Skip to main content
Loading video...

Zombicide: Dead Men Tales - How will Asmodee CMON? - Kickstarter Critique Review

Transcript 23:52

Ahoy there, YouTube. I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every week at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. Give my honest thoughts on how that project is being run. Quick apologies on yesterday not having a show. My granny came over. She's 90 years old and gave me some advice on my house. But today, I'm actually legitimately excited to see how Fantasy Flight Games and Asmodee, curiously, lowercase Asmodee, I don't know if that matters at all, but uh are doing Zombicide: Dead Men Tell. So this was part of the CMON sell-off or CMON had a whole bunch of issues, CoolMiniOrNot for you that aren't big board game nerds, massive board game company ended up doing a lot of minis games that ended up having a lot of problems and they had to sell stuff off and this is Zombicide which has seen like 20 different versions already, but a million people, excuse me, a million dollars have already made So this one's going to be version 25. Fantasy Zombicide is back and this time it's a pirate invasion Dead Men Tell. Dead Men Tell brings the hugely popular Zombicide game play to paradisiacal pirate island. Is that a word? Paradisi- Oh, it's like paradise, but it's a it's a it's an adjective. I've never seen that adjective. Paradisiacal pirate islands where gold is plentiful from grog.

Where gold is plentiful grog flows freely. Command crews of humans, orcs, elves, and more as you face off against relentless zombie hordes. Fire cannons, swing from ropes, and fight for survival as the undead attack from every direction including the sea itself. Dive even deeper into the fantasy world with Black Plague Comics volume two and the Plague Bear role-playing game for an even more immersive experience. All this comes to life with the stunning artwork and miniatures you know and love from Zombicide. So it's the expansion / game, but we're also we're just going to throw in a comic book and some RPG book cuz you know why not? We're just seeing if we make more money. Interesting. One to six players, ages 14 plus. Look at the main image. It's boring. Very boring. There's a box. Hey, it's Zombicide and now it's got pirates. It's It's all I know. And if I don't know the difference Like if I don't pay attention to the publishers, then I don't notice anything different about this.

That shot right there is a nice rectangular shot. As always, the video I'm thinking three things. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? Let's see how they convince 5,000 people to give them $1 million of their $200,000 goal. A plague might have devoured the land, but a pirate's life is the sea. It kept us safe to plunder and pillage to our hearts' content. There's a map with an X. It kept our islands untouched by death's grasp. So this is one of those things I like to do when I really don't like videos. So I just want to put this in perspective. We have 129 seconds and we've wasted 21 of it. Got it. So that's roughly 1/6 of our time. But the curse can't be held at bay forever.

Oh, there's zombies. Wait for a very different kind of sale. Is it different? Uh there we go. Where's the game? Oh, that See this This is nice. I would love to see this on the main image. I would love to see this closer to the main start. Like showcase something here aside from hey, it's It's now it's Zombicide but with pirates. Like come on. Okay, there we go. Very looking minis. It's a swashbuckling new installment. With a governor plotting an evil scheme,

and it's all hands on deck to stop the scourge. Steel your nerves with liquid courage. So they're just saying hey, you can use cards to to plan yourself. Okay. Until the dead who run this port.

Learn the ropes. Ha, pun cuz there's rope there. I will say they did a great job spotlighting the components though. Really in-depth miniatures. Fire. You can fire at the shooting cannons at the zombies obviously, you know. That's cool. Oh, hey, there it is. So there's all this stuff we're trying to sell you. Two completely unnecessary three RPG books that are completely unnecessary for the game, but they're here. A comic book extras. Oh, so this is a miniatures. It's some extra cards. Okay. From Fantasy Zombicide. What is I don't Okay, what is? Some expansion-ish content. And then an RPG screen for the books.

