Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 33:25

hi I'm Adam on the geek and this is a gyro file review it's the first video review I've done in this series of reviews and at the moment it seems to be the first video review of winter tales winter tales is just a beautiful game that's called my attention over the last few months and I've written about it quite a lot of BoardGameGeek either Susie a Stickley talking about the gameplay or writing strategy guides and that sort of thing um it's by a company called Albee Pivo who also did an arcane samurai and bitter Vikings another game called Nero I'm not very familiar with I probably pronounce their name wrong as well but but there's going to be a Fantasy Flight Edition that's been announced recently which is great news because it deserves a wider distribution and when I first noticed the game it was a nestlings on display and you couldn't walk by you know without spotting the beautiful twisted sort of fairy tale art here the sort of Nightmare Before Christmas sort of aesthetics of it it's a story of fairy tale characters fighting against each other in a sort of Narnia esque permanent winter and oppression by these fairy tale characters gone bad and this

is a storytelling game okay there are cards in it we have cards which we use to we spend them to move around the board and position ourselves strategically we have cards which we used it to bid against each other blind bidding and playing battles against each other and you know what's so fast so euro but this is more than that this is not like any other board game that you're going to have played and because it has such a strong storytelling aspect to it and the cards are used in a way which may be familiar of Europe there Dixit for example where an abstract image on a card is used as inspiration for the players to create stories and they really drive the game so it's not enough to just play with euro game sort of strategy you also need to unlock your imagination and creativity in order to really excel at this game and that's not as hard as it seems you know lots of people seem to be anxious about will I be able to cope and it's not that hard you know it really is about being brave enough to to get in there and have a go and if you're a if you're a player for many other games like once upon a time or now though fiction area is one that I played a bit then or even a role-playing game you know a player of RPGs and then

you're not going to find this stuff too taxing but the board game mechanics help those players who aren't familiar with those sort of games anyway let's have a little look at what's in the box we'll have a look at the components and talk a bit about how the game actually plays so the first thing that I want to do before I start to show you about how you play win details is just show you the components that you get inside this rather large box now unfortunately the first major component the again side the box is quite a lot of air there's not that much in here but what we do have is of a very high quality so we have this lovely thick rulebook and it's it's it's really sort of nicely produced lots of great graphics good examples and that sort of thing unfortunately the English in it is not great and so every now and then it's quite hard to actually interpret what's what it's trying to say and there's quite a lot of typos in there but maybe that'll be fixed in the new Fantasy Flight Edition who knows but anyway it's a nice thick rulebook the next thing that you notice when you open the box is these player aids so these again nice thick player aids they're Italian on one side and English on the other a real nice thick piece of card with a real sheen to it unfortunately most of the information

that you're going to be grasping for throughout the game is not on this reference which is a real shame what you're going to be looking for throughout the game is what the characters are all about what the settings are all about and what the quests are all about and so to that end I did end up actually making my own reference with the rules on one side and description of all the different quests on the other that's not necessary I mean you can use the the rulebook that's got all that information in there the next thing that you notice when you get inside the box and and and and put everything out on the table is this fantastic pretty massive actually map this board good thick board lots of space very functional and extremely pretty and the board shows us a series of different destinations so we have the fare of Wonders we have an abandoned puppet theater we have the winter prison the nightmare factory the Mad Hatter's asylum the Oaks Park which is an abandoned wood the cemetery Dorothy's mansion so I mean this is great stuff this is a lovely board and down the bottom here we have a space to place cards which act as memories of quests that have gone by so this keeps a track of our story and allows us to reincorporate elements that have come

