Skip to main content
Loading video...

Our Thoughts on Children of Blood | The Arkham Horror "Podcast"

Transcript 1:29:35

Hello everybody and welcome to an Arkham Horror podcast where today Daniel and I are going to be talking about Children of Blood. We have both finished our first run. Have you done one or only Have you done only one or have you done multiple at this point?

It's so short to ask now.

Yeah, I know, right? It's technically I've only done one complete run, but I've played the first scenario three times and the second scenario twice. I've done both the night and the day.

Nice. Nice. Um I've only played it once. Travis Burn and I, we uh did it uh uh Travis enthusiastically called it an Iron Man on Wednesday night where we ran through the whole thing in one sitting. And uh

honestly, I actually enjoyed it. It was kind of fun to just like start a campaign and finish a campaign that also was meteor than uh for example like um Brother of Ash or Knight of the Zealot, right? because I think we can both agree off the hop that this is like a meteor sort of experience. Overall, I don't think it's like more complex than like the complex moments of the starting scenario can be a little bit there. There could be some stuff there that can be a little bit daunting for new players, but um I enjoyed the idea of coming up with a deck, playing the deck, and then finishing the deck. Um on

you want to start there with our discussion? I think that's an interesting like new experience. Um

well actually what I want to start with I think that's a good place for us to like bite into like for the media to bite first, but I want to actually because this on my channel I've shared my review where I'm overall positive on Children of Blood. What are your thoughts after your first Blind Play?

Um like just a simple positive negative or

Yeah, just like a general vibe. Is it passing the is it passing the smell test?

Yeah. No, it is. I have enjoyed playing it and that's always a good thing. So I have some criticisms and thoughts like in general about like how this fits into

I don't know these other points like is this a what's the experience like sitting down playing it in a weekend or in just one sitting or over just a couple days um versus a fuller campaign that we're used to. Um, I I think we can talk about that too at some point. But overall, I liked the scenarios. I liked some of them more than others. And that's a typical experience, I suppose. I can I'll save like the comments for each scenario when we want to talk about that or if you want to talk about just the I mean, there's only three to talk about, right? So, it's kind of weird.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's it's so much it's it's different. This is like we've never really done in-depth discussions on like the core sets because

I think they're just like they they as I said there was not a lot of meat on the bones. But I'm excited to dive in and kind of just it's a podcast so it's going to be kind of free discussion. I will also say right now if you're watching this and you have not played Children of Blood or you want to avoid spoilers, I highly suggest leaving this video um because there are going to be spoilers. We're We're not like the gloves are off. We're going all in. Uh I might even hear some slight spoilers for uh the day half of the New Horizon scenario cuz I only played the night half for that one. Um uh

mostly because uh I think it would be I think it'd be non uh it would be disingenuous to not also talk about that here because it is kind of a flip side of one of the other scenarios. So um

it's pretty similar.

Yeah, I I believe it. I believe it. It's not like uh for example the apiary for Drown City which has like a completely different finale depending on the side that you go.

Um but I I I want to ask you a question. So this now we can start biting into this. Um

I know that you are a player that likes to experience your deck over multiple scenarios. And I imagine that that is uh was kind of a one of your sticking points when it came into the idea of this of a three scenario campaign. and I guess even by extension a five scenario campaign. So, uh, how did that feel for Children of Blood? Did you feel like you were able to experience your deck over the three scenarios or is was your fear kind of uh like actually substantial in regards to that?

So, I think I can answer this partly by saying I've played Brethren of Ash probably more than you have, too. Um, I've played it, I don't know, maybe five, six times by now, and I quite enjoy it as a core set. Um, especially compared to the original one. I think there's a little bit more to enjoy there. So, I think my expectations of what is Three Scenarios like has changed since I first heard about the news because I now know what playing Three Scenarios is like. And I think this was no different from me going through Brethren of Ash. The only difference and I I know you uh have the same kind of feeling is that the scenarios are a bit longer,

especially I think the first two

and you do get to experience your deck more.

That said, as far as like going into these scenarios, the mulligan is hugely uh important. Like I do think you can get to all of your good cards eventually, but I played Carolyn Fern. This is the only one that I've played the completely through um Carolyn Fern deck and the first scenario I had like the dream opening hand. It was absolutely astounding. I had I think private practice. I had the cat book. I had I don't know if it was Dorothy. I don't think it was Dorothy. I think it was the the other ally. I had the the archivist and like an emergency cash or something. And then eventually Oh. Oh, and her signature which is kind of important. So I was just like cool. Uh, this is all I ever need. We will play these five cards and we will win the scenario. And we did. Um, scenario two, I think I got like half of that and it was fine. And then third scenario, um, I think I had like no healing, just never drew into it and whatever. We just did book v shroud for a while. And that is what happens when you play a deck in three different scenarios. M

uh so there's that half of it. Then there's the half that people say about like upgrading your deck and getting

all of that part. I will say this is a pretty low XP campaign compared to I don't know like dream meters where you play four scenarios and you get a lot right off the rip.

Yeah. It's design sensibility was not like dream eaters where it's like here's 12. I mean like it gave what? Like I what's the max in the first scenario? Is it 10?

It's eight.

Eight. Okay,

but you could get I think it's just eight because if you fail then you get more but then you don't get the Julia XP. And of course you get five if you're playing on hard. Hard also has some extra enemies set aside that have VP that standard and easy do not.

So I think it's really just eight on on standard.

So like that's about like waking nightmare which is like the lower side of the like the average experience for dream eaters. And I think we consider that to be like on the lower end for like the dream

scenario of TCU is just circle and done, sorry, is eight. Like that's just

that's what you get at the beginning and that's fine. Uh but usually you're progressing towards something. I I find myself also, you know, having played these a little bit in a shorter compressed time frame in between I'm just like what's the best card I can put in here? I don't know. Deduction level two, great. Let's go. And then you just play the next scenario. So, it almost felt a little like Iron Man uh when we weren't like agonizing over agonizing is not the right word here, but you know how it is sometimes week to week you're you're thinking about like you know maybe I really want this instead. I know you're the kind of player who you make your deck upgrades at the end of a scenario and then you don't think about it again for a week.

Uh but I'm not that way and other I know a lot of the people like change their minds after a while and uh this was there was like almost no point in doing that because I with three scenarios I didn't feel like I needed to reach a uh you know a combo deck something where I was like really invested in something working cuz a I wasn't going to get the XP and b it might not come together and oh well we're just playing the scenarios. So, I think I focused much more on these scenarios themselves rather than what the deck was doing. And that's fine. Like it it it's like to me my experience was very much like playing a standalone that had multiple parts and you just

like Guardians of the Abyss. Yeah.

Yeah. Exactly. Right. You focus on like what the initial deck is. You get most of what you want going on there. There's some upgrades that you can put in that are cool to try out. Um, but ultimately you're not gonna it's not evolving into something else.

So, one thing I'm actually curious about, I actually want to check out this for

Guardians of the Abyss Scenario pack is what they called it. I'm actually kind of curious now if there was like a a mental thing where if Children of Blood was called a scenario pack instead of a campaign,

a small campaign.

Yeah. Would that have like changed things? And I'm kind of like like like the mental like the mental reaction to it. I'm sure there would people who'd be like, "Why aren't we getting a campaign this year?" I think like that'd be one of those things. But honestly, there's people already saying that in regards to uh Children of Blood. A lot of there's a lot of people out there who don't view it as a full campaign. And I know you're in the comments writing that comment right now. I I know you. I see you. I see you every week when we post one of these videos. And I'm listening.

Yeah.

Um I think that there's a very good point though about how um in a three scenario campaign, your deck is definitely more susceptible to the mulligan. Um, I I played Joe Diamond for ours. Uh, and

it's it was one of those things where like it's like if you play an investigator with built-in draw like also like Marie Lambo, I imagine it very similar. I always was able to do what my deck wanted to do even after a mulligan, right? So, I think that is a pretty interesting thing to consider, especially if they're going to continue to make small campaigns. If they print an investigator like say for example Marie Lambo and Amina Zadane brought the exact same deck to Children of Blood. Uh I think just inherently due to the power level of investigators uh Marie Lambo is going to have a much easier time and I think that that is worth a consideration when it comes to design sensibilities of investigators going forward. But so the wacky part, I mean, this is a a Joe and and Marie thing, too. Uh, for Carolyn, I saw my weakness in scenario two only.

