Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ranking Uwe Rosenberg's Board Games

Transcript 1:16:06

hi everyone my name is Monique and I'm Naveen from before you play and Welcome to our final Uday Rosenberg series wrap-up video oh my gosh we're here we made it yes uh so if you're not familiar with what we're talking about uh Monique and I have been covering a lot of uve Rosenberg games on the channel for the past year year and a half maybe almost two years almost two years maybe um so we've been doing playthroughs and reviews of basically all the games that we could get our hands on we've also covered uh many of the tile land games the exclusive like polyamino only kind of games and we have a ranking video for that specific kind of genre of his games which you can check out up here yes that was actually a separate series that we did as sort of like a warm-up to getting into this one although we didn't realize how large of a series this was gonna be after finishing the Thailand series we basically said let's do the big box games and then we ended up incorporating not only the big boss games but also the smaller two-player only games and basically all of UV rosenberg's games that we literally could find so this ended up being a total of I believe 18 videos and so that's not including hellertell because hellertile was a gameplay that we did prior to embarking on the series but it also includes two non-game play videos which were a comparison of the two big bucks uh caverna K versus cave and Agricola All Creatures big and small as well as uh the big box for Agricola which was not the most popular of things to be released yeah we have to we got to show you what's in it yes so just a few things before we get into it we are going to start with just discussing how

the overall series went some of the challenges we faced and just some of our thoughts on how Uber Rosenberg designs and then go into our rankings now there are a lot a lot of games that we had to rank and so we're going to be basically doing them uh through a tier system as you'll see all right so it's funny that you're mentioning uh how long it took we have posted our first video in the official series on August 15 2021. oh wow two years yeah we're about five days short of it being a two-year long Endeavor and this is for various reasons it's not ideal obviously we would have wanted it to be much shorter than that but one of the main reasons is because we didn't expect to cover all these games we thought we had a certain number of them we had a certain sort of mindset going into it as to what this would look like and how many games it would entail and it ended up being much larger than that yeah more games came out um and then also just a lot of the games that we ended up featuring that he designed and released we had not ever played before so the build up to be comfortable enough to understand the game play it on camera teach it and then talk about each individual game that adds so much more time yeah beyond all the other videos that we try to do for the channel so that's with that actually let's start by talking about some of the challenges that we Face started going into this series we're going to approach this like our research paper basically I would say probably the biggest challenge that we had was time right um I know throughout the series we had a number of comments that people who are kind of like where's the next game in

the series but doing something like this takes a lot of time and I I think that people know that but maybe don't realize just exactly how much time each single video takes a heavier game can take probably like 20 hours total just for one game for anybody who has a part-time job maybe that is the entire week of work half a weekend that's that's 20 20 hours of work so something like a piece for Odin um just editing A Feast for Odin so not not even the playing or filming literally just the editing part it's probably like eight hours which is a whole work day just because we have to take in the shots so that you can see the game better so all this to say it took a long time so we apologize for threat being so much longer than it was but it is what it is because Naveen also works and I think when we first started it I was still working I was working uh my day you did not uh transition to yeah full-time yeah until Midway of 2022 so half of the series we were both working that's right putting it into that context will hopefully make the two years make a bit more sense but despite these challenges I had a lot of fun yeah you know going into this series we mentioned that Ruby Rosenberg was one of our favorite designers and that was what caused us to go on this whole journey in the first place yeah it's interesting to see like you know because we only had like knowledge about five of his games pretty well uh and then ballooning that out to now playing like about almost 20 extra games from that and just seeing all the differences that one person can kind of come up with and how like somebody with can just come out with a

game year after year after year because uh when we go into each video we always look at like what year was this releasing like yes that was released and then that was released like how does one person work on something yeah they're so committed to the craft of Designing board games and to have so many really really good ones this is built into its DNA yeah at this point right yeah and that was another thing that was really fascinating why we I really enjoyed doing these series is because we were able to Chronicle them in order and so you can kind of see his design style evolve you can kind of play the later games and also remember the mechanics that were in the earlier games that probably led up to this large magnum opus right so it was a lot of fun despite the time uh spent um now we actually don't really own some of the games anymore so all of the the b-roll that you're gonna see is going to be from the videos that we made and so you will probably see our uh journey through content creation uh change over time as well because in those two years still images yes yeah in those two years we have also upgraded our studio uh behind the scenes now moving on to what we learned so you know this is a long series we learned a lot of things about Ruby Rosenberg along the way uh let's start with going into it what were your sort of preconceived notions of uber Rosenberg and his games just before getting into the series well I always knew Euro like you're gonna get a pure Euro you're not going to get like uh attack roll dice and fighting kind of game yes even though there is some die rolling in one of his games but it's not like you're attacking each other obviously so no battle um resource conversion and just kind of

like uh obviously the farming theme is something that I always knew it's something that was always told to me and I could just easily see it in just some of his other games yeah that's what I was gonna say actually going into the series that was what I knew in my mind Rosenberg farming farm so much over this bed of this series Euro farmer with the with always some little mechanism the feeding mechanism obviously yeah everybody talks about that that anchors you to justify why you're doing something but also forcing you to kind of split your attention between like I still need to focus on this slightly so I can't just go on my own little Venture and just say forget that one element of it because it's going to drag you back down so that's something that we see a lot of times in a lot of his games and that's funny that you mentioned that those are the two exact things that I had in my mind about Uber Rosenberg farming and feeding right because of my grecoola caverna if he's for Odin those were the main three that I had played and they all have farming and feeding and surprisingly that's not the case in all of his games they're not all farming themes actually only a few of them are and only a few of them require you to feed your workers yeah I don't think in Power Tower you have to feed your workers I don't think you have workers no no I don't yeah it's not it's not the same sort of uh implementation of a farming theme definitely solve this to say those two things that I sort of had in my mind is sort of selling him short you know there's a lot more to Everett rosenberg's designs than just those two things art style uh they're they're all sort of similar in that regard it all

kind of speaks to you it speaks to me it's got that old-timey Euro uh yeah just kind of just floating through time just you know it just it's at Lookout games look out games Clements France look I personally like it uh I know people are kind of split on it but it's so homely to me like yeah anytime I see a box that has that art style on it with those that like iconography and you see the little resources I'm like this is a nice looking game now people getting into the hobby now are probably not gonna have that sort of same sense of Holiness because when we got into the hobby a lot of the games were like that sure and nowadays you know the art is way different very different but uh yeah that is definitely a homely feeling and of course we learned a lot about the different uh mechanics mechanisms that Uber Rosenberg incorporates into his games um in my opinion what I saw throughout the series is that he sort of does a few things and then he'll sort of tweak them and then incorporate that into a new thing he like shakes it up and then like spits out and like okay these three are the mechanisms now in this game maybe he'll have like six Main mechanisms and then he'll use two of them in the next title and then he won't use them for a while then he'll use another two another in another title right um the first big box game I suppose was Agricola and that for a lot of people was what introduced uh Gamers to Evie Rosenberg you know they learned about farming via Agricola and that was what a Euro was like back then I think it came out back in 07. yes it came out a long time ago and the design style of

