Immersion & Theme in Board Games
Transcript
hi I'm admin Wales and this is my board gaming Vlog and today I'm going to give an update on what I've been up to and why I've been absent from this channel for the last few weeks uh but also I'm going to as supposed get stuck into a little bit of discussion about so-called thematic gaming and immersive gameplay experiences those terms that we hear quite a lot and the reason for that is because I've been playing quite a lot of these games recently and they're not normally to my tastes so uh what have I been playing Star Wars Destiny the collectible dice game I've this is my first collectible dice collectible anything game uh experience I've also played Star Wars rebellion for the first
time uh yesterday a long game of Star War I don't think there's any such thing as a short game of Star Wars rebellion uh so I've played that that big sort of Fantasy Flight uh monster that uh made the number one of a lot of people's 2016 best games lists um and I've recently picked up a new copy of blood bow the The Games Workshop that this re-edition 2016 Edition I started playing blood ball in second edition in 1988 uh when I was 10 years old and so it's it's it's kind of a something that sort of you know um that I find quite affecting uh blood bow it's something I remember very fondly from my childhood um but I'm start off by talking a little bit about immersion and theme in board games because I think the term is used differently in board game sort of media and board game design than it is in the sort of wider context I mean if we if we think about board games as an art form which I do and as a form of literature maybe I'm pushing it a little bit then when we talk about theme in literature we're not talking about uh necessarily the setting of a a a story we're not talking about um the sort of the the story itself The Narrative we're generally talking about something very specific uh it it it's often a one-word thing it's what the the story is about uh what it tells us what it's uh perhaps
a recurring sort of message that comes through the story so if we take Star Wars for example what are the themes in Star Wars in the broadest sense there's War but that's probably the least interesting theme in there because it is so broad within that we've got themes of sort of family connections and loss and betrayal and sacrifice um we've got the sort of theme of um nature versus technology and uh and and spirituality all these things are themes within Star Wars love and um and hate um now are those themes in Star Wars Destiny the collectible dice game or are those themes in Star Wars rebellion I would say largely no largely those themes are not there the themes we have in Star Wars rebellion and Star Wars Destiny are largely themes of um I don't even know if you can call it a theme you know fighting and War um perhaps struggle I mean these are very broad uh not particularly interesting themes okay now the narrative is there we have the setting of the Star Wars universe and we have The Narrative of this happens and then this happens and then this happens but that is a slightly different thing to theme now I might be nitpicking a little bit here but it leads me into my next point which is about
immersion how do we get immersed in games is it enough to just simply have this really rich theme which is Illustrated with lavish artwork and lots of flavor text and things like that when I hear the board game media talk about immersive gameplay experiences they tend to mean okay we've got artwork we've got the characters have names they have Back stories they have flavor text on there that isn't what immerses me in a game now it might be what immerses you uh I mean we we there's some evidence I suppose that people have different learning styles okay I I know this often comes up in education and and it's controversial because whe we can use the learning styles to teach people is an arguable thing but I think it's fairly well established that people prefer a certain way of learning they find there's a certain thing that will immerse them in a problem or an activity so that might be uh visual information people might prefer drawings and and and videos and things like this it might be auditory people might immerse themselves because of sound soundtracks stuff like that noises people might immerse themselves because of the written word uh they might read or write in order to immerse themselves in something it might be kinesthetic it might be the the the movement and and and and spatial sort of placing of things it might be to do with logic and reasoning people might immerse themselves because of mathematical and logical problems they might immerse themselves if they manage to work socially within a group or they might
