Keyper Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to John gates games today I'll be reviewing keeper this game was designed by Richard priests and on the face of it it is a worker placement style game but it brings several new ideas to this mechanism where you can share in the activations of your Lawrence workers you have six different colored workers who all specialize in a variety of different things and the places that you're putting your workers down onto are these mind-bending flippy-floppy boards you are going to be generating a wide variety of resources as well as a surprising number of different animals and it will first explain how the game plays and then jump in in my review here we have a two-player game of keeper all set up but before I go into this any further I do want to mention that all of the little meatballs are screen-printed with these cute little graphics on them that's because I own the character edition of the game which is significantly more expensive than the base one which just has different colored meeples without the graphics on them but it is worth noting that even in the base version of the game you still get to this wonderful variety of different animals at its heart keeper is a worker placement game and out here we have these boards which are full of different worker placement locations you're gonna have one of these poor players so this is kind of a dummy two-player situation and you start the game with this wide variety of workers down here which called cables and for an example if we wanted to we could take this orange one right here and send it over to at this location in fact it is valid to put two this one down on to any of the spots out here on the board the only place these can't go is the castles with this special indent I'll talk about that later so if we sent this orange one over here we see that there is a gray cube and that means that this orange person is going to harvest one gray cube but
before that happens we they will now ask their opponent to the left if they want to join them and the opponent can only join if they also have a matching colored worker whether it be the orange or if it is one of these white ones which are essentially generalists and they are wild they match everything and so let's say the player to the left decided they did want to join in so they would bring it their worker over here and at most you can have it two workers on every one of the locations out here so you don't have to ask if anybody else wants to join in and then they're gonna work together so whenever somebody joins in with you you get +1 action so that means instead of getting one cube we're now going to get two of these gray cubes but as he kind of penalty to us that means our opponents to the left is also going to generate two great cubes for themselves so instead of us getting one we get two and they get two and they're probably going to be relatively happy about that but now let's talking about what would happen if instead of going on to this grace bond we went down to this orange spot down here we see it is now matching the color of the worker and whenever that match happens you get an automatic plus-one activation so that means by going here we are looking at getting two of these orange cubes and if our opponent now joins and you must ask if your opponents want to join in then when you go here you get another plus one and now you're gonna get three of these weren't you banned your neighbor to the left is also going to generate three of these cubes if they decide they don't want to join in then you're gonna pass to the next person on their left you're gonna go all the way around the table to see if anybody wants to join in here if
nobody does then this worker will just hang out here and in this case we would have generated two of these orange cubes on each one of your turns you're only gonna evaluate one action so that means by going here we would now be done and play would go to our opponent on the left and they have a new option because this spot right here can take two different workers and right now it only has one because everybody passed so if they wanted to they could come in with one of their white workers or orange ones and actually join in here as their entire turn but now this worker is not associated with us anymore because it's their turn and that means they're gonna go over here and they're going to get to that triple activation because again this white is acting like it's orange so they are matching the area and there is a neighbor who's joining in so they get those three activations but it's important to note that any one worker can only activate twice with that around so when this white one comes in you've flopped the other one down to show that it's working for the second time and then that opponent would grab three of these cubes so this is a nice way for them to get cues and not give bonus to their opponents but I'll explain why they might not want to do that later let's now take a look at some of the other options on this board and most of them should be pretty obvious down here we could generate some sheep over here we could make some pigs there are also abilities like this one which could allow us to spend a cube of any color to create two cubes of any other color if we wanted to and this one up here can make some wheat but there are a couple other spots in particular I want to talk about this one right here so this is where you can build new buildings onto your own plot of land in front of you over to the left of our board we have at 12 of these starting