Agricola was never to be seen again I feel right like you played a good color and you felt how tight it was and how uh punishing it can be or Cut Throat it's not yeah it is actually very pleasant because if you don't feed your people but after that you know none of the other games after that were as punishing or as tight as as agriculture we're talking about for uve Rosenberg games yes right yes forever Rosenberg game yeah everything else was less emphasis on like you must feed you must spend one of your three actions to feed or to find a way to get food everything else was like in the process process of taking these other actions I'm going to find my my way to forage this food and to be able to just handle the feeding part of this you're given more Tools in a lot of his future games but Agricola is where we started to see one of his uh main mechanics that we saw throughout the series which was of course worker placement but we see that in a lot of Euros but really his card system so he does this thing where he'll create a system for the board game and then he'll just make a bunch of cards every time you play you just switch out what deck you use and it feels different right yeah because you never know what you're gonna get it's not like one of those games where it's like all 12 of these cards will show up at some point so you're like okay in round six I I most likely am going to get access to that one card I know about granted the work replacement spots are like that work replacement spots but that's obviously the actions that you're yes the actions that you take you can and that's a bit of the strategy with a circle as well as Cabernet yes right because you know like certain actions if you haven't played a gricola are going to be uncovered in

let's say around seven eight or nine you know we're going to have access to having a third worker or something I don't remember the exact one yeah but the cards themselves there's always such a thick deck in most of his games that you could play three games and see a totally different combination of cards yeah especially never rely on just any one specific like card like oh I'm gonna use that card when it shows up and I know I'm gonna get it yeah um so I think that's fascinating that he's able to have so many different cards it's brilliant really because if you can fall in love with the system then now you have a game that you could play over and over and over again you can play at tournaments you can do this and that and that's exactly what happened with Agricola and it's not only in Agricola you know we see this in a piece for Odin which is one of the first ways in which we experience that right that game has these occupation cards and there's like a b and c you can start with different ones and over the course of the game there's a thick huge one that has a huge index and glossary kind of going through cards a ton of cards that you can play with this or at labora that comes with two different decks um of course there's hallertau which sort of uh has like four decks yeah sort of realize it relies on that deck system and then most recently there's around Burger Canal right and that yeah that one uh the base game I think starts uh with deck A and B and then there's also comes with the game which is technically an expansion has like deck c and d uh we have not explored deck C and D because that's one of the more recent games that we've played but I'm really excited to try to play and kind of see what different combinations can be made and in addition to the card system he also plays around a lot with resources resource conversion uh there's the cubes he did in Cube form in Mercator uh with fulfilling contracts

yeah different ways to acquire your resources different ways to spend them uh to kind of game the resources by having a resource wheel move he's like so he's a resource wheel the resource wheel yeah which was pretty unique I think um yeah I think I've seen it introducing or at labora yeah we saw the card the tile flipping mechanic kind of make an appearance in lahav and then an early design yeah an early design it evolved and eventually we saw it again in fields of oral we probably decided a little bit more in between and then it all led up to eventually A Feast for Odin which is probably the most epic game of tile resource flipping right to Green yeah into blue blue is the best yeah it's it's very very interesting how he was able to just kind of come up with that and also incorporate the polyaminos from his smaller polyamino games like Patchwork into a big heavy Euro like a piece for Odin he even uh played around with turn order you know some games had different amounts of turns depending on the player count um yeah like an oranian Burger Canal which is a one or two player game every round one player is gonna get three actions in a two player game and the other round uh the other player is going to get the reactions and and your opponent gets only two actions so yeah he does that also in a new spirit we saw that we're at labora and also a two-player lahav um you're gonna have alternating uh numbers of turns you're gonna take per round which actually plays into the game uh quite well for all of them because you can kind of game it where you're like okay I'm going last during during

this round but that means I get to go first for the next round so I get double turns on the next round and I get to go back to back yeah and so that adds into like some of that strategy and kind of variability It's So Meta it's very meta right like you really get into your head and I feel like that is a pseudo way of incorporating player interaction in eight Euro game and I really appreciate that so anyway we can go on and on about the various mechanics that he employs in his games but we'll be talking about them a little bit more when we go into our final rankings where we talk about each game but uh before we do that let's have some superlatives shall we let's do it all right ready yes the theme oh best theme I'm gonna go with A Feast for Odin Bonanza Ah that's a better one maybe farming easiest to teach it's in my mind Bonanza easiest I think so all creatures big and small hardest to teach It's gotta be Feast Road in so many spots a piece product easiest to start with Ray gold glass Road best at two players not including the two player only games gotta be lahov Aura at labora it's kind of long can't be long yeah biggest surprise ooh uh the most recent one or onion burger Canal yeah me too yeah a random Burger canal and finally most different slash unique Mercator probably Mercator but also a tiwa a tiwa I found to be pretty unique all right so there you have it those are our superlatives uh enough talking let's get into our rankings shall we yes let's do it okay we're going to be ranking 18 games uh we're going to be including Bonanza so we're gonna have both Bonanza the duel as well as Bonanza on here and we're also including hallertau even though it

was not technically a part of this series it was filmed prior so uh like I was mentioning at the beginning we're going to do a three-tier system so we're going to basically start with the bottom six go into the middle and then the top six and we're going to just say what they are and then discuss sure okay so let's start with the third tier the lower six of all of these 18 games do you want to go first sure all right games 18 to 13. you want me to Rapid Fire all of them off yes bring it on the uh the pad paper there write it down in dead last it's gonna be Ray cult okay followed by atiwa then glass Road caverna cave versus cave Aura at labora and then Bonanza the duel wow that is my block a third I will try to keep my reactions uh tame this time around but let me give you my bottom six okay it is number 18 Rick Holt okay followed by atiwa oh okay Mercator news Fjord or at labora and then caberna cave versus cave so that is the two player version so I think we had different for so in that we both had four of the same games in the bottom two which ones were they Ray called atiwa uh caverna K versus cave at labora okay so let's start there oh you all said or at labora I did yeah okay so four out of the six four out of the six are in the same yeah okay so we're a bit in agreement here that now granted I don't

think that any of these games were bad no like I have to rank them you have to rank them uh I enjoyed a bit of all of them to an extent but Ray cult was definitely the one that stuck out that stuck out from all of them first time we played it was demoing it at s in the year it released I think that was 2018. I remember not being wowed then yeah and so going into this series you know years later you know about four or five years later after playing that demo replaying it again I realized no I think my initial Impressions were kind of right this is not the best of games I liked it better actually when we played it again really so when we were playing it preparing for the series I thought okay so it's it's a lot of math it really is it does feel like a math exercise um We're not gonna be going through what what all of these games are by the way but we'll give a little synopsis Ray cult is the one where you are farming in uh Iceland right quote Iceland so I actually really enjoyed the theme because we have both visited Iceland before we've actually visited Ray cult oh yeah Ray I said Reykjavik yes yeah and it's beautiful what a beautiful place country right yeah um and so I was looking forward to this game knowing about the theme but the mechanics it just was not engaging it's a race at the end of the day it's a race to get the right amount of vegetables to springboard yourself onto the next spot to get ahead of your opponents yeah it's another take on at the gates of loyang which we'll be talking about later on in the system but I I definitely don't think it was better version it's it's it's a it's similar in the sense that

it's also a race of sorts you're just trying to be the furthest ahead on the score Track by the end of the game as most games are but your resource convergent can conversioning to get there yeah and you get one free move going off and I think that free move it's it's nice like you get always get one free move to advance and so sometimes you can game the game with it and so I don't know it just it always felt like we were always getting to the same exact location every time it fell quite flat yeah uh next one for us both was a tiwa it sounded like yeah so tiwa we also said it in our in our review of the game it was one that I was really looking forward to knowing that there was a a new uh play on a mechanism in that game that we haven't seen before which is the variable worker placement spots or the way that the the tile slides depending on the round that'll change up some of the work Replacements but it'll also change the way that your animals breed and I thought that was interesting that now that that is variable and also the resource map that everybody had where everything that you take is from your own player board it was a very unique idea but there was something about it that just was not for me for me I think the biggest problem was at a certain point in the game everything just kind of Auto feeds in and the engine just like it just plays and you're just kind of playing to the end game because we played we played so many games of it and every single time at about the 60 mark it was like I'm all set I don't really have to worry too much these bats are going to give me this I'm gonna go send them out I'm gonna get this and it's just gonna run