before the other great thing about this region here is that we can have a variable length your average game will be three quests long but you could go considerably longer and make the game much bigger than than it is in its basic form so that's quite nice this game is customizable you can you can do what you like with it really over here we have the player pieces is a nice thick cardboard tokens with images of the different characters on and they all correspond to the cards that we have here so this top one these are tarot sized cards like you'd get in Elder Sign this is manga Foucault who in the Disney cartoon of Pinocchio is known as Stromboli so he's a Pinocchio character and the graphics on these cards are fantastic you'll notice in the bottom corner they each have a special ability and that's different on most of the different characters on the back I've stuck this story on the back on the back of the sleeve at least I wouldn't damage the original card but each character has a back story that's in the rulebook and as I say I don't want to be grasping for it throughout the game so I've stuck him on the back of the card and I find that quite useful actually because it means that a player can read out the story the first time they have to pay this character and it gets that used that player used to speaking in front of the group telling stories and also sets the scene for everybody else

so that was manga Foucault we now have Dorothy who's now an old lady after the events of The Wizard of Oz we've got the cat and the Fox from Pinocchio we have the big bad wolf the scarecrow from The Wizard of Oz Alice and this is an example of the sort of twisted fairy tale world where in that Alice is now in a straitjacket and has spent some time in a mental asylum you have candlewick who was Pinocchio's best friend in the original story but now it's a evil character and that that carries through the Mad Hatter he's evil Snow White she's evil Pinocchio he's not so evil but but he factors in the game then we have the little MatchGirl grumpy the dwarf the evil white rabbit and the tinman so lots of variety through lots of characters and the other variety in the game comes through use of these quests so each of these tokens represents a different type of quest this quest is called armed retaliation this one is the frozen horror the great artifact the safehouse this one's all about friendship and companionship and so every story is going to take a

different sort of turn a different feel depending on these these individual quests and the tokens are nice good quality thick tokens got more tokens over here which give the players extra powers we've got tokens to determine who is the the currently active player who is the story arbiter the person who gets to decide whether the story is making sense or not bookmark token you know good stuff and then a big pile of cards and these cards are the story cards these are what we're going to use to inspire us when we're telling the story so these all have different images on abstract images that we could interpret in a thousand different ways on one side they're in this reddish color which means that they're being played by the good guys if they're playing played by the bad guys they'll play on the white color though the image is the same so here we have another one you know we could interpret this as you know a fight or we could interpret it as a group of people helping somebody or as a forest you know whatever you want you can you can use these cards perhaps this is a cat perhaps it's a king perhaps it's someone looking out of a window perhaps they're going and looking in a cupboard perhaps they've found an escape hatch you know we don't know it comes down to you and your imagination as you use them is this a tin man is it a bird is it a tent is it a teepee is it a bell you know you can interpret these really

widely some of them are more literal than others here I think you're gonna be hard-pressed to find anything to say about this apart from a fire but perhaps it could be a rocket or it could just depict a house you know and you can use it in multiple different ways so here we have more examples of these cards unfortunately what you tend to find is that you get through these cards quite quickly although there's a large pile of them it looks bigger here because I've got them in sleeves and but you do tend to get through them quite quickly and find the same pictures are coming up as you can see here we've got two of this cross or plaster or whatever it is and when they come up players do tend to find it quite hard to reinterpret it as something different to what they've said previously it would be nice to have more of these cards and maybe future expansions if the game does well we'll bring those I think that would be nice it's good that these cards that have these childlike images that are quite easy to interpret I think I think that's good anything more literal would make the game much more boring I think and then there's these cards over here which give different types of objectives for the good side the bad side which you can play in a sort of advanced game the game offers you modules extra rules that you can incorporate into the game if you want to make it more more like a traditional board game really you know so so set objectives powers that the the

the characters start off with powers that they can gain through completing quests these will all be familiar things to traditional board gamers and particularly eurogamer's so so it's a nice feature that they've incorporated those I think what we'll do now is have a little look at how we play this game and I'll show you a sort of sample round of the game because that's the most common thing that seems to be asked on board King because how exactly does this thing work it looks great but will I be able to cope so let's have a little look at that how the game might actually play I've set up the board here as if for a three player game so in a three player game each of the different players will have four characters and one of the players will be the writer which means he's a neutral player so he controls both good and bad characters in this case he's got the little match girl Dorothy manga Foucault and the Mad Hatter now the writers aim in the game is to bring everything to a draw he wants the game to end neutrally this character is playing for evil cat this player is playing for evil characters Snow White the wolf candlewick and the White Rabbit and the player here has got the spring carrot as the good characters which are the Tin Man grumpy Pinocchio and I think this is