tiles that we can build out into our area so let's say for instance we wanted to do the build action out there on the board to get to this brick maker down now this seems like a pretty good idea because it turns the orange bricks into the refined orange resource right here and we have a couple orange bricks already and if we look up here in the top left we see that the cost is going to be one refined orange resource which is I believe clay and then one white resource which is one resource of our choice we start the game with one of each of these that means we could for instance do this orange one or this grey one but if we had instead harvested some grain earlier you can always substitute a grain for a white cube or a white refined resource so in this case we could do the wheat for the white one right here and the orange one and now place this building out into our area and since it has the tan background it has to go over here in the village and the orientation might matter for you because there are a couple of these tiles which will generate you points based on what they are adjacent to but once this goes down that is now built and it is now a new worker placement location because if you look right here that little symbol means you could put a worker down on top of it not every one of these tiles allows you to do an action but this one should be pretty self-explanatory if I took this a great person right here and put them down there there is no color matching necessary because there is no color to this area so we just get one activation and our opponents are not going to be able to follow on our actions within our own given village so that means we could go right here and we could spend one of these oranges and then gain back one of these with the ability of this specific tile it is also worth noting that as our
entire action instead of placing one of these workers out onto the main boards or onto any of these buildings we could build a building by just placing that this worker down onto any of these over here so for instance if we wanted to make a sheep shelter we could take this worker right here and put them down on there and that is in and of itself an action to get this built but now the worker is gonna hang out on there and of course we would have to spend the fee in this case it would be a cube of any color or since its white that means we could spend one of our wheat just like this and now that worker is gonna hang out on top of it and if that had been one of these spots that means he is kind of clogging it up to use it but over here the sheep shelter we're totally fine with that because all this does is store sheep and give us points for them at the end of the game it is worth noting that any of the tiles with the green background are our farmer tiles and they must go over here into the matching green section in your area earlier on you may have noticed all of these shiny new tiles and you may be wondering how you gained access to them and that happens through this spot right here on the main board now you may notice that there is no border around it which means there is no color matching so it doesn't matter what color worker you put down on here and now if one of your opponents joins in well they do have to match the color in order to actually join so it could again be a green or a white in this case and now both of you are gonna get to grab two tiles from this area of course if nobody joined in you would just get one activation and only grab one tile but when you are in this situation we would get to grab a tile first in this instance we might want to take this one right here which is going to give us extra points when we sell things to boats which I'll talk about in just a second and now my opponent is gonna get
to draft two of these tiles for instance that they might take this livestock market which is going to allow them to turn some animals into other animals and maybe they'll take this hop field which is gonna allow them to turn wheat into an animal of their choice and finally it would come back to us to grab one more in this instance maybe we're doing a lot of shipping so we'd want to take the dock right here which will give us six points at the end of the game if we have made at least 20 points in the shipping at this point we now of course need to refill this market back to eight tiles and we're gonna grab them out of this big bag right here and it's worth noting that at the beginning of the game we are in the spring season and you can tell by this symbol right here on the main board and in spring you must put new tiles down that have the green spring leaf and in the other three seasons it doesn't matter whether that has that symbol or not and as you can see if I dig here into the bag there are a wide variety of towels in here some with that symbol and many of which don't have that symbol at all at this point I'd like to briefly go over three more spots on this one right here lets you build at a discount of one cube or one cylinder this one right here lets you do an upgrade action with that arrow which means if it is a green tile you can flip it over to its better signed by spending a white cube which means any colored cube or a wheat and if it is a village style you can flip that over to get a better benefit in this case you get two cylinders for one set of 101 and that's going to cost you a white cylinder so that's any cylinder of a color or one wheat again the last action space are these double wide water areas and you can of course send to any worker to them but if we sent a blue one we would get an extra activation and