immerse themselves if they are able to work alone and everybody will have different preferences on that sort of spectrum um and I say spectrum because I don't think anyone is any one thing but I know myself that I struggle with reading novels for example I just don't get into them occasionally I do but I'm much more likely to manage to immerse myself in a graphic novel um and for a long time that's been a bit of a guilty secret of mine that I don't really I don't really get novels it makes me feel a bit stupid that other people who I think are really intelligent and they read a lot and there's me and the only things I can get into are graphic novels and plays oddly I I do like reading plays and and I can really immerse myself in that I can immerse myself in television the visual and auditory thing really works for me and theater um just that directness now where does this take us with board games well what does Star Wars rebellion offer us it offers us a long gameplay experience between two people with limited social interaction lots of gameplay interaction but there's not much in the way of negotiation or lying or bluffing or anything like so the social Learners they're out okay there's nothing auditory in there so they're out visually yeah it's quite a visual sort of feast uh and and certainly there's lots of lots of text there now as I said text is not something that I find particularly immersive um tactile well the pieces are
three-dimensional but essentially we're just pushing them across the board so I would say no there's not that kinesthetic sort of thing there's some logic and reasoning but that's often up upset by um by the other players uh actions and by Randomness in the game and so for me it doesn't quite you know it doesn't quite fulfill what I want from a logic reasoning sort of experience so for me I didn't find it very immersive not really I found it sort of nostalgic to look at the characters and it broadly told me in a story in the way that a novel would tell me a story so I see that checca moves to this planet and then Boba Fett comes into that planet and chewbaca Boba Fett tries to capture Chewbacca but Chewbacca I play a card which says that chewbaca escapes because he's got a guardian okay now I have no ageny there I'm playing a card that says chewbaca escapes I'm not making him Escape I'm not doing anything to do that recently actual all John who is another YouTuber from the UK who's he's very popular and has lots of subscribers you should go and look at his channel it's very good he did a review of mansions of Madness and he pointed out that in that game which is supposed to be totally immersive and all the more so because of its new app that in that game you might pick up a card that tells you you've gathered some evidence and you're trying to solve a mystery here but the card says you've gathered evidence and once you've collected enough of these cards that say you've gathered evidence then you've
solved the mystery that's not immersive that's that's there's no agency there it's just a card that says evidence why not give us some evidence and then we can do the logical deduction required to immerse ourselves in the game if we look at a game like Dr Eureka in Dr Eureka everyone has three of these test tubes with these little balls in them of the three different colors and on what they happens is they turn over a card and then everyone will try and solve this puzzle at the same time and they're not allowed to let the balls touch the table and then not allowed to touch the balls themselves so you have to do it by tipping these things between the different containers so uh for example you know stick that in there and um oh what am I going to do now let's go in there and this is terrible I'm doing really badly stick that in there and then I can get one of them in there that goes in there and I'm racing against my opponents to do this in fact most people would have done this by now I'm just particularly bad at the G game so let's put that in there and that in
there and I think I'm done there you go then if I do that before the other player I score the card we turn over a new one and we do the same thing again that's Dr Eureka so Dr eure immersive absolutely immersive I'm totally engaged in a t ask I have absolute agency it's my job to put those balls from that test tube into the other test tube I've got a job to do and I've got to do it before the other player it's tactile it's it's got some sort of logical reasoning but also the kinesthetic thing of moving the balls about it's got social interaction that race I've got to do it before the other player and the frustration to do one card after another now is it thematic no there's no theme there no theme at all I mean what would the theme be um I don't even I can't even put a theme onto it it's got a setting and what it has is this uh this idea of puts me into a role I'm a I'm a a doctor a lab phys a physician or a chemist or something like that and I'm mixing these things together and and I'm actually doing something that that role would do you know Star Wars Rebellion I'm a Wookie okay what does a wook do goes around and bashes people and makes weird noises am I doing any of those things no I'm playing cards and I'm rolling dice that