Okay. After the video, do I want it? Um I mean not particularly. Like I'm not like bowled over, but it's like yeah, but I like Zombicide. I don't think you fumbled, right? It's like okay. Could have got me there way quicker. Show me more. But yeah. It depends on the price. Can you do it? Yeah, it's Fantasy Flight Games / it's actually Asmodee. We just We just buy everybody so we can get bought out by somebody else and make a lot of money cuz that's how money works. So 110 bucks for a deluxified bunch of box big file box full of miniatures and the stretch goals and the rewards. Interesting decision not to show the stretch goal box to go with the Just put it all in one box as opposed to the second box strategy. I kind of really love it cuz you know makes your shipping better. But Do I don't feel like on the can you do it aspect, we really need to do much work here. Do you feel like Asmodee / Fantasy Flight Games who is the biggest company in our hobby like you know, aside from like you know, the Hasbros and various different stuff like that for the most part. Do you think they're going to go belly up? If the answer's no, then we're good. I don't think we need to do the can you do it, but Cthulhu: Death May Die which once again This is Oh, so this is like their strategy. Someone at Asmodee is like all right, here's Here's what we just got to do. We just got to pick up these massive Kickstarters that had big issues and then get their fan base and make the minis and blah blah blah blah blah. So cool.

Can you do it? Is a yes. So do I want it? Yeah, well enough. Can you do it? Yeah, well enough. How much is it? Price feels reasonable. So it's going to be a good good no matter what. Hopefully we can get a rule booklet. Hopefully we can get a game play video, a couple quotes, spotlight the pedigree of this if I'm new to Zombicide cuz once again, Zombicide is For those of you too young to remember, Zombicide was really the game along with Zpocalypse that kickstarted the the huge zombie craze that took over for oh so long. It was those two and there's been all these arguments about which one's better and Zombicide obviously ended up long outlasting it, but still like it's This is This is hallowed ground here. So hopefully spotlight that. So now you can play with the role-playing game system. Sure that's moving units. Not.

I can't just can't imagine that, right? Because it's essentially just saying hey, we know you you pick up every single Zombicide cuz you love it, but here, start role-playing. Hopefully If you do, I guess it's a natural progression. I'm interested to see if we can see actually how many of those units get moved. Go down grog. So here's components. They look nice. This is just This is just kind of you regurgitating the video. Is that what we got there? So 10 survivors, excellent minis, cool, love it. 42 zombies. So we're up to 52 zombies. Hopefully he's hitting me with this number later on. 10 survivor ID cards, 80 equipment cards. Like I said, $110 for this like big plastic survivor dashboards. Deluxified components, $110 feels fine. I will say there is inevitably going to be the people who say yeah, I feel like I just wait for this at retail. And for those people, there's no argument, right? This is now Asmodee. This is now Fantasy Flight Games. You are going to be able to pick this up after the day after the fact, no problem at all. So hopefully they can do some good stuff with the stretch goals to really wow us and hopefully we'll get there. So we got ourselves a rule booklet here. Back page, use it well. You didn't advertise, did you?

You wouldn't do that, Fantasy Flight Games. You know better than that. All right. The adventure doesn't stop here. Take control of the adventure with the role-playing game. I I did I We already talked about that, but thanks for telling me about it again. Hey, this is That looks cool. That looks like a Kickstarter right there. That looks like a separate Kickstarter project. Okay. Is this Is this playable with the thing or is this just We're just like we're going to throw this in here. Hopefully move you some units. We don't want to spend all the time and effort and make it its own separate Kickstarter or something. Cool. Neat. Take a break with comic add-on pack with exclusive content. So they're essentially trying to get the comic crowd here and the role-playing game crowd here along with the Zombicide / board game crowd here. I don't hate it.

Right? You're selling three separate products and it looks like they're really putting in some time and effort into selling all three of them. So I can't even knock it. But as a board game perspective, I'm like okay. Nice. Can I get the shipping first? Black Plague volume two is a graphic novel. Cool. Box of exclusive characters that you want for things. I don't even know what we're I just feel like This is Okay. What are these guys? The company of the Gallows. Are these Can I play these? Brought to you by Zombicide. Cool. So these are your extra things. So then so 110 bucks gets me this plus a treasure trove of exclusive stretch goals waiting to be unlocked and added to your pledge for free. So the The how much is it? They crushed the CMON aspect of it. CMON did very very well at getting that fear of missing out by having a whole bunch of awesome stretch goals which for some reason they're down here. Hopefully they spotlight these and put these up higher and really have a good job of spotlighting it. So, 4,970 people also stretch pay, nice. 22 bucks a month.

