Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dragons of Etchinstone Solo Review | AzureDeath

Transcript 22:55

foreign hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and this is solo review of dragons of epginstone this is an 18 card game by Joe clifffeld and you can get this from the game crafter or the PMP files from PMP arcade if you want to print it at home in the interest of disclosure I got this with my own funds from the crowd sale that happened last year and I received this recently I've not been playing it a bunch so I'm gonna share my thoughts with you and I also posted a full playthrough of this if you want to see how it plays I'll leave a link to that all right first let's start with a component overview and that should be quick because this is a pretty minimalistic game you get the talk box and 18 cards no rulebook you can download the rulebook PDF offered by the designer and it is a 24-page rulebook uh and there's a this is the lowing version but there's a fancier version uh with background texture all right uh but now let's look at the talk box now even so I'm a compulsive slaver as I've stated uh in the past so how the so the sleeve cards are not gonna fit back in here the talk box sadly but I do still

keep it because it it comes with some rules reminders and also it comes with this very handy icon reference so uh the even if you plan to sleeve the game The Talk box does have its use um so yeah no rulebook that in mind you're gonna have to print it or look at it on your device now for the cards you get 18 cards there's a dragon card this is actually the boss that you battle at the end there's four different ones I'll talk more about that later and you get 18 sorry 16 action 16 action cards and the region card I'll talk a bit more in detail about this later but yeah so you get those two and then the 16 action cards which is what you use throughout the game so yeah so those are the components and now let's talk about how this game works before I share my thoughts okay so what happens in this game so what you do is you set up which you can play on a table or or on your hand which I I really appreciate that you have both options so it's super portable low uh low um footprint but what you do is you you pick a dragon to fight at the end okay so there's four different colored dragons included and then you start in region one so think of the regions as dungeon force all right so you're gonna go to region one where you will face different enemies and Journeys uh and for enemies

you use the uh combat value of Your Action cards and for Journeys you use the movement value the you so that's what you use those two for uh movement for Journeys and combat for enemies so uh once you set up you're gonna start engine in region one and each turn you're gonna draw four cards and then you're gonna have the stack of cards that you're not using it's gonna it's gonna be face up like this and it'll tell you which uh it'll tell you which enemy or Journey you're facing so this one the stack on top here uh the only thing that you care about is that uh that information right there it tells me that I need to face Journey number two and it includes an extra um uh obstacle in there but so this stack will determine what you're gonna face either on enemy uh which this one for example if I look at the next one if I was looking at this one the skull tells me that I have to face Enemy Number One so then I have to puzzle with these four cards using uh figuring out the best way to use the combat value or the movement value depending if I'm facing an enemy or a journey I have to try to use these cards as efficiently as possible to defeat the enemy or or Succeed In the Journey without taking any damage or penalties right or suffering in any way so that's what happens that's the main puzzle and each card from your hand you have to play three of them and one of them may be kept for next

turn so it helps you plan a bit ahead uh but you have to parcel and figure out which of the three cards uh to and how to use them uh to uh to best get the best possible result uh against uh either the journey or the enemy uh and then once you finish once you go through the deck okay because when you're when you use your car to discard them and then you draw another up to four Once you the deck Runs Out you then move on to the next region Now by by succeeding in enemy combat or Journeys you're gonna gain experience which lets you upgrade your cards so all cards in the regular difficulty start at level two and as you level up you're gonna increase your cards so that they get better stats by paying the uh experience there all right until they reach level four with which is the max and that they that's the best stats that the cards offer uh So you you're also going to be taking damage and when you take damage you downgrade the card all right so War stats uh so you're gonna as you go through the regions you're gonna downgrade some cards as you take damage and increase and level up your cards as you gain experience and you have to try to um get the best deck possible with upgraded cards so that you defeat the dragon at the end and that pretty much is the guest of of the game at the end when You Face a

dragon uh if you if you survive the combat you win that that's the win it's a win-loss Condition it's not a bit your own score game uh hard a bit hard win or loss condition so that's how uh that works now let's move on to my uh to my thoughts what do I think about this game okay so I have to mention the fact that this game screams mesh 9 okay and in fact I have some rare footage of the developer working on it so as it happens meshnert is one of my favorite solo games and in fact it's my number one solo game so if you haven't played mesh night it's gonna be a bit more difficult to appreciate what this game does and and honestly I'm just gonna Rave about this game for quite a while but before we get to that part I want to go ahead and get out my negatives I want to get those out of the way uh which honestly I see them more as nitpicks so first thing I'll mention is the talk box which is not very durable to be honest with you and even if I decided that I wasn't gonna leave the cards so that I could take it with me everywhere with all the cards in there I think this wouldn't last a lot and this hook would tear really fast okay so the the talk box isn't super adorable and uh also although I find the graphic design to be an overall big positive for me I do have to disclose the fact that or warn you that the text of the

