Skip to main content
Loading video...

Scythe vs. Root – Which is Better?

Transcript 13:01

today I'm going to compare two games scythe and root and my goal is by the end of this video whether or not we' even heard of these games you'll know which game appeals more to you the way I'm going to do this is by comparing five attributes theme mechanics luck strategy and complexity I call that breakdown the perfect board game formula and if you'd like to learn more about it you can check out information at the perfboard game.com or you can buy this t-shirt which is carefully handdrawn and features more than a 100 board game components cards on the table between these two games my personal preference is root however it's not my goal to convince you that root is a superior game so I'm going to be sure to list the strengths of both games and I'll even try to be a little more generous with Scythe to compensate for my bias so first what are these games about Scythe takes place in Eastern Europe in an alternate timeline after World War I when the different nations are competing for dominance of the region by amassing the greatest Fortune they do this by increasing with popularity among the locals and building resources and dominating different areas of the board in order to make money the game ends when one player has achieved six Victory conditions now let's talk

about root root is also a game about competing factions and area control in fact the subtitle of the game is a game of Woodland might and right players are competing for the first to gain 30 victory points or the first to complete the victory conditions on a dominance card but how that theme is embodied in the game play is very different from how the theme is embodied in sight as we're about to find out as we talk about pics for Scythe playing Scythe feels much like a puzzle because every player has a player mat which is different and a faction which has a unique ability and a position on a board which is symmetrical in shape but not symmetrical in the availability of resources so from the onset every player must consider their combination and try to optimize how they're going to use their factions abilities and the limitations on their player mat they also have an ability during the game to upgrade the player mat and make certain actions cheaper in order to provide for this engine that produces resources and helps them move across the board for each individual player in Scythe a character will emerge out of the combination of how they play their strategy with their faction and their player mat this is the defining characteristic of Scythe mechanics however it does have a few other things

that are worth mentioning most notable is how the game handles resources in a lot of other games resources stay by the player but in Scythe the resources stay on the board and who has access to the resources depends on your presence on the board if an opponent invades you and you lose in battle your pieces will Retreat to your home base and that player will assume control over the region and all of the resources you left behind this means that the Defending Your regions is of critical importance but when it comes to conflict in the game this is where I personally have the greatest issue because conflict in Scythe is not very common compared to other games that are similar with area control simply winning two conflicts is enough to gain a star which is one of the victory conditions and really in a game of Scythe the number of conflicts can be between two or six I guess even more than that depending on the players and the way they St strategize but conflict is rare conflict is very simple in Scythe each player reveals a card and then the high card along with the um uh reinforcements wins the battle and the loser has to retreat but because the retreating player loses resources it can really really hurt to lose and then because conflict is so rare there aren't very many chances to make a comeback from there now the great response to that is well then don't lose conflict or reinforce your position so that people

don't invade and that's an excellent response to my complaint nevertheless I I get kind of frustrated by it so how do I rate that for mechanics well usually I give a very high rating when a game seriously impresses me with something that's ingenious um or Innovative in this case nothing about Scythe is especially innovative although I do really like how the different factions in the player mats lends itself to excellent replayability that's not Brilliance in mechanics though uh that's a replayability factor I think that it gets some credit but mostly the game is pretty average about a six for mechanics now let's compare that to root in root each faction has a completely different set of rules so it's very hard to describe the Mechanics for the entire game what I can do is I can sort of briefly describe the things that are generally in common although again every faction has its exceptions so uh it's a board where you're moving around following roads unlike Scythe when you land in a space where an opponent is present you don't have to have a conflict with them conflict is optional when conflict is resolved dice are roll and the value of your dice is limited by

