Skip to main content
Loading video...

The innsmouth conspiracy review

Transcript 25:09

Koto and welcome to this very special review of The enouth Conspiracy for Arkham Horror the card game the enouth horror might be my favorite Lovecraft story so I was very excited to see how the enouth conspiracy handled that excellent source material the creepy town of enouth full of suspicious people with a certain fish-like quality to them and the town's folk with their absolute hostility to Outsiders plus the secrets their keeping of what's actually out there in Devil's wreef and what lies in the caves under the township now the insouth horror is Peak Lovecraft is the insouth conspiracy Peak Arkham Horror let's bring the lights up probably bolted on the other side he's awake and there I can hear him moving about out break the door down you damn fool this review contains a ton of spoilers for The insouth Conspiracy viewer discretion is advised the insouth conspiracy is the sixth campaign that Arkham horr put out and it was the last one to be released in installments that means we don't have a handy big box for this campaign for me to point at but based on current timelines and how Fantasy Flight games is handling arhamar at the moment you should expect to see a big box of this come out about this time next year maybe earlier and until then it's probably going to be a bit of a pain to pick up so why are we covering it now well because uh you voted for it you voted for this one to be the campaign we did after the Scarlet keys well maybe not you directly but you as a collective group of people who watch my

Arkham Horror videos and vote on the polls and on that note the next one is going to be Hemlock Vil because of course it's going to be Hemlock Vil that one just came out but let's get back to the outh conspiracy a campaign I found at times absolutely brilliant but campaign that just didn't quite stick The Landing let's go through the various parts of the campaign now for starters I've gone through the insouth conspiracy twice now uh the first time was in person with uh my friend Fraser and my other friend Jared and I played in that campaign Tony Morgan I was the main Grunt and dealing with the enemies that were rushing in uh Fraser was playing a clu getting Patrice deck and Jared was playing a flex deck which was Diana Stanley with a lot of cancels and stuff the second time through I played it solo two-handed and I was playing as Trish gabra who is our cluter and with Zoe Samus who was our fighter so that is my experience with the campaign going through twice with those sets of characters let's talk about some of the features of the campaign the first of these features is delayed XP now the way the campaign is structured is there are flashback missions and then there are missions happening in the current time and you're trying to piece together your memories during the flashback missions one of the mechanical consequences of this campaign structure is they don't want you spending XP just before a flashback Mission and I get it from that point of view like from a purely artistic point of view that makes some sense but from a fun point of view it's

not exactly the best decision here and it really has two main consequences uh the first one is it slows down your overall feeling of progress that you get Arkham Horror one of the fun things about this game is experience it is getting new cards or up grading cards within your deck to take the idea you had a game start and make it better stronger and more efficient that's one of the big things that draws people into the Arkham Horror card game experience making Decks that do stuff that are fun and the delayed experience is a bit of a handbreak on that it's a bit of a actually no we're going to hold your XP back so you have to play with the same deck two missions back to back it's not that bad but it is I think needless uh in many ways and I don't think you'd lose much of the feel of the campaign if you were allowed to spend that XP anyway the second problem I found with it is you really have to do the first half of the campaign with bugger all XP like figure out how to make your deck work with under 10 XP because that's see that you're going to be running the first four scenarios with most likely then at the midpoint you'll get a whole bunch more XP and be able to ratchet your deck up but you're going to have to do the nuts and bolts of the campaign probably with 10 or under XP and I know there's a lot of deck combinations a lot of ideas that don't really come on stream until you're hitting like the 15 to 20 XP Mark so straight away a recommendation after playing this through twice is pick characters that are good out of the box if you want to do well don't think about an Aman deck that's going to take like

24 XP worth of stuff to K her up because you're probably not going to get that until like mission 7 the second feature of the campaign I want to talk about are flashbacks now flashbacks are almost like stretch goals uh but there're a main way to get experience points and advantages in this campaign so you can complete most of the scenarios uh in the campaign pretty easily if you ignore doing the flashbacks but the flashbacks are where you get bonus XP and you also get to manipulate the chaos bag now this campaign starts off with a pretty rough chaos bag it has two skulls two cultist two broken tablets and two Elder things out of the box so so 20 tokens in the house bag and nine of them are pretty haery and ugly but as you do the flashbacks you not only get rewarded with XP you also get to take some of those tokens out of the bag making the campaign easier now again this leads to an effect where the front end of the campaign is harder than the back half of the campaign because on the first scenario you start off with this really really ugly uh chaos bag and if you manage it well over the first four or five scenarios you can get get rid of a lot of those nasty tokens you can even add in an extra plus one token U so we had two plus ones in our bag and that makes everything you do just that much easier so again just how I mentioned with XP that the front end of the campaign is a lot harder cuz you've only