run run run like that and that was happening game after game after game so um I could be very wrong maybe uh maybe there is more variability than that but it felt like it's the same puzzle that you're trying to yeah it did feel the same and I feel like it's one of the challenges in incorporating a theme like that because that is going to be the end goal with this theme right like there's a there's a teaching and educational aspect to the theme that he was trying to get at but also just the movement of pieces was so tedious having to move the pieces back to your board and then move them back to your player board right so I I was walking into that game really ex really hoping for a more fun experience now going a little bit further up on my list my number 13 was caverna K versus cave and what number was that for you uh 15 on my list okay so you ranked it a little bit lower a little bit lower correct so what what why did you why is this in the bottom tier for you you gotta have something there um so uh you know it's it's a good game I I actually we want to keep it in the collection I enjoy playing it yeah I'm actually surprised because after we played that one you liked it more than I did there you go I don't know I don't know people told me this is what it is and I was like okay yeah that seems right yeah I guess for me it's a fine game yeah um Uber Rosenberg has made a lot of two-player only games and I just did not find it to be the best out of all of them sure you know something has to go in that spot and that's really the only reason why it's there I think it's a good idea and we have a big box there's more there's more to be added on we

haven't really explored the big box too much um we've only played I think one game after we played the main yeah yeah with the big box and yeah it adds a little bit extra stuff um it's a good game it's a good two player game easy to understand easy to play yeah I think there's just nothing in that game in particular that was like wow like this is so interesting and nothing to move it into the next tier yeah yeah but I have a good time playing it and so that's why it ranked a little bit higher than some of the other ones in this tier and from hearing your list I think the only other one was Aura at labora which was my I believe number 13. my 14 on the list oh yeah exact same position yeah I think we had pretty much identical experiences with or at labora good game long long long um I I think that it is really it's really it really is an interesting game it's just that it takes so long particularly for us because we are so paralyzed by all of the uh the rules right so first of all Aura labora is a sort of a play on lahav except now you have your own uh property your beachfront slash mountain property where you have to build yeah we have to build these buildings onto and the buildings have a requirement like only this building can be built on a Mountainside or so you have to really now plot the spatial aspect of your playing area and to clear off space yeah you have to make sure you have access to certain different Resources by clearing off this is the first time you see the resource wheel in there yes so it is a good game uh it's just every single time we've played it it's just ran so long because

you're trying to hit that end game trigger which I can't remember what it is now it's uh I think it's like building a certain number of things but basically you have to get the wheel to to move all the way to the end game right uh the resource wheel the way that it was incorporated in that in that game was interesting but also very strategic because uh every time it would produce it kind of tells you how many of that specific resource you're going to produce when you take that producing action but only one player can actually produce on one type of resource unlike glass Road and um uh or anyone Burger Canal you have your own Resource Board and this one it's a shared communal one so if money takes all the wood

that one can get a little frustrating it could be a little bit long but it's also really fun trying to plan out where exactly everything's gonna go yes and I believe those were our only crossovers from is here so so for the other two titles that we kind of differed on I chose Mercator I guess Mercator is my number 16 for the third from the bottom yeah that one was I actually think that that's a pretty good game it's the probably the the unsung hero I guess of the of the whole thing sure but it's also the least like everything else it's very different it's very different and it's very very dry it's just it's all cubes and contracts if you were to put that in the superlatives that would be the driest if like the driest you wouldn't want to say for sure when we say dry we mean like devoid of theme find your way to a city spending time to get there getting the cubes that are produced there to accumulate them so that you can fulfill a contract in a different city yes you can literally draw out the board and then draw out the contracts and probably play a game of it right with colored cubes so that was why it made it down uh to the very bottom here but really I actually thought that was a pretty good game one of mine is Bonanza the duel a game I I really enjoy it's actually one that we take with this one we travel yeah I feel a bit betrayed we love playing this that game it was the best game in this tier for me let's say that it was number 13. good game good game love it um but obviously I did not choose regular Bonanza in this tier because that is going to be somewhere else yes I prefer regular Bonanza over

Bonanza the duel yes Monique is also very good at Bonanza the duel and I'm very not so good at it and my other one was new spirit so newsford ended up making it to the bottom I'm actually surprised that it made it down uh this far but I think for me newsford was also a bit dry it it really did feel like I was on a foggy Coastal Port uh fairly light yeah it's it's it's not that's not the problem that I actually don't have a problem with it but it's not the the fact that it's light that made it our language has to reflect the fact that everything's in the bottom yeah you have to justify right they're going to be people out there who are like newsford is my favorite of all the titles why is it in your bottom tier and this is why yeah um I did not think it was a bad game at all there were a lot of things going for it that I found to be really interesting like the Gathering of the fish on the the dinner plates um and also the the turn sequence was really interesting but it did fall a little bit on the flatter end I think I saw in some comments on our video that uh people said it is better at three plus our experience is because it was lighter than we expected and a two it just didn't have that extra element but it's not in my tier that's a fair point um it's going to be possibly in my next tier what was the last game that we differed on for you uh was glass Road glass Road was one of those uh elusive games for me for a long time yeah um I wanted to play it for a very very long time I've been seeing it in Virtual flea markets and math trades and I'm like oh should I pull the trigger on getting this game finally got to play it and it

is a good game I do appreciate what it's doing but that's one of those games where somewhere at the the 80 Mark of the game I'm like it's it that good compared to some of the other ones yeah no I don't think so and it's actually fairly low it was actually number uh 16 on my list last Road huh last road yeah yeah glass Road it's not I will talk about glass Road when it gets to my ranking of it but that's a fair assessment um I had played glass road before going into the series and Naveen had not so the only did you we've only played it at two uh I've only played it at two together yes yes even played it too and so I I will I will go back to yeah to the same uh argument that you made for newsphere that maybe it wasn't as good as it could be it's the following mechanism in glass Road there is a follow mechanism that has to do with the cards and at two players it's basically just me and you I gotta follow each other yeah exactly um and glassroad does tend to have a tighter scoring system like you really have to look for these points in that game so maybe that could also be part of it it's like I would play it it's not one of those games that I'd be like what else do you got yeah I would play if somebody said like okay we're gonna play it because quick to get into yeah fairly fast everybody's active on each other's turns um it's just something had to slot into 16 and I felt like glass Road when I did the pub meeple yeah that that suited me all right moving into tier number two so things are heating up this is now the middle of the pack and I it is numbers 12 to seven yes would you like to start off uh sure okay well this is the the last one you just spoke about newsfield

yeah number 12. okay hallertau at 11 All Creatures big and small that's the Agricola two player only uh goes next at the gates of loyang followed by Mercator which was low on yours and then of course Bonanza is the highest in this tier so I spoke about it in reverse order interesting yeah okay let's see how many crossovers we have so my number 12 is glass Road okay not too far inverted yeah 11 is Agricola All Creatures big and small then hellertau okay uh Bonanza the duel followed by lahav at number seven at the gates of loyang so three crossovers this time yep let's talk about them they are hellertau yep I'll gricola All Creatures big and small and at the gates of Lane so do you want to go first sure uh hallertau um was a game that we both uh played like we said earlier in the video uh that we played before even embarking on the Uber Rosenberg series it was the newer game that came out I want to say in early 2020 or 2021 yeah like right like right before we started a year before we started yeah yeah that one it's it's a good game uh it's interesting like there's like kind of this push-pull mechanism where you're trying to build your structure and kind of move it along yeah you're just trying to build the community center trying to build the community center um I will say it does get messy in terms of moving your resources up and down you're basically doing a lot of accounting in that game yes but uh I know I really enjoy it there's something about like okay these are my resources