let's go ahead and say that we went right here and now we're gonna choose one of the available four ships now there are six ships in the game and you randomly choose four with each season and we might want to take the sea Vashon right here so we would put that in right over here and of course ask if anyone wants to join in and now we can evaluate it since we put a blue person down that means we get two activations and for each activation we can either work on the ship and gather one of the shown resources or we could sell to the ship and have it sell one of these shown resources so in this case we have a sheep shelter so maybe we'd want to grab a sheep for one activation and we can go ahead and put that over here and then we have an ore cube so maybe we'd want to sell that for two points and you're gonna track that by this little pier scoring thing right here so we go one two and that would be points for us at the end of the game that will does add in with everything else at this point you may be wondering what this special worker right here is they're kind of waving and they match our player color and that's because they're not a worker at all and said they are a keeper you see they're holding a little key right here and on your turn instead of a playing out a worker you can instead to put your keeper out onto one of the boards when you look out to the board you'll notice that each one of the player areas has a keep on it which matches the outline of this figure so we could put this right here and that's our entire turn but we have now a laid claim to this spot right here which means at the end of this season all of the workers on this board are going to comment into our area and they will be available for us to use in the next season so play is going to continue going around and around the table until you get to the moment where one person
has no more workers and no keeper to place now as long as somebody else has at least one worker or keepers then this player now goes into the laydown phase of their turn this means that we can select one action location that has at least one standing up worker on it that is either in our area or on the board that we placed our keeper down onto and then we can evaluate that spot once again so that means a down here we could lay this person down because again every single worker can only activate twice and that could generate us another orange cylinder for an orange cube but that's a bad idea because we don't have any orange cubes anymore but instead we could come up here and we see that our opponents at one point went over here to gain some sheep well we have claimed this board and we have no more workers so we can lay both these down if we want to we could also do it one at a time but for the most part you probably wanna do both at the same time and we're gonna get three activations for ourselves so we grab it three sheep and put them into our area so that means we didn't have an any part of either of these placements but since we claimed this board and we have no more workers we still get to squeeze some worth out of that spot but now since they're both laying down we obviously cannot come back to that area once the last player places out either their keeper or their final worker everybody else gets one last lay down action and then the season is going to come to an end the first thing you're gonna check it to see is how the festival went so I haven't talked about these yet everybody starts with a random spring summer and fall festival and if at this point you flip this over and you could show that you have at least what is showing on this tile you don't have to get rid of them you just have to prove that you have them then you can
put this down like this and generate two points at the end of the game unfortunately we ignore that and we would need a pig and a brown cube which we don't have so that means we fail to evaluate this festival and we just discard the tile next up each player is gonna take all of their animals and now is when they actually have to put them into their little enclosures each one of these tiles can only accept animals that are actually printed on the tile and each tile can only hold four animals it's now time for each player to claim their country board so we selected this one right here so we're actually gonna grab the whole thing and all of the different workers on it are gonna come off into our area as well as this and now we are going to randomize up with these six different boats and pull four new ones out as well as discard at this entire market and bring eight new tiles out once that is done each player is going to take you there a country board and they are now going to make it a go into a new iteration so as you can see this board kind of infinitely flips within itself and we started the game off in the spring which means we add this leaf right here but now we are in the second round which means we have a summer and that means we only have options that show this keep right here with the Sun symbol so that means we could put this out like this we could also put it on like this we could also flip this over like that and then lastly we could of course do that one right there so there are four different options available and once everybody selects it you can go ahead and put it into the middle the last thing we have to do before the next season is a little bit of worker management because all the workers that
were on your buildings also come back into this area and in a two-player game you're only allowed to have nine workers and in a three and four player game you can only have eight so at this point we actually have 11 which is two more than we should have so at this point we have to pick two of these out perhaps we'd take one of these greens and one of these gray ones right here and we put them over here onto this tile so we now have the appropriate number of workers before the next round and in the next round whenever we place our keeper out we can then exhaust each of these workers and if you'll notice the brown green blue and white ones will generate one of these types of animals and the black gray orange and white ones will also give us the option of doing a cube you now know the overall structure for a season and once players go through spring summer fall and winter then the game will come to a close and they can add up all their points to see who won now you get points for a variety of things first of all you have the points from the ship actions that you may have done also if you look down here many of these tiles give you points for conditions so this one right here gives you two points for each of these boards that are on it and this one gives you one point for sheep so that would be four points right there and two points for this boar this over here is just going to give you five points for existing which is nice and then this goldsmith right here shows that's a bit of set collection between gold and these blue gems can't member the name of them but either way you can do every single one of these activations up to four times so that means if we have all of these resources well we only have three