um uh the text of the region cards uh is very tiny so you if your eyesight is not perfect uh or if you have trouble reading small text you uh your you might have some trouble reading this tiny text so keep do keep that in mind uh also the fact that it doesn't include a rulebook I know some folks might find that a negative uh I I'm honestly okay with it because I would rather have this than uh just some tiny cramped uh sheet that is unable to cover the information with a bigger text like this that the designer offers I'll talk more about that later but yeah that's really all the negatives so now I just want to go ahead and Rave about this game so I need to disclose the fact that I've never met or talked to the designer I've never spoken with the designer of this game I know that he's responsible for other minimalistic versions of bigger games he made the Gloom holding version of goom Haven uh he made a handheld version of missed fall mini Rogue so he has a lot of experience with distilling bigger designs into something smaller I have had in the past thought of printing Gloom holding just having gotten around doing it but just keep that in mind never tried any of his designs before and never spoken to like okay because the the thing is man I just absolutely adore this game okay

this game it kept me up at night when I first got it um and I spent some time reading the rules when I first started playing it it just entranced me all right because I was just in disbelief at how this game distills mesh night into 18 cards it it was just on Candy I I just could not believe what I was experiencing and and that is the Crux of the there is an issue here okay if you have not played Mage Knight before it's gonna be a bit harder to appreciate this game now that doesn't mean that if you're completely um like if you've not played Mage Knight in the past that doesn't mean that you can enjoy this the Apostle here is just pure joy I love figuring out how to use my hand to try to beat the enemy as efficiently as possible I love how it scales I I love upgrading my card it's just the Apostle is just wonderful and it's so uncanny and so like I was having Deja Vu to when I was um uh assaulting castles in mesh night and figuring out how to use my hand as efficiently as possible and this guy this guy like I don't know what sorcery he used okay he obviously has experience uh with doing this because he's made other designs like if it was it if this was his first design like I would be

even more blown away but he obviously has some experience creating this type of design and it shows this is it shows how much all of the work that he's done in the past like how well this is made and you have to keep in mind that you know when you have a board game and you have all of these components on your at your disposal like you can just have a a bombing of components and just in in those you know as a designer and tells yourself I'll have like 50 000 different types of tokens I'll have dice I have boards now something that is super difficult to do and I know this just in general right with any with designing anything learning what to remove okay how to keep things simple that's super super difficult to do and the fact that this somehow with a deck of 18 cars this guy managed to distill the maze not experience into this it just blew me away I could not stop playing this for like three days straight since I got it and I've just this game has been living rent free in my head like I had to stop my I have I had to force myself to stop playing it uh to like get work done and to not procrastinate and it's dangerous because it's it sets up in a minute all you have to do is Shuffle this deck and and put the Choose Your Dragon and put the uh region card in level one and make sure that this is in level two the course and

that's it it literally sets up in a minute and you can play it in your hand now um one one thing that I really appreciate about this game is that I don't have to play it in my hand if I don't want to I love um Palm Island which is another hand held card game it made it to my top 20. I think it's an incredible minimalistic game but I I kind of resent the fact that I have to play them I have the nature sure of that game forces you to play it in your hand and my hands just like get uncomfortable after a while from holding it and I really dislike that aspect of it but I love that I can just put that in my pocket and I can play it while waiting anywhere now this um I don't have to and it occupies barely any table space as you'll see in my playthrough all right so you can conceivably play it on a table and just the card play just just you know figuring out how to use your hand it's just not how it reminded me of maze not how this guy did it like I don't know look I I think it's again it Bears repeating learning minimalism and knowing what to remove there's just such a delicate balance and it's it's such a tough thing to do um and the I just have to applaud this design and another thing that this game has done it has absolutely ruined other portable games like I don't I'm gonna have a hard time playing any other uh portable games like for my button shy

Library I have a I have an extensive button shy library but this is just such a like what this offers the the hand um the apostle that it offers which it's so remin reminiscent of mesh night and now I can play it in my hand or in a tiny table space why would I want to play anything else once you okay so let's talk about the rules right so the rules is 24 pages long right and some people you know tiny game why is the rulebook that long it really isn't that bad it really isn't that bad and this does a much better job than other portable games that I've seen um that I've experienced let me give you an example um recently uh battle Crest by uh button shy look at what I what you have to deal with to learn that game that is also supposed to be minimalistic just look at this I just got aggravated from the tiny ass text I'm sorry I just really disliked this and it really does encouraged me from reading the rules I'm sure that I'll get around to to learning the rules of this but the fact that this is the only thing that they offer that you practically have to use a magnifier to read the rules it really really just left left a bad taste in my mouth and I just put it away and I didn't want to keep dealing with learning this like it's already a bit of a complicated game to begin with if you want to play it solo and they don't even offer just a plain award file so that you can look at it in big size like on your screen or something I really dislike that they don't offer that so the designer here has the sense of thank you thank God he

