The feast of Hemlock Vale review
Transcript
this video is brought to you by the three-minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon Kyoto and welcome to this review of the Feast of him loock Veil this is our fourth and our ongoing series of Recaps of the campaigns for Arkham Horror the card game previously we've done the return to kakosa the Scarlet keys and the enouth conspiracy and if you want to check out those reviews they're available here on the channel I'm going to start off with a short spoiler-free review before moving on to a bunch of spoilers I will signpost when that's about to happen if you know nothing about the Feast of himl Vil just know that your group has been invited along as part of an expedition to explore Wildlife on this island it just happens to be the same time they've opened up the island which is normally closed off to a festival so there's going to be lots of people running around the village with masks on and flowers in the hair are doing strange ritual things while you're conducting your survey and that combination of isolated island Village Life with strange monsters in the forest at night is what sets the backdrop for this whole campaign unlike most of the earlier campaigns a feast of Hemlock Veil only lasts for six scenarios and you do get some options on how those scenarios are chosen and what order you do them in the final mission is always the final mission but how you get there can change each time you play that said I would not
recommend this to people who are just getting into Arkham Horror the card game I personally think the Feast of Hemlock Vil is an expert level set there's a lot of really rough scenarios in here and a lot of situations where if it's your first time playing through you're probably going to end up having a pretty gruesome time for people who've been playing Arkham Horror a lot absolutely this is a set you'll enjoy just know that at some points it gets pretty difficult and if you're still finding your feet with a game it just might not be for you I'll give some advice later on the video on how I toed up to finally beat the campaign on my fourth attempt it took me four gos at a feast of Hemlock Val to get through the finale and I don't think I'm super bad at this game but it did take a lot of thinking and a lot of tuning my decks to fill very specific needs in order to get through the campaign effectively I'll talk a lot more about that later in the video so that's probably the end of the spoiler-free section and even that contained what some people would consider spoilers but let's talk about the campaign overall it's sitting and inspiration so clearly this is inspired by the HB Lovecraft Story the color out of space which is about a farm where a meteorite lands and terrible things start happen to the farm the the livestock starts getting mutated and and growing gigantic the crops get ruined um and just there's a blight that comes across everyone and everyone goes mad and it's all awful if you don't want to read the short story there is a recent film uh starring Nicholas Cage and
whether you find that enjoyable or not probably has a huge amount to do with how much of Nicholas Cage you can handle acting at any given time because you make some very very strange acting choices uh in the movie and if you like Nicholas Cage you'll probably find them endearing but um yeah it was a little much so that forms the core inspiration for the campaign but there's definitely another inspiration in there and that's of the folklore horror of things like Midsummer hence the flowery Crown I am wearing right now the idea of a secluded Island where people have their own little cultures their own festivals and those festivals take a dark turn uh is another part of of the Feast of Hemlock Veil so it sort of takes the idea of the color out of space and merges it with that sort of folklore horror genre I'm going to take this off now cuz it's actually quite scratchy the campaign structure is really neat there are three days and three nights and you play them through in sequence and on the first day you get to choose from any one of these five scenarios to go and do and it's your choice which one of them to do in the evening you can either have the set evening scenario that happens on the first night or you can do one of the four of the five uh scenarios you missed uh there's an opportunity cost of doing that uh you'll end up with a worse chaos bag and you might miss out on some other things if you go that way but it's a choice you can can make on the second day you'll do
um one of the remaining standard missions and then again in the evening you'll have the choice of the night Mission or doing one of the standard missions and in third day is the same aside from you get no choice on the night of the third day you always go to the finale and I think this campaign structure is really cool uh how they designed the different scenarios so different things would happen at different days so different people will be at different locations on different days or or evenings uh so if you're trying to follow an individual character story um you have to go at a certain time and listen to the clues of where they're going to be and this day structure ties into the residents of the island really well so the residents are the suite of about 10 characters that you need to get to know well you don't need to get to know but it's probably in your interest to get to know and form relationships with them um having strong relationships with people in the village will help you out you'll be able to bring them on to your side through the course of the campaign and one of them goes I'm off to the mines today you should probably go to the mines to make sure that they're okay if you're actually interested in keeping that particular character alive so the use of the resident characters and how they structure the campaign overall and change the scenarios so that each day they're a little bit different keeps this campaign quite Fresh So I've done uh scenarios where I've done it on the day first day or on the third day and they have felt quite