full sets of the blue and gold so that means that these are essentially wasted over here but each of these sets is gonna be worth four points so that's a nice twelve points for us and all of the resources at the end of the game that are not actually activated into SCI collection are going to be worth nothing and of course lastly you add in any of the fair points that you got as you were playing the game with these festivals and whoever has the most points is gonna be the winner let's now begin the review for keeper by starting with a few positive points and the first of these has to do with all of the decisions that come into play when you're trying to figure out how you are going to be placing your workers down on to the boards so this implies that you are in the phase where you still have workers to actually place down and there are just so many things going on because if you have your keeper and some key poles which are essentially a clay marker and your workers then is this gonna be the turn when you spend that clay marker in order to grab a one of those boards which is going to dictate the number and different colors of workers that you're gonna have to work with on the next turn or maybe this isn't the turn you're gonna do that you're gonna wait to see things how see how things work out a little bit more and instead you're gonna play one of your workers down and what order are you gonna be playing these workers which one is gonna go on to which spot all these things are great decisions and there's so many different ramifications of those for instance do you want to make sure you match the color of your worker to the spot you're going on too well usually you do want to do that but you don't always have that option with the different colored workers you have in front of you so you need to figure out which one of your actions is going to be the really streamlined one that's going to give you the most bang for your worker buck and which in which cases maybe you just put
a blue worker down into a brown spot because you don't definitely need to get those extra activations the next thing to think about is what color workers do your opponents have because maybe this is a situation where you really want them to follow in with what you just did so you were going to try and work it so you're gonna do this when they have the opportunity and they are enticed to go ahead and do that but maybe the opposite is true because of the various game states are in that you don't actually want anybody to follow you so you might stall out on doing that until you could put a worker down onto that location that does not match any of your opponents so now they can't follow you and maybe you've worked it so that you have another one of those so on your next turn you can also go on to that same spot you went to last turn and activate it again and just get even more of whatever that thing is that's working well for your plan and on top of all these things you have the extra decision what it's not even your turn of do I follow on at my opponent starts you know they are going to be putting things down and asking around the table clockwise and you're gonna have many many many opportunities as you're playing this game to follow on with your opponents and once again you're thinking about your plants like you have to do this and then this and then the other thing like you have certain goals that you're setting for yourself as you're playing each one of these seasons and maybe by following in with that opponent you can't quite pull off that entire set of things but it might work out well for you because it means you're getting rid of workers which means you get rid of your workers faster and I'll talk about that soon but this is just just this hopefully goes to show the vast number of decisions that come into play with when and how and where you're gonna be putting all of your workers down and I just love all of those decisions next up
we have positive number two and for this one I want to talk about the awesome mechanical design of the lay down phase of each season so by this I mean you have spent all of your workers out into various places and you have claimed one of the boards with your keeper so when it's your turn you have nobody to actually place out so now you get to lay down workers that are on your plot so the various buildings that you've built in front of you but also you get to lay down the workers that are on the area that you claim Dow there with your keeper and when you lay them down you get to reactivate them every single worker can be activated up to two times and this is such an awesome idea because you only get to do these actions once you've spent all your workers which means that you are incentivized to follow on other people's actions to get rid of your workers quickly so that you can do these lay down actions but also in incentivizes you to have less workers than your opponents and this is really the crux of why I think this is awesome because in general when you're playing a worker placement game if you have the ability to make more workers then you should do that because more workers means more actions which means you can pull ahead from your opponents but keeper says no no no we want you to have maybe a couple less workers and then your opponents so that you can put yourself into a good situation so that you can go out early and then reactivate the great spots that are out there so it's one of the things you have to consider when you're putting your keeper out to claim one of the boards not only are you figuring out which of the workers you're gonna have for yourself on the next round and also what number of workers you're going to have but also you're considering what kind of actions are you gonna want to do on this season because those are the only ones you're gonna have access to and so that