72 people wanted just "Hey, I just want the digital." That's just the digital though. So, this means it's going to have a pretty good number there. 806, not too shabby. Not too bad. Okay. Uh we got those. What do we got going on here? Message in a bottle. What are these? This message will I broke a cruise that these are theme. Follow the messages clues the following day you'll find a new castaway reward unlock for all backers with the pledge that includes the Zombicide Dead Man Tales core box. These every other daily unlocks are crowdfunding exclusive editions giving alongside the campaign stretch goals. Okay, so this is what I was just asking there. Why do I need to get it now as opposed to purchasing at retail? And that is 1,000% their biggest concern. Like you got to look at it from their perspective. Most Kickstarter companies are not worried about that.

They're worried about a lot of other factors. That's not one of them. But for them, they 100% need to be worried about that. And it seems like this is going to do we still have the stretch goals, but we also have this other exclusive stuff that you have to get only if you're backing here and not if you're picking it up after the fact. Maybe, even though we're not children here. Um Zombicide Dead Man Tales unboxing, jump to ship, cool and unboxing, gameplay, we got the uh a full gameplay. Awesome. We have all the videos you possibly want here. Reveal. Hopefully they get some Ooh, I gameplay video with the team behind the team behind the game. Love that. Honestly love that. More of this. Ooh, I kind of love that idea. Guillotine Games, I kind of want to steal that, right? I want to play some games with some of my friends that are board game designers and like do like a a DVD commentary.

Like "So, what were you thinking about with this card? Like what what" They'd be like "Oh yeah, that card that one that one went through a lot of revisions before blah blah blah." Like that would or like that card I wish that card. Yeah, not my least favorite. Let's not talk about it. Uh that would be That'd be fun. All right. Uh most states, so 2027. Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico 25. So, what am I in at? 130 to 140? It doesn't feel great now. And it doesn't feel great because I don't see that second box. And now you see why companies want to put that second box on that main image cuz now I'm like uh It's It doesn't feel terrible though. But I don't feel like you're doing a great job spotlighting your stretch goals, which at the very bottom for the most part. Like "Hey, here's painted minis." Uh a video dump. I feel like some quotes could be smattered about. And that's it, by the way.

Like we're not going to put any respect on Zombicide uh and Zombicide's like just assume everyone knows what Zombicide is. Come on. Come on. It was Yeah, it's a 14-year-old game. Let's not just assume. Let's tell people it's a top 250th attic game of all time and a top 760 game of all time, which was followed by a whole variety of spin-off games, most of which are probably very highly rated. 63, 882, 2366, 2059, 2637, 498, 287. Like you don't want to spotlight the fact that in theory you could play this with the Night of Living Dead. Like or Marvel Zombies. And I know that you were not selling those. I understand that. But if I don't know about your game and I find out oh, if I if I can mash together all this stuff for this amazing gaming system, like this is just my entry way into it. And I don't feel like they sold that well, which is unfortunately considering this is their first time with the uh with the license, right?

Like this is their first thing. And then ew. Ew. What is this? Oh, it's an index. Okay, so it's going to be an index with more information. Never mind. Not ew. Fantastic. I take back my ew. Instead, it will be a ooh. Love it. Love an index in the back. All right, so um Yeah, so 140 roughly in the United States of America. It doesn't feel terrible. It feels Kickstarter reasonable. It feels like what I would expect to pay for the Zombicide thing and that's nice considering it is, you know, a 12-plus-year-old game, right? So, if the stretch level if the if the pledges are feeling the same 10 years later, I'd say that feels pretty good. So, how much is it? It feels fine. Cuz you you just But that being said, I don't feel like they're spotlighting it well. I don't have that massive number there of this is how many zombies These are how many minis we've unlocked, right? Like I didn't feel like they just had that big all-encompassing shot or picture or graphic or anything where I got the grandiose sense of scale for both the game itself or the system itself. And I feel like that's a sorely missed opportunity, especially when you could just easily splice out the first 20-plus seconds of stupid pirate mumbo jumbo garbage. Like it's not special that you were bringing zombies to fricking to pirates. Like Have you Have you seen Pirates of the Caribbean? And the extra tiles pack just one of the same tiles that are already coming with the game. I thought there'd be additional tiles, not the same. Is that how the other games did it? Is there a way for us to already own the Black Plague comics and the