Alice that we've got here yeah this token just means that this is going to be the first player to activate his characters each player is given four story cards to start the game except for the writer and the writer only gets as many story cards as there are players of each faction on a player's turn they can activate one of their characters so I think I'm gonna start off by taking Pinocchio and activating him so Pinocchio who is currently in the puppet theater his controlling player will receive four new story cards from the story card deck so these get added to that player's hand immediately on activation now what I like to do at this point is get the players to read out an introduction to the character and the first time that we play it to introduce us to Pinocchio but we won't do that now so Pinocchio is activating he has four new cards for his player now bear in mind this player needs to use these cards for all of the characters it's not all for Pinocchio so we don't want to go overboard with playing these cards but these cards are going to be used as resources and Pinocchio now has the choice of either moving around the board which will cost him cards it costs two

cards up one card to move two spaces or to undertake a quest and currently he's in a location with a quest or to place a new quest on to a different space of the board now because he's here I think he's going to undertake this quest and so that means that he's going to need to play cards and describe what he does to undertake the quest um this quest is called the great artifact that's what this image represents here so what we need to think about is what exactly that artifact might be he's in a puppet theater so what I call and using this of improvisation term circles of expectation tell us that in a puppet theater we're likely to find marionettes we like to be defined wood carving tools or all manner of things to do with a theater so whether that's lighting or curtains or or seats or box office tickets you know but here I think what we're gonna say is that this great artifact is some form of puppet that Pinocchio is looking for and let's reincorporate his old dad Geppetto the puppet maker who perhaps before he died told Pinocchio that he was creating a brother for Pinocchio a new puppet there was going to be a great warrior now this puppet has never been seen because since Geppetto has died no one's

known where exactly it is hey Pinocchio is going to try and undertake this quest of finding this puppet so what he does to do that is he takes the cards from his controlling player and has a look through and and tries to use these cards to tell the story so perhaps we say the puppet theatre was long ago burned down by the winter soldiers and left in ruins a sort of rubble and Pinocchio has spent subsequent years trying to build this puppet theater back up but at the time many items were looted from the puppet theater stolen by the winter soldiers and so not much remained but Pinocchio has high hopes that his brother the warrior puppet will still be found what Pinocchio does know about the theatre is that there are several levels to it and he's not fully explored these levels because of the the danger of going below beneath the floor for example into the basement or going high into the lighting rig which is where Pinocchio is going to go and look for the puppet first so Pinocchio goes up into the lighting rig and and starts to look for this puppet now at this point he's going to leave these four cards because he doesn't want to use up his whole hand at this point because they'll

leave his control him playing not much to do later in the game so at this point it's left open for other characters to activate so perhaps their player control in the winter forces chooses to activate candlewick because he's nearby so candlewick might choose to move into this space now we should have on here a token to say that there is currently a quest on going in this space candlewick will by activating his his controlling player will receive an additional three cards for activation so these get added onto his pile of cards there and candlewick will spend one of these cards in order to move up to two spaces so he's going to discard this odd fish card here you discard that to move into the space now candlewick gets a chance to tell his bit of the story and how he tries to prevent Pinocchio from finding this other puppet so perhaps candlewick is aware of the location of the puppet when he when the winter soldiers looted the puppet theater they found a letter which described this puppet and although they didn't find a puppet themselves they know where it is candlewick sees through an open window what Pinocchio is up to his spots that he's currently in the lighting rig so candlewick finds his way