means you can actually play off of and get great benefits from good plays from your opponents like if you're porting to your left goes on to a spot with a color matching worker and your pone to your right follows them and they're you know they high-five or whatever they get all their different or resources and it's good for them and bad for you if you claim that spot later on and you lay all those down then you also get those benefits you have kind of tag-teamed in and followed on their following to a certain degree and I just think this is a wonderful extra decision that you are considering because you don't always want to do these lay down actions in general it's good to get these in because they are kind of like a Greatest Hits section you are kind of re-evaluating all of the best actions that got hit on that one given round but I have had situations where within a given season you like actually those lay down actions are not super important to me right now instead it's much more important to actually not follow with my workers and place them out so that I can get good actions with them and it's okay if my opponents are gonna be doing that so it's just this push and pull of how quickly if you want to get rid of all of your workers that you get into this lay down action and I just think it's a brilliant mechanical innovation on worker placement to say no you don't always want more workers than your opponent's sometimes you actually want less for positive number three I now like to discuss the way that you have full control over your own endgame victory point conditions so in your standard euro style game it's gonna say you're gonna get a certain number of points for this resource and certain number of points for that resource maybe you are in a race to compete on this thing or that thing with your opponents but innkeeper the game essentially says
you're only gonna get the points for the things that you have push yourself to do so obviously you get points for the buildings that you put down in front of you if they show points on them but lots and lots of the buildings in that bag just give you different scoring conditions through section usually and there have been many times where I've been playing this game and we've been kind of near the end and somebody says you know how many points do we get for just liquidating our resources at the end is it like you know five to one or something like that I say no it's zero you only get points for things that you have it set yourself up to get points for and I just love that customized ability and I think then it really puts the onus on the players to find themselves to their own victory condition and I just enjoy the decisions that come into play with actually picking those out and getting them built into your area all right it's not time to talk about a couple of neutral points and for the first of these I want to talk about two those flippity-floppity mind-bending country boards and on the one hand I almost made this a positive because I think that they are a pretty brilliant idea in fact I heard that the game design kind of began with those things with the designers seeing one of those different things that said there's a board game in there and from that the rest of this game came out and I think that what that little board does to the actual flow of the game as you go from season to season is pretty darn cool because it means that in the earlier stages of the game you have no ability to get any of the gems and gold but it also means that you have the ability to do some refinements like some raw resources into some better resources but once you get into the fall and the winter you no longer have the ability to
do those refinements beyond the stuff that you have built up in your own city area and now there's gems in gold coming out all over the place and I think that's a pretty cool flow and progression through the game that would have needed tons of different cardboard boards in order to try and make work without this flippy board but the reason this is a neutral is because on the other hand I almost feel like it's a little too clever and when you have the situation that happens three times throughout the game where you personally have a choice of how you want the board to flip in such a way to have those options be available to you on the next round I've often found that players as they are doing this they end up saying I don't know this will work into the middle of the table and I think that maybe if you get really really good at keeper you're gonna have a perfect sign for every single situation based off of the strategy that you are making but I do also think that it's almost too much when it comes to the different things you're like wait this has a cow but that also has a cow what's the difference between these two oh this one has a build action over there and that's an upgrade and and there's just and you're like oh that's only two of the options now I'm gonna flip this thing around see what the other ones are I just I think it works pretty well and I think it's a very interesting idea to get implemented and I don't have any problems with it but just like I said sometimes it's almost anticlimactic when you're actually picking these because it's maybe just a little too clever next up we have neutral number 2 and this one is pretty simple I have noticed that downtime and analysis paralysis can definitely creep into this game and that's largely because there are so many