and how am I going to be this little Goblin and try to move things around and like come out ahead you know then yes um hellertau is one that got really mixed reviews if I'm remembering it correctly uh when it came out there were a lot of people who were like oh this is finally Uber Rosenberg has another new game and it sounds like it's going back to the farming theme but it was not quite the farming theme right it had farming in it but it was not the Agricola caverna that maybe people were thinking I want to say it was the first one of his or only game of his that had hops in it possibly that doesn't as a resource really yeah I think so pop somewhere else were there maybe not so many resources but that is the game where all the resources came in one giant bag huge bag do not separate those components I said it in that video and I'll say it again and don't just leave it all leave it all in one leave it on her big bowl and grab what you need yes so Holly tell it for me um it's I feel like it's not surprising that it's in the middle tier because I actually ended up liking it more than I think I should have because at the end of the day Hellertown does feel a bit the card play is a bit too much like the card play can really get you a win when you really don't deserve one yes you know what I mean hard draws can be pretty brutal now yeah you can just fall into a nice card play but I think it was so fun there's something about it for people who don't like math you might not enjoy this one because it really is a lot of like how can I get this resource convert into this resource you have to keep track of your resources via that tracker it feels like you're moving around in Abacus yeah

entire game but if you enjoy like that like kind of mathy accounting of like okay I got four resources I need to get them to five so that I can spend them all to do this to do this to ultimately move my community center yes and make these cards you know really worthwhile for me then this might be one that you'll enjoy yes yes I we actually still own it um which is surprising because we tend to call games a lot but that just goes to show that we both actually really did enjoy it uh it's not our favorite and that is why it is in this middle middle tier next crossover we had was Agricola All Creatures big and small now this is the two player version of Agricola right yeah and this was actually my number 11. yeah my number ten my number ten okay so like right there uh do you want to say why um you know I like it better it's weird because like I feel like I can only compare it to the caverna two-player game I feel like that's like the fairest comparison yeah and of the two I prefer a great little All Creatures big and small yes yes that makes sense yeah now leading up to to or I guess I we had we had played all All Creatures big and small for the first time in this series and before I had found out about the big box I think it might have appeared lower it definitely would have appeared much lower because I think it's actually quite good um for people who like two-player only games I I think between the three of these small box two player only games there was actually a third one for anybody who didn't catch that in a previous video there is another uh two player only small box game called the Hub the Inland Port Inland Port is that right that's right and we did not cover

that one I had played it once before it was kind of hard for us to get it and honestly that one I think maybe felt a little bit flat for me so that had been number 19 on this one I didn't feel the of to include it she told me like we're not doing it yeah but out of all of this small two-player only games I think Agricola All Creatures big and small was the best even without the big boss sure yeah and then when we made our video so many people so many people uh wrote in comments saying oh you have to play with the other buildings the the variable uh building play that we were mentioning yeah yeah there are a ton of other buildings that you can kind of incorporate mix and match and kind of cater what kind of gameplay you're going to have and and just play with this one system and after the discovery of that thank you to everybody who put that on our radar that game climbed much higher on my list same exact reason yeah and the third crossover we had was at the gates of olayang that was my number seven so it was almost in the first tier yeah mine my number nine on the list okay we're like right in that same range yeah we are right now with this game as well as marketor by the way those are two that are probably pretty hard to find Mercator we were just lucky to have a friend who had it but at the gates of loyang it was published by a company that is no longer in business so you could probably find it on the second hand Market especially if you live in the US but I can't speak for other places around yeah I don't know if any any company has picked it up or picked up the design so it might be just influx right now yeah now at the gates of the Yang I quite like that game that is a very good game for a lot for some people I know actually I have a few friends who say that that is their favorite Uber

Rosenberg game of all time there are some really interesting sort of cut throat things that are going on in that one you're basically just uh you are farming there's a bit of farming in there you're trading um different produce you're trying to grow produce to feed to people in your in your restaurant it's very cute you have like casual customers that are coming in that you just need to feed them one time and then they go and then you have like recurring loyal customers that you have to ongoingly feed yeah um but it's not in that it doesn't feel like feed your workers kind of thing no no it's not like oh my God yeah leading customers you know what I mean yeah but they can still get angry you know the regular customers need to be fed every round and if you miss one uh feeding then they become angry you get a little nice taste if you don't feed them again then you start uh it starts docking penalties in that sense and then the way that you uh the way that you score for your casual customers depends on how many regular customers you have it's very clever the card play how you have to put a card into the courtyard and then uh there's sort of this like standoff with the with other players who's gonna put a card in the courtyard am I gonna have more to choose from before I actually choose my cards right and that would all make sense if you've played the game or if you've seen the video but um it is quite interesting in that regard and it can be quite uh tactical but the reason why it's not further up on my list I suppose besides the fact that it's hard to get is because at the end of the day the main goal here is to climb up on that track yeah you're doing all this work to gain coins to buy your

way to Victory that's right that's exactly it I thought that was a little bit so if you're on the scoring track it's basically a race whoever's going to get out in front if you're trying to go from six to seven you have to spend seven coins yes yes if you're trying to get from 18 to 19 you got to spend 19 coins right right so that's essentially what you're trying to do you're trying to do all these different things to collect money so you can spend it to go up on a track yes and so scores end up being very tight uh you know it is it is a tight game yeah yeah but the mechanics in that are quite special so those are the only three that we had crossovered in this section uh we already kind of spoke on Newsfeed in the previous section which is what you had that was the very first one in this next year that was going to be uh number 12 for me and then Mercator which is that kind of dry resource uh kind of sending it from City to city that is actually higher on my list that is number eight overall for me I really enjoyed it I would love to get a copy of it um why are both of those titles I suppose higher on your list than maybe it was online well newsford is right on the cusp it was just right to be clear it's not that high yeah well I did I did enjoy it the fact that it was light was kind of nice it felt kind of good to like you get that box on this shirt yeah yeah I think like oh what is this going to be like I haven't played it and then you like once you taught it I was like oh that's it yeah okay cool like like a light just kind of casual experience it's daunting but when you get the box it looks like it is and then you look at the components and you set it up and you're like oh that's it okay cool yeah okay I totally get it you get into it so I think that's why sometimes you want like an experience like that yeah and I did enjoy my experience of playing music I

do want to play it at higher player counts because I've also heard that it is a better experience when you play with three or potentially four players yeah so it's just right on the cusp though it could have gone either way to the other tier uh Mercator though that was I do like dry games this is a very dry game um that was a really fun one you're trying to manage your time as well as try to run around the board uh collecting different types of resources from their respective cities putting them all together so that you can go and fulfill contracts and try to refulfill that contract over and over and over again um it's just a fun game for me because it's kind of like this like tactical and like how you're gonna get your way around and you're trying to wait till certain resources accumulate and try to capitalize on it before your opponent does so I don't know I thought it was a really good experience we only played that one I think at two and maybe we played it at three also yeah so but not not any higher than that and that was one of the earlier ones that we covered yeah we didn't play it at four but both both player counts felt balanced and good for me and yeah yeah it's really enjoyed it I specific typically remember in the moment when we were covering Mercator that you were quite impressed Naveen was very very happy about that game and was like why isn't this why is this such a sleepy sleeper hit yeah why is it not in print yeah but it I mean I'm speaking from somebody who put it lower on on my list but it is quite dry but but mechanically sound yep and of course the last one in this list the highest one uh in this tier would be regular old Bonanza love that game it's a great game you're Bean farming You're basically trading with your opponents yes yes uh very interactive super

