Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Best Comic You Never Read - James Robinson's Starman

Transcript 29:28

Here's my Viking.

Hello everybody. Uh this is me, uh Lance Meister, the Undead Viking. Uh this is going to be uh ostensibly a book review, but it's going to be more about comic books. Uh, I want to talk to you a little about some of the comic books that uh, I really enjoyed reading. Now, I I I want to do kind of a a video about how I got into um, comic books and how I got into reading them. Uh, and but that would be a really really long video and it would take away from the fact of that I want to talk uh about about this comic in particular. Not this like graphic novel uh or trade paperback is what whichever version you want to call. I think I think this is called a trade paperback or I think this is commonly called accurately a trade paperback because this is a compilation of um a few issues of Starman. Uh and a graphic novel is in my opinion and it might be the correct uh definition that it was created for this like in in this type of of of of book like a book, right? you know, like a not a comic, you know, you you you get a graphic novel uh that was only produced as a graphic novel, not as individual comics as well, but that's neither here nor there. Uh so this is Starman. Uh this comic book um came out

was in 1995. So it being uh 2026, you know, whenever I start thinking about things that happened in the past, I start realizing just how long ago they were. So this is 30 years ago, which is insane to me. Uh 1995, uh I would have been, if my math is correct, I would have been 24 25 years old. Uh at this stage in my life uh I did not yet have uh my full-time job at US Bank and I was uh living by myself in an apartment uh and I lived by myself in that apartment for many many years uh until I met my who would then become my wife uh and mother of my children. Um, but uh at that time in my life uh I was working several jobs. Uh I guess a lot of people would say I had kind of a bohemian lifestyle.

You can look that up for you young kids. Uh and you know a lot of my jobs like paid cash because you know not because I was doing anything illegal but like I worked security for concerts. Uh and you know we I I wasn't a contracted employee. I wasn't a 1099 or anything like that. I was just, you know, getting paid cash every night for for working security. Um, you know, I I took care of uh ice houses uh at at uh local uh skating parks during the winter and during uh the summer I would uh ref uh intramural basketball games and softball games uh for the same park board that I worked for at at the ice rink. Uh you know, I delivered pizzas. Uh I worked at a record store, you know, I mean I I I at any given time I had between two to five or six jobs uh at any time in my life just to you know make money uh and then kind of spend it as quickly as I made it uh because I was young uh and living alone and I didn't really think ahead at that time in my life and I had a lot of fun. I mean, it's kind of like thinking back, you know, thinking back to being 25 years. I mean, at 30 years ago, it it's kind of tough for me to remember being 25 in a lot of situations, but I do remember like little snapshots and and the thing that I remember the most

is I remember uh living uh in that apartment uh and and having for the first time ever in my life a one-bedroom apartment that was all to myself. I didn't have any roommates. My rent was very reasonable. Uh, and it was a good place to live. Uh, and I sometimes drive by my old apartment building. It still exists. And I and I just kind of remember, you know, living there cuz I lived there for about 10 years. Uh, which is crazy when you think about it. But, you know, at that point in my life, I was bouncing around between apartments constantly. Uh, you know, I'd live somewhere with somebody and then we'd get on each other's nerves or whatever and once the lease was up, we would go off and do something else.

But that was like the first time when I was like, I'm going to live by myself and I can I can't annoy myself, right? Anyway, I'm telling stories that are beyond the fact that I want to talk about Starman, but I'm trying to give you a presence of mind of where I was. I had read a lot of comics when I was younger, but I would buy single comics. Uh, I can remember my mother would take me to the comic book store after school uh in in middle school uh or junior high as we knew it. Uh she would take me to the comic book store, Lantern Comics, uh when when Comic Book Day was there and I would go there and I would pick up the ones that I wanted. Uh, the thing that I remember that was a little bit crazy at that point in my life was that I had no idea how much comics cost. I mean, I would just pick the ones my mother would pay for them. It wasn't until much later uh when I got to be uh in uh like after I was in college and I would want to go and buy comics again because I didn't really read comics in high school. I just kind of got out of it. I would pick up a few here and there, but I didn't really get into it again. And it wasn't until I was in college and I I I can't remember the guy's name, but I met somebody who had a bunch of comics and I read his in college and I was like, I got to get back into this. Uh, it was after college, uh, when I started making my own money and I had my own money that I really got back into buying comics. And the big reason why I got back into

