Forest Shuffle Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Forest Shuffle which is a two to five player card game designed by Kos and published by Lookout games this one takes around 45 to 60 Minutes to play now before I get started on my review of forest Shuffle I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who I my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so Forest Shuffle is a tableau building set collection game that's going to look like this as you progress so essentially you are building your own little Forest out there which is going to consist of these trees as well as these little critters and insects and little mushrooms and things that tuck behind uh the trees now the objective of the game is to get as many points as you can by synergizing these cards together as much as possible and the game is going to end when three of these winter is comings cards is revealed from this large stack of cards and depending on the player count there are going to be more or fewer of these cards in the deck so if you're only playing with two players for example I'm quite a large stack of these cards will not be used now of course I have progressed the game here somewhat just to show you some scoring examples and momentarily but at the start of the game you're actually going to start with nothing in your Forest at all um except for this cave card which can potentially
synergize with some other cards and get you some additional points um you're going to start with a hand of six cards which come in two different types you have the trees themselves which will come in different um different types of trees as well as these other cards which are either split half and half in terms of the top and bottom or to the left and right as you can see with cards um like this now the information on the cards is pretty simple where in the top left hand corner is the amount of other cards you must discard in order to play one of these you have a little suit type here which can be important when it comes to kind of um scoring abilities and stuff like that um as well as some additional information at the bottom again with more symbology relating to different scoring options um and also some bonuses and things so a lot of the times you'll have like a scoring criteria here so you can see this silver Fair will say I'll get two points per attached card to the silver refer but sometimes you'll have an additional bonus and even a special bonus that looks like this where is if you pay for this card um involving all of cards of a certain color then you'll get this bonus bonus as well but that's not always um not always on the cards and sometimes you'll get the bonus regardless if you play with any cards essentially like this one the beach card will let me draw a card once I've played it so mechanically the game could not be more simple you have one of two options that you can do on your turn the first of which is to draw two cards and when
you draw those cards you can either draw them from the top of the deck and add them to your hand bearing in mind you have a limit of 10 cards in your hand or you can draw them from the clearing here which will start to fill up when people start playing cards so let's just talk about how that works now so let's say for example I wanted to play um without thinking too much let's say I'm I wanted to play this little wood out here I'd have to discard one card again without thinking about it let's get rid of this horse chestnut now this card would get put into the clearing meaning that it can it can now be drafted by another player in any combination so when I said you can draw two cards you can draw one from here one from here both from here both from there it is entirely up to you and when you play or pay for that card you're going to tuck this card under one of your trees as long as you have room for it because as a general rule each tree can only ever have one card tuck to the left right um to the upper and the lower part of the card so let's say we play for that fire an it would go under this card like so um meaning that's going to get me two points um because it's going to give me two points per card below a tree um that might mean that my strategy might be I want to start building loads of cards below trees so once you've either drawn your cards or played a card you are going to check if the clearing has 10 or more cards there and if it has then you are going to wipe those trees off and put them in a discard pile to start the
clearing uh again there is an additional way that the the clearing gets filled up and that is whenever you play a tree card and when you play these tree cards not only will you have to pay the cost you'll also draw another card from the top of the deck and put it into the clearing to give more options uh to the other players additionally there is one extra rule where if you don't have any tree cards in your hand and you wanted to play one you can play the reverse side of any card as has a kind of um just kind of a dummy tree really with no special abilities but it gives you another option to start building around and that is essentially how the game works as I said you'll keep on taking these turns until three of these winter is coming cards are revealed from the deck and they have been shuffled into the lower third of the deck so you know you're going to go through quite a few cards before they come out and at the end you're going to calculate all your points based on the trees you've collected based on the cards above and below the left and the right and any extra points you make gets from cards that you've put onto your cave the player with the most points will be the winner okay so now we know how to play for a shuffle I think it's more important to talk about the cards themselves because you know mechanically this game could not be more simple draw cards or player card simple as that but where the game really lies is in the cards themselves there are so many cards here and tons and tons of different ways that you can score points um and even build a little bit of an engine and let's talk about how um some of these cards work you can see that these butterfly cards want to be you want to
be collecting as many different types as you can you can get a massive 20 points if you get them and they're nice and cheap to play as well because you do not have to discard anything you got this raccoon here that says you can play any number of cards um from your hand into your cave and draw an equal cards amount of cards back so if you've got a dud um bunch of cards that you don't really want to do much with then you can get rid of them and get a ton of points that way and replenish your hand and you got this like bullfinch here that says you get two points for every bug symbol so you can already start to see how these butterflies will start to synergize with these because these are bugs um and they'll get you two points per bug so that's two different ways you're going to score for those butterflies you got the brown bear that says you can place all cards from the clearing into your cave so you might want to trigger that card when the clearing is absolutely full of cards and you can get you know even more than 10 points in a single card play there but bearing in mind it's going to cost you three cards in order to you play that card in the first place you got the toad here that lets you break a rule by playing two Toads below a single tree and if you have a pair that's going to get you Five Points you got the links that says you get 10 points if you have at least one road deer in your forest and you can see here I've got that road deer so you really start to see how you starting to build up these different sets and you know a single card can contribute to multiple sets at the same time and we're not even talking about the actual trees themselves yet because the trees themselves actually have a better so you can see here that the lyen tree gets you a point or three points if you have more lyen trees than anybody else you got a