interact might have been might be his most interactive game like I said your bean farming you are trying to trade with your opponents because you're kind of stuck in the situation where you cannot move the cards that are in your hand yeah sometimes cards in your hand just get in the way and you're like I know if I give you this card it's gonna be really good for you but it's gonna be equally or even better for me to give off this card to you so that I can get my farm right and so um right I don't know it's it's I always have a really good time with it and that's why it's number seven on my list I'm honestly quite shocked that it's higher on my list than on yours because Naveen loves that is funny Bonanza he will take Bonanza and I'll say no no that's not let's not play Banana it can be very long and I'll talk about it more when it appears on my list but I'm just I am I am quite shocked honestly that is so funny I I it's weird yeah I like Bonanza more than you but it's better on your list yes yes yes oh Pub meeple what have you done and for me the three titles that differed from your list where number 12 for me was glass road so it's not actually that far off from yours yep um I I do think that I like glass row just a little bit more than you do uh I could tell that just from I was excited actually to show him glass road because glass Road was one of the first Uber Rosenberg games I'd ever played it actually I think it was the first one maybe because I started playing glass Road when I first got into the hobby a friend taught it to me and that was before I even knew who Rosenberg was and I thought this is this is interesting you know it was what introduced me to this style of uh art and just this theme game so I was actually introduced to the wheel before

any of the other farming games so maybe I do have a slight you know bit of attachment to it and I I've also played it with more than two players right so I can I can kind of see what the game is capable challenge for that experience yeah but it also does I do agree with a lot of the points you made and so that is why it is at the bottom of the middle tier for me okay the next one for me was Bonanza the duel which was my number nine and I know that appeared much lower that was near tier three yep I cannot believe that but now that we love Bonanza the duel we do we we do a lot of videos where we talk about uh travel games or we actually did one more recently and we did not mention Bonanza the duel but this is actually one of our most traveled games it's small box it is you get the Bonanza experience it's done very well for two players yeah um the way you kind of have to give up different uh different beans yeah something beans it is so funny and you're trying to match these different contracts that are on some of these cards to score more points yeah it's it's a good game I really enjoy it I do I have seen people review it sort of lukewarm you know I don't know if other people share the same fervor that I have for Bonanza the duel I think it's also dependent on who you're playing with because with Bonanza the duel what sets it apart from some of the other games even regular Bonanza is that bluffing aspect because you have all the beans in the middle and you have to gift each other a bean card and you might not even have the bean card in your hand but you can still pretend to gift it and I think that is what you don't want them to take you up on the offer yeah that is a really funny experience yeah those are the big three that we always travel with used to travel with at least we're

Bonanza the duel hanumikoji and a shot and ton so I'm a little bit offended that it was a little bit lower on your list but and the last one is my number eight which was just one step above Bonanza the duel and we haven't heard it on your list yet I didn't mention it in this last year makes sense because I know going into lahab that was a game that Naveen was much more uh much more excited about I think than me he even even played the app right I have the app the app's great yeah we'll save that for when it gets to your list I guess but for me lahav runs a bit too long because you have to build out all the buildings if I'm remembering correctly I do like a lot of things that lahav does especially because it is such a simple concept you know you you move your ship and then you either take resources or you build buildings like the the options are so simple and so straightforward but it's the end goal that is so interesting because it's it's like for me it's his first like truly economic game but it's not economic like other games such as like brass or anything that like really exchanges money it's all in the form of these buildings you're buying buildings but you can also sell them back but you're gonna take half the amount that you spent for them but you're also buying ships and then you can utilize the buildings so I do find it quite interesting and that's why it made it into this middle tier but uh it also just gets so messy by the end of the game if you catch the playthrough like all the building the discards all over the place yeah yeah they are I struggle a bit with games that sort of end like that but it is in my middle tier after

all so it's a good game it's fair all right moving on to the final tier this is the top six games on both of our lists and I think we'll go one by one this time since it is the top of the the cream of the crop there you go the top of the top all right uh coming in at number six Naveen number six this is the newest one to us one that we did not think we were gonna cover on the channel if you know it is oranion Burger Canal uh very very good one or two player only game this was a very limited release in terms of uh production and how many copies are out there it was on game found and so we really weren't sure if we were going to cover it and so we fortunately were able to borrow one of our friends copy um and it's a fantastic game you are trying to build out different uh routes on your own board and put different types of uh structures or buildings around it and try to make those structures or buildings trigger so that you can try to get more resources to score more you're building the Iranian Burger Canal you're building the canal so you're trying to build Rail lines and different Pathways and the canals and you're trying to Cozy up things next to each other try to build Bridges or Canal uh Bridges from building to building so that you can try to trigger them uh it's very very uh simple design but also complex at the same time right right I really enjoy the turn structure in this game the way uh we kind of mentioned it earlier in the video this one has it in a two-player game one player is going to go three times on one round and the other player will go two times until you're trying to figure out okay Monique

really needs that spot I could use that spot I don't know it's just a very very good experience it is freshest in my mind in terms of all the UV Rosenberg games so that okay probably play some role into it but I still really really enjoy it and I'm very glad that we were able to pick up our own copy of it and so that is my number six that is already in Burger Canal awesome all righty bear Canal uh I have not spoken about yet so I'll talk about it more when when it gets to that point but my number six is Bonanza the game that I guess I like more than you even though you like it by one more than me like it more than I do truly um Bonanza is a fantastic game if you've never played any uh Uber Rosenberg game before this is not going to give you an idea as to how the other games play you know how because it's so different yeah in the superlatives you said most different I said Mercator Bonanza is very much so yeah this is just a card game you are bean farming and being trading and the trading is where a majority of the gameplay takes place you are uh there's so much player interaction you know you are asking do you have a red bean I'll trade you for this bead it gets very political it's it is the game where you cannot change the order of cards that are in your hand so if you ever hear that mechanic the first time I've seen that was from Bonanza and every time we play it there are laughs around the table um it's just a good time it the reason why I don't like it as much as or like the reason why I think Naveen likes it more than I do is because I I sometimes veto the game because it can run a bit long she feels like it runs long I know I disagree because as the rounds go on

the first round is the longest yeah but as the rounds go on and people start scoring cards come out of the deck so as you Shuffle and go through it it's just going to be faster and faster as it goes along and there are different versions now of the game so I could I think when we we played Bonanza fairly recently this year at um at aircon with a fine group of folks thank you so much for playing that with us and they were playing with the newest edition of the game that was different from ours they don't have a third field they do not have a third field yeah I think you're right so just be aware that there are other versions of it I think I liked this that version better the one without the third field so I would recommend maybe trying that but also can you imagine he designed Bonanza he designed a piece for Odin he also designed at the gates of Lang like these are super super different different games and that is why I think he is such a fantastic designer uh my number five is two-player only again this is a Fields viral two player only where uh part of the actions you're gonna take uh are gonna be on one side of the board and then at a the next round you can take actions on the other side of the board and so trying to figure out like okay I need this in this action on this side and then hopefully when it's my turn yeah that one spot of these like 12 spots that I I can go to is open for me but of course Monique takes the one spot that I need to go to so I gotta find other clever ways to get the things that I need which actions am I going to upgrade so that they're better every single time I take them yes yes there's a lot of little things that are going on in this game that that I really really enjoy and um we had not