Mhm.

And it came up on the last draw, unfortunately. So, I just had to eat the 2XP loss. Um, which ended up being that I had only what, nine, eight plus six. I think I only had uh 16 XP in the deck, which is that's not much. Um, and usually, you know, that can happen once or whatever and you're just like, "Okay, whatever." But in a small campaign, it hit a little bit harder.

Mhm.

But I didn't even see it in the other ones because I just didn't draw enough and I didn't really need to. I do feel like the chapter 2 investigators so far um are like they're good on the surface, right? Their abilities are are good. They've got pretty good stat lines. They're not We don't have any gimmick investigators, per se. Mhm.

My other two runs, I'm playing Andre and Joe, and yeah, it's like a different story because you you have much more draw in uh Rogue and you have Joe who just sees his whole deck. So,

yeah. Yeah. No, I think it's very very uh I I didn't consider that consideration because again, my experience was with Joe. Um, but I think that that's something that

I I think that for a first attempt at like a noncore three scenario campaign, I think that there are positives and negatives for Children of Blood. And I think that if they continue to explore those positives and maybe try to strengthen like the weaknesses, um I think that they have a good thing to continue to explore because realistically um if they ever like I know there's people out there who hope they stop doing the three snare campaigns and go to like two fives or I know people realistically want 28s if I'm going to be real with what I've uh gathered from the people who post stuff. Um I think that that won't happen for like at least another two years at the minimum, right? So we have at least probably at least one more short campaign um in the books.

Yeah. So let me like directly answer your question

which was like 10 minutes ago and I think the question was

I don't even know what was the question exactly.

Uh yeah. So like your your concern about like the uh not feeling like your deck is upgrading through it. like it's like one of those things where in a short campaign your concern was that like are you actually being able to experience and play your deck? Do you feel like that was an issue with Children of Blood?

Right. [clears throat] So my answer is that did not go away. I do appreciate that the scenarios maybe were a bit longer so I could experience it longer for the scenario. Uh but at the same time, no. But my mindset has changed to be like, okay, this is acceptable Arkham. It's different. And if you don't like different, then you might not like this for that reason. Um I think I would be more upset if there weren't other longer campaigns, too. But this is like this was fun to sit down and play in a short period of time and say, "Yeah, I I played Arkham. It was fun. and I got to do something with the deck, but it felt much more and maybe it's also because it's the a new campaign, but I was more focused on the campaign rather than the investigator development, if that makes sense.

Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, I imagine this might be something that after a few more plays, you might have a more solid opinion when it's like you get to that point that you and I get to when you've played a campaign so much, you're not really like the you're not really like playing the scenario. The scenario is happening around you because you understand all the mechanics. You know what to expect. Yeah,

that makes sense.

No, that's that's true. And I do think that Caroline, as the person that I played first through this,

she's so good.

Yeah. that it it made it easier to just be like, I have the five cards I need in play. We will use them. We will get all the clues and then, you know, do whatever else is going on. I didn't need to think more about it. And um this is maybe like a side comment, but I was talking with one of my friends who was we were playing this campaign with. And I know there's a lot of different kinds of players out there. Like what brings you to Arkham? What is the reason? What is the enjoyment you get out of playing this game? cuz there's so much, right? There's the scenarios,

there's the investigators, the deck building, the RPG aspects. There's so much going on that I think everyone has their own answer for that. And I think for the um like my answer when I kind of talked about this with him is I view Arkham Horror, the card game, as a card game. Like it's it's there in the title and I'm there to interact with my deck and all of that. That's interesting to me, especially because we play this game so much. Um, but for him like he's it's not a goal for him to see the majority of cards in his deck. Like that's not how he plays the game or is interested in playing the game. So I think a shorter uh campaign and a you know where you're not actually uh worried about this issue of like do I am I upgrading my deck? Am I seeing all these cards that I spend XP on? Um isn't that much of a bother. So for him, it's less of a primarily a card game and more of a narrative experience that he's using cards to interact with the game. And I think maybe part of the the reason why people have different opinions on this is because of uh what you're getting out of these scenarios, what you're getting out of the game itself, what brought you there, and maybe the frequency which you play also has something to do with that.

Mhm. I think yeah, that's one of those things where like um you and I are in a in a a slightly advantageous and also sometimes disadvantageous position where we uh can share an opinion and we get to then experience a bunch of opinions being shared back with us in the comment section, right?

And uh we see and we pay attention to these different comments and we can kind of like see how different people are reacting to this kind of stuff. if we get the general sort of idea, right? Um there are a lot of people who are vocally against a three scenario campaign. Um but there also are people who enjoy the smaller format. There are some people who said that I've seen people say that the eight campaign were too long, like they were too long for them to actually play with and the three scenario and then ultimately five scenario is a lot more appealing to them, right? Um, and I think that it's it's one of those things where uh it's I I think that if Arkham started like this, uh I still think uh I I think the game would still have been where it is today.

I don't think that ultimately a three scenario or eight scenario campaign is going to be the make it or break it in the long term uh of Arkham especially if they if FFG sticks to this four release a year schedule which is so much better than the two release a year maybe the three release a year schedule that we had but also like kind of handwaving the two things can kind of fluctuate between then. Yeah, I do wonder if there would be some differences in design or card design

um as we went along. Um the one thing that

uh who did who who you all playing in in your playing run?

Izzy, Andre, and then Joe. Okay, so one thing that I think is a little bit of a um I'm not going to say it's a bad design choice or anything, but we immediately got a three scenario campaign followed the three scenarios in Brethren of Ash and all these investigator cards that cost a lot of XP

in Rogue in um Mystic in particular, right? So, it's kind of a can you buy the red clock in this campaign? Probably not.

And that's okay. Like just put other stuff in your deck. to me. Bren and I actually talked a bit about this while we were playing

and we view it actually more of a red clock problem. Uh red clock probably should not have been included in the uh

in the the rogue starter. I think the rogue starter has a lot of issues in comparison to the other ones. Um and I think that that is quietly one of them, right? Where like it should have been like just two 5xP cards as oppos like like the card counts because there's only one exceptional. So, there's like some complicated math that comes with it afterwards, but

um I I I definitely view that as like a like I think like for example, buying a cosmic flame right now only one of is okay in both Marie and Dexter because they can find it. Yeah.

But um I think that in the long term uh that's a thing that's easily fixed by just more options, more spells in like further expansions. But Red Clock's always going to cost 10. And that's always an issue for these short these short campaigns. And I think that that was a it's like a cool flashy card, but I think that I I definitely agree with what you're saying. And I I wish that the rogue pack was a little bit different for for that reason.

Yeah. I mean, I think it's somewhat true of Mystic, too. I I know what you're saying, but like we also have Shadow Meld, not that I've played the card yet, and Second Sight at level five, and there's an exceptional card also that's six. Um I don't know, like having I'm fine with low XP campaigns. I think you and I are aligned on that respect. Like, I don't need to have 60 XP in my deck before I enjoy it at all. That's just not me. It's also more fun, I think, when you're, you know, there's a little more difficulty at lower XP um trying to do these scenarios. So, I agree with you, I think, on that one, too. But at the same time, like the card pool needs to reflect that. Like, they can't just

I don't know, like there there are perfectly good cards at level zero and one and two in those decks. and just to have some cardboard that's just not used because man, what's the situation that you're reaching for level five shadow melt? I I just don't know.

I uh don't get me started on that. I think that evade spells should just like only be 2 XP maximum. They could have done something else with it. Evasion is just like I know there's evade lovers out there. It's just not the way.

Evade heads.

Yeah,

I like evading too. the I don't know why they even even second sight five is is a pretty pricey

uh addition to the level zero card like you can get by just fine with the level zero card and all of your uh skill cards. So

yeah, I I I think it would have been ultimate like we're getting a bit from children blood here, but I think it is relevant because I No, I think you're 100% right though. I think it is relevant in terms of short campaign designs, but like I think that it would have been fine if Second Sight and Shadow Meltd did not have XP versions because I think they're both playable at level zero and Cosmic of Flame does it does need to scale up because that thing we talked about how enemies scale but clues don't, right?

Yeah.

Um because I think we both agree Cosmic Flame 5 is worth 5 XP. That card's a banger. Sure is. Right.