buying comics again was because that my my tattoo artist had a shop and above his shop there was a comic book store and there were many times when I would go there in preparation to like get some work done and he said, "Hey, this one's running late. Can you hang out for like a half hour or whatever before your thing?" I was like, "Yeah, that's fine." And I would go upstairs to a place called Comic Book Junction. Now, Comic Junction still exists. It still exists here in town. Um, Lantern Comics no longer does. Uh, but, uh, Conqu Junction does. It still exists. And the owner, Kip, is still alive and I still pop into his shop and say hi every once in a while. Uh, but what changed for me was I got I got out of buying single comics. I got out of that. I I remember I said I was going to tell you a bunch of stories about comics here and what they mean to me. And but I I'm kind of going down this path, but I I'll go deeper into this and I'll go deeper into how I got into comics with another video, probably the next one I do because I'm just getting passionate about comics again. Uh because of the fact that I dug out all my old graphic novels and I'm trying to figure out a way or trade paperbacks. I'm trying to figure out a way to store them in a way where I can read them again when I want to. uh because I want to go back and read the old stories that I really really enjoy.

So, Starman. So, I was suggested this by Kip, the man who owned uh who owns Conic Junction. He suggested that I read this and I'm glad he did. Now, theoretically, I would have picked it up maybe at some point in my life or whatever, but it doesn't matter. I I I read this and it it it is one of the most highly enjoyable 7-year run of comics that I've ever read in my entire life. Um it is written by James Robinson, uh who has other uh you can you can Google him. Uh, I originally thought he did not win an Eisner for for his writing, but he did win one Eisner award for a four issue arc uh during like issues like 20 to 23, I believe, uh, of this of this comic and he won he won a uh, Eisner for that. Uh, but and he was nominated before. Uh it was it's uh the artist for for the majority of of it is a fellow by the name of Tony Harris. Uh if you Google him, you can see there's a little bit of u there's some controversy surrounding him. Nothing like really really horrible, just some like unfinished work, things like that. I don't really know anything about it. uh and um uh

Peter Snberg uh took over after like issue 50 and I think this ran 80 issues total over seven years. Uh it was nearly cancelled. I I remember reading that it was uh um it was nearly cancelled uh several times uh because of of whatever reason uh maybe just well probably poor sales. Why is anything cancelled? But this is Starman. So, Starman is hard to explain exactly what this comic book is. It is ostensively, yes, about Jack Knight, this guy right here. And it is about Ted Knight, his father right here, this fellow over here with the top hat, that's the shade, who becomes a very, very important character throughout the throughout this whole series. Now, I have all the graphic novels. I and I understand that the graphic novels, these original uh trade paperbacks, God, I keep saying whatever.

It doesn't matter. They're interchangeable. I do understand that those these like I I I'm looking at them right over here. It looks like one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine. There's 10 of them. Uh there's a handful of of comics that weren't included in in that run. Um, there are two big giant compendiums now, and I'm thinking about picking them up, uh, that were published in the mid 2010s, uh, that have every single appearance of Jack Knight, the Starman. And I think I'm going to have to buy them. I mean, just because I need to read those and read what I haven't gotten. But, uh, Jack Knight is the son of Ted Knight, the original Starman. Um, and I I'm going to try to remain relatively spoiler-free, uh, as as far as, uh, how this goes. But, um, the the way that this opens up is basically, um, with this scene, uh, right there, and you can see that is uh, Jack Knight's older brother. um who took on the mantle of Starman uh and on one of the very first nights that he is uh being you know taking on the role of Starman from his father Ted uh he's he's assassinated he's shot and killed and the first

story arc is about Jack Knight being the reluctant hero and having the mantle of Starman foisted upon him and he has to do it in order to protect his father and protect himself and protect the people that he cares about and protect his city. Uh Opel City is the name of the city that they live in. Uh, and then after that, um, it becomes a a a a longer story arcs of Jack Knight coming to grips with the idea of being a hero. And, you know, and it's it's kind of a trope, right? You know, it's like, I don't I never wanted this. I never wanted to be a hero. And but it grows into this role that he um eventually uh becomes um kind of unwillingly realizes that he's pretty good at it and starts to really enjoy it. And then he starts to find out things like the darker like for lack of a better word underbelly of being a hero and what it means to be a hero. Um along the way he he joins the Justice Society of America which is one of my all-time favorite um my all-time favorite uh groups of of uh superheroes.

I mean, superhero groups come and go, but I mean like there's two that I've always liked. Um, I really really liked the JSA, the Justice Society. Uh, and the other one that I've always liked is the Defenders. Uh, you know, that's and that's a Marvel thing. Um, and and Alphalight for that matter now that I'm thinking about it. Um, but it doesn't, you know, those are like I like superhero groups. I like that that interplay, but I also like when you have a solo character like Starman. The best thing about Starman is not the fact that he is I mean there's a lot of things going for him. Uh he's the reluctant hero. He has kind of a uh an arrogant streak to him. Um but he's also very human and he's written very human.