this is one of those games that we had not played it sat on our shelfish aim for a very very long time and so because of doing this uh this series we were able to pull it off the shelf and play it several times and really really enjoyed it every single time I played it yeah big box two player only all right well my number five is Agricola which I'm not actually surprised by um Agricola was a game that I think had I had I even played it I think maybe it was one of the games that I hadn't played going into the series Agricola was a game that we had not played we had caverna before that and I was so surprised by that because getting into when we're getting into the hobby Agricola was like the game that everybody was going into tournaments for everybody had that foundational knowledge of Agricola yeah in the medium to medium heavy like yeah I think at the time its reputation uh succeeded or whatever that saying is that I heard about how how heavy it was before even getting to try it and that was daunting for me you know when you first get into the hobby you're just trying to explore games you don't want to get into anything that's too intense anything that is marketed by people as the game punishes you yeah it doesn't sound uh like uh I don't know yes now I have a good understanding of why people consider that game to be a masterpiece it is really punishing it sometimes does not feel good to play that game yeah and so that is why it is kind of a little bit lower in this tier as opposed to some of the other games that it might be similar to it um but it is a very well designed game they do not make games like that as

often as they did back then I feel where you could really you could really hurt yourself yeah like you you really are really stealing uh work replacement spots from other people the timing of when you take certain spots is so important it is variable in the occupations and such that you put into play and you're sweating the whole time it's a really really good game uh it is actually my number four on my list so we can just go ahead and just reveal that now okay talking about it you just kind of you know blend it was just slightly higher the one nothing though that I want to say is even though agriculture is so high on my list this is more of an objective Viewpoint um in terms of fun factor and do how often do I want to play these games it would not probably appear that high because of how painful it can be yeah but I can objectively see it as a really really really well designed game like that really set the tone for a lot of things in this space yeah this one is it's really tight and like you're always every single round you have to almost it feels like to me that you almost have to dedicate one of your actions to somehow eking out some food so it's like sometimes you have three words I think that's a fact right because I think in the game you start with two and then yeah you can grow your family to three four you know but every single round one of your workers is like anchored to this need to feed and that like that stress of of like how the heck am I gonna do this but I still want to build this and I want to do that I mean they'll have to think about this food what you really want to do is create a food engine

engine so if you can get that going that's what you really want to do because you don't want to be in later rounds trying to just get the fish or whatever it is right you you want to be able to create a process that's like okay it's not as uh stressful to feed later on in the game yeah right and building towards that engine yeah is one of the funnest parts for me yeah and I think the one the other thing that I didn't mention that is quite uh intro ing about this game is this scores you know it's scores I think are low if I remember correctly we've got to do a little bit of everything you have to do a little bit of everything instead of like um you know more recent Euro games where it's like you can kind of specialize and just hit that one thing really hard and score so many points because of this one path that you took and I quickly you have to do it all because you're going to get docked points if you don't have one type of animal or something there's like a chart that you follow that'll get literally negative points yeah like you omit getting a certain type of animal a certain type of resources things like that so you need to spread out you do yeah so you have to manage your animals you have to manage your crops you have to manage your people yeah really really good game yeah because my number four and your number five Agricola my number four is Burger canal so we have touched upon this one a little bit um this is one of the ones but by the way we're so sorry we have not been discussing which games we got as review copies uh yes um around number cadell was actually a game that was lent To Us by Jennifer thank you so much in order to do the video and then we got a review copy of that one I think other than that the other review copies we got were Ray Holt which is the one that appeared at the bottom of our list news

fjard atiwa atiwa uh hallertau I think that's it that might be it that might be it because a lot of the other games were are so old you know but we bought them or we bought them or we had them or we traded for them so anyway Orlando is one of them and this was a very big surprise for me uh like Navy was mentioning we were not planning on covering oranenburg Canal at all because it did not have distribution in North America and we really kind of care about that because it's uh we don't want to you know make a gameplay video and it's like well sorry now you can't get it like just watching yeah yeah this is the newest one yeah yes and then we went to Japan on our recent trip and we saw it there so we thought you know what it has a wider distribution in other areas of the world like we can we should probably cover it and I can see it being picked up by somebody we don't know where it's at right now where it is right now so maybe it is getting distributed in North America or maybe it's already here we're not sure who knows but it is so good that I really really enjoyed that as it and it's it's interesting that it's another uh it seems like a small box two-player game but it's really not no it is like a big it's not as big as fields for our like I feel for all is really heavy two-player game a roundabout Canal is uh it is exactly how Naveen described it but just that there's so much going on for it in terms of the The Meta game of the worker placement uh you know which spots they take there's only a certain number of spots where you can actually build buildings and then build bridges yeah before you can build bridge and then yeah build Bridges and the spatial aspect of okay how am I gonna plot my

routes because some of the cards require uh you to have the certain routes around it so there's is a large spatial component to it but there's also the timing of when to actually trigger your buildings and all of that into one makes for a really crunchy uh satisfying puzzle yeah and you have to take the opportunities when you can on certain actions sometimes like you're taking an action it's like and you can build a path or and you can build a something and you're like I don't know what needs to go here but I'm going to build a canal here and try to find the card that's going to make that work yeah because because you have to take opportunities when they're presented to you because if not you're going to find yourself like oh I wish three rounds ago I built the railroad track here because that would have been so perfect so um it yeah it's it's a really really good game we really enjoy it and I'm actually really looking forward to getting into the other decks expansions no Gunner there is a bit of recency bias right that always comes into some of this that is the most recent game that we covered but so was a tiwa and they made it onto very different ends of our list so anyway highly impressed by a Randy bird Canal that was my number four all right this comes down to the top three Ube Rosenberg games of all time up to now because cause he knows what's coming out yes that's true my number three is caverna the cave Farmers wow big box this is one of those games that I uh I actually picked up on a whim it had the uh oh what's it called the broken token inserts yeah when I got it I think I got it in a trade or some somehow in some way I found it um it's a great game there's always that question of Agricola versus caverna yeah which one do you

like which one do you like more I like Agricola but clearly with karuna being number three and a group of being four yes caverna just inches it out just a little bit more I really enjoy in Agricola the fact that you can kind of go and craft those weapons yes sorry in caverna then you can go craft those weapons uh and kind of go on those little excursions yes yes yes kind of build out your cave but also build up the Forest Area yeah put different building tiles uh down um it's just a really really fun game it's very similar in that vein as like a gorilla but it just adds those elements that make it that much sweeter it's a gricola with a with an opposite feel yeah completely different feel I'm actually very surprised that this is in your top tier because the first time the first few times we played kubernet I think it took a little bit of time to let it for it to stick so Corona was one that I had played before going into the Uber Rosenberg Series yeah and then like we had played it once maybe twice and then there was a huge like lag time before leading into uh playing this and then we played it more and more getting ready to be able to film it um it's the playing it more and more get getting ready to film it where I really saw some of the strategies the first time I was kind of wandering aimlessly yeah that's what I mean you're just kind of wandering around and like I don't really and a lot of we didn't mention this and a lot of uber Rosenberg games you're gonna look down and be like huh how the I don't see where this is gonna ramp up fun of that in a bunch of his games yeah because it's like that's gonna cost a lot of ore there's only one coming out every round huh how's it