things and stuff? Uh I really don't understand the latest update. Bah. Well, that's not great if people are not understanding uh in this update we reveal the extra player packs and extra tile packs. Ahoy there, survivors. Before we get into our optional buys we must We just like to make official something we addressed in the last live stream. To the Black Plague comics volume one extras, we're adding Dead Man Tales survivor ID cards, abomination cards, and necromancer cards. So, essentially we It sounds to me like we don't like how this is selling, so we're going to try and get more people to back it that wouldn't have otherwise backed it by essentially lumping in stuff that we know they want because us board gamers are stupid and completionist who can't just enjoy having six boxes of our favorite board games. We need those promo cards, too.

This will allow you to use the contents of games of Dead Man Tales, the White Death core. That's cool. Stuff, things. Uh and so this is that one thing. Whoever wrote this note, extra player packs. Okay. "We want a bigger crew ready to take on the undead. With the extra player packs you can bring even more pirates into the fight so it can play more than six players." Okay, for this this pack provides six additional survivor dashboards letting you expand your game beyond the core crew. Alongside this component to find a rules leaflet explaining how to scale your game to support up to 12 SURVIVORS PLAYERS. OH my gosh. I'm going to go with just a full point grade bump down for the lot of the stuff that I hate about the cutty sark jig. I was just talking about how you need to just make it feel like this is another part in this massive universe that I'm just leaping into or I feel like you should, right? If you have this many expansions, it feels like a no-brainer to just lean on be like "Hey, look at all that other stuff. You can play with this stuff." And then the fact that this is now like all right, it goes up to 12 players, you can buy And it's just like it's just a it's a little fart here.

Like I didn't even see this on the add-on page, did I? I just scrolled by this and I I didn't even like I didn't even notice it. Like "Oh, cool. This is now like a convention special This This is now honestly a game game experience, right? At 12 Like if you played 12 player Zombicide and you had all the different characters rubbing up against each other, you're going to have a gaming experience that you're most likely going to remember for the rest of your life for one reason or the other. You have bumped your game up to something special. And the amount of spotlight that you could have just alluded to cuz most of the time people are never going to do that. Nobody's going to get to We all want that. That's why we got big boxes all over us cuz we're just hoping for those those brief glimpses of time where we get to actually envision those perfect games with our perfect friends in the perfect situation in the perfect setting. And you could have sold me that and it said it's like "Oh wow, that's a thing that I can have with this game. Thanks for mentioning."

And I luckily know about this because I know about Zombicide, but if you don't, it's just yeah. Okay. Uh so a lot of questions. It confuses me a little too, but I don't think so. So, yeah, so a bunch of people that are Love that it's not a male, but it's still too pale. Okay, so more representation. But mostly mostly it's just like confusion. People are looking at your updates and like wait, what? What's going on? That's not good. Like that was three people right there, I believe it was, that were just like "Not quite sure." And updates they're normally not something that require a good deal of thought, especially if you're trying to sell me something. It's not good if I have to put Yeah, ick. Final grade. Let's go. Do I want it? Fantasy Zombicide Dead Man Tales. I do.

I played Zombicide once. I believe I actually own two copies of Zombicide that I could rub together. It'd be a whole bunch of fun. Yeah, well, I'm right there's a base Zombicide 2 photo and another one over there. I should rub them together and have fun with that sometime. So, yes, I do. I want more pirates. But if I don't know about Zombicide I don't feel the love at all. Like it's just "Oh yeah, we're also selling some other random crap." But it's like if I don't know what that random stuff is, it's confusing. And even if I do, the people that do, they're still confused. And it's Like and I'm not saying that this campaign is fully not great because they decided to lump together three separate products, but it's just there's so many little things. Like not spotlighting the stretch goals when you're trying to sell me, you know, a $140 box, but it's probably not. It's going to be two boxes and just like there's all these extra add-ons and things that I'm assuming are going to be a big pledge at the end and I want to check out the most engaging update. I want to I I do want to do that before I before I give this a grade.