It is crazy.

Yeah. Second sight you can get by with level zero for the whole campaign. Um, okay.

Yeah.

Um, what did you think of blood tokens?

Uh, they're cool. I I like them quite a bit. Oh, I think I'm the one causing the flashing. No, you're c causing the flashing. Okay. Um, I think they're neat. I think that there's I mean, first let's like get the elephant out of the room of you and I have both played Beard's custom campaign, Circus X Mortise, right? And the moon tokens in that um are reminiscent, right? They have a lot of similarities. And if you're using the digital version here, we, you know, just borrowed some

Oh, yeah.

the the moon token helper, it's down here. It's now the blood token helper. It's literally the same thing because it works the same way. Um I'm I know that that's just

there are some easy things to design, I think, with no tokens. So, this isn't like a someone stole from someone else. We know that's not the case.

Um, but I think they were a really cool addition um to the campaign. Like you notice them especially by the end

and it's like a mini curse that you can't get rid of. So you're doing different token math than just the I need to be up by four on standard. So I like that.

Can I ask a question uh to see if it was similar to my experience with blood tokens? But compared to frost tokens, did you have more fun putting blood tokens in the bag? Cuz for me, the shorter campaign made me feel like the stakes for these were lower. And the game was like, "Would you like to put in two blood tokens?" And I was like, "Hell yeah, I'll do that. That sounds fun." [snorts]

That's an interesting question. I hadn't thought about it like that. Um I mean, certainly the frost tokens represent something else. Like they always seem to be bad.

Yeah.

Um and there's that autofail part, right? Like you draw two Frost tokens and you automatically fail a test. So the confluence of those seems worse than oh I'll take another minus one. What's the worst that can happen and you you end up failing tests from that. But uh yeah I mean I I like in retrospect yes. I think I was more likely to put them in. Although in the first scenario there was a treachery that said either take two or put put a blood token in. And I know I was playing Carolyn, but in the other two runs, I was not putting that blood token in. It was horror every time.

How did y'all experience that one?

Yeah, I I remember when I drew that first one, and I was like, Travis, just so you know, I'm putting the blood token in because I want to interact with the new mechanic. Um,

and I actually think the blood moons, that's the blood moon treachery, which we can now go up here to this thing where if we can type in blood moon. Whoa, that's this one right here. I like the design on this one because I think that like um because this is this only in the first scenario.

It is. There's three copies, I think.

So, it's like designed to kind of load the bag up. I'm curious to see how this one feels versus standard and hard, which is such a cool thing to say that's never been relevant before in like Arkham Conversations because there's a bunch of locations in the first scenario that you can like burn down and add blood tokens and on hard you have to put in two, but on standard you only have to put in one. Um,

so I'm kind of curious to see how that feels.

Blood tokens in.

I was all about that. This one I'm like, I could take the horse or

Yeah,

for the locations I definitely was. Let's just

load up the bag, please.

Here, let's even set up the scenarios. Let's go through the setup thing together. Oh, I need to probably click F11. Uh, there we go. Yeah, cuz I had it all hidden. Uh, do you want to restart? Okay, standard difficulty. Two investigators, me and Daniel. There we go. So,

let's go.

Yeah, there's these uh like the waterfront warehouse locations. Uh if there are no clues, you can uh put it beneath the location, put the put in the victory display, add a blood token on a hard, you have to add two. This is really good because it gives less place for Julia to hide in the first uh

scenario, which is a relevant a relevant thing to to keep in mind as you are playing.

And then there's also

perform a ritual to cleanse it. Yeah. And then uh unvisited aisle has a similar thing, but you don't get rid of it. But you get the sacrificial dagger, the fang of Zubura Morte. Y but yeah, I think that the Yeah, I felt like uh I think with the blood moon, I think the effect here is actually really interesting. And I think it does scale to the difficulty that you have cuz I think in standard I'm most likely to just be like I'll my first one I see I'll probably just add a blood token because I think by the end of the campaign it wasn't the blood tokens weren't really an issue because the the the the design philosophy on the blood tokens in practice is that they're only a problem once and then they're kind of just on you, right? And it's that's at least in my first play how I found like yeah if I fail a test from a blood token that's bad but then it's like gone and it's kind of like removed for the foreseeable future.

Sure. Yeah. It powers up other cards but like that was kind of the design. That's kind of like the gameplay principle I was going in. Um but I'm curious to see how that changes on hard expert difficulty when I come times comes to play that.

Did you get the weakness?

Uh Travis and Brenn did. I did not.

Okay.

Yeah. that that's an interesting weakness that interacts with blood tokens in a way that I did not anticipate until I saw that.

And I don't know it it there there's a lot here I think with the blood tokens. So maybe you're right with um hard it's different too, but I was still I was kind of interacting with them. I mean not just with this but also with other uh effects in the next couple scenarios. Um, but I definitely did fail a good chunk of tests where it was blood token into minus four because I was just unwilling to to go up five every single [clears throat] time.

Yeah.

And that's that's cool. I I do like that. I I wish there was a little more more interactivity with how you get them off of you.

Mhm.

This is kind of the biggest one. And then there's some token effects that get rid of them. Um, like in this one, the Elder Thing token does it, but I wish there was a little bit more. Maybe I have that expectation coming from Circus where it was basically free choice. You keep them or you don't at the end of the round.

Uh, I mean, there's a negative to releasing them, but they always gave you. And in this uh campaign, it's a little different.

Yeah. Yeah. That's where like the the mechanical like um Yeah. Cuz like really like Yeah. Blood and Moon are tokens are similar in the fact that they both seal on your investigator and they cascade, right? Like and that is ultimately like where the similarities end. Um,

and it's it's I think they both obviously I think Moon tokens are great. I actually really enjoy blood tokens. I said in my review, I'd love to see them again. Um

Mhm.

because I think that they are cool and I think blood is universal enough like they could be used as like sacrifice like if it's like a ritual themed thing like blood could come back.

Um and I would I agree. I think that they are open enough that you could explore many different ways to interact with them, right?

And with only three scenarios and we you've talked about this a lot with dark matter. Um there was a lot of space to iterate on and explore the design. I think they, especially since this is kind of the first campaign and one that includes new tokens, they might have had to dial back some of their other ideas of what to do with it, but I think it was enough for a three scenario campaign to explore these things. So, I Yeah, I agree. Let's get another one out there so we can try something else.

Yeah. Uh, also there was

What do you think of Oh, yeah. Go ahead.

Oh, no. You go. You go. You go. Well, I just wanted to ask you about this first scenario in general because it's sitting out here. Um, I this is the one that I've played three full times now and I think this is a banger. I think this is a very good opening scenario.

Mhm.

And I might have enjoyed it the most of the three. Maybe because I've played it three times, but it is um I think extremely tightly designed. Everything felt like it had a intentional purpose that I understood and I I don't know like there was a lot of good stuff. I have like a nitpick with a couple of wording things on the agenda but uh whatever like in general this is a was a very interesting fun first scenario that um not like in the top tier like it didn't have quite the stress of pit of despair that always is uh you know like is this going to work out or not? Mhm.

Uh but this one had stress in terms of it kind of came down to the wire every time I've I've played it. The third time especially, but it uh it has some teeth. You have to figure out the puzzle. Uh, I think that I've so I've only played all these scenarios once for I'm just going to kind of put that caveat here at the start of this, but um there's something about this scenario and actually this whole campaign and the story that it tells through its scenarios that is very interesting to me and I've been stuck on it since I've played it and it kind of just feels like it's there more and more. Um, but this is such an unconventional story for a start of an AR Arkham Horror campaign. Um, this is like if we're playing in like a full campaign, this would be like scenario three or four, right?

Yeah. where

like in the first like story beat of a eight campaign eight scenario children of blood campaign we would be like in the woods and there would be a dead body and then there would be vampires right and we'd be like eads there's vampires right then in this second scenario we would go into the library and we would read a book about vampires and then we would connect with someone who is like Julia Stern is my wife and she's a vampire, right? Um,

so it kind of feels like we are more directly thrust into a story, right, in comparison to some of the other things. And I feel that mechanically the scenario also functions the same way. Um because even though like I mentioned at the start how I think that as a whole these scenarios are all mechanically they're not that much of a jump up from um Brethren of Ash. I think that this is a really good first scenario for new Arkham players right who uh if they just play chapter 2 Corbox and just come to this it's going to be really good. But there's a lot of like small things that I mechanically really linked in where it's like you have to keep the waterfront civilians alive, right? Like that's a little bit more mechanically complex. There's the snare and the fact that I think um that uh no, one of these are going to be Julia.