different then we come on to preludes and preludes are something they've introduced in the Feast of hamlock Vil and they're sort of like an expanded narrative introduction so you set up the board of the village as you would a normal scenario uh but there's no Mythos de and generally there's very low risk of anything potentially bad happening I you don't get to Mulligan and you go around for a couple of turns meeting the villagers and doing things in the village and I thought the first time through that these were really neat I thought that the preloads are really cool you could uh customize and build up your hand and have one asset and play ready to go when you started the campaign the scenario proper and I thought that was really cool then I played it through the second third and fourth times and they get old really quickly I I think they were done this way H based on the feedback from the Scarlet Keys having too much reading in it um but I found that this took way longer than getting through the narrative bits of the Scarlet Keys you have to do all the setup move the characters around do all that kind of stuff for what is essentially just a a a narrative Prelude and it's the same each time really uh and especially the first one you get to know where everyone is really quickly um and if you need to know what you need to do you just go through and do it and yeah I don't think there's there's much there in the end and it also leads into one of it's hard
to call this a problem but it's a feature of the campaign and that is that the daytime scenarios are really quite easy and the nighttime scenarios are not so you get these preludes when you're playing the day scenarios which are naturally just easier there are easier scenarios in general the five default scenarios uh none of them are what I would call Brain meltingly hard scenarios um in fact most of them very middle of the road even on day three uh they're all very very doable by reasonably competent characters but you get this whole Prelude to tune up for them so you start with like if you if You' running a shotgun deck um you can get your shotgun out most likely ready to go at the start of that scenario and probably have an extra ammo card in hand and a few other bits and pieces is that you're ready to you know start blasting things to Kingdom smag in a relatively easy scenario so you do all this work to build up the perfect hand to play a scenario where you probably just a random selection of cards you're probably going to do okay anyway because they're not that hard and then you go to the night scenarios and they are all all three of them are really really challenging um the first one on on night one is what I would consider a tough challenging scenario the other two are off the chart they are two of the hardest scenarios I've played um it took
me as I say four goes to get um get through those and um the first time we went to the the the longest night the second night scenario we just got completely bodied absolutely smashed to Pieces everyone resigned with half of the scenario go it was it was something else and so this creates this this up down up down thing uh throughout the campaign where easy lethargic sort of day scenarios and frantic night scenarios which you don't get to prepare for and I just feel the balance there is a little bit out I would probably preferred if the day scenarios had been just a little bit tougher to be honest um the night scenarios do give you something to work towards and they do definitely say hey here is a here is a skill you need to be this good at the game to continue this ride uh when you play the longest night um and it definitely definitely checks you if you are not up to that level uh once you get to that scenario but preludes for me ton of busy work and not needed and the scenarios where you really needed that extra prep work you just don't get them that said the Codex system that they use through this campaign is really clever uh printing on the card uh for for a character that gets reused through a ton of scenarios a little identity number and then based on the scenario
you're playing you check the specific entry for that scenario based on based on where they are so one character could be have entry one on them and that entry could be triggered uh in multiple different stages in the campaign it just means you you don't have to go look up um reference 119 or reference 122 or print a different card for each um each resident each time they used um it just it's simplified and streamlined things very very well and made looking stuff up in the book really quite simple I think the Codex is definitely a keeper and something they should use here on out if there's a recurring character um just print their codex number on them and whenever you're at the appropriate time of scenario and you need to check that codex you flick through the book and you find it I think think that's that's really good uh codex excellent addition to the campaign so here we are to the advice I have learned through four playthroughs one of them successfully so my successful playthrough group was Harvey Waters who is doing uh a lot of cards and getting his uh book number very very high and doing a bunch of things to just get lots and lots of Clues uh Advanced fingerprint kit High deductions um allies that boost his book he he was out there just basically accumulating Clues and handing out cards to other players the second character was Leo Anderson who had a ton of allies to use his meat Shields a shotgun tried to get his uh
big shotgun numbers up uh very high so he could do hideous damage to things plus also Branda cuga uh which would be very important when I mentioned later on having that was a big big Cornerstone to the campaign and finally a skido tool of all people who was playing a dirty fighting um agility based Deck with a little bit of uh clue getting from thieves kits in there but mostly uh skids was there to deal with um evading things and in doing quite a bit of damage because in this campaign the first bit of advice there are way more monsters than you could possibly deal with and a lot of the scenarios you'll get big high Health creatures coming at you left right and Center um you'll draw like a 10 Health worth of Critters a turn some turns and be like oh okay how am I going to deal with 10 Health worth of Critters in one turn and you need to do a lot of damage to the ones you can and you need to evade the ones you can't even my seek was running a bunch of combat stuff with the ravenous Mike in it and the event card whose Name Escapes me that can do up to four damage if you've got a lot of Clues on you tons and tons and tons of damage and Monster mitigation um I'd also recommend uh getting cards that allow you to taunt things or deal with aloof and Elusive um because these Critters are going to be take actions for you to engage them and then they're going to run away from you as well um