got a limited XP pool you also got a tougher chaos bag to work with so again it's frontloading the difficulty to the first half of the campaign some of the other features in the campaign include keys title tunnels and flooding now keys are very straightforward they represent objectives uh usually in the form of an object and normally you're allowed to pick up a key once you've taken all the clues off a location and sometimes you can take them off enemies and keys normally work to either give you a special power or there's gated informational access behind a key so a lot of flashbacks work by taking a key to a specific place so the idea of keys is great and it's an excellent thing to add into the developer toolbox for making scenarios for Arkham Horror the problem is they're in practically every single scenario here so they kind of lose their impact pretty quickly they're a cool idea and they allow for some fun gameplay and story elements to be happening but I don't think they should be used in every scenario and that leads me into the tital tunnels and flooding so in a lot of the scenarios in this campaign you have uh these tital tunnel locations and they're not connected with location markers like most locations are in Arkham hor a lot of these maps are just just orthogonally connected so so you're connected to the locations up and down and left and right from your current one the problem is this gets a little bit syy and you see these tidal tunnels in over half the scenarios there's also another system where you place flooding tokens on locations to represent whether they've got some water in them or if

they're completely flooded and being stuck in a flooded location uh at the end of your turn is pretty bad news because you know you don't have gills but again these are cool ideas that get used too much in the campaign so the title tunnels flooding and keys they're all really cool the first few times you get them in the campaign by the time you get to the finale you're like okay we've seen tital tunnels we've seen flooding and we've seen Keys we've seen all that stuff before and the finale revolves around those three things so I guess this brings me to my core problem with the endsmouth conspiracy and that is that it's a lot of great ideas but not necessarily enough great ideas for eight missions and that could have been a bit more variety here especially with the last two scenarios that I thought were a bit Yeah a bit n so let's talk about the actual scenarios the first scenario is the pit of despare and this might be my favorite opener I've played yet it is straight drama right from the start you wake up in a cave and you go to get the hell out of there as the place is filling with water this is the first time you see title tunnels it's the first time you see keys and it's the first time you deal with flooding and they're all immediately impactful this opener is just really exciting it's fast-paced and you have barely enough time to do everything you need to get the keys to get the hell out of there you leave the pit of the spare just just buzzing because it was such a close tight nasty

scenario it's also the first time you encounter the Deep ones and the Deep ones in this campaign have a thing when they engage you they do stuff to you whether it's damage or make you discard a card that means you have to be really K about okay am I going to pull that guy off my friend and take the engagement damage um or do I just take the risk and try stabbing him um and maybe damage my friend the whole deep one thing about engagement just shakes up how you deal with them and another thing about pit of despar is it goes after your health and it goes after your sanity real hard out so not only is there a fast Doom clock um there's the timer from flooding and then there's a Time from essentially the amount of damage you're taking and if you're playing a pretty squishy character and you're not running allies and don't have any kind of healing you can get overwhelmed and put it topair pretty quickly it's just a really exciting opening scenario and it leads straight into the vanishing of Alina Harper this is the scenario where you learn about the town of outh so you go all around outh and you're asking questions and you're trying to figure out who's kidnapped Elina Harper where is she being kept now Alina Harper is a federal agent and her disappearance is is the reason for you coming to enouth and I love how the scenario builds the town up and it's a very clue driven scenario compared to the previous one that was very fisty and sometimes the investigation mechanic just kind of breaks down and you don't get enough clues or you don't draw the right things from the investigation deck to determine accurately where Alina Harper's being kept and who's holding

her despite having hoovered up every single clue from the board and I imagine that could get very frustrating still a very cool scenario for how it Paints the town of enouth and for showing how enouth is part of a conspiracy this is of course the first flashback scenario which then takes you through to into deep where you return to enouth as enouth is being overrun by Deep ones this is an absolute top tier scenario this is a whale of a time there's hideous time pressure in order to get off the map there's so many different setbacks that happen in this scenario there's surprises in the middle of town uh it's tough and if you want to get all of the keys and all of the flashbacks on this scenario you have to do a lot of fighting and a lot of clue getting this is a rough scenario that will test practically any group and I really like that it shows the town that you visited before just in a very different light and it has this real palpable tension as you're desperately trying to get to your cars and get the hell out of Dodge that brings us to into deep which is a scenario that introduces vehicles in this case a boat now the setup is you're out on a boat and you're going to different Islands trying to find Clues and traveling between the islands is very very difficult without the boat so while the boat's sufficient moving around it's a magnet for teror and monsters this is a cool scenario because it does different things with the map the introduction of the boat's quite interesting because when one players on one Island which is a totally different