Where where you hiding, Julia? Head down in the alley. Um, this is a intense enemy for a new player's first scenario, right? After Brethren of Ash like

a lot of keywords,

lot of keywords. Realistically, you can say that this is very similar to uh Ghost Rider, right? Where it's like it's has the same sort of it has retaliate, it has a lot of health, it has a high attack value, a high evade value. But [clears throat] in comparison to that, uh, Julia is more of like a puzzle enemy, right? Like this is a puzzle scenario as opposed to just like a straightforward kill the bad guy scenario.

Um,

and and like all these scenarios, they do kind of have like a similar story beat where it's like find the bad guy, kill the bad guy. Like every three for this have that. Um, and I can definitely see how that's like a positive and a negative for the storytelling thing, but I think it all kind of makes sense for the story that this campaign was trying to tell, right? Um, but I I I know that this is a very roundabout way of answering the question about if I enjoyed this scenario, but my feelings on Children of Blood have been evolving in a way that I did not expect them to where I'm actually feeling um that there is a lot of thematic complexity that you can feel in this campaign um through the way that it tells a story that I'm of the belief wasn't possible in an eight scenario campaign. Um, and again, I don't really know why that is yet. I'm still kind of working for it, but I talked about this a bit in my review where it's like the pacing of the scenarios and how the story is told over the three scenarios. Um, and like how I said like this feels like this is the fourth third or fourth scenario in an eight scenario campaign.

And we've never really had that sort of pacing,

but it really does feel like we're we're skipping over the boring stuff and just getting to like the three big story beats, right?

This is partly why to me it felt like a standalone. Did I tell you this like before you played last week?

Nope.

Did I mention that?

No. Okay. I was I I spared you my earliest thought, but I I my after having just played this one and given it's a relatively longer Doom clock with, you know, one kind of Ancient Evils effect, um it felt like playing a standalone because there is that thing you're working towards, but they don't they're like, you said it yourself, like they cut out the boring stuff and standalones generally have to have a little bit of setup time, but you're working through some bigger goal. And I found this to be like a more collaborative. Again, I played it in two and three player. Solo is another beast this scenario. I don't know how it works in solo, so once I try it, I can say more, but there's something weird here in solo. Anyway, um it felt really much like a a set piece in in three player where there was a lot of enemies around cuz I think elusive is used extremely well here. Mhm.

And uh there's this unvisited aisle business that sometimes you fall off the bridge to go to. And but mostly right from the get-go, it is you're finding Julia. She's hiding in one of these layers. And you have ways of making there be fewer vampire layers. So she pops out somewhere that's more predictable. Um and eventually you get to the point where you say, "All right, we can do it. We've got all of our our ability to put snares down. The map is clear enough for us to do this." And then it's it's uh time to go to work. Figure out after I hit her with my machete or something, where is she going to go with elusive? Am I ready there to put another snare on her? Like thematically, there's a lot going on which is really fun and was enjoyable for us in every playthrough to figure out and have everyone contribute in ways that I don't think we've really seen with uh with bosses before

cuz they're contributing different ways. It's not just spend a clue for three damage. Yes,

it's actually spend a clue to let other people do damage. So, everyone's important

and then it becomes like how can we most reliably use these snares to like get the damage. I think I I agree with you completely uh on all those points.

Uh this you and you talking there kind of gives me the this

this is a very reminiscent scenario of Rugaroo, right? Where there's this thing that's like you have to solve a puzzle of how do I beat it? uh the puzzle. This one is a lot easier, but I think that there's a lot of really cool moving parts around it. Um and I think of course one of those as well is like the the civilians, like you said, the elusive, like the predator stuff. I think that there's a lot of really cool stuff with that. Um

also, so you've now played as well, um and we're going to load in a bunch of cards here, everybody. Give us a second. So you've played this now two-player and three player. This was the first time that I can recall. I mean, I'm sure they've done something like this before. Um, that I just can't remember right now, but the extra encounter set for three or four players.

Yeah, there's two copies of Rotting Remains, which is interesting instead of the usual three. And then there's I don't remember the name of it. It's the one where it uh includes

like it checks how much how many blood tokens are on you. Frenzied hunger. No, this is the one that Oh, no. This is like the the frozen and fear. And then there's one more.

Yeah, you're right. So, seven cards. Seven cards is a lot.

Yeah. But the thing is like I think the theory behind it. I'm just trying to find the last one cuz we I only clicked two players so it's not going to be here. But I think the design theory behind it makes total sense. So, this is something that you and I have talked about in the past where in um in three players you can kind of get through the deck quicker, right?

Yeah, exactly. And it's nice to like have the deck be bigger and then also have these like threatening cards to balance it out a bit because in three and four players the game is generally easier because you'll outtempo the game in the long run. So I'm just going through and trying to see if I can find this last one. Um, but I actually loved the addition of this because I think it's then kind of fun when I'm going to play this in two-player where it's going to be like, oh, I don't have to worry about running remains in this run because here it is. Torturous transformation cuz let me tell you, uh, this this this set was very relevant in our blind play of this campaign.

Yep. Mhm. It's interesting that the last one where if you have three blood tokens, which happened to me, you're Yeah. It just happens.

Yeah. Yeah. Take a damage, discard a card at random. Yeah. I know you hate that line of text and like Yeah. It's a spooky thing. And I mean like but also like this card like it hits on all three, right? I think all three modes it does

are relevant for its own reason. Um,

there's another card I think that doesn't hit unless if there's no blood tokens in the bag, and I don't remember which one that was, but

I just kept reading for it to have surge and there wasn't. But yeah, this is this is a good one.

Um, what do you think of two copies of Rotting Remains versus three? Do you think my my theory crackpot theory here is uh only two and also two copies of Grasping Hands um in the normal encounter deck is to keep you from comboing out. like this is intentional not to have three copies

you're less likely to draw both

especially since the discard pile doesn't shuffle back in I think in this scenario ever and probably rarely in the other ones.

Yeah, I think that this Yeah, it someone actually left a comment. There's actually only one moment where when new cards are added, you shuffle the encounter deck in and I think it's only for the final scenario.

I think that's right. Yeah,

everything else kind of just evolves over like the story is kind of evolving over the encounter deck that you have. I think that treachery and encounter deck design is incredible in this campaign. Um, I think it's one of those things where it's it's just like it's killer, man. And it's one of those things that you like I think that if you just start out, you might not feel the same sort of thing. Um,

those are the nasty.

Yeah. No, that's a mean ass car. And like I I I talked about this in my video. Did I talk about this in my video or did I talk about this just to myself in my bathroom? But how the um the the the the new core encounter sets make so much more sense because I think you and I even talked about how there's some heavy hitters, but overall I I think they're like softer than the original core, but like when they come together they're very powerful. And I think that's that works so well with the treacheries here where it kind of like sings like a perfect like it like they come together to tell like a perfect story and like fit very well with it and it makes them I think scarier because the treachery encounter cards are just they're so much more laser focused.

There's also like those damn bats

like the bat horrors

and then don't even get me started on aerial. Not this one. That I mean that card's also relevant, but like this aerial pursuit is a nightmare of an encounter card as well. All right. Like

it's funny when the waterfront civilians are grow wings and fly towards you though.

Yeah. They just like come and just take you out. Uh yeah, I want to bring up that because of the large encounter deck size, they have both Red Herring, which is from the core set.

Mhm.

And this one, Misinformation, which is a little different of a card, but it's a similar idea, which is just from Children of Blood. So, there's only two copies of each of them, I think. No, there's three copies of Misinformation. Um, so they did need to make sure that you weren't just getting by with, oh, you drew both of these red herrings, you're done with that issue. So they have kind of doubled up on or doubled down on this kind of effect, which is I think cool.