for me is is one level of abstraction that makes it difficult for me to immerse myself and that's not true of all games I do frequently manage to immerse myself in abstracted games but it's usually where the activity is in itself in it's got some really interesting logic or reasoning sort of activity to take on lavish artwork really helps and nice tactile pieces um I I I came from a background of of theater in education so uh about 10 years ago I was working a lot in in Little Theater and education companies around Wales uh and theater and education in the UK has connotations of leg a Kimbo the old uh League of gentlemen two men in a in a little van going around schools and teaching them about hey strangers are dangerous and you know it's all a bit Na and a bit cheap wasn't like that in Wales not 10 years ago anyway it was kind of the backbone of Welsh theater through the 60s and 70s and it was high quality stuff and a lot of it was based on um Dorothy Heth got's mantle of the expert so mantle of the expert is another educational sort of tool whereby we put children into roles so if we want to teach them something if we want to immerse them in an activity then we say to them this is fictional we don't tell them we don't lie to them and say you're actually doing this but we say to them right okay you're running a a travel agency and we give them a role you're the travel agent so all your art lessons are going to be about creating posters
to advertise your travel agency and all the history is going to be about history of those different locations and geography will be based around that um and and and maths will be about doing the accounts fora travel agency um and and and this is giving them that sort of expert role which is what a good board game does too it tells me who I am and then I take that on and I and I try and sort of work from that basis now some games you're one individual character and and you go on from there and others you control a group of characters so like flasho fire rescue is an example of a game that I I really enjoy where I take on one role and what I'm doing yeah it's totally abstracted isn't it I don't get the smell of the smoke and I don't get the the the sort of noises and and that sort of thing but I do get the the sort of tension the fear of of that fire hitting my person or even wor hitting one of the survivors in the building and killing them before I can get to them because that's what immersion's about as well isn't it it's about what do we want in a game a bit like a piece of drama what do we want um we want to survive we don't want to die we want pleasure meble experiences um whether that's love or whether it's um sex or whether it's uh other sensal experiences like food or uh or you know all manner of different
things like this are there any threats to those things in a game like uh Star Wars rebellion is there any joy to be had there no no one's really seeking out joy in that game is there a threat of death there is is on a sort of global scale we might see a planet blow up we might see a unit of troops destroyed but Princess Leia can't be killed um or uh Darth Vader can't be killed or Emperor Palpatine can't be killed um and so you don't have that sense of threat and you don't have that sense of ownership of taking on those roles I mean who am I in that game am I some sort of Master tactician sending players out I don't know I don't know who who I am that's true of quite a lot of games uh actually I don't know who I am in the game um but it's quite nice when a game does provide you that thing let's take a look at flick up in flick up players split into two teams of cowboys a scenario is picked from the scenario book and the table is prepared accordingly Cowboys move by flicking a movement disc and relocating the disc may not hit anything or the move fails Cowboys shoot by flicking a bullet disc if it knocks a cowboy over they take a wound each Cowboy can take three wounds before they die but they never take wounds if they're lying down on the table each Cowboy takes two actions moving Andor shooting and then the process is repeated until the scenario objectives
are met some scenarios will have players entering buildings or jeweling oneon-one or two onone or stealing gold or rescuing a non-player character the set includes rules for rifles and dynamite and Gallows scenarios and it also leaves it open for players to create their own scenarios now in flick up when I flick that uh that bullet when I when I when I get down there onto the table and I uh and I I flick the bullet at another person I'm doing it I have agency there I'm doing the action that that that gets the result that I want the story is clear I find that immersive um where am I going with all of this I don't know I don't know somehow uh I'll tell you what let's move on let's let's let's forget about I'm going to stop getting angry about the terms theme and immersive gameplay and I'm going to talk about something else so let's talk about collectible card games uh I've never got into a collectible card game before uh and I've often read and heard again on board game media about how awful ccgs are this magic the Gathering thing and how the the collectibility and all of that how it's so unfair how it rips people off because they're getting things they don't want and all of that and I totally agree that