So, what do we got here? So, this one's 21 55 97 76. Let's check out this one. Maybe it was just that one where people were being confused and this this is Here's some art. Here's some minis. This one gives me an undead. What a great monster design. Love it. I love it. Okay, so these are just people that are both excited about the game. So, it's not like this is a common theme. It's just that last one they fumbled it. I don't want to go too harsh on that, but still this just it doesn't hit the mark, I don't think for anything other than okay, yeah, I'll throw my money because I want more Zombicide. And it really could have. It could have done a lot of different things, especially if you're opening up the potential of making Zombicide 12 players. And maybe it already was, but now you're leaning into it a little bit more. Like there there's so much that could have been done with the pedigree and the award-winning nature of the game. And then even here, like as I was reading it, I was getting bored cuz you just put so much I don't know.

It feels like this Kickstarter this Gamefound campaign was designed by someone who does not love Zombicide. And I'm not saying that that should be a prerequisite. But if this is your first time and you just probably purchased a lot of money for this intellectual property and and I don't know. Let's see what the other Zombicides did. I am very curious to see like a million bucks after the first week or whatever it is or cuz I believe it just launched a couple days ago. Yeah. So, let's let's see what they were getting before. So, $3 million for White Death. So, this one was one of the ones that wasn't themed. Uh deceased. So, this one raised God, 854. That doesn't tell me diddly squat. I hate that. So, this is So, this is the last one. So, that one raised 2.5. Okay.

So, I can't imagine that they're thrilled with their launch off. But then again, they had to kind of expect it to launch with three things. I don't know. Like maybe they were worried. Maybe that's why they put together all three of the projects cuz they were like, we're worried that this Zombicide is not going to do the numbers that we're hoping it is. So, we're just going to bring these other two fan bases in here and kind of just mush the stuff together because they are loosely attached. I don't know. I don't feel like it hits the mark nearly how they're hoping it to. And I think there's a lot of little things that I've discussed throughout it. So, final grade, do I want it? Yeah, but can you do it? Yeah, I'm not worried about that. But I am like I don't feel the need to necessarily get it now. I feel like, yeah, I'd probably pick this up for, you know, maybe 80 bucks after the fact without the kit without the stretch goal stuff, right? But like if I told you pick this up 80 bucks on sale 7 months after it comes out, are you really going to be like, "What?" Get out of here.

So, do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? It's a fine. So, I'm going to go Final Grade is a uh I think a B minus. I definitely don't I I definitely feel like this could have been a much more of like a love letter to Zombicide and to the the the passing of the torch from one company to the other of like, "Hey, we're going to do like we're going to do some different things." And it just honestly feels like you copied the basic CMON formula, but then you just kind of like, "Yeah, we're going to shove in some other stuff here, too, that we're just going to try and sell for you." I don't know. I'm going to go with a B minus. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Zombicide: Dead Men Tales. Also, if you enjoy Kickstarter content, please oh please, I am running a Kickstarter May 11th to just try and raise $3,000 to help get to conventions later this year. I don't want to sweat it out. So, if you want to purchase a Kickstarter critique, they're 30 bucks.

But if you click on that pre the pre-launch link right down below and just like my most recent update or tell me it you pretend and back when you get two Kickstarter critiques for $30. And if 100 people back it, then I don't have to sweat anything. And also, if you want to sponsor the whole channel, you got an upcoming game, you're a company, you just want to me to say your name a lot cuz kind I don't know. I don't care. 3,000 bucks day one. Only one person gets it. Hopefully, somebody takes it real early and then I can just relax. But yeah, running a Kickstarter. Done shilling. Bye. Love you.

Progress saved