with the men who never committed cards, even just been like, "Yo, uh, I'm men. I would like to commit cards to your tests. Why don't we slow it down?" Right.

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. But I understand it can be tough to do that, but you should have confidence to do it. So, cuz I think that

and other people probably should not be ignoring you at the table.

Yeah.

You know?

Yeah.

I think it% Yeah. Yeah, because it's one of those things where I don't know. I I'm I still have a little bit of doubt for the synchron uh the simultaneous play. Like I'm I'm I'm I just can't imagine like after the mythos phase going like, "All right, I'll see you guys in upkeep, right?" Like I just can't imagine that happening, right? I

I have to assume that it is something slightly different than what we're imagining is what's actually happening and they're just characterizing it as

literal simultaneous play. I agree. I agree.

I just don't know what it is.

Yeah. So, again, please

if you were at Arkham Con or you played games at Gen Con and you saw any of this, give us more context in the comments because I am curious about this. So,

I think we should end this here. This turned into an Arkham podcast. So, that's good. I'm going to call it that. We're going to be an Arkham podcast video.

So, uh thanks for watching everybody. Uh and again, uh please do not seek out this Reddit thread to comment on it. the co it's like uh three days of the time that we recorded this video, so it's already like in the ether. Um,

and again, if you are the person who made this this thread and you want to talk with me in the comments, I'd be happy to because again, I do agree with your original assessment how it's hard to find a proper evaluation of the game if people are approaching the rules in different ways. Cuz I do agree with that completely. It's something I've said quite a bit even in videos on this channel about how I don't like house rules for that reason and why I don't like to play with house rules for that reason. Um, and uh I I I I think that I'd be interested to hear more about what happened because again I empathize, but I I I just I find it so like it it reminds me like a I think you should leave sketch in Arkham where I just don't understand it and you're just like [snorts] what what's happening? Like you're just watching all these people play a game that you've never played before. So I'd love some more context in that. Um, yeah. Any final thoughts, Daniel, from you? From your side. Cool.

All right. Well, thanks for watching everybody. I hope you guys enjoyed this video. Uh, if you like the Arkham Podcast, let me know in the comments. This is a little bit of a of a weird one, but I I had a good time. It was a a topic I I do have a lot of thoughts and beliefs in. Thanks for watching everybody. Have a good one and as always, a

Progress saved