Yeah. Yeah. And I think they fit for like the scenarios they're in, right? So like we have the misinformation in River of Blood. Does it carry into the next one? Right. Like there's no misinformation here, but we go to the final scenario. So, let's check if it's there. Here's Charlie Kane. Everybody say, "Hi, Charlie." It's not in here. So, it's like one of those things where like you can see that the the whole pacing of the first scenario is like how can we slow you down, right? And I think that like the treachery design is so much more focused because of that and that like it's it's one of those things where like this this card would feel like unfair in New Horizons, right? But that's because clues are used differently in New Horizons compared to like uh what is it called? River of Blood. That's a metal ass name. But like that's like I think a really cool sort of design philosophy that we're seeing in action here.

Plus there's like a chunk of victory point locations. You're more likely to drop them on these, you know, if you're sitting on them too long. That happened a few times. You're you're on the unvisited aisle and you're saying, "You know what? Let's just get there's a lot of clues there. Let's just try to get them before we leave. We don't want to come back because you have to spend an extra action and then you just drop all your clues and say, "Well, I don't know.

What do we do now?"

Yeah.

Yeah.

I think just the design of this one was very fun. Um, really interesting. I I do think that the civilians are a little bit of a trap. They don't actually do anything.

Mhm.

Right. They're just here to kind of be in the way. Um, but if you're playing this one and you kind of figure out the puzzle, other than like maybe one moment, she should never be like attacking them. Like she's the only one with Predator.

Yeah.

So, you can make them go away if you want, but ultimately if you hit her or fail and she's just no longer ready, so she won't be ready to attack them in the enemy phase uh ever. But

yeah. Yeah. I feel like the um they're more there to give you the uh storytelling perspective of um there's innocent people who are dying, right?

I wish and maybe they had tried this and it was just too much for scenario one. I kind of wish they had patrol and they were like walking around town in a clockwise manner like in uh Fortune Folly. I

I would wager that that could have been that that was probably there. I think that's a pretty pretty good call.

Uh but yeah, just too much.

Yeah, it's one of these things where like I feel like um I mean obviously they they like this new doomed keyword and having like innocent people kind of hanging around, right? They kind of I think they really have vibed with that idea. Um,

but like I I view these as like if they were story assets that

like had the text if they are at the same location as Julia Stern when she is ready at the start of the enemy phase kill them right in a place of doom on the agenda. They're kind of like set dressing. They're there to make the scenario feel a little bit less empty rather than I think they are mechanically relevant. They're relevant for the free move

and for your scene of the crimes, but otherwise you're right that they're not they're not really enemies. I'm curious to see this scenario without these locations if I when I play on hard or expert because the free move is very nice. It's very nice

and it's one of those things that um I'm curious to see how the tempo feels in comparison to uh the standard versus hard. I think that that's going to be very interesting.

I mean, I think hard's going to be hard. I haven't tried it yet either. I'm interested but also kind of scared because it it's already been kind of close in scenarios one and two. I haven't been defeated but the people I was playing with. We had an almost total party wipe out in scenario two. So it's like am I ready? Is our group ready to play on on hard? Like in three or four player, I can see that you kind of need that a bit more cuz it truly to be hard, right?

But with the card pool as it is right now,

I think it's it's a bit of a challenge. So

yeah. Yeah. We we made a deal with the three of us that if we lost the campaign on standard, we would play it on hard legacy, but if we won, we'd play it hard chapter 2.

So we're playing hard chapter 2. Spoiler alert, everybody. Yeah.

All right. Uh,

anyway, good scenario.

Yeah, I'm gonna clean up the mess. Get out of here.

All right. New [snorts] Horizons setup. Standard two-player. Search during the night because that's the one that I did.

Mhm. This is with the night watchman. I love that they came back with the uh the night border.

Yes. That's really cool. Uh, it makes me kind of feel like I wish they did that in the first scenario as well, but I think the because that one takes place over days and nights, it doesn't feel as mechanically

the agenda the agendas are go between the different color borders, which is cool.

All right, we got some caves.

Yay, we love caves. So, the only difference in day is these locations up here. The ones at the bottom are the same. And there's slightly different encounter sets,

but generally it's the same idea.

That's the layer of Sabura Morte. Okay. Yeah. So then and then halfway through you get the boss at least on the night one. You get this guy who I saw [snorts] a comment which I think in in I I disagree with it but I think it's a fair thing and I'm going to point it out where like they said that this doesn't feel like an Arkham horror. This feels like a Resident Evil type enemy. Um, but at the same time, like I think that gives a lot of grace to some of the other random ones enemies that appear, right? Like

the catacombs, you know?

Yeah. Like Yeah. There's just the spectre of death. We have like the ooze guy from Paris who's just like a pile of sludge with a yellow cloak, right?

Right.

Um I think like or like the creature in Dunich, right? Like

Mhm. I think that there's like a lot of like the monster of the week type stuff. Those can be whatever the they are. At least for me. I think like I said, I think it's like a fair criticism, but to me it's kind of all there's always kind of been like this funky random stuff that exists in in Arkham.

Yeah, I don't really care too much. Like they have I give the designers free reign to pick what they want to happen in these scenarios. That's that's fine.

Um, as a side note, I I like I like New Horizon. I I think I like I said, I liked all the scenarios. I think I like the first two more than the last one. Um, just at least on my blind play. Um, but I can see myself liking the third scenario more on future plays. But I think that's something I need to kind of like experience.

Um,

yeah, we'll talk about that one some more, I think, when we get to it because it is unusual for a lot of reasons, which are could be good, could be bad. We'll talk about it.

Um, but I loved this guy. I thought that his lines of text were very menacing. Um,

yeah,

it's like this guy was actually, it's kind of one of those things where it's like when he appeared, it was like, okay, we need to work together to defeat him. I said, uh, my I called my prediction months ago where I said that the new core set feels more violent compared to the original core set, and my theory was that it's the intention is that everybody should be able to fight, right? And then by nature, everybody should be able to grab clues. And that's what Travis Burn and I did. And I think it's the correct way to go in this new Arkham because um let's say for example your Clover goes first. Suddenly the Night Watchman has chased this guy down, right? And is like corning him. Let's say your Clover goes second. Suddenly your fighter who has been fighting this guy is no longer with him, right? He's with somebody else. And I think that's like it's very intriguing gameplay uh that is a lot more interesting than just the uh here's a guy evade him and just beat him down. I think it's a really cool boss monster for a scenario.

I think that's true of a lot of the bosses here that evasion doesn't simply solve them which was I think a problem in chapter one. got to be a problem, which they had sort of solved initially in the first couple of campaigns and then they said, "No, no, that was that was too tough. You can't have the experiment ready all the time. You can't have Umardoth ready at the beginning of the enemy phase. That's just that's a bit much." This is more interesting. I will say this guy took out two people in first play of this.

Uh but that's more thanks to the retaliate keyword. Uh turns out if you're Daniela and you fail an attack and then you say, "Well, he's attacking me. I guess I'll hit back again and then a second auto fail.

Oh, you built your own attack twice, Matron. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah, exactly. So, um, you know, jokes on me, I guess, for making two videos about how much I love the auto fail. Uh, I mean, that's that's nothing you can do about that. That, but that's a it made for a very interesting end of the scenario where Carolyn had to use her her tricks to just finish things up as best she could and then resign. Um, this is a it's a it's a good it's a good enemy to drop in in the middle. The the daytime one also has something like this, but not quite as um

menacing.

Menacing is probably the best word, but also makes you do something else if you want.

Okay.

It's the guy who has the keys. You have to get the keys off of him.

Uh I also want to shout out this the cultist set for this campaign. I think they're great. Um, I think they're all relevant for different reasons, which I think is really cool. Uh, this one's the the the acolyte. Um, which is one thing that, uh, so there's this thing in Magic that like it's like lovingly referred to as bear with set mechanic where it's like the bear is just a common enemy and the set mechanic is the mechanic of that set. And these acolytes are acolyte with set mechanic, right? um cuz they have kind of like the basic sort of cultist that was in the core set, but they're not using them here because it's a little bit more interesting for the campaign if they have uh if it's necessary for not just an like a a cultist, an acolyte that puts a doom down. What if it was a bit more interesting and they actually interacted with the mechanic of the set?

And you kind of see that here with this where

this guy enters play to place a doom on it, but also you can drink from the cup and put some blood token on your investigator to not have the doom on it. So like there's a lot of player agency there with some downside downsides that like carry over with the other stuff in the set which I think is very cool.