Uh which is kind of coincides with the fact that he has no special powers himself. Um, they kind of off-handedly mentioned that like he he's a like a a jiu-jitsu uh he he learned jiu-jitsu because he wanted to learn some martial defense and that kind of explains why he's so athletic. But his powers come from the cosmic rod uh or cosmic staff. Uh I'll find a picture of it so you can see what what what he has. Um, but like here here he's holding his cosmic staff in that photo right there. Um, the cosmic staff uh absorbs stellar energy. Uh, and then it gives him the power of flight. He can shoot energy bolts. He can do, you know, he can do crazy things with his staff.

It's never really fully explained all the powers that he has, like they don't like write them out. and it has kind of a it can do whatever uh it wants him to be within reason kind of thing. But he has no super strength. He doesn't have any uh like like armor or anything like that. Uh you know he it is hinted that he has a little bit of like uh by a few characters that are mystical. He's hinted to have like a kind of a second sight, if you will, uh that like kind of tunes him into the spirit world, which is why he has um these wonderful issues of every uh every arc usually ends up having one episode of where he visits the dreamlands, where he gets to talk with people that have died, including like and and his like his older brother who was assassinated.

There's there's uh in the the first um issue or the first this first trade um like he has this story arc um here and you can't really tell but it's all black and white and and that signifies the fact that he's visiting the dream world and when he goes to the dream world like he gets to see like the people that have died will always be in color and he gets to reconnect um with with these people and and have conversations. Now, it's never really is it like part of his subconscious? Is it really happening? You know, they never really, if I can remember correctly, explain it definitively. Um but it's it's a nice little aspect. And that's something I really want to say as well. Ostensibly, yes, this is a superhero comic, but you will go pages and pages and pages and pages and pages like like here you can see like here's here's a classic, you know, uh you know, two panel like thing of like of of Jack Knight, you know, doing battle on the rooftops of Opal City with with this marauding gang of people. But um you know but then you will go right after that gets done like you will you will go on and on and here is you know here's pages and pages and pages of him speaking to uh this this woman and then she's a very important

character in in in the comic um that is a fortune teller and it and it just it just tells this huge huge backstory. There are pages and pages and pages of stuff where like he um like has conversations with his father Ted Knight and and they just talk about their lives together and what's been going on and the troubles they have between a father and a son. And that's something that I really like about the book as well. It deals with family problems. It deals with people that have issues like that are unresolved and and they don't just get solved in in an like one conversation. It is sometimes years of conversation between people in like in the in the in the in the storyline of the book where they eventually come to grips and forgive each other for what they've done and and forgive themselves for what they've done and they get to move forward. And if I had to describe one thing about the the Starman series, the the 80 issues or 81 issues, I think of number zero to number 80. So I guess that'd be 81. Over the 81 issues, I feel like the whole story is about redemption. It is about accepting the things about yourself that

you aren't really proud of and and and giving yourself the grace to accept those things that you did. to accept the fact that you are not perfect, that you made mistakes, and and learning to love yourself and and be comfortable in your own skin. And I'm rereading these after I dug them out, and I am getting a whole new perspective of what was going on.

in this comic book in in because when I read it I was in my mid20s and now as an old as an old man I call my you know uh as as an old man uh who is in the back n of his life this kind of speaks to me differently now and in in a good way and I've been really really enjoying the exploration of my own feelings as as I'm reading the exploits of of of Jack Knife. Uh, it would not be a uh it would not be a a a good comic book review, I guess, if you will, if I didn't take a brief moment to talk about the art. Um, this art is highly stylized. Uh I I feel like there's in a lot of situations where um it is both good and bad. I I I'm no art critic, but I know what I like is is something that I fall on a lot. Um there are things like this these this two-page panel here. Yet another giant discussion, no combat, no nothing going on. just a conversation between cops and Jack Knight and his father as his father's in the hospital. Uh, and his father and him are having an argument.

The art in here is is ancillary at best to to the conversations that are happening between the characters as they go. But I don't like this. I don't like the way this looks. I don't like um the the the use of shadow. I don't like the fact that it it just feels like everything is very um you know just muted and dark and and and uh not exactly for the lack of a better uh word precise. Um, but that could just be uh my own personal feelings as far as what I like or what I don't like when it comes to how a a page of art will look.