gonna happen yes yes and then all of a sudden as you get going and so the first game or two I didn't see that ramp up yeah so it was so hard to predict what actions make sense as you play it more and more you discover more and more as to like what you need to do by a certain point and then you can go on different paths you know yeah so that's what made this game uh in top top three for me yeah I remember the first couple of times um Naveen played it in particular we would play it again and he would say I I'm just not seeing it I don't know what what are you supposed to do in this game like what am I supposed to do and I wasn't that I wasn't appreciating it yeah it's just I was not making combinations or making decisions you weren't seeing the past I wasn't seeing a pathway I would just take this random action maybe that's door a and then all of a sudden I'm doing something in door d and then I'm doing something in door B but they're never like coming together converging yeah so then as you see that kind of happen uh then the game becomes way more enjoyable yeah and the end becomes a game yeah exactly so yeah that is my number three that is caverna okay I will have more to say on that in a bit but my number three is one that you'd already mentioned it's fields of oral I quite enjoyed fields of oral the first time we played it I actually didn't enjoy it as much as I thought I would for some reason and then we played it more and I really started to see where what it's getting at and and sort of what what makes it so great fields of oral by the way we mentioned it earlier but this is the the two-player big box heavy experience but only for one or two players and uh I think the reason why I didn't really take to it initially was

because I saw a lot of similarities I saw a lot of precursors to A Feast for Odin that I felt like was like you know when you kind of see the premature version of something it's a little bit more lackluster maybe if I had played it in the opposite order I would have a I would have had a different experience but eventually I got to a point where I kind of saw the game for what it was and how tactical it is I really enjoy the different seasons mechanism that you're kind of alluding to and the fact that once per round one person can jump to the opposite side but it also affects turn order so clever in that so if you jump ship then you are going second for sure yeah so if you're already going second then it's like I'm gonna totally jump yeah yeah to the other side but the timing of that because what if the other player does it first you know he was able to produce a very tactical two-player experience in a big heavy uh gameplay and I thought that that was really cool being able to go up on the tracks um in order to uh maximize the outcomes of some of the actions was really interesting but also figuring out which tracks to go up on because don't just go up on them willy-nilly it's very expensive to do that so you better go up on the tracks that you know you're going to utilize expensive and build time and resources yeah you have to spend one of your few workers to just be able to say okay I'm gonna go make this action better was that worth it was that a good use of that did you do it early enough in the game right taking that better action better and more times yes uh so which action do you take you know which which pathway am I going to go down but there are also so many other things that are going for it the fact that you have to clear your board but there are only

certain spots that'll actually allow you to do that you know or if you have them on your board it's negative points that I think it's Pete there's always Pete anyway it was the first game she likes to utilize his Pete a lot it's a very clever game really really well done it tends to do in it yeah lots of things to do and that is one that is still in our collection one that sat in our collection also that's what's so great about doing these Series yeah it's like it forces you to play it forces you to play then you're like I've had this for four years yeah what the heck what have I been missing out yeah yeah yeah but it's nice to know that we we own it all right the final two Naveen what is your number two favorite game if it wasn't Burgers games 10 ultimate on my list as Monique would like to say right it is an older one okay one that we have not mentioned before love I mentioned it yeah you mentioned yeah it's Lauren I think because it was so low I was like this just forget it don't even Adventure money kind of already mentioned some of the mechanisms when she talked about it but for me this one is really I like like this one a lot because of the way the energy is used in this game so there's uh you get the resources like Peach and then you want to convert it this is like the very first time you see any of his conversions you want to convert it into better stuff but in order to convert it you better have have the building or your opponent has the building that allows you to convert these raw materials into better quality materials and there's this huge economy going on with a bunch of different resources you have to still feed your people so you have to always be Tethered

to that idea of like I need to to take care of my family in order to kind of prosper in this Society you're trying to build different ships to try to ship different goods and uh there's a lot of different things going on in it but on your turn it's very simple you just move the pawn do you want to take all the things do you want to construct a building yeah or um or do you want to activate one of your buildings essentially so I don't know the app makes it really really easy to learn if you've already played the the physical game oh okay if you were to download the app it's a fantastic app I could see this being super difficult to understand but reinforcing my gameplay by playing the app after we had played the game a bunch made it kind of elevate for me the AI on the computer is fairly good on the app and I don't know it's just such a smooth design for me now I know you did mention that it gets kind of messy with all the buildings but I guess not with the app I've never played the app the app is is nice and neat yeah and then like as long as you can kind of section things off then yeah it's not too bad yeah I I knew that this is going to be high on your list uh truthfully I didn't realize it was gonna be number two I didn't know that it was gonna be that high I didn't think about it until I put it in Pub meeple and every time it was showing up that I was smacking down another game and like allowing this one to go and it showed up yeah number two and I was like you know what yes I I would still pick that in that top three top four and sure enough when I look at lahav caverna and Agricola I think lahave is my favorite of those three and

sometimes you love a game for no other reason but the fact that you just you'll love it yes right and so I feel like that a lot of that kind of shines through I want to play it again all right um my number two this is my penultimate choice is caverna the cave Farmers so this is not actually one that I was surprised by I was I was sort of pseudo hoping that I would find a game along the way that would supersede that for me because I already knew going into the series that I really loved Governor um especially as opposed to Agricola there are very different experiences but they pretty much play on a lot of the same mechanisms it's the same theme it looks very similar you have the same like board and like main board and it uses the same sort of system in terms of the worker placement spots but just the things that he added to caverna just changes the feel entirely this is the first sandbox game that I've ever played and that's kind of where Naveen was kind of running into his issues with it the first few times he played it I'm sure a lot of people can relate to that that feeling of running around with your head cut off right yeah you weren't being funneled into like ah this is the decision you make there's no there are no obvious decisions you just go and make a decision and then you keep making them to try to build something but the thing that feels so good about Cabernet is there are many parts of the game that are just an obvious serotonin release like you can always go on an adventure and whenever you go adventuring with your uh are they dwarves the dwarf that makes weapons you're always going to get something in it it kind of reminds me of my childhood of like when you go to like

uh you know a place where you can win yeah we can win prizes and it's like well these are the different tiers depending on how many tickets you have it is sort of like that that's true that's funny you can choose from the menu of items and even in that decision you're like which items are gonna serve me the most you know so it's very strategic in that regard but there's just so much more that you can do with it and just that that feeling of your head is buried in this game creating this grand plan that's going to come to fruition or not is just such a fun experience and then you take that base game experience yeah you add on your what one of your favorite things which is asymmetry which is David mentioned yeah I think that's playing that is what elevated the game for you the very first time I played Cabernet was with the expansion the Forgotten folk expansion and we did not cover it we didn't feature it because not everybody is going to have that expansion um and I believe they release two more expansions after that that we haven't played just so you know but with a forgotten folk expansion everybody plays as an asymmetric uh faction and one there is there's a very strong power that's associated with it and a very strong negative negative is that a boon yeah yeah something like that like you're really good at something but then but to counteract that it's like yeah but you're also hurting in this one other thing yes and it also includes some other um new mechanisms and resources that are not part of the base game but I really really enjoyed it with that but I also enjoy it without it so I think kaverna is a an excellent game um some might say a masterpiece really depends on where you are fantastic in that that uh threshold of a great versus caverna so that is my number two caverna the