into the theater and he surprises Pinocchio and pushes him off the rig and Pinocchio falls to the floor at this point candle wicks minions crowd into the puppet theatre to grab hold of Pinocchio okay at this point kind of way it's gonna leave it open for other players to activate and maybe join in with this battle so it would be over to the writer player now who remember controls evil players and good characters so the writer could choose here to activate one of his characters perhaps he could activate the Mad Hatter because he is nearby but in order to do that it's gonna cost him cards and at this point he doesn't really care who wins this quest because his aim is to come to a neutral finish in one way or the other one team is going to be ahead here so he's not going to activate the Mad Hatter and he's going to leave it for these two characters I again the good player could at this point try and bring Alice into the play but he's going to lose cards by doing that so he thinks no he's going to be alright currently the good player has played four cards and the evil player has played four cards this means currently this quest is at a draw but Pinocchio gets one last chance to play a card and what we're going to say is that as he falls from the lighting rig the floor has been weakened by the previous damage

to the theatre and Pinocchio falls through the floor and into the basement where he finds the body of his abandoned brother the puppet the warrior puppet so in doing this Pinocchio has completed his quest and when we look at the number of cards that have been played we find the spring players have played five the winter players have played four so the spring players win and they complete the quest so that means we gain this token here for the spring players and that gets placed here we gain a memory of the quest which goes on to the memory track here and this is the body of the puppet and then we briefly sum up what has occurred and we say Pinocchio has found the body of his long-lost brother which he hopes to rebuild and and hopes can be a powerful force for good in this oppressed winter world the other thing that happens is that the good guys now gain this power which is to utilize this particular memory in subsequent stories so that's what this great artifact power is all about so that's how a quest works obviously they get more complicated the more players that get involved and the more characters that get involved and the other things that can interrupt it

are traps and battles which occur either in a winter character moves into a spring characters space then they could have a trap or they could be trapped or conversely when a spring player moves into a winter space then a battle can ensue now these are similar concepts but they work slightly differently in a trap players will secretly beard cards against each other and see who plays the most cards in order to win whereas in a battle it's a more a case of I play one you play one I play one you play one until eventually somebody gives up all the time of course telling a story about what's occurring and during this battle or trap but both are essentially forms of auction or bidding using cards to determine a winner after three quests have taken place in a standard game we get to the epilogue although as I said before the game is variable in length and we could go much longer during the epilogue players play all their remaining cards and the winner is determined by how many cards were played during that epilogue by each side plus three points for each quest that has one by each team of course this isn't a game about winning or losing and if you play it to win or lose you're going to miss out on a lot of the the sort of nature and feel of the game it really is a game about telling a great story and

and and and putting your sort of ego aside being generous enough to the other players to allow yourself to lose as a character if it's in the best interest of the story and that's where it's going to be a big shift for a lot of board gamers in allowing yourself to lose and allowing yourself to be open enough to build on other players ideas accept their offerings and not shoot them down you know if a Creed if a character creates fantastic object you don't destroy it in your next turn because that object could become a pivotal part of the story except that object build on it use it re incorporated throughout the story and you'll create something much more satisfying you don't want to negate what's gone before but instead you say yes and you build on what the other players are giving you even if they are from the opposing side and that's the that's the very nature of a storytelling game I've talked a little bit about how to play winter tales and what components are like I should say this game is for three to seven players so it really has that its Fame but it's not that many games which go up to seven players and still provide a really enjoyable and deep game in a reasonable time frame but you can get through a game of this in an hour and a half and the game is actually customizable you can take longer or keep

the game short depending on what you want to do so that's a really nice feature of it it's not a game that everybody is going to love okay if you're really hard set on winning the game then this is not going to be a game for you it's a game that the group really has to come together and an approach as a collaborative almost cooperative exercise in telling a great story and the rulebook repeatedly talks about that and is the only way that it's ever kind of work if players start battling with each other and contradicting each other stories then the whole thing will fall apart but there are mechanics in there there are modules which make it easier for competitive players to really get into the into the schemes of it by giving their own characters rewards for completing quests or different objectives and abilities so that all makes it a lot more familiar this is not complex stuff but it does have a long rules explanation and it's going to be unfamiliar to a lot of players so it's going to take a while to set it up and get people into it I think that the the video the promotional video which has been put out by a company how they pay bow and you can see on BoardGameGeek or on their website that is a great tool that really does show players very quickly what the theme of the game is basic idea of how the cards are to be