disconnected set of tiles over here from uh the other investigators on a different set of tiles here you feel like you are a ages apart and you are like if you had to move yourself from one Island to the other it could take you two whole turns uh drowning along the way and our first playthrough of this one where I was playing Tony Morgan I also had a very exciting Showdown with the big bad boss monster of this scenario out in the boat by myself armed only with a switchblade as Ron apparently dived off the boat went under the ocean with a switchblade and murdered the giant monster a very very fun dramatic exciting moment and at this point of the campaign I thought the inth conspiracy was absolutely brilliant I was really on a high here um i' enjoyed all four of the previous scenarios The Vanishing of Elena Harper had you know the the cludo element to it was a little bit n but the other three scenarios here had been really fun and then we got on to horror and high gear the third scenario and that brings us to horror and high gear a scenario I didn't really care much for this one's about cars and you get in the cars and there's a whole bunch of locations that will be arranged out in front of you so you start driving and you flip over locations and then you'll keep flipping them over and then locations will drop off behind you now my problem with this one is I didn't really feel like there was a lot of choice here you just kind of kep moving forward and dealing with whatever popped up in front of you and a lot of the encounter deck is just Test X take a lot

of damage text X your car blows up even though you're driving you feel like passengers in the scenario neither of my playthroughs of horror and high gear I felt like I really made a difference it was how well the deck was put together to start with and whatever I drew from the bag I didn't feel like I made many choices that brings us to the sixth scenario a light in the fog which is absolutely great um this one you're going to a lighthouse and then the Lighthouse Keeper tries to murderize you this has a lot of elements that make the Unspeakable oath from kakosa really a great scenario there's moment where you're like oh wow we're screwed and we need to work really fast or we're all going to die and the baddy is a memorable baddy and he interacts with the characters in a different way than most so light in the fog was a real bright spark in the second half of the campaign even though it was the third time we'd seen the title tunnels uh they were used in quite an interesting way here and there was a neat mini game about pumping water so you could have some locations flooded and others not so so far we're up to scenario 6 and this been four absolutely excellent scenarios one good scenario and one I didn't care for but then we have the last two and I'm just going to run through these real quick the last two scenarios are pretty average the seventh scenario the L of Deon it's all a doom pressure scenario so so many things spawn that have doom on them if you can't deal with them the Doom clock's going to advance there was an opportunity here as well to explore

the esoteric order of Deon which is one of the iconic things from the enouth law this is the Sinister group of cultist town people who are behind everything and you start off by going into the temple and then you're in the title tunnels you're in the title tunnels there's flooding mechanics and you're using keys again and the way the scenario fits in the story is this is the final flashback scenario so you're always essentially going to lose this one regardless of the outcome you get knocked on the back of the head and you end up in the pit of despair which is another reason why I think the idea of the flashbacks as cool as an idea but not NE neily that much fun when you're playing through the scenario because yeah this scenario you are doomed to fail even if you win it narratively it is always a loss and I think that kind of sucks and that brings us to the final scenario into the Maelstrom and we had the weirdest thing happen with the scenario so on the ACT card it says if you have all four Keys uh Advance the act and we started the cam the game with all four Keys uh because we' done quite well in the previous Mission and this felt really wrong to to us so we looked up online and yeah that's as it's printed how it's supposed to work but then we found a designer note that said oh actually you've got the choice advancing it doesn't automatically happen it's just very weird to set up a scenario and be told oh you Advanced straight away and the opening of a scenario is title tunnels and keys and flooding and you move on to a second act which is just flooding and keys so you have to use the keys to do things with flooding and by this point in the

campaign we're just we're kind of over that you also had the initial tear of oh no it's Deon and Hydra but they didn't really do anything this kind of sat there and once we' put down enough keys they were kind of muted and we just beat them up and there's a querk in the scenario that if you beat on deard heavily you can take the damage and use that to unflood section so yeah Tony Morgan just kind of jumped on him with a switchblade and just stabbed him until the land dried out it's very odd very very odd finale and in the end I was a little underwhelmed that's a quick run through of the eight scenarios but overall thoughts on the campaign now I've bitched and moaned about title tunnels and about keys and about the Sam of uh the enouth conspiracy and I think that is a genuine problem with the campaign the first six missions my my issues with horror and high gear aside that's great that's as good a first sort of 2third of a campaign as you've got for any of the campaigns we've played uh um P to spare into deep Devil's reef and um the lighthouse one um they they are great scenarios those four are absolutely fantastic scenarios the SEC the last two are they're not very good at all uh and it just makes the campaign whimper out and also as I mentioned way earlier you do the first half of less XP and you do the first half of a heart of chaos bag