there was a riot whistle I think it is a card on Leo um that he got that gave him a free taunt action each round that got so much use that card was essentially just giving Leo a bonus action for most of the camp campaign um became incredibly useful useful card and yeah I didn't even need to upgrade it or anything he just sat with that foot of the whole campaign cuz yeah an extra action's a really good thing to have and in some of the scenarios you're going to be fighting every single turn against big scary things the next thing is so many of the treachery cards or the Mythos cards in the deck go after your cards in your hand there'll be a lot of other um effects on the tokens let's say if you lose discard cards and there is a particular treachery that can end up uh in front of you that does five horror I believe if you run out of cards so there's a lot of stuff that attacks your cards in hand that's one of the reasons why I ran Harvey uh so he could boost a bunch of card draw and you know not just keep it all for himself he was actually helping the other uh characters keep their hand sizes up as well so lots of things go after um your hand and just try to make you discard cards and when you run out of cards you get smashed so plan for that soort of my last point for dealing with a campaign is magical damage uh there are a couple of monsters out there in the campaign that just can't be hurt by regular weapons and I'm not saying like um they take one only
one damage or whatever they just can't be hurt at all if you don't have a spell like brand cthugga uh that's it you you can't get rid of these creatures through the game unless you know have Ways and Means to do magical damage uh to them kind of a a dick move when you first come across them cuz you're like ah cool I guess we'll have to evade that every turn or just deal with the consequences um which is I I kind of I get why these things are in Arkham um but when you first come across them they just make you go and you kind of have to you have to Tech for them you have to you have to build your deck with them in mind the next time you go through um because yeah the Feast of haml vale first playthrough is just it's brutal absolutely brutal like these are my lessons learned from going through it several times to see what works um the first time through we didn't have any of this and we got as I say we got spanked we got spanked hard
so we're just going to go through the scenarios uh one by one and I'll just give you a couple of thoughts on them uh the first one written in the Rock uh this takes place in a mine and the highlight of this one is the you move the locations around to change the tracks um on the rail cart and if you end up having the rail cart hit a wall you all die so you're having to gain Clues and do stuff to move move the the train around really fun scenario I think this is one of the the funnest neatest um designs I've seen so far in Arkham uh each time I played it it's brought a smile to my face makes me think it's it's a better idea than um the horror and high gear it's a similar sort of idea that you you're traveling and you can't really get out and do an awful lot but I think they executed it way better here I think written in the rock is just really neat good solid fun time uh himl house is a cool scenario that does stuff with locations uh one thing I died in this was that the locations are the monsters and if you burn down the house it starts collapsing really fun very different sort of um scenario to the others because it's the only one that really happens inside um I mean some of the others happen underground but this one's sort of the only house uh that you come across through the whole campaign so just it feels very different to the the other scenarios the silent Heat's probably my least favorite scenario uh in in this set um because you can kind
of just get in do what you need to do gather a lot of Clues and get out without triggering off any of the alarms or having to fight the the baddies um it really is a scenario where how fast can you gain Clues and if that answer is real fast then there's not a lot of threat here um yeah I think of of all the scenarios this is the one I think is the most mid uh the loss is a really good time one of those scenarios where you're exploring and just adding stuff and trying to find things and then you get the final uh encounter with the baddy and this is just a really neat boss fight because the Critter um behaves differently when it's in light or whether it's in darkness and it tries to retreat Back to Darkness and so you got to try and lure it out attack it and it's a very cat- and mouse kind of uh game with this giant monster uh lost sisters a really good time um definitely one you should check out and play and the final one of the day scenarios is the thing in the depths and I've only done this one on day one I've done it twice on day one and it felt a little easy uh like you could maneuver um the creature you need to rescue around the board pretty easily while just you know attacking the thing in the depths uh once or twice to make it run away um I think hunting the thing down and killing it would be a real big challenge but I don't think you need to do that to win the scenario looking at how the scenario is written though I think this would be quite a bit more challenging on day three as the basic tentacles that pop up and try to attack the creature you're trying to rescue I get way tougher then
we have the night scenarios and the first one is the Twisted Hollow which is a bit of a messy scenario as it really comes over three a so you're exploring the forest and as you do stuff the various bits of the forest will fall away and get reshuffled so it's trying to make you feel like you're getting lost in in the woods but it goes through two resets so the first time you've got to you find a clue and then uh an evil bear turns up and you run away and then you have to reset and do it again and essentially the second act you know the the location you need to go to is in the bottom four cards so you just kind of Bel line in a line until there's only four cards left and then start looking there so that part of scenario is pretty straightforward and then the third part is a sort of set arrangement and you've got to ideally kill the bad guy kill the big evil bear and then find the way out which could be the first location you turn over or it could be the last location you turn over and that dramatically changes how difficult the scenario is um one time we played it it was literally the last scenario uh sorry the last location um that we could uncover was where we needed to go another time I played it it was the third location I turned over so I think this scenario while it's quite interesting and it does create the feeling of being lost in the woods really well uh can skew really dramatically the game length can be very very dramatically different um again if