cave Farmers which leads us to our number one and I think we both did not mention the same title I already knew this one for you but this is also my favorite as well so our favorite game of ugly rosenberg's of all time up to this point is a feast yes and this is does that come as a surprise I think uh to either of us this is this was our favorite game of his going into the series before we even started and I think sometimes honestly sometimes it our top my at least my top five games of all time of uh kind of they rotate right depending on my mood sure and every now and then this is my favorite game of all time yeah so it's okay it's in that five yeah yeah the top three to five I remember where it was in my top 50 of all time but it's somewhere up there yeah it's definitely somewhere up there up there with vitalacertas games with side these are all games that I really really love and so this is definitely still the number one um of all 18 or so games that we played so a piece for Odin is the other Sandbox game probably the most Sandbox game that I've ever played sure it incorporates so many of his previous mechanisms you've got the worker placement but now it's this massive board massive menu that people will look at and run in the opposite direction it's what makes teaching the game a little difficult because like you want to say like these type of actions are all grouped together but you need to know every single one of these actions just so everyone can care about it it's also really interesting because you start the game with negative points like you have to cover up your entire board and like Naveen was saying sometimes

with these games it's really hard to kind of foresee the ramp up and in this game in particular you're like in around five sometimes and you're like I have so many negatives I gonna just see my myself out somehow though like by the by the sixth and seventh round you're just like and it just kind of all like sets itself as long as like you you've gone on a direction that that makes sense it's kind of like in that same vein of caverna you could technically take a bunch of actions that don't really go together yeah and kind of just go nowhere but with experience in this game you should be able to to get a lot of those negatives off of your yeah there are two versions of the game there's a sixth round and the seventh round and we will always say that the seven seven round game is the main game because the six round game does not allow for enough ramp up in our experience but a major part of the game is the polyamino tiles so I found it to be super interesting that he took the polo polyamano experience from like his other Italian games and Incorporated that into a big box game I was sort of alluding to that in fields of oral that you kind of see the premature versions of that like you see the polyamino tiles that need to go into your vehicles they get flipped over but it is a very precursor to What A Feast for Odin really is I mean the game comes with like two trays of these tiles that are all you know color-coded and you have to upgrade that and flip them over and it's just this really intense experience yeah there's so much going on in this one um competition for spots in a two-player game is less I think I like this game best at three and four players yeah it

plays really well higher player counts just because it's it does get tighter and just agonizing waiting for your turn to to be able to go wailing or something like that yeah you know in a higher player account is just a little bit bit more interesting I still enjoy playing it at two but the Norwegians expansion also really uh solidified this game as my number one because it's not so much like uh like an expansion that adds different things although it does you know it adds a lot more variety in terms of the island it's more of a large component fix it expansion for me I think it just like it balances things out it adds another animal in there like the the horses is it yeah um and then also it changes some of the worker placement boards and then it also added this element of a fifth uh column where you can place your workers out to take actions but if you place your worker out there that's the end of your round for you so you're trying to do this thing where you're kind of waiting when is the right time to go and take that really sweet action the game also comes with a ton of cards those occupation cards the guys are mentioning earlier can be uh useful but what I really enjoy about it is if you find yourself in an occupation that you've drawn and you're like this is not good for me there's an opportunity to get rid of them just to score some points which is also really really nice yeah that regions expansion is my favorite expansion of all time and honestly that is the the way that I prefer for our expansions to be I don't necessarily need an expansion to to introduce a new entirely New Concept into a game that I already love I would just rather it improve upon the game that I love to make it to make me love it more right something that I can incorporate from the get-go and not have to teach

somebody the base game and then the expansion right the Norwegian expansion is exactly that yeah whenever we teach new players we'll just teach what the Norwegians expansion not even tell you what is the difference between the two uh with and without the expansion yeah but if he's for Odin is just such a unique experience we can go on and on about that game but there's just so much going on with it that you don't really see in other games even something just like the the income the income mechanic how you have to cover up the income and then maybe get additional islands and you know more experienced players uh and I wouldn't even consider ourselves we have played this game a lot but we're not particularly good sorry nivian I don't know if that's true for you but I know I'm not particularly good at it but if you want to get really good at it you have to be able to utilize those islands and that's for me that's the hard part yeah right early early gaming with this it's like I I'm going to take on more negatives by taking on an island no thank you no there's there's enough time there's enough way to go ahead and get those islands coming to score points to use them to your advantage uh it's just a fantastic game there's so many different Avenues uh and Pathways that you can go on yeah and if you see that one of your opponents is kind of running away on a pathway you're like enough get competitive stop stealing it and that's what's so great because it it mixes both the competition for spots as well as the openness at the same time like you can always zag or you can just compete with somebody who's doing something too much there's always a competition for flipping over your boats right because that always scores a lot of points but now you're out of commission on a boat it's just such a clever game very well designed and up to this point I think I still think it is his Magnum magnum opus

number one for both of us number one well there you have it that is our final uh ranking oh my gosh it's done Naveen it's done done I can't I cannot begin to describe the the feeling of relief of being able to close this chapter of Our Lives not just of not just the viewing of the channel it's really of Our Lives because we've been having this in the back of our mind for two years we love the games we love the game but there's a difference between just exploring the games and the content creation aspect to it completely different parts of having to do something like this but it's important for you to know that this list was not exclusive there are other games that we did not cover um there are only a few of them that we were able to include but uh I know I mentioned the two player only Inland Port as an example but these are a majority of them that he had released and we'll see if we can continue to cover them but this is probably the largest sort of series that we'll ever be able to embark on yeah as as more games come out very similar to um the laserta series uh as more games come out hopefully we can try to you know still feature them but there's not like this kind of love with rosenberg's games yeah but there's not this kind of like oh my gosh we have six more games on the horizon that we still have to cover that are all two two and a half hour games so that does feel pretty nice so we can kind of get back to our other scheduled programming so uh before we get to what's coming up next we want to thank of course Daniel from the game table um and Jennifer for uh lending us some

of the games that we were able to cover thank everybody out there who's been following along on the series because this was a very difficult Endeavor for the both of us um thank you to all the Publishers who are very supportive in this as well uh most notably asmode and Lookout games are very supportive and making sure that we had the games that we needed Capstone games sent us yes so yeah we had we had all the games that we could grab yeah and and so we were able to spillworks also thank you so much for sending a copy of whatever Canal yeah because again it's on our top tier and so we're really excited to have that yeah and I really hope that gets a wider distribution if it has not already so now now that this is done uh moving forward I know a lot of people have been asking what series are you gonna do next we are going to do the rest of the Mind Clash stuff that we had started there were a lot of issues in terms of the Mind Clash Series in terms of what was happening in our lives at the time when we had started that as well as now running along with Uber Rosenberg series now that we've been talking about it clearly um you know we couldn't have done both at the same time which we now know timing was and for the Uber Rosenberg series I believe we did at least five more games and we than we had anticipated so it was just a big time commitment so we are actually we have been actively working on anacrony which is going to come next so you should stay tuned for that and then after that we're going to take a little bit of a break before we start on a new series because of a few reasons first thing is we are actually moving out of our house for a few months yeah uh so that'll make doing something like that very difficult very difficult and also because we want to get back to just covering older games in

general that is our passion we love covering older games that are that are still good that still hold up to this day and sort of spreading the word about it so we'll be doing that before we embark on anything new also if you all want to let us know in the comments comment section what you would rank as your top 18 top 20 whatever however many games you've played of uber Rosenberg we'd love to see that and we'd like to see where kind of our ranks uh Stack Up and also where other people's ranks stuck up to other people so yeah and why and why here whatever you're willing to share yeah we definitely read those and and uh it plays a role in how we think about about these games yeah it does again thank you all so much for your support uh we really hope you enjoyed the series and we will see you all next time thanks thank you bye thank you foreign

Progress saved