if you have not got enough disposable income then these are probably not the things for you and the problem is that they are aimed at children and teenagers who probably don't have that much money or that much sense in order to stop them from buying again and again and again but as my first experience of a collectible game I've really enjoyed Star Wars Destiny there is something really exciting about opening a little packet not knowing what you're going to get it was cheap you know it didn't cost me a fortune if I get something I didn't really want well was a minor disappointment but the next one I open will have something really exciting wow now I've got Jabba the Hut you know that's that's quite an exciting sort of thing to me and a new experience I'm not going to invest loads of money into this i' I've picked up enough actually to to have a good game with my friend um and I'll probably buy a few more boosters from time to time but that's about it it reminds me of the excitement of buying Panini stickers when I was a kid and filling up those sticker books um that was that was always very exciting so collectible card games is something new for me uh for 2017 uh and Star Wars Destiny actually I can recommend as a dice game it's really good not immersive although you you've only got one or two characters so you can just buy into it enough and the actions all make sense and so it does have an element of narrative in it uh even if um you know using our broader sort of literature term theme is absent I should say at this point this all sounds a
little bit pretentious doesn't it because I do accept that theme is board gaming jargon and it has a different meaning within the board gaming context theme means the broad All In compassing thing of of artwork and narrative and uh and and you know intellectual property and all the rest of it I get that I get that it's different in board games but for the purposes of this video I really wanted to pin down what is it that makes me engage with a game and how that might be different for different people with their different tastes the other thing that makes me engage with a game is Nostalgia and uh one really nostalgic experience that I've had recently is the re-release of the game let me grab it now blood bow now blood bow is games workshops uh game it came out uh I can't remember when it originally was but I had the second edition in 1988 when I was 10 years old and I played it throughout my teenage years it's you know if I think of board games from my teenage years then that is the one that I played a lot of it's long it's out outdated it's extremely luck based with all the dice rolls and everything is about mitigating that luck and pushing your luck and that can lead to a frustrating experience there's a lot of modeling required and you know and and and and building and and painting of models and all this sort of thing not usually something I would get heavily
into but the Nostalgia Factor here is high I think I like this game for the same reason that a lot of people are going to like things like Star Wars rebellion Nostalgia oh it's all about star Star Wars here it's all about blood bow it's about Griff overal and and Morgan thorg and and and you know all the tree men and the halflings and I find it quite exciting bloodb and I've been painting a lot of these figures over the last few weeks in fact let's take a little look at some of the figures so here is a human from the 2016 edition of bloodbowl and I just wanted to compare it really to a human from the old 1988 version and you can see how much better Games Workshop has got at doing these sort of dynamic poses excuse the bad paint jobs um I'm a particularly uh I Rush my painting I do it really fast and sometimes I'll sit down and play uh and do some painting with um Tom my uh my friend and and he will he will take you know ages to do one figure and he'll do it beautifully and I'll get seven figures done in the same time and they're all a little bit rushed uh and I've never quite keep to the lines and this is even worse cuz I did it years ago um and in fact my fingernails are showing that they've got paint all over them so you can see I've been doing some work on this this morning so here we are there is a human here's another one in a nice Dynamic pose you know how much better are these than the old um blood bow figures from the 80s again if we have a look at a
scaven so this is a little ratman he's back from second edition 1988 this little scaven look at them now look at what the rats are like now you know and this is plastic this one's metal um so things have really improved and they were really fun to to paint I haven't actually played the game yet um but the rules haven't actually changed at all which leads me to believe it'll be quite a long frustrating Affair but I'll still love it because of the Nostalgia finally I wanted to show you this old model uh again back from 1988 this guy is a big metal troll look how not Dynamic his poses just sort of standing there looking gormless with his massive hand now he was covered in layers and layers of childhood paint he looked awful until fairly recently I got him out and stuck him in a bowl of dle soaked all the paint off and I was surprised by how much detail there is on this old metal model um CU I mean to be honest even after soaking it I thought God that model looks awful um but it all came together quite nicely uh in a sense but I'm looking forward to seeing what Games Workshop will do with the big guys like this a big sort of new troll in a dynamic po will be quite exciting to have so I think that's about it long rambling Vlog today uh if you enjoyed it and I don't know why you would I'm Adam in Wales uh this is my channel Adam's board game Wales please subscribe to it and please follow me on Twitter at boardgame Wales or on Board Game Geek I'm adam78 thank you very much for watching all the
best n