in that final bit the very first location you come across as the way out it's going to play out very differently and if you have to explore the whole Forest the longest night was absolutely crazy the first time we played it um and if you haven't played this one what really makes it stand out is that not only is there a encounter deck which has horrible horrible horrible treacheries in it that you have to draw you also have to draw from a monster deck each turn and these monsters will spawn at the perimeter of the map and just start moving in and these monsters are all quite tough like the weakest the weakest of them is pretty weak but there's some five Health Critters in there plus you have a suped up giant killer bear who's roaming around uh trying to eat your face this is a scenario where you have to use defensive tactics you have to use a lot of the scenario features of putting out decoys barricades and traps to slow down the critters but you also need buckets of Firepower uh just to to stop them from getting to the center and eating the things you're protecting uh first time we played this through we were not tolded up to fight remotely um this this world we did just didn't have a a a trio of characters that were were to out for for a big slow slow fight like this and we just got overwhelmed we ended up resigning on turn six um because otherwise we were all going to get murdered even with the right toed Up
characters that I had the the fourth time I took a crack at this it was still Touch and Go still touch and go until about turn eight where I was like okay I think we're we're pretty comfortable here for this scenario to to win it you need to deal a ton of damage um and you need someone picking up Clues as well in order to put down the barricades and everything else but yeah you monster management of off the chain here and even then there's a couple of treacheries in in the encounter deck that activate all the monsters and move them again and a badly timed one of those can can throw the game for you as well I had the Good Fortune of all but one time I drew this card it went to skids who had like seven feet at the time um so these tests were relatively easy to do but if I think if we' failed those three tests even K it up and ready for it we probably still would have lost that scenario uh long night's real real challenge um but that's good Arkham needs challenges like this it needs um scenarios that make you go oo that smarts um because it's you know the only way you're going to get better at the game and it was all Cakewalk uh it wouldn't be a lot of fun either and then we get to the finale which I have a few problems with but mostly just due due to how it's structured I think the finale could almost have been two scenarios you've got like a a Prelude that you do that isn't really a Prelude um then you've got this whole phase uh where you lose
your character temporarily and a given a temporary character and you have to sort of recover your memories as the as a sort of the framing for it uh by doing a lot of Investigations and succeeding a lot of checks because the more you succeed um the more cards you get to look at the more likely you are to find your character card and get back to doing what your character does so well the thing is once you get through that and that is a a pretty chunky part of the scenario as well you then have to do a reset uh of the board and then set up the village again so there's like set up for the Prelude then set up for the first part of the uh finale and then set up again for the second part of the finale it's a lot and in this hour in the we run um it's it's pushing the amount of time we've got to actually play through one campaign so I just feel like maybe it could have been split as two scenarios and there's nothing wrong with splitting it up as two scenarios um because it just felt a little a little too much the finale's got some cool stuff in it I think the abyss deck and how that all works is very interesting and and novel uh I was slightly mythed to lose my character the first time through but you know it it's it's a challenge you know the first time through the campaign I was kind of a little bit H by cuz how badly bodied we got how badly smacked over we got but the more I've thought on that the more I've gone that probably a good thing you
probably shouldn't win a campaign the first time through unless you're really cheesing it you should probably go and get your face smacked a couple of times before you you know get into a campaign otherwise the Box won't have any longevity it won't have a challenge to it and and as I said I won this uh playing through my fourth time that was on tabletop simulator and that was me playing all three characters I still have to play this through and win it in person which is a very different thing so yeah uh the finale it's it's interesting it's different it's challenging it's thought-provoking I just feel like it maybe just too much like either do something with the the pre make that less less setup or just do a narrative preload um because having to do three setups was just a little little too much for one campaign sorry for one scenario so yes that's my conclusions on the Feast of Hemlock Vil I think this is a very good campaign I just think it's an expert campaign I would not recommend this to new players for Arkham horor I think they should definitely try dunich or kakosa or enouth or something else before coming to Feast of Hemlock Vil it's I think the hardest campaign I've tried so far and we've done dunich carosa Scarlet keys and enouth and feast and I think Feast is probably the toughest one of those um that may have
just been our experience getting our ass handed to us that first time but Bo that was that was an ass kicking um we're currently playing through the circle undone so the next video in this series will be for the circle undone and until that time um thanks for watching and if you enjoy this video hit the notification button like share and subscribe to the channel