little bit of an area control thing going on there you got the um the beach trees that say if there's at least four beaches in your Forest then you'll get five points but this one gives you a nice ability to draw a card once you play it you got the silver thir which I think we've talked about before where you know you get two points per card attached to the silver first so that you want to really build um around these you've got the oak trees that say you get 10 points if all eight of the different tree types are in your Forest you've got the um horse chestnut which gives you another set collection bonus there the more horse chestnuts uh you have I didn't even talk about the mushroom trees which will give you ongoing benefits which says you know whenever you play a card with the kind of PA print symbol you'll get to draw a card so again you can really see how all these different things are trying to work together and a single card could be scoring multiple categories and it's all about trying to um you know points Max every single card um you play and I also do love this mechanism of the almost multi multi-use card system where in order to um play a card you need to pay for that card with other cards and the fact that these cards go into a kind of a common display adds another wrinkle to the strategy because you might think that you know what I really know my opponents are going for the butterflies and I've just played a butterfly that they want I don't really want it myself but do I want to put it in the common display because they're just going to grab it and then start using that to score points for
themselves at the same time you might be able to use this tactically by thinking there's quite a few cards in the display here if I buy a more expensive card now and spend a card that somebody else wants I know that the central Reserve here is going to get wiped therefore they're going my opponent is going to lose the opportunity to grab the card that I've just used to pay for another card with so definitely wrinkles of gaml here I think the player engagement of this game is generally very good you the turns themselves are very rapid and a lot of the time you're just drawing cards so you know the turns don't really take too long until it gets back round um to you at the same time the game doesn't go on too long you know you are looking at slightly longer than an average card game here know 45 minutes to an hour maybe a bit shorter with two players maybe a bit longer if you're playing with the full um five players but it does feel like you got a lot to sink your teeth into and within that time frame here again the downtime isn't too bad and the actual play interaction is okay as I said it mostly leans towards that shared carpol which I think is a great addition to the game actually and it makes um again it makes that consequence of what you're paying for a lot more interesting because you're not just throwing cards away into the abyss not to be used again as a lot of card games tend to do and I think I you know I personally really appreciate these extra touches they give you just an extra thing to think about I think the replayability here is excellent I mean there are so many different things you can go for and of course you're going to be tactically reacting to the cards that
you have in your hand knowing which order to play these in knowing which ones to throw away which to keep a hold of um trying not to clog up your hand too much um yeah there are so many things you need to consider at all times yes you can go for a strategy but you are going to have to kind of pivot and um you know if you are starting to fill your hand up of a certain type of card you might want to start leaning towards that strategy instead of the one you intended in the first place but yeah generally speaking there are so many different synergies here um and yeah what I've showed you here is just scratching the surface um in terms of the scoring opportunities that that lies within this huge deck of cards the production for this game is decent um the cards are you know they're fine quality they're not linen finished but they look fantastic you know you can see here just from me showing you that the artwork on these cards is quite spectacular I I love the way that the cards tuck behind each of the trees it just looks really when it's on the table and it is going to be a bit of a table Hawk so be prepared for that because you know each player's Forest is going to get quite um large the actual um little card sheet here is quite nice because it fits exactly 10 cards on it if you lie them next to each other like this so you can easily track when it's time to wipe off that kind of central Reserve there um yeah generally speaking I've got no issues with the production at all you got tons of cards here yes the car quality could be a bit better but the game itself is quite affordable and it's just all nicely put together very nicely um Illustrated okay so let's share some final thoughts on Forest Shuffle and man
am I impressed with this one you know this one kind of came out of nowhere for me because I wasn't really um I wasn't really monitoring it but it came up on my radar I thought I'd take a look at it because I love I love card games I love set collection games and um this one is amongst the best I've played to be honest it is so interesting how some of these cars work and the idea of you building several sets at the same time is just so so um so satisfying because you know sometimes you're playing a card for its ability you think well that's a great ability in itself but then you think well that's actually synergizing with three other the cards I've already played as well as two more that I still need to play so you're always constantly adding and almost compounding the points you're guessing on each other and know at the end of the game when you're calculating all those points it gets so cool when you realize how many points you've kind of um you know extorted from a single uh card now the only criticism I would say is that the end game scoring can be quite fiddly because there are so many different categories going on at the same time I personally don't mind that but I can see that a lot of people might find that a bit a bit tedious at times and might want like a a quick solution um but you know that's part and parcel of the game you know if you want a game with this magnitude which is kind of the unique setting point of this game is that you are collecting so many sets at the same time you need to be prepared that the scoring might be a little bit longer than what you're used to but personally I love the variability here I love the card tucking system I love that every fast of the game scores I love the shared card row um I love the you know the the interaction in terms of that card row grabbing what you want and
being careful not to do things at the right time um when you know your opponent wants a certain card it almost reminds me a little bit of ethnos you know when you're playing those big plays and you flood the market full of cards that other people um might want but yeah for me I think this game is is two thumbs up I think it is great it looks gorgeous and again just so much fun uh to play so yeah definitely gets my recommendations and a Chairman's Commendation and I wouldn't be surprised if this is going to be in my top five of the year I've not played all the ESS releases yet um but I played hardly any of them but I like this game so much and that's coming from someone who's played a ton of set collection games I'm very picky over the the um the card games I have my collection and this one is a no-brainer it's gone straight in and I am really kind of champing at the bit to get this one back to the table because I have enjoyed it that much and yeah definitely going to be top 10 of the year and I'll be surprised if it doesn't make my top five so that is Forest Shuffle