And I feel like the art is very uneven uh throughout the thing. So, because I mean, you have that that that those two pages here, but look at that page. I mean, that's just a great page of art. It it it just it feels better. Maybe because there's more light. I don't know. I I it just But there there's a lot of shadow as well. And it just it's one of those things where I feel like uh maybe as as the the the issues went on, they kind of just learned what they wanted to do or or they they they were more comfortable uh getting into the the process of of what the presentation of of the arc was going to be. I mean, there are there are moments and I'm just going to like show you something here. Um, like it looks almost cartoonishly bad for for lack of a better term here. Like here, I mean, and that's a pretty epic moment uh right here on this page right here. And I'm not going to go into it. Um, but I Jack Knight is is in this this is a this is a spoiler, but Jack Knight is is killing the man that killed his brother on this picture right here. And I don't it it just looks silly to me. I mean and and that's just maybe that's just my uh my mindset or or whatever, but I mean it

just looks almost like a bad cartoon uh in that moment. So I but it gets better as it progresses and it and it gets um more uh for lack of a better word refined. Uh, and and I guess maybe that's good. And and honestly, when Tony Harris leaves around issue 50 and and Peter Snberg comes in, uh, I think the art got a lot better as well. Um, one of the things that I really really like about this is that in the first four issues of this, um, they they do a uh, a thing where they have epilogues where they there's this epilogue here. Sorry, I'm pointing the wrong thing.

They have an epilogue here that gives you a hint as some for something to come and and and because there is there's uh this bluekinned guy over here is one of the original Starmen over here. Uh and then they give another epilog here that's a big mystery and you have no idea what's going on with that. And they give yet another epilogue here that you don't really know what's going on with that. And some of these things that they that they hint at in in the book, they don't actually come to a like any sort of a fruition or or or culmination uh until years later. Uh James Robinson put seeds of storylines that never paid off until issues and issues and issues later, which you know, you know, one one half it's it's very very

frustrating as a person that's reading. They're like, "What's going on with that? Remember when you mentioned that all those issues ago?" But when he pays all of them off eventually, it's it's very, very satisfying. Um, so if you do decide to read this, just stick with it. the stuff that he hints at, the stuff that he suggests could be happening, uh, will eventually be revealed, will eventually be solved, will eventually, you know, be brought to bear and you'll be able to, you know, have a satisfying conclusion. And that being said, I'm not going to give anything away about how how or why the series ends. Well, I'll say one thing.

Jack Knight lives. I'm just going to say that right there. Jack Knight lives to the very end uh of this. And for as far as I know, I I think the character is still alive in in the the Starman univer or the DC universe because this does take place in the DC universe. It does have other heroes from the DC universe pop in and out just like any good story line will. But Jack Knight lives, but he stops being Starman. And I'm not going to tell you why. You're going to have to read it. And it is it is a wonderful wonderful reason why. And it is the story arc of this just perfectly comes to a close and it really really it begins a chapter of of this like forgotten golden age superhero. It writes a love letter to golden age superheroes as my dog comes over to say hi right now. and and then it like culminates with a very very wonderful conclusion to that golden age era of comics. So there you go. That is Starman. Uh this is the first trade sins of the father. I I mean it's tough to get a hold of but like I said if you want to there's two giant compendiums that have everything. You can pick them up almost anywhere. I just Googled it here before I did this. Um, so if you want to take a read and you know, plus I mean you might be able to find it on internet archive or whatever if you just want to read them on comic book reader,

you know, so you know, you can you can go that route too. But do yourself a favor and but you got to read it. You you can't you like I I fall into the trope all the time of the trap where I will just skim comic book pages and I won't you got to just stop and read every panel and read every word of conversation uh that they have when they when they talk about the what's going on and their personal feelings and whatever. And there are so many characters I I briefly talked about that woman who is like the fortune teller like she's she's a huge character. You might have seen that there was some cops like in the pictures. Hi. Hi, buddy. You might have seen that there's some cops or whatever. Like those cops all have story lines that they that they invade. I didn't even really talk about the shade over here. The shade is a villain that lives in Opal City that is inspired by Jack Knight to become a hero. Uh, and you know, and he's got a whole story arc that's fun to watch and listen to. So, um, check it out. Check out Starman. Uh, one of the best comics you probably never read. Anyway, um, if you've read Starman, you have your own thoughts about it, let me know. I'd love to hear about it. If you've got a comic book you think maybe I've never read that you think I should read, you should let me know because I'm kind of out of the comic book world right now. I mean, I I I know kind of what's going on in the old comic book stuff, but um I mean, quite honestly, after like I had kids, I just didn't have time to go to the comic

book store anymore and read. But I'll talk about that when I talk about what comics have meant to me over the years. And I'll talk about that more in in another video. But anyway, that's Starman. Check it out.

Progress saved