so all of the excitement and tension is really just low front loaded in this campaign if it had sustained it it would be absolutely amazing but it just yeah it just kind of drops off and it's frustrating in so many ways because if enouth had had uh a great finale and had a great seventh and eighth Mission this would have been as good as kakosa cuz the first half is the first half I think is as good as path to kakosa but path to kakosa has a really good seventh scenario and a pretty good eighth one and enouth conspiracy doesn't and while I think enouth and kakosa both do have a bunk scenario um kakosa one is very early on and it's jammed between the last king and the Unspeakable oath which are both awesome see kind to you know can forgive it but when three of your last four scenarios are yeah at best yeah not not great for the campaign I'd still replay it I still think it's a good fun time I do think this is a very good Campa and I'm probably being very harsh on the finale because my expectations were so high going into those last two scenarios because after a light in the fog I was like this is the best campaign ever this is this is fantastic this is to carosa um and yeah then it just it just Peters out and and dies like a damp squib at the end very quickly I'll run through a couple of tips I think if you're going to run through the enouth conspiracy

that would help you through uh first one is be ready to take a lot of damage uh there's going to be sanity damage there's going to be damage damage there just going to be a lot of it coming at you all the way through the campaign another good suggestion is to have some travel cards that sort of break the travel rules open gate in particular can really throw up some scenarios like Devil's Reef another good bit of advice is to take cards and effects that stop things from engaging you so whether that's evade effects that last longer than one round or things that just move monsters around or prevent them from entering into your region anything that stops you getting engaged and re-engaged is very handy in insouth there's not that many really big chunky enemies in insouth it's not like stacked full of things that have six Health uh but there's a lot of uh different deep ones and a lot of different creatures that will just sort of somewhat swarm you so having the ability to deal with a lot of different targets uh is really good and you know things like dynamite blast can really shine here as well so very quick run through of the deck I used in our main campaign and I was playing Tony Morgan and Tony Morgan is filthy he's so damn good I did most of the campaign solely with switchblade 2 in the last couple scenarios I didn't even bother bringing the guns out I didn't need them what I focused on instead was extra actions so I put a lot of XP into H instinct which is one of the customizable cards that allowed me to get two extra actions I said double double which allowed me to double an event so if I played H Instinct I could get four extra actions I also had Swift

reflexes which could pay for extra actions as well and I could double double that as well and haste which allowed you to take extra action so when I did encounter a big bad sure I was only using a switchblade but I was using it like eight times in one turn and that can put out a heck of a lot of damage Tony's really simple to run that way you just give them a basic weapon like switchblade and you just let him go you give them lots of actions and you know with lonie r and the switchblade he's starting at eight and sometimes he's only doing one damage most of the time he's doing two but who cares when you're attacking four five six seven eight times adding some vicious blows sweeping kicks and strong arms and you got a little bit of extra damage there as well very simple deck to run I was also running glory for card draw and Payday for money not that I really needed it because the deck ran efficiently using mostly just a switchblade and because this deck was so efficient with its money I ran StreetWise three I which allow me to spend money to boost my book or boost my foot so we did need to evade something or we did need me to flex and do some investigating I could cuz I have the resources to power this and sure you're spending two resources to get the six book but if you need the clues it's worth doing it and I wasn't spending the resources on anything else also with Lonnie RIT and a leather coat he was basically impossible to kill because she can heal damage off the leather coat and heal sanity off herself the only time I had any problems with Tony was the one game where I didn't draw a weapon until

the very end of the game so yeah I'm sure someone can make a far better and far stronger Tony deck but this really simple concept of switchblade plus actions did really really well so that's the end of the review The enouth Conspiracy came tantalizingly close to being my favorite Arkham Horror experience to date and I really do wish it finished just a bit stronger than it did now I know I've been a little bit harsh on this campaign probably a little too harsh to be honest because I did enjoy it but I suppose it's always the last memories that are the freshest and my final memory of this campaign was kind of being a little bit Ah that's it when we finish the campaign now I don't think every campaign finale needs to be something new Innovative and interesting but into the malstrom in particular just went over the same ground as previous scenarios and I guess this campaign like this review is just going to end with a bit of a bum note now apparently there is a fan-made return to enouth horror uh on the ancient evil site and um I'll put links to that in the description below if you have played through the nsmith conspiracy had similar issues to me and want to check out how someone might do a return to for the enouth conspiracy cuz I'm pretty sure we're not going to see an official one come out anytime soon if at all all right join us back here in a couple of months where we'll be covering the Feast of Hemlock Veil and until next time like share and subscribe to the

channel if I were a deep one all day long I'd swim benath the sea if I were a deep one terrify the tourists blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah BL if I were a ncky yicky fish scaly slippery frogy kind of man

Progress saved