the number of Warriors you have in the space and players use cards to craft them in order to gain points or to play them in order to uh do some types of movements or uh do some of the other types of faction actions so there's a lot of card play there's some dice rolling it's area control again um there is some building construction for some of the players like that but if you notice what I'm not saying is anything that's very unheard of this is all very common elements again I think the game is pretty average in its mechanics but in Root's case where the Brilliance comes in is the fact that every single player has a very different set of rules um that means that the game is more complicated because you can't just learn how to play yourself you have to learn how other players are playing as well you have to really really pay attention and the speed at which players can ACR victory points is much faster at a certain point it isn't uncommon out of 30 possible victory points it's not uncommon for a player to win by 10 victory points or even more than that so it's important that players pay attention to what other players are doing in order to sort of form alliances and prevent them from shooting up ahead I really like that that level of attention is required in this game and I

really think it's admirable that a game with so much difference can still be balanced although if I want to be fair and list a complaint about that I do think that some players will be frustrated by the requirement to be to have to understand what other players are doing and the fact that another player can jump ahead so quickly that might actually turn some players off I really like how it requires me to pay attention to the game but if I'm going to grade these two games on the same standards then again for mechanics I'm going to give it about a six now that brings us to theme so for Scythe I have to note that with Scythe the game is exceptional in its components and artwork I think this world of postor war I alternate history timeline with Mech and the stylization of all these characters really encourages players imaginations in fact the encounter cards that you pick up during the course of the game they don't even have flavor text they just have pictures which in in the rule book even it encourages you to sort of fill in the blanks for what could be happening in that graphic I think it does an exceptional job of creating a story through the artwork but when I rate theme it's not the components that influences and creates a high rating what creates a high rating is whether or not the game game play supports the theme and it feels too much like a puzzle to me uh to say that the

game feels very thematic in its gameplay if I want to be clear for theme I would say the game has a four when I compare root earlier this year I did a review of root and I rated it on the theme of animals and woodlands and I gave it a four also because the theme is very painted onart and it's true there's nothing about this game that feels like you're a cat or you're a bird but that's not really what the game is about the game is not about what the animals are the game is about the roles of the characters it feels kind of like uh Peter Pan or Robin Hood or something like that and the Marquee de cat is the sheriff of goddingham and the um Vagabond is Robin Hood and then the Woodland Alliance is like the poor people something like kind of like that each player has a very different role and rather than trying to figure it out by optimizing the costs of different actions uh the characters are very well defined in the rules for each faction so the game play of root feels extremely thematic now there are a few very minor criticisms but I could twice to say that when I give a nine or a 10 it's only because I'm really wowed by the theme root is not extraordinary in that sense but for theme I would say it has an eight when it comes to luck I think both games are extremely comparable uh Scythe

has cards which you draw so that's luck involved uh when you play rout you're rolling dice that's luck involved however both games have lots of ways to mitigate for bad luck and lots of strategies surrounding the luck there're certainly not games that are focused on luck but it does really have an influence on the outcome of the game so for luck I give both games of four for strategy the strategy is very different in both games in Scythe I've made it very clear the game is all about optimization of your faction and your player map for strategy oh and not to mention paying attention to what other players are doing and preparing defenses in case they invade and take all of your resources I really like that it feels very strategic I would give it a nine for root there's so much going on again player-to-player interaction as you're obser in what other players are doing trying to prevent them and ra and trying to achieve dominance yourself so it feels very strategic again a nine and then for complexity you can just look at the length of the rule books root has two Rule books scyth has one um Scythe every player is mostly playing by the same set of rules in rot every player is playing by a different set of rules uh for Scythe complexity is a five for root complexity is an eight now in summary which of these two games would you rather play the big difference here is complexity and theme at least

the way that I rate theme if you can handle a more complex game I think you would definitely be interested in root if you prefer theme that's embodied in the game play you would prefer root but if you prefer theme and the components and the artwork you would prefer sighty if you like you're engaged by a puzzle you would prefer Scythe this is my take on these two board games my preference is in the theme and the gameplay and the factions ability in rout but I definitely recognize some of the strengths in Scythe if you like this video if you like the way I describe and the way I prefer these games Stick Around by subscribing so you can hear more of my recommendations don't forget to go to the perfboard game.com thanks for watching I'll see you next time bye-bye

Progress saved