Yeah, we never did this. We just said, you know, it looks so much like the basic acolyte from chapter one that we're like we know how to kill those.

Yeah. The other guy though, a little bit more interesting.

Yes, the he is the um wizard of the order. Uh but it's whenever a blood token is sealed on investigator, place one doom on it. So in theory, this guy could do nothing. Like he could just like just not be a problem. But then suddenly it's like, oh, I've sealed a blood token on him. Uh sorry guys. You know, like I get some some doom on this guy, which is like really really really cool. I think that it's like

it's threatening but not like obviously threatening but suddenly this guy can become a problem out of nowhere which is really cool.

Yeah. It doesn't have like the immediate oh I know how the wizard works. End of the mythos phase he gets a doom. We'll go try to get him before it matters. This gives you the it's like leaving nihilism in play. Right.

He allows you to make a mistake. Yeah.

Yeah.

Also this is one of my favorite art in this set. Uh it's fantastic. Yeah.

It's good. And then of course this carries over to the the climax of this one where you place doom on it equal number of blood tokens seal on your investigator which is also can just become a problem out of nowhere. Do you know what's scarier than like placing one doom on an enemy? Placing three doom on an enemy.

Yeah. Yeah. You went and left this guy out in the corner and then Whoops. Wait a minute. Y

gota go back. Yeah, they're good. And it is interesting because they brought the spawn at any empty location thing back versus the cultist in the core set which was just they're aloof at your location.

So I like that they have these cuz I I think they're more interesting for the this sort of design where you have a lot of locations they could go.

Yes. I think that like it shows that they're not like forgetting old effects and rather using them as like the specific tool for the job that they need to solve in that moment for that scenario which I think is

again I think that it's showing a lot of really good design sensibilities. I also What's about this one again?

Talk prey let's go.

Yeah. Yeah. I mean yeah they're giving you the tools to to deal with stuff as well. Um I also got to talk about the poor lamb. Um I because there's like um do we have any of the cards here?

Uh no. Cuz like I remember there was a thing we talked about in the new core how there's a lot of treacheries that like give you a choice when the original original ones didn't. Um and they instead decide to um have [snorts] those hard heavy hitters be existing in the campaign as opposed to the generic core. And then it allows the generic core to give you the choices where like these cards are still spooky, right? But they're giving you more agency. So these cards kind of become the soft cards of the encounter set. Um, which is a little bit alarming because I think these cards are still a little bit spooky, right? But

yeah,

it's very interesting to see it all in action. I do like that the doom mechanic is more relevant here because of the doom on other things. Although they gave you a pretty big honken agenda.

Yes.

14.

14. But it all adds up as we go to our final fight with Mr. Okay. I also have to shout out these blighted workers. I loved these guys.

Oh yeah, they're cool.

The flavor on them was really neat.

Up in in the the tunnel.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Uh but then we have Zabu Raort himself. Big daddy Zabu Raorte. So, I have no idea what happened with you. So, in my first play of this, uh took one look and said, "We're going to go resign." In the second play, one with Carolyn, uh

didn't even go in here. So, we didn't add the two blood tokens, but

yeah.

Um this is uh

this is a big guy. Big Z. Um I

I mean, did you guys defeat him? What?

We did. We did defeat him. Yeah.

Good job. It's uh we had like uh uh so I think yeah I think a big thing was the fact that all of us were able to deal damage to him, right? And like both Travis and Andre I don't know why I'm calling Brin Andre but like both Izzy and Andre could evade him, right? So then I was able to just like grab the clues and attack him. Like we basically like we all could do it which made it very like straightforward for us. Um but he is something man like this guy has once again keyword soup right

um

but it's all very relevant um for like all the parts of him right

so the one time I saw him and like we had thought about it

was in two player and that's what 8 plus 6 14 health

it's a lot um so we just I think we took one evade got the auto fail and said, "Uh, yeah, that that ended our chances, so we're leaving."

Yeah, I think we got we had no auto fails on it because I think that would have changed things immensely if this guy got one attack off from an auto fail on either the evade or like when we never attacked him while he was up, but like still the evade, right? He has alert.

Yep.

Um, does he have I think he loses alert on easy because there's one for easy as well. Um,

which I think is really nice again to have like those kind of things for players. Um,

it should be hard. Like I think this is it's a stretch goal I think in in this campaign and in this scenario. Like the only thing you're missing is the 2vP and they give you other VP like the other locations get it. Like you can get away with just noping out here and it's fine.

Yeah.

Um

I think a big thing that helped us is because this was a fight um on the thing I had two vicious blows for the attack. So

successful. Yeah.

That that like that we got very lucky with that as well. And I think that like that's one of those things that I think once again once you get like that campaign knowledge. However, I will also say Travis Burn and I are the strongest in our blind plays and next time we try this guy's going to kill us. I know that for sure.

In hard heals a flat four.

Yes.

Instead of one per player.

Yeah.

Which is a bizarre choice to me because that's the same as in four player.

Yeah. I mean, I I'm I'm I'm fine with them like making things hard on like hard. Like I know it doesn't scale up to four players, but I think uh it's I I love when I saw that text, I was like, "Oh,

no. I I think it should be hard, but like I just think of the solo players as what?"

Yeah.

And maybe like you can't balance solo with these harder difficulties. Like it's already playing on hard, I think. So, but yeah, I mean just it's double on two-player, which I think is fine, but four times the amount on single player.

Yeah,

I don't know. Like, they they could they could do better.

Now, to me, that's a big like put the cross up and be like, "All right, brother. You're out. I'm out. I'm out. You got this. I'm going to go upstairs." Yeah.

But overall, Yeah.

Yeah. This is cool. What do you think the manager's office business?

I like it. I like the stuff. Um Yeah. Because how do you do it? Yeah. And this one you have to steal it from storage. So you have to add the extra blood.

You need to steal it from the guy who's not this guy.

And it's actually kind of interesting. That's essentially the only difference

is about how you get into the office. Locations have a little bit different text, but not really. And the encounter cards are there's fewer enemies in the day. Like you get the uh knife feeders here, right?

Yes. Yeah, you get the knife feeders.

These guys are big.

They're big. Yeah. like they're all it's they're all relevant. You actually one thing that I think is really cute is the vampire enemy from Miguel's in of evergreen starter follows was a hint to these guys because they have the same sort of mechanics.

Um

yeah, they do.

And that's who Travis had for his random basic which I think was kind of cute.

Nice. Um but yeah, no, I think this is a a good scenario. And the one other thing I I kind of criticism, but it's not that big of a deal. In so this is the connecting one, right?

Yeah.

Okay. So in hard you need to spend actions in order to put them into play.

Mhm.

Which is you know they're they're putting pressure on action compression which I think is probably where we've talked about this in the full card pool you get so much more of.

Yep.

Right. Um, but what surprised me kind of the other direction is we saw in Brethren of Ashtriged ability to move, right, for one and and two players.

I feel like this sort of location should get that

uh on standard anyways because

what order you go in in these caves sort of matters. Not like hugely hugely, but

um this is like the unspeakable oath, right? or you go down as the basement and then you have to bounce back and forth

to uh

get through like you want to go to this one last of course.

Yeah.

Um but

yeah, you you need movement in this scenario for sure.

Yeah, I think that's a pretty I think that's a pretty good um

sort of uh criticism for this because I think that like on easy standard those options it wouldn't hurt to have. Uh, I kind of like the idea of g of hard being gloves off every time, right? Where it's just like,

yeah, that's fine.

Yeah, no matter what, you're going to get the hardest thing that we have to do, even if it is like mathematically a little bit unfair. But I I I can get behind that logic that this should have um a little bit more uh

just because we got that in in Brethren of Ash and I don't think we had any of that in this campaign which was a little I mean you have it in the in the first scenario just built in period but none of the player count scaling part. I did love this uh oneway connection business though. This is cool.

I think this is actually something that now looking at this that Travis Burn and I definitely mucked up uh in our blind play. Yeah, but

I think it's neat. It helps you a lot with the enemies that they can chase after you this way and then you give them a slip and go up through.

Yeah, it's one of those things. Yeah, actually I think I think we might have had a It might have been both positive and negative for us as a up. But it's not a blind play unless you up at least one thing.

No, it's true. I missed in the very first time I played the uh first scenario, I missed that this the dock workers all spawn in empty locations, so they loaded up in one location.