different potentially mind-bending and very consequential decisions that you have to make as you are figuring out where it can be placing are you gonna be following what are you gonna be laying down what board are gonna be taking how are you can be flipping the board around all these things are important and all these things can take time to actually process and I have noticed while playing the game and that sometimes they're gonna have trouble that really do feel like a little bit longer than I'd like although often times I'm also punching through my plans trying to figure out the order in which I want to do things as well so this is just a little bit of a warning that if you play with people who are prone to analysis paralysis this game can exacerbate it to a certain degree but that being said all those decisions are also wonderful and really crunchy and yummy and I enjoy them so I don't really regret somebody from really going through their turn and going through their options because once it comes back to me I kind of want to also have that option available to myself because you can do a seat a certain amount of planning when it's not your turn but things can change and with a flip of a coin based off of how your points go to a spot maybe that's the spot you want to go to or maybe now you follow and need to kind of rejigger your plan and then to all of those things end up taking time it's now time to discuss a couple negative points to the game and the first of these has to do with that big bag of tiles that come out in the market row that you can then draft into your area and inside that bag there are effectively two different types of tiles you have tiles that are gonna get you points either through festivals or just in-game victory points with set collection and whatnot once you've built them into your area and the other type of tiles once you get them built in are going to give you an ongoing cool benefit or maybe it's a spot that you
can go to with one of your own workers to activate to do something cool and I think that it's great that both of those are in that bag my problem is that only thirty percent of those are the worker placement extra action type and seventy percent of them or different ways to get victory points and I already mentioned that I really like the fact that the game will ask me to cultivate and customize my own endgame victory conditions but I don't like that there have been many times where you refresh that market row and it's like all right they're just all new ways to get points and I already am pretty set on the ways to get points I've figured out my strategy and
interested in any of those and one thing that really excites me in boardgames is when I get to do something that nobody else gets to do that makes me feel special and maybe it feels game-breaking in certain ways and those act available abilities as well as the ongoing ones are ways to do that and some of them are pretty darn cool and I just wish there were more of them I really wish that bag was like 5050 with those different types of tiles as opposed to 70/30 I feel like I would be much more excited about the new tiles it would come out of the bag with each flop once you are resetting for the next season and I just feel like that was maybe a little bit of a Miss from a design perspective now for my other negative point I want to talk briefly about some of the color choices with the different workers in particular it just seems like when you are not playing with the character version of this game I have heard and I've talked to a colorblind friend that yes we would probably be having issues with differentiating between some of the different types you have brown and orange you have the white and the gray and when you have just a sea of color out in the middle of the table they could be hard to differentiate and that's honestly part of the reason why I spent a significant Lee a significantly large extra amount of money to get the character version of the game also I knew I liked the game but I just love the little screen prints on them and I think it's a bummer that that's not going to be an option for most people because it's a limited print run and it's so much more expensive and I just feel like when it comes to these color selections they could have done a better job of differentiating them out for the standard version of the game also with the resources you have grey brown and orange I just feel like those could be a little bit more different like those are
the only three based resources in the game you know we have all of these wonderful variety of different animals and then the resources just cubes and cylinders and these three relatively similar colors I just feel like that was also just a little bit of a misstep when it came to packaging the game together okay it's now time for us to discuss the variability for keeper and I think that it's pretty much as I expected going in you have that big bag of tiles and every one of those tiles is different so you are going to be putting them out and cultivating a slightly different set of victory point conditions for yourself every time you sit down to play the game even if in one game you try to go heavy on diamonds and gold in the next game you do the same thing there are enough different ways and different scoring tiles there you can't have variations on maybe a heavy diamond and gold strategy versus maybe a boat strategy and building strategy and an animal strategy there are lots of different ones and the game does reward you for going really hard on one but it also seems like you can be relatively successful hybridizing between a couple of these and going with the the nice options that show up for you and so I think that's why it's about what I expected I do feel like it could be raised even higher if it had more of those exciting game breaking a worker placement he kind of tiles in the bag like I complained about already as in the negative number one spot but either way that doesn't really tarnish the overall variety of the game when it comes to player count keeper supports two three and four players and I'm happy to say that I played all three of those counts and I'm also happy to say that it was great at all three of those counts