just offers the file in a just a plain PDF file that you can print at bigger sizes if you want thank you for doing that because I don't care it could be 30 pages long for all I care uh this is just well written and and I can print it at a bigger size and just you know highlight them right over it okay write notes I can't do that with these super complicated button shy games like I know that they're trying to cram a lot with the component limitation but this could never be about a shy game because how do you fit this in one of these all right you can't all right and I just think that this this is a restraint like this this is a huge restraint when designing one of these games so I have to make that comparison with button shy because this is a 18 card game right and and I I thank you so much for offering this like I can't overstate that this this game that it has a lot going on that you didn't limit yourself to this I just really hate it I'm sorry like I I hate that I I have to practically use a magnifier to read these rules if it's a simpler game fine but these more complicated games you need to offer this okay now um so again I I also have to mention the replayability so you have four different dragons you have four different regions and it's gonna play Super differently every time all right you're gonna get like the permutations with the different

possible possibilities of hands that you're gonna get with the dragon which encounters your graphins which encounters you're gonna face either Journeys or enemies replyability is insane so I I just love I just love this game so much and it has killed all our games for me

I don't know why you uh I don't know why I would play other games because because once you internalize the rules which again are not that bad honestly there's a lot going on here but after a couple of plays you're gonna you're gonna be uh going through your turns this quick all right um I don't know why I would play all their portable games honestly this right here is gonna I'm pretty sure that next year when I vote for my games this is gonna make my top 20. and um one thing I do wish though there's a couple things I do wish one that uh there was a plastic card version of this because uh one thing I love about um Palm Island is that uh because it's plastic cart I don't have to sleep them so I feel comfortable you know handling them right you play it in your hand that's gonna wear under the cards really fast but uh with cardboard I simply like this is not gonna last anything I'm sorry like I'm kind of rough with my cards so I want uh I want a plastic card version of this I I really do so I hope that happens one day and uh man I want more content for this now I understand as I said minimalism it's tough learning what to keep and what to remove okay um so I know that expanding this could be tough but I want expansions for this one aspect of Masonite that is uh that I really miss from this is the fact like picking a character how picking a character gives you different um that different starting card for your deck if this guy can somehow figure out a way

to add an expansion where you choose a character that's just gonna be the cherry on top um so I folks I really can't uh Rave enough about this game uh I if if you have played if you have played played Masonite you'll know what I'm talking about once you play this game and I think it's nuts that you can get this for nine dollars like the experience that you get from this for the portability for the the puzzle the replay ability is just unparalleled uh and this is gonna be my go-to a quick setup uh just portable game I'm gonna I'm I'm ordering a second copy of this just so that I can uh so that I can allow myself to wear out the cards I want to have one copy a slave copy and since I don't have a plastic version I'm gonna order a second copy that I take I'm always gonna take this with me everywhere all right this is just incredible and again I have to reiterate I have not met I have not met this guy but I think you know he's nothing short of a genius like how he did this the skill required for that and again it shows all the all the the signs that he's done in the past this is probably his magnum opus I don't know how he feels about that but the oh and okay one thing I haven't talked about the graphic design I think this game is Just so well designed graphically man like it just it it might be like slightly generic but it's just well done like I can read the cards fine one big mistake

that uh one big unfortunate thing with some indie games is that the graphic design Department lacks but this is just this is just so well done easy to read it just have it just it just has some personality the artwork uh the one thing I'll say the artwork uh it has that flat um color uh style that's the one thing I'm I'm not a huge fan of um I do wish that the artwork was more like um personally if um if you've seen those chip Theory again uh from uh too many bones that artwork that goes in the corner that's very tiny like little portraits of the uh of the enemies that would be really cool like something a bit grittier so this these guys look a bit too friendly for for my liking but the I think the Landscapes are gorgeous though I do really like the Landscapes but the enemies I wish they had a bit more teeth to them they look a bit too um too friendly but um other than that folks I I think that you really have to try this you can't really go wrong for the price um and I I really like if there's expansions for this in the future like I'm really hoping there will be because men like just what what a game what a game and just super kudos to Joe form coming up with this design uh it it just feels almost like a dream come true almost like how can someone distill this

into uh into an 18 card game how can someone be still mention it in 2018 card game it's just it blows my mind that that's even possible but um that's pretty much it folks and I told you I was gonna Rave about this game this might be one of the best games of the year for me and I'm pretty sure that this is gonna be my top 20 and it like I said it has ruined other portable games for me like I don't know why I would play anything else versus this like because maze not is that that thing that every that's that's the Holy Grail experience that everybody tries to go after like oh how do I recreate that this does it beautifully okay so thank you so much for watching folks um and if you enjoyed this content please go ahead and like And subscribe and if you have any questions go ahead and post them in the comments section and I'll see you in the next one

Progress saved