Yeah. just there on their lunch break.

Yeah, exactly. It's like the picture of all the people sitting on the the the beam, you know, above New York.

Yeah.

All right. Uh Blood Money, this is a strange scenario. So, I I want to repeat what you said in your review because I think it's relevant and interesting that the pacing of this campaign is uh not what we've come to expect from this game where you put you said I think you fight big monster, you fight bigger monster and then you fight biggest monster, right? Mhm.

And this is this scenario is like after you fight the big source of the blood is in the last scenario. So that guy is the biggest monster and now this is the aftermath essentially. You're I think thematically Nick talks about it in the epilogue as well as being like well who's really responsible for this nonsense? It's the the rich guy in his penthouse, right?

Yeah. And you said this is kind of like growing up. This story is a little bit more complex than just a uh escalating threat in terms of health and everything else. Um which I respect. I think this is an interesting take and I also respect that they tried something a bit different here. Uh, I think you also alluded to Forgotten Age as being similar, that Yig was the thing to fight in scenario seven, but scenario 8 is not. You don't see Yig there.

That's kind of like the It's like wrapping up the story,

right? Exactly. And that's kind of what this is, too. Now, I think I understand and respect that and still have the question of, well, a, is that right for an Arkham campaign? you know, like if you're reading a book or watching a movie, it's almost like you get the epilogue which ties things up.

Um, and the answer could be yes or no.

And then also, is this a good implementation of this idea, which could also be yes or no?

I would say no. I I didn't I think there's something off about this scenario and the pacing maybe just sort of throws me off at the beginning. Um, because it is a little odd. like you might have expected this as a scenario like two or three in a normal campaign, but here it's showing up as the finale and it feels it's different and that's okay. It can be that this isn't really the typical finale where you expect um that they throw everything at you right from the beginning, you know, like the stress we have in Before the Black Throne. Um, even in Carcosa where you're thrust into sort of the big set piece, you immediately take a bunch of horror and you're like, I don't have time to just sit around and talk to party guests.

Mhm.

And that is what this scenario is. It's a very strange one because check out the encounter deck here at the beginning. Let's look for the enemies. Oh, there aren't any.

Yeah,

it's just more suspicious guests. The uh treacheries themselves, they are just the ones we've seen before or they are from the core set. There's nothing like escalating that we saw in say piece of hemlock bail where those are just heavy hitters um right away. Again, doesn't have to be a bad thing. It's just something that's clearly different about this scenario. I'm just not sure it works on its own terms either. So this first act here where we had a Dianiela who was a fighter and she's like what do I do? I can spend resources to talk to these uh guys and that's fine but also I have like the rest of my turn and it was strange.

Um what did you think of this this first part and then I'm gonna say something else to sort of

wrap this idea up.

What do you think? My my thing is was a little bit mechanical of the idea was that um I was a little bit confused about who I wanted to talk to first and I wish it was signposted a little bit better.

Okay.

Uh cuz I went to talk to her first.

Ah

and then I was like what do you mean I have to talk to her four times? I was like that's awesome.

I was like that's that's like abysmal. Like why would I ever want to do this? Right. Um, and then we talked to one of these guys and we had the token sealed and I was like, "Oh, that's how we do it."

We got lucky. I I kind of nailed it. I went and talked to these guys first and I said, "How many times should we seal something onto her?" I said, "Probably three sounds about right." And it was like my Arkham Spidey sense went off and that's exactly what you need to do.

Yeah.

Um, and I kind of liked reading through the codecs here and talking with them.

I thought that was pretty cool. I liked it uh as well. Um because it's kind of like a slot machine to how it goes. Brin drew like four auto fails talking to them which was really funny. He kept biting them and they bit him back. Yeah,

that's funny.

Um I I will say that um before we move on to the next part, I something what you're saying resonated with me how like it felt strange that this is how this it starts when the how the last one ended. And I feel like that is a sort of dissonance that your investigator is actually feeling that you and the player are now actually feeling as you're playing the game where it's like, did these not know that there was a giant bat underneath the meat district?

And I feel like that there should have been like some sort of way to show that desperation as an action. So like for example after you parlay with one of these guys maybe there's a reaction effect where you can reveal another symbol token but it defeats the suspicious guest right so like you can like rush through it at a cost but it's that idea of the suspicious the guest is ignoring you but you can be like no man like there's something in the new horizon meat packing plant right and I think that um I think thematically this makes sense where Um, you have this like it's supposed to feel a little bit off-putting to go from this horrifying discovery to this calm, quiet party, but I think mechanically it it's missing that one little thing to give you a little bit of agency and to feel that stress through like an action in the game.

Maybe even the treacheries could could do that. I think this scenario also brings back the uh yeah the afflicted encounter set. Strangely the second one doesn't have any boost for three or four player.

I thought yeah rotting remains etc. is in here.

I don't think so.

Oh well Travis put it in. We got a little bit by that.

It's in there anyway. Just by default.

Oh it's in by default. Okay then that makes sense then. Okay. No then that's good. Yeah. Okay. Then we did it right.

You did it right. It's just it's not a bonus. Um, okay. So, I'm going to say something.

Mhm.

You can just kill her.

Let's go.

You remove her from the game. You advance the act.

Yeah.

You don't need to do anything else. You just go kill her.

Yeah. Yeah.

That it might just be an oversight. Like this is why I think earlier when you said these people are just story assets. They shouldn't be enemies.

Yeah. But you take your one doom, which it would have taken you several rounds to spend all these clues anyway, and you move on.

Yeah,

there's they never bring up Priscilla again.

Yeah,

there's no consequence for doing this other than the Doom.

I I'd argue there is a consequence for doing it.

All right.

You as a your uh player, your character in the story has just killed somebody, right?

Yes, that's true. Yeah. And I I think that that actually is an interesting choice because I would never choose to kill her in any of my games because of that reason.

I mean, I I feel like I'm ignoring something about what they want us to do here, but just like the way it's written,

it's feels like,

yeah, it just should be a story asset. Um or they, you know, maybe the the guy comes out right afterwards if you killed her. There's something about that. But I agree, like you would never make that choice as an investigator. But as a I don't know the pro gamer move. You just go up and nuke her and move on. Uh so I mean that's not like the the criticism really about this. Like I think that's an easy fix if they don't want you to do that. But there's something about this first part that just feels a little bit there's something missing there. And

mostly it was this sense of um of pressure that's missing whether that's through as you said some other kind of action or treacheries. Um, that would be interesting, right? Cuz the treacheries themselves, kind of like in The Last King, can force you to make this part harder or it's like what? Why is no one Why does no one understand that all of these um people are actually vampires? Like that that kind of part would that unease could be part of the mechanics here and it's just kind of missing. I mean, I feel like they try to do that with the codeex

where like you can get the vampire, right? You that you have a chance of getting it as Brin saw every other time they were just vampires biting him. But, um, I do I do agree that there is like something missing at the start because it kind of feels like a prelude in this first little bit. Right.

Right. where it's like it's it's feeling a little bit um a little bit off. Like maybe if there were multiple suspicious guests, there was a card that could just like kill them, right? If they were like moving around as well, right? If there was like a murderer at the party, so to speak, right?

So yeah, even when that does happen, I don't know what happened in your playthrough. So when you advance somewhere Yeah. Um, and there starts to be cultists and and then the they turn into vampires too, or the these guys do. I forget exactly how it works, but um, the text here is saying that like the party plunges into bloody chaos. No one ever died, you know, other than the one person that had to had to die from this agenda flip. Like I didn't get the bloody chaos out of what was actually going on on the table. It

they were just kind of still hanging out. Did you have a blood bath? Was that something that happened in your in your playthrough?

No, we only had the one person die. Um I mean I feel like it should have been one of those things where like um each enemy got like predator.

Yes. The predator keyword just didn't do enough in this scenario.

I think it's just Howard.

Yeah. Yeah. Like I think it could have been fun if like every cultist was every civilian was stop swapped with a cultist. I think that could have been cool as well,

right?

Um I think that I think that that that could have been neat. Um yeah, cuz these guys had Predator, but I feel like even these children of blood, like she looks like she could freak a guy up, right?

Yeah. Mhm. So yeah, they when the people die, I think they turn into this. Is that it?

Yes. After defeated the predator keyword, they become a new

only ones that went into the victory display. Right.

And then also the first effect on this one. Yeah.

Right. Right. Okay. So this is the if you get one of these guys and then they use the predator keyword, then you get another Well, could just be the children of blood also. I don't know. This we got one.

Yeah.

And then that was

Yeah. The only one we got was the one that was from the advance the the act advancing the agenda advancing.

Yeah.

Right. Is that here too?

No, that's the one we get. It's only on this one if Julia Stern spawn it.

Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, I don't know. Like it it's something that didn't quite come together in the way that I felt like the text was implying was happening.

Mhm. Um, you know, you get your nine clues, you walk into the master bedroom, and then you get the guy. I do want to talk about that because I think it's cool.

Yeah. So, you get the balcony in the master bedroom, and then we get Mr. Howard Wilks.

Yeah. Just hiding in the

Yeah. Who also is again has this uh very scary line of text.

Yep.

Which is why we pushed him off the balcony in our play.

Yep. We did the same thing. We just saw the opportunity. Uh we love how this is a call back to Murder at the Excelsier Hotel.

Yeah.

Which Nick also designed, of course. And yeah, you just you just do the thing. It is kind of fun because those are three potentially tough tests. It was our Danielle who did it. Didn't even have to use scrape by. We just committed a bunch of icons.

Yeah. No, I like it cuz it it felt like we all came together to push him on towards the balcony and then like we all helped Andre like kick him off the edge which I think was

it was a very fun little story moment that came with it.

Yes. If you're playing on harder expert, this ain't here.

Yeah. Which is uh going to make it a lot harder cuz not only is Howard Wilks like uh harder, but there's no easy you die and like if you have to fight him in the bedroom, right? like um that's a very bad place to fight a guy. Like there's a lot of like oh uh okay.

Yeah. So I think this a this is a cool enemy. Like it's just another interesting boss in a campaign of three. Quite unique. I think bosses mechanically. Great job.

Um but there's something about the rest of it that just didn't come together for me. Um, again, I only played it once, so we'll see if like the second and third times go differently, but I don't know. Like the treachery is also like the only treachery, I believe, that's unique to this set is this one. Unnatural strength. Nope, that's from the other set. It's the other one. It's uh Where are you? There's something else. Well, I think bloodthirst is potentially new.

Oh, there's this one. Sanguin rebirth.

Ah, that's it. Thank you. Sang Rebirth. That's the other way to get um another spawn. Cool. I think that's kind of neat.

Yeah. I think it's like um I think a big thing is I just feel like I think they they tried for something different with the pacing for this one.

Um and I think that it's like a few little like like bells and whistles from being like I think really strong in that in that attempt to try something a little bit unique. Um,

and I want to say like just because using all of my experience with Arkham, I say it doesn't feel like a finale, that's not itself like legit. I think it's really these other things that are did the scenario itself come together in like the intended way and then also asking the question of like is this a good Arkham scenario? And I think if you're playing this all in one sitting, it probably feels fine, you know?

Yep.

Like

if you're playing it just like you, Last week was New Horizons and this week is let's finish up the campaign with a big epic, you know, ending. Like this one felt much shorter.

Yes, it was. It was the shortest of the three for us as well.

Yeah.

Um like I I think that this is a good ending to the story. Like I think that of the campaign story, I think that this is a solid ending. Um I also think in all fairness as well to the swing for this one, people have been requesting for a long time for a finale that's not just like going into another world and fighting a monster, right?

Yeah.

Um

and I think that this also like kind of succeeds with that with a very interesting pacing. Um I don't think any of the scenarios in this are bad. I'm happy to play all of them again. Right. I think that this one might be a little bit um could have some annoying thing on like if I play it frequently over a small period of time where like drawing the tokens can really matter for like what you get for these people, right?

Like when you're talking to them.

Uh cuz it's kind of just like slot machine, right? Um, but uh I enjoyed all three scenarios and uh I actually might even grow to like the weird pacing of this one because I will feel like my I I feel this one does a good job of putting yourself in it as a character.

Um now like I'm like yeah the the first part is very strange especially when we come right after like seeing Zabura Morte at the at the meat packing plant. I think that that's really neat. I really like your ideas though of how to fix that. I think there's there's something to the the the narrative that should be felt more on the investigators and there needs to be some other way to um not just make this okay. You know how in um this is I mean it's very Carcosa coded of a of a comment here, but you know how in um I think it's the last one in Dim Carcosa where on the agenda flips maybe they start repeating things that you've done earlier in the campaign and you're like

no no no no that that we already did this that that's this can't be happening right now or is it you know?

Yeah.

And like mechanically they make you do some tests to like redo what you were doing before. retake horror or something. Um, I think this could have used something something there to to make this first part more stressful both on your like own sanity and um the character sanity, but I don't think in principle the story that's being told is bad one for the uh campaign itself. I think it's perfectly fine.

Yeah. Yeah.

Um, I want to say something else though. And I think coming from Queen of Ash, which is the finale of Brethren of Ash. Sorry, Brethren of of uh Brethren of Ash. That's what it's called.

Yeah, I think so.

Yeah. Okay. Okay. It is. All right. Sorry, we've been talking a while. Words. Um I think that that scenario is absolutely stressful. It's it's a really welldesigned like moving through the tunnels and or the sewers or whatever it is and having to think about your choices about where to end your turn, you know, killing Elas or go the other route. The enemies are all relevant. I think it's a really cool finale and because this one is just totally different. It It's like, okay, well, it's trying to do something else and that's that's okay. Uh, but that one I think was like a really good escalation of the story. This one is It's not escalating. It was doing something else, which is a cool thing for them to try out cuz we haven't seen it before.

Yeah. No, I think that um with all this said and done and all this there's all this chat, I think that um they did a good job with the amount of cards in the box to make each scenario feel distinct. Um, and I said in my review, this actually makes me intrigued for more three scenario campaigns.

Yeah,

I suspect we've been talking for like way too long, right? Should we wrap 90 minutes? Yeah, we can move to start wrapping it up, but

Okay, great.

I I enjoyed it. I enjoyed Children of Blood. Um, and like I said, it's kind of been growing on me. I feel like this one might be like Inmouth where um I thought the blind play was fun but not my favorite but like now I'm like the scenarios are just like good Arkham and like that's fun. I could see the same thing sort of happening here because they're kind of just like good Arkham. Um

yeah. Um I I'm I'm curious how my second and third plays of this last scenario are going to go just to see if I how I enjoy it. Like I really did like the parlaying part as like a cool way to do it,

sealing tokens and all. It just felt a little out of place. Um but I think the three scenario campaign is for a three scenario campaign it's a success. I don't think we're going to convince anyone that

if you don't like three scenario campaigns in principle, are you going to go into this with a uh an open mind? Probably not. Um, I would say like personally I wish they had four and six. I still maintain that uh from my initial uh hear of this. But it's fine. It's fine. Arkham like if you like playing the game, it is more of the game. They did a good job with the scenarios and I'm looking forward to whatever else they come up with. It's it's fun to play the game this way. But it can't this can't be the only version of the campaigns and it's not. They have said that they are making longer campaigns, five scenarios in particular. We'll see where they go from there.

Yeah. And I mean like uh I recently actually just played Edge of the Earth as a six scenario campaign and it felt perfect. Um

turns out even though even though I love Ice and Death part two, uh not playing Ice and Death part two and not playing hit uh Fatal Mirage is like actually

it's it's just like a goated experience for Edge of the Earth. Um so I also have faith in the five scenario campaigns. I think that that's going to be I'm very intrigued when they announced that. I imagine in November we're going to get all that information dropped on us, which um is a few months away at the time of recording this video and its release, but it is getting closer and I'm excited to to see the details on that.

Mhm. Cool.

All right. Well, those are our thoughts on Children of Blood where we talked about this as we had our blind plays in the books. Uh I imagine you and I will run a Children of Blood campaign sometime in the near future. I think.

Yeah, I think I want to do like a challenging I want to do like a challenge legacy pool run, but like make it like a really crazy challenge. I think that that could be kind of fun. So, um it's kind of ripe for that. But in the meantime, thanks for watching everybody. I hope you enjoyed this video. I'll be back for another video and you go check you should go check out Daniel's channel which you can find down in the video description. In the meantime, thanks for watching everybody. Have a good one and as always a GG's.

Progress saved