used and it's dark it's creative and it's beautifully produced so I'll often show players and that's a little promotional video before we actually play it just to get them into the feel of the thing it might be again this I think a game that is again the children could play but but there is complexity there and they're going to need a lot of guiding through it but as we know true imaginations are going to run right with this sort of thing and they're gonna love it and from that perspective some of the scenes may be a little dark if they're younger you know we have electric shock therapy and torture and those sort of elements of story about oppression and war I suppose but there's the fairy tale characters are going to be familiar anyway it's going to work with a family crowding and non-gamer crowd as long as they're okay with the slightly darker sort of subject matter how does it relate to other storytelling games it's not really like what we've seen before and if you think about a game like Dixit Dixit Odyssey I mean a game like Dixit that the characters in their so-called story tell us the players are called story tellers but it doesn't really involve any storytelling it involves naming a cards you know giving them titles and interpreting sort of abstract images and beautiful images so I mean in

that in that sense it is similar to two winter tales but this is not really true storytelling although it's a fantastic game is one of my very favorite games this is a party game and winter tales really is not there's something much deeper going on in with details then you'd see in a game like Dixit and Dixit was followed by a game called fabula which I haven't played but like a lot of other storytelling games popular and first employs me meets a a games master which winter tears does not and has the concept of judging other players stories which i think is difficult for some players because it can meet a bad feeling no one wants to be told my story is better than your story and the beauty of winter tales is that it avoids that another game which I've had fun with in the past is this one nano fiction Airy which again we're judging each other's stories but they're short they're light they're silly what they are not is beautiful okay these little hand drawn images I didn't draw these these are the finished sort of published cards it's a Looney labs game you also do flux and it's fun it's short and but it's it's not again it doesn't have the depth that you get in a game like winter tales this is where this is where sort of area that

we're in with winter tears is the one shot RPGs which of things like here we've got microscope there's another very popular on called fiasco which mimics the Coen Brothers movies these are short books you know they're not like an RPG book that you've seen before they don't tend to require a games master you can play it just in an hour or a couple of hours and that's it there's no campaign although sometimes they can be built up into a longer thing another very simple one is called oh the flying temple which is simpler even than winter tables you know these one-shot RPGs really feel like the same sort of world that we're in with winter tales well then without the beautiful artistry to go around another thing you might want to look at if you're interested in these sort of things is the story world books stood well I think books they're like little sets of cards story world these aren't games but they are storytelling aids where you get these beautiful cards with beautiful artwork or describing different situations to do with a certain theme so here we have the great experiment and then on the back of the card it has a series of questions which help you to tell the story so why are some creatures running away you might have tinkered with the experiment and what's about to appear you know these sort of things they're great for

kids if you can throw a bunch of these cards together and try and create a story out of it that's the realms that we're in with winter tales but with a board game or games mechanics to help you along the way and drive the action I don't have a lot more to say about winter tales it's a fantastic game I think I've given you all the reasons why you'll know if it's suitable for you and your group or not and as I say it's not gonna be for everybody and it it's different with different numbers of players I think it works particularly well with an odd number of players because we have this writer mechanic that player who's trying to force things towards a draw which really balances and he swings between the the bad side and the good side and keeps the story interesting it's beautifully designed so that that there's a natural rhythm as the good guys excel then the bad guys start to start to fight back because the good guys will be running out of cards at that point and so there's a natural back and forth and it culminates in the epilogue where all players finish off with their final cards and then encounter and we see which side has one I mean that's a is a clever mechanic and it's just one example of great things that the designers have come I've done you know in making this into a fantastic story to having exercise

Progress saved