if I had to pick a favorite it would probably be the three player game but honestly the four player game was great just downtime is a little bit exacerbated with that extra person around the table in the game where there's so much to think about and the two-player experience was honestly really good but it was much more cutthroat than the three and four player game largely because there's all these extra seemingly very important decisions that come into play with following because it's just you and one opponent so if they go on to a spot that decision of whether or not you follow feels really important because it might not be a spot that you want to go to but if you pass and don't do that and do something else then it's gonna go right back to your opponent and now they might be able to activate that spot again getting a really good benefit and now you can't follow this time you don't even have the option to follow because they went to themselves and follow themselves and now you're just losing tempo because as you follow you kind of maintain pace as you are trying to hopefully lose all of your workers before they do so that you can get into those great lay down actions and it seem like the mental complications that came into play to try and figure out where you are tempo wise with your opponent and what decisions you can make to try and gain the speed advantage to try and go out before them seemed a lot harder than it did in the three player game so the two player game I honestly recommend it it was great it was just maybe a little bit more cutthroat than I expected going in and like I said if I had to pick a favorite it'll be three but it was created all three of these counts in conclusion I've played keeper four times at this point and I have really enjoyed every single one of those plays this game was honestly surprised me right out of the
gate when I played it for the first time it was taught to me and I didn't really know much going into it beyond the little flippy floppy boards that seemed like a bit of a gimmick and as I learned the game that first time I was just like what oh that's cool and oh that's it oh that's how that uh-huh oh that's cool and I just was repeatedly having these utterances of pleasure as I just figured out how this thing was working together and I liked it so much I went out and bought a fancy copy of it and I've really enjoyed every subsequent play that I've had of it I think it's great that you can kind of customize it your own strategy and it will kind of evolve as you were playing the game like you don't have to commit to a specific strategy in the very first round I've seen somebody go ahead and draft like some specific like a diamond making buildings in the very beginning of the game and then end up not even building those and do something else and do very well with themselves and it didn't necessarily shoot them in the foot that they had to change their plan you know about at the 50% mark the way through the game or so like I like it when a game allows you to be somewhat flexible with the options as they come out and I also like it when a game rewards you for solid strategic decisions and there are so much strategic planning that goes into play with this game and I just love all of those decisions I love a lot of the mechanical innovations in particular the one where you don't always want as many workers as your opponents in fact you kind of want to have slightly less and you want to try and get rid of them as quickly as possible that's such a neat idea for a worker placement style game then I almost don't even want to call this a worker placement game because so many work in placement games feel so similar to each other and this one feels like it's just
other it's just sitting over here in the corner doing something very different with a familiar idea and as I mentioned in the negatives realistically the the biggest thing that bugs me is I wish the game had more cool things that made me feel special compared to my opponents around the table and of course if there are more things then they would also have those special making things that would help them go even harder with their gaming strategies I think that the game could have used more ongoing ability amplifiers you know like in the game already has one where when you go to a boat you get an extra bone action well I want one of those for when I go to a mine and I want one of those for when I go to a field and I want you know more of those kind of things to just make certain parts of the game feel even better for me and it feels like a little bit of a nitpick and I do think that if this game came out with an extra tiles expansion I will be all over it in particular if as long as that wasn't a bunch of extra victory point scoring things because I really feel like the game has enough of those and broad enough variety of those in the box already so I strongly recommend in this game if you are into euro games if you're into games with interesting new takes on familiar concepts this one has a lot of awesome things going on in there and yeah I heartily recommend it as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash Jonge